Loading summary
Samsung Galaxy User
I can say to my new Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra hey, find a keto friendly restaurant nearby and text it to Beth and Steve. And it does without me lifting a finger so I can get in more squats anywhere I can. 1, 2, 3.
Cashier
Will that be cash or credit?
McLeod
Credit. 4 Galaxy S25 Ultra the AI companion that does the heavy lifting so you can do.
Cashier
You get yours@samsung.com compatible with select apps.
McLeod
Requires Google Gemini account. Results may vary based on input. Check responses for accuracy.
Lowes Advertiser
Spring Fest and Ego days are here at Lowes right now. Get a free select EGO 56 volt battery with purchase of a select trimmer, blower or mower kit. Plus shop today for new and exclusive items you need for your lawn. So get ready for spring with the latest in innovation from EGO, the 1 rated brand in cordless outdoor power. Only at Lowes we help you save. Offer valid through 4 2. Selection varies by location while supplies last.
McLeod
Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile with a message for everyone paying big wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop with Mint. You can get premium wireless for just $15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying. No judgments. But that's weird. Okay, one judgment anyway. Give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch upfront payment.
Samsung Galaxy User
Of $45 for three month plan equivalent to $15 per month required Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan taxes and fees extra. See full terms@mintmobile.com.
McLeod
There'S perhaps no prison more infamous than Alcatraz, the Rocky island and the cold waters of the San Francisco Bay. It's a place steeped in history and suffering. But what if the walls that held America's most dangerous criminals now harbor something far more sinister? Sometimes the most dangerous inmates aren' the ones who served their time. They're the ones who never left at all. Welcome to Sightings, the series that takes you inside the world's most mysterious supernatural events. Each week we bring you a thrilling story that puts you at the center of the action, followed by a discussion that dives into the accounts that inspired the story and our takes on them. I'm McLeod.
Brian
And I'm Brian. And today we're heading to the rock itself.
McLeod
What terrifying mysteries lurk within its rocky shores? One unsuspecting prisoner is about to learn for himself. Find out how on this episode of Sightings. My name's Lee Filson. I'm 43 years old and I've been in Alcatraz for six years, eight months and 17 days. Not that I'm counting or anything. When I first got sent here in 53, I figured I could handle it. I'd done time in hard places, sure, but nothing like this. Because this isn't just a prison. It's a concrete tomb. Of course, they don't tell you that when you first arrive. But I could feel it right away, the moment I got off the boat. This weight pressing down on me. Like the whole island was trying to swallow me whole. I think the seagulls felt it too. Screeching non stop, like tortured souls as guards marched me up the hill in shackles. Then they stripped me down, hosed me off and tossed me in my cell. Yeah, welcome to the Rock. I figure just about everybody says this, but I used to be somebody, you know. Had a life running numbers back in Detroit. And for good money, too. Least until the feds got wise and set me up so. Next thing I knew, I was looking at 20 for tax evasion, of all things. But that feels like ancient history now. I still remember my first night here. My cell was so small I could touch both walls with my arms outstretched. Everything was damp from the bay air. And there was this smell. Not just normal prison smell, but something older, deader. But the worst part was the sounds. See, sound does strange things on Alcatraz. The walls are so thick they swallow most noise. But then there's the other sounds. Sounds that shouldn't be there at all. Sounds that almost feel alive. You'll be lying in your bunk at night and suddenly hear footsteps when there's no one walking or voice is having conversations that make no sense. The guards say it's just the way sound carries from the city across the water. But I've been here long enough now to know better. Because this place, it wears you down. Makes you just another number in a jumpsuit. Another ghost walking these cold halls. And speaking of ghosts. You know, I can't believe I just said that. I never used to believe in that kind of thing. But after six years. Yep. After six years, things change, I guess. And for me, it happened in the hole. That's what we call solitary. These windowless cells under D block where they put you when you act up. No bed, no light. Just you in the dark and the cold seeping up through the concrete floor. And, yeah, the guard made a crack