Loading summary
Detective Aaron
Want to get more work done with less effort.
Advertisement Voice
On TikTok, creators are sharing AI automation
Yardley Smith
tips that save time and deliver better results. Tap to discover try TikTok now.
Advertisement Voice
Be adventurous in the sun. Be protected in the sun. Be confident in the Sun Be fearless in the sun with Blue Lizard Australian Sunscreen. As experts in mineral sunscreens for nearly 30 years, we've earned awards for our high quality products and the trust of healthcare professionals. Embrace every moment in the sun with your family and Blue Lizard by your side. Be fearless in the sun. Shop Blue Lizard Australian sunscreen now on Amazon.com
Yardley Smith
hey small town fam, it's Yardley. I want to remind you that if you want access to bonus episodes and regular episodes a day early and ad free and our community forum and other behind the scenes goodies, you gotta go to smalltowndicks.com superfam and then in the top right hand corner, hit that little tab that says join. And then listen to the end of today's episode for a sneak peek at today's new bonus episode. Hey, Small town fam, it's Yardley. How are you guys? I hope you're all well and I hope you're exactly where you want to be. We have such an interesting case for you today, brought to us by returning guest, retired detective Aaron. You'll recognize Aaron's voice from seasons 16 and 17. He's definitely one of our favorites. So I would describe today's case as quintessential true crime. The circumstances are harrowing. The victim is extraordinarily brave and a great witness. And the suspect is a repeat offender who never should have been let out of prison. And just when you think you know how this case is going to end, the case gets thrown into jeopardy because of illegal technicality. But that's not the end either, because then karma makes a cameo. And, well, you're just gonna have to listen to see what happens next. Here is. You're mine. Hi there. I'm Yeardley.
Detective Dan
I'm Dan.
Detective Dave
I'm Dave.
Paul Holes
And I'm Paul.
Yardley Smith
And this is Small Town Dicks.
Detective Dan
Dave and I are identical twins and
Detective Dave
retired detectives from Small Town, usa.
Paul Holes
And I'm a veteran cold case investigator who helped catch the Golden State killer using a revolutionary DNA tool.
Detective Dan
Between the three of us, we've investigated thousands of crimes, from pet theft to sexual assault, child abuse to murder.
Detective Dave
Each case we cover is told by the detective who investigated it, offering a rare personal account of how they solved the crime.
Paul Holes
Names, places, and certain details have been changed to protect the privacy of Victims and their families.
Detective Dan
And although we're aware that some of our listeners may be familiar with these cases, we ask you to please join us in continuing to protect the true identities of those involved out of respect
Detective Dave
for what they've been through.
Yardley Smith
Thank you. Today on Small Town Dicks, my friends, we have most of the usual suspects. We have Detective Dan.
Detective Dave
Hello there.
Yardley Smith
Hello, you. We have Detective Dave.
Detective Dave
Hello, everyone.
Yardley Smith
Hello. Hello. We do not have the one and only Paul Holes today. Don't worry, he'll be back next week. Sometimes, you know, in the herding of cats one gets. But you have the OGs here on the microphone with you today, so you're in excellent hands. And my friends, we are so very lucky and delighted to have returning to the podcast, Detective Aaron.
Detective Aaron
Hello.
Yardley Smith
Hi, Aaron, it's so great to see you again.
Detective Aaron
It's great to be seen.
Yardley Smith
Thanks so much for joining us. Small Town fam. If you've been listening for more than a minute, you'll remember Aaron from past seasons. He's actually given us three episodes so far, starting with one that we called Dead weight in season 16. He then went on to Give us two more in season 17 whose titles I'm gonna put in the show notes because maybe you're driving or walking a dog or walking yourself and you don't have a pen handy. So don't worry, I got you. All of Aaron's episodes are definitely worth a listen. So, Aaron, without further ado, please tell us how this case came to you.
Detective Aaron
Absolutely. So this case came to me in January of 2017. So January 2017 in the Portland area. It was a really, really cold winter that winter, and we had temperatures dipping below zero. So this case came to me early on a Saturday morning. I was on call. So at the time I was signed as a major crimes detective, Homicide and child abuse. But we take on call weeks. So the on call weeks, meaning that if anything comes up during our off times or off hours, then we're the primary detective that's going to respond out to that. And that's the way this case came to me. It came to me early, about 7 o' clock in the morning on a Saturday morning is when my phone rang. And as any officer or detective could understand, the information you get sometimes is very convoluted and it's hard to make heads or tails out of. So the information I got was patrol officers were out at a residence in my city. And in my city, there's a part of the city called Rockwood. And Rockwood is, I would say it's probably the most dangerous part of the city of Portland. And for our police department, it takes 80% of our resources about 80% of the time. So it's got a very high violent crime rate, high murder rate, that type of stuff. So when this call comes in, it comes in that officers are at a residence, and at that residence they have a man in custody. They're not quite sure what for, but at least burglary. The original report says that just before 7am a woman comes pounding on the door. The homeowner opens the door, lady comes barging in, says, he's after me, he's chasing me. And the man closes the door, tells the lady to go and hide. This is a stranger to him. And a couple minutes later, there's somebody banging on the door. And ultimately the guy inside says, hey, I've got a gun. Stay out, don't come through the door. The guy outside kicks in the door and comes into the apartment looking for the woman that he's chasing. And that is what we know. When the officers call me, they said that the woman is hysterical. She's on her way to the hospital. She's reporting being sexually abused. She's reporting a kidnapping, and her story is all over the place. The young lady we're talking about has some drug addiction issues. She is addicted at the time to methamphetamine as well as heroin. So we're dealing with some under the influence type behavior as well. And it's really hard to make heads or tails as to what we've got. So myself and my partner, Detective Dan, we rolled out to the scene. I went to the scene, and he went to the office to try to get things going at the office. When I got to the scene, it's exactly what I would expect. This is an upstairs condo apartment unit. Front doors obviously have been kicked in. The female victim, Lindsey, she has been transported to the hospital. And I'm at the scene with the police officers. I speak to the homeowner, and he relays the same story. There's not a whole lot of change from what I originally got told. And that is good because it means that the story wasn't so convoluted. He essentially wakes up to somebody banging on the door. Normally in this part of town, he said he wouldn't open the door to people because it's a dangerous area. But he heard a female voice. When he opened the door, she came barging in, Reports that she's being chased, closes the door, and a couple minutes later, an unknown man is kicking the door down.
