#550 - Kinky Killer Couple - Dover, New Hampshire

Summary

Small Town Murder: Episode #550 - Kinky Killer Couple - Dover, New Hampshire

Release Date: December 7, 2024

Hosts: James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman

---

Introduction

In Episode #550 of Small Town Murder, hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman delve into the chilling case of a young woman’s disappearance and subsequent murder in Dover, New Hampshire. Combining meticulous research with their signature comedic flair, James and Jimmie unpack the complex dynamics of a seemingly ordinary small town harboring dark secrets.

---

Dover, New Hampshire: The Setting [03:12-10:15]

Overview of Dover: Dover, situated in southeastern New Hampshire, boasts a population of approximately 32,599. As a historical mill town, Dover thrived on textile production until economic downturns led to the migration of mills to the southern states. Today, Dover serves as a suburban commuter hub for Boston, with a median household income of $82,387 and median home prices around $416,800.

Community and Culture: The town is lauded for its Victorian-style homes, excellent schools, and abundant outdoor activities such as fishing and canoeing. However, reviews of Dover are mixed, highlighting a picturesque environment juxtaposed with a less welcoming community atmosphere.

Notable Points:

• Dover is recognized as the birthplace of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles’ backstory.
• Proximity to Portsmouth offers residents a taste of city life within a short drive.

Notable Quote:

James Pietragallo [09:40]: “Dover is fantastic for exploring outside as there are several great fishing and canoeing sites.”

---

The Disappearance of Lizzie Marriott [10:15-24:13]

Background: In October 2012, 19-year-old Lizzie Marriott, a vivacious and socially active sophomore at the University of New Hampshire, vanished under mysterious circumstances. Known for her love of marine biology and involvement in community activities, Lizzie was living with her aunt and uncle near campus while her parents resided in Massachusetts.

The Night of Disappearance: On October 9, 2012, Lizzie attended a Tuesday night lab class but later sent a text at 8:55 PM stating she was visiting a friend named Kat McDonough, a coworker from Target. Lizzie promised to return by midnight. When she failed to return, her family reported her missing. Police discovered Lizzie's car on campus but found no immediate evidence of her whereabouts.

Notable Quote:

Jimmie Whisman [19:17]: “He knew Lizzie was always happy and found the best in everyone.”

---

Seth Maziglia and Kat McDonough: The Suspects [24:13-40:39]

Profiles:

• Seth Maziglia (29): An actor, writer, and fight choreographer with a background in theater. Seth’s online presence is heavily tied to BDSM and bondage communities under aliases like "Dark Kaiser."
• Kat McDonough (19): A former honor student who dropped out of high school and became involved with Seth. Kat’s theater involvement and relationship with Seth marked a significant shift in her behavior and lifestyle.

Relationship Dynamics: Seth and Kat’s relationship was characterized by extreme BDSM practices, including dominance and submission. Their involvement in fetish communities raised red flags about their influence on Lizzie.

Key Developments:

• Lizzie’s sudden disappearance led police to question Seth and Kat.
• Initially, both denied involvement, presenting alibis that later fell apart under scrutiny.
• Text messages revealed disturbing communications between Kat and Seth, indicating a desire to involve others in their BDSM lifestyle.

Notable Quotes:

James Pietragallo [36:15]: “This is BDSM fucking. Oh, Ropes and bondage and shit.”

Jimmie Whisman [37:22]: “Dark Kaiser. Dark enough.”

---

The Crime Unveiled [40:39-78:22]

The Night of Murder: On the evening of Lizzie’s disappearance, Seth and Kat hosted a gathering with Lizzie and another individual. During a game of strip poker, tensions escalated when Seth initiated non-consensual acts. Lizzie reportedly had a seizure, leading Seth to strangle her with a rope. In a state of panic, Seth and Kat attempted to dispose of her body by throwing it into the ocean, while also destroying evidence such as clothing and ties used in the murder.

Investigation and Trial:

• Evidence: Recovery of Lizzie's car and items linked to the crime scene.
• Testimonies: Roberta Gerken, a friend, described finding Lizzie's body. Kat eventually testified, detailing the events leading to Lizzie's death.
• Legal Proceedings: Seth was charged with first-degree murder, rape, and conspiracy. Kat faced charges for hindering the investigation but received a plea deal for a reduced sentence.

Notable Quotes:

Kat McDonough [68:57]: “He moved up behind her and pulled the rope over her neck and strangled her.”

James Pietragallo [74:37]: “She's dead. He murdered her over a year and a half ago.”

---

Conclusion and Aftermath [78:22-82:11]

Verdict and Sentencing: Seth Maziglia was found guilty of first-degree murder and rape, resulting in a life sentence without parole. Kat McDonough, having taken a plea deal, received a lighter sentence for her role in hindering the investigation.

Impact on the Community: The case left a lasting scar on Dover, highlighting the hidden dangers within seemingly tranquil small towns. Lizzie Marriott’s family established the Lizzie Marriott Intrepid Ocean Explorer Fund in her memory, aiming to honor her passion for marine biology.

Notable Quote:

Lizzie’s Father [74:45]: “I cannot comprehend that level of evilness and disregard for humanity.”

Final Thoughts: James and Jimmie reflect on the tragic loss of Lizzie Marriott, emphasizing the importance of recognizing and addressing abusive relationships. The episode serves as a sobering reminder of the darkness that can lurk beneath the surface of small-town life.

---

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• James Pietragallo [15:23]: “She was very social and everybody liked her.”

• Jimmie Whisman [19:43]: “She probably stayed late and, you know, can I just crash at your house? And that's probably what happened.”

• James Pietragallo [25:10]: “He’s a twisted individual who brought only darkness and pain into this world.”

• Jimmie Whisman [39:05]: “Feels like shit. He would write and then hide it.”

• James Pietragallo [66:55]: “He is a cold motherfucker.”

---

Takeaways and Reflections

Small Town Murder Episode #550 meticulously unravels the heinous crime committed by Seth Maziglia and Kat McDonough, showcasing how abusive dynamics and obsession can culminate in tragedy. The hosts effectively balance the gravity of the subject matter with their comedic insights, providing listeners with both a compelling narrative and critical reflections on human behavior and societal perceptions of small-town safety.

Key Insights:

• Abusive Relationships: Understanding the signs and recognizing the manipulation and control inherent in abusive relationships.

• Community Impact: The ripple effects a single heinous act can have on a close-knit community.

• Legal Nuances: The complexities of prosecuting cases without a body and the ethical considerations in plea deals.

Conclusion: This episode serves as a poignant exploration of darkness within the facade of normalcy, urging listeners to remain vigilant and compassionate in their communities.

---

For those intrigued by the depths of small-town mysteries and the intricate human behaviors that drive them, Small Town Murder continues to offer insightful and engaging storytelling with every episode.

Transcript

[James Petragallo]

Audible's best of 2024 picks are here. Discover the year's top audiobooks, podcasts and originals in all your favorite genres, from memoirs and sci fi, mysteries and thrillers. Audible's curated list in every category is the best way to hear 2024's best in audio entertainment, like a stunning new full cast production of George Orwell's 1984 heartfelt memoirs like Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson's lovely one. The year's best fiction, like the Women by Kristin Hannah and Percival Everett's brilliantly Sub. Right now I'm listening to Starkweather by Harry N. Maclean about the murderer Charles Starkweather. It's pretty good. I can recommend that to you as well. Audible. There's more to imagine when you listen. Go to audible.com smalltownmurder and discover the years best waiting for you. Hey everybody. Just gonna take a quick break from the show to tell you about Uncommon Goods. Spark something uncommon this holiday with just the right gift from Uncommon Goods. The holiday season's busy and it's here, and Uncommon Goods makes it less stressful with incredible handpicked gifts for everyone on your list, all in one spot. When you shop at Uncommon Goods, what you're doing is supporting artists, small independent businesses. You know, people like us. Yeah, good people. Many of the handcrafted products are made in small batches, so shop before they sell out because these things sell out small pins. It's not a big giant manufacturing thing. And looking around on the site, I already found things. Good presents for this holiday. Absolutely. Going to have some stuff made for people, I think. Let's make it personal here. It's perfect. And with every purchase you make at Uncommon Goods, they give back $1 to a nonprofit partner of your choice. You even get to pick They've donated more than $3 million to date. To get 15% off your next gift, go to uncommongoods.com smalltownmurder that's uncommongoods.com SmallTownMurder for 15% off. Don't miss out on this limited time offer. Uncommon Goods we're all out of the ordinary. Now.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Back to the show.

[James Petragallo]

Hey everybody, Just gonna take a quick break from the show to tell you a little bit about Shutterfly. Shutterfly allows you to create truly personal and meaningful GIFs for your family and friends. With custom photo GIFs, you just upload your photos from your phone or social media or whatever to the Shutterfly app to start creating GIFs in minutes. You get photos off your phone and into a photo book. Like I have an idea for. I got a brother who's got some kids and they tend to like those kids. So I'm gonna put some stuff. Yeah, I got some ornaments I think I'm gonna make for them. I think that' that's the way to do it here for them. I think that's going to be a good gift. Explore gifts like blankets, mugs, photos, books and [e-mail] all easy to customize in minutes with your favorite photos. Enjoy 40% off your Shutterfly order with the code Small Town and make something meaningful this year. Get free shipping on qualified orders. See site for more details.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Now back to the show.

[James Petragallo]

Hello everybody and welcome back to Small Town Murder Express.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yay and choo choo.

[James Petragallo]

Oh, yay indeed, Jimmy. Yay indeed. My name is James Petragallo. I'm here with my co host.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I'm Jimmy Wissman.

[James Petragallo]

All aboard the murder train, everybody pulling away from the station. Let's do this. Thank you for joining us. We have an absolutely insane case. Just a real scumbag today, obviously, as usual. Sometimes, sometimes it's less scummy than others, but today we got a real scumbag and obviously Small town Murder Express. 10 pounds of murder and 2 pound bag. So you're getting a lot here before we start. Definitely head over to Shut up and give me murder.com. get your tickets for live shows. You're listening to this you the last two shows of the year you can get. Also new dates for 2025 are coming out. So get those. They're going to be for sale next month, but Bost and New York, still a few tickets left for those. It's actually Medford and Tarrytown I believe.