about my mother and I lost it. So there I was in cell 14D. Worst of the bunch, they say. And I quickly realized why. Because, well, something's down there. Something not human. Look, I know how that sounds, but I Was alone in that pitch black cell when I felt those icy fingers on the back of my neck. And when I was trying to sleep, I heard whispers. Words I couldn't quite make out. Then I woke up to this feeling. This absolute terrifying certainty that something was in there with me. Right next to me, breathing on me. I screamed until the guards came. Told them I was having an appendicitis attack. They took me to the hospital wing. Realized I was lying. So they sent me back down there. But to a different cell, thank God. After that, I knew I had to get out of here. Out for good. And that's where Jackie G. Came in. Jackie was doing 25 to life for armed robbery. But he wasn't your typical con. Used to be an engineer before he went bad. And he knows things, notices things. Like the fact that the bars and Block B were corroding from the solar salt air. Where the guard, Matheson, always took an extra five minutes for his smoke break on Tuesdays. So we started talking during yard time. Careful like. And Jackie told me he had a way past the locks, the guards, the walls. All of it away. Off the island for good. All he needed was time to work out the details. I, of course, reminded him that nobody escapes Alcatraz. And you know what Jackie said? That's just because no one's done it yet. Course, we Both knew about the 46 attempt. Coy, Kretzer and Hubbard were the prisoners names. They had it all planned out. Take control of a cell block, get to the recreation yard, over the fence, down to the water. But they couldn't find the key to the yard door. They held that block three days before the Marines were called in. And they fled to a utility corridor where, instead of freedom, they got grenades. Some say you can still hear them in the corridor at night. They say they're trapped there forever, trying to escape. Jackie laid out the plan. Over a few weeks. He analyzed guard routines, the timing of lighthouse sweeps, all of it. And he said we'd need tools. Spoons from the mess hall sharpened to cut through the mortar surrounding the ventilation shaft behind my cell. Then. Well, we just needed the time to pull it off. Two months of chipping away, hiding our work. Finding a way into the utility corridor. The same one where Coy and the others died. And after that, a drain pipe led straight to the bay. And then we'd swim like hell, even though I knew the water would be cold. I'd been on the swim team in high school. One of the few straight things I ever did. And despite the currents I knew I could make it to shore. So that was the plan. And until last night, the whole thing went off without a hitch. I was in my cell as usual, running the timeline through in my head. I closed my eyes, tried to sleep. When I felt it again, that same feeling I'd had in the hole, the presence. My eyes shot open, but there was nothing in my cell. Nothing but me. And an unusual chill I couldn't quite put my finger on. But eventually the cold receded and I drifted off into sleep. Into nightmare. I'm running through D block, alarms blaring, lights flashing. The escape is on somehow. But something's wrong. Jackie's not with me. I'm all alone, desperately searching for a way out as guards shout all around me. I'm cornered. And the only escape route is down, down to the hole. I take the stairs two at a time, plunging into darkness. But as I reach the bottom, that feeling hits me again. That feeling. I'm not alone. And sure enough, down at the far end of the pitch black corridor, two cold blue eyes gleam in the dark. And I can hear whatever it is dragging itself along the floor, its breath rattling as it gets closer. Closer. I screamed. In the dream, I screamed until my throat was raw. Until I woke myself up. Except I wasn't the only one screaming. The cell block was in chaos, and somewhere down the row, a man was screaming in complete, unhinged terror. The scream of a voice I'd know anywhere. It was Jackie. And he was going on about eyes in the dark, about someone watching him. And the guards were trying to talk him down, but he was hysterical. Soon enough, they dragged him away to the hospital wing, and he was still screaming until those big iron doors closed behind him and the block went eerily quiet. And just like that, our perfect plan was shot to hell. But I couldn't stay here another night. Couldn't risk another trip to the Hole. Couldn't risk facing whatever had scared Jackie so bad. So I decided I was going, come hell or high water. Because if I could just get out of here, just reach the bay, I could make it. Little did I know I wouldn't be getting off this island as easily as I thought. And this prison I thought I knew it was about to get a whole lot worse.
