The Best SEO Podcast: Unlocking the Unknown Secrets of AI, Search Rankings & Digital Marketing

Episode Summary: "From Cold Emails to Hot Leads: The Digital Marketing Backbone You Can't Ignore" Featuring Jay Schwedelson

Release Date: June 28, 2025

In this insightful episode of The Best SEO Podcast, host Matt Bertram delves deep into the enduring relevance of email marketing in the modern digital landscape. Joining him is Jay Schwedelson, a seasoned expert from InternationallyInspiredly.com, who brings a decade-long perspective on automated marketing and email strategies that convert cold leads into hot prospects.

1. Email Marketing: Alive and Thriving

Matt Bertram kicks off the conversation by addressing a common misconception: the belief that email marketing is obsolete. He underscores its persistent effectiveness in converting leads, despite the rise of various other marketing channels.

Jay Schwedelson passionately counters the notion that "email is dead," sharing his own success story: “I've generated millions of dollars online with email marketing, so it definitely works” (02:42). He emphasizes that the primary hurdle is not the medium itself but the preconceived notions marketers have about its execution. According to Jay, overly focusing on design detracts from the core objective of email marketing: delivering valuable content that resonates with the audience.

2. Overcoming Email Marketing Challenges

Jay highlights the evolution of email deliverability, noting, “DNS records used to be the exception, now it's definitely the rule” (02:42). He explains that while getting emails into inboxes has become more challenging, adhering to best practices ensures higher deliverability rates. Additionally, Jay advocates for integrating text marketing alongside email to enhance engagement and maintain active conversations with prospects.

3. Selecting the Right Email Marketing Tools

The duo transitions into a comparative analysis of popular email marketing platforms. Jay Schwedelson provides an in-depth evaluation:

• Go High Level: “It's everything ClickFunnels wanted to be initially” (17:14). While offering extensive functionality, it presents a steep learning curve for new users.

• ActiveCampaign: Jay praises ActiveCampaign for its powerful automation and CRM capabilities, stating, “ActiveCampaign is a cleaner interface, smaller learning curve. It’s still the king with automation and CRM” (17:14). He personally prefers this tool for its balance of functionality and user-friendliness.

• HubSpot: Although robust, Jay points out the escalating costs: “HubSpot generally gets very expensive” (18:06), making it less accessible for smaller businesses.

• Mailchimp: Recognized as a great starting point, Matt adds, “You can get started with Mailchimp in a day” (18:35), highlighting its ease of use for beginners.

Both Matt and Jay agree on the fundamental advice: “Use something. Build a list with a purpose” (19:01). They stress the importance of selecting a platform that aligns with the business's specific needs and scalability requirements.

4. Building Trust and Selecting the Right Clients

A significant portion of the discussion revolves around client management and establishing trust. Many businesses struggle with clients who have been previously disappointed by subpar marketing efforts. Jay advises, “Jumping on a Zoom call with them, asking questions, kind of seeing what they are... if it's not a good fit, I'll just say, hey, you know...” (29:11). This approach ensures that both parties have aligned expectations and reduces the likelihood of future conflicts.

Matt shares a personal anecdote about a challenging client who demanded unrealistic guarantees, reinforcing the importance of setting clear boundaries: “...if you don't get his first position for SEO in, like, three months, like, are you going to give us all our money back?” (31:54). Both hosts concur that discerning early signs of problematic clients can save agencies from potential setbacks.

5. Effective Email Sequencing and Consistency

Consistency emerges as a cornerstone of successful email marketing. Jay compares it to a workout regimen: “If you do a good workout five days a week, you're going to see a difference in three months, big time” (13:55). He advises maintaining a steady cadence of emails—typically between two to four times a month—to stay top-of-mind without overwhelming the audience.

Matt echoes this sentiment, emphasizing the need for routine: “I like the consistency of the military. Just really helps you... you work out forever. You don’t know when the muscles are going to start showing up” (15:16). Both agree that persistent, value-driven communication fosters trust and keeps the audience engaged.

6. Integrating Paid Advertising with Email Marketing

The conversation shifts to the synergy between paid ads and email marketing. Jay recommends using platforms like Facebook Ads to supplement existing organic efforts, especially for businesses relying heavily on referrals. He notes, “If they have a budget Facebook ads as a supplement to what they're already doing is generally where I go first” (22:57). This integrated approach not only drives traffic but also feeds into the email marketing funnel, enhancing lead capture and nurturing.

Matt expands on this by highlighting the importance of multi-channel strategies: “Posting on TikTok, YouTube Shorts, and Instagram is where it's at to get organic reach” (38:33). Combining these with targeted email campaigns ensures a comprehensive reach across various touchpoints.

7. Authenticity and Personalization in Email Content

A recurring theme is the value of authenticity in communication. Jay describes his email style as “unapologetically authentic” (38:38), emphasizing that genuine storytelling and personal anecdotes resonate more with audiences than polished, impersonal content. Matt concurs, sharing his shift towards conversational emails: “I'm just talking and then I'll grammar check it” (37:08), which mirrors real-life interactions and builds deeper connections.

8. Strategies for Building and Maintaining an Engaged Email List

Both hosts stress the importance of creating valuable lead magnets to attract quality leads. Jay advises, “Your lead magnets... should be worth a couple hundred bucks or more in perceived value” (19:01). This strategy ensures that the email list comprises genuinely interested prospects, enhancing engagement and conversion rates.

Moreover, they discuss the significance of email analytics and continuous optimization: “You can continue to optimize based upon data. You don't have to just guess” (20:44). Leveraging data-driven insights allows marketers to refine their strategies, ensuring sustained effectiveness.

9. Overcoming Execution Paralysis

Addressing a common barrier, Matt and Jay encourage listeners to take immediate action rather than waiting for perfection. Jay shares a pragmatic approach: “Good enough to get it out there” (11:04), advocating for incremental progress and iterative improvements. Matt reinforces this by citing the “Start Ugly” philosophy, urging marketers to begin and refine along the way: “Do it now, do it now. You just gotta take action” (12:06).

Key Takeaways

1. Email Marketing Remains Crucial: Despite evolving digital landscapes, email marketing continues to be a powerful tool for lead conversion and customer engagement.

2. Choose the Right Tools: Platforms like ActiveCampaign offer a balance of functionality and ease of use, making them suitable for a wide range of businesses.

3. Build Trust with Clients: Carefully selecting clients and setting clear expectations can prevent future conflicts and ensure long-term partnerships.

4. Consistency is King: Regular, value-driven email communication fosters trust and keeps your audience engaged.

5. Integrate Paid and Organic Strategies: Combining paid advertising with email marketing amplifies reach and enhances lead nurturing.

6. Be Authentic: Genuine, personalized communication resonates more deeply with audiences than overly polished content.

7. Take Action Now: Overcome perfectionism by starting and iterating, ensuring continuous progress and learning.

Connect with Jay Schwedelson:

• Website: intentionallyinspirational.com
• YouTube: Check out the "Smoke Flow and Grow" playlist for more insights.

Further Resources:

• MatthewBertram.com: Explore Matt’s coaching courses and additional content to elevate your marketing strategies.
• EWR Digital: Visit ewrdigital.com for comprehensive digital marketing solutions.

Stay tuned to The Best SEO Podcast for more expert insights and strategies to keep your business ahead in the competitive digital arena.