[Jimmy Wissman]

So literally like a few.

[James Petragallo]

Like a few. So get your tickets right now and get in there and come see us. We are excited for those. Shut up and give me murder.com. also listen to our other two shows, Crime in Sports, which you don't have to like sports to enjoy. It's just stories of people screwing up when they don't have to. So I mean, who doesn't like that? Who doesn't like a fall from grace? You know what I mean?

[Jimmy Wissman]

It's a good time.

[James Petragallo]

Then also listen to your stupid opinions which you're going to hear reviews about everything and we'll make fun of them and it's so much fun. And then if that's not enough for you, get patrion patreon.com Crime in sports is where you get all the bonus material. Anybody $5 a month or above, you're going to get everything. I'm talking hundreds of bonus episodes you've never heard before immediately upon subscription and new ones every other week. One Crime in sports. One Small town murder. And how much of that do they get, Jimmy?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, you get it all.

[James Petragallo]

You get it all. That's right. This week, what we have for you for crime and sports, a real gross one. It is the United Kingdom soccer sex scandal and it is pretty gross stuff. It's kind of equivalent to our gymnastics, basically. It's pretty disgusting. Then for small town murder, if all of these words don't trigger you, I don't know what will. The cult baby murder trial. We're going to talk about more than that. We're going to talk about these people's philosophy and their whole polygamist deal. And they drink their own urine every day and use weird, completely, you know, discredited medical devices from the 30s. And they swear by. It's crazy stuff. We'll talk all about that and more. Patreon.com Crime in sports. But today we have a crazy ass case. And I think it's time, everybody, I think it's time to do this. What do you say here? Let's all take a deep breath, arms to the sky and let's all shout shut up and give me murder. Let's do this, everybody.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Here we go.

[James Petragallo]

Let's go on a trip, shall we? Let's do it.

[Jimmy Wissman]

We should.

[James Petragallo]

Going to New Hampshire, a very nice place. I know Jimmy's a big, big fan of New Hampshire.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Fan.

[James Petragallo]

I like New Hampshire, love the northeast, New England states, Maine, all that good stuff here. This is in southeastern New Hampshire, practically Maine, almost Maine. It's in Dover, New Hampshire where we're going here. It's about an hour and 20 to Boston from there. And it's still considered like a commute. Yeah, absolutely. People live here, they work in Boston, a lot of them. About an hour and fifty to Jackson, New Hampshire, which was our last New Hampshire episode. Episode 498, the mysterious disappearing Murderer. That was a fun one. And then population of this town is 32,599. So not that big, not that small. Just kind of your average small town here. Median household income slightly above the average 82,387. And I think you're going to get that from your Boston work there. Probably going to drive it up a bit. It's 69,000 is regular. That's average median home price here, $416,800. Pricey. Wow. Because it's commutable to Boston. You can draw about an hour, 45 minute circle around New York, Boston, Philly. And you see where it's expensive. And right outside that circle. Shit is half the price of that. So how it works, the motto here is grow with us. May as well come on along with us.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Everybody, let's grow his waistline because the food is terrific.

[James Petragallo]

Oh, it's good. Tons of seafood up there.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, my.

[James Petragallo]

This is oyster central and clams and all that good stuff. I love it. History of this town. It's a mill. It was a mill town for years and years and years. Everybody worked at the mills. Like a lot of northeastern cities, they made textiles up here. There was the Dover cotton factory, which started in 1815.

[Jimmy Wissman]

And that's fascinating. They would get cotton from somewhere else, right?

[James Petragallo]

Yeah. From down south. Yeah, we come up from down south and they'd make it and.

[Jimmy Wissman]

All right.

[James Petragallo]

And ship it out from there and then ship it out to Europe from there. Because you're by the ports. That's why they did it up here, because it was in the ports. Because Baltimore had a lot of that. All the port cities did that. Shit. Sure. It was renamed in 1827 the Cocheco Manufacturing Company because the other one wasn't so successful. The next year, it was the site of the first women's strike in the United States. They said, we're not fucking anybody. No, they didn't do that. No, they did the strike of the. Of the mill girls. It was called December 30, 1828, where about half of the 800 women employed at the mill walked out over lower wages and longer hours that the new owners had implemented.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Tired of this shit.

[James Petragallo]

Tired of this shit. Don't know how that worked out, but I'm not sure. Dover became incorporated in 1855, huge national producer of textiles. And it was going real well until the depression happened. And then it didn't go so well. And the textile mills started all moving down south for cheaper. Cheaper, you know, production costs and everything. Cheaper. A lot of things eventually went out of business. Yeah. A little fun fact here. Dover, New Hampshire, is the birthplace of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, if you know what the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle backstory. Absolutely. Reviews of this town. Here we go. Five stars. I love Dover because it's a quaint New England town with Victorian style homes and great pizza.

[Jimmy Wissman]

That's true.

[James Petragallo]

That's true. Northeast also good. Is that New Haven style up there? Are they doing that?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Probably, yeah.

[James Petragallo]

Okay. I'm into it. I'm into It. It's a great area to raise your kids with several excellent schools surrounding the area. Dover is fantastic for exploring outside as there are several great fishing and canoeing sites. Yeah, yeah. Portsmouth is only 15 minutes away if you're craving more city life. Really? Is it the big city of Portsmouth?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Portsmouth is bigger. It's pretty booming, but it's not a city life.

[James Petragallo]

That's what I mean. Like, that's a little. It's just a little bit.

[Jimmy Wissman]

It's a very quaint boutique town.

[James Petragallo]

It's by the water. It's there to take your money. It's all it is. Yeah. So you go there, you spend, you know, 30% more on dinner than it's worth, you buy some knickknacks and you fuck off. That's how it works. Yeah.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Buy yourself a fucking hammock and go home.

[James Petragallo]

That's it. I've lived in Dover for most of my life and it's truly a one of a kind town with a charm of its own. Yeah, here's four stars. It's where I was raised. I try to escape it, but I always come back home. The people here aren't nice, but deep down you know they love you.

[Jimmy Wissman]

It's got a hold on me.

[James Petragallo]

This is a description of an.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, they treat me like shit, but that's because they love me.

[James Petragallo]

They just described an abusive relationship. I've been with this person a long time. I try to escape, but I always come back. This person is not nice to me, but deep down I know they love me. That's exactly what you'd say. No, get out of that relationship. Terrible.

[Jimmy Wissman]

That's called a cycle.

[James Petragallo]

That's terrible. Yeah. This is what they have going on with a town that's fucking wild. Here is three stars. This is very short. They need to stop building brand new houses where people don't want them.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Well, where do you. This person is close to. Wants them somewhere else. Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

I don't know where I don't want them. Take away people, that's when they ask you if you want to know what someone thinks about something. Don't ask them what do you think? Because then they might hedge. You ask, what do you think people think about this? And then they'll tell you what they think. That's what that is. People don't want these houses. Whose people?

[Jimmy Wissman]

People want them other places.

[James Petragallo]

Me and my wife don't want those houses. There, that's it. And then finally, one star. This is pretty honest. Absolutely. A hell hole is the first line.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Okay.

[James Petragallo]

All right. That's setting it off. It's the drugs, isn't it, setting it off? The state is beautiful. The people are not. Yeah, yeah. They will scowl at you. Or they were. They will scorn at you and scowl. I don't know. They'll scorn and scowl at you.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I didn't know you could do that.

[James Petragallo]

They're not afraid to treat you badly for being a quote, outsider. Even the police here will treat you bad. When you call them out on their behavior, they will gaslight you. What does that even mean?

[Jimmy Wissman]

What has happened?

[James Petragallo]

What are you talking about? Tell us exactly what. When you got pulled over, what the fucking problem was.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Tell us the situation.

[James Petragallo]

This is like a vague Facebook post here. This is ridiculous. The worst city I've ever lived. This is like the Twilight zone run with three exclamation points. I don't believe that person.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I think they're exaggerating.

[James Petragallo]

The truth is somewhere in the middle I believe there things to do the Cocheco or Cocheco or however the fuck you say at arts festival. The festival began in the summer of 1987. They said that the chamber of commerce had accepted the challenge of matching an anonymous donation to produce a summer concert series. And the summer long festival showcases regionally recognized acts as well as top Seacoast entertainers. In other words, fucking cover songs. And when they play originals, you go to the Porta Potty. That's what's going on here.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Covers played by people you don't know.

[James Petragallo]

You don't you've never heard of. It's free to attend and open to the public also. That's always where the best bands play, where it's free to see them. The series here, the headliners from this series are the Rebel Collective. That's one band. Tower Hill. Nope, nope. Toby McAllister and the Sierra Sounds.

[Jimmy Wissman]

It's like someone plays country.

[James Petragallo]

As I say, someone will confuse me for some other country artists. Right? Toby McAllister. They'll go, I think I've heard of him. Right? Those are familiar names, sir. Sounds I've heard of that Sierra. That sounds like the Sierra Nevadas. That's a Western. Dusty. August 2, Maddie and the Penders. No, don't know. It's just some Irish guy. Hey Matty. He's like I brought the pendants with me.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I'll bet it's a gal.

[James Petragallo]

It's probably a gal. Then after that, Lexi James and Wild Heart, which sound like they play nothing but Lita Ford covers or very country shit. And then August 16th, finally, the old hat String Band. That sounds like a country band, too.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Watch that.

[James Petragallo]

That's interesting.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Watch and listen to that one. They know a lot of Alabama.

[James Petragallo]

They know. Oh, my. It's all Alabama. We're gonna play a chunk of Skynyrd now, is what we're going to do. And then follow it up with some 38 special. Let's go, everybody. 1, 2, 3, 4. And they're fucking going, oh, God. We're going to play. Give me three steps 12 straight times is what we play.

[Jimmy Wissman]

36.

[James Petragallo]

It's 36 steps. 36 steps, mister. So let's talk about a murder. What do you say here? I think it's time. Yeah, let's do it. It's the time to do this. Let's go back to 2012. Here we go. Let's talk about a young lady first. She is 19 years old in 2012. So 2012, not too far back. Everything's exactly the same, pretty much, right? You still. IPhone, Instagram.

