Podcast Summary: Smosh Reads Reddit Stories – "Are They Overreacting?"

Podcast Information:

• Title: Smosh Reads Reddit Stories
• Host: Shane (Shayne Blaise Topp)
• Description: Tall tales from Reddit serve as the foundation for hour-long reaction videos. Host Shayne engages with various Smosh cast members, sharing themed collections of Reddit posts that explore personal anecdotes related to friendship, romance, revenge, and more. Each Saturday, “Reddit Stories” offers a blend of delight and disgust through hilarious commentary and discussions.
• Episode: Are They Overreacting? | Reading Reddit Stories
• Release Date: June 14, 2025

Introduction

[01:30] Shane:
"Hi, welcome to Reddit Stories. I'm Shane and today's theme is 'Am I overreacting?' And I'm joined by two people who are always overreacting, Angela and Courtney."

Shane sets the stage for the episode, introducing the theme and his guests, Angela and Courtney, who are humorously labeled as frequent overreacters.

Story 1: Fiancé Not Invited to Wedding Due to Bride's Insecurity

[03:07] Riley Herbst:
"I kind of love when they are though. It's kind of funny when they are overreacting."

[04:19] Shane reads the Reddit post:
"A 26-year-old man is getting married, and while his groomsmen received invitations with their significant others, his own fiancé was excluded. The bride's reasoning: she doesn't want guests to think the fiancé is prettier than her. Feeling unfairly treated, the groomsman considers declining his role and attending the wedding alone, despite his fiancé being supportive."

Discussion Highlights:

• Perception of Fairness:
  [07:54] Riley: "Oh, that's so tough."

  [08:18] Riley:
  "And it's the fact that all the groomsmen were able to bring their plus ones. It's shitty no matter what."

• Bride's Insecurity:
  [10:02] Riley:
  "You ever just meet someone that's so friendly, gorgeous, it's painful?"

• Friendship and Respect:
  [09:53] Riley:
  "I don't know why I want to be around the bride."

• Concluding Thoughts:
  [12:54] Riley:
  "You can't blame women for thinking that when you're constantly put up against each other."

Notable Quotes:

• [03:07] Riley:
  "I kind of love when they are though. It's kind of funny when they are overreacting."

• [12:29] Riley:
  "You can't control how your face looks, but you can control how your heart looks."

Verdict: Not Overreacting

[08:18] Riley:
"Not overreacting, and I don't think he's overreacting."

Conclusion:
Shane and guests agree that the groomsman's feelings are valid. The bride's insecurity is seen as the root cause, and the guests empathize with the predicament, emphasizing the importance of fairness and respect in friendships.

Story 2: Boyfriend Makes Inappropriate Reference During Intimate Moment

[24:05] Shane reads the Reddit post:
"A 37-year-old woman describes an incident where her 39-year-old fiancé made a derogatory meme reference during sex, comparing her to the Penguin from Batman. Despite apologies, the comment has led to prolonged emotional distress."

Discussion Highlights:

• Emotional Impact:
  [25:03] Unknown:
  "I feel I'm about to lose my fucking..."

• Understanding and Maturity:
  [29:44] Riley:
  "He's being immature for his age."

• Potential Narcissism:
  [29:44] Riley:
  "He might be a bit narcissistic or just incredibly immature for his age."

Notable Quotes:

• [26:07] Riley:
  "Do you want to be clear."

• [30:29] Riley:
  "You're welcome."

Verdict: Not Overreacting

[27:13] Shane:
"You're not wrong to feel how you feel. He hurt your feelings, period."

Conclusion:
The hosts and guests unequivocally support the woman’s feelings, highlighting the inappropriateness of making hurtful comments during intimate moments. They advocate for open communication and self-respect in relationships.

Story 3: Considering Leaving Husband After He Neglected Her During a Medical Emergency

[33:20] Shane reads the Reddit post:
"A 37-year-old woman suffered a severe allergic reaction (anaphylaxis) while shopping with her husband. After being treated in the ER, her husband chose to go out and play Dungeons & Dragons with friends instead of staying by her side, leading her to contemplate leaving the marriage."

Discussion Highlights:

• Neglect During Crisis:
  [35:38] Shane:
  "He wouldn't. So she had to go herself."

• Emotional Betrayal:
  [36:58] Unknown:
  "The fact that he refused to call about ER coverage is such a red flag."

• Behavioral Red Flags:
  [37:13] Riley:
  "They're gonna make your life hell forever."

Notable Quotes:

• [38:31] Riley:
  "Leaving them at the emergency room is wild."

• [39:25] Unknown:
  "This is horrible. What an asshole. No, you're not overreacting."

Verdict: Not Overreacting

[38:31] Shane:
"You're not overreacting."

Conclusion:
The episode underscores the gravity of emotional neglect during a medical emergency. The hosts advocate for prioritizing self-worth and recognizing unhealthy relationship dynamics, encouraging the woman to seek counseling and reassess her relationship.

Story 4: Leaving Birthday Dinner After Fiancé Announces Fake Pregnancy

[43:20] Shane reads the Reddit post:
"During her birthday dinner, a woman’s fiancé unexpectedly announces a fake pregnancy by claiming to 'manifest' it. Feeling humiliated and unsupported, she leaves the dinner, prompting backlash from her fiancé’s family."

Discussion Highlights:

• Inappropriate Announcement:
  [44:35] Unknown:
  "Do you want this? Cool trinkets tee?"

• Lack of Communication:
  [46:10] Riley:
  "If they were, they have to talk about it first."

• Emotional Manipulation:
  [47:21] Riley:
  "It's so many layers."

Notable Quotes:

• [44:46] Shane:
  "He's like, no, I'm gonna make it happen."

• [46:37] Unknown:
  "He's manifesting this."

Verdict: Not Overreacting

[45:25] Unknown:
"No, you're fine."

Conclusion:
The hosts condemn the fiancé’s irresponsible and emotionally manipulative behavior, supporting the woman’s decision to leave the situation. They emphasize the importance of mutual respect and sincere communication in relationships.

Story 5: Cutting Off Family After They Harass Fiancée’s Workplace

[48:21] Shane reads the Reddit post:
"A 24-year-old man considers severing ties with his family after they aggressively confronted his fiancée at her workplace, accusing her of deceit regarding her employment and personal history."

Discussion Highlights:

• Boundary Violation:
  [52:25] Shane:
  "They drove a long time... to harass her coworkers."

• Family Dynamics:
  [54:29] Riley:
  "They think they're so goofy."

• Lack of Support:
  [56:12] Riley:
  "It's like, that's about you in that moment."

Notable Quotes:

• [52:40] Riley:
  "They don't know what happened to her."

• [53:07] Unknown:
  "That's so funny."

Verdict: Not Overreacting

[58:59] Shane:
"Not overreacting because they're not."

Conclusion:
The hosts empathize with the man