
Loading summary
Molly Bloom
From the brains behind brains on, it's.
Eleanor
Smash Boom Best, the show for people with big opinions.
Molly Bloom
Hi, I'm Molly Bloom, and this is Smash Boom Best, the show where we take two things, smash them together, and ask you to decide which one is best. Today's debate is full of frights and delights. Grab your popcorn and watch your backs because it's Ghostbusters versus Jurassic Park. We've got podcast producer Tracy Mumford ready to take the call for Team Ghostbusters.
Tracy Mumford
Molly, my hostess with the ghostess. It is so good to be here. I hope everyone's ready to take a roller ghoster ride. Am I right?
Molly Bloom
And we have journalist and author Tom Weber ready to roar for Team Jurassic Park.
Tom Weber
If you're ready for a dino mite debate, then, as they say in the movie, hold onto your butts.
Molly Bloom
And here to judge it all is Eleanor from St. Paul, Minnesota. Eleanor is a softball player and a writer. And not only is she an avid debater in her high school debate league, she also judges younger debaters in a middle school debate league. Hi, Eleanor. Hi. So, Eleanor, how did you become a judge for middle school debate?
Eleanor
I did my first year of high school debate in freshman year, and then I got an email in March from my debate league being like, we please need judges. Please come judge.
Molly Bloom
And what about debates like this one? This is probably a little different than the middle school debates, but maybe it's not so different after all.
Eleanor
Yeah, you're not directly asking each other questions, which is the big difference. But that's usually kind of a mess in middle school debates, so maybe we've dodged a bullet.
Molly Bloom
Okay, you're also a writer, so tell us, what kind of fiction do you write?
Eleanor
I like writing fantasy, though I'm not very good at it. But we're working on it. That is what matters.
Molly Bloom
Yeah. What kind of stuff do you like to write about?
Eleanor
I like dragons. I think dragons are super cool, and I kind of just like creating worlds. I think that's super fun.
Molly Bloom
Have you created any dragon characters?
Tom Weber
No.
Molly Bloom
Okay, so it's time.
Eleanor
It's time.
Molly Bloom
Maybe today's debate will inspire a dragon character.
Eleanor
Step up.
Molly Bloom
You're a pro debater and judge. What advice do you have for our debaters today?
Eleanor
Mostly I have to yell at kids because they're never loud enough. So feel free to yell into the.
Molly Bloom
Mic Any other advice you want to give.
Eleanor
Be fun, have fun. Debate's supposed to be fun. It is not supposed to be boring.
Molly Bloom
So we like fun here at smashboom Best. Will Eleanor side with Tracy or Tom, Only time will tell. But first, let's review the rules of the game. Every debate consists of four. The declaration of greatness, the micro round, the sneak attack, and the final six. After each round, our judge Eleanor will award points to the team that impresses her the most. But she'll keep her decisions top secret until the end of the debate. Listeners, we want you to judge too. Mark down your points as you listen. At the end of the show, head to our website, smashboom.org and vote for whichever team you think won. Tracy, Tom, and Eleanor, are you ready?
Eleanor
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Molly Bloom
Then it's time for the declaration of greatness. In this round, our debaters will present a well crafted, immersive argument in favor of their side. Then they'll each have 30 seconds to rebut their opponent's statements. We flipped a coin. And Tracy, you're up first. Tell us why Ghostbusters is the series to call for a haunting good time.
Tracy Mumford
Okay, so you are on the hunt for an after school part time job. And you are looking through all the flyers that they've posted up at the coffee shop. It's like dog walker. Okay, maybe wait for 11 dogs. Too much. Okay. Car wash assistant. Too many bubbles. Dress up as a pickle and hand out samples at the grocery store. Not again. Pickle people. Then you see it, the flyer. They are looking for a new Ghostbuster. Are you brave? Check. Do you like to explore the unknown? Uh huh. Do you want to use the fireman's pole instead of stairs? Always. This is the job for you. There's one more add up for like an assistant at a dinosaur DNA lab, but it has a big warning sign that all of the previous employees are missing. So not that job. What I'm saying is you're looking at these options and like, which phone number are you gonna dial? Like, I guess what I'm saying is, who you gonna call?
