
Loading summary
Sponsor/Ad Voice
Sometimes you just want a good story. On TikTok you'll find short dramas emotional, fast and impossible to stop watching. Download TikTok now.
Shane
This podcast is sponsored by Talkspace. Last year, I went through many different life changes. I needed to take a pause and examine how I was feeling in the inside to better show up for the ones who need me to be my best version of myself. When you're navigating life's changes, Talkspace can help. Talkspace is the number one rated online therapy, bringing you professional support from licensed therapists and psychiatry providers that you can access anytime, anywhere. Living a busy life, navigating a long distance relationship, becoming a first stepfather. Talkspace made all of those journeys possible. I could speak with my therapist in the office. I could speak to my therapist in the comfort of my home. I was never alone. I Talkspace works with most major insurers and most insured members have a $0 copay. No insurance, no problem. Now get $80 off your first month with promo code space80 when you go to talkspace.com match with a licensed therapist today at talkspace.com save $80 with code space80@talkspace.com hello and welcome to Smosh Reads Reddit Stories. I'm Shane and today's episode is a classic Am I the asshole Episode. However, we have a very special guest joining us here today. We have jacksepticeye on the couch.
Jacksepticeye
Wow, that was so cool to watch you do that.
Shane
Yeah. And we also have Trevor, who wore the same outfit as me.
Trevor
Well, actually I had it on first. Also, my collar's pop, so it's like basically we're not.
Jacksepticeye
He's wearing your top of my jeep.
Shane
I watched you put it on.
Trevor
That's not even true.
Jacksepticeye
You can't prove that I was dare.
Shane
Thanks for being here.
Jacksepticeye
Thank you. I'm so excited. Woo.
Shane
So cool. Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Let's judge some people.
Shane
For people watching today, we've been filming tons of videos. You've been in everything.
Jacksepticeye
Yes.
Shane
You filmed a Try not to laugh. You filmed some games videos. We did jackbox.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah.
Shane
And now you're here.
Jacksepticeye
First rated story. First try not to laugh.
Shane
Whoa.
Jacksepticeye
This is big for me.
Trevor
This is my third video with Sean today.
Shane
Dude, insane. You guys are like, we're getting married. I think we should kiss. Yeah. That's how you definitely get the smosh. Egot.
Jacksepticeye
Am I the asshole for thinking Trevor should kiss me today?
Shane
And you've watched plenty of clips from this show, right? Yes.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah, I think a lot of these are very. I was so happy when you read Poop Knife?
Shane
That's. Yeah, finally got that one. Are you much of a Redditor?
Jacksepticeye
Oh, gosh.
Trevor
Answer carefully.
Jacksepticeye
It's like, do I say no or do I say yes and be cringe?
Shane
It's damned if you do, damned if you don't.
Jacksepticeye
I go on Reddit for like gaming stuff.
Shane
Sure.
Jacksepticeye
So it's like gaming news and whatever and stuff always ends up there first. Yeah. And like leaks and whatever. So I'm on there a lot more than I think I would like to be.
Shane
Okay. Trevor.
Jacksepticeye
Trevor, what do you think?
Shane
How are you?
Trevor
No, I feel like you guys did it really well. I didn't think that I needed to add anything else.
Jacksepticeye
Are you a Redditor?
Trevor
Oh no.
Shane
Oh God no.
Trevor
And I don't even mean. I just don't. I don't go on Reddit. If I do, it's because I'm trying to look something up and figure something out. It's always like a medical question or something.
Jacksepticeye
Honestly, I think that's probably how I'm on Reddit most as well.
Trevor
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Am I dying Reddit?
Trevor
Yeah. Or something like a game. I'm like, how do I do this thing? But no, I don't like scroll on Reddit. I'm not lurk in any subreddits or anything.
Shane
That's true.
Jacksepticeye
I don't have a subreddit. I go to. What's your Reddit rap like?
Shane
Not much. I do sometimes go on and I get caught up in an am I the asshole? Story. But I'm reading it and then I'm like, wait, I shouldn't do this. Yeah, save it for the sage. This is work I don't need.
Jacksepticeye
Can't bring work home.
Shane
Yeah, yeah, no, I'll solve this later.
Jacksepticeye
Did you get some good stuff for us today?
Shane
I think so. Okay. I haven't read them, but I'm about to. Okay, read it.
Trevor
I sure hope he did.
Shane
Nice.
Jacksepticeye
Don't give him that.
Shane
Sick. Okay, let's hop into these stories. Our first story comes from Am I the Asshole? Posted in November of 2025. Would I be the asshole for refusing to bring $100 minimum to Thanksgiving? Okay, let's see what's going on here. Okay. My family and I celebrate Thanksgiving every year with my siblings, parents and their kids. We roughly 20 to 25 people, including kids. My family is only two people with one six month old baby. In the group chat, it was decided that my nephew would cook meat since he bought a grill. He also told us that we could bring the sides. He chose to spend $300 on meat. I messaged in the group chat that we could bring mashed potatoes. My sister responded that every family has to bring $100 worth of food minimum, or help my nephew pay for the meat. I'm not totally against the idea of bringing that much food, but just the way it was presented and the fact that it wasn't agreed to beforehand makes me upset. The following day in the group chat, my sister said, Option one, bring food enough for everyone, not just yourself. Option two, help Thomas pay for meat $100 family. Option three, help dad pay water bill, $200 a family. Choose wisely upset. I responded with option four, don't show up. Am I being an asshole if I don't show up at all in protest to this $100 minimum rule? What the.
Trevor
That's insane. You wanna come over for Thanksgiving and. God, could you just like chip in a little for the water bill?
Shane
Yeah. And also you have to pay my rent. Yeah, yeah.
Jacksepticeye
We're looking to get an extension on the house and like, really use the money.
Shane
Pay off my house? Yeah. This is just absurd.
Jacksepticeye
I think it's always weird when money enters family shit like that.
Shane
Oh, yeah, it's messy.
Trevor
I think it's like very. If you're like, hey, I'd love to like cook all the food for Thanksgiving, like, if you could just like chip in like 20 bucks or something, like, just be buying everything. Like, especially if you're like younger, you know, or whatever. But asking someone being like, hey, I chose to buy $300 of meat, so can you just. Can you just reimburse me for that?
Jacksepticeye
I bought $300 of meat and I can't afford it. So.
Shane
Yeah, yeah. To be clear, what the family is asking for is that between the two of them and their six month old, they're asking them to spend like a $50 meal. It's like, hey, you could just go to a really nice restaurant instead of going to the family dinner.
Jacksepticeye
Is it a thing at Thanksgiving? Because I don't celebrate it that like you bring a piece of people bring
Shane
like, yeah, you bring like your own dish. Like, it's like they would bring mashed potatoes. Someone else brings green beans. And 20 to 25 people. If everybody brought like a couple sides, which is not. Doesn't have to be a hundred dollars.
Jacksepticeye
No, that's what I'm thinking.
Shane
It would be plenty food.
Trevor
That's what I'm also wondering is, like, when you say like $100, like $100 of mashed potatoes is like enough to fill this room.
Shane
Yeah.
Trevor
Like, potatoes are like all that's in mashed potatoes is like potatoes and milk and butter.
Shane
It's like, that's a lot of potatoes. It's a lot of potatoes.
Jacksepticeye
It's weird to be like, bring money instead of just being like, bring outside.
Shane
How do you quantify that too? It's like, are they checking? It's like, did you spend $100 on the food?
Jacksepticeye
Show me the receipt.
Shane
Yeah.
Trevor
Bring me the receipt from your house.
Shane
Yeah. And they also the option to bring enough food for everyone, not just yourself. It's like, if everyone brings enough food for everyone. This house is overloaded with food.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. You have excess.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
It's like, I bought $300 worth of meat and it's like 8 ounces of wagyu.
Shane
Yeah. Also, to be clear, if all the families help pay the water bill. $200 a family. How much is that water bill? That's a thousand dollar water bill.
Jacksepticeye
How much water?
Shane
Way more. Dad's like, well, I'm always in the shower.
Jacksepticeye
We filled the kiddie pool. We thought it would be fun. We really wanted to have Thanksgiving.
Shane
The verdict was not the asshole poo mode. Like, so extremely poo mode. Yeah. It's when it's just. It's voted into oblivion. It's just like, everyone's like, my God,
Jacksepticeye
is that what it's called? I haven't read it.
Shane
It's rare. It's rare poo mode. Comments? Not the asshole. This is a potluck, not a charity dinner. If your nephew couldn't afford to buy the meat, he shouldn't have bought it. 15,000 upvotes. Someone said the math isn't mathing. $300 divided amongst 20 to 25 people is not $100 per family. Someone said the math isn't mathing and just basic communication isn't communicating. This whole situation is a complete zoo. Someone said, how did the water bill become part of the discussion? I'm wondering, does son live with the sister and is it her running this Thanksgiving grift? Rather than saying we can't afford to pay our bills, Someone said, don't forget petty option number five. Buy $100 worth of mashed potato ingredients and show up with 50 pounds of mashed potatoes. Not the asshole. $100 worth of sides is obscene and far too much food. Someone said, choose wisely would have me staying home enjoying the peace and quiet of my living room for free. Not the asshole. We have a small little update. Ooh, it happened.