Yardley Smith
And Aaron, this homeowner, he doesn't actually know Lindsay. This is just the first door Lindsay happens upon, is that so?
Detective Aaron
That is correct, yeah.
Yardley Smith
Okay. And does the homeowner have a name?
Detective Aaron
The homeowner's name is Rick. So Rick says that when the door got kicked open, he was looking up and he saw a huge man standing in the doorway. He said this man was broad at the shoulder, narrow at the waist, physically fit, muscular. And he said he was scared. He said he told the guy not to come in, that he had a gun, he would shoot him. Rick said that he pointed the gun at the suspect and at that time the suspect came in, the suspect hit Rick in the face and that's about the time the police showed up. So that's the information that we have, that situation.
Detective Dave
Rick is fully within his rights to handle that with the gun in his hand.
Detective Aaron
Yeah, fully within his rights.
Yardley Smith
Aaron, how old is Rick?
Detective Aaron
Rick is about 50 years old.
Yardley Smith
And what's the suspect's name?
Detective Aaron
Suspect's name is Andrew.
Yardley Smith
Andrew. It's easy for Andrew to get one over on Rick. I mean it's so discombobulating. Somebody fucking breaks in your door after this strange woman goes, let me in.
Detective Aaron
Yeah, Rick was pretty shook up that morning. I left a team there processing that scene. But I went out inside and I spoke to Andrew in the car. Andrew is a mid 20 year old white male who is physically fit. He is the star football player, the jock on the football team. Six pack full of muscles. There's a reason why he's full of muscles. We'll get to that in a minute. But he's full of muscles. And he's the kid that never got past about 13 years old. Mentally he's kind of stuck in that juvenile. I'm the coolest kid in town state and that's what I'm dealing with. But I don't want to talk to Andrew too much right now because I don't have a lot of facts about the case. So I want to dig into the case more and ultimately Andrew's the last person I want to talk to once I put all the other pieces together. So from that point we know we have at least burglary on Andrew for breaking into Rick's apartment. So I asked the patrol officers take him back to the office and basically put him on ice, put him in the holding cell until we can make heads or tails as to what we're dealing with in this situation. By the time I got back to the office, Lindsay had returned from the hospital, and she was there waiting for me. So now I get to speak to the female victim, Lindsay, in this case. And this is what I learned. So Lindsay says, I met Andrew about six months ago. We dated for about four or five months. Andrew became very close to my family. He was paying the bills for my family. He was paying my sister to go to school. He was taking care of us. And everybody loves him, she says. I loved him, but he was very violent sexually with me. And that became a point of contention where I couldn't take it anymore. And I broke up with him, she said. But when I broke up with him, that upset him and he refused to let me go and he stalked me, she said, about six or seven days ago, I was able to get away from his house, and he lives here in Rockwood. Lindsay says she went to hide at a friend's house, But Andrew knocked on the door late at night and asked Lindsay to go outside to the car to speak with him. Lindsay says she and Andrew went out to the car. And as soon as Lindsay got in Andrew's car, he started to back up down to the end of this dead end road. Lindsay says that that scared her because Andrew would have no reason to back up other than not wanting to be seen by anybody looking out of the house. So Lindsay and Andrew start talking, and Andrew tells Lindsay that he wants her back and he wants this relationship. Lindsay says this is clearly over, and Andrew starts to drive away. When Andrew starts to drive away, Lindsay reaches for the door handle, but realizes the door handle has been taken off of the inside of the car. So there's no door handle and there's no window crank. This is an older car with a window crank. So Lindsay is stuck in Andrew's car As Andrew starts to speed away. Lindsay says that Andrew drives them all over the Portland metropolitan area down a bunch of back roads. Lindsay says that Andrew is driving at a high rate of speed. He's beating her up as he's driving, and he's saying that if I can't have you, nobody will. And Andrew is telling Lindsey that he's going to drive both of them either into a bridge embankment or a tree or a telephone pole. He is going to kill both of them, Lindsay says. This goes on for a couple of hours, and then finally, Andrew brings Lindsay to an unknown house in the middle of nowhere. Lindsay's beat up, she's upset. She doesn't know where she is, but she knows she's at a home. And it feels like it's in the middle of the woods. Lindsay says Andrew takes her inside and takes her to the basement of this house. And Lindsay describes the basement. She describes the basement as having avocado colored walls, A brown sectional sofa, and that Andrew had taken the cushions off of that sectional sofa. And laid them on the floor as a makeshift mattress. Lindsay said that Andrew forced her onto that bedding and sexually assaulted her. Lindsay says that by this time, it's well into the middle of the night. And after being sexually assaulted, he takes her outside. And at this time, temperatures are nearing zero degrees. Lindsay says that Andrew walks her across the property. And puts her into what she believes is a barn in the middle of the property. Lindsay says that Andrew had inside of this large barn. Which was dilapidated and no longer being used. There was a smaller room constructed in the corner of this barn. And Lindsay says that Andrew took her in there. And there were some eye bolts in the wall with rope on it. And Andrew tied Lindsay up to this rope to this wall. And there was a mattress inside of this room. And Andrew left her there. Lindsay says that over the next three days, Andrew would come down and bring her food after breakfast, leftovers. And brought her a blanket so she could wrap up in this blanket. And Lindsay says she spent the most of the three days alone inside of this room. Except for when he would either feed her or come down and sexually abuse her or assault her. She said that on about the third day, Andrew came down, it was the middle of the day, and said, hey, I need to go to my probation office in Salem, and I need to take you with me. Because if I don't take you with me, Nobody knows that you're here. And if I go to jail, I can't just leave you here tied to the wall, unattended. So Andrew brings Lindsay some clothes, and she puts them on. Lindsay tells me that these are not her clothes. She doesn't know where the clothes came from, but they're definitely not hers. Lindsay said that Andrew walked her to the car, put her in his car, and Andrew then drove Lindsay down to Salem, Oregon, out of the Portland metropolitan area.