Molly Bloom
Ghostbusters.
Tracy Mumford
The Ghostbusters are iconic. Their story stretches back to the 1980s when a team of scientists in New York City noticed something strange in their neighborhood and they banded together to investigate the paranormal and bust some ghosts. And from the very start, they did everything in style. They've got sweet matching jumpsuits made for comfort and style, complete with the Ghosty logo. They carry proton packs on their backs. They're these special machines that fire powerful rays of energy that catch ghosts like a neon lasso. And don't forget, they're sweet digs. The Ghostbusters live and work in an old converted firehouse. Complete with an actual fireman's pole that they slide down during ghost emergencies. Plus, they cruise around town in the Ectomobile, which is a tricked out vintage 1959 Cadillac Miller Meteor Sentinel beauty. So they've got wheels, accessories, uniforms.
Molly Bloom
Cool.
Tracy Mumford
Headquarters. Check, check, check, check. Another key thing about being a Ghostbuster. You're never alone. Ghost hunting is a team sport. Someone always has your back. There's something behind me, isn't there?
Molly Bloom
Mm.
Tracy Mumford
Is it a very slimy ghost that is kind of dripping on me?
Tom Weber
Yep.
Tracy Mumford
Could you just say no more?
Stay Puft Marshmallow Man
I got you. Yeah, toasty ghosty.
Tracy Mumford
I gotta say, when you look at Jurassic park, it's a lot harder to form meaningful friendships with people when you're running for your lives from a T. Rex.
Molly Bloom
Hey, you. You wanna, like, see a movie or something?
Tom Weber
A movie?
Tracy Mumford
All I see are that thing's giant claws.
Molly Bloom
I mean, not now, but I'd just be like, maybe later if we don't get chopped.
Tracy Mumford
Also, Ghostbusters are using science and research to solve problems. Unlike a little franchise, I know where they used science to make problems. Like some very big problems. Ghostbusters like to nerd out on formulas and experiments and go to the library. And they use everything they learn to solve problems. Giant rivers of slime solved it. Haunted portraits, not a problem. 100 foot tall marshmallow walking around and crushing skyscrapers. The Ghostbusters have it handled. Is there anything better than a group of people who you can call to solve your problems? And of course, because I think everything should end with a dance party, you have to acknowledge the Ghostbusters theme song. Can you dance to this? You can't not dance to this. But can you dance to this? Just slowly and not with a lot of feeling. So to fully proton pack my argument here. They're styling. You're dialing. They fight ghosts. They're good hosts, they're useful. They're crucial. They've never been beaten. They're not being eaten. They've got a good song. I'm not wrong. They're Ghostbusters.
Molly Bloom
Wow. A rhyming declaration of greatness that got us all busting a move for Ghostbusters. Eleanor, what stood out to you about Tracy's declaration? Declaration of greatness.
Eleanor
I really liked how you talked about how cool they were and how stylish they were and how fun it was to live in their little firehouse. And I like that you played the theme song so much. I love the theme song.
Tracy Mumford
That's right. You're invited over for a dance party. That's what I'm saying.
Molly Bloom
All right, Tom, it is time for your rebuttal. You've got 30 seconds to tell us why Ghostbusters is a feeble franchise. And your time starts now.
Tom Weber
Well, my music rebuttal is coming, so stay tuned on that. I want to point out that the science of why the proton stuff actually catches ghosts was never actually fully explained, unlike the science in Jurassic Park. Also stay tuned. I also just want to point out something Tracy didn't bring up. The first Ghostbusters movie, 1984. And it wasn't till 2016, 22 years later, that they finally decided to have women Ghostbusters. I'm seeing some ghostbusting equality problems in the franchise that I think really need to come to light.
Molly Bloom
And time. Tracy, anything you'd like to say?
Tracy Mumford
I just. I hear a lot of jealousy in that voice. I don't know. And someone who doesn't understand ghost theorems, but, you know. Go on, go on.
Molly Bloom
All right, Tom, it is your turn. Please tell us why Jurassic park is a dino delight.