Jacksepticeye
My first update.
Shane
Your first update.
Jacksepticeye
Oh, My God. Can you make a bigger deal out of this, please?
Shane
It's just such a small one. Do you want me to make a big deal out of it, though?
Jacksepticeye
If you could.
Shane
Okay. Okay, okay, okay, okay. All right. And then. Oh, it seems here we have Update. Oh, my God. He said it. Oh, my God. Oh, my God.
Jacksepticeye
The pool was made out of mashed potatoes.
Shane
Oh, my God. They killed the father. Oh, that's what I would do, I think.
Trevor
Not that they filled the kiddie pool
Shane
and drowned him in it. With mashed potatoes. With mashed potatoes. They filled him with mashed potatoes and killed him in it.
Jacksepticeye
Oh, this is sick.
Shane
Okay, update. I'm a teacher and she posted a picture of my salary she found online to shame me in the group chat. Definitely not going now. Ooh. Whoa. This family's awful.
Trevor
She said you can't pay our water bill.
Shane
Broke.
Jacksepticeye
Like, what?
Shane
What a nightmare.
Jacksepticeye
This you?
Shane
Yeah. Jesus. All right. Yeah, don't go. And probably don't show up to any family function.
Jacksepticeye
This is the thing about Thanksgiving, right? Where you're kind of like the meme is that, oh, I gotta go see my family. It's always tumultu. If you're adding that shit on top of it. I'm like, I'm staying home with my $100 and getting dinner.
Shane
If the shit like that is happening before you even show up, it's gonna be so bad. Holy God. There's no Thanksgiving equivalent.
Jacksepticeye
No. Even Spencer was messaging me and he was like, got time off. He's like, what do you guys do during Thanksgiving? And I'm like, it's Thursday.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
It's literally just another day. We have nothing.
Shane
But I guess still I think it's the same for Christmas. Like families get together and do have dinner.
Jacksepticeye
To me, Thanksgiving feels like first Christmas.
Shane
That is what it is. It's kind of feels the same.
Jacksepticeye
The gathering feels the same.
Trevor
It's like a warm up. Warm up Christmas.
Shane
It truly is.
Trevor
Practice your recipes.
Jacksepticeye
I mean, that's about as close as we would get. Is Christmas.
Shane
Yeah. Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
It's like, if I wanted to see my family, I would. I'm not going. Yeah, don't need another excuse to avoid you.
Sponsor/Ad Voice
So you're running out of closet space. The good news, you don't need to stop shopping. You just need to start selling with the RealReal. The RealReal is the world's largest and most trusted resource for authenticated luxury resale. Whether it's that mini bag that can't even fit your phone or those boots you never fully broke in. The RealReal handles everything from photography and copywriting to shipping and pricing. So you can just sit back, get paid, and make room for things that actually feel like you. And with 10,000 new arrivals every single day from top designers like Prada, Celine, Louis Vuitton and Loewe, all for up to 90% off retail, you're bound to find something perfectly on brand to fill that extra closet space with. Plus, right now you can get an extra $100 to shop when you sell for the first time. Make room for what feels like you go to therealreal.com to start selling and get your extra $100 to keep shopping@therealreal.com that's therealreal.com terms apply.
Shane
Reggie, I just sold my car online. Let's go Grandpa.
Jacksepticeye
Wait, you did?
Shane
Yep, on Carvana. Just put in the license plate, answered a few questions, got an offer in minutes. Easier than setting up that new digital picture frame.
Jacksepticeye
You don't say.
Shane
Yeah, they're even picking it up tomorrow. Talk about fast.
Jacksepticeye
Wow. Way to go.
Shane
So about that picture frame. Ah, forget about it. Until Carvana makes one, I'm not interested.
Sponsor/Ad Voice
Car selling made easy on Carvana. Pickup fees may apply.
Shane
This episode of Reddit Stories is sponsored by zocdoc. Is there a doctor in the house? Anyone? No, there isn't. Which is why I use ZocDoc. I can find someone who is a doctor who is located nearby so I don't have to depend on my film crew to answer questions like should I be concerned about this rash? Anyways, ZocDoc is a free app and website that helps you find and book high quality in network doctors so you can find someone you love. What's cool about ZocDoc is that I never have to leave the Reddit set. I can do a video visit right here and you can see the doctor's realtor availability and click to book instantly. No phone tag, no waiting around. Whether you're looking for dermatology, dentistry, primary care, eye care, or one of the other 200 plus specialties, you can find them on Zocdoc. I've said it many times. I was pushing off my doctor's appointments for years until I downloaded ZocDoc and it was simply too easy to push them off anymore. I had an appointment set up within days. Stop putting off those doctor's appointments and go to Zocdoc.com PitReddit to find and instantly book a doctor you love today. That's z zocdoc.com PittReddit Thanks, Zocdoc, for sponsoring this message. Now back to the show. All right, our next story. This comes from Am I the asshole? This is posted November 2025am I the asshole for expressing my surprise that my fiance didn't know who Muhammad Ali was? That's.
Jacksepticeye
This is a sentence that's never been
Shane
spoken expressing my surprise. All I did was express my surprise,
Jacksepticeye
you dumb fucking idiot. How do you not know who Muhammad
Shane
Ali is, you dumbass.
Jacksepticeye
He died for our sins.
Shane
God. Hi. The other day my fiance and I were watching baseball and the infographic and commentary were showing some stats of Babe Ruth. So I told her she doesn't really watch that much baseball, that Babe Ruth was like the Muhammad Ali of baseball. She asked me who Muhammad Ali was and I said, you know Muhammad Ali. She was still confused and I realized she didn't know who Muhammad Ali was. So I said, how do you not know who Muhammad Ali is? And I told her about him. I noticed she was quiet afterwards, so I asked if she was good. And she said she was hurt at the way I had been surprised at her not knowing who Muhammad Ali was. If I have to keep saying that phrase. I said, he wasn't just a boxer, he was a cultural icon. So it just took me by surprise that she didn't know who he was. Then yesterday she came across something on her Instagram and was showing it to me. It was about Timothee Chalamet and Kylie Jenner. She asked me what I thought about her and I said, I actually don't know a lot about her. I know of her, but not why she's famous. She then feigned surprise and was like, you don't know who Kylie Jenner is? I realized she was still hurt over the Muhammad Ali thing. So I didn't say anything. I didn't point out that it wasn't really the same thing. Kylie Jenner wasn't an icon the way Muhammad Ali was, and I had heard of her anyway. But she seems still to be hurt by what I said. Was I the asshole? Edit going to put some of my replies here? A lot of people are asking about our ages. I'm 29, she's 27. And as for how I reacted in the moment. So when the infographic popped up, I said, babe Ruth is like the Muhammad Ali of baseball. She said, who's Muhammad Ali? I honestly thought maybe she knew multiple important Muhammad Ali's. So I said, you know Muhammad Ali? And she still didn't recognize him. And again said, muhammad Ali who? And then I Just said in a regular tone, how do you not know who Muhammad Ali is? She said, why would I know of some Muhammad Ali? And then I was stunned for a couple seconds. Maybe that showed on my face. And then I went over who he was.
Trevor
Oh, I just, I fear that this is giving. Like I don't trust men on Reddit to accurately represent the way that they said something because I just can't believe in my heart that if it actually happened that way that she would have been upset.
Jacksepticeye
You dumb fucking idiot.
Trevor
I have to believe it's something like, you don't know who Muhammad Ali is. Like, you don't know who Muhammad. Like, what do you mean?
Jacksepticeye
Shadow boxing?
Trevor
Yeah.
Shane
It's such a bummer when people do that, right? Like it does hurt. Even if you're like, you know, I should know who or what.
Jacksepticeye
For a movie, it's like, you haven't
Shane
seen Monsters Inc. And it happens all the time.
Trevor
Yeah. Feeling like being like, oh, like making you feel like dumb or something.
Jacksepticeye
Like you don't know Kylie Jenner, the Muhammad Ali of the Kardashians.
Shane
Come on. That time she just knocked out Kim. Incredible. I think there's like, he's absolutely right in that. Muhammad Ali is like this huge, big icon. There's also a lot of icons in history and it's okay that someone doesn't know one of them. I just think it's like, especially if it's an interest, it's always an opportunity to be like, oh, let me tell you about this awesome person. It's cool that I get to tell you about this. Yeah.
Trevor
Especially like, I think it's very reasonable for a 27 year old woman to not know. If you're not very into sports, that is completely understandable.
