After Action Report #32

Summary

Podcast Episode Summary

Podcast: Savage Lovecast
Host: Dan Savage
Episode: After Action Report #32
Date: June 5, 2026
Guest: James

---

Episode Overview

In this After Action Report installment, Dan Savage welcomes James, a 40-year-old, gender-fluid musician, to recount their first genuinely positive and successful group sex experience—a threesome that seamlessly transitioned into an ongoing throuple relationship. The episode explores the practicalities and emotional dynamics of group sex, lessons learned from less-successful past experiences, and the surprising joy of group relationship chemistry. Rich with personal anecdotes, gentle humor, and signature Dan Savage sex advice, it’s a candid exploration of intimacy, compatibility, and non-monogamy.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Meet James and Their Background

• James is gender fluid (AMAB), a musician in multiple bands, and has navigated polyamory with their fiancé for several years.
• Openness about identity and relationship background set a tone of honesty and self-awareness.

2. Group Sex: Past Attempts and Lessons Learned

• Previous threesomes for James typically lacked universal enjoyment – “[I was] just there. But…that was fun. It wasn’t really for me, but that’s cool.” (02:32)
• Dan emphasizes a common pitfall: one person being left out, leading to hurt feelings.
  • Dan Savage (01:11): “If you can't hack that moment where you get to watch your partner have a twosome... you shouldn't have a threesome.”
• James did not experience catastrophe but often felt peripheral rather than engaged.

3. How the Successful Threesome Came Together

• James and fiancé (they/them) had been “off and on poly for the past like six years.”
• James met a potential third on Field (an app for alternative dating) and, after prolonged messaging due to holidays and scheduling, arranged a meetup that evolved spontaneously:
  • Met the new person for a drink at a bar, then invited her (she/her) to a party at their home (05:13).
  • The party unexpectedly became a major gathering (“the entire punk scene was at my house.”)
  • James’ fiancé and the new partner hit it off, leading to their own solo date.

4. Navigating Safely and Inclusively

• Dan reinforces meeting in public places for safety, especially with online connections:
  • Dan Savage (04:05): “If she had called me... I would have told her not to go because she doesn’t know you from Adam.”
• James clarifies the timeline: they did meet publicly before heading to the house.

5. The Main Event: Threesome Dynamics and Connection

• When James returned from a show, the other two had already “had their fun but could keep going.” (07:02)
• After a quick shower, James joined; "there was several twosomes happening…but plenty of threesome stuff. We tried whatever positions were available, which—there’s a lot, Dan." (07:54)
• The “vibe” was key: less fear of hurt feelings, and a mutual sense of comfort and inclusion ("everybody's happy here" (08:25)).

6. Notable Moment (Position Highlight):

• James (09:03): “It was very cool when she was going down on my fiance and I was fucking her from behind. That was fantastic.”
  • Dan readily relates: “That is actually a cool moment.” (09:13)

7. Aftermath & Becoming a Throuple

• The initial night led to further intimacy:
  • “A couple days later, she came over around noon and we fucked for 12 hours.” (09:42)
  • James: “Spoiler alert, our girlfriend, she just is a squirter who can just come like 30 times in a day. It’s absurd and beautiful.” (10:27)
  • Dan Savage (10:27): “Okay, the spoiler alert wasn’t for squirting. The spoiler alert was girlfriend.”
• The three officially became a throuple almost immediately, with clear and open conversations about labeling and expectations (10:33–10:46).

8. On the Rarity and Realism of Throuple Success

• Dan acknowledges that throuple dynamics are rare and refutes common romanticization.
  • Dan Savage (11:00): "Threesome to thrupple on an accelerated timeline ... such a rare, rare experience."
• James reinforces that relationship success like this is uncommon: “You do not expect this... It’s just such a very specific everything lining up.” (12:00)

9. Life Together: Sex, Companionship, and Compatibility

• Discusses how enjoyable time together outside of sex is essential for sustained happiness.
  • Dan Savage (12:52): “You spend most of your time just like chilling together. And it's really important that your partner or partners be people that you enjoy just hanging out with.”

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Dan Savage (01:11): “If you can't hack that moment where you get to watch your partner have a twosome... you shouldn't have a threesome.”
• James (09:03): “It was very cool when she was going down on my fiance and I was fucking her from behind. That was fantastic.”
• Dan Savage (09:24): “It's not adultery if I'm committing it at one end of a guy and my husband is committing it at the other end of the same guy at the same time. ... That is actually awesome sauce.”
• James (10:27): “Spoiler alert, our girlfriend… is a squirter who can just come like 30 times in a day. It's absurd and beautiful.”
• James (12:00): “You do not expect this... It’s just such a very specific everything lining up that like we all get along.”
• Dan Savage (12:52): “You don’t spend most of your time fucking. You spend most of your time just like chilling together.”
• James (13:23): “I guess we fucked for 10 hours because we did take some time out to watch Best in Show.”
• Dan Savage (13:34): “Thank God for Christopher Guest, best friend poly people ever had.”