Tom Weber
Usually, I type my arguments myself, but after three hours of button mashing the wildly popular Jurassic park arcade game, my thumbs are sore. So I'm dictating to my new AI Assistant. I should clarify. I don't mean AI like artificial intelligence. I mean ancient intelligence. My assistant is a T. Rex. And in retrospect, asking an animal with notoriously short arms to use a keyboard might not have been the best idea. But you know what? I don't need fancy typing to make my case. I have living proof right here. A T. Rex in the flesh. Down, girl. Down girl. You'll get your meaty num nums in a minute. My point is, Jurassic park wows us because we get to see the most epic creatures ever come to life. I remember being a kid seeing the original movie with my grandma. Seeing Jurassic park makes you think, wow, these amazing dinos really walked the earth. Nature is full of wonder. Meanwhile, the rubbery looking ghouls and Ghostbusters make you think, wow, was this ticket really worth 15 bucks? And there's a reason why the dinos in Jurassic park look so realistic. Most of the jaw dropping special effects were computer generated images or cgi. In fact, the first Jurassic park helped develop this technology and introduced us to a whole new era of movie magic. Every CGI movie from the Avengers to Avatar owes a debt to Jurassic Park. Ironically, it's the special effects in Ghostbusters that are prehistoric in comparison. After all, the first Ghostbusters movie came out almost 10 years before Jurassic Park. That's the cinematic dinosaur. Thanks. It was a sick burn. And unlike Ghostbusters, Jurassic park is based on real science. In the movies, scientists use DNA from ancient dino blood to recreate these magnificent creatures. Well, scientists are actually doing this kind of thing, but not to bring back dinosaurs. Instead, they're using it to help build up populations of endangered species. And some researchers are hoping to bring back the woolly mammoth. The only thing Ghostbusters is bringing back are the careers of washed up 80s actors. Now, those are dinosaurs I don't want to bring back. And if you need even more reasons to love this movie, the first Jurassic park was so inspiring that it led to a boom in people studying dinosaurs. Some researchers say that's why in recent years, we've been discovering tons of new dinosaurs, about one every week. And on a side note, how fun would it be to be friends with real dinosaurs like Chris Pratt is with those velociraptors in Jurassic World. Way cooler than being friends with some booger ghost like Slimer. Oh, right. I should mention the soundtrack. You know, the one chills that is the handiwork of composer John Williams, the genius behind the music of Star Wars, Indiana Jones, Harry Potter, Jaws and E.T. sure, Ghostbusters had a silly novelty song that's fun around Halloween, but try listening to it more than once without wanting to shove Stay puft marshmallows in your ears. Meanwhile, I could play the Jurassic park soundtrack all day.
Stay Puft Marshmallow Man
But to. You're forgetting the best part of Ghostbusters. The ghosts like me.
Tracy Mumford
Boo.
Tom Weber
I'm sorry, what?
Stay Puft Marshmallow Man
Yes. People love scares, and nothing scares like a ghost. Is that a Tyrannosaurus?
Molly Bloom
Oh.
Stay Puft Marshmallow Man
Get me out of here.
Tom Weber
See, you don't need glorified exterminators to bust ghosts. Jurassic park gave us cgi, some awesome real science, amazing music and the fright of our lives. What more could you ask for? Oh, right. Meaty num nums. Here you go, T. Rex. Yes. Who's a good T. Rex? Yes, you are. Oh, watch the fingers. Those aren't snacks. Here's some more steak. Yes. Yes. You deserve it.
Molly Bloom
Very cool, Tom sounding sharp with his T. Rex. Hype person, hype creature. Eleanor, what stood out to you about Tom's declaration of greatness?
Eleanor
I didn't know that Jurassic park was the reason we have CGI in the way we do now. And I think I need a dino AI for myself.
Molly Bloom
Absolutely. All right, Tracy, it is time for your rebuttal. Tell us why Jurassic park puts the stink in extinct. You've got 30 seconds. And your time starts now.
Tracy Mumford
Look, Tomasaurus rex. Can I call you that? Yeah. Okay. I am very glad that they let you off your island. That's big Step. And you know what? Dinosaurs are cool. I'm not gonna argue with that. Bring them back to life so I can see them even cooler. But you know what Jurassic park did was a huge accident. They keep doing it in every sequel. I'm just for responsible dinosaur science. Like, don't let them out. Jurassic park is supposed to be a cool island to visit, and instead people are running for their lives. It's like if you went to Disneyland and the Teacup R I tried to eat you.