Shane
I don't think it's out of this world. Like it's very much. Especially nowadays with the way the Internet is so algorithmic where you kind of get served your interests over and over again. It actually makes more sense nowadays. It's like, yeah, you probably don't know because is it not in your field of interest then? Yeah, you probably. The Internet never shows it to you.
Jacksepticeye
I think growing up as like a 30 plus year old, it's like Muhammad Ali is like everywhere. Even if you don't know who he is, that name is just synonymous with everything. But I feel like now it's come full circle where it's not anymore. Yeah, I mean it's kind of left pop culture.
Trevor
I'm 26 and I'm like, yeah, there are plenty of people I know probably that don't know who Muhammad Ali is. Like, that's fine. You could have just. He could have just said LeBron.
Jacksepticeye
I feel like more people don't know who Babe Ruth is.
Shane
It's also possible. I think it's possible for a lot of people not to know. Besides, like, that. It's the candy bar.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah.
Shane
And a lot of them, like, people don't know. Like, they don't know anything about the person. They just know of the name.
Trevor
The name.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. Right. It's like, you hear about Martin Luther King or Gandhi. It's like, I don't know anything about Gandhi. I just know the name.
Shane
Right.
Jacksepticeye
He sounds like a chill dude.
Trevor
He sounds pretty.
Shane
I just think what we're dealing with here is he made her feel stupid, Right. He's just like, you don't know this. It's insane. You don't know this thing. And that's gonna make a person feel insecure. And so now she's, like, doing this.
Jacksepticeye
The gloves are up.
Shane
Like, Mohammed Truly. Who's your Truly?
Jacksepticeye
Babe Ruth of boxing.
Trevor
Oh, thank you.
Jacksepticeye
The Kylie Jenner of boxing.
Trevor
The Kylie Jenner of boxing.
Shane
For someone who knows of him, it's like, oh, he's such a legend. Cause not only was he such a legendary boxer, but he also opposed the Vietnam War and was very much like a vocal person in a time where that was pretty extreme.
Jacksepticeye
I honestly didn't know that.
Shane
Yeah, no. He was extremely vocal on so many things that even by today's standards, you'd be like, whoa. So he really was truly, like, a legendary figure. So for people who know him, I get the feeling of, like, whoa, you don't know who this guy is? But. But she's 27. In an era where the Internet is so different. I think it's. I'm like, yeah. And she's not sitting here going, what is he, some dumbass? She's like, no, I don't know. But she's open to hearing about it.
Jacksepticeye
It's always like, a teaching moment to be like, yes, but please tell me.
Shane
Yeah, I think for a lot of people, it's like, they know he's a boxer. That's it. I think there's a lot of people. It's like, do you know who Lucille Ball is? Do you know who Carol Burnett is? Like, I think her field could probably have a lot of. There's a lot of people out there that.
Jacksepticeye
It's like, start making that Venn diagram.
Shane
Yeah. Especially when you're talking about people who were really legendary back in the 60s, 70s.
Trevor
Like, I love basketball. I could name, like, every player on, like, the Showtime Lakers. But, like, yeah, I. I know who Muhammad Ali is, but I don't.
Shane
I don't.
Trevor
Yeah, that's not really a flex.
Shane
Oh, no, it's not really a flex. And Sean loves Dr. J. So, you know.
Trevor
Yeah.
Shane
But anyways, Dr. J, I have no
Jacksepticeye
idea who that is.
Shane
Mm.
Trevor
Julie serving.
Jacksepticeye
Ooh, basketball.
Shane
That's the one. We have some comments. There was really no verdict. The verdict overall was no assholes here. But a lot of comments are all over the spectrum. I think this is like a very mild, am I the asshole? Right.
Jacksepticeye
I feel like this is one of the more relatable ones where everyone has someone who's done this to them.
Shane
I think this is a very accurate use of this subreddit. Right. Cause sometimes it gets so extreme where it's like, you need to talk to your friends and family.
Jacksepticeye
I shot my husband. Am I the asshole?
Shane
It's like, hey, but this one's a really perfect one. Cause it's one of those where it's like, yeah, I can see what's going on here. But we have some comments. Someone said, this just makes me think of the XKCD comic, where there are two ways to handle someone not knowing a specific reference. You could be an ass and say, how can you not know about this? Everyone knows about it. Or you could go in with genuine excitement and go, you don't know about this thing. Let me share with you how awesome this is. How did you go about it? And we don't know. Someone said, this sounds like no one's the asshole, honestly. Just that you're both being kind of obtuse and you'd better communicate a little better or you're going to end up on the rocks. I realized she didn't know who Muhammad Ali was. So I said, how do you not know who Muhammad Ali is? Tone matters a lot. Even if you don't think your tone was insulting, half of it is how it's taken. You should probably have a quiet conversation and just genuinely apologize because she's clearly hurt. It's not as hard as it sounds to just say, hey, I'm really sorry. I should have been more thoughtful the other day, so it didn't seem like I was talking down to you. I promise I wasn't, but I'm sorry I was careless about it. Lastly, someone said, the way this is worded, it seems like you think you're better than or smarter than your girlfriend. I'm sure that's what she's picking up on. You're the asshole. I think much is to be. I think it's true. Tone kind of shifts this in a bunch of different directions.
Jacksepticeye
I think Reddit armchair therapist always comes out in these scenarios where they're like, if I was in this scenario, I would have reacted this way. And you always kind of pick a side.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
I think the way it's worded shows sort of a pattern. Like why somebody reacted the way they do is probably because this has happened numerous times where they're kind of like at their wick's end where they're like, dude, why do you always react this way? Like, just tell me.
Shane
Right.
Jacksepticeye
You don't have to be an asshole about it.
Shane
Yeah.
Trevor
I think that there's a very. I think there's a very great lesson in this of just like, hey, even if you didn't intend something in a certain way, like your partner, if they take it in a way and it makes them feel something, it's like they're feeling that, like, you can change that. Like, even if it wasn't your intention.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah.
Trevor
It's like, just be like, hey, I really didn't mean it to come across like that. I'm really sorry I made you feel that way.
Shane
Right.
Trevor
And this is probably the best situation to learn that lesson in something very low stakes to be like, oh, I can have a takeaway from that.
Jacksepticeye
Communication is key in every single relationship.
Shane
I think it's important in a relationship to clock too, when it's like, oh, are we in a battle of who wins right now? Like, who wins and who loses? As opposed to just like, oh, wait, you feel hurt. I said something that you were hurt by. Let's figure that out.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. Which usually, I mean, any of the people I've met, not like partners, but any friends who are like, you don't know who this is. It's a chance for them to feel superior.
Shane
Totally.
Jacksepticeye
And I think that's where the dangerous side effects come in, where no one's right. You just don't know a thing.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Not knowing a thing doesn't make you stupid. Not knowing something and not always wanting to know something. Like, I don't know.
Shane
There's too much shit.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah, yeah.
Shane
There's simply too much shit.
Trevor
Let's start doing it with random people that nobody would know. You don't know my buddy Eric.
Shane
What, dude? You don't know Steve? That's crazy.
Trevor
What do you mean, dude, are you fucking stupid?
Jacksepticeye
You don't know how to get to that right? What the fuck is wrong with you?
Shane
Random pivot. You said they're at their wick's end. And I realize I feel like I've heard wit's end.
Jacksepticeye
I think, yeah, I've heard both my
Shane
whole life, but wick's end makes way more sense.
Jacksepticeye
I think I've actually. At the end of their wick and at their wit's end, I think I mixed them.
Shane
But at the wick's end makes sense. Cause it's about to explode.
Jacksepticeye
There's nothing left to burn.
Shane
Dynamite's about to blow up.
Trevor
I was thinking like a candle.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. You went explosive.
Trevor
Explosive is crazy.
Jacksepticeye
You went like. Well, yeah.
Shane
Cause when people are at their wicks end, they're gonna explode. Cause not just die out.
Jacksepticeye
And just dynamite has a fuse. It doesn't have a wick.
Trevor
Ooh, Got ya. Checkmate.
Jacksepticeye
Am I the asshole for calling out Shane on a Reddit story? Oh, vocab Shane.
Shane
He hit me. He smacked me.
Jacksepticeye
Update.
Shane
And the shot of me above him
Jacksepticeye
like, here's your thumbnail. I found out that those things I think are called eggcorns, that the term is called that. Cause some people think acorns are called eggcorns. So it's when you mix up words like that and say it a different way, it's called an eggcorn.
Shane
I hope to God someday to meet someone who calls it an eggcorn so I can be like, did you just say eggcorn? You're gonna have a Reddit? Do you not know acorn, dumbass.
Jacksepticeye
You're gonna have a Reddit story written about you.
Shane
This guy's never seen an oak tree.
Jacksepticeye
I met a guy on the street who just started hitting me for no.
Shane
Yeah, Shane beat me up.
Jacksepticeye
Am I the asshole for getting my ass beat?
