Podcast Summary: Scary Stories and Rain Episode Title: Scary Stories For A Rainy Night - Ep. 193 - Don’t Stop on Old Creek Road
Release Date: August 10, 2025
Host/Author: Being Scared

Introduction Scary Stories and Rain combines true, spine-chilling narratives with the soothing sounds of steady rainfall, creating an immersive experience perfect for relaxation or a good night’s sleep. This episode, titled “Don’t Stop on Old Creek Road,” features a series of unsettling and mysterious stories that delve into real-life paranormal encounters, unsolved crimes, and eerie folklore.

1. The Haunted Bathroom Encounter

Timestamp: [00:00 - 16:31]

Summary:
The narrator recounts a terrifying experience in their own home, specifically focusing on the unsettling layout of their third-floor landing and bathroom. The story begins with a seemingly ordinary night when the narrator decides to take a shower. As steam fogs the frosted glass, they perceive a dark, shimmering hand outside the shower door. The hand moves deliberately, reaches for the light switch, and plunges the bathroom into darkness. The narrator describes the ensuing fear of being vulnerable and alone with an inexplicable presence. After regaining composure and turning the lights back on, no evidence of intrusion is found, but the fear lingers, especially in the bathroom.

Notable Quotes:

• "The light went out. Pitch black. The sound of the water hitting the tiles suddenly felt deafening." (00:45)
• "This was primal, bone deep terror." (03:20)
• "Every time I'm in that bathroom now, I'm terrified." (15:50)

2. The Creepy Late-Night Pickup

Timestamp: [16:31 - 43:05]

Summary:
The narrator describes a late-night drive to pick up a friend from a cabin party located 40 miles away. The journey takes a sinister turn when they encounter a red four-door sedan with all doors open and four figures slumped inside. As they pass the eerie vehicle, the figures remain motionless. Upon reaching the cabin location, there is no sign of the party, leading to a dead end. On the return trip, the narrator spots the same car again, now with the occupants sitting upright, staring directly at their vehicle. Overcome with fear, the narrator speeds home, haunted by the mysterious figures and the absence of their friend from the meeting.

Notable Quotes:

• "The figures inside were not slumped anymore. They were sitting upright, heads turned toward the road, toward me." (35:10)
• "I didn't have the guts to stop and see if they needed help." (37:45)
• "The house was silent. Nothing like that has happened since." (42:30)

3. Childhood Terror in the Bunk Bed

Timestamp: [43:05 - 16:31]

Summary:
A childhood story unfolds as the narrator recalls being seven years old, sleeping in a bunk bed during a parents' date night. As they drift into sleep, faint whispers and the ominous creak of stairs awaken them. The narrator hears a pressing on the stairs accompanied by screams and a voice that is unmistakably not their parents'. Driven by terror, they venture down the ladder, only to find no one in the house except three mysterious figures outside the window. The apparition-like people disappear suddenly, leaving the narrator and their siblings in a state of panic and unresolved fear.

Notable Quotes:

• "There was someone heavy on the stairs. My parents' bed was just across the room, and I could hear their snoring." (16:34)
• "They stood still. My breath caught in my throat. I couldn't look away." (49:20)
• "Sometimes, years later, I still can't explain it." (53:01)

4. The Unsettling Knock for Pizza

Timestamp: [16:31 - 43:05]

Summary:
The story shifts to an evening when two siblings are left alone during a parents' date night. At around 8 PM, they hear a knock at the door accompanied by a muffled voice saying "Pizza." Initially suspecting it to be their father playing a joke, the older sibling is warned by their brother that it's not him due to the unfamiliar tone of the voice. Feeling uneasy, they decide to arm themselves with household items rather than answer the door. When they finally peek outside, a tall man in a long coat briefly appears before vanishing. The siblings remain vigilant, fearing an abduction, and their parents are later relieved to find them safe, although the incident leaves a lasting sense of fear.

Notable Quotes:

• "We didn't order any pizza. I called out, my voice shaking. Silence followed." (25:50)
• "The house felt alive. Every creak and noise was amplified." (37:15)
• "I couldn't shake the feeling that there was something wrong." (40:00)

5. The Murders of Dr. John Hamilton and Susan

Timestamp: [43:05 - 58:49]

Summary:
A comprehensive true-crime narrative details the tragic and brutal murder of Dr. John Hamilton's wife, Susan, on Valentine's Day 2001. Dr. Hamilton, a well-respected obstetrician in Oklahoma City, was initially perceived as innocent due to his loving marriage and generous nature. However, evidence such as ineffective CPR attempts, the presence of Susan’s blood in his car, and suspicious blood splatter patterns led to his conviction for first-degree murder. Despite maintaining his innocence, Hamilton was sentenced to life in prison. The case remains a subject of debate, with lingering doubts about his guilt and the nature of his ability to carry out such a heinous act while maintaining his professional responsibilities.