Lowes Advertiser
Still, getting around to that fix on your car? You got this on ebay? You'll find millions of parts guaranteed to fit. Doesn't matter if it's a major engine repair or your first time swapping your windshield wipers. Ebay has that part you need ready to Click perfectly into place for changes, big and small, loud or quiet. Find all the parts you need at prices you'll love. Guaranteed to fit every time. But you already know that. Ebay things people love. Eligible items only. Exclusion supply.
Brian
So, McLeod, as you know, I go to Area 51 every once in a while to, you know, do top secret stuff. But whenever I do, I always like to make a stop in Las Vegas. Because I have to admit, I love casinos.
Cashier
Yeah, some games of chance get the blood pumping. Now I want to go to a casino.
Brian
Well, now you can with Golden Nugget Online Casino.
Cashier
Wait, I can. Can I use real money?
Brian
Oh, yeah. If you're in Michigan, New Jersey, Pennsylvania or West Virginia, you sure can. And right now, new players can play just $5 and get 250 casino spins on a featured game. With our promo code sightings, that's 250 chances to win after you play just five bucks or more.
Cashier
So don't wait. The best rewards and the brightest moments are waiting at Golden Nugget Online Casino. Whether you're spinning slots, doubling down on blackjack, playing roulette, or any of our exclusive games you can't find anywhere else, you can make any moment golden at Golden Nugget Online casino gambling problem. Call 1-800-GAMBLER please play responsibly. 21 plus physically present in Michigan, New Jersey, Pennsylvania and West Virginia only. Void in Ontario. New customers only. Non withdrawable casino spins valid for featured game only and expire in 168 hours. See terms@goldennuggetcasino.com promos ends 4 hours, 27 minutes and 25 at 11:59pm Eastern Time.
Samsung Galaxy User
This episode is brought to you by. Enterprise Mobility. From fleet management to flexible truck rentals to technology solutions, Enterprise Mobility helps businesses find the right mobility solutions so they can find new opportunities. Because if your business is on the road, they want to make sure it's on the road to success. Enterprise Mobility Moving you moves the world. Find your road@enterprisemobility.com.
McLeod
I decided to make my move. Come nightfall, I still had the sharpened spoons we'd been using to chip away at the mortar. Still knew the route we'd mapped out. But the only thing I didn't have was Jackie's perfect timing. I'd have to wing that part. So after lights out, I waited until Brenner made his rounds. Brenner was like clockwork. Down the block at 9:15, back at his station by 9:20. And the moment his footsteps faded, I slipped the last bit of mortar away from the vent cover, and pulled it free. The opening was small, barely big enough for a grown man, but I squeezed through, feeling the rough edges scrape against my jumpsuit, and lowered myself into the narrow space between the walls. It was pitch black in there, and the smell, musty, decayed with a hint of something metallic. I thought of blood, but pushed it away and started inching forward, using my memory of Jackie's map to guide me. The space widened after about 20ft, opening into a maintenance tunnel that ran beneath D block. I could stand up, which was a relief. And I was sweating despite the cold, worried the guards could hear my every move, every heartbeat. But there was no alarm, no shouts, just the distant hum of generators and the steady drip of water from somewhere ahead. So I followed the tunnel, counting my steps in the dark, just like Jackie taught me. Left at 50, right at 30, more, moving ever closer to the utility corridor, the same one where Coy, Kretzer, and Hubbard met their end. The ancient door was heavier than I expected, but it gave way with a low groan that froze me in place. I waited, listening for any sign that someone had heard, but there was still nothing. The corridor was narrow but tall, with pipes running along the ceiling and walls. I just needed to follow it to the end, where a drainage pipe would lead straight to the water. So I moved quickly, counting my steps again, and as I neared the spot in the dark, I started feeling for the opening. But there was nothing. No pipe, no hole, nothing. I felt along the wall more carefully, thinking I'd miscounted. Still nothing. Panic rising, I pulled out my contraband match and struck it against the wall. And the sudden flare of light showed me what Jackie couldn't have known. Where there should have been a pipe, there was now solid metal, a circular outline sealed with fresh welds. The match burned down to my fingers, and I dropped it with a curse. This couldn't be happening. Jackie had sworn the pipe was open, had mapped it even. And of course, that's