Shane
Yeah. All right, our next story. Am I the asshole from November of 2025? Damn.
Jacksepticeye
November. Big month.
Shane
Yeah, big, big month for assholes. Am I the asshole for refusing to pay to have my friend's house cleaned? I had to quickly come down to the city where I grew up due to the death of a close family member. It was a pretty spur of the moment occurrence and I had to drop things rather quickly. I informed one of my friends and they offered to put me up for a few days. I said that would be great, but told them I'd have my dogs with me, so totally understood if they wouldn't be able to. The friends said it would be fine and they were more than happy to host me. For context, my dogs are not badly trained. But by any standard. But they are both large breed dogs, a lab and a German shepherd. So of course can be a bit much for many non dog owners. I am aware of this and that's why I usually don't bring them to people's houses. I made the five hour drive down and my friend came out to greet me. When unpacking the car, I let the dogs out and immediately they went off to toilet. Since it was a long trip, my lab went into the bushes to pee, but the German shepherd began to pee in the middle of the front porch. Don't ask me why, but she much prefers peeing on hard surfaces. And my friend immediately freaked out. I was a bit confused and apologized, but it's outside so I didn't get why she was so freaked out. The dogs were fine the entire stay. They are non eventful inside. They let me know when they need to go out and I cleaned up the poo straight away. I keep them under good supervision. At the end of the trip, my friend sent me a text saying, hey, as you know, the house is quite messy because of the dogs and I'm going to hire a cleaner. Would you mind paying me for that? I was a bit taken aback. The dogs had zero accidents inside, didn't break anything. I asked what she meant and she explained that there was dog hair everywhere. The thing is, they are shedding dogs. I know that if she'd asked me to vacuum up after them, I would have, but she didn't. I also didn't think a deep clean would be necessary. A quick vacuum of the carpets, couch, bed, et cetera, would be more than enough to remove any trace. I don't know what to do. I didn't ask to stay with her. She offered. I told her about my dogs and she was fine with that.
Jacksepticeye
That's. I wasn't just asking for money.
Shane
So the verdict is asshole. I can see it because dogs, yeah, they do shed, like animal shed. They bring a lot of stuff with them. It might have behooved this person to like talk about it while they were staying there.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah.
Shane
Cause to like have them leave and then send a text and be like, hey, I'm gonna need this money. I can see how it now causes a weird situation, but I'm also a little surprised OP isn't like fair. Like the dog stayed here for a few days and yeah, this happens.
Trevor
Yeah. I think it's crazy to me that OP didn't like really clean at all. Like if I'm taking my dog's shed into a House where someone doesn't have dogs. And I know my dog shed. I'm gonna try and clean up as much as I can. Like, I'm asking, hey, do you have a vacuum? Like, I'd love to, like, make sure things are as clean as possible. Like, I think the fact that they were like, oh, yeah, like, they're just my dogs. They're shedding dogs. Like, that comes from a place of like, oh, I have them, and I'm fine with it. So I expect you to be fine with it. Kind of.
Jacksepticeye
You're bringing them into their space.
Trevor
Yeah, I think it's very. I think it's reasonable for them to be like, hey, I want to hire a cleaner. Like, I don't know, maybe he can be like, hey, I'd love to, like, you know, help pay for it or something like that. Like, if they don't. If it is, like, a lot of money. But, yeah, I don't think it's unreasonable.
Jacksepticeye
Plus, we, like you said, we don't know the state of the house. Like, it's not just hair and stuff.
Shane
We don't know. It's true.
Jacksepticeye
It's a whole bunch.
Shane
Yeah. OP says, oh, well, they didn't ask me to clean up. It's like, well, you know, you could have done it. It's one of those where I'm a little biased from growing up with so many animals that I'm not. It's not something I'm bothered by personally, but some people really are, and it doesn't take long for.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah, you always have those people, like, you bring their dog over and they start licking people. Like, oh, my God, I'm so sorry. Like, I'm imposing on you.
Shane
I'm bothering you by my dog being here. Sure. Let's see some of the comments. Someone said, so let me get this straight. And I say this as an owner of one lab, but have had two at the same time in the past. A friend allows you to stay with two large shedding dogs at the last minute, and you make no effort to vacuum or otherwise contribute to cleaning before you leave. I'd be so embarrassed to leave without cleaning after staying that I'd have paid for the cleaner in a heartbeat. You appear incredibly entitled and disrespectful to your friend and a clear asshole. 11,000 upvotes. Someone said, she's not used to pet hair. You saved money by staying with her instead of a hotel. And dog boarding, paying for a cleaning will still have saved you money. Someone replied to that saying, given that OP didn't even seem to see the problem with the dog peeing on the front porch. I'm guessing OP's hygiene standards are pretty damned low. And a shepherd in a lab in the house for several days means that there's going to be a lot of hair everywhere. Someone said, you should have vacuumed without her having to ask during and before you left. You have dogs that shed. You should have been overly conscious about making sure the place is clean before you left and during your stay, especially if it's a non dog household. Someone lastly said, pay her 1.2 thousand upvotes.
Trevor
Yeah, I have two dogs and I take them on walks twice a day, but we have a patio and we have a grass pad on the patio and a little doggy door so they can go out during the day to pee if they need to. And every once in a while, one of them will pee on the concrete. And I hate that. I'm like, no, I don't want. Even if it's outside, that's just dried pee now on the concrete. I'm out there rinsing it off, getting the water. Being like your dog peeing on the front porch of somebody else's home. Like, I would be mortified if my dog did that. Like, if I took him somewhere and they just started like peeing on the porch, I'd be like, yeah, I. I think it's.
Shane
I think an important factor of this is that they stayed here for free. Like, they stayed there for free. So, yes, paying for a cleaning is gonna still be saving you a lot of money compared to the hotel and everything.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. Like, jumping into this person's life, you should be helping out where you can instead of. Of taking more from them.
Shane
Right? Absolutely.
Jacksepticeye
I did stay at a friend's house one time where they had big shedding dogs and there was hair everywhere. And it was like, okay, friends are coming over later. And I was like, are we gonna clean up? And I was like, no, not really. But it was so much hair everywhere that I even cleaned up. And I'm like, I'm staying at your house and you don't see the hair everywhere. I'm like, I know you're okay with it, but I don't think everybody else is.
Shane
Right. You can. I think it's possible for people to get just very used to their situation.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah.
Shane
But yeah, when you're a guest somewhere, it's just so important to be mindful of the impact you're having on the place you're staying in.
Jacksepticeye
Especially we don't know how clean the house was before.
Shane
Yeah. I'm really kind of curious to see. Cause I have a feeling it's very possible that this was all worse than we thought.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. Isn't that kind of the thing? Like, leave it how you found it?
Shane
Totally. 100%. And yeah. Finding out that they didn't even try to clean. Clean.
Jacksepticeye
Unless your friend.
Shane
Yeah, yeah. It's like, okay. Yeah, it's tough.
Jacksepticeye
Yikes.
Shane
Anyways, moving on.
Jacksepticeye
Our first asshole.
Shane
Yeah, it's rare that op's the asshole.
Jacksepticeye
I know.
Shane
Our next story. Am I the asshole for not letting a kid eat my food?
Jacksepticeye
Oh, I love this title.
Trevor
I love a title like that. That just gets me so excited.
Shane
Yeah, here we go. This was posted in October. The other day, I was at the mall with my boyfriend and our two kids. A girl who's 5 and a boy who's 6. We were sitting, eating a bag of roasted chestnuts, when this kid around 10 years old, starts hovering around us. Now, I admit I'm not the biggest fan of any kid that doesn't belong to me, so this alone was already annoying me slightly, but I still smiled at him. Then he calls my son over and whispers in his ear, and I knew it was about the chestnuts. My son nods yes, and the boy comes up to me and reaches for a chestnut. I moved the bag and said, no, you have to go ask your parents. My boyfriend got upset, called me rude, and handed a chestnut to the boy. The boy leaves and I tell my boyfriend he shouldn't have done that. That you don't just give food to a strange kid. The boy then hovers back around us and without a word, snatches two chestnuts from the bag that my boyfriend was now holding. I stood up and said very firmly, sorry, but you can't take our stuff like that. Go to your parents. He put them back and ran off. I think the kid had no manners. And I wasn't gonna let my kids think it's okay to accept anything from strangers or that it's okay to be pressured into sharing. My boyfriend doesn't agree and thinks the kid trusted us because we had kids ourselves. He thinks I was just selfish. So am I the asshole?
Jacksepticeye
No.
Trevor
I think that the policy of not giving food to a child without asking their parents first is 100% always the right thing. You should never just give food to a kid. Like, if their parents.
Shane
Especially any form of nuts.
Trevor
Yeah, that kid could just fucking die. Cause he's stupid and being like, oh, yeah, yeah, I want whatever's in that bag. And you could just die on the spot, like.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah, that's true.
Shane
Now you killed that kid.