Yardley Smith
And about how far is that?
Detective Aaron
It's about a hour drive from where they were.
Yardley Smith
Aaron Howell is Lindsay.
Detective Aaron
Lindsay's 25 at the time. So she's probably 32, 33 now.
Yardley Smith
And Andrew was about that age, too, at the time this case came to you?
Detective Aaron
That is correct.
Detective Dan
And Aaron, what is Andrew on probation for?
Detective Aaron
That is a great question. He's on probation for rape in the first degree. So Andrew has been out of jail about six Months. When he meets Lindsay, he's out, he's on probation. So all those muscles and that six pack is all prison strong. So that's how he got that.
Detective Dave
I feel like the rehabilitative efforts of the Department of Corrections did not take in this situation.
Yardley Smith
It didn't take with Andrew.
Detective Aaron
It's going to get worse before it gets better. It will.
Detective Dave
Deleteme makes it easy, quick and safe to remove your personal data online. At a time when surveillance and data breaches are common enough enough to make everyone vulnerable. It's easier than most people think to find someone's personal information online. Addresses, phone numbers, even family members. And once that information is out there, it can be used in ways that can get dangerous fast. From my time in law enforcement, I can tell you you don't want that kind of information floating around. It's just one more way people can be exposed. That's one of the reasons I take privacy seriously. Deleteme helps by going out and removing your personal data from hundreds of data broker site which can help reduce your risk and give you a little more control over what's out there. It's a practical step. You can't control everything, but you can make it harder for your information to be misused. Take control of your data and keep your private life private by signing up for Deleteme now at a special discount for our listeners. Get 20% off your delete me plan when you go to JoinDeleteMe.com Smalltown Dicks and use promo code Small Town Dicks at checkout. The only way to get 20% off is to go to joindeleteme.com smalltown dicks and enter code Smalltown Dicks at checkout. That's joind deleteme.com smalltown dicks code small Town Dicks.
Detective Aaron
So Andrew and Lindsay go down to Salem. On the way down, Andrew tells Lindsay, don't think about escaping, don't think about running away, don't think about disclosing what's going on because I know where your family lives. They're very close to me and I could very easily go and kill them. So with this information, Lindsay goes to the probation office and sits in the car while Andrew goes inside and checks in. As luck would have it, Andrew doesn't get arrested and he goes back to the car. Andrew then says, you know what? I need to stop at Walmart. So let's go to Walmart. We'll go shopping together. But again, please don't tell anybody because I'll kill your family. So Andrew and Lindsay go to Walmart, and they walk around the store. She says, they shop, they get some household items, and then they get back in the car and they drive back to the Portland area, back to this barn, if you will. She says she's tied back up, and Lindsay spends the next night in the barn. Now we're gonna wake up to Saturday morning. This brings us to the morning of the incident, early morning of the incident. So Lindsay tells Andrew, hey, I'm dope sick. I need some methadone, and I need to go to a clinic. Andrew trusts Lindsay at this point because Lindsay has had multiple opportunities to escape but hasn't. So Andrew says, all right, let's go. So Andrew saddles her up in the car, and Andrew takes Lindsay to the local methadone clinic in the heart of Rockwood.
Yardley Smith
Can I ask you a question, Erin?
Detective Dave
Yeah.
Yardley Smith
If Lindsay is addicted to methamphetamine as well as heroin, is methadone a remedy for both of those drugs?
Detective Aaron
So methadone is a opiate. So methadone is the fix for the heroin side of it. But oftentimes people will use both drugs, and they'll use them to counterbalance. Back in the day, it was a speedball. You're taking cocaine, and you're taking an up and a downer, and you kind of find your balance in the middle.
Yardley Smith
I see.
Detective Aaron
So Lindsay had the foresight to realize that Andrew could not go into the medical facility with her, and that would put some separation between the two of them. So whether she was actually trying to get her fixed or whether she was trying to set up an opportunity to escape, either way, Andrew took Lindsay to the methadone clinic. So Andrew and Lindsay get to the methadone clinic, and Andrew has to wait in the lobby, and Lindsay goes back to see her provider. When Lindsay is in the back to see her provider, she asks to go use the restroom. And when she goes, Lindsay actually runs out the back door of the methadone clinic.
Yardley Smith
I love her.
Detective Aaron
So this is shortly before 7am on Saturday when we got the call. So Lindsay runs out the back door. Andrew realizes something's amiss and looks outside and sees her running across this open field towards some apartments. So he gives chase. Now he's in pursuit. Andrew's in pursuit of Lindsay. Lindsay makes it to the stranger's house first, goes inside, closes the door. Andrew steps behind, kicks the door open. And that's how this story started. So that's what we've got going on, and that's what Lindsay tells me during this interview.
Detective Dan
So Yardley, I know you're like, hey, I love this girl when she books out the back. The safest place for Lindsay to be was in that clinic. This is like the addict behavior that we see where they're just not thinking straight and they don't process information like you or I do in our sober state of mind. So the most rational thing for her is to book it out the back when really she was safest. Just being in that office with the doctor and the medical staff there.
Detective Dave
She's in an office full of mandatory reporters.