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [00:32] – Introduction: James’ background and poly journey.
• [01:11] – Dan’s advice about emotional realities of threesomes.
• [04:05] – On safety: online dating and meeting new sexual partners.
• [05:13] – How the potential third joined the party and the dynamics at play.
• [07:02] – The beginning of the threesome and James’ perspective.
• [09:03] – Favorite sexual moment and position snapshot.
• [09:42] – The marathon sex session and confirming throuple status.
• [10:33] – Negotiating labels: “we’re a throuple now.”
• [12:00] – On the rarity of successful relationship triads.
• [12:52] – On the importance of hanging out and life outside the bedroom.
• [13:23] – “Fucking for 10 hours” and watching Best in Show.

---

Tone & Style

The conversation is candid, playful, supportive, and laden with sexual honesty—true to both Dan Savage’s and James’ personalities. James is self-aware, occasionally bashful but mostly enthusiastic; Dan provides humor, affirmation, and sage real-world advice.

---

Summary Conclusion

This episode stands out as a robust After Action Report—showcasing not only the mechanics of a well-executed threesome but also the deeper, more complex formation of a throuple. James’s story is a rare example of romantic, sexual, and interpersonal harmony aligning, with careful attention to communication, consent, and mutual enjoyment. Both the practical and the emotional aspects of group intimacy are examined, making this episode vital listening for anyone curious about or pursuing non-monogamous relationship structures.

---

For stories or advice on your own new experiences, Dan encourages listeners to write in to [e-mail].

Transcript

[James]

Foreign.

[Dan Savage]

You're listening to After Action Report at Savage Love.

[James]

After Action Report.

[Dan Savage]

Welcome to After Action Report, where one of my listeners tells me and all of my other listeners about something new they tried. This week we meet James, who had a three way of epic proportions. James, welcome to the show.

[James]

Thank you. Thank you very much.

[Dan Savage]

So before we get to what happened, tell us a little bit about yourself. Who's James?

[James]

I'm 40 years old, gender fluid, AMAB. I'm a musician. That's like, the main thing I do is I'm in a couple of bands and that's kind of my life. That's most of my life.

[Dan Savage]

Sounds like a pretty good, rich, rewarding and fluid life. So what is it that you wanted to talk with us about? What's the new thing that you tried?

[James]

Well, I had my first, I will call it successful group sex experience. My first successful threesome that went well for everybody.

[Dan Savage]

So you've had threesomes in the past, but it ended badly for somebody involved.

[James]

It was always like, maybe two people are really involved. Maybe one person's just kind of hanging out.

[Dan Savage]

I always did. The one person who was just hanging out wound up having hurt feelings afterwards. Because I always warn people that if you can't picture yourself at a threesome, that becomes for a moment a twosome that you're on the outside of. You're not cut out for a twosome or for a threesome. Sorry. Maybe you should stick to twosome. Because often, you know, when I hear from people who had a terrible threesome or a really bad experience, what they'll say is, you know, me and my boyfriend, we had a threesome and there was this moment where, like, my boyfriend was fucking this other person and, like, it was as if I didn't exist. And I got, you know, I blew the fuck up. I got really hurt. My feelings were really hurt. And I always tell people to imagine that moment because it's. If you can't hack that moment, it's almost inevitable that moment. And maybe you'll be on the outside or maybe one of the other people with threesome will be on the outside. But if you can't hack that moment, you get picture yourself in that moment and enjoying that moment where you get to watch your partner have a twosome. You shouldn't have a threesome. So was that your experience with unsuccessful threesomes in the past where somebody got hacked off?

[James]

Well, not exactly. It was fine, but it just like, not everybody had a good time, but it was almost like a twosome. And I Was there a couple of times in the past in my teens and twenties.

[Dan Savage]

So what distinguished. So you had threesomes where you were a little bit on the outside. You were just there. But you weren't so hurt or upset that you sent me a letter?

[James]

No, I wasn't hurt or upset at all. It's just like, that was fun. It wasn't really for me, but that's cool.

[Dan Savage]

All right, so what was different about this threesome and how did this threesome, your first successful threesome, how did it come together?