when I heard it. The distinct sound of a siren wailing across the island. They knew I was gone. They were looking for me. And I was trapped in a dead end. I've been in here for half an hour now, and the walls feel like they're getting closer by the minute. The alarms are still blaring, of course, but it's not the usual bells. I don't know. It feels like the whole prison is howling. I can hear the guards, boots all around me, running, searching. And those damned seagulls screaming. Now more than ever. Enough to drive you Mad. I know I have nowhere to go, no option other than to retreat back through my cell. And I'm sure they'll find their way in soon enough. If not via my route, then with brute force. Ah. Yep. And there it is. The sound of an arc welder. They're trying to cut through the wall. It sounds like screaming. Or maybe it's just those seagulls. Still, I. I don't know. It's hard to tell. Everything just echoes. Wrong in here. I knew I should run, hide, anything. But I can't stop staring at the wall. In the dim light, I can make out these. These marks. They look like bullet holes, but. But too big. Almost like something exploded in here, like grenades. There's other marks too. Long scratches in the concrete, like someone tried to claw their way out of here. If I didn't know better, I'd say they look fresh, but. But that's impossible. No prisoners. Been here since 46, right? Damn, I screwed this up good, didn't I? When they find me, they'll drag me to the hole and forget me until I go crazy like Jackie. And maybe that's what I deserve. Maybe that's what this whole place is. Just one big hole they throw bad men into and forget about. Wait. Wait. I've still got one of those sharpened sweet spoons in my pocket. And I'm wondering if I can use it on the guards or no, on myself. Yeah. Yeah. Just one sharp jab to the throat should do. I can't. Because every time I reach for it, I feel those icy fingers on the back of my neck again. Feel that breath that isn't breath at all. The corridor's gone quiet. I can't hear the guards anymore, or the welder or the birds. It's like someone threw a switch and turned off the world. No sound at all. Except. Wait. There it is. That dragging the one from my dream. It's getting closer. What is that? Whispers forming words I still can't quite make out, but they're clearer now. Closer. The temperature has dropped so low, I can see my breath. No, not my breath, because I'm holding it. I know what's behind me. Know what I'll see if I turn around? Those cold blue eyes floating in the dark. The eyes of men who tried to escape and failed. Men trapped here forever, just like I'm about to be. The whispers are words now, clear as day. And they're saying my name over and over, calling me to join them. Promising me that the pain will stop if I just give in. That I'LL never have to go back to the hole. Never have to feel alone again. Maybe they're right. Maybe this is where I belonged all along. Oh, God. It's right there. Right behind me. I can feel it reaching for me.
Brian
Sightings will be back just after this.
Samsung Galaxy User
This episode is brought to you by Shopify. Upgrade your business with Shopify, home of the number one checkout on the planet. Shop pay boosts conversions up to 50%, meaning fewer carts going abandoned and more sandals going cha ching. So if you're into growing your business, get a commerce platform that's ready to sell wherever your customers are. Visit shopify.com to upgrade your selling today.
Brian
Hello, skeptical geckos and believer beavers. Brian here and I want to share one of my favorite podcast recommendations with you. It's called Believing the Bizarre, and it's a paranormal extravaganza that dives into hauntings, cryptids, aliens, conspiracies, and more. I myself have been listening to Tyler and Charlie for years because they're so much fun. They really do bring an entertaining yet balanced perspective to all things supernatural. And the show really feels like just hanging around the campfire telling ghost stories with friends. So if you ever thought the Loch Ness Monster could be a ghost, which is a theory I have not heard before, or if you bring a skeptical eye to some conspiracies you read on the Internet, I think Believing the bizarre is going to be right up your alley. They've got new episodes every Tuesday, so check out Believing the Bizarre right now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
Samsung Galaxy User
This episode is brought to you by Pluto tv. Are you looking for your next case? Pluto TV has all your favorite crime dramas streaming for free, which means Suspicion is free with countless cases to crack. Watch csi, Criminal Minds, ncis, Blue Bloods, Tracker, FBI, and swat. All for free from all your favorite devices. Feel the free Pluto TV stream now. Pain Never.