[Jimmy Wissman]

She is so young.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, 19. Yeah, 19 then. Very young. She is known for being kind of, you know, real upbeat young lady here. Vivacious. People call her a lot. Hangs out with her friends a lot. Yeah, she's not at 19. That's what you do.

[Jimmy Wissman]

That's all you do.

[James Petragallo]

Very much into what her dad calls little critters all the time. And her mom, like, out, like woodland. Yes. Little animals, frogs, turtles and shit, shit like that. More into the things in the water. Water type animals, really. Salamanders and turtles and that kind of shit. Frogs, turtles. Like maybe a salamander or two. I don't know what she's into.

[Jimmy Wissman]

It's what she likes it.

[James Petragallo]

Her mom said about when she was little, you know, you'd see her and she'd have a tortoise in her hand or a little turtle and, you know, she'd be putting it back on the brook side of our road, so, you know, helping the turtles who cross the road get back to the brook there. She said she and I used to do the silliest things together. Just no rhyme or reason. That's what her dad said. She's very popular when she grows up. Very. Course, she's outgoing. She's the prom queen, for Christ's sake.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Is that right?

[James Petragallo]

Absolutely. The prom queen with a turtle in her hand. So unbelievable. A sweet kid, basically, is what she is. October of 2012, she's 19 and had just entered the University of New Hampshire as a sophomore, but I think she went somewhere else for her freshman year because she's new to the University of New Hampshire.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Get some prereqs out of the way elsewhere.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, do that. I guess or I guess she. Maybe the last semester she went something like that. Her uncle said it's a wonderful marine biology program and that's what she was going for.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Is that right?

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, that's pretty cool. That's one of those things that like little kids say they want to be but then they don't become that. You know what I mean? But she actually was going to do that.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, it's romantic the idea of it. And then you grow up and you go, well that's not very practical. I gotta live on land.

[James Petragallo]

That's. That's gonna be tough. I don't really want to live on a boat. But yeah, if you ask a nine year old girl what do you want to do? They'll Half of them say marine biologist or a vet or vets too. Animals. They want to. When you're a little kid, you want to work with animals. Then you grow up and you're like.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Sounds awesome to me.

[James Petragallo]

Too many animals. So she said that's where she really wanted to go. Her uncle said too. Her father said she always loved critters and how a 9th grade trip and a week long marine biology camp really got her into it even more and made her focus. And she kept her focus all through high school and then wanted to do that. They said. Her dad said this called. This led to Lizzie. Lizzie to UNH University of New Hampshire. She wanted to go there so bad and it was so very happy. And she was so very happy when she started classes here.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Right.

[James Petragallo]

So while she's doing that, she's living with her aunt and uncle who live close to the university. Her mom and dad live in Massachusetts. It's a longer drive, so her uncle and aunt live within a half hour of the university. Nice, nice driving range there. The uncle said. One of my favorite things was when she'd come back she'd scream, I'm home. And it really made us feel comfortable that she really felt like our home was also her home.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, look at that.

[James Petragallo]

Nice. Nice family. Nice girl.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Nice one. Just like a little phrase like that makes the fucking world different.

[James Petragallo]

That is nice because most people are shitty and they'd be like, oh fuck yeah, we got this. She's home. Great. You know what I mean? That would be the most reactions, including mine probably, you know, fuck, she's. Jesus Christ. This person who we didn't fucking, who didn't come from our loins is home. Perfect.

[Jimmy Wissman]

We didn't make this person.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, I didn't do this. Made it back by accident or on purpose. I didn't make this person.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

So October 9th, it's a Tuesday, 2012. It's just over a month into her first semester here as a sophomore and she planned to attend a Tuesday night lab class that would end at 9pm so she was. That was her plan. She was going to go from her aunt and uncles over to the class and do that. At 8:55pm she sent a text message to a friend of hers saying she was going to visit a new friend, a co worker at a department store near campus. She works. She got a job at Target, by the way.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

So she said that she was going to a friend's house and she told her aunt and uncle she'd be home no later than 12 or 12:30. And her uncle said, and that's the last thing we heard from her.

[Jimmy Wissman]

That's a late night.

[James Petragallo]

Be home at 12:30. Then Wednesday morning, she's still not home.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, no.

[James Petragallo]

So the uncle said, it kind of made me nervous, but at the same time, she's 19 years old, she's a college student. She's going to hang out with friends. Who knows if she had a.

[Jimmy Wissman]

She fell asleep.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, she had a couple of beers and didn't want to drive and fell asleep. I mean, that's. That would be responsible, actually. And you'd be okay with that? And he said, too. I said, well, you know, teenage girl, she probably stayed late and, you know, can I just crash at your house? And that's probably what happened. It's fine.

[Jimmy Wissman]

It's a long ride home.

[James Petragallo]

So they wait all Wednesday, but they don't hear from Lizzie. They don't hear from her. She doesn't come home, Nothing. So then Thursday morning, her aunt said, look outside. Still no car.

[Jimmy Wissman]

What the fuck?

[James Petragallo]

So now it's two nights, and that's not right. And she said, oh, my God, Lizzie's not here. And then it was like sheer panic. The uncle said, now we knew something was really wrong. So, yeah, at that point, they get a call from Lizzie's dad. Yeah, he says, hey, it's Bob. Have you heard from Lizzie? And they said, no, we were just about to call you because we haven't heard from Lizzie. And he said, you know what's going on? And they were like, holy shit, we got to figure this out. And the uncle said, that's when your heart goes in your throat. And the dad, Bob Marriott, said, what you do? What do you do when your child's missing? I didn't have a checklist that told me what to do. It's not like it's at the mall. You know what I mean? If you lose your kid at the mall back, you'd go to the security office first, then you look around. There's no, like, what do you do here.

[Jimmy Wissman]

It's still sheer panic.

[James Petragallo]

Absolutely.

[Jimmy Wissman]

The one thing.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, this is worse. Yeah, that's what I mean. In the mall at least, you know, it's. Unless somebody kidnapped the kid. They're probably within the building still, you know what I mean? There's plenty of entertaining shit for them to do here, so.

[Jimmy Wissman]

And lots. Yeah. To be distracted by.

[James Petragallo]

Exactly. So probably. But I mean, when it's a 19 year old and they're out there, she could be anywhere on earth.

[Jimmy Wissman]

She says a car could be anywhere.

[James Petragallo]

Two days worth of head start, who knows?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh yeah. 48 hours head start is a long time.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah. And it's. But it's not like, you know, they. Lizzie's not a runaway type or she has no pressures that she's trying to get away from. You know, she's a happy kid. So they don't understand it. They called the police immediately to report her missing. And dad said we worked the phones for, I don't know, two hours maybe. And finally I just couldn't take it anymore and jumped in the car and drove. He said, it's like, let's call the FBI, let's call the state police. I'm driving. And she's calling the cell phone to call and she's using the cell phone to call. Anyone we can think of, anybody. Have you heard from Lizzie? Have you heard from Lizzie? And then they realized they didn't know because they're trying to trace it back. When's the last time you heard from her? And they said, well, she said she was going to visit a new friend. And they said, do you know who that is? And nobody knew who that was.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Wow.

[James Petragallo]

So that is really hard. So then they ask around a little bit though, and talk to her friends and they find out who she was supposed to be hanging out with that night. And that was another 19 year old girl named Kat McDonough. So that was who she was supposed to be hanging out that night. A mutual friend of theirs who worked at Target with them, a guy named Nate McNeil. Because both cat, Lizzie and Nate all worked at Target.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Right.

[James Petragallo]

So he knows both of them. And he said, I knew Lizzie and Kat had met. I didn't know if they were anything more than work acquaintances at the time. You know, he said, I just. You know, I knew they had met and whatever, maybe stock some shelves together or something. But she said, he said, Lizzie was always happy and she always found the best in everyone. She had such an aura about her. You know, people wanted to talk to her. So it was normal for her to make new friends, too. This totally normal for her to be like, I want to hang out with new people tonight. I'm going to a party. I mean, that was just. She was very social and everybody liked her. So then before they can really locate Kat and figure out what's going on and talk to her, they find something they don't like. They find Lizzie's car. Oh, and it's a 2001 Mazda tribute, which I don't even remember that fucking model. That's how long that lasted it.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I'm sure it's a. I believe that's the small suv. That's like. Like a Ford Escape. I think so.

[James Petragallo]

Mazda, huh? I've never. I'm looking this up right now. I gotta see. What the hell? A 2000. This has nothing to do with the story. I got it coming up right now. I gotta find out, though. Mazda 2000?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, it's. Yeah, it's the smallest UV.

[James Petragallo]

What a piece of. Huh? Yeah, I never.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Well, I mean, it's like a Ford Escape. It's. It's not a great car, but it's. But they made them all the way to 2011.

[James Petragallo]

It looks like they were so successful, they've left such a stamp on society that I didn't remember it existed. Don't even remember commercials for them or anything. Nothing.

[Jimmy Wissman]

It was like a Honda passport. It was a tiny, little. Tiny little shit suv.

[James Petragallo]

So that's where they find her car. It's on the University of New Hampshire campus, is where they find it.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Okay, so that's interesting.

[James Petragallo]

They're like, okay, did she not drive from here? Because she was here is the last time anybody knew where she was, definitely and for sure.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

So they're like, did she get in a car with somebody else and leave? Did this. You know, did they. She meet people here? Who the hell knows? So they secure the car for evidence. They say there's no threat at the campus. Everybody don't freak out. Even though they don't know if she was disappeared from the campus parking lot or not. They have no clue.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, but she. So she was supposed to be with her friend that she met at Target. Yeah, but she left her car at camp.

[James Petragallo]

It doesn't make sense. So Kat McDonough we got to find out about her a little bit. She is a former honor student who dropped out of high school in February of this year.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh.

[James Petragallo]

So it was her senior year and she dropped out. So she went from honor student to drop out in, like a year, basically. Wow. Junior year, honor student, senior year, dropout. What happened? Her parents were like, God damn it, what the fuck? I thought it was all going great.

[Jimmy Wissman]

So much money we wasted.

[James Petragallo]

Oh, shit. So Nate, the guy from Target, when he found out about Lizzie, he reached out to Cat because he knew they, you know, at least were friends. And he said, at that point, I actually texted Cat because I knew that they had plans Tuesday night. And I asked, hey, did Lizzie ever come over to your house? No one seems to know where she is. And Kat texted back, no, I didn't see her. She never came over. So now we got a real mystery here. Right.

