Smash Boom Best: Ice Age vs Jurassic (August 14, 2019)

Episode Overview

This episode of Smash Boom Best brings together two epic epochs in Earth's history for a family-friendly debate showdown: the Ice Age—home to gigantic mammals and early humans—versus the Jurassic period, the land of dinosaurs. Hosted by Molly Bloom, with guest judge Layla (a young debate aficionado), the episode features Lee Overtree championing the Ice Age and Peter McNerney arguing for the Jurassic. Through clever banter, creative segments, and rapid-fire arguments, the two debaters try to win over Layla—and the listeners—to crown their era as "Smash Boom Best."

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Setting the Stage (00:00–05:02)

• Introduction of Main Theme: Debate between the Ice Age and Jurassic, explained as eras packed with fascinating creatures and geological drama.

• Meet the Participants:

  • Host: Molly Bloom—keeps things moving and fun.
  • Judge: Layla—a seasoned youth debater ready for a “time traveling twister.”
  • Debaters: Lee Overtree (Team Ice Age) and Peter McNerney (Team Jurassic).

• Fun Opener Quotes:

  • Lee on his preference: “Jurassic. Cause dinosaurs are sick.” (00:41)
  • Layla: “I do really like dinosaurs, but also like saber toothed tigers, you know?” (01:29)
  • Layla on debate skills: “It's really good to like take notes. And you can also spread which is just speaking really quickly to get your point across.” (01:54)

Debate Format

• Declaration of Greatness: Each side presents facts and lore.
• Micro Round: Each tackles a creative challenge.
• Sneak Attack: An impromptu task.
• Final Six: Persuade using just six words.

2. Declaration of Greatness

The Ice Age—Lee Overtree (05:06–12:25)

• Ice Age Defined: The most recent ice age (the Pleistocene) was full of giant icy sheets and massive animals (“megafauna”).
• Key Creatures:
  • Glyptodon: “Imagine an armadillo that's up to 5ft tall, 10ft long, weighs as much as a car, and has a pretty cool, funny looking beard.” (07:25)
  • Mastodons & Mammoths: “Mastodons roamed... with tusks up to 16ft long. That’s more than two LeBron Jameses and like 40 Peters.” (08:00)
  • Dire wolf, Saber-toothed tiger (Smilodon), Giant sloths, apes, cheetahs.
• Significance for Humans:
  • “Modern Homo sapiens appeared in Africa somewhere around 200,000 years ago... the Ice Age helped humans move to new places. That's what we call teamwork.” (10:08)
• Fun Science Fact: “We are currently in the middle of an ice age right now... We just entered a warmer period... called an interglacial period.” (11:00)
• Climate Connection: “Humans are putting a lot more greenhouse gas into the atmosphere right now... If we don't do something soon, it's going to cause more intense, even dangerous weather.” (11:43)
• Notable Dialogue:
  • Lee: “If there’s one thing I know about ice, it’s that I love it.” (06:39)
  • “What’s cooler than cool? Well, as two great men once said, ice cold.” (02:54)
• Layla's Reaction: “It’s still relevant. It's still happening. Also, megafauna is such a cool word.” (12:31)

Jurassic—Peter McNerney (13:57–19:52)

• Jurassic Basics: Spanning from 200 to 145 million years ago; famous for dinosaurs and massive biodiversity.
• Dramatic Storytelling:
  • Hilariously describes the size of Brachiosaurus by stacking elephants, giraffes, and dolphins for scale.
  • Quote: “That’s about how big a Bronchiosaurus was back in the Jurassic era, because it was.” (18:33)
• Diverse Creatures:
  • Sauropods: Plant-eating giants; Brachiosaurus described in imaginative terms.
  • Allosaurus: “My arms might be tiny, but I've got a huge head equipped with dozens of sharp serrated teeth.” (18:46)
  • Stegosaurus: Tiny head, huge plates, spiked tail.
  • Ocean and Air: Liopleurodon, flying pterosaurs, and the first birds.
• Cultural Impact: “We still can't stop thinking about it, learning about it, making movies about it and doing podcasts about it.” (19:33)
• Layla's Reaction: Loved the playful metaphor making dino sizes relatable: “I really appreciated that example of how large the dinosaurs were with the elephants and giraffes and dolphins.” (19:59)

3. The Micro Round: Top of the Hour (24:55–31:00)

Challenge: Debaters present a breaking news broadcast from their respective eras.

Team Jurassic—Peter (25:31–27:53)

• Setting: Reporting live from the belly of an Allosaurus.
• Key Segments:
  • Interview with Stegosaurus about “friendly” battles with Allosaurus.
  • Stegosaurus: “In my prime, I could swing that thing so hard that it could send an Allosaurus to an early extinction.” (27:32)
  • Stegosaurus starts a book club inside the Allosaurus.
• Quote: Peter: “Reporting live from the proverbial end of the road, I'm Peter McNerney. Please send help.” (27:53)

Team Ice Age—Lee (28:28–30:55)

• Setting: Ice Age News Network (WICE), Pat Penguin reporting.
• Key Segments:
  • Teens at airport swooning over a celebrity... who’s a glacier.
  • Interview with glacier about size, speed ("Glaciers like me can move 50ft a day." (29:18)), and how glaciers create lakes.
  • Glaciers carve “huge holes in the earth. Those lakes are my little gift to you.” (30:13)
• Quote: “If it isn't cold, it's not cool.” (28:28)

Layla’s Reaction: “I have swam in the lakes that Ms. Glacier made. I feel so honored.” (31:05)

4. Sneak Attack: The Secret Handshake (31:40–36:49)

Challenge: Each debater improvises a secret handshake for their time period.

