Summary of Podcast Episode: "Creepy Killer Motives - Wakefield, Massachusetts"
Podcast Information:
- Title: Small Town Murder
- Hosts/Authors: James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman
- Episode: Creepy Killer Motives - Wakefield, Massachusetts
- Release Date: June 26, 2025
Introduction
In this gripping episode of Small Town Murder, hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman delve into the unsettling double homicide that shook Wakefield, Massachusetts. Combining thorough investigative research with their signature comedic flair, the duo unpacks the intricate motives and events leading up to the tragic murders.
Background of Wakefield, Massachusetts
[05:04] James Pietragallo: Wakefield, a suburb located approximately 15 minutes outside Boston, has a rich history dating back to its settlement in 1638. Originally known as Lynn Village, it became South Reading before finally adopting the name Wakefield in honor of Cyrus Wakefield, founder of the Wakefield Rattan Company.
Key Points:
- Population: 27,041 residents with a nearly even gender split.
- Demographics: Predominantly White (91.6%) with a significant Catholic population (50.1%).
- Economy: High median household income ($110,372) and expensive real estate (median home price ~$645,500).
- Community Life: Known for events like the Festival Italia and active community involvement.
The Murders
[21:04] Jimmy Whisman: On March 13, 2006, Michael Zamitti Jr., age 39, and his colleague Chester Roberts were brutally murdered at the All State Concrete pumping company.
Details:
- Victims:
- Michael Zamitti Jr.: Shot twice in the face with a 16-gauge shotgun.
- Chester Roberts: Shot in the back while attempting to flee, resulting in death.
- Crime Scene: No forced entry, suggesting an inside job or someone with access. Surveillance footage captured suspicious vehicles but lacked clear identification.
Notable Quote: [47:25] James Pietragallo: "They killed seven people." (Referring to a similar massacre in Wakefield)
Investigation and Suspects
The investigation initially pointed towards organized crime due to the nature of the murders. However, detectives soon shifted focus to personal motives within Zamitti's inner circle.
Primary Suspect: Sean Fitzpatrick
- Background: Neighbor and friend of Michael Sr.
- Motive: Involved in an extramarital affair with Michael Jr.'s wife, Michelle.
- Evidence:
- Surveillance: DNA found on the steering wheel of a suspicious green F150 pickup truck matched Sean.
- Alibi Inconsistencies: Sean claimed to have been in Florida during the time of the murders, but E-Z Pass records contradicted his alibi.
- Threatening Letter: Sean admitted to sending a threatening letter post-murders, raising further suspicion.
Key Developments:
- Letters: A threatening ransom-style letter was received by Michael Sr., with a palm print later matched to Sean.
- Truck Evidence: Sean's involvement was further implicated by the presence of his DNA and the suspicious green truck linked to the crime scene.
- Affair Revelation: Michelle admitted to an emotional and physical affair with Sean, complicating the motive.
Notable Quote: [64:16] James Pietragallo: "You have to have something to say about that."
Trial Proceedings
The trial of Sean Fitzpatrick was mired in complexity due to circumstantial evidence and personal relationships.
First Trial:
- Verdict: Deadlocked after seven days, resulting in a mistrial.
- Reasons: Jurors cited reasonable doubt due to lack of direct evidence and reliance on circumstantial links.
Second Trial:
- Changes: The defense attempted to introduce an alternate suspect, Ricky Cali, but the court deemed it irrelevant due to the time lapse since their last interaction.
- Outcome: Convicted of two counts of first-degree murder; sentenced to two consecutive life sentences without parole.
Notable Quotes:
- [166:10] James Pietragallo: "You have the wrong person."
- [168:03] Jimmie Whisman: "She might have great kids."
Aftermath and Public Reaction
Post-conviction, the case garnered attention on media platforms like Nightmare Next Door and Investigation Discovery's "A Concrete Motive." Michael Sr. tragically passed away in custody, leaving behind a grieving family.
Impact:
- Community: Wakefield remains scarred by the events, emphasizing the thin veneer of safety in seemingly tranquil small towns.
- Legal Precedents: The case highlights challenges in prosecuting incestuous or personal motive-related murders without substantial physical evidence.
Notable Quote: [169:48] James Pietragallo: "Nobody talking about, is there an alternate juror sitting upstairs?"
Conclusion
Creepy Killer Motives meticulously explores the intricate web of personal relationships and misguided motives that culminated in the tragic murders in Wakefield. James and Jimmie adeptly balance the gravity of true crime with their comedic insights, offering listeners both enlightenment and entertainment.
Notable Quote: [170:35] James Pietragallo: "It's a crazy fucking story. Very quickly here we'll go through the end. That was bonkers shit."
Recommended for Listeners: If you haven't tuned into this episode yet, Small Town Murder offers a compelling mix of in-depth investigation and humor, making it an engaging listen for true crime enthusiasts and comedy fans alike.
Connect with the Hosts:
- Website: Shut Up and Give Me Murder
- Patreon: patreon.com/crimeinsports
- Social Media: Follow James and Jimmie for updates, merchandise, and live show information.
Note: This summary captures the key points, discussions, and notable moments from the episode, ensuring an engaging and comprehensive overview for those who haven't listened to Small Town Murder.