Trevor
Now you're.
Shane
Hey.
Trevor
Am I the asshole for killing a kid?
Shane
For killing a kid. Hey, Sal. Hank.
Jacksepticeye
What's going on?
Shane
We haven't worked a case in years.
Jacksepticeye
I just bought my car at Carvana
Shane
and it was so easy. Too easy.
Jacksepticeye
Think something's up? You tell me. They got thousands of options, found a
Shane
great car at a great price, and it got delivered the next day. It sounds like Carvana just makes it easy to buy your car, Hank. Yeah, you're right. Case closed.
Sponsor/Ad Voice
Buy your car today on Carvana. Delivery fees may apply.
Trevor
He came up and asked for it. So am I the asshole?
Shane
I like the concept of asking someone if you can eat someone else's food. Like seeing someone eating something and just me asking a random person, like, can I have that guy's chips?
Jacksepticeye
Can I have Shane's lunch?
Shane
Oh, yeah, you should. I encourage it. Take it, dude.
Jacksepticeye
Give me nut. Give me now me wanty.
Shane
Yeah. No. She is 100% right for just multiple reasons.
Trevor
Yeah.
Shane
The verdict was not the asshole comments. Not the asshole. Your boyfriend could have killed the kid. How does your boyfriend know the kid is not allergic to nuts? Absolutely. Never give food to kids without talking to the parents first. Someone also said. Also, don't want a strange kid's hand in my food. Someone said, not the asshole. You have no idea if this kid might be allergic or if his parents want him having this. It is also dangerous that this boy thinks it is okay to take things from strangers. I would have handled it by asking him to talk to his parents and then maybe giving him one with their approval as a lesson to everyone. But you certainly were not in the wrong for simply saying no. Someone said, remember when your parents warns you about not eating food from a stranger? Someone said, no one's the asshole here. Based on your description, this kid may be hungry and knows the best option is to seek out other kids being fed like a stray kid. It's awful. I live in an area with a lot of poverty. My two kids always have snacks to share. One has literally earned the nickname Snacks by her schoolmates. And I would have just asked the kid if they were hungry and either shared or gotten them something to eat. But I am a softie and don't believe a child should ever go hungry. If I can help. Lastly, someone said, you don't give strange kids nuts.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. Yeah. I'm gonna take a different approach.
Shane
Okay.
Jacksepticeye
Like the fishermen feed a kid a nut, he's gonna go Hungry again. But teach a kid how to get chestnuts himself.
Shane
True.
Jacksepticeye
That's what you should have done.
Shane
You take that nut and before you hand it to him, you dig a hole, you plant it, water it. Be like, come back in 20 years, come back in 60 years, you'll have some chestnuts.
Trevor
And that chestnut grew up to be Barack Obama.
Jacksepticeye
So it really makes you think.
Trevor
Yeah, really?
Jacksepticeye
Who? You don't know Barack Obama.
Shane
You don't know Barack Obama.
Trevor
He's like the, he's like the Ed Sheeran of presidents.
Jacksepticeye
Wow.
Shane
Okay.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah.
Shane
All right. We're gonna keep that one in.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. Again, as Michael Jordan said, fuck them kids.
Shane
Yeah. His greatest legacy is that I just
Jacksepticeye
have a thing for like, I'm even like a dog at the table getting food. And I'm just. I don't like things being around me being like, it's my food, leave me alone. Totally my nut. I got nut. I climbed the street.
Shane
Yeah. Something very scary is a rogue 10 year old. Yeah. You're just somewhere and a 10 year old shows up. That's scary.
Trevor
Yeah.
Shane
Like, oh, that's a scary age. Yeah. It's like, oh, they'll do whatever.
Jacksepticeye
He rips off his mask, he's like,
Shane
this is a test with a CIA,
Jacksepticeye
never give kid a nut.
Shane
Yeah. I've got a 10 on the kid who gave kid nut. Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Buck em loo.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with just saying no to a kid who wants your food.
Shane
Well, especially when you're a stranger. Yeah. You're allowed to say no to anyone.
Trevor
People say it kindly be like, hey, sorry, I don't know. Go find your parents, whatever. There's nice ways to just be like, hey, sorry, buddy, I actually can't give
Shane
you any of this.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. People on the Internet are, are obsessed with finding the exact perfect solution to stuff like this. Being like, if I was in this scenario, what would I have done? Okay. Mind palace.
Shane
Right?
Jacksepticeye
And then they get into the weeds of it and they get the exact perfect answer. They get the good ending.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
But it's like you can just say no and that's fine.
Shane
Like, nah, dude. Our next story. Am I the asshole for not checking my phone when a friend bailed to meet us? Okay, okay. I, a 28 year old man, and four of my friends, also all 28, finally managed to hang out. After over a year of everyone being slammed with work and relationships, we all agreed to meet at this indie cinema doing a marathon of a movie series we once watched together in college. Right. Next to the cinema is a cafe we used to practically live in. I messaged the group saying let's meet at the cinema early to grab seats and thought everyone would know the drill. Two of us showed up at the same time and since the theater wasn't open yet, we went into the cafe to hang out and sent a photo to our group. Rick showed up a bit later but walked straight into the theater. Since it was open and by that time we were already there, we figured he'd realize and come over. Our last friend, Mark, never showed. About 20 minutes in, I noticed my phone was still on silent from work and saw one single missed call from Mark. Turns out he'd been sitting in his car in the rain looking for us outside the cinema, didn't see anyone, didn't call anyone else, and decided we ditched him. He went home and later sent a bunch of angry texts and a long voice message full of frustration and swearing. He said we ghosted him and that he was sick of being the afterthought. I even offered to pay for a ticket to the next showing, but he said it was too late and refused. So am I the asshole for not checking my phone and assuming he would know we left the cafe and got to the cinema when it opened?
Jacksepticeye
I'm gonna say no.
Trevor
I fear that that is a crazy thing to. If you are going with a group of people and you only call one person one time and that's all of the reaching out and then you're like, well, they don't care about me. They ditch me. I'm an afterthought. That's unreasonable.
Jacksepticeye
And you're sitting in your car waiting for an answer.
Trevor
Yeah, I like just reach out to a few people, try and text, call a couple people, whoever it is. Or yeah, go inside and look around.
Jacksepticeye
Even a kid can go look for nuts.
Shane
Yeah, yeah, true.
Jacksepticeye
Just talk to people, get up, go do your thing, go look for people.
Shane
Sure.
Jacksepticeye
Look, I'm saying this as a 35 year old man. You're in charge of your own shit. Yeah, I guess your friends aren't in charge of how you deal with this situation. I don't think.
Trevor
I think if, like there is kind of an argument. I think for him to be like, oh, I was supposed to be there and not anyone checked on me or did look at their phone. But again, that's. That's not their fault necessarily.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah, if there's a pattern of them doing this all the time, then maybe. But we don't have context.
Shane
We don't have context. On that, to be clear, they sent a photo of them all hanging out at the cafe.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. Wait.
Shane
Yeah, they established they're there. Oh yeah, they established that at the cafe because the theater hasn't opened yet.
Jacksepticeye
And not only that, but the other friend just walked in. He didn't see that, Just went to the theater.
Shane
At least go into the theater theater to find out.
Jacksepticeye
Maybe he actually just hates whatever movie series that we're gonna watch.
Shane
Maybe he found an excuse to leave.
Jacksepticeye
He was like, oh, I'm so sick of watching the critters movies.
Shane
We're watching all the critters movies. The verdict was everyone sucks.
Jacksepticeye
I'm so curious why.
Shane
I'm very curious too. I wonder if the take is kind of more like just that overall as a group, like they also didn't check their phone. Like they just assumed like, oh, he didn't show up, we're not gonna check. There's that element. They didn't like, also try to reach out to him.
Trevor
Yeah.
Shane
It just feels like a very kind of distant friend group in a way where it's like, hey, if your friend's not showing up to the big movie marathon, are you gonna at least text him too to be like, hey, where you at?
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. Also, there's no group chat between these friends to kinda like.
Shane
I think there is. Is what's weird.
Jacksepticeye
Why text that one friend text the group chat?
Shane
I guess I'm a little. It is confusing. This is one of those where I'm not like, this person's in the wrong. This person's the wrong. I'm just kinda like, what's going on?
Jacksepticeye
You've been in that scenario where like you're all in a group, time passes way faster than you think. You're all catching up with each other. It just kind of slips your mind.
Shane
Yeah.
Trevor
It seems like so many stupid things had to happen for it to get to this point.
Shane
Totally.
Trevor
Like there's no. Yeah, I don't know.