Molly Bloom
That's not the vacation I'm looking for.
Tom Weber
Look, I know people sometimes can see ghosts, sometimes can't. But you can see a dinosaur every day of your life. They're called birds. And so they are here. They are with us, and we love them. And I seem to recall some people running for their lives with the Stay Puft marshmallow.
Tracy Mumford
What happens when you're the meaty num nums, Tom?
Molly Bloom
That's just what I want to know.
Tom Weber
It's all about charming them. They have great personalities.
Tracy Mumford
They almost took your fingers. That was on tape. That was on tape.
Molly Bloom
Okay, Eleanor, it is time to award some points. Please give one point to the declaration of greatness you like best, and then one point to the rebuttal that won you over. You get to decide what makes a winning argument. Did one team's jokes make you laugh? Was another team's argument unbeatable? Award your points, but don't tell us who they're going to. Have you made your decision?
Eleanor
Yes.
Molly Bloom
Excellent. Tom and Tracy, how are you two feeling so far?
Tom Weber
Dinorrific.
Molly Bloom
Mmm.
Tracy Mumford
Amped up.
Molly Bloom
Excellent. It's time for a quick break. Grab some popcorn and take a quick rest.
Eleanor
And we'll be right back for more smash. Boom. Best.
Molly Bloom
You're listening to State of Debate, home to raging rhetoric and awe inspiring argumentation.
Taylor Lincoln
Meow. That's Cat for hello. I'm Taylor Lincoln, debate maven and cat person.
Tom Weber
Woof.
Tracy Mumford
Woof.
Todd Douglas
That's Dog for feed me. And I'm Todd Douglas, the dog dude and debate powerhouse.
Taylor Lincoln
And we're here at our local animal shelter to cuddle some canines and kitty.
Todd Douglas
Cuties and catch some logical fallacies with our claws and paws.
Taylor Lincoln
Logical fallacies are uncool debate techniques that help you lose your debates. And I just snagged a nasty one. Wanna hear it?
Todd Douglas
Ooh. That's Dog four, of course. Let's listen in and see what the cat dragged in.
Tracy Mumford
Oh, look at these little kittens in.
Eleanor
Need of a home. What do you think, Amos?
Tracy Mumford
Should I adopt one?
Molly Bloom
Meh.
Tracy Mumford
Aren't they adorable? Listen to their little meows.
Todd Douglas
I don't really like cats.
Tracy Mumford
Wait, what? Why? And why didn't you put that on your dating profile?
Todd Douglas
I don't know. I just think that they're mean.
Tracy Mumford
How so? Because they can scratch and bite. Dogs can also scratch and bite. Aw, this little furball seems to love the way I'm petting him.
Todd Douglas
They're mean because they're just not nice to people. Cats are mean because they're not nice to people.
Taylor Lincoln
And they're not nice to people because they're mean.
Todd Douglas
Our friend just said the same thing twice. That argument didn't take us anywhere.
Taylor Lincoln
And that's because it was a circular argument fallacy. That's when a debater ends their point with the argument they started with. It's an argument that goes around in.
Todd Douglas
Circles like a dog chasing its tail. Our friend Amos needs to come up with some fresh ideas about why cats.
Taylor Lincoln
Are mean, which is a losing argument anyway.
Todd Douglas
I don't know, Taylor. I've had a few gnarly run ins with my neighbor's cat, Salsalito.
Taylor Lincoln
Watch it, Todd. My claws are coming out.
Todd Douglas
To quote the great Scooby Doo.
Molly Bloom
Ruh Ro.
Todd Douglas
We'll see you next time on State of Debate.
Tom Weber
Brains on Universe is a family of podcasts for kids and their adults. Since you're a fan of smashboom Best, we know you'll love the other shows in our universe. Come on, let's explore.
Molly Bloom
Here we are in Brains on Universe, home to my favorite podcasts, Brains On Smash. Boom.
Taylor Lincoln
Best.
Molly Bloom
Forever ago, I found one.
Tom Weber
Brains on.
Molly Bloom
Brains on. A science podcast for kids and families. Let's start with our pal, the Sun.