Yardley Smith
Yeah, you're right. You're absolutely right. Yep.
Detective Aaron
That was the safest place for Lindsay to be. She chose to escape.
Yardley Smith
So, Aaron, Lindsay escapes from Andrew, and she goes to this apartment, bangs on the door, guy lets her in. Then Andrew shows up, kicks the door in, and Rick, the homeowner, has a gun, but he's in his 50s. Andrew is super fit, blah, blah, blah, overcomes Rick. How much time passes in that assault on Rick before the cops show up and get Andrew in handcuffs? Because it seems like Andrew is unstoppable.
Detective Aaron
It was just a couple of minutes. I would say two to five minutes is how long it took for the police to get there. When Lindsey came in, she immediately called the police and made that 911 call. In the report, there were actually several 911 calls as a result. So the police were in the area. Remember, I said this area takes 80% of our resources. 80% of the time, there was already officers nearby, and they responded in and took care of business.
Yardley Smith
I see. So when police officers encounter Andrew in Rick's apartment, he may be going wild, but he hasn't had much time to do any damage. And I'm assuming like Lindsay's locked herself in the bathroom or something.
Detective Aaron
That is correct, yes.
Yardley Smith
Because two minutes can seem like a really long time. I think if your life is in
Detective Dave
danger, that's a real long time. With an armed homeowner and a home invasion burglary 10ft inside that door.
Detective Dan
Andrew, covering 10ft is like covering a mile if I had a gun in my hand. Like, you made bad decisions, and now you're going to pay for it. Andrew got lucky with Rick.
Detective Aaron
So with this information that I've got from Lindsay, I'm a little bit more armed and prepared to go talk to Andrew and get some of his information. But we want to put a good story. You know, this sounds convoluted, and one of the things that law enforcement we hear, we hear these convoluted stories, and we have to try to put the pieces of the puzzle together. Because sometimes they sound like they're made up and they sound fiction. They sound like they're off the movies. I'm sure there's a movie made out there about somebody being tied up in a barn for three days. It just happens. So now we gotta try to put some physical evidence with that. I need to try to identify where this house was that Andrew took Lindsay to. So one of the things that Andrew told Lindsay just prior to the drive to Salem was, my parents don't know you're here.
Yardley Smith
Why on earth would you say that if you weren't inferring that my parents are nearby?
Detective Aaron
You know, I think that morning when Andrew told Lindsay, you know, my parents don't know you're here, Andrew is getting a surprise call for a surprise visit to his probation officer. And he's made himself a tangled web of lies and deceit. He has somebody tied up, literally in the barn, and he needs to do something. So he is just reacting. This isn't something he forethought. This is a reactionary phrase and statement that he made to Lindsay. And he says, let's get our shit together. My parents don't know you're here. You're coming with me. That's the kind of comment but Lindsay was smart enough to pick it up and hear it and remember it.
Yardley Smith
I feel like perhaps that gave law enforcement sort of a place to start, right?
Detective Aaron
Absolutely. That is definitely what we heard and how we started this. And one of the first things we did in that investigative process was identify the house. And we did it fairly quickly. And it was based off that one comment.
Yardley Smith
Yeah.
Detective Aaron
So we started looking for a parent's house. And as luck would have it, we found Andrew's parents house out in the middle of nowhere in a remote part of the neighboring county. And when we looked at the Google Earth image, we could see it looked like an outbuilding on that same property. So now we have somewhere to start. My partner and I take Lindsay and we drive out to Andrew's parents house. And as we pass by, we don't mention it to her. We just drive through the area and she's like, that's it, that's the house right there. So now we have a place that we can go and serve a search warrant on.
Detective Dave
I mean, that's like a perfect field show up, you know, where the victim is leading you to the location and giving you details rather than you feeding them details. When you have a defense attorney at trial, how'd you find this house? And you put that in front of them. How do you argue with that? We didn't say a word. She told us. She told us where it was. It's a brilliant move.
Detective Aaron
Yeah. In this case, you know, we were having general conversation about other stuff, completely non case related, and she broke that conversation to excitedly point out, that's it, that's the house right there. And one of the things that we have to look at as detectives is we're asking questions today and making strategic moves today to close the loophole 10 years down the road when this final goes to trial. Because there's going to be a lawyer out there somewhere whose job is not to present facts, it's to create confusion. And we need to be able to put the facts together today, ask the right questions, and pave the way to a successful prosecution tomorrow. And that's what we were doing when we do this field show up. General conversation. Lindsay excitedly points out the only house in the middle of nowhere that happens to look just like the place she was held captive.
Detective Dave
Aaron, how far is this outbuilding slash barn from the main residence?
Detective Aaron
About 150 yards.
Detective Dave
So I was thinking Lindsay's going to be screaming at the times that Andrew's not right in her presence, so he has to have her far enough away that nobody can hear. And, you know, it gives you some insight into where Andrew was with this crime is Andrew's got his other life, going to a podcast, meeting, all these things, but he has to have as much control as possible. And I think that explains away how we end up out in this rural property.