McLeod
Welcome to the Rock.
Brian
You had to go there.
Cashier
I had to go there. Welcome back, everybody. Alcatraz. So cool. Because I'm Brian. I'm, you know, I'm familiar with the notion. I've never been to Alcatraz. Have you?
Brian
I have. I have a couple of times, actually. It's a really cool place to visit if you haven't been. It's kind of. And it's also kind of terrifyingly creepy. Is it?
Cashier
So did you feel the vibes like this guy was feeling?
Brian
Well, not as much because it's all been a little bit polished. You know, it's kind of hard to feel those vibes when you're surrounded by tourists rather than being a prisoner alone in a cell kind of thing. But I think the whole atmosphere of the is. Is just creepy in the sense that it's in the middle of the bay. There's almost always fog obscuring part of the island, so that naturally gives us.
Cashier
Super creepy kind of creepy vibe.
Brian
It's also just rocky, and there's not ornamentation, and it's not a pretty island by any means. And then the buildings, a lot of them are kind of dilapidated and falling apart and stuff like that. And it sounds like a lot of them were dilapidated and falling apart back in the 30s, too, when the island became a federal penitentiary. Before that, it was a. There's a whole history of the island that we can get into.
McLeod
Right.
Brian
But, yeah, it's just. It just seems like a natural place to have creepy ghost stories flying around.
Cashier
And the sounds was your experience, you know, did it have an odd sound to it?
Brian
No, not as much as was portrayed in the.
Cashier
Okay.
Brian
I think the reason why was I had a headset on the entire time because it's like a guided audio tour kind of thing.
Cashier
Gotcha.
Brian
Interesting thing about the birds, you know, and the birds, you know, I brought a lot about the birds squealing and things like that. You know, Alcatraz means island of the Pelicans.
McLeod
Oh.
Brian
Ironically, it's not pelicans on the island, though. It's almost all seagull. They make a lot of noise. So I think that's kind of a fun, fun little thing.
Cashier
Okay, well, so anyway, I've, you know, I've probably, like, a lot of our listeners heard stories about Alcatraz being famously haunted and about it being super difficult to escape and that supposedly, maybe only one person ever did it.
Brian
Allegedly, three people did vanish.
Cashier
Three people vanished.
Brian
Yeah. So they. They did. And. But. But they were never seen again. So it is presumed that they just drown in the bay.
McLeod
Right.
Cashier
It is notoriously difficult to swim those currents. Correct?
Brian
Well, it's the currents and the cold.
Cashier
Right.
Brian
You know, that water's freezing. So I don't feel great for the prospects of our main character here, even.
Cashier
If he had gotten out.
Brian
Yeah, exactly, exactly, exactly.
Cashier
So my question for you, is our man here, is this a specific tale? Is this, like a known ghost, like, escape attempt, or is this kind of called together from the generalized Alcatraziness?
Brian
It's kind of the latter. Yeah. It's kind of a patchwork of things that are known or legends of Alcatraz all kind of patched together.
McLeod
Gotcha.
Brian
The idea of the way he was trying to escape, that's a real thing. Like the idea that there was the mention in the story about the three people who tried to escape, went down this utility corridor and got grenaded by Marines. That happened. That was in the 1940s. That escape attempt went real bad.
Cashier
Yeah.
Brian
And the idea that, you know, there are ghosts and hearing voices and feeling things, especially in those in the hole, that's all allegedly true. But again, like, there's Alcatraz is kind of unique because a lot unlike some other haunted house stories we've done, there's not one, like, ghost necessarily.
McLeod
Right.
Cashier
There's not like the. Oh, like the ghost that does this all the time.