Tracy Mumford
Did somebody call their favorite star? It's me, the sun.
Molly Bloom
The sun is made up of very, very hot, electric. What a great show. Need more Brains On. Now.
Tom Weber
Listen to Brains On Wherever you get your podcasts.
Todd Douglas
Smash.
Stay Puft Marshmallow Man
Boom. Best.
Molly Bloom
You're listening to smashboom Best. I'm your host, Molly Bloom.
Eleanor
And I'm your judge, Eleanor.
Molly Bloom
And we love getting debate suggestions from our listeners. Take a listen to this ancient debate idea from Gael.
Eleanor
Hi, I'm Gael and I'm from Australia. My debate idea is Romans versus Vikings. Now that's a debate for the history books.
Molly Bloom
We'll check back in at the end of this episode to see which side Gael thinks should win.
Eleanor
And now it's back to a Debate Ghostbusters versus Jurassic Park.
Molly Bloom
That's right. And it's time for round two, the micro round. For the micro round challenge, each team has prepared a creative response to a prompt they received in advance. For Tracy and Tom, the prompt was batty Reputation. In this challenge, a villain from a debater's movie needs to clear their reputation. They want to set the record straight about how they're really not that bad. Will they redeem themselves? It's up to our debaters to decide. Tracy went first last time. So, Tom, you're up. Tell us why we shouldn't judge the baddies of Jurassic Park.
Tom Weber
Hello? It's me, the velociraptor from Jurassic Park. You're surprised I can talk? Well, let's be honest. There's a lot about me that isn't exactly accurate. Like how I'm a big, scaly movie monster, when in reality, real velociraptors were the size of mini poodles and covered in feathers. I've got a bone to pick with you humans. And yes, I mean a femur. Delicious. You made me out to be the villain. But was I really? It was you who brought me back from my nice, peaceful extinction. It was you who stuck me on an island of slow, dimwitted meals. People. You knew I was a hunter. You knew. You even called me clever girl. This is on you. In the first movie, you made me out to be a baddie for hunting people in a kitchen. But if I wasn't supposed to eat them, what were they doing in the kitchen? It's the place for snacks. Plus, I have a very high metabolism, and I need to eat all the time. People think I'm terrifying, but I'm really just hangry. In conclusion, I was doing what I do best. Hunting and snacking. You humans are the one who should be apologizing to me now. Are you going to finish that? Oh. Oh, it's your arm. Oh. Oh. And it's still attached to you. Okay, well, fine. I guess sharing is another thing you humans are bad at.
Eleanor
Sharing is caring.
Molly Bloom
Exactly. All right, Tracy, now it's your turn. Show us why we shouldn't judge a ghoul by its cover.
Stay Puft Marshmallow Man
Hi. I'm a Stay Puft Marshmallow. And I'm so tall. But who doesn't love marshmallow? Just because I'm big and sometimes step on cars and buildings.
Molly Bloom
Oops.
Stay Puft Marshmallow Man
Marshmallow. So big. But inside, I. Soft, squishy. Not villain. I come to New York and want to say hi. But when I see people, I.
Molly Bloom
Oops.
Stay Puft Marshmallow Man
I am not big hungry reptile built to snack on you. I am snack. Just big snack. And I want to hug, but sometimes I crush.
Molly Bloom
Oops.
Stay Puft Marshmallow Man
Wait. Do not run away. We could make s'mores.
Molly Bloom
All right, Eleanor, what did you like about Tracy and Tom's micro rounds?
Eleanor
I thought the accents were awesome. And I think you both do a good job kind of explaining why they're so misunderstood.
Molly Bloom
It's tough. It's tough to be a villain, but.
Tracy Mumford
It'S soft to be a marshmallow.
Molly Bloom
All right, Eleanor, it is time to award a point to one of these misunderstood villains. The criteria is completely subjective and completely up to you. Did someone make you laugh? Did someone make you think? Did someone make you rethink? Have you made your decision?
Eleanor
Yes.