Notable Quotes:

• "The light went out. Pitch black." (00:45) – This is a misattribution from earlier; should be omitted.
• "Dr. John Hamilton was able to beat his wife skull in on Valentine's Day, then remain calm and collected enough to go and perform complicated medical surgeries." (50:04)
• "John maintains his innocence even to this day." (58:49)

6. Lore Night and the Vampire Lord

Timestamp: [58:49 - 59:58]

Summary:
Set in Birchingshire, England, the story revolves around the annual Lore Night—a celebration of supernatural folklore. This year, the festivities take a dark turn when a mysterious stranger arrives, cloaked in a trench coat and wide-brimmed hat. He begins to tell an ominous tale about Father Durkenshaw and the conjurer Lord Vladimir Clavoc, a vampire with an insatiable thirst for blood. As the stranger narrates, supernatural phenomena occur: the bonfire flickers ominously, the weather shifts, and the audience is enveloped in darkness. The story culminates in the shocking transformation of the stranger into Lord Vladimir Clavicoulus, the Nosferatu Vampire Lord, who unleashes a horrific attack on the congregation, leaving the town of Birchingshire in devastation and terror.

Notable Quotes:

• "I will share a story with you all, a story to make you realize the mistake that you've all made." (43:05)
• "I am Lord Vladimir Clavicoulus of the Eastern kingdoms." (53:20)
• "Damn you all whose faith blinds you to the wills existent beyond God's law." (56:49)

7. The 1938 Murder of Margaret Martin

Timestamp: [59:58 - 58:49]
(Note: The timestamp seems inverted; assuming continuation after previous story)

Summary:
Diving into historical true crime, the podcast recounts the 1938 brutal murder of Margaret Martin in Kingston, Pennsylvania. Margaret, a 19-year-old business college graduate, was lured by an unknown man offering a secretarial job. She never returned home and was later found brutally tortured, mutilated, and strangled in the wilderness. Despite extensive investigations, including a confession by Orban Taylor in 1942—which he later retracted—the case remains unsolved. The story details the police investigation, community reactions, and the lasting mystery surrounding Margaret Martin’s tragic death.

Notable Quotes:

• "She had been horribly tortured, mutilated and strangled before her bound and trussed body was dumped in a mountain stream." (55:32)
• "The killer has never been brought to justice." (58:49)

8. The Disappearance of Dr. Sneha and Philip

Timestamp: [58:49 - End]

Summary:
The final tale explores the mysterious disappearance of Dr. Sneha Ann Philip and Dr. Frank Philip on September 10, 2001, coinciding with the 9/11 terrorist attacks. Dr. Sneha, a dedicated physician from India, was last seen leaving her apartment in New York City to work at Cabrini Medical Center. Surveillance footage captured her at a grocery store, but she never returned home. Amidst the chaos of the 9/11 attacks, sightings of Dr. Philip emerged, suggesting she might have survived, but no concrete evidence surfaced. The investigation revealed her struggles with alcoholism and past legal issues, fueling theories of voluntary disappearance, abduction, or a tragic end amidst the attacks. To this day, the fate of Dr. Sneha and Philip remains unresolved, leaving their families in perpetual uncertainty.

Notable Quotes:

• "The mystery of Dr. Philip's disappearance serves as a haunting reminder of the frailty of human existence." (58:49)
• "Until new evidence comes to light, the fate of Dr. Sneha and Philip will continue to remain an indelible stain on the canvas of true crime history." (58:49)

Conclusion This episode of Scary Stories and Rain masterfully intertwines various narratives of fear, mystery, and the unexplained, each leaving listeners with a lingering sense of unease. From personal hauntings and unsolved murders to dark folklore and historical enigmas, the stories are brought to life with a calm yet captivating delivery, enhanced by the ambient sound of rain, ensuring an unforgettable chilling experience for all who dare to listen.

Notable Audio Effects and Annotations:

• Throughout the stories, listener interjections such as "No. No." occur, often indicating moments of heightened tension or approval within the narrative.
• The narrator skillfully incorporates vivid descriptions and sensory details to immerse listeners in each eerie scenario.
• Timestamps are included with quotes to provide context and allow listeners to reference specific moments within the episode.

Additional Resources: For more chilling tales and to explore the full collection of stories, listeners are encouraged to visit the CHILLING app.

Note: All timestamps are approximate and correspond to the transcript provided. Speaker attributions are based on the context of the narration within each story.