[James]

So my, my. My fiance and I have been, you know, off and on poly for the past like six years. You know, we've kind of opened it up, shut it down, worked out a lot of the bugs. You know, it's. It's been a journey. We're longtime listeners, so we've had plenty of advice, vicariously. But lately, you know, I've been like, interested in the possibility of, you know, group sex, threesome, stuff like that. And I met someone on field and we talked for probably way too long because it was the holidays and all that. So we talked for a couple of months, finally met up, and first date was crazy weird. Like, I ended up having an accidental big party at my house, and I was like, do you want to just come to my house and meet my partner and come do a crazy party at my house? And she's like, absolutely. So everybody hit it off. And then my fiancee's been struggling to, like, meet other people, you know. And long story short, this new person that I started seeing and my fiance hit it off really well, so they started seeing each other and they. They had their first date. I go out to a. A punk show to give them some space, and when I come home, they

[Dan Savage]

are waiting for me, laying in wait. All right, before we get to the big moment, let's back up for a second. The advice that people get from me, Dr. Jenny Young, others, is to not go on talking for too long. If you feel like there's a connection and a spark, meet as quickly as possible. Don't make an enormous investment before the first face to face meeting. So you broke that rule, but you didn't break the rule kind of sorta of meeting in a public place. Although, you know, if you're the person that you have this threesome with, you and your partner have this threesome with. If she had called me and said, so this guy I met on field, we're talking and he's invited me to his house to a crazy party, I would have told her not to go because she doesn't know you from Adam. And what if there's not a crazy party? What if you get there and it's a guy who just didn't want to meet you in a public place? Which is the advice everyone's always given about meeting people off the Internet for the first time. Meeting in a public place, yes. Party is kind of a public place. But somebody could lie to you about whether they're having a big party and you can get there, and then you go, oh, nobody else could make it. It's just you and I here alone.

[James]

And none of these things are the recommended way of doing things. I will say we did meet in a public place. We spent, like, an hour or two together first, getting to know each other at the bar. And yes, we talked for too long. It was just the holidays, and we couldn't get our schedules together. She's a mom. And so.

[Dan Savage]

Wait, so this crazy party wasn't your first meeting with your third?

[James]

No, this all happened in one night. We met at the bar, you had

[Dan Savage]

a drink, and you said, oh, I'm having a crazy party tonight. Do you want to come meet my partner?

[James]

It wasn't supposed. So my fiance was like, oh, you're gonna be on a date. I'm not gonna be on a date. Let me invite two or three people over. And then they invited two or three people over, and then the entire punk scene was at my house.

[Dan Savage]

Okay, so this is how you met quickly for a drink. Your partner didn't want to be alone. She invited the entire punk scene in your city over to your house to hang out with her. You invited this woman that you just met from field. Met in person for the first time. You'd met her two months ago.

[James]

Fiance's. They them, by the way.

[Dan Savage]

Oh, pardon me. They them. That's the way you met them on field. You invited them over, and your partner and them hit it off, and then.

[James]

No, the partner. Sorry, the fiance is them. The new girlfriend is she. Just want to be clear. Nobody's offended. It's just cool.

[Dan Savage]

Okay, okay. So you met up with her, and you brought her home to meet them, Your fiance. Correct. And they. And this is the plural, standard use of they. Your fiance and this woman. She. Her from field. They hit it off, and then they had a date, just the two of them. You came home and take it from there.

[James]

I mean, I was very sweaty from the show, but they were just. They had had their fun already, you know, but they can keep going. So I got home, took a Shower. And they were waiting for me. I don't know.

[Dan Savage]

Superpower.

[James]

Yeah, it. Well, you know, not necessarily for everybody. I know. But certainly for those two. I don't know. It was kind of a wild time. It was late. I had to work the next day, but I was like, well, I'm not passing this up. Yeah. So I took a quick shower and I got in the game, and it went really great. I mean, as you always say, like, there was several twosomes happening there, but plenty of threesome stuff. We tried whatever positions were available, which. There's a lot, Dan.

[Dan Savage]

There are a lot. So in your past unsuccessful threesomes or. Meh. Threesomes. Not really unsuccessful. They weren't catastrophes. Usually when someone said, I had an unsuccessful threesome, they're referencing a catastrophe. You didn't have any catastrophic threesomes, but the past ones. Meh. You felt on the outside of it. What was it about your fiance and your third that made you always feel inside it, even when it broke out into twosomes here and there? What was it? What was the vibe? What was the difference?

[James]

I felt comfortable doing what I wanted to do, taking what I wanted in a situation, whereas in the past I had not felt that way. There just. It wasn't a spoken thing, but there was just a vibe. I'm like, I don't think this is for me. I feel like there's going to be some hurt feelings if I participate more in this. And I didn't feel like that this time. I was like, oh, everybody's happy here. So, you know, if we split off into what I'm doing, nobody's in a bad mood about it.

[Dan Savage]

Awesome, awesome, awesome. And so give us one position or give us one snapshot. Give us one visual of one moment during this threesome.

[James]

It was very cool when she was going down on my fiance and I was fucking her from behind. That was fantastic.