Shane
It's a lot of non communication comments. Everyone sucks here. You should have communicated better. Sending a picture in a group chat isn't the same as a quick message to say where you are. It's also not ideal to have your phone on silent and not be checking it regularly when you're planning to meet people at the same time. Mark should have probably messaged the group chat too to see where everyone was. I can't imagine, not at the bare minimum, texting my friend who no showed someone replied to that saying, I can't imagine going to meet a group of friends. And not thinking about calling other friend. When other friend doesn't answer my phone. Someone said, info. Is Mark in the same group chat? Did he not receive the message about the change? Op said we didn't end up changing it. Maybe I didn't express myself very well since I'm really tired, but we waited for like 10 minutes at the cafe, took a picture to show the boys. Yes, he's in the group chat. And I said in the group chat that we were waiting there for the cinema to open. We went in as soon as it opened, but I didn't say we were going in that moment. Someone replied to that, saying, I'm gonna go with a soft. Everyone sucks here. You and the rest of the group didn't say anything to Mark beyond a picture of all of you still on the cafe. But he also should have made more of an effort to contact the group than just the one phone call. It sounds like it wasn't malicious. And maybe Mark's been sitting on some resentment for a while, but everyone contributed to the miscommunication.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah, I'm putting myself in Mark's scenario where other friend goes in, doesn't see the other text. He knows, oh, maybe they're not here. I don't see them at the cafe. I'm just gonna go in. That's our plan. Yeah, I think that's what you do. I'm putting myself in his position where I'm like, I have a lot of control in that scenario. I'm not just gonna sit and pout in my car and be like, no one cares about me. And then also to send such angry messages afterwards, I feel like is really unfair.
Shane
Yeah. It's also a cinema, so it's a place where people might silence their phones. I would certainly, especially if I showed up late or later than everyone, I'd be like, oh, maybe they're in the theater and their phones are silent.
Trevor
I think that there was an opportunity for the other friends to be more considerate and, like, go check and reach out, whatever.
Shane
Totally.
Trevor
But I don't think that they're necessarily in the wrong for not doing like that. Like, he sucks for reacting the way he did. And he could have. There's just so much more. Just take a step outside, walk inside.
Jacksepticeye
Like, the plan to watch the movie didn't change. It was just to meet up beforehand. So it's like you just assumed they weren't there. I don't understand that.
Shane
It's very confusing to me. And I think what Mark is feeling is just. He just feels Sad that. That the group chat didn't contact him or care that he.
Jacksepticeye
Which can. It does.
Shane
There's something hurtful there, but it just feels to me, this is like, not a matter of assholes. I'm just like, what? Guys?
Jacksepticeye
Come on, again, Just talk to each other.
Shane
You guys need to talk to each other better. Is that how old everyone was? Yeah, they're all like, 28. Like, dude, dude, just text each other.
Jacksepticeye
I think to paint them as the assholes means big leaps in logic. To be like, he could have been hurt. It's like, yeah, but he wasn't. Like, you're starting to really poke holes in this thing.
Shane
I think I see when people are doing the cause. I agree. This is a soft situation. Right. This is a very relatable situation, too, of just like, look, the way this all shook out. Mark was hurt and felt that the situation happened differently than it actually happened.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah.
Shane
They didn't abandon him. They were in the theater. He was waiting for them to walk in, but they were already in. It just kind of was like, it's kind of a stupid situation.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. Cause I have a theater back in Brighton in my mind, and I'm like, it's kind of hard to miss that the cafe's not a completely separate building, like, a block down the road or something. You just poke your head in, look around. If you really want to know, ask. I don't know. I feel like there's so many other ways you could have gone about this
Shane
to read into it. It does feel like Mark has some resentment there. Maybe he has felt like he's outside of the group a little bit, and I can see feeling hurt that it's like, oh, I didn't show up and none of you texted me. That's probably more what he's heard about. They thought he no showed, and they didn't even text him when he no showed. It's like. It's just like, how good of friends are we?
Jacksepticeye
We're getting into the territory of playing
Shane
mind games, though, and I think that's totally.
Jacksepticeye
I'm not a fan of that. Like, just. Just say what's on your mind.
Shane
Yeah, absolutely.
Jacksepticeye
If they were younger and they were like, 19 or something, maybe I'd understand
Shane
it's a bit, but 28.
Trevor
Yeah.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Having been that age, that shit's in my control, man.
Shane
Totally. All right, our next story. Am I the asshole for buying myself an Xbox when my boyfriend said he got me one for my birthday last year? Okay. Okay.
Jacksepticeye
I don't know how double Xbox is. Gonna be bad.
Shane
All right, Stack em. My boyfriend who's 20 and I 24 year old woman have been dating for about a year and a half now. We're long distance and he's been out here to visit me about four times for weeks at a time. Last year, on my birthday in June, he had told me he got me an Xbox. I was really excited because I've had mine since 2016 so we can assume that they had an Xbox One and was looking forward to an Xbox Series X. We met for the first time last October. He didn't bring it with him that time. No big deal, he only had a small bag that time. Fast forward to December. He came out for Christmas, he bought a bigger bag and even asked if he could bring his PS5 so we could play games together. And I said yes. After Christmas he went home and I asked about the Xbox. Whenever I asked him, he got frustrated and said I was nagging him about it, but he'll just send it to me in the mail. A few weeks go by and nothing. So I ask him again and he gets really upset again. He said it was in a box under his bed and he didn't want to deal with it right now. It got to the point where I just said that it didn't matter whether or not he bought it, I just wanted to know. We got into a huge fight about it and I told him I wanted proof that he actually had it. He sent me a picture of the box. I was suspicious about it because he had mentioned to me before that his best friend had the same Xbox I wanted. So in my head I was thinking that he had just taken a picture of his friend's old friend Xbox box. But I promised him I'd let it go after he sent the picture. So I didn't bring it up. That was sometime in January. My birthday is coming up again and we were on the phone and he was talking about things to get me for his birthday. I had gotten him a game and a vinyl wrap for his PS5. So I had told him a wrap for the Xbox would be cool. My way of hinting that I wanted my Xbox and he said no and that he'd think of something better. I promised him I wouldn't bring it up again, but it's been almost a year, he's coming out for my birthday, so I thought maybe he'd bring it. We were texting about my gift the other day and he had mentioned he needed to buy what he was getting me. So to me it sounded like he wasn't bringing it. I've been wanting this Xbox for so long and I was sick of waiting. So I went looking on ebay and bought one. It's coming this weekend. So I had to tell him. I told him not to be mad, but I bought myself an Xbox. I tried to explain my reasoning and that I didn't want to wait anymore because my Xbox now barely works. But he got so mad at me and just said that was a fucking waste of $500. So I offered to pay him back for it and he said he doesn't want my money. Now he's really upset with me and it has me questioning if it was messed up that I ended up buying the Xbox for myself. Am I the asshole?
Jacksepticeye
This dude does not have an Xbox.
Shane
He doesn't have an Xbox. This is the funniest version of catfishing.
Trevor
Yeah.
Shane
Like, he comes and visits her. So he's not catfishing himself, but he's catfishing a whole other thing.
Trevor
And Xbox.
Shane
Yeah, I've got an Xbox for you.
Jacksepticeye
I'm gonna bring my bigger bag. Psych. Nothing.
Shane
Yeah, sorry. Couldn't bring the Xbox.
Trevor
You couldn't bring the Xbox to play games together on.
Jacksepticeye
You had to bring the PS5 to
Trevor
play games together on.
Jacksepticeye
Also a scenario is like, oh, you bought one. Okay, well, now we have two Xboxes. We can play games together. Yeah, like, that's such a win.
Shane
Sorry, man. It's been a year. Yeah, you can't buy someone a gift and be like, yeah, I'm holding onto it. And a year goes by.
Jacksepticeye
Sorry, it's under the bed.
Shane
I don't wanna deal with it. Sorry, I just. I'm gonna get it to you eventually.
Jacksepticeye
That or this guy has been playing some mad Xbox in his spare time.
Shane
Yeah, he bought himself.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah, he was like, it's pretty sick. I'll turn it on just to see what it's like.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Knee deep in Halo. He was like, well, I can't give it to her now.
Shane
Absolutely.
Jacksepticeye
She's gonna see that it has miles on it. That's so funny.
Shane
That's absurd.
Trevor
Just being like, so about that Xbox. And he's like, stop asking.
Shane
Don't ask about the Xbox. Shut up about the sun. Doesn't matter.
Trevor
Shut up about the sun.
Jacksepticeye
Wait, what Xbox? I also wanna hear a super cut of how many times you said Xbox in that story.
Shane
I said it a lot. Almost as much as Muhammad Ali. The verdict is not the asshole comments, not the asshole. That Xbox doesn't exist. He just wanted brownie points without making the brownie. Also, him getting mad over it every time is kind of a red flag. So I'm not one to say break up, but consider if he's worth this. Op said, yeah. I was dreading telling him that I got it, but he's younger, so I figure that maybe he's got that mindset that he needs to get me expensive gifts to keep me, even though I've made it clear that I don't need gifts like that. Not the asshole Op wrote. So I offered to pay him back for it. No, no, no. You are paying him back for what? For something you don't have. Haven't seen. What the hell? He is lying. Why are you still with him? Someone said, not the asshole. He never bought it. He's a narcissist and wanted the attention of buying you a nice gift without actually buying it. That would be a deal breaker for me.
