Smosh Mouth Podcast
Episode #95 - Try Not To Laugh: The Podcast w/ Chance McCrary
Release Date: May 26, 2025
Hosts: Shayne Topp, Amanda Lehan-Canto
Guest: Chance McCrary

Introduction

In the 95th episode of Smosh Mouth, hosts Shayne Topp and Amanda Lehan-Canto welcome special guest Chance McCrary for a rib-tickling session of "Try Not To Laugh." The episode promises a blend of humorous challenges, candid conversations, and playful banter, setting the stage for an engaging and laughter-filled listen.

Setting the Stage: Try Not To Laugh Challenge

[01:00 - 02:00]
Shayne introduces the "Try Not To Laugh" challenge with Chance. The rules are simple: engage in regular conversation, crack jokes, and keep the humor flowing without laughing. The winner will receive a Chili's gift card, a choice made by Chance himself.

Notable Quote:
Shayne (01:07): "The rules are you just don't laugh. Don’t. But we can have normal conversation. We can talk about whatever we want."

First Laughs and Early Challenges

[02:00 - 05:00]
The trio dives into casual topics, but laughter begins to surface quickly. Amanda jokes about Chance canning bears, leading to Shayne’s first crack at [05:42].

Notable Quote:
Shayne (05:49): "And you cracked. I'm in the lead now. This is awesome."

Chance's Ex-Centric "Hit List"

[11:00 - 37:00]
Chance reveals his meticulous "hit list"—a compilation of every man he's ever hooked up with, complete with photos and names. This segues into a daring segment where Chance decides to make prank calls to his exes, adding a layer of excitement and comedy to the challenge.

Notable Quotes:
Chance (09:02): "It's called the hit list. It has pictures. You can blur this out, but it has pictures of every single one."
Amanda (13:07): "This was a sexual experience for me."

Prank Calls to Exes: Hilarity Ensues

[30:00 - 37:00]
Chance executes his plan by calling various exes, including a memorable call to Dylan at the Cheesecake Factory. The awkwardness and Chance’s earnest attempts to reconnect lead to uncontrollable laughter from Amanda and Shayne, testing their composure against the challenge’s premise.

Notable Quote:
Amanda (12:54): "You crumbled. I'm in the lead now. This is awesome."
Chance (30:39): "Hey, it's Chance. Sup? Hey, I was just... my birthday's coming up..."

The Dune Yell: An Attempt at Classic Humor

[14:00 - 19:00]
Shayne suggests resurrecting the classic "Dune yell," leading to both Shayne and Amanda attempting the yell in unison. Their off-key and exaggerated performances result in bursts of laughter, further intensifying the challenge.

Notable Quote:
Shayne (17:28): "Someone had to get into the recording booth and do that."

Social Anxieties and Relatable Mishaps

[02:00 - 07:00]
Chance shares a relatable Uber story where he felt socially anxious about requesting the driver to change the air direction, sparking a discussion on social interactions and personal discomforts.

Notable Quote:
Chance (02:00): "I don’t like talking to the Uber drivers. So I was like, um, could you turn the air a different direction?"

Pop Culture and Celebrity Chats

[22:30 - 44:00]
The conversation shifts towards the new Pope and various pop culture topics, including discussions about "The Matrix" movies. The hosts playfully debate character names and plot points, weaving humor into their musings on current events and beloved franchises.

Notable Quote:
Shayne (24:15): "He’s from Chicago. We didn’t know who the Pope was going to be until he was chosen. It could have been one of us."

Football Fantasy and Humorous Debates

[53:00 - 58:30]
Shayne and Amanda engage in a spirited debate about football quarterbacks, specifically focusing on Justin Herbert. Their playful disagreements and creative takes on fantasy scenarios, like a gorilla on the football field, add a layer of comedic tension to the episode.

Notable Quote:
Shayne (54:00): "I think the gorilla can make it to the end zone past 100 hundred men."
Amanda (57:45): "He can’t chop wood, but he’s sweet looking."

Conclusion: Determining the Winner

[61:00 - 62:30]
As the episode draws to a close, Amanda emerges victorious in the "Try Not To Laugh" challenge, having laughed 22 times compared to Chance’s fewer counts. In a lighthearted finale, Chance is awarded a turtle cheesecake as his prize, capping off the episode with sweet humor.

Notable Quote:
Shayne (62:02): "We're getting you that turtle cheesecake."

Key Highlights and Insights

• Camaraderie and Chemistry: The dynamic between Shayne, Amanda, and Chance showcases their strong chemistry, enhancing the comedic flow and making conversations effortlessly entertaining.

• Relatable Humor: Topics like awkward social interactions in Uber rides and the challenges of phone conversations resonate with listeners, adding a layer of relatability to the humor.

• Engaging Challenges: The "Try Not To Laugh" format, combined with unique segments like prank calls to exes, keeps the episode lively and unpredictable.

• Pop Culture Integration: Seamlessly incorporating discussions about current events and beloved franchises like "The Matrix" keeps the content fresh and engaging for a diverse audience.

Final Thoughts

Episode #95 of Smosh Mouth is a masterclass in blending structured comedic challenges with spontaneous, heartfelt conversations. Shayne, Amanda, and Chance navigate through laugh-out-loud moments, personal anecdotes, and pop culture references, creating an episode that's both entertaining and relatable. Whether you're a long-time listener or a newcomer, this episode delivers laughter and engaging content in equal measure.