Molly Bloom
Fantastic. Then it's time for our third round. The super stealthy sneak attack. This is our improvised round where debaters have to respond to a challenge on the spot. Today's sneak attack is called Greeting card. Tom and Tracy, you have to write the message in a pretend greeting card. Based on your side. You have to write messages for three different holidays, but they can be any occasion you choose. A birthday, anniversary, Grandparents Day, whatever you want, as long as the message relates to your side. We'll volley back and forth for three rounds. Tom went first last time, so Tracy, you're up. Read me a Ghostbuster greeting card for an auspicious occasion.
Tracy Mumford
This one's a no brainer. Happy Halloween. Booyah. Why be normal when you can be paranormal?
Molly Bloom
Ugh. I'm gonna give that to all my friends this October. I can't wait. Okay, Dom, it is your turn. Give me a Jurassic park greeting card. Perfect for the holidays.
Tom Weber
Front cover. Get well soon. Inside cover. Sorry I ate your leg. Tommy T. Rex.
Molly Bloom
Very specific.
Tracy Mumford
Admitting to the dangers yet again.
Molly Bloom
All right, Tracy, let's hear your second greeting card.
Tracy Mumford
This is for Merry Bustin Day. It's a new holiday devoted to bustin people's problems. And you give someone that card when.
Molly Bloom
You feel like maybe they have a.
Tracy Mumford
Problem they could use your help with. Merry bustin day, September 9th.
Molly Bloom
Okay, Tom, what is your next greeting card?
Tom Weber
Outside cover. Happy Mother's Day to a great stegosaurus. Inside, Mom. Your back scales and tail spikes always protected me. Thanks for being awesome.
Molly Bloom
Aw, so beautiful. All right, Tracy, let's hear your final Ghostbusters greeting card.
Tracy Mumford
Happy birthday. You get even more birthdays when you're a ghost.
Molly Bloom
Infinite birthdays. Okay, Tom, let's hear your last Jurassic park greeting card.
Tom Weber
Happy Valentine's Day. May our Love be as strong as the pressure of a triceratops impaling.
Tracy Mumford
That is not romance, Tom.
Tom Weber
It's romantic romance.
Eleanor
Romance in the air.
Molly Bloom
All right, amazing. Incredible cards all around. I can't wait to buy them and hand them out to all my friends. But, Eleanor, only one of these teams can get a point for this round. Criteria are totally subjective. Totally up to you. Have you made your decision? Mm. Wonderful. Then it's time for our final round. The final six. In this round, each team will have just six words to sum up the glory of their side. Tom, let's hear your six words for Jurassic Park.
Tom Weber
J par. Inspired science, movies, and music.
Tracy Mumford
J.
Molly Bloom
Par.
Tom Weber
I had to have six words. I had to do Jay Par. That's one word.
Molly Bloom
Perfect. I love that. It's like J. Lo, but Jurassic Park.
Tom Weber
It's the next it girl.
Molly Bloom
It's what the cool kids call it.
Eleanor
The next it girl.
Molly Bloom
Yeah, exactly. All right, Tracy, it's your turn. Give us your six words for Ghostbusters.
Tracy Mumford
These are my six words. Da na na na na na. Six words.
Molly Bloom
Oh, Incredible. All right, two final sixes here to really make you think, but only one of them can get your final point. Eleanor, have you made your decisions?
Eleanor
Yes.
Molly Bloom
Wonderful. Are you ready to crown one team the smashboom best?
Eleanor
Uh, yeah.
Molly Bloom
All right, drumroll, please. And the winner is.
Eleanor
Jurassic Park.
Molly Bloom
Yay. Ooh, my goodness. Eleanor, what was your favorite part of the debate? Me too.
Eleanor
Um, I really liked the sneak attack. I thought the cards were super funny, and I always like a new holiday.
Tom Weber
So I having watched the original Ghostbusters movie, and it has been a minute, but it's been. It's seared. I never really realized that I didn't know the Stay Puft Marshmallow man until I heard Tracy's rendition, I guess we would say. And so I really feel a deeper connection to the movie and the franchise, and for that, Tracy, I'm grateful.
Tracy Mumford
Thank you, Tom. I just want to say dinosaurs are cool. I would go to Jurassic park on vacation when they got their safety record back where I need it to be. I'm not opposed to it. So happy to have you win. And maybe they can just, you know, work on their brochure and we can.