Jacksepticeye
Damn, People really jump through the narcissist breakup real bad.
Shane
That one was pretty quick. I'm like, no, he just sounds like a dumbass.
Trevor
Yeah, he sounds like a 20 year old dude.
Shane
Yeah, 20 year old dude.
Trevor
What's crazy is like after a year, if you lied about this Xbox and it's been a year, how have you not scrounged up like 500 bucks to make it happen? Like, maybe it's like I said it and now maybe after a year I can finally do it.
Jacksepticeye
Also, you've never been to his place.
Shane
No.
Jacksepticeye
To see this Xbox or the chalk outlane where the Xbox was.
Shane
Yeah, it was right here.
Trevor
I would've reverse image searched it to see if he pulled the picture off Google or something.
Jacksepticeye
A simple like, man, I'm so sorry. I wanted to get you a nice thing. I didn't. I thought I'd get the money by then. I'm like, I don't have it.
Shane
Yeah, easy. No so easy. Update. Yes.
Jacksepticeye
Third Xbox.
Shane
A fifth Xbox is entered. Update. He ended up sending a long text this morning about how pissed he was and that it was stupid that I bought it for myself. Oh, no, he was going to bring it. The only reason he didn't tell me was because it was supposed to be a surprise for my birthday. Wasn't it? Last year's birthday?
Trevor
Oh, Shane.
Jacksepticeye
This is the bad kind of update, isn't it?
Shane
He said he's pissed because he bought more accessories for the Xbox Two. So he spent well over $600. But now that I bought one for myself, I should keep it. And he's not going to give me anything. He got. I told him that he should have just sent it in the first place and it wouldn't have gotten to the point where I had to buy it myself. I also explained that I didn't need expensive gifts and that if he didn't get it for me and just wanted to impress me, he should have told me. When I gave him the opportunity to come clean, he explained the reason everything was so expensive was because I liked gaming and Legos, which are expensive, so it wasn't to impress me. He apologized because he made me so upset about it for so long and that he didn't think about it because it was under his bed. I told him I felt like he never listened or cared about it because I had nagged him multiple times about sending it, but he somehow still forgot. He apologized for being lazy and making it seem like he didn't care about it, how he should have brought it in the first place, and that he was wrong for not doing that. I'm even more conflicted at this point. Maybe I should have just waited for my birthday, but it genuinely sounded like he wasn't going to bring it. Update number two. Oh, my God, now he's dead. Now he's for sure dead. I ended things with him today. I couldn't do it on the phone, so I did it over text. Everything he said proved that you were all right. He's trying to manipulate me back into the relationship, but I'm at my breaking point. Thank you for all your help on this.
Jacksepticeye
Wow.
Trevor
Jesus Christ.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah, after that first update, I was like, what are you conflicted on?
Shane
Yeah, he sucks.
Jacksepticeye
Like he was a bit of a douche and then he double douched.
Shane
Yeah, I love the idea that like,
Trevor
she got her own Xbox and he got all these accessories and he's like, you can't have the accessories now you bought your own.
Shane
Give me the accessories.
Trevor
It's like you could still be like, oh, well, I got you these two cool controllers.
Shane
But he's like, no, you don't get
Trevor
any of it now.
Jacksepticeye
This guy's like in a burning building and he's like, I'm fine. Yeah, I can get out of this myself. Yeah, go play xbox.
Trevor
20 year old kid who's just the worst manipulator ever.
Shane
Yeah, not doing it well. Yeah, God, I still am laughing at, yeah, I got you an Xbox. And then you just don't ever give it.
Jacksepticeye
I got it for your birthday next year.
Shane
I'm laughing actually really hard at like buying someone like an Xbox One and then waiting so long waiting for the Xbox Series X to come out, like, wait 20 years. Be like, oh, I finally got that Xbox for you.
Jacksepticeye
Three generations later.
Shane
It's ancient. No.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah. And him saying, it's in a box under my bed. I just can't deal with it.
Shane
Saying he forgot about it is ridiculous.
Trevor
It's so funny because he literally. She specified that he. He got a bigger suitcase and then was like, let me bring my PS5. You have a bag that can fit a gaming console in it, and you choose to bring your PS5. Instead of being like, you know what? I'll bring you the gift I got you.
Jacksepticeye
Maybe he was like, I'm trying to change her into a PS Girly.
Trevor
Like, it's.
Jacksepticeye
Instead, I got an Xbox, but I'll bring my PlayStation just to show you how sick it is.
Trevor
Yeah, well, you know, the PlayStation has so many games for it.
Shane
Nice. He explained the reason everything was so expensive was because I liked gaming and Legos, which are expensive, so it wasn't to impress me. Yeah, I still think it.
Jacksepticeye
You have expensive hobby. He was trying to buy a game, not a console.
Shane
Yeah, he was trying to manipulate me.
Trevor
Buy a game. Buy a cool Lego set. You can get some dope Lego sets
Shane
for like 80 bucks.
Trevor
I think the DeLorean Lego set's like a hundred dollars.
Shane
To be fair.
Jacksepticeye
Lego is. It's crazy expensive for what it is.
Shane
It's expensive.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah, there's way, like you said, really good ones for cheaper.
Shane
I have some solid $20 ones.
Trevor
There are.
Shane
I'm a simple man.
Jacksepticeye
You should have made an Xbox out of Lego.
Shane
Yeah, like here. That'd actually be sick.
Jacksepticeye
Turn it on her. Yeah, either way, good for her. She got out of that. She learned a lesson. Yeah, and she has an Xbox now, which she never did before.
Shane
It's true. It's true.
Jacksepticeye
Go play Stardew Valley or something.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Hey, go marry Leah.
Shane
Yeah, nice.
Jacksepticeye
Hey, good reference.
Shane
Good reference.
Jacksepticeye
Or go marry Harvey.
Shane
Leah.
Jacksepticeye
Leah. Yeah, sorry, I'm not in. Sorry, I'm not in. Lovers in here.
Shane
Yeah, sorry.
Trevor
Anyone for Harvey?
Jacksepticeye
In the room.
Trevor
Anyone for Harvey?
Jacksepticeye
Hey, don't. Shh.
Shane
All right, it's time for our final story.
Jacksepticeye
Oh, sweet sorrows.
Shane
Am I the asshole for connecting to the earpod after my niece swallowed it to see if it would play in her stomach? This rules. That is so cool. Can we judge now?
Jacksepticeye
Cool.
Trevor
Not the asshole.
Shane
That's science.
Trevor
Was Galileo an asshole? Was Einstein an asshole?
Shane
Da Vinci?
Jacksepticeye
Newton?
Trevor
Were they assholes?
Shane
Muhammad Ali.
Trevor
Was Muhammad Ali an asshole?
Shane
Babe Ruth.
Jacksepticeye
Look, it's in there already. We gotta Try this out.
Shane
We gotta do it.
Trevor
Was Oppenheimer an asshole?
Jacksepticeye
Yeah, probably. I don't know him.
Shane
Okay. When my 3 year old niece swallowed my sister's left AirPod, everyone started worrying right away. I was trying to lighten the situation, so I connected the AirPod to my phone and put my ear on her stomach to check if I could hear it. Surprisingly, I actually did hear a little sound coming from inside her, which made the moment a bit funny for me. But the people around us didn't really find it amusing. They all looked at me like I wasn't taking things seriously at all. I was just trying to calm the mood. But instead I ended up being the only one laughing while everyone else was still stressing about the AirPod inside her. Oh, man.
Jacksepticeye
Okay, that is kind of funny. And you got an answer?
Shane
Yes. Okay. Scary situation. Of course.
Jacksepticeye
At least.
Shane
I mean, I don't have a kid. At least they're not choking on it. At least it's here. I was gonna say it's like, yeah, it made it there. So you can now go to the doctor and be like, how do we get this chopper?
Jacksepticeye
Olin's playing in our AirPods.
Trevor
Pretty tiny. Like, I know. Obviously there could be complications and issues. I think this is objectively funny.
Shane
It is funny. To be clear. It's funny.
Jacksepticeye
I think the doctor would also be like, they're not showing any problems right now, so listening to it is like, what else were you gonna do?
Trevor
Yeah, yeah.
Shane
The doctor's gonna be like, look, I can. We can work on this, but you gotta play like Phil Collins or something. Yeah, I need to follow it on the way down. Play the Tarzan soundtrack. Yeah.
Trevor
Honestly, it's kind of meta if you think about it. He's figuring out where it is so they can better assess the situation.
Shane
Exactly.
Jacksepticeye
It's like if I made it, find my iPhone, find my AirPods. It's different if I don't know. If something like this passes through your system and then I don't know if it will if you need surgery. It's different.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Like, that's scary.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
But in the moment I'm like, I feel like I would probably laugh at that.