Brian
Yeah. But I think it kind of speaks to just the nature of prisons in general and that they're these places of kind of misfortune and being stuck.
Cashier
Deprivation.
Brian
Exactly. And I feel like a lot of these prisoners have unfinished business in life and probably in death. And it's kind of interesting when we go into some of the ghosts. Some of the people who are purported to haunt Alcatraz did not die on Alcatraz Island.
McLeod
Huh.
Brian
And yet they are still purported to have a presence there.
McLeod
Oh, wow.
Cashier
I can't wait to hear about that. So before the ghosts, or maybe including the ghosts, like, can you tell me a little bit about the history of Alcatraz? Has this always been a site of paranormal activity?
Brian
I don't know about paranormal. It was always a spooky place, it seems like. So, you know, the island was, quote, unquote, discovered in the 16th century by the Spaniards. Of course, that's not taking into account the Native Americans who were already there. And they knew about Alcatraz island and did not go near it. They considered it to be a place of evil spirits, so to speak.
Cashier
So it did always have spooky vibes.
Brian
Vibes, I think, rather than actual activity, per se. But, yeah, it definitely scared the Native Americans, it seemed like. And as the settlers came in and it started changing hands, it changed hands a lot with the United States and the Spaniards and all that kind of stuff. But by the 1850s, it had become a fortress, basically. It was the first had the first lighthouse on the West Coast. And it eventually, after the Civil War, became a more of a military prison situation. And even during the Civil War, there were Civil War prisoners who were kept on Alcatraz. But it didn't really become a prison, per se. It was more of a fortress until the 1870s.
Cashier
I'm most familiar, I guess, with Alcatraz being like a federal prison. Didn't they have some really famous prisoners? Like, was Al. Was Al Capone there?
Brian
I think Al Capone was there, yeah. So in 1934, it became a U.S. penitentiary. And that was basically because, I guess the state or whoever was controlling it before that couldn't handle the upkeep anymore. So the feds took it over. And it basically kind of served the dual purpose of being a place that we could put our worst public enemies. But also because it was such a scary place, kind of like a warning to criminals, like, don't mess around with the US Government right now. This was right after the Depression. There was kind of a new class of criminals, kind of like organized crime wise.
Cashier
Bootleggers.
Brian
Yeah, bootleggers, organized crime, tax evaders, things like that. It was the era of, like, these big, big gangsters that the government was always trying to bring down. And like you said, Al Capone was at Alcatraz for a while before eventually being released. But when it was a federal penitentiary, it was the worst of the worst. Federal penitentiaries, they made that thing as tight and sealed up as possible. You know, they cemented over old utility tunnels. They built guard towers all over the place. They made toolproof window coverings. You know, there was no way off this island, even though, you know, many, many people tried.
Cashier
My goodness. Like, what did you have to do to warrant being imprisoned here?
Brian
Well, Al Capone was technically in prison for tax evasion, because that's all they could pin.
McLeod
Right.
Cashier
One of those things where they're just like, we'll find something.
Brian
Another famous prisoner was known as the Birdman of Alcatraz. And that's mainly because before he came to Alcatraz, when he was in prison in Leavenworth, he took up ornithology and started writing books about birds, even though he seemed like to be kind of a charlatan and a guy who could just resynthesize information and make it sound like it was from his own observations. Yeah, exactly. But he went into prison originally for murdering somebody. Right before he was supposed to get out of Leavenworth, he murdered a guard and then he got sent to Alcatraz. Yeah. So he ended up getting released and died a free man, it sounds like.
McLeod
Oh, he got released. Interesting.
Brian
Yeah. But he's also now theoretically a ghost of Alcatraz in that people can hear him whistling or attempting to communicate with birds from beyond the grave.
McLeod
Huh.
Cashier
But that's so bizarre. So, like, so we mentioned this earlier. Let's like, let's visit this notion of people. People dying off the island, returning to haunt it.