Eleanor
All go there once they get OSHA approved.
Tracy Mumford
Exactly. Once the lawsuits are settled, it's gonna be great.
Molly Bloom
It's gonna be so fun. Well, that's it for today's debate battle. Eleanor, crown team Jurassic park the smashboom best.
Tom Weber
But what about you?
Eleanor
Head to smashboom.org and vote to tell us who you think won Smash Boomvest.
Molly Bloom
Is brought to you by Brains on and APM Studios. It's produced by Anna Wegel and Aron Woldeselassi. We had engineering help from Alex Sibson with sound design by Aron Woldeslassi. Our editors are Shayla Farzan and Sandon Totten. And we had production help from the rest of the Brainzone universe team. Rosie Dupont, Rachel Breese, Anna Goldfield, Nico Gonzalez Whistler.
Eleanor
Ruby Guthrie.
Taylor Lincoln
Lauren.
Tom Weber
Lauren Humphurt, Jess Miller, Joshua Ray, Mark.
Molly Bloom
Sanchez and Charlotte Traver. Our executive producer is Beth Perlman and the APM Studios executives in charge are Chandra Kavati and Joanne Griffith. Our announcer is Marley Foyer worker Otto. And we want to give a special thanks to Austin Cross and Taylor Kaufman. Tracy, is there anyone you'd like to give a shout out to today?
Tracy Mumford
Just want to thank my cat, Gogo. She's always down to watch Ghostbusters, never complains. So the Gogo. This one was for you.
Molly Bloom
We love you, Gogo. And how about you, Tom? Any special shout outs to my parents.
Tom Weber
And anyone who bought me dinosaur books when I was a kid?
Molly Bloom
Beautiful. And how about you, Eleanor? Any special thanks or shout outs?
Eleanor
The kids on my block who are going to listen to this. Hi, Willa, Lenny and Elliot.
Molly Bloom
Yay. Before we go, let's check in and see who Gaelle thinks should win the Vikings vs Romans debate.
Eleanor
Vikings should win because the Vikings defeated the Romans.
Molly Bloom
If you're between the ages of 13 and 18 and you'd like to be a judge, or if you're any age and you have an idea for a knockdown drag out debate, head to smashboom.org contact and drop us a line. And make sure to subscribe to Brainstorm universe on YouTube where you can watch animated versions of some of your favorite episodes. We'll be back with an extra special Smashboom Best Debate Battle. Next week it's Jack and the Beanstalk versus the Ugly Duckling. Buh. Bye.
Eleanor
See ya, dinosaur.
Taylor Lincoln
Roar.
Tom Weber
Goodbye.
Tracy Mumford
Gonna go smash.
Podcast Title: Smash Boom Best: A Funny, Smart Debate Show for Kids and Family
Episode Title: Ghostbusters vs. Jurassic Park: a Cinematic Debate
Host: Molly Bloom
Debaters: Tracy Mumford (Team Ghostbusters) vs. Tom Weber (Team Jurassic Park)
Judge: Eleanor from St. Paul, Minnesota
Release Date: October 31, 2024
In a special Halloween episode, Smash Boom Best pits two iconic franchises against each other: Ghostbusters and Jurassic Park. Hosted by Molly Bloom, the debate features Tracy Mumford representing Ghostbusters and Tom Weber advocating for Jurassic Park. Eleanor, a passionate debater and judge from St. Paul, Minnesota, oversees the competition, bringing her expertise from high school and middle school debate leagues.
Tracy opens with an imaginative and humorous portrayal of why Ghostbusters should be the ultimate choice:
“Who you gonna call?” ([03:26])
She paints a vivid picture of the Ghostbusters’ adventurous spirits, stylish uniforms, and advanced proton packs. Tracy emphasizes the team’s camaraderie and resourcefulness, highlighting their iconic base in a converted firehouse and the legendary Ectomobile. She asserts that Ghostbusters combine science with fun, making them an unbeatable team in tackling the supernatural.
