Podcast Summary: Small Town Murder
Episode #599 - Madness Of A Murderous Maniac - Summerville, Georgia
Release Date: May 29, 2025

Introduction

In Episode #599 of Small Town Murder, hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman delve into the chilling story of Hayward William Bissell, a man whose descent into madness culminated in a horrifying murder spree in Summerville, Georgia. Combining meticulous research with their trademark comedic flair, the hosts explore the complexities of small-town life and the dark events that unfolded.

Background of Hayward William Bissell

Hayward Bissell, born on March 28, 1962, is introduced as a physically imposing figure standing over six feet tall and weighing around 400 pounds. Raised in a tight-knit family in New London, Ohio, Hayward exhibited behavioral issues from a young age, characterized by constant complaining and resistance to authority.

James Pietragallo [26:03]: "Never wanted to follow the rules. He'd have a 50 in one class and a 97 in another because he didn't like that class."

Despite these challenges, Hayward enlisted in the Army in 1979, where he excelled in his duties as a motor transport operator. His military career provided him with structure, but underlying mental health issues persisted.

Early Signs of Mental Health Struggles

Hayward's struggles with mental health became increasingly apparent after his honorable discharge in August 1985. Transitioning to civilian life, he faced difficulties maintaining stable relationships and employment, frequently finding himself in conflicts and battling depression.

Jimmy Whisman [41:01]: "He had a lot of depression, too. He's got a lot of mental problems that are really starting to cook up here now."

His interactions with mental health professionals were sporadic, often involving voluntary admissions to clinics where he received inconsistent treatment. This pattern of seeking help without sustained intervention contributed to his deteriorating mental state.

The Relationship with Patricia

In late 1999, Hayward's life took a fateful turn when he began a tumultuous relationship with Patricia Ann Boer, a 25-year-old woman with her own troubled past. Despite Patricia's efforts to seek healthier relationships post her first marriage, she found herself entangled with Hayward, whose controlling and abusive behavior mirrored his longstanding issues.

James Pietragallo [73:36]: "Patricia was excited about her pregnancy, but also said she didn't intend to marry him."

Their relationship was marked by cycles of reconciliation and separation, with Patricia eventually breaking off the relationship due to Hayward's escalating violence and manipulation. However, Hayward's persistent threats and erratic behavior kept drawing Patricia back, culminating in the tragic events that followed.

The Rampage and Murder

On January 23, 2000, during an intense winter storm in Summerville, Georgia, Hayward's mental instability reached its peak. Seeking shelter and driven by delusional commands he believed were transmitted via a satellite implant, Hayward committed a gruesome murder.

In a remote service station parking lot, Hayward attacked Patricia Ann Boer, inflicting multiple stab wounds that resulted in her dismemberment. His actions were marked by intense brutality, including the removal of her eyes, heart, liver, and legs.

James Pietragallo [130:08]: "He stabbed James in the abdomen without any warning. He just stood there and did it."

Following the murder, Hayward embarked on a violent rampage, targeting individuals in his path. His spree included the attempted assassination of a local police chief and other residents, leaving a trail of fear and devastation in his wake.

Law Enforcement Response

Law enforcement officials, including Chief Randall Kilgore of Greenwich and Deputy Chief Dwayne Wooten, responded swiftly to the murders. Recognizing the severity of Hayward's actions, they coordinated efforts to apprehend him amidst the chaotic winter conditions.

The culmination of their pursuit led to a dramatic confrontation where Hayward was finally subdued after a violent chase. Despite his size and aggression, law enforcement managed to apprehend him, though not without casualties and significant trauma to the community.

Jimmy Whisman [157:05]: "He couldn't stop, he kept speeding down the road and disappeared over a hill."

Aftermath and Trial

Hayward Bissell faced the full extent of the law, ultimately pleading guilty to murder while being declared mentally ill. The court sentenced him to life in prison without the possibility of parole, deeming him a continuing threat to society.

The trial underscored the challenges of dealing with individuals suffering from severe mental health issues, highlighting the gaps in the system that allowed Hayward's instability to go unchecked until it was too late.

James Pietragallo [181:40]: "He pleads guilty, but mentally ill in Georgia. He'll spend the rest of his life in the state penitentiary."

Conclusions

Episode #599 of Small Town Murder serves as a sobering exploration of how untreated mental health issues and systemic oversights can lead to tragedy. Through the story of Hayward Bissell, James and Jimmie shed light on the complexities of small-town dynamics, the importance of mental health care, and the dire consequences of neglecting individuals in need.

The hosts blend their comedic insights with a deep respect for the victims, ensuring the narrative remains both engaging and respectful. This episode stands as a poignant reminder of the delicate balance between community support and the necessity of addressing mental health proactively.

James Pietragallo [185:03]: "This is one of the craziest goddamn stories we've ever told. He's still there for as far as I know, I haven't seen him die at all."

Notable Quotes:

• James Pietragallo [26:03]: "Never wanted to follow the rules. He'd have a 50 in one class and a 97 in another because he didn't like that class."

• Jimmy Whisman [41:01]: "He had a lot of depression, too. He's got a lot of mental problems that are really starting to cook up here now."

• James Pietragallo [73:36]: "Patricia was excited about her pregnancy, but also said she didn't intend to marry him."

• Jimmy Whisman [157:05]: "He couldn't stop, he kept speeding down the road and disappeared over a hill."

• James Pietragallo [181:40]: "He pleads guilty, but mentally ill in Georgia. He'll spend the rest of his life in the state penitentiary."

Small Town Murder continues to unravel dark and complex narratives, offering listeners an in-depth look into the hidden stories that define small communities. Subscribe and follow James and Jimmie every Thursday for more compelling episodes.