Brian
Al Capone's another one, really. Al Capone was arrested in 1931. Eventually he was moved to Alcatraz. He was released in 1947. But while he was at Alcatraz, he was kind of a model prisoner, actually. But he was released and then died in 1947 as a free man. But people still hear him. Apparently something he did in prison was he had a banjo. And people still hear disembodied banjo playing in the shower room in one of the cell blocks. So besides those two people who didn't actually die on the island, there's lots of other people who have died on Alcatraz. A lot of civil war soldiers. And that seems to be kind of the brunt of the hauntings are probably a lot of these earlier prisoners.
Cashier
You know, interestingly, what's happening for me is kind of almost in part because this story is a amalgamation, an aggregate story. There's something that rings true to me. Whether it's necessarily real ghosts or kind of more of a metaphor, like this story feels true. Even if it's not a true story, it has a truth to it. And in part, it's ghost. In part, it's the nature of sensory deprivation and of psychosis and of desperation.
Brian
I feel like the psychosis part is what really kind of stuck out to me because there's definitely a mental component to what I was imagining for this character. And I imagine for a lot of the prisoners on this island, it's a mental game trying to survive.
Cashier
Yeah. And I don't doubt the experience of these men in the hole, you know, feeling these ghost touches or these, like, hearing these breathy things, because I think when the mind is deprived of stimulus, it creates.
Brian
Yeah, I can only imagine what it was like hallucinating or just letting your brain kind of take over and try and fill that darkness and emptiness with stimulus of some kind or paranoia of some kind. But what's kind of interesting about the hole in particular is that modern day visitors to the island have seen weird things down there and felt icy fingers on the back of their necks and things like that, too. And then another location that's really popular for paranormal activity is the laundry room. People have seen kind of like a smoke in there, Almost like there's a fire. But then when they investigate, it kind of just vanishes. There's whispers that people hear, People hear footsteps. There's even rumors that before the current lighthouse, there was apparently another lighthouse on the island, and people have seen that second lighthouse, even though it no longer exists. So is it calling Tormented souls home or something? I don't know.
Cashier
Very trippy. Very trippy.
Brian
I believe I'm a believer, Beaver on this one, in that there's something happening on Alcatraz. What do you think, McLeod?
Cashier
I'm a believer, Beaver. That there's something happening and in the kind of metaphorical imprint that horrible things happening can have on a space.
Brian
Yeah, yeah, absolutely. So, listeners, tell us what you think. Hit us up on Instagram yitingspod or drop us a line on comments on Spotify. That'd be awesome.
Cashier
So, Brian, break me out of this cage. Let's escape this prison and get on to the next Supernatural event. What you got for me?
Brian
Well, we're gonna have several supernatural events because it's another listener story.
Cashier
That's right.
Brian
We're gonna dive into three awesome new listener stories. Keep them coming, everyone. They are awesome. We love them. They're creeping me out all the time. So I am excited to share three of our favorites. So come back, same time, same place, next week and check them out.
Cashier
Looking forward to it.
Brian
Sightings is hosted by McLeod Andrews and Brian Sigley. Produced by Brian Sigley, Chase Kinzer, and McLeod Andrews. Written by Brian Sigley. Story music by Madison James Smith. Series music by Mitch Bain. Mixing and mastering by Pat Kicklater of Sundial Media. Artwork by Nuno Cernatos. For a list of this episode's sources, check out our website@sightingspodcast.com Sightings is presented by Reverb and Q Code. If you like the show, be sure to subscribe on your favorite podcast platform so you're first to hear new episodes every week. And if you know other Supernatural fans, tell them about us. We'd really appreciate it.
Podcast Information:
In the "Ghosts of Alcatraz: California, 1959" episode, hosts McLeod Andrews and Brian Sigley take listeners on a chilling journey into the infamous Alcatraz Island. Released on March 24, 2025, this episode intertwines a gripping narrative with insightful discussions, exploring the supernatural legends that haunt one of America's most notorious prisons.
a. Lee Filson's Background
The episode opens with the haunting tale of Lee Filson, a 43-year-old inmate who has spent over six years at Alcatraz. Filson reflects on his arrival in 1953:
"[00:14] McLeod: ...it's a concrete tomb. Of course, they don't tell you that when you first arrive."
