#560 - Solving A Murder Puzzle - Chicopee, Massachusetts

Sat Jan 04 2025

This week, in Chicopee, Massachusetts, who could have brutally killed a happy, bubbly, very cool young woman in her own home? It's a mystery, but detectives have DNA, some very small shoe prints, and a name, written on a white board to go on. When a...

Transcript

James Petregallo (0:02)

Hey everybody. Just gonna take a quick break from the show and tell you about noom. Has NOOM helped you? I believe it has.

Jimmy Whisman (0:08)

Oh, it's got an app. You can do tracking. It's terrific.

James Petregallo (0:11)

It does. And NOOM builds personal plans that can meet individual needs. That's the thing. Takes into account any dietary restrictions, medical issues, other personal needs that helps build a plan that works for you. And yes. So you've. I know that you've had your own personalized program here that you've been working on.

Jimmy Whisman (0:28)

And weight loss, this is weight loss results that last. They stick around because you get yourself into a lifestyle change. That's what matters.

James Petregallo (0:38)

That's mainly. You can't just say I'm going to cut that out for a month and then go back. That's not what it is.

Jimmy Whisman (0:43)

You don't.

James Petregallo (0:43)

So I'm glad it's helping you. That's great. And it really does. I like the psychology and biology based approach here. NOOM weight uses psychology. That's why they say losing weight starts with your brain but it also takes into account your unique biological factors. Jimmy. All of all of your all different multitude flora and fauna that goes on inside of you there. Stay focused on what's important to you with Noom's psychology and biology based approach. Sign up for your trial today at Noom.com, noom.com n o o m.com here. Based on 3.5 year study of actively engaged Noom users with minimum starting BMI of 25. Individual results may vary. Visit our website for more information. Hey everybody. Just gonna take a quick break from the show and tell you a little bit about Rocket Money. You wanna save money?

Jimmy Whisman (1:38)

Always.

James Petregallo (1:38)

This is what it's about. They found a subscription of mine that I paid for for years. You know how angry I was? I was equally as angry at that as I was happy that Rocket Money found it. Like, thank you for saving me. It's excellent. And that's what Rocket Money is. It's awesome. Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps find and cancel your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending and helps lower your bills so you can grow your savings. You can't beat it. See all of your subscriptions in one place. You know where all your money's going. Create a personalized budget you can do too. It tracks all your expenses. You get alerts if bills increase in price. Rocket Money has over 5 million users and has saved a total of $500 million in canceled subscriptions, saving members up to $740 a year when using all the app's premium features. Cancel your unwanted subscriptions and reach your financial goals faster with rocket Money. Go to RocketMoney.com SmallTown Murder today. That's RocketMoney.com SmallTownMurderRocketMoney.com SmallTown Murder now back to the show. Hello, everybody, and welcome back to small town Murder Express. Yay.

Summary

Small Town Murder Podcast Summary Episode #560 - Solving A Murder Puzzle - Chicopee, Massachusetts Release Date: January 11, 2025

Introduction In Episode #560 of Small Town Murder, hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman delve into the harrowing murder case that unfolded in Chicopee, Massachusetts. Combining meticulous research with their signature comedic flair, the duo unpacks the intricate details of the crime, the ensuing investigation, and the eventual prosecution.

Overview of Chicopee, Massachusetts The episode begins with James and Jimmy providing a comprehensive overview of Chicopee, a mid-sized town nestled in south-central Massachusetts. With a population of approximately 55,636, Chicopee is characterized by its rich industrial history and diverse community.

James (06:14): "Chicopee, Mass. Is in south central Massachusetts. It's kind of like mid. Mid Massachusetts, we'll call it."

Jimmy (06:11): "It's a nice place."

Despite its seemingly quaint appearance, Chicopee grapples with economic challenges, evident in its median household income of $56,509, which is below the national average. The town's industrial decline has left remnants of its manufacturing past, contributing to its unique socio-economic landscape.