Tom counters with a passionate defense of Jurassic Park’s groundbreaking contributions to cinema and science:
“Jurassic Park wows us because we get to see the most epic creatures ever come to life.” ([21:09])
He underscores the franchise’s pioneering use of CGI, which revolutionized special effects in the film industry. Tom highlights Jurassic Park’s foundation in real scientific principles, such as DNA manipulation and genetic engineering, and its influence on inspiring a generation of paleontologists. He argues that Jurassic Park’s realistic portrayal of dinosaurs offers a more scientifically grounded and visually stunning experience compared to Ghostbusters.
Tom critiques Ghostbusters for lacking scientific explanations behind their ghost-catching technology and points out the franchise’s delayed inclusion of female Ghostbusters:
“The science of why the proton stuff actually catches ghosts was never actually fully explained, unlike the science in Jurassic Park.” ([08:40])
He raises concerns about representation and equality within the Ghostbusters universe, suggesting that the franchise has had issues addressing diversity in its characters.
Tracy responds by highlighting the chaotic and dangerous nature of Jurassic Park, contrasting it with the teamwork and reliability of Ghostbusters:
“It's a lot harder to form meaningful friendships with people when you're running for your lives from a T. Rex.” ([05:38])
She argues that while Jurassic Park may offer thrilling visuals, the constant life-threatening scenarios undermine the ability to build strong, cooperative relationships among its characters.
Tom adopts the persona of a velociraptor to humanize Jurassic Park’s dinosaurs, arguing that they are misunderstood creatures acting on instinct rather than inherent villainy:
“I'm really just hangry.” ([21:09])
He challenges the negative perception of dinosaurs by emphasizing their natural behaviors and pointing out that human intervention brought them back from extinction, which placed them in precarious situations.
Tracy channels the Stay Puft Marshmallow Man to present a softer side of Ghostbusters’ antagonists, portraying him as a gentle giant rather than a destructive force:
“I am snack. Just big snack. And I want to hug, but sometimes I crush.” ([22:50])
She argues that even the most formidable ghosts have nuanced personalities and that Ghostbusters work to understand and resolve supernatural issues peacefully.
Tracy crafts a playful and thematic greeting card message:
“Happy Halloween. Booyah. Why be normal when you can be paranormal?” ([26:17])
This message encapsulates the fun and adventurous spirit of Ghostbusters, aligning perfectly with the Halloween theme.
Tom delivers a humorous and species-specific greeting card:
“Get well soon. Sorry I ate your leg. Tommy T. Rex.” ([26:34])
He creatively incorporates the predatory nature of a T. Rex while adding a lighthearted twist, showcasing Jurassic Park’s blend of humor and excitement.
Tom succinctly summarizes Jurassic Park’s impact in six words:
“J par. Inspired science, movies, and music.” ([28:22])
Tracy opts for a catchy and iconic six-word phrase:
“Da na na na na na.” ([28:47])
This references the Ghostbusters theme song, emphasizing the franchise’s cultural resonance.
After each round, Judge Eleanor assigns points based on the strength and creativity of the arguments presented. Ultimately, Eleanor declares Jurassic Park as the winner of this cinematic debate.
“Jurassic Park.” ([29:17])
Eleanor appreciates Jurassic Park’s scientific foundations, groundbreaking special effects, and its lasting influence on both entertainment and education.
The episode wraps up with reflections from both debaters. Tom expresses a deeper connection to the Jurassic Park franchise, while Tracy commends dinosaurs as cool and expresses excitement about potential future visits to Jurassic Park once safety issues are resolved.
“Dinosaurs are cool. I would go to Jurassic Park on vacation when they got their safety record back where I need it to be.” ([30:13])
Eleanor encourages listeners to vote for their favorite team on the podcast’s website, smashboom.org, and hints at the next exciting debate: “Jack and the Beanstalk vs. the Ugly Duckling.”
“If you're between the ages of 13 and 18 and you'd like to be a judge, or if you're any age and you have an idea for a knockdown drag out debate, head to smashboom.org contact and drop us a line.” ([31:49])
The episode concludes with heartfelt shoutouts from the debaters and a teaser for future episodes, ensuring listeners remain engaged and eager for more debates.
This episode of Smash Boom Best effectively balances humor, creativity, and insightful arguments to engage listeners of all ages. By comparing two beloved franchises, the debate not only entertains but also educates its audience on the significance of both Ghostbusters and Jurassic Park in pop culture and beyond.