Filson, once a successful individual involved in financial dealings in Detroit, finds himself incarcerated for tax evasion—a charge he deems unfair and a mere stepping stone to a more sinister reality within Alcatraz.
b. The Supernatural Experiences
Filson recounts his eerie experiences within the prison walls:
"[01:00] McLeod: ...sounds that shouldn't be there at all. Sounds that almost feel alive."
He describes unexplained footsteps, indecipherable conversations, and a pervasive sense of being watched. These phenomena intensify during his solitary confinement in "the hole," where sensory deprivation exacerbates his psychological stress.
c. The Escape Plan with Jackie G.
Desperate to escape the oppressive environment, Filson partners with Jackie G., an inmate serving a life sentence for armed robbery:
"[01:37] McLeod: Jackie G. ...he had a way past the locks, the guards, the walls. All of it away."
Together, they meticulously plan an escape, utilizing sharpened spoons to breach the ventilation shafts. Their strategy hinges on timing and precise execution, drawing inspiration from a failed 1946 escape attempt by other inmates.
d. The Nightmare and Failure of the Escape
As the night of their planned escape unfolds, Filson experiences a vivid nightmare where he becomes isolated and hunted within the prison corridors. This unsettling dream mirrors the actual chaos that erupts when Jackie G. becomes hysterical, derailing their meticulously crafted plan.
"[02:22] Brian: And I'm Brian. And today we're heading to the rock itself."
The escape attempt collapses under the weight of supernatural interference, leaving Filson trapped and questioning the very fabric of reality within Alcatraz.
Following the narrative, McLeod and Brian delve into a comprehensive discussion about Alcatraz's haunted legacy.
a. Historical Context and Paranormal Phenomena
The hosts explore Alcatraz’s transformation from a military fortress to a federal penitentiary in 1934, housing notorious criminals like Al Capone. They discuss how the island's grim history lays the foundation for its ghostly legends.
"[25:06] Cashier: ...a whole history of the island that we can get into."
b. Famous Prisoners and Ghost Stories
Al Capone's presence is frequently mentioned, not just for his criminal exploits but also for the lingering spectral remnants reported by visitors, such as disembodied banjo music.
"[31:53] McLeod: Oh, he got released. Interesting."
Other spirits, including Civil War soldiers and the so-called Birdman of Alcatraz, add layers to the island's haunted reputation, with sightings and unexplained noises continuing to fuel ghost stories.
c. Psychological Explanations
McLeod and Brian consider the psychological toll of solitary confinement and sensory deprivation, proposing that hallucinations and paranoia among inmates could explain many of the supernatural sightings.
"[33:42] Brian: ...the psychosis part is what really kind of stuck out to me."
They argue that the extreme conditions within Alcatraz could lead prisoners to experience vivid hallucinations, blurring the lines between reality and the supernatural.
d. Modern-Day Paranormal Reports
Interestingly, the discussion highlights that even contemporary visitors to Alcatraz report paranormal activities, such as feeling icy touches or hearing whispers, suggesting that the island's dark history continues to leave an imprint.
"[34:13] Brian: ...modern day visitors to the island have seen weird things down there..."
The episode culminates in a reflection on the enduring mysteries of Alcatraz. McLeod and Brian acknowledge that whether through actual supernatural events or the psychological impacts of imprisonment, Alcatraz remains a potent symbol of isolation and fear. They invite listeners to ponder the interplay between the island's historical horrors and the ghostly tales that persist to this day.
"[35:22] Brian: ...it has a truth to it."
The hosts encourage audience interaction, urging listeners to share their own experiences and theories about Alcatraz's haunted legacy.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps:
Final Thoughts: "Ghosts of Alcatraz: California, 1959" masterfully blends a compelling firsthand account with a deep dive into historical and psychological perspectives. McLeod and Brian provide a balanced exploration of supernatural lore and the human psyche, making the episode both intriguing and thought-provoking for listeners interested in the mysterious and the unexplained.