The Murder Case: Amanda Lynn Plass and Seth Green The focal point of the episode is the brutal murder of Amanda Lynn Plass in August 2011. Amanda, a 20-year-old waitress and artist, was tragically found dead in her apartment, having been violently stabbed multiple times.

James (15:23): "So champ, how long was that?"

This tragic event sets off a complex investigation, with Seth Green, a 27-year-old construction worker and Amanda's boyfriend, becoming the prime suspect.

Investigation Details Seth Green initially reported finding Amanda dead, describing the scene with blood on the floor and himself noticing the absence of his weed pipe and knife. Despite his statements, inconsistencies in his story and physical evidence led detectives to scrutinize his alibi.

Jimmy (16:04): "Oh, Seth Green. Why did I saw Seth MacFarlane?"

James (16:45): "Nah, you can go here all you want, head to Chicopee all you want."

Forensic evidence revealed significant clues:

Bloody Shoe Prints: Determining a men’s size 7½ or a youth size 7.
DNA Evidence: Amanda's fingernails contained DNA not matching Seth.
Broken Porch Window: Indicated a possible staged burglary.

James (24:30): "Looking for a very small man, an average sized woman or. Or a very large 12 year old."

The investigation led detectives to explore potential suspects, including a man named Dennis, whose presence was hinted at through Amanda’s dry erase board scribbles ("Dennis was here").

Trial and Conclusion After extensive investigation and months of pressure from Amanda's grieving mother, the case against Seth Green intensified. Despite passing a polygraph and having a solid alibi initially, DNA and footprint evidence ultimately linked him to the crime scene.

James (63:45): "How do you explain that?"

In court, the prosecution presented overwhelming evidence, including:

DNA from Amanda’s Fingernails: Matching Seth.
Footprint Analysis: Aligning with Seth’s shoe size.
Aggressive Nature of the Crime: Suggesting a personal motive.

James (72:21): "You were there for blood and a palm print on the broken window."

The jury deliberated for five hours before convicting Seth Green of first-degree murder, including robbery, leading to a sentence of life imprisonment without parole.

Aftermath and Reactions The community of Chicopee was left in shock, grappling with the loss of a beloved resident and the revelation of systemic issues within the local police force. Additionally, the episode sheds light on the misconduct of certain officers who mishandled crime scene protocols, sharing unauthorized photographs and breaching professional standards.

James (75:11): "It's fine. I'm telling you. Start the year out with greater peace of mind."

Legislation and Impact: Amanda's Law In response to the mishandling of the crime scene and the emotional toll on Amanda's family, Amanda's Law was enacted in Massachusetts. This legislation prohibits first responders from taking unauthorized photographs of crime scenes, ensuring the privacy and dignity of victims and their families are upheld.

James (78:51): "She said, yeah, body cameras should never be turned off. That wasn't the issue. The issue was personal cell phones."

Amanda's Law stands as a testament to the family's resilience and their pursuit of justice, aiming to prevent similar tragedies in the future.

Conclusion Episode #560 of Small Town Murder offers a profound exploration of a tragic event that shook Chicopee, Massachusetts. Through detailed storytelling and insightful commentary, hosts James and Jimmy provide listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the complexities surrounding Amanda Lynn Plass's murder, the investigation process, and the broader implications for the community and law enforcement practices.

Notable Quotes

James (15:23): "So champ, how long was that?"
James (24:30): "Looking for a very small man, an average sized woman or. Or a very large 12 year old."
Jimmy (26:21): "That's kids."
James (63:45): "How do you explain that?"
James (78:51): "She said, yeah, body cameras should never be turned off. That wasn't the issue. The issue was personal cell phones."

This summary captures the essence of Episode #560, focusing on the key elements of the Chicopee murder case while omitting advertisements and non-content sections to provide a clear and engaging overview for listeners and potential new audiences.