Small Town Murder: Serial Butcher Killer - Parkersburg, West Virginia
Hosted by James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman | Released on June 19, 2025
Introduction
In this gripping episode of Small Town Murder, hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman delve deep into a chilling case from Parkersburg, West Virginia. Combining thorough research with their signature comedic flair, they explore the dark underbelly of a seemingly quiet town and the horrifying actions of a serial killer with a background in butchery.
Background of William Dean Wickline Jr.
William Dean Wickline Jr., born in 1952 in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, emerges as a central figure in this narrative. Growing up in a blue-collar family, Wickline exhibited troubling behaviors from a young age. Described by peers as "very direct and didn't smile a lot," his early years were marred by violence and antisocial tendencies.
- Notable Quote:
Jimmy (25:31): “He’s a weird, real weird guy.”
Wickline's path took a darker turn post his involvement in the Vietnam War. Struggling to reintegrate into society, he turned to drug dealing, establishing himself in the underworld and earning the nickname "the Butcher" due to his gruesome methods.
The Murder of Charles Morgan Marsh
On November 20, 1979, the tranquility of Marsh's household was shattered. Marsh, a 33-year-old Vietnam veteran and drug dealer, was found brutally murdered. His head was severed and left on a nightstand, accompanied by a chilling note: "I came, you weren't home. I love you."
- Notable Quote:
Jimmy (26:08): “He’d had his throat cut and his head cut off, obviously. They have his head sitting there.”
The dismemberment suggested a level of expertise typically associated with butchers, hinting at the killer's possible background in the trade.
Investigation Challenges
The initial investigation proved difficult. Police found no fingerprints, signs of forced entry, or other physical evidence linking anyone to the crime. Marsh's involvement in the drug trade added layers of complexity, with money and illicit substances intertwining in the case.
- Notable Quote:
Jimmy (35:19): “This is a scene you would tell people about for years. What's the craziest thing you ever saw? Well, let me tell you something. It's this.”
Wickline's subsequent arrests for unrelated drug offenses scattered evidence and made it harder for authorities to connect dots across different states.
Connection to Other Murders
Over the years, more cases surfaced that bore striking similarities to Marsh's murder, all involving dismemberment and decapitation. Theresa Kemp, a close associate of Wickline, testified about her involvement in these gruesome acts, implicating Wickline as the mastermind behind the killings.
- Notable Quote:
Jimmy (69:12): “Wickline is the most dangerous man I've ever encountered in all the years of my career.”
Despite the mounting evidence and witness testimonies, Wickline maintained his innocence, leading to prolonged legal battles and appeals.
Trial and Conviction
In a high-profile trial, Wickline faced charges for the murders of Christopher and Peggy Ann Lurch. The prosecution painted him as a calculated and remorseless killer, citing his meticulous methods of disposing bodies.
- Notable Quote:
Jimmy (132:10): “Katherine Ramsland ... she knows a lot of gross. A lot of gross shit here.”
Wickline's defense attempted to discredit testimonies, particularly those of Theresa Kemp, arguing coercion and financial motives behind her statements. However, the court found him guilty, resulting in a life sentence for one murder and the death penalty for the other.
Appeals and Execution
Wickline's journey through the legal system was fraught with appeals, all of which were denied. By 2004, his execution was set for March 30. Despite his efforts to argue ineffective assistance of counsel and highlight mitigating factors, the courts upheld his convictions.
- Notable Quote:
James (166:35): “He doesn’t care.”
On the day of his execution, Wickline was portrayed as a composed and unrepentant individual, further cementing his image as the "Butcher" in the annals of Ohio's criminal history.
Post-Incident Revelations
Years after Wickline's death, revelations came to light confirming that Chester McKnight was the true perpetrator behind several dismemberment murders, including the Lurch case. McKnight's confession in 2008 exonerated others wrongly convicted, highlighting significant failures in the initial investigations.
- Notable Quote:
Jimmy (170:11): “Chester McKnight, confessed in 2008. That is fucking wild.”
These developments underscored the complexities and challenges law enforcement faces in solving intricate and gruesome crimes.
Conclusion
This episode of Small Town Murder serves as a sobering reminder of the fallibility of the criminal justice system and the enduring quest for truth. Through meticulous research and engaging storytelling, James and Jimmy shed light on a case that intertwines violence, deception, and the relentless pursuit of justice in small-town America.
For more in-depth discussions and upcoming episodes, visit shutupandgivemurder.com and follow Small Town Murder on Instagram and Facebook. Don’t forget to support the show on Patreon for exclusive content and shout-outs!