Summary of Small Town Murder Episode #554 - "Murky Murder Motives - Fort Pierce, Florida"

Release Date: December 21, 2024
Hosts: James Petregallo and Jimmy Whisman

Introduction

In episode #554 of Small Town Murder, hosts James Petregallo and Jimmy Whisman delve into the intricate and dark case surrounding the murder of Ashley Paulo in Fort Pierce, Florida. Combining thorough research with their trademark comedic flair, the duo unpacks the events leading up to the crime, the ensuing investigation, and the subsequent legal battles that unfolded in this seemingly tranquil small town.

Fort Pierce, Florida: A Town with Hidden Struggles

The episode begins with an exploration of Fort Pierce, a city with a population of approximately 46,409. While some reviews paint Fort Pierce as a "hidden gem" with affordable housing and a small-town feel, the hosts highlight a contrasting reality plagued by crime, particularly gun-related incidents. James notes, “[...] the city is the definition of crime, drugs, and gangs” (08:43), underscoring the tumultuous environment in which the central murder took place.

Ashley Paulo: Profile of a Complex Individual

Ashley Paulo, whose full name appears variously as Ronald Ashley or Ashley Ronald, is introduced as a successful tax attorney admitted to the Florida Bar in 1980. Despite his professional achievements, Ashley's personal life was marred by violent behavior and mental health struggles. His daughter described him as a "workaholic" who was "very doting" yet conflicted, stating, "He was something of a workaholic" (14:48). Court records from 1999 reveal a violent past, including restraining orders and psychological evaluations, contrasting sharply with his non-violent public persona.

The Murder at 2J's Gourmet Deli

On August 2, 1999, Ashley Paulo assaulted Julius Melnick at 2J's Gourmet Deli, leading to Melnick sustaining a broken hip from which he later died due to complications. Initially charged with aggravated battery, the case took a dramatic turn when the medical examiner ruled Melnick's death a homicide, resulting in a third-degree murder charge for Paulo. James sarcastically comments, "They don't let old people write the elderly law, and it makes no sense with the rest of the laws" (20:04), highlighting a perceived flaw in the legal statutes.

Investigation and Legal Proceedings

Despite numerous accusations and a troubling history, Paulo maintained his innocence, attributing his actions to accidental motives. After a prolonged period without further incidents, Paulo resurfaced in 2010, leading to renewed suspicions and investigations. The turning point came when Michelle Lockridge, an employee with a criminal background, implicated her boyfriend Thomas Barnard in Paulo's murder. Through meticulous police work involving surveillance footage and forensic evidence, including acid burns on Paulo's body, the prosecution built a strong case against Barnard.

During the trial, Michelle's credibility was undermined by her extensive criminal history and conflicting testimonies. James mocks the defense's shaky narrative, stating, "You have to refute her story" (64:11). The jury ultimately found Thomas Barnard guilty, sentencing him to life without parole. Ashley's family expressed their relief and sorrow, with his sister proclaiming, "That's a cold-blooded murderer" (68:40).

Related Crimes and Persons of Interest

The episode also touches upon the tragic case of Frederick Matthew Lockridge, a 15-year-old who was convicted for the murder of his 10-year-old sister, Isabella, in 2016. Frederick's multiple confessions reveal a deeply troubled individual, further painting a grim picture of Fort Pierce's societal issues.

Conclusion

Small Town Murder Episode #554 provides a comprehensive and gripping account of Ashley Paulo's murder, set against the backdrop of a city grappling with crime and corruption. Through detailed storytelling and candid commentary, James and Jimmy shed light on the complexities of small-town intrigue, the failings of legal systems, and the profound impact of personal demons on community safety.

Notable Quotes:

• James Petregallo on Fort Pierce's Crime:
  “The city is the definition of crime, drugs and gangs.” (08:43)

• Jimmy Whisman on Legal Flaws:
  “They let old people write the elderly law, and it makes no sense with the rest of the laws.” (20:07)

• James Petregallo on the Murder Trial:
  “You have to refute her story.” (64:11)

• Ashley Paulo's Sister on Verdict:
  “That's a cold blooded murderer who robbed them of a kind and gentle man.” (68:54)

This detailed summary captures the essence of the episode, providing listeners with an in-depth understanding of the discussions, insights, and conclusions drawn by the hosts without requiring prior knowledge of the podcast.