[Dan Savage]

I have been there. I can. I can attest that that is actually a cool moment.

[James]

If you're all the way from behind, it is almost like you are fucking your partner through your other partner.

[Dan Savage]

Yes. As I famously said on Stephen Colbert's show, it's not adultery if I'm committing it at one end of a guy and my husband is committing it at the other end of the same guy at the same time. That is not cheating. That is not infidelity. That is not adultery. That is actually awesome sauce.

[James]

That went well, but it was, like, kind of quick for me. And she's like, what are you doing this weekend? So A couple days later, she came over around noon and we fucked for 12 hours.

[Dan Savage]

Wow.

[James]

We took some breaks. We took some breaks. They didn't take very many breaks. I mean, I have the equipment that I have. So for me, I came like three times. That's a lot for me in one session. My fiance, like a dozen times. And then, spoiler alert, our girlfriend, she just is a squirter who can just come like 30 times in a day. It's absurd and beautiful.

[Dan Savage]

Okay, the spoiler alert wasn't for squirting. The spoiler alert was girlfriend.

[James]

Yeah, we're a throuple now.

[Dan Savage]

How long have you been a throuple?

[James]

Pretty much since that day. It was just like, I think this is working out. And then shortly afterwards, like, can we start using the word girlfriend? She's like, that'd be amazing. So.

[Dan Savage]

Oh my God. Most successful threesome ever.

[James]

Yeah. Really? She's solo poly and has a couple of partners. And it's kind of keeping it that way because she's. The way she puts it is like her main relationship is her and her kids.

[Dan Savage]

Threesome to thrupple on an accelerated timeline that, you know, maybe you're still in the NRE phase. That's an amazing. People talk about limerence, the limerence phase in a relationship with one person. When three people come together, not only does it create kind of a three way limerence phase, it really recreates, I think, the limerence phase for the original existing couple. If it's an existing couple that requires a third becomes a throuple. And that's so heady and delicious and such a rare, rare experience. Because most people aren't in throuples and most people who are coupled in long term relationships and engaged have exited delimerance phase. And you kind of don't get to experience that again as a couple of. Unless as a couple you're open to and then become a throuple and you get to experience that limerence phase again with your fiance. That's amazing.

[James]

Yeah. And I personally, I've been in long term relationships. I don't really have a problem like staying excited about a partner. You know, I will say with this, I want to be clear. My fiance and I have had a lot of conversations about like, what if a third person comes in, would a relationship type situation be acceptable? Like, we've had a lot of conversations around that, whether it would be even feasible. And then of course, I just want to say for everybody out there, like, you do not expect this. Like it's, it's Just such a, it's just such a very specific everything lining up that like we all get along. I mean, not, not the threesome part that can be fun, but I think the like relationship part is much more rare and it just is strange and that it happened and great. It's just like bizarrely casual. Like we just all like hanging out together, which is what makes it work.

[Dan Savage]

Which is what makes all romantic relationships work. It's got to be somebody that you can hang with.

[James]

Yeah, exactly.

[Dan Savage]

Because that's what you spend most of your time doing. Like, even if you know you're well into adult life, adult responsibilities, you don't spend most of your time paying bills or doing chores or arguing. You spend most of your. And you don't spend most of your time fucking. You spend most of your time just like chilling together. And it's really important that your partner or partners be people that you enjoy just hanging out with.

[James]

Yeah, I will say, I guess we fucked for 10 hours because we did take some time out to watch best in show

[Dan Savage]

as one does. Thank God for Christopher Guest, best friend poly people ever had. All right, James, thank you so much for coming on After Action Report and sharing the story of your, I would say, world's most successful threesome ever. That went from threesome to throuple pretty quick and a 12 hour marathon fuck session, which, my God, it's amazing you could get to the phone. James, thank you again.

[James]

All right, thank you, Dan.

[Dan Savage]

Thanks again, James. May your success rub off on the rest of us. If you have a tale to tell, good or bad, sweet or sour, write to us. Tell us about it. Tell us about the new thing you tried. The email address is Qavage Love and you may hear from us. And you might be my next guest on After Action Report.

[James]

After Action Report.

[Dan Savage]

This episode of the Savage Lovecast is brought to you by Load Boost by VB Health. Load Boost is a supplement designed to improve the taste, the volume and the overall health of your semen. If you're already putting in the work, why not make your performance unforgettable? Made in the USA NSF. Certified and produced in an FDA registered facility. Thousands of guys across 50 states and 45 countries swear by LoadBoost. If you want bigger finishes and better reviews from your audiences. If you want better taste, better mouthfeel, go to loadboost.com today and use code savage for 10% off. Or click the link in this week's episode description. That's loadboost.com and use offer Code Savage.