Detective Aaron
You know, Dave, I completely agree. And one of the things that we really considered and thought about when we were looking through this case, we're going to find everything that Lindsey explained and described and we'll go ahead and go there now. So we end up drafting that search warrant for that property and we end up partnering with a lot of other law enforcement agencies because we are in a neighboring county, needs to be signed by a judge in another county with reciprocity between them and our city. So we're doing a bunch of logistics in the background. We have a team writing search warrants, and ultimately we go and we serve that search warrant. And we really have to think about the details that Lindsay gave me during that interview. Lindsay says the sexual assault occurred in the basement. There's brown cushions on the floor. I don't have my clothes. I was wearing tall boots. He walked me outside in the cold. I could feel the cold on the snow and on my feet and I believe that I could feel like thorny bushes. But I don't know if it was just the freezing ice, chunks of snow, or if it was actual thorns. We walked a long ways in the cold and the wind until we got to this barn. In the barn, I'm tied up. There's an eyebolt on the wall, There's a mattress. But in the cracks where the walls are formed and the two by fours lays across the bottom of the concrete, there's a whole bunch of spider eggs and spider nests in all of those cracks. And she said, I remember just being disgusted, thinking that the spiders would get me. So we're thinking about this stuff as we go in, and this is all the stuff that we're looking for in that search warrant. When we go to the house and we serve that search warrant, we find everything she described from the avocado walls, the makeshift bed. We find all of her clothes, we find her boots. We go out to the barn, we find the rope, we find the eye bolt. More specifically, we find all the spider eggs. There are thousands of spider eggs and nests along the walls of this constructed room inside of this barn. And the pathway between the house and the barn is a downhill slope. It's frozen over with snow and ice, but you have to walk right through the middle of a bunch of BlackBerry bushes. So what Lindsay was describing on her feet were the thorns from dead, fallen BlackBerry bushes. We were able to collect all of that physical evidence. One of the things that we found at the scene of sexual assault was a pink towel. That pink towel is what she described as being used to clean up after the sex act. So we're able to send that off to the lab. And immediately we get quick response that there was seminal fluid on that, which ties it together with all of this information and with the injuries that Lindsay had on her body. She was covered in bruises from head to toe, control marks around the wrists, control marks around the ankles, linear bruising across the ankles that is consistent with the ligature or the rope. With all of this information, we felt like we had enough to arrest Andrew on all of the charges and all of the things that Lindsay was describing. So that's exactly what we did. When I went to interview Andrew, Andrew had been through the system and was not going to talk to me. So Andrew politely told me to piss off and, you know, he had nothing to say to me. So that started the trial process and the court process. And about a year and a half later, we went to trial on this foreign.
Detective Dave
That's what I really like about SimpliSafe, they've taken a different approach. No long term contracts, no gotchas. If your situation changes, you're not stuck trying to fight your way out of it. What stood out to me is how straightforward the whole setup is. You go online, build the system that makes sense for your home, and it shows up at your door. The sensors are peel and stick. The app walks you through everything and you can have it up and running in under an hour. No scheduling a four hour window or waiting around for a technician to arrive. And it actually covers what you need. Entry sensors, cameras, monitoring around the clock. If something happens, there are real people ready to respond and help. Simplisafe is just a smarter way to do it. You're protected, but you're not trapped. I want you to experience the same peace of mind I do. Which is why we've partnered with SimpliSafe to offer an exclusive discount to small town Dicks listeners. Right now you can get 50% off your new system by visiting simplisafe.com smalltown that's half off@simplisafe.com smalltown there's no safe like SimpliSafe.
Yardley Smith
Erin, before you go on, is the house that Lindsay is taken to first with the avocado walls and the brown sofa, Is that Andrew's parents house?
Detective Aaron
It is, yeah. That's Andrew's mom and dad's house. And Andrew's mom and dad and family were very, very supportive of Andrew. When we got there that morning, they're like, there's been no woman here. We don't know what you're talking about. You got the wrong people.
Yardley Smith
The parents were home when Angie's bringing Lindsay to the basement.
Detective Aaron
Correct. Parents were home. And the parents were home for the three days that Lindsay was trapped out in their barn. But the parents did not know about this. When we got there and knocked the door, the parents said, there's been no woman here. Andrew lives here. But I don't know what you're talking about. There's been no woman. You guys have the wrong place.
Detective Dan
So Aaron, there's a difference that we run into where you have people who are oblivious, dumbfounded surprised that you're there and they don't have any idea of what you're talking about. And then you have parents that you run into, friends that you show up at a house and they're just not cooperative. There's a little attitude there. There are other things. Which way would you describe Andrew's parents in this situation?
Detective Aaron
You know, Dan, that's a great question. I would say that they were a little of both. I think they were completely dumbfounded that we were there and had no idea what we're talking about. I truly believe Andrew's parents had no idea the crimes that had been committed underneath their nose over the past 72 hours.
Detective Dave
I'm just thinking about how many times Andrew's parents have had the cops come out to the property and knock on their door for some bullshit that Andrew was doing. And so this is the 20th time. And they're like more people that have frequent contacts with the police build up some calluses when it comes to dealing with the police. So this is kind of how I picture as some of our most wanted, where Dan and I worked. And you go out to their parents house. They're cool. Ish. But they're not going to give their son up. And they're tired of the police coming out to their house and harassing them. So I see how you can get both ways, both types of cooperation.
Yardley Smith
But Andrew is on parole for a very serious crime, for rape. So surely they know that. So you were going to say Aaron like Yes, they were surprised, but
Detective Aaron
they are very supportive of their son and they believe their son can do no wrong. They believe their son is the second coming of Christ and walks on water. And as a result of that, it made it very difficult for them to talk to us or deal with us. They definitely wouldn't provide any information. They were uncooperative with the investigation. You know, they had to be removed from the house so we could process a search warrant. And they didn't like that. And they remained that way through the entire investigation to the point where during trial dad and brother got kicked out of the courtroom for being unruly by the judge and banned from the courthouse.
Yardley Smith
Oh shit.
Detective Aaron
So they are not nice people, I guess.
Detective Dave
Yeah. Going back to Lindsay, Lindsay is an outstanding witness.
Detective Aaron
Lindsay's great.
Detective Dave
When Aaron's talking about details for the search warrant, sometimes we'll get a disclosure where it's like, yeah, I was kidnapped and I was taken out to this property. And then he drove me, you know, an hour south of where we were. And then we came back and there's really no like detail detail. Lindsay's giving sensory detail that can be corroborated. It's cold, there's snow on the ground, there's thorns. There's all these things that Lindsay is perceiving that a detective can come back and take pictures and show it to a jury. She's a great witness to have all that detail just stowed away and to be able to recall it in an organized manner, she's a blessing to this case. Sometimes you don't get that kind of information from a victim because they're either in shock. Sometimes they kind of want to cooperate with the police, but don't want to be known as a snitch. So you have all these dynamics that are working against you.