Shane
Oh, in the moment I would laugh even. No matter how serious it's about to get.
Trevor
Yeah, I'd be laughing.
Jacksepticeye
I couldn't get a chestnut, so it ate an airpod. Oh, it comes back.
Shane
I think it's funny. And yeah, it does serve some sort of purpose. The verdict is not the asshole.
Jacksepticeye
Good.
Shane
So I guess apparently tech can contain small batteries that can injure organs and harm people. So it could require endoscopy or surgery, which is what I assumed. I'm like, yeah, but even then, it's still just like, well, this is still the situation we're in. Take them to the doctor. I'm sure it's gonna be okay. I feel like kids swallowing stuff is normal, but then again, I don't have
Jacksepticeye
a kid, and I think people laugh in crazy scenarios anyway. I don't think they should come down on that person for laughing about it. Somebody's gonna laugh.
Shane
Yeah.
Trevor
I totally understand, like, the medical concerns and having those concerns. And I could understand being the parent and being like, that's their first thing that they're thinking about. And that doesn't change for me. How funny?
Shane
Absolutely.
Trevor
It's hilarious.
Shane
I am also, once again, biased. You know, I drowned as a baby, and my family makes jokes about it.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah.
Shane
So, you know, people make jokes to, like, lighten their kid's not gonna remember this. No. This is traumatizing for everyone but the baby.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah.
Sponsor/Ad Voice
Shane, were you legally dead?
Shane
Yeah, I think so. I was like, they had to perform CPR on me. Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Four minutes or I forget.
Shane
It was heaven real.
Trevor
I don't know.
Shane
I don't think they. We don't know, like, the exact amount of time because it was, like, crazy in the moment. You don't want God, but yeah. My family calls me Shane Bobber.
Jacksepticeye
What were you bobbing for?
Shane
Comments. Not the asshole. I get why everyone else was angry. You made a joke when they were all stressed and worried. On the other hand, this is 100% something me and my husband would do. If our kid had swallowed an AirPod, we would have figured out what to do to fix the issue, and then we would have done the test and had a laugh. To lighten the mood, Opie said we had already called the hospital, and they said an ambulance would be sent. So being that everyone was stressed and seeing it would rub off on her, I decided to be playful. Uncle. She knows. Someone said it was not for laughs. It was for science. Had to be done. Someone said, I'm a nurse, and I would absolutely laugh at my balls off, not the asshole. There are way more dangerous things to swallow by accident. Edit, y'. All. I never said they shouldn't get help. Yes, it has a small battery in it and it needs to get out asap. But swallowing a loose battery without anything casing it is way, way, way more dangerous.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah.
Shane
Someone said, let's get through the plastic first. Yeah. Someone said, never an airpod but when the youngest nephew was a wee tot, he swallowed a ball bearing. The doctor said all we could do was wait for it to pass. So each night we had him lay on the floor and checked him with a metal detector, the kind for beach combing. He thought it was great fun to have that thing go beep, beep, beep over his middle nephew. And I would have been thoroughly amused by his tummy making music. Added bonus, since your niece thought it was humorous, you're calming the patient, not the asshole.
Jacksepticeye
Damn.
Shane
Someone said, peak uncle moment. Well played, sir. Op said, this moment is easily the best time of my life. Seeing her smile made everything worthwhile. Plus, we shall always have this moment. Someone said, my dog swallowed my AirPod. And I did the same thing. I picked Crazy Train. Yeah.
Trevor
What song did he pick that could make him gasoline?
Shane
Yeah. The song is what determines where he goes.
Jacksepticeye
Dogs out.
Shane
That's awesome. Incredible.
Jacksepticeye
I mean, if you call the hospital and an ambulance is on the way,
Shane
it's like, what are you gonna do?
Trevor
You can't do anything about it.
Shane
It's a stressful situation. You're the uncle. You're gonna make a dumb joke.
Jacksepticeye
You're never gonna have that chance again.
Shane
It's true.
Jacksepticeye
And everyone. Everyone's wondered that.
Shane
It's like, guys, can we throw up Backstreet Boys onto the baby? Yeah, you hold them up like a boombox.
Jacksepticeye
You just have the baby up.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Like a JBL speaker.
Shane
Yeah.
Trevor
Can someone skip? Can we go next song?
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
I would get the kid to, like, move to see if it amplified or.
Shane
Guys, we've got LMFAO on the baby.
Jacksepticeye
It's the moment that it's like. Ask the kid, like, what's your favorite song? And then the kid's like, it's coming from me.
Shane
That's true. It's so fun. Oh, my gosh.
Jacksepticeye
It's like I'm a speaker.
Trevor
That's awesome.
Shane
I wonder what it felt like. It must feel like. Cause it has, like, a vibration and stuff.
Jacksepticeye
Like, K Pop Demon Hunters coming in.
Trevor
Guys, should I swallow an AirPod?
Shane
All right, all right. Toss us an AirPod.
Trevor
Guys. If this video gets 200,000 likes, I'll swallow an AirPod.
Shane
Toss me an AirPod. We're going up on. Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
If you swallow an AirPod, can I put on jacksepticeye videos?
Shane
Yes.
Trevor
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Yeah.
Trevor
You guys can put on whatever you want all the way until that thing comes out. You have my express permission to play Whatever Happened to Ox?
Shane
That'd be sick.
Jacksepticeye
The ox is Trevor Trevor's the ox doing room tone.
Trevor
And you just hear a song. Hey, can somebody pause the song on my phone?
Shane
Stop it.
Jacksepticeye
Sorry. Belly noises to fall asleep.
Shane
Well, that's all our stories.
Jacksepticeye
Remarkable.
Shane
Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
Incredible. It's incredible to see where the sausage is made.
Shane
I know, isn't it?
Jacksepticeye
This is so cool.
Shane
Isn't it? So simple. Like, when you're sitting here, it's just so chill. Yeah.
Jacksepticeye
I've never been on the stage until today, and now we're just in a wee little corner.
Shane
I know. It's very funny.
Trevor
Imagine now.
Shane
It's very funny because behind these cameras is, like, the whole other, like, everything else that we do. Our pit stuff, like, the try not to laugh set is right there.
Trevor
There's 30 other shows.
Shane
Yeah. So much stuff. Bit city's right there.
Jacksepticeye
That's true.
Trevor
Yeah, dude, the poop corner's right over there.
Shane
Poop corner, where Trevor poops. All right.
Jacksepticeye
Poop.
Shane
It's just. Just Trevor poop. Dick.
Jacksepticeye
This was fun, though. Thank you guys for having me.
Shane
Of course. Sean, thank you so much.
Trevor
Yeah, of course.
Shane
Pleasure. Lovely.
Jacksepticeye
Legendary.
Shane
Such a great guest. It's been so fun to have you on all the channels. I know. We'll continue to have you.
Jacksepticeye
I'll be back multiple. Multiple times.
Shane
I'm not going for the SME.
Jacksepticeye
God. I'm going for most concurrent guest episodes.
Shane
Whoa. All right, well, then we'll see you again soon. Soon.
Jacksepticeye
Yes.
Shane
And we'll see you guys next Saturday. Bye.
Jacksepticeye
Bye. Get your pancakes out.
Shane
Nice. Well, I hope they've eaten them by now.
Episode Date: March 21, 2026
Host: Shayne Topp
Guests: Jacksepticeye (Sean), Trevor
This lively episode of Smosh Reads Reddit Stories dives into a fresh batch of "Am I The A**hole?" tales from Reddit, featuring guest Jacksepticeye alongside Smosh's Shayne and Trevor. The group reacts to awkward family drama, clueless partners, hairy dog mishaps, and hilarious mishaps involving AirPods, applying their trademark blend of humor, empathy, and playful roasting. Throughout the hour, they not only judge Redditors' behavior but also reflect on communication, boundaries, and the wild quirks of human nature—all while delivering memorable banter and plenty of laughs.
Story: Would I be the a**hole for refusing to bring $100 minimum to Thanksgiving?
Story: Am I the asshole for expressing surprise that my fiancée didn’t know who Muhammad Ali was?
Story: Am I the asshole for refusing to pay to have my friend’s house cleaned after my dogs stayed there?
Story: Am I the asshole for not letting a random kid eat my food?
Story: Am I the asshole for not checking my phone when a friend bailed?
Story: Am I the asshole for buying myself an Xbox after my boyfriend (20) promised me one for my birthday a year ago—and never delivered?
Story: Am I the asshole for bluetooth connecting to the AirPod my niece swallowed to see if it would play?
A classic Reddit reactions episode elevated by Smosh banter, Jacksepticeye’s earnestness and wit, and a relentless parade of relatable disasters. The episode is packed with laughs, memorable moments, and takeaways about friendship, family, and sometimes just having to buy your own Xbox.