Team Ice Age—Lee (33:01–34:36)

• Four Steps:
  1. "Give them the cold shoulder" — pin ice between shoulders.
  2. "Keep a cool head" — pin ice between heads.
  3. "The freeze" — stand together until ice melts.
  4. "Break the ice" — together, swing an axe into a block of ice.
• Quote: “That’s called the cold shoulder... keep a cool head, everybody.” (33:10)

Team Jurassic—Peter (34:54–36:49)

• Four Steps:
  1. “Stomp, stomp”—approach and turn, dinosaurs style.
  2. “Double jaw snap”—clap hands together like dino jaws.
  3. “Tail swipe”—swing joined hands around and “smack tails.”
  4. “Reach for the sky”—hands up, slap above, “like two bronchiosauruses kissing each other good night.”
• Quote: “It's stomp, stomp, double jaw snap, tail swipe, reach for the sky.” (34:55)

5. The Final Six (37:10–37:43)

Each debater gets just six words to make their conclusive case.

• Peter (Jurassic): “There is nothing cooler than dinosaurs.” (37:29)
• Lee (Ice Age): “You literally cannot get any cooler.” (37:39)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Lee Overtree: “If there’s one thing I know about ice, it’s that I love it.” (06:39)
• Peter McNerney: “Dinosaurs, baby. Has there ever been a creature more amazing, more captivating than the dinosaur? Scary, scarier, cooler. Name one. I dare you.” (03:32)
• Layla: “Megafauna is such a cool word.” (12:31)
• Lee’s Ice Age Reveal: “We are currently in the middle of an ice age right now... We just entered a warmer period of that Ice Age.” (11:01)
• Peter’s Size Explanation: “That’s about how big a Bronchiosaurus was... and that’s just one of the cool creatures around.” (18:33)
• Lee’s Rapid Rebuttal Rap: “Anything born from an egg, I don't trust. What's better than a lizard? ... megafauna.” (20:16)
• Layla’s Judging Rationale: “It's still relevant. It's still happening.” (12:31)
• Final Decision: “While it was a very difficult debate... I had to go with the Ice Age.” (38:02)
• Lee’s Closing Rap: “This age is so cold. Good luck trying to melt it. Dinosaurs fart. I know cause I smelt it.” (42:11)

Timestamps for Key Segments

| Timestamp | Segment / Topic | |------------------|----------------------------------------------------| | 00:00–05:02 | Introduction, Meet the Participants, Debate Format | | 05:06–12:25 | Declaration of Greatness: Ice Age (Lee) | | 12:52–13:57 | Jurassic’s Rebuttal (Peter) + Layla’s Response | | 13:57–19:52 | Declaration of Greatness: Jurassic (Peter) | | 20:08–20:45 | Ice Age’s Rebuttal Rap (Lee) | | 24:55–31:00 | Micro Round—Top of the Hour News Broadcasts | | 31:40–36:49 | Sneak Attack—Secret Handshake | | 37:10–37:43 | The Final Six—Six Word Summations | | 38:02–40:00 | Judge’s Decision, Reflections, Goodbyes | | 41:59–42:09 | Lee’s Closing Rap (Bonus) |

Final Decision & Reflections (38:02–40:00)

• Judge Layla sided with the Ice Age, citing the abundance of puns, ongoing relevance, and fondness for glaciers.
• Layla: “I felt it in my heart.”
• She also praised Peter’s size comparisons and fun with dinosaur names.
• Concluding camaraderie: Both debaters complimented each other’s research and creativity, with Lee’s rap and puns being a tipping point.

Summary Table: Strengths of Each Side

| The Ice Age (Lee) | The Jurassic (Peter) | |---------------------------------|------------------------------------| | Still relevant; ongoing today | Dinosaurs: Most captivating creatures ever | | Epic mammals (megafauna) | Incredible diversity—sea, air, land| | Helped human migration | Giant size made relatable/fun | | Lakes and land shaped by glaciers | Inspired countless movies and imagination | | Clever climate science & puns | Vibrant metaphorical storytelling | | Audience engagement (rap/puns) | Hilarious, accessible explanations |

In Conclusion

This fun, fact-filled, and pun-heavy episode showcases not just the wild creatures and climatic drama of two fascinating time periods, but how playful debate and kid-friendly logic can make “which is cooler?” a genuinely tough call. In the end, the Ice Age slides away with the win, but the Jurassic leaves a lasting roar.

Want more? Cast your vote and discover more epic debates at smashboom.org.