[Jimmy Wissman]

And she didn't make it to Cats.

[James Petragallo]

But she left her car at camp. And Nate believes Kat because she's just not a Target friend. She's known him for years and years and years. He said, she was my sister's friend from kindergarten. So, I mean, this is like an old, old friend. So they're starting to piece together this at the time, they find they're looking into Kat a little bit, and they find out Kat is living with her boyfriend, Seth Maziglia. Mazaglia, Here he is 29 years old, so a little older than the rest of the crew here. And yeah, they said one of the friends said Cat was a fairly known person in the community, and she seemed to be a normal teenager. Apparently, Seth and Seth and Kat met in the summer of 2011, the year before, which is right when her academics went in the shitter through the local theater scene. They're both trying out and doing, like, community theater and shit like that, like small plays. And one of her friends said, when I met her, she was very young. She was 17, and she was a sweet girl. Now, according to Seth's website, smmaziglia.com he's an experienced actor, writer, and fight choreographer who's worked both professionally and non professionally in the theaters that's important to put on there in the theaters of Southern New Hampshire for many years. The site states that he recently finished performing as Captain Keller in the Garrison Players deeply moving production of the Miracle Worker, quote unquote, Helen Keller. Shit. I wonder if he played Helen.

[Jimmy Wissman]

The website worked professionally, and obviously if you've worked professionally, in other words, we assume that you've done some amateur shit.

[James Petragallo]

Well, in other words, you can pay me or not is what that says. Yeah, yeah, but I like money in the theater world, that's what that says. I've worked for money, so I'm good enough to get paid, but I'll work for free. That's like the translation of that. If you've ever like put a movie together or something, you're looking for crew people. It's the type of shit you look for for free. So the. It also says that he's been spending his time writing, auditioning and contemplating his next projects. Contemplate. Do I do that one with Scorsese or do I do the comic book movie? I don't know what to do. Projects which he hopes will bring him closer to his goal of working in film. Quote, unquote.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

So according to his theater credits, he appeared in 2008 production of Beauty and the Beast at the Prescott park arts Festival, the 2006 production of the Elephant man at the West End Studio, 2004's yous Can't Take it with you at the Seacoast repertory theater. And 2000's Romeo and Juliet at the Romeo and Juliet 2000. Sorry. Yeah, yeah, cool. Romeo and Juliet. With pagers. That would be. Hey, everybody. Just gonna take a quick break from the show to tell you a little bit more about Aura frames. Best gift you could possibly give somebody, your family and your friends. Anybody you're close to. From big events to the silly moments you capture every day. Doesn't it sometimes feel like all your favorite photos are just stuck on your camera roll? How you have to scroll back so far to get them. They're pretty much gone forever. That's how it feels. Wouldn't it be better and great and awesome to have an easy way to share and enjoy them with. With your friends and family? So these pictures that you took that are important to you actually get seen. That is where Aura comes in. And they come in huge here. Everyone I know has one of these because I have given them to them because they're phenomenal, they're awesome. And we keep doing this. Like I'll get pictures of the kids when I go to Arizona and stuff. And they're on my dad's before I'm even back in New York. They're on my dad's frame, they're on people's frame. Save on the perfect gift by visiting auraframes.com to get $35 off Aura's best selling Carver matte frames. And they're beautif too by using promo code small Town Murder at checkout. That's a U R A frames.com promo code. Small Town Murder. This deal is exclusive to listeners, so get yours now in time for the holidays. Terms and conditions apply.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Now back to the show. Christmas is coming up, James. Did you know that?

[James Petragallo]

It is coming up. That's very important. You know what people should do around Christmas? Oh, you need shopping money. And the thing is, sometimes you're gonna find money in places you never thought like where, like subscriptions that you're paying for that you don't need to pay for because you don't even know you're paying for them, but yet they're coming out of your account every month.

[Jimmy Wissman]

How can you fix that?

[James Petragallo]

Rocket Money is what helped me out. That's the thing. Rocket Money is a personal finance app that finds and cancels your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps lower your bills so that you can grow that savings. Rocket Money will they negotiate lower bills for you? They can do that by up to 20%. All you have to do, submit a picture of your bill. Rocket Money, they take care of the rest. They'll deal with customer service. You don't need to be on hold for two hours. Rocket Money will take care of it. It's wonderful. Rocket Money has over 5 million users and has saved a total of $500 million in canceled subscriptions, saving members up to $740 a year when using all the app's features. Stop wasting money on things you don't use. Cancel your unwanted subscriptions by going to Rocketmoney.com Small Townmurder that's Rocketmoney.com SmallTownmurder Rocketmoney.com SmallTownmurde now back to the show. Just a beep and going off and. Yeah, let's put fucking about.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Talking about.

[James Petragallo]

What do you say?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Talking about which color Apple laptop or desktop they have.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah. Which imac are they using? I got the purple one, I got the blue one. The site lists him as 5 9, £200 and states he's also a martial arts instructor, along with having taught a form of martial arts in 2004 at both York Middle School and Newfields Elementary School.

[Jimmy Wissman]

592-0059. Muscular or portly.

[James Petragallo]

He's just kind of a little fire pluggy guy. But he's young though, so it's like, you know, he's not. Yeah. You know, when you're younger, your body just kind of stays like a thumbs, but then as you get older, like parts start sticking out. Yeah. So I think that's you didn't get to that part yet.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, Because I'm not quite 200 and I look in the mirror and go, what the fuck, man?

[James Petragallo]

Oh my God. Well, here I found. There's an audition of him auditioning for a play here. And I'm going to play just.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh yeah, he is just very. He looks like fucking Francis from Peewee Herman.

[James Petragallo]

He's a very average looking guy.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

Here he is. It's hard to hear, I guess.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, echoey. Yeah, it's in like a. Okay, he's a.

[James Petragallo]

He's doing.

[Jimmy Wissman]

He's a dork.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, he's doing like bad Shakespeare. They laughed. He stabbed himself and then fell like a fucking stooge. Like one of the three stooges. Like, fell and got a laugh.

[Jimmy Wissman]

The people watching laughed, which means, like, you didn't get the part.

[James Petragallo]

Well, maybe it's a comedy. We don't know.

[Jimmy Wissman]

It better be.

[James Petragallo]

It better be. Because otherwise you just gotta laugh in your death scene, which isn't good. That's not great. You're not looking for laughs in the death scene. I don't think that's what Shakespeare was after. And then he dies and then everyone cracks up. Haha. I'm a master of both comedy and drama. And then here's Katz. Which cats is crazy?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Okay. Is he dressed?

[James Petragallo]

Oh. What? That's cass. That's Cat McDonald. She forgets her shit. She forgets. Look at her. That's her forgetting. That's all right. Don't worry about it. She forgot. Yeah. Settle down, catch up.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Are you gonna burst into song?

[James Petragallo]

Okay, listen to her. Her singing is really irritating. All right, here it comes.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I've got a.

[James Petragallo]

Okay, that's good.

[Jimmy Wissman]

All right.

[James Petragallo]

I had to hear. I had to show you that because I almost fell off the couch and I played that. Hi, I'm a crow. Oh God. Jesus Christ.

[Jimmy Wissman]

What is she singing? Is that Peter Pan?

[James Petragallo]

Some horseshit show tune. I don't know, it's terrible. I think they're trying.

[Jimmy Wissman]

She did like chicken arms when she.

[James Petragallo]

She like, looked up in the sky. She really acted it out real cheesily.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I don't know. They didn't laugh at that. But they laughed at Dude's Ball.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, they laughed at his death. Holy. So according to his website, Also, he's a 2001 graduate of the Berwick Academy. 2006 graduate of University of New Hampshire. And the university confirms that he did graduate there in 2000. So he's not lying about that. The one guy who directed Cat offered Cat a part in a play. He Was directing in the fall of 2011. Said, I saw a young girl who was very interested in partaking in the production, who was reliable and helpful, which in director language means not that talented, but she'd work for free, show up on time and, like, set shit up and do what I asked. Basically, she'll. She really wants to be involved.

[Jimmy Wissman]

She's attractive enough. She's a go getter.

[James Petragallo]

She's just untalented, as we could hear from. She's not real talented. So this director said that McDonough changed a lot after she started dating Seth. So she went from an honor student who was one way to a dropout who was another way. They appeared together in the play last rites in July 2011. And that's kind of how they got together. And eventually they moved in together. And by the time of Lizzie's disappearance in October 2012, they were living together, sharing an apartment in Dover.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Wow.

[James Petragallo]

Now, here's what they're into, by the way. And also, when she got together with Kat, she basically cut off all contact with her family. Or when she got together with Seth, she cut off all contact with her family. Dropped out of school.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Is it.

[James Petragallo]

I'm gonna be with this guy. It's not. It's not meth. It is fucking freaky sex that they are into together.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Real.

[James Petragallo]

It is BDSM fucking. Oh, Ropes and bondage and shit. Like, really? Yeah. Apparently the one friend, the guy from.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Target, she couldn't get enough getting choked and fucked. Her grades off.

[James Petragallo]

Her grades off. And her family and everybody else. That's how much she enjoys being tied up and fucked, so. Or tying up other people and fucking. Whatever the case.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Whichever way.

[James Petragallo]

Whichever way she likes tying to have you think? The guy from Target said, we thought it was, you know, very sudden, and we all knew that her parents didn't really approve of it. When she moved in with this guy, Seth was working at a local electronics store and was a trained emt, but not working as one.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Okay.

[James Petragallo]

Now, they said that when you come across his name on the Internet at the time, it's all on sex and bondage sites all over the place. Yeah, that's where you find him. They said they learned also Cat was involved. She posted pictures of herself online using screen names such as Vampire Actress, Vampire Pirate, Vampire Actress, and Miss Scarlet.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Okay.

[James Petragallo]

And they said she had obviously developed this fetish that we learned about that had to do with ropes and bondage and submissiveness. Because the police start looking into these, people are like, holy fuck. This is what we're Finding. Yeah. So he. By the way, his other aliases online are Dark Kaiser.

[Jimmy Wissman]

No.

[James Petragallo]

Dark Kaiser.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Dark Kaiser. Dark Enough.

[James Petragallo]

That's what I mean. What are we doing? Enigmatic Shadows. That's a name which sounds like a really pretentious fucking high school band. We're Enigmatic Shadows and then they play fucking Emo and Rogue Temptress even though he's a guy.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Temptress.

[James Petragallo]

Temptress. They also found some text messages here between Kat and Seth about this. Gives you a good insight into their life. Okay, this is her to him. A cat to Seth. To my love. I want you to attack me. I need to be dominated. I have clothing you can tear off me, even cut off me. And then there's a couple redactions because they're people. How about getting something then when you're ready? That's redacted. Then it gets to go and then that's redacted. Okay. Then she says, I'm aroused and I want to be hit and thrown down. I really want to be tied up tight. I will be your submissive. Oh, and I know you get jealous when I call Cyrus certain names during our fun. He goes by Cyrus sometimes. Also Seth. I can call you anything you want if we can have fun. Leave bruises, she says. And then God damn love the willing. That's how she signs up because you can't rape him.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

Then he says back to the willing. To the my willing. I will dominate you brutally, without mercy. Mercy. Leaving my marks upon you. You will be known as mine by the way I tie you, bind you. Others will watch as I command your submission and as you fall prey to my whims. I am your lord. You, my lady, are my toy. I will use you until your exhaustion and then command still more your love. Signed your love.

[Jimmy Wissman]

And that's hot.

[James Petragallo]

That sounds like shit BTK wrote about people. It really does. Like I've read so much of his shit. That's exactly what he would sound like.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Feels like shit. He would write and then hide it.

[James Petragallo]

In a log somewhere in a hidey hole as he'd call it, in his fucking. In his shed. In his parents shed.

[Jimmy Wissman]

So nobody sees it. He can read it and jerk off later. But nobody else gets that with a.

[James Petragallo]

Little drawing of a fucking tied up woman that he made. Awesome.

[Jimmy Wissman]

This guy. Clicks send as imessage.

[James Petragallo]

Perfect. Well, I mean his response was actually correct to what the fuck she said.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, that's.

[James Petragallo]

Anything less it would seem like she's more into it than he is. You know what I mean? What are you going to say yeah, sounds good. I mean that's. She's like, well, fuck, that's no fun. You know, you're trying to keep up. I don't fucking know who's the leader and who's the follower here.

[Jimmy Wissman]

So I'm in C at 8.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah. All right. So they're also. They've posted on fetish websites looking to bring a third into their relationship.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Okay.

[James Petragallo]

She dropped out of school for this. This is.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Okay, that's fucking crazy.

[James Petragallo]

This is an actual ad that they posted and I'll read the whole thing and it's fucking lengthy. Dom slash switch couple looking for female slave slash sub in Dover, New Hampshire. Okay. This is personal ads to another level here.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

My lord and I are looking to acquire a live in slave. That's.

[Jimmy Wissman]

She wrote this.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, well, it's. I guess it's less creepy if the woman is doing it.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, that. That indicates more safety almost.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Right.

[James Petragallo]

You know, I guess for sexual pleasure and housework. Looking for a bang maid. Looking for a bag maid is what they're looking for. What the fuck? He is now.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Fuck us and bring a shark.

[James Petragallo]

No shit. Holy shit. Fuck us and bring 409.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Don't forget the Mrs. Meyer.

[James Petragallo]

Jesus Christ. He is the dom of the house and the master. He's also 30 years old. I am a nymphomaniac. Switch. And I switch from slave sub Dom. So you may never know what mood I'm in. Oh, that sounds terrifying.

[Jimmy Wissman]

That's fun.

[James Petragallo]

This is how our household works. We also have a cat. Little bit about us. Important shit first, by the way. We also have a cat.

[Jimmy Wissman]

It feels like they had that ad up and got a girl over and she walked in.

[James Petragallo]

Allergic cat. Oh, I'm allergic. But this ad isn't over. They just stuck it somewhere in the middle.

[Jimmy Wissman]

We also have a cat.

[James Petragallo]

All right.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Anyway, moving on.

[James Petragallo]

Anyway, our slave would be expected to keep the apartment in order, do the dishes, laundry and some of the cooking. You have to be a good cook and a weird and a freaky fuck. That's a lot to ask of a stranger. Also to be available for some form of sex at potentially any given time. We wouldn't expect you to have a job outside the house. What happens in your free time will be approved by the master.

[Jimmy Wissman]

What the fuck?

[James Petragallo]

Wow. We plan to meet up with any potentials in person, if interested, to discuss the household further and see if you have any specific requests. Then we would invite you in for about a month for a trial period to see how it works and if by the end of that month we decide to part ways, so be it. If on the other hand, you're able, you're. You are to stay, we can adjust what needs adjusting and go on with the agreement. This can be for a little while or long term. Be aware that we choose our long term companions very carefully. They're she's 19, she's not have any long term anything unlike ridiculous. Unlike many men and women who are willing to dive right into things on all levels. Even though we are physically intimate right away, we will take our time to circle you mentally and emotionally. We want to know who you are, what you are, how you respond under different pressures. That's terrifying. We want to be sure of your interests and hopes and goals in life. We also need to know your business plan for the future.

[Jimmy Wissman]

What do you see in some part.

[James Petragallo]

Exactly. It's a weird interview question for this particular thing. We will want to know you and be sure of you beyond a doubt in our minds. If you're interested at all, please contact us as we'd love to chat and discuss the possibilities. Also, bring Cat toys. That doesn't say that.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Bring catnip.

[James Petragallo]

Here is another text message from Seth's phone to cat's phone on August 25, 2012. So about a month and a half before this all happens. And it says this quote, the second price is this. You choose a friend any of yours will do and you offer her to me. That I may do. And then with asterisks around it, anything I wish with her while you watch and assist in any way I might command you to do so. Ideally this friend watches your punishment and helps, but I'll settle for someone who I interact with directly while you watch. In other words, I'll fuck her and you watch. But otherwise, yeah, obviously I think it would be fitting in the first. If the first thing you saw me do when you got back is to pleasure one of your friends until they died of something. You can fill the blank because it's redacted. I don't know.

[Jimmy Wissman]

He wrote that or Cat wrote that.

[James Petragallo]

He wrote this to her.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Okay, yeah.

[James Petragallo]

And then and only then, turn my brutal attention to you.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Jesus.

[James Petragallo]

Now the cops don't find Lizzie on any of these websites. She doesn't have profiles so she wouldn't like answered them her them on there or anything like that. So they're like she knows her from Target, which is way different than fetish websites. That's.

[Jimmy Wissman]

That's fucked up.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, so. But three days after she disappeared though, everybody's Convinced that it's Seth and Kat have something to do with this shit. So police bring them in for questioning at the same time. Put them in different rooms, obviously, and they talk to him and Cat here. There is a friend of hers named Roberta Gerken who they also chat with because they find a text to her on Kat's phone. So they get some information first and then they go in. They say she got a straight. She said she got a strange call From Cat around 10:49pm the evening in question.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Right.

[James Petragallo]

She said something was going on, they wanted my assistance and they wanted me to come over there. So her and her boyfriend Paul Hickok arrived like Wild Bill arrived at Seth and Kat's apartment a little after 11. This Roberta Gerken says, as I'm walking in there, there's a body on the floor. There's a body on the floor right next to the bed. So Hickok, the boyfriend, said that all he kept repeating, meaning Seth, all he kept repeating was, quote, he's gone too far this time. He's gone too far. He told the court later. So he said Seth was sitting there on the bed, basically where her head was and Cat was against the kitchen cabinets, almost in a fetal position. That's what they walked into. Be like, oh, all right. Good to see you guys. See you later.

[Jimmy Wissman]

There's a body.

[James Petragallo]

I gotta go drop the six pack off on the counter.

[Jimmy Wissman]

There you go.

[James Petragallo]

It's for you guys. Yeah, enjoy. They described that there. This is. They said that, yeah, she's. I guess they were talking about set sitting right there, saying, I went too far, I went too far. Or his cats rocking back and forth in the fetal position in the kitchen. Not wanting to get involved. The two that came over, they just fucking left and didn't call 911 or anything. They said you should call an ambulance and left. No part of this.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I mean, I Vegas car dealer doing.

[James Petragallo]

But call 911. Yeah, someone went too far. This isn't going to be on me. I'm not going to prison for this.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I just got here. I went too far by coming over here.

[James Petragallo]

I'm standing here with a fucking six or an ultra right now. Like, this is bullsh. I want to go home. So the police, when they talk to Kat, she says, at first Lizzie never showed up. Never showed up. And then about two hours into the interview, she just stopped talking. She just wouldn't give anything anymore. She just sat there. And so they finally said that you're free to go. And she said, no, I'm Going to wait for Seth to be done. Problem is, Seth is in there for 11 hours.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, he's talking.

[James Petragallo]

He's. Yeah. Well, at first he says that he. Lizzie never made it to their place. And, you know, he'd gone out for a run, but he twisted his ankle, so he was slow getting back to the house. She never came back.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, I've seen you, sir. You're not running.

[James Petragallo]

You're not running anywhere. Five fucking. Five, nine, two, zero.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Five, nine, two zero zero.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah. Where were you running? Fucking McDonald's. Where were you running? Fucking Wendy's. Where were you running off?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Was the Hot Pocket done in the microwave? Why were you running?

[James Petragallo]

And also, Kat had told police that she went that night. She has an alibi. She said, I was at. I went to a nearby cemetery trying to take pictures of ghosts with my digital camera. I was ghost hunting. He's going for a jog at night. You know how people do.

[Jimmy Wissman]

They had a busy night.

[James Petragallo]

It's the same day, though. They keep talking to Seth, and he's talking about bondage and sadomasochism and all that kind of shit.

[Jimmy Wissman]

And his name is SD sm, too.

[James Petragallo]

Sm. Yeah, absolutely.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Whoa.

[James Petragallo]

So he said that he then talks about Kat and another couple maybe harming Lizzie. Now he's putting it on them. He said that when I arrived home with my sore ankle, Lizzie was at the house. I lied. She was there, but I didn't know what happened. When I got there, she had a ligature mark around her neck. And he said that some other guy must have done something really terrible, and then he wouldn't, like, say anything more about. So they keep.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Just fucked up. Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

They keep pecking away at him, and eventually he goes, okay, fine. There was sex and something went wrong. That's what happened.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Okay.

[James Petragallo]

He says that neither of us tried to revive Lizzie or summon help. They said. Well, when it went. He said, basically, they were in the middle of sex and we'll give more details, and she had a seizure. When they were doing something, when they were doing some bondage thing, she had a seizure and then she just stopped breathing. He said, so. They said, so did you try to help her? Give her CPR or something like that? He said, no, we put a plastic grocery bag over her head and tied it around her neck. Which is what you do when someone has a seizure at your house. You just go, well, that's it for that. And you fucking tie them up.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I'd heard about this foam, and I didn't want it to get it all over my Apartment.

[James Petragallo]

Tie it up like they're a fucking bag of cat litter, scoopings like, what's going on?

[Jimmy Wissman]

And tied her head like, my dog just shit on the sidewalk.

[James Petragallo]

Why would you do that? Unbelievable. Unfucking believable. So Seth, you know, said, yeah, you know, all this type of shit they said, Was Cat involved? Where's the body? That's another thing. Where'd you put the body? Seth said after Lizzie died, he panicked and brought the body to Pierce island, which is where the river meets the Atlantic Ocean. He said he and cat used Lizzie's 2001 Mazda to take her to Pierce island in Portsmouth, where they threw her and her cell phone into the river.

[Jimmy Wissman]

God damn it.

[James Petragallo]

Her torso remained above the water, he said, though, for a while. Then he said he made Cat go into the. Go in the water, in. To push her off, to get her off the rocks. And she'll describe that. And then he made a joke to them about Davy Jones's locker. And he's making Pirates of the Caribbean references. What are you fucking doing, dude?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, my God. This is a cold motherfucker.

[James Petragallo]

Cold as ice. Sick and cold, he said. Then they drove the.

[Jimmy Wissman]

He's so cold, he doesn't even realize he's cold.

[James Petragallo]

No, this is all normal to him. He's just been acting like a psycho for so long, he doesn't know how to be normal anymore. Then they drove her car to the University of New Hampshire, left it in a student lot, discarded her belongings in trash bins, and that was that.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Does he know that he just gave them everything they needed? He's in a lot of trouble.

[James Petragallo]

That is fucked up. They. By the way, she goes on a little more. That gherkin lady, Roberta Gerken, she said that when she got there, she actually also did take the bag off of Lizzie's face. She used a box cutter to cut the bag, and she said that her face was totally blue when she did that.

[Jimmy Wissman]

You mean dead? Dead, dummy.

[James Petragallo]

And then they. She also said. I also heard them. Heard Cat and Seth something else I didn't tell you at first. Kat and Seth, I heard them talking about, quote, dumping the body, which is also a dead giveaway. So they look in a dumpster behind Seth and Kat's apartment, and they find men's underwear, a pair of black gloves, and Lizzie's sweatshirt in there.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, God.

[James Petragallo]

Evidence. They start searching everywhere. No trace of Lizzie, though. They can't find her anywhere. Obviously, her body is not to be found right now. They told the parents, and the dad says they brought us into the station, and we went off into a separate room, and we're given the news that Lizzie was dead. You're kind of numb after you hear those words.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

And the mother said she was just out there someplace. They just threw her away in the ocean.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

So they talked to one of sets. X's. Seth's ex, Seth X. Okay. This woman named her name. Her name's Catherine. She dated Seth when he was in high school and when. When she was in high school and he was in college in upstate New York. He likes them young.

[Jimmy Wissman]

He likes young girls named Cats.

[James Petragallo]

Because then they don't have. He's.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, they look up to him.

[James Petragallo]

Well, no, he also wants to set. They don't have a thing yet. He's gonna set and try to cement in early what their thing is. They're. The cement's still wet, I think, sexually is what he figures. So he can and, you know, get them into weird shit if they're not already into it. So she said that it was inevitable that Seth was going to kill and Lizzie Marriott was the perfect victim for her. For him. They said, she's asked in an interview, do you think that maybe it was a sexual encounter that went awry and it got too rough? And she said, no, this was murder. It's murder is what she said.

[Jimmy Wissman]

He wanted that.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, that. She said, I wish that she hadn't been there, but if it wasn't Lizzie Marriott, it would have been somebody else. He fantasized about murder a lot when I was with him. Great. She said initially he was, you know, flowers, and he was very caring. He said. She said, but he's always been into the BDSM type thing. And she said that we were naked and fooling around, and he put his hand around my throat fully, and I told him to stop, and he started doing it harder, and it just completely freaked me out.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, my God.

[James Petragallo]

Not into that. Some women like to be choked, and some women don't like to be choked a lot. It goes. It's a lot either way. Nobody's lukewarm on that shit either. Don't choke me or choke me now. Choke me right fucking now. There's no other. No in between. Hey, everybody. Just gonna take a quick break from the show and tell you more about our safest sponsor, Simplisafe. If you ever worry about the safety of your home and family, there's no better time to act than right now. Simplisafe is the home security that we trust. That is a fact. We've been using it for I think seven years now. And it brings great peace of mind. It's fantastic. You know your stuff is protected. You knowing your home is protected 24. Seven by SimpliSafe is a huge relief. Get 50% off today just by visiting simplisafe.com small it's your last chance to protect your home at Simplisafe's lowest prices of the year. Simplisafe's Active Guard Outdoor protection changes the game by preventing crime before it even happens. If someone's lurking around or acting suspiciously, those agents see them in real time, talk to them directly, set off your spotlights, and even call the police before anybody's had a chance to get into your house. That is awesome. Simplisafe is extending its massive Black Friday deal for our listeners this week only you can get 50% off any new system with a select professional monitoring plan. This is your last chance to claim their best offer of the year. Head to simplisafe.com Small that's SimpliSafe. S I m p l I safe.com Small there's no safe like SimpliSafe.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Now back to the show.

[James Petragallo]

Hey everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show to tell you a little bit more about chime. You know, we all spend more than we should during the holidays and that kind of thing, but we have something that will help you take control of your finances. You use a Chime checking account, which features like no monthly or maintenance fees. They have none of that. Yeah, a fee free overdraft of up to $200, which is incredible. Or you can get paid up to two days early if you have direct deposit. It's wonderful. You learn [e-mail] SmallTownMurder We've done it. We've all overdrafted by accident. The next thing you know, you're paying as much in fees, sometimes more in fees than you even drafted out for it.

[Jimmy Wissman]

So sometimes something happens in the car and you gotta get it fixed. What are you gonna do? Sometimes it's more than you expect.

[James Petragallo]

Hey, enjoy the holidays while keeping your financial goals on track with Chime. Open your account in two [e-mail] SmallTownMurder that's chime.com SmallTownMurder Chime feels like progress. Banking services and debit card provided by Bancorp Bank NA or Stride Bank N A members FDIC SpotMe eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply. Direct deposit timing depends on submission of payment file. Boosts are available to eligible Chime members enrolled in Spotme and are subject to monthly limits. Fees apply to out of network ATMs and for OTC withdrawals.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Now back to the show.

[James Petragallo]

Hey, everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show to tell you a little bit more about Quince. Quince can help you with this pesky holiday shopping that we all have to deal with. It's so hard trying to get. It's hard picking gifts for people, people you love. You want them to have something nice, check out Quince. You can do it. Quince lets you treat your loved ones and yourself to true quality at an affordable price. Everyone's happy here. Something everyone needs in their closet here. Quince's iconic Mongolian cashmere sweaters. Always nice. A classic. They start at $50. We've used quince. I found very nice stuff on Quince at a great price. I got a jacket, sunglasses. Jimmy's got some pants and he's rocking. It's good stuff. Gift luxury. This season without the luxury price tag, go to quince.comsmalltownmurder for 365 day returns plus free shipping on your order. That's Q U I n c e.com SmallTownMurder to get free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com SmallTownMurder now back to the show. So he's. She said that I told him to stop and it started getting harder and I got freaked out. And she said it was. It's this slow descent into a lack of choices to the point where I couldn't leave is what her life with him was. She said in 2002, they moved to New Hampshire, where Catherine says Seth was always trying to bring other women into the bed. She said it was something that was just constant. There was always needing to have more than just me in the relationship. And they said, why didn't you leave? She said, where would I have gone? I was 600 miles away from home and afraid to leave because if I left, he would kill me. He would hunt me down and he would kill me. She ended up eventually moving out and going into hiding, like dropping off the face of the earth.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Wow.

[James Petragallo]

So finally, cat cracks when they go in there and they go, she's got to. He's telling us all sorts of shit in here.

[Jimmy Wissman]

He said, you sunk a body.

[James Petragallo]

According to him, a lot. Most of it's you. So you want to talk here, bad guy. And she's like, whoa, I'm not the one with the dick here. That's the guy who was horny for her. She then says, okay, this is what Happened. Lizzie's death was an accident, but it happened in our house. She said she was sitting and the two of us were just kind of goofing around or Seth was sitting and the two of us were just kind of goofing around. The two girls, I guess the night started. The three of them watched a movie. Don't know which one. And played cards. And then they played strip poker is what they did, as we'll find out.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

She said that it went from silly to kind of sexual. It started getting a little bit more intense. And she said that Lizzie agreed to be tied up with bondage ropes and even draws a diagram of a harness for them that they had. She said I tied a harness on myself before, but it was the first time I'd ever tied a harness on someone else. So she even got down on the floor and demonstrated how she was positioned over Lizzie and was acting the whole thing out, which was probably poorly acted as we've seen from her other.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

In the middle of it she put her head up and went, crocodile docket. Oh my God. She said that the. At that point, she said that Lizzie had a seizure and suffocated and died as she was lying on the floor there. As she was lying under her on the floor. She said that they in the video too very detached. She seems real weird Cat. She said it was too much to handle. I was freaking out. She says this while looking completely unemotional. Yeah. So then a little reaction here from their friend Nate from Target. He said it was extreme and it didn't make sense. I couldn't see Lizzie just outright doing something like that. Well, you don't know how people fuck though. You don't have no idea.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I mean, yeah, I met a lot of girls you don't know eventually. Like they're. Wow, you do this.

[James Petragallo]

Didn't expect that. That's what I mean. Jesus. Put it where. Okay. He said especially with Kat and some guy. She only went over to a house once and yeah. She said no. And also she said Lizzie at the other point of this was in a committed relationship. She had a long term girlfriend. Lizzie liked girls.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh.

[James Petragallo]

She had a long term girlfriend, Britney. And said that they were in a long term committed relationship. He said they always talked about. She always talked about all the fun things they would do and how much they really cared for each other. And the Bob, Lizzie's dad said Kat's responsible. Kat's involved in this. You know, why isn't she arrested? Because they arrest Seth right away. But they don't arrest her, which is crazy. And they said, yeah, we've got him behind bars, but what about her? So it was two months before Kat's finally arrested.

[Jimmy Wissman]

What?

[James Petragallo]

She's not arrested for murder, though. She's charged with three counts of hindering an investigation and ordered to have no further contact with Seth.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Huh.

[James Petragallo]

The dad said she needs to rot in jail. That's what she needs.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yes. She facilitated this.

[James Petragallo]

Yep. But they need Kat's testimony, apparently, and she's got a lot more to say. So they offer her a deal instead of a possible 21 year sentence she'd be getting for those three things. Really, it could be life because she's in the room and you could definitely charge her with murder. If she testifies, she'll get a maximum of three years, one and a half to three years. So she took it, obviously, because that's insane to not take that deal. Who would not especially because she was probably sitting in jail for a while waiting. It's probably going to be almost time served by the end of it.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Every day that we get closer to the trial is another day I don't have to serve.

[James Petragallo]

That's it. So Set's trial. Lizzie's dad before the trial said, when you have a kid, you spend a lot of time thinking, you know, what can I do for them? And when a child is murdered, the number of things you can do really evaporates. And supporting her at trial was one of the last things I'll be able to do for her. The prosecution said, this is a. This is the opening. This is a case of deliberate rape, of deliberate, purposeful, cold blooded murder. The defendant struck quick and he struck without any mercy whatsoever. This is his victim, 19 year old Elizabeth Meredith. After his rape and murder, the defendant conspired with Catherine McDonough to falsify evidence of his crimes. Why is she only getting three years then?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, no kidding.

[James Petragallo]

She said the defendant ordered. McDonough was to obey without question. They said the case is not romanticized, fictionalized novel. Some of you may read this was an exercise of power and control. Basically they were trying to get out there because this is when 50 Shades of Gray was big. So they were trying to fucking. This isn't Fifty Shades. This isn't. Oh, they were having this hot time. That all you.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, it wasn't. It wasn't some mutual thing. They tricked her.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah. That the seven women on the jury, you've all fucking diddled yourself to. That's not what this is. No, this is different. So he's got to Put that. He said that Lizzie was attractive. She was what he had been looking for. The defendant and McDonough schemed about how they could exploit her sexually. Letters shown in court, the prosecutors argue, point to the reason McDonough lied. They say that she's a liar, but she lied for a reason. Because they got to say that she is credible. Basically they say she is his victim in the relationship where violence and abuse were masked under the guise of so called kinky sex. And then they brought up the letter that said, I'll dominate you brutally, without mercy.

[Jimmy Wissman]

God, Jesus.

[James Petragallo]

But that, that was really. Those two were. Really seemed mutually excited about that shit. That was.

[Jimmy Wissman]

And it was a lot targeted on her. Not. Not somebody else.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah, but the defense said that guy Cat killed Lizzie in a sex game gone wrong. That's what this was. Seth wasn't even involved in it.

[Jimmy Wissman]

He was sitting there jerking off.

[James Petragallo]

Yeah. Ladies and gentlemen, Seth Maziglia did not rape, he did not murder Liz Marriott. Kat McDonough caused her death. He said that her testimony is a lie that you're going to hear. Seth is nothing more than a love sick accomplice and Kat is really the aggressor. He said that although Cat caused Lizzie's death, Seth in fact was there is what his defense attorney said. And so he did participate in the deeply flawed acts that followed the death. You know, dumping her in a fucking ocean. They say that now Cat's only blaming Seth to save herself. That's what happened here, they said. Yep. They said test results, by the way, found that Lizzie and Seth's DNA were on the underwear, not cats. Okay, cats weren't on him, but. So the defense says that the DNA doesn't prove anything though, because, you know, they were all proves a lot. Exactly. They said the physical evidence shows what, sex. That's what he said. Yeah, yeah, sex. And then the person's dead and then in the ocean, you have to assume.

[Jimmy Wissman]

It was against her will.

[James Petragallo]

A squared, B squared, C squared.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, that's rape and murder, my friend.

[James Petragallo]

Rape and fucking murder. Here. So Kat testifies, this is the whole case is Cat. Basically, the prosecutor said, how often will the defendant be dominant and you be a slave or submissive? She said all the time. Daily. Yes. She says prosecutors are talking about, you know, this is what he does. He dominates, he controls. They said regardless of whether you'd be the defendant, slave or submissive, who always had the final say on matters. She said he did. She. They said. She said, this is just the beginning where I've been able to Open up. And actually explained and will explain what happened to Lizzie. So they said, who killed Elizabeth Marriott? She said, Seth points to him, did Lizzie die accidentally during some form of sexual activity gone bad that you both. That she agreed to? Cat says, no. Okay, this is the big twist.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Here we go.

[James Petragallo]

Cat, he said, who introduced the ropes into use in sexual activity? And she said, he was the one who brought the ropes in. They said, did he and did he and you engage in domination? Master submissive. She says, yes. Then they read a bunch of text messages where, you know, promising this and commands for him to find. For her to find him a girl and all that kind of shit. It's time I punished you. Other one, a text message reading. There was a bunch of details. And at the end it said, it's time I punished you, you filthy little whore, was what he texted her. Now, he then reads from a second part of the text in which he says, you choose a friend. Any of yours will do the one we read earlier. And yeah. So then they said, Ms. McDonough, did your efforts to locate another sexual partner for the defendant intensify when you received that text message? And she said, yes. She was given a directive here. Basically, they said it was that when you reached out to Lizzie Marriott and invited her over to the apartment. And she said, yes. So texts from October 9, which is the when Lizzie disappeared, show that she arrives at the apartment at 8. 51. They said. And then we all started talking about what we wanted to do. They said they decided on a movie at Cat suggestion. Then at Cat suggestion, a game of strip poker. She said, we all sat down and began to play. The lights were very dim. We were just kind of laughing. I ended up not wearing anything. She ended up in just her underwear. And she said, that's when Seth made his move to initiate sex.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, boy.

[James Petragallo]

Seth suggested that I should kiss Lizzie. And she said she wasn't comfortable with that and that she was in a committed relationship. Cat said so.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Really?

[James Petragallo]

Yeah. She's like, no, I don't want to do that. I'll play around. I'll be in my underwear, but I'm not kissing anybody or, you know, fucking anybody. Basically, yeah. So Kat says that Seth made another suggested suggestion or asked a question. He asked her if he could have sex with me in the room, is what Kat said, Can we fuck in front of you? How's that? Yeah.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah, yeah.

[James Petragallo]

And she said, no, she wasn't okay with that.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Okay.

[James Petragallo]

Okay. So this is going to be an awkward Monday at Target. Let me tell you Something?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah. Oh, boy.

[James Petragallo]

So she said that he looked. She. She. She could tell he started to look angry. At this point, she said he didn't like to be told no. Seth would sit. It was sitting on the futon behind us, and that's when he did it. She said that while Lizzie sat on the floor watching a movie, Seth quietly put on gloves behind her and grabbed a rope. Holy shit. She said, quote, he moved up behind her and pulled the rope over her neck and strangled her. She let out a quick noise, and then she sort of. Sort of stopped moving. This fucking horrifying.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Holy shit.

[James Petragallo]

That is just disgusting. This poor fucking girl. Jesus Christ. They said, and do these appear to be the gloves they showed? They hold up the gloves, and they're like these black, creepy gloves. I got a picture of them. I'll post.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, boy.

[James Petragallo]

And she said, yes. And they said, then what happened? Was that the end of it? And she said, no, it wasn't. Then he raped her when she was dead.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, my God.

[James Petragallo]

After he strangled her.

[Jimmy Wissman]

What the fuck?

[James Petragallo]

This is horrific.

[Jimmy Wissman]

They said, so there was no BDSM tying up?

[James Petragallo]

Like she said, no nothing.

[Jimmy Wissman]

There was no harness?

[James Petragallo]

No. There was a rope.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Straight up murder.

[James Petragallo]

Yep, it was a murder. And then he raped a corpse. Yeah, exactly. I'm horrified.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, boy.

[James Petragallo]

For everyone involved, except for Seth. He sucks. So Kat said she wasn't moving at all. She was completely limp. And they said she wasn't conscious. And she said, no. They said, did you tell him to stop? And she said, no, no.

[Jimmy Wissman]

I mean, what are you guys saying?

[James Petragallo]

Wow. I guess at that point, I mean, he's got the rope out. They said, did you yell for help? She said, no. He said, did you. Did you do anything to save Lizzie's life? Not at all. Okay. She said, I definitely have. Oh, this is a juror later on said, I definitely have sympathy for Cat. I don't think she was in control of her anything. Her mind, anything. That night. She also said on the stand, Kat said, seth came over to me. I was still curled up, and he held out his arm to me, and he said, come on, we're in this together. Oh, boy. She said, by that time, it was very late, like 1am they said together. The prosecutor said, together. They located Lizzie's car, took the car using back roads and avoiding all the toll booths they went to.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Right. So no cameras.

[James Petragallo]

No cameras, Yep. They said that she helped put the body into Lizzie's car. They drove 13 miles to the coast, and they parked at the end of Pierce island and brought Lizzie's body wrapped in a tarp and stuffed into a suitcase.

[Jimmy Wissman]

What the shit?

[James Petragallo]

This is fucked up, man. Up to a path and an overlook above the river. They took her body out of the suitcase and they asked who pushed Lizzie's body over the cliff at that point. And she said, seth, did she? The body tumbled down the cliff, but it was low tide, and she landed on the rocks. Oh, God. Jesus. 35ft down.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, Jesus.

[James Petragallo]

So Seth said. He said he couldn't climb because he was too exhausted. So that's when I climbed down to her. He said to cover her with seaweed. So I covered her completely with seaweed, and I managed to push her into the water. She said that she spent the remaining hours of that night throwing away the evidence that's never been recovered. Suitcase, most of her clothing, the rope that she was strangled with, all of that. And then they left the car in the parking lot and walked six miles.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Good God, what a gross six mile.

[James Petragallo]

That is disgusting. And you're with this piece of shit next to you.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

Corpse raper. So they said that. She said she was completely isolated from her friends and family. She said, I didn't want to lose him. He was the only person I have. I didn't have anywhere else I could go. Holy fucking shit. And they said, also the underwear. They said that was another item you threw away in the dumpster. And she said, yes. And these items showing the gloves and all that? She said, yes. The juror later on said, the gloves, for me, were very incriminating. That was the point where I thought premeditation. When he put on those gloves, he was actually thinking about doing something.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, boy.

[James Petragallo]

Cross exam here. Defense attorney says, do you have the capacity to look these jurors in the eye and lie to them while you project meekness and submissiveness and remorse? And she said, I'm not lying to them. I'm up here to explain everything that had happened truthfully to the point where I'm admitting to awful things that I personally have done. I did lie a lot, but I don't want to anymore. And that's why I'm up here telling the truth. Yeah, they got a psychiatrist in here who's an expert on abusive relationships and said that you can love someone and be afraid of them simultaneously. This is what abusers count on. This is a very gradual increase of the manipulation and control, and it usually just increases when they feel the need to. Closing arguments. The defense argues that Cat can't be trusted. Said, yeah, what we have is Cat McDonough being the manipulator of facts. Lying. Lying to you from that witness stand. And the prosecutor said that she's not on trial. Set this right. He said, send him the message that you know the truth about him and that he's a cold blooded killer. The verdict. Five men, seven women. And that comes in the. Lizzie's dad said, I've never been that nervous in my life. We were all sitting on pins and needles.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Right?

[James Petragallo]

And they find him guilty of first degree murder.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

By strangulation. Guilty of first degree rape and murder. And guilty on two counts of conspiracy. He's fucked.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Super. Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

For sentencing. He didn't want to show up.

[Jimmy Wissman]

He didn't even show up.

[James Petragallo]

He ended up showing up, but he didn't want to. He was trying to get a really. The judge to sign off on it. Now, technically, you have a right to be there, but you don't have to be there. You don't want to. A law professor said that it's not remarkably unusual and he's seen a lot of judges grant these requests.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Really?

[James Petragallo]

He said, what's he going to miss? He's going to miss the judge. Probably saying nasty things about him and other people saying nasty things about him. He doesn't want. Of course he doesn't want to be there. This is taking your medicine after all this? Why be there?

[Jimmy Wissman]

Sit down. Yeah.

[James Petragallo]

They get the family up on the stand here. The uncle that she was living with, that Lizzie was living with, Tony said, you are the one that took her life from us and Lizzie from us. He said, you're a twisted individual who brought only darkness and pain into this world. Wow. Her dad said, it's so hard to envision that level of evilness and disregard for humanity. Lizzie's gone. I still find that hard to comprehend. You murdered her over a year and a half ago. And every day I wonder what she would have been doing. She said, I call this Dad's Exhibit one. And was allowed to walk around the courtroom with a big picture of her holding a. Holding a little turtle in her hand. Oh, fuck her frog. I'm sorry. He said, look closely and you can see a frog gently cupped in her hands. Why is Lizzie so happy she's saving that frog? Mom said, we were all shell shocked during the trial. Lizzie died twice a day, every day. It was awful. And then she said, Mr. Mazzeglia, I'm Melissa Marriott. I'm Lizzie's mother. I miss Lizzie every day. I wake up in the morning and she's gone. I go to bed at Night. She's still gone. And all because a cowardly 30 year old man could not deal with a confident young woman. He just didn't want to fuck her. Or she just didn't want to fuck her.

[Jimmy Wissman]

She didn't want to fuck him.

[James Petragallo]

That's it. He could have went, oh, that's cool. Finish the movie. She took off. And then find somebody who wants to fuck you.

[Jimmy Wissman]

He's a five, nine, dumpy. Shit. Nobody wants to fuck you, man.

[James Petragallo]

Especially if she's into chicken. That's the last guy she wants to fuck. So Seth has a chance to speak and he does.

[Jimmy Wissman]

What's he say?

[James Petragallo]

A quote. I did not rape and murder Elizabeth Marriott. Bad start.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Don't do that.

[James Petragallo]

However, I do understand the Marriott family's pain and I did play a part in covering up her death. A mistake I tried to correct when investigators came to me and I showed them exactly where I left Lizzie's body. Unfortunately, we are unable to recover her. And for that I am truly sorry. My heart goes out to the Marriott family and I'm very sorry for their loss. I'm sure you are.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Super sorry.

[James Petragallo]

The judge says, you dumpy little pervert. Yeah, may fuck off. Life without parole. Oh, is that right, dicks? You little fucker. Yeah, he had all the aggravating factors forever and ever. Fuck you.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh, boy.

[James Petragallo]

Dad said Lizzie's dad, Bob, these parents, I feel terrible. They seem like nice people who raised a nice kid and they're a great kid. They're just fucking. Just obliterated by this. He said, we're very grateful that the jury returned a verdict of guilty. And for first degree murder. The truth of what happened to Lizzie is horrendous. And every time it's been told, it's reinforced the despair that we feel. Here comes unbelievable. Kat pleads guilty to hindering prosecution and is sentenced to. You, ma'am may fuck off. I guess a year and a half to three years in prison. She gets.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Christ.

[James Petragallo]

The jurors said, how can you prove a murder without a body? One juror said, no body, no crime.

[Jimmy Wissman]

They're going to keep saying it.

[James Petragallo]

I'm telling you, they're going to say.

[Jimmy Wissman]

It all the time. I mean, it's very easy. If she doesn't exist, you can't see her anywhere. She's not using her car, her money.

[James Petragallo]

She's not alive.

[Jimmy Wissman]

She's dead.

[James Petragallo]

She's dead. He said, I didn't think it was possible. One juror said, they kind of believed the defense. They said that put a question mark in my Head. Could that have actually happened the way she's describing it? Meaning cat. Cat was on the stand for 10 days, by the way.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Jesus.

[James Petragallo]

So they said that if he testified, it would have helped to at least get his side of the story and put it together. One juror said she could have manipulated him. She's an actress. She's a compulsive liar. No, she's not. All these things are questions that go into your head. No, she's definitely not.

[Jimmy Wissman]

You see your audition. She's not an actress.

[James Petragallo]

No. They said, though, it was kind of like ping pong. We broke it down step by step. They said. I think she's. One juror said, I think the cat's way more culpable than her sentence. Like we thought she should have. She should have got more. So I think she should have gotten a longer sentence. I mean, we can't forget that she helped dispose of a fucking body, obviously. So anyway, they have remembering Lizzie.org by the way. L I Z Z I.org they set up a scholarship in her memory. It's called the Lizzie Marriott Intrepid Ocean Explorer Fund. So that's nice if you want to put some money somewhere nice. 2016, Seth tries to appeal, saying that you. We weren't allowed to introduce evidence of Lizzie being into freaky sex.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Oh.

[James Petragallo]

And that she wanted to be there and all this type of shit. They said, you're not bringing her sex life into this because it's fucking irrelevant. Someone there said you fucking strangled her when she said no, then raped the corpse. Just because she likes other shit is completely irrelevant.

[Jimmy Wissman]

She wasn't alive when sex was done.

[James Petragallo]

Yep. And so that was that. That was. The state supreme court said, not happening, motherfuckers. Stacey, you're not. You're not gonna now run this girl through the mud because you feel like her memory.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Jesus.

[James Petragallo]

There you go. He's rotting in fucking jail, luckily. And she's out. Okay.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Jail by now, right?

[James Petragallo]

I don't know.

[Jimmy Wissman]

She's a. She's a shit bag.

[James Petragallo]

She's definitely having freaky sex. I'll tell you that much. She's into that shit. So there you go, everybody. If you like the show, please, please leave a nice review for us. Give us five stars. Say something nice on whatever app you're listening on. It really helps a ton. Shut up and give me. Murder.com is the website. Get all your tickets for live shows. All the 2025 dates are going to be announced in December. Tickets will go on sale before Christmas. So get in there.

[Jimmy Wissman]

Right.

[James Petragallo]

Tarrytown and Boston. You guys are last two shows of this year. Few tickets left. Get in there if you want to see the show. Shut up and give me murder.com patreon.com crime in sports bonus material 5 bucks or above. Every a month you get everything. Hundreds of back episodes. New ones every other week. This week for crime and sports, what you get. We're going to talk about a crazy United Kingdom English soccer sex scandal. It's gross. Then for small town murder cult baby murder Talia we're going to talk about a wild polygamist sort of sect with five people and they drink their own pee. It's insane. We'll talk all about that. That is patreon.com crime and sports follow on social media malltownmurder on Instagram, small town Pod on Facebook. You want to follow us? Shut up and get me murder.com drop down menu. Hit that. Keep doing it and keep coming back. And until next week everybody, it's been our pleasure. Bye. If you like small town Murder, you can listen early and ad free now by joining Wondery plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. Prime members can listen early and ad free on Amazon Music. Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short [e-mail] survey.

[Lainey Jacobs]

They say Hollywood is where dreams are made. A seductive city where many flock to get rich, be adored and capture America's heart. But when the spotlight turns off, fame, fortune and lives can disappear in an instant. When TV producer Roy Raiden was found dead in a Canyon near LA in 1983, there were many questions surrounding his death. The last person seen with him was Lainey Jacobs, a seductive cocaine dealer who desperately wanted to be part of the Hollywood elite. Together they were trying to break break into the movie industry. But things took a dark turn when a million dollars worth of cocaine and cash went missing. From Wondery comes a new season of the hit show Hollywood and Crime, the Cotton Club Murder. Follow Hollywood and Crime the Cotton Club Murder on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. You can binge all episodes of the Cotton Club Murder early and ad free right now by joining Wondery Plus.