Transcript
Evan (0:00)
Foreign.
Melanie Hempe (0:10)
Hi, everyone, and welcome to the Screenstrong Families Podcast, bringing you the best solutions for parents who are serious about eliminating screen problems in their home. This is Melanie Hempe, and I want to welcome everyone today. We have such a fun show today, and I am gathering my son Evan here to join me to talk about Christmas gift alternatives. So I just want to welcome everyone. We're glad that you're here. If you are one of our regular listeners, welcome back. And if you are a new friend, we're so glad you found us, especially right now in this Christmas season when we're trying to figure out what kind of gifts to give our kids. So if you have a tween or teenage, you're getting a lot of pressure to get them a smartphone. And I'm so glad that Evan is joining me to help me kick off the show and just talk about this for a minute. Evan, thanks for coming today.
Evan (1:09)
Yeah, thank you for having me.
Melanie Hempe (1:11)
Okay, so Evan is a senior in high school, and I just recruited him to help me go through these gift ideas, and I wanted to start with his take on why you shouldn't give your kid a smartphone for Christmas. And I know, Evan, I know I'm putting you on the spot here, but I trust that you can answer this question. You know, a lot of parents this time of year get really stuck because this. Right. This is what all their kids want is smartphones. So what do you have to say about that?
Evan (1:45)
I definitely remember going through that, coming back to school and everyone has phones and feeling a little bit like, you know, I was missing out. But then once I came to my senses, I realized that, you know, it was. It was kind of cool to be. To be different. There were a couple years definitely where, you know, oh, wow, you don't have a smartphone, or what do you do? And stuff like that. And, you know, it just. I mean, that's just how. That's just how it was. There's immature middle schoolers that's. I mean, just because you have a smartphone doesn't mean you're not going to get made fun of. So we'll just put that out there.
Melanie Hempe (2:18)
Well, that's true.
Evan (2:20)
And so. So you're. I mean, you're gonna get made fun of regardless. So just not having a smartphone, kind of being different. It always kind of begged the question why? And it was like, you know, the answer was, well, my. My mom won't let me in middle school or whatever. And of course, because you don't. You don't know what you don't Know when you're in sixth, seventh, all right, possibly even eighth grade. Then as I got a little bit older, I realized, hey, you know, that was actually a good move. Not. Not giving me that, not exposing me to all that. And. And it didn't keep me from making friends. I think the biggest misconception is that, oh, we need to get our kids smartphones so they can, you know, be social and talk. Talk to their friends. Well, you can be social at school, face to face and in all your activities. I think the biggest fix, if you feel like your kid can't be social without a smartphone, just have them get out and do stuff, or have him or her get out and do stuff. Have. Have that. Have them play sports, have them play instruments. And there's so many people you can meet. And not every conversation revolves around what's on the phone. Yeah, sure, there are some conversations where they talk about things that are on their phones or people will be on their phones and stuff. And you. I mean, you just. That's. That's just how it is. But the majority of conversation is not going to be about that. People are going to actually want to talk about interesting things that you do. You're going to want to talk about things that you do together. If you play sports, you're going to want to talk about sports, kind of stuff like that. So I just think, fear not, if everyone else is getting smartphone for Christmas and you're not, because I've been there and I lived through it and it turned out just okay for me.