Detective Aaron
Yeah, Dave, you're completely right. Lindsey in this case, provided so much detailed information. One, when we were there, we as police, when the police were there serving the search warrants, there was no doubt we were in the right place. And then all of that information was able to come out in trial, which is very clear and convincing to a jury. When you have a jury listening to the facts of the case and what the victim in this case, Lindsey, is describing, and then the police go out and find exactly everything to a T, that paints a very clear picture. And as we know, on the sexual assault side of things, the number one argument is going to be consent. In this case, I believe that consent, we dealt with that based on the totality of the circumstances and of the barn and the ligatures and tying up and the one single blanket. You know, even in a consensual relationship, I don't care how kinky you are, that's not even in the rules of the game. To be tied up at zero degrees outside and freeze your ass off for three days, you know, only to have the occasional quote, unquote, consensual sexual act. That doesn't even make sense. And the jury was able to see through that pretty clearly.
Detective Dave
Yeah, most people don't have a Buffalo Bill Silence of the Lambs fantasy.
Detective Aaron
Exactly. Yeah, exactly.
Yardley Smith
So, Aaron, what you're saying about consent is there was this concern on the prosecution side that the defense would argue the whole thing, the whole scenario, the whole play, was consensual. And Lindsey was into it because she had two opportunities when she was in the car with Aaron, once at parole and once at Walmart where she didn't actually get out of the car. Now, to me, I'm like, well, he threatened to kill her family. And Lindsay was very much under his thumb at that point. And I fully believe that Lindsey believed Andrew, but I'm guessing defense would still use that as a no, no, it was all copacetic. Everybody was on board.
Detective Aaron
That is correct. And you hit the nail on the head, Yeardley. There's a couple things on the consent. So the first thing in a sex crime, a rape, a sexual assault, Case, we always have to overcome the consent. Is this a consensual act between two consenting parties or not? And sometimes there's clear and convincing evidence that says that there is. Other times it can be a little bit more gray and a little bit more questionable. In this case, if you look at the totality of circumstances related to the crime scene, this looks like a forced sexual act and everything that Lindsey is describing. But then you're absolutely right. One of the big things that came up during trial were the two times that Lindsay could have escaped at the probation office and at Walmart. We got this case at 7 o' clock on Saturday morning. We worked about 36 hours straight and had this case wrapped up. During that 36 hour period, we were able to pull video up and down the i5 corridor that showed Andrew's vehicle traveling to and from just like Lindsey said it would be. We pulled video from the probation office that shows Andrew going in and Lindsay in the car in the passenger seat. We pulled video from Walmart that shows the two of them arriving, entering into the Walmart shopping and exiting together. So we were able to corroborate a lot of what Lindsey was saying in those first 36 hours. That, you know, just really kind of sealed the deal on this case. And all of that stuff came up in trial. But the two big things that really hung us up on the defense side was her opportunities to escape. So I had to take an opportunity during the trial to explain the domestic violence cycle. The I love you, I get beat, I hate you, you're the only person I have because you've eliminated all my other friends and family. So I have to love you again. And the cycle starts over. The other thing that I had to talk about during testimony was duress and delayed report, why somebody might not report. And that's exactly what you were saying, Yeardley. Lindsay was scared that Andrew was going to go back and kill her family. So therefore she would rather sacrifice herself than sacrifice her family or point danger in the direction of her mom and dad and sister and everybody else. So these are the things that I had to describe during the trial process. During the trial process, I expected some challenge from the defense attorney, more so than I got, quite frankly. The defense attorney asked me some questions, would refer to my very lengthy transcript of the interview, but would point me to the right page, the section that he wanted me to take a look at. I would look at it. I answered the questions. I think there was actually 12 questions that I answered in this case. And then I was off the stand. This went to the jury and ultimately the jury convicted on all of the counts except for one. I can't remember what the one count was, but it was a nothing. It was something the prosecutor added on there as kind of a freebie and that one went away. But all the major counts, the kidnapping, the rape, the sexual abuse, assault, all of that stuff he was convicted of during that trial process.
Yardley Smith
What kind of sentence does Andrew get?
Detective Aaron
I believe Andrew got an 18 year sentence on this case. But about three years after this case was sentenced, the case got overturned on appeals. So Andrew got out of jail.
Detective Dave
What?
Detective Aaron
And the issue on the appeal was all that testimony that I gave about domestic violence and duress and the domestic violence cycle and delayed report, While all of it was accurate and true, the prosecution failed to swear me in as an expert witness. So therefore, and I see some nodding of heads, so therefore, if I'm not sworn is an expert witness and they're considering that expert testimony, it's like the testimony never happened. So without that chunk of testimony, this case likely would have not been found as a guilty. So therefore the case was overturned on appeals and Andrew got out and returned to the.
Yardley Smith
Oh my God. Okay, first of all, I think it's a stretch that the whole case would have fallen apart without that testimony. You know, being tied up, you have so much physical evidence. It seems to me like a no brainer. But I understand that, as I always say, all of the dominoes need to line up perfectly in order for justice to be served. So I'm just. I have. I don't understand. When you're up on the stand testifying as Detective Aaron. Aaron, you are introduced as. That. As I'm the investigating officer, I'm Detective Aaron. Do they then have to swear you in separately as an expert witness to this domestic violence piece?
Detective Dan
They have to qualify you.
Detective Aaron
Yeah, they have to qualify you. There's a qualification process where they dig deeper into your background, your history. The prosecution presents their case. Defense has a right to challenge you during that qualification process. And if all the stars line up and everybody says, okay, he's qualified to speak about this, then you're sworn in as an expert in that court. And that's the way that it works. I haven't sworn as expert witness in other fields and other things, but this case, on this day, we just didn't go through that process.
Yardley Smith
And does that process happen at trial or does it happen before the jury sits down?
Detective Aaron
It can happen either way, but it's not going to happen in front of the jury. The jury would be excused in a trial process.
Detective Dave
I see for the courts, they're ignoring just the. As a detective working these types of cases, when you have this type of experience, there's no piece of paper somebody can give me and go, you're a qualified domestic violence investigator. Like, you know what you're doing or you don't. So in this case, you ask a detective who's worked hundreds of these types of cases throughout patrol and being a detective, what's your experience? But you didn't do the voir dire process and didn't do the qualification as an expert. However, we still got a detective who's like, yeah, I've worked hundreds of these. And this is generally how it goes. There's a common sense factor to that, which I think you're resonating with Yardley, like. Like Aaron doesn't know what he's talking about. Which we all are going, yeah, he does know what he's talking about. But in the court's eyes, you gotta go through that check mark process and check all the boxes. So you qualify this person as a, quote, expert. I think detectives look at it and they're like, well, I mean, you don't need to shoot me to tell me it hurts. Like, I know it hurts.
Yardley Smith
That's what I said.
Detective Aaron
Exactly.
Yardley Smith
And also, Andrew is released now. You have a very dangerous man back on the street. And I'm assuming Lindsay is just trying to live her life and she's still around and probably like, oh, shit.
Detective Aaron
Yeah, exactly. Lindsay's out living her life. Lindsay's actually had a child at this point and has cleaned up and is living a better lifestyle while Andrew gets out of jail. He is not living a better lifestyle and continues his life of crime. Andrew's out of jail about six months or so, and he goes to my city and files a lawsuit against me and the city for unlawful imprisonment. So I don't even get notified of that. And the next day, Andrew finds himself drunk in the street, trying to cause fights with people. And when nobody would fight him, he tried to carjack an Uber. And when he tried to carjack the Uber, the passenger in the Uber, a nice little old lady, was armed and shot and killed Andrew during the carjacking process.
Yardley Smith
Okay.
Detective Aaron
So therefore my lawsuit was cleared. Exceptional. Not gonna happen. And Andrew is in a better place, hopefully.
Detective Dan
And he never got convicted of these acts.
Detective Aaron
Never got convicted.
Detective Dave
Yeah. And Andrew also ran into somebody who was tired of his shit.
Detective Aaron
Yep.
Yardley Smith
Yeah. But wow. So when Andrew gets released from prison on this appeal, I'M assuming the prosecution was gearing up to try him again.
Detective Aaron
That is correct. Lindsay was on board with another trial process. She was willing to go back. Everybody was going to go back. We were going to repeat round one, but with expert testimony at the time. But we didn't get there because Andrew found himself in another set of circumstances.
Detective Dan
Aaron, do you remember where you were, what you were doing when you got the news about Andrew's untimely demise?
Detective Aaron
I do, yeah. By the time I got that news, I was out of law enforcement, retired out ptsd. And I was keeping in touch with my partner as I would see these murders continue to come out. Continue to come out. Sometimes she would talk to me about them, sometimes she wouldn't. But my partner reached out to me and said, hey, do you remember Andrew? He's involved in one of our current cases. What can you tell me about him and his family? So I started telling her. And then it was at that point I realized Andrew had met his demise and the circumstances surrounding his untimely death. And to be quite frank, I wasn't surprised.
Detective Dave
Yeah, self inflicted behavior that leads to Andrew meeting an old lady with a hand cannon.
Detective Aaron
Yeah.
Detective Dave
I'm curious about during trial. You had mentioned that Andrew's father and brother had been kicked out of the courtroom. Can you describe what was going on in there?
Detective Aaron
Yeah. So Andrew's father and brother, every time that something would be said in the courtroom that was contrary to Andrew being the second coming of Christ, they would explode with emotion and scoffing and talking out loud. The judge asked them to quiet down several times. They failed to comply and ultimately was not only kicked out of the courtroom, but kicked out of the courthouse. They were just problems for us. And it was the same way during the death investigation that ensued. They were problematic in that as well. It's everybody else's fault. Andrew was a perfect son and a perfect young man and the world has painted him into this terrible picture in this dark light. The family just wasn't seeing the reality. Earlier I said, it's like the 13 year old kid that got stuck in adolescence. I believe his parents are still seeing Andrew as that, that star football player scoring the touchdowns. And in their mind, he will always be that person.
Detective Dave
Nice work, Aaron.
Yardley Smith
Great work as always.
Detective Aaron
Thank you, guys.
Detective Dave
Aaron, can you tell our listeners where they can find your podcast and kind of what subjects you're covering?
Detective Aaron
Yeah, totally. So my podcast is on all streaming platforms. It's called Murders to Music. And what I describe is I describe life of law enforcement into the corporate world into the transition out. You know, one of the things that I've always done is I've always been a musician. I've played music and I've DJed and I've entertained and sang since I was 13 years old. And being a law enforcement officer, that was always the thread that kind of kept me grounded. Insane. But I never really had time to pursue it fully. So coming out of law enforcement now, that's what I do a lot. I mean, I do a lot of music, I do a lot of entertaining. What I learned in law enforcement allowed me to use my skills and attention to detail to help people on their worst day, and now I can help them on their best day. And that is what this podcast is about. And I attack it and present it in such a way where you don't have to be a cop or musician to get something out of it. But I think anybody listening to this right now can understand what an identity crisis is. And if you lose your identity and all of a sudden you were somebody yesterday and today, you can't go back to that same job and you lose that identity and you crumble. So I presented in such a way that anybody can understand and get something either educational, entertaining, or valuable from the podcast.
Yardley Smith
That's great.
Detective Dave
Awesome.
Yardley Smith
That's amazing. We're so happy to see you, Erin. Thank you again for sitting down with us. It's always a delight.
Detective Aaron
Thank you so much, Arlie.
Yardley Smith
Now for a sneak peek at today's new bonus episode.
Paul Holes
When you walk into these cooks houses, you find back in the day, hundreds upon hundreds of these packs of Sudafed where as they're tweaking on meth, they are frantically picking out all those pills. So one of the things you look for is all these empty blister packs of Sudafed. In order to establish, okay, they've been going around to all the stores and snatching up all the Sudafed.
Yardley Smith
To listen to today's bonus episode and actually access hundreds more, go to smalltowndicks.com superfam and hit that little join button. Small Town Dicks was created by detectives Dan and Dave. The podcast is produced by Jessica Halstead and me, Yardley Smith. Our senior editor is Soren Bajan and our editor is is Christina Bracamontes. Our associate producers are the real Nick Smitty and Erin Gaynor. Logan Heftel is our production manager. Our books are Cooked and Cats Wrangled by Ben Cornwell. And our social media maven is Monica Scott. It would make our day if you became a member of our Small Town Fam by following us on Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube. Smalltowndix we love hearing from you. Oh, our groovy theme song was composed by John Forrest. Also, if you'd like to support the making of this podcast, go to smalltowndicks.com superfam and hit that little join button there. For a small subscription fee, you'll find exclusive content you can't get anywhere else. The transcripts of this podcast are thanks to Speech Docs and they can be found on our website, smalltowndicks.com thank you Speechdocs for this wonderful service. Small Town Dicks is an audio 99 production. Small town fam. Thanks for listening. Nobody is better than you.
Paul Holes
It.
Release Date: April 24, 2026
Host: Yeardley Smith
Guests: Detectives Dan and Dave; Retired Detective Aaron
Case Location: Portland, Oregon Metropolitan Area
This episode of Small Town Dicks centers on the harrowing case of Lindsay, a young woman who was kidnapped, assaulted, and ultimately escaped from captivity in rural Oregon. Retired Detective Aaron, who led the investigation, walks listeners through the case, highlighting Lindsay’s courage, the difficulties of investigating crimes involving vulnerable victims, and the challenges of ensuring justice is served—even when the legal system falters.
The story is as much a tale of resilience and fate as it is a procedural, complete with a shocking legal technicality and a striking twist of karma. The episode underscores how flawed offenders are sometimes protected by legal oversights, and how victims’ testimony and investigative rigor are crucial for justice.
[04:58–09:02]
Memorable Quote:
"Rockwood is... probably the most dangerous part of Portland. It takes 80% of our resources about 80% of the time."
— Detective Aaron [05:25]
[09:13–16:11]
Memorable Quote:
“Andrew... is the star football player... Mentally he's kind of stuck in that juvenile ‘I’m the coolest kid in town’ state.”
— Detective Aaron [09:30]
[17:58–22:13]
Memorable Quote:
“Lindsay actually runs out the back door of the methadone clinic. ... Andrew realizes something’s amiss and looks outside and sees her running across this open field towards some apartments. So he gives chase.”
— Detective Aaron [20:35]
[22:13–27:20]
Memorable Quote:
“When we go to the house and we serve that search warrant, we find everything she described... we find all of her clothes, we find her boots. ... We find the rope, we find the eye bolt. ... More specifically, we find all the spider eggs. There are thousands of spider eggs and nests along the walls...”
— Detective Aaron [27:20]
[32:09–35:06]
Memorable Quote:
“They believe their son can do no wrong. ... During trial, dad and brother got kicked out of the courtroom for being unruly by the judge and banned from the courthouse.”
— Detective Aaron [34:24]
[35:06–38:04]
Memorable Quote:
“Even in a consensual relationship, I don’t care how kinky you are, that’s not even in the rules of the game. To be tied up at zero degrees outside and freeze your ass off for three days...”
— Detective Aaron [36:58]
[41:17–42:25]
Memorable Quotes:
“All that testimony ... while accurate and true, the prosecution failed to swear me in as an expert witness. ... So without that chunk of testimony, this case likely would have not been found as a guilty. ... Andrew got out and returned to the world.”
— Detective Aaron [41:29]
“You gotta go through that check mark process and check all the boxes. So you qualify this person as a, quote, expert. I think detectives look at it and they’re like, ‘Well, I mean, you don’t need to shoot me to tell me it hurts. Like, I know it hurts.’”
— Detective Dave [44:55]
[45:09–47:40]
Memorable Quote:
“Andrew finds himself drunk in the street, trying to cause fights with people. ... He tried to carjack an Uber. ... The passenger ... was armed and shot and killed Andrew during the carjacking process. ... My lawsuit was cleared. Exceptional.”
— Detective Aaron [46:05]
On the victim’s credibility:
“Lindsay is an outstanding witness... giving sensory detail that can be corroborated.”
— Detective Dave [35:12]
On defense strategy:
“The number one argument is going to be consent... [But] to be tied up at zero degrees outside... only to have the occasional 'consensual’ sexual act, that doesn’t even make sense.”
— Detective Aaron [36:58]
On the unpredictable legal process:
“All of the dominoes need to line up perfectly in order for justice to be served.”
— Yeardley Smith [42:25]
The conversation is detailed and measured, balancing empathy for Lindsay with a pragmatic look at investigative challenges and the frequent frustrations of the criminal justice system. The tone is conversational and forthright, with dashes of gritty humor typical of veteran law enforcement.
Detective Aaron's account—amplified by the hosts' questions—reveals the complexities of policing, the importance of corroborative physical evidence, and the unique courage required for victims to come forward and stay the course. The final commentary leaves listeners reflecting on the limitations of law, the unpredictable hand of fate, and, ultimately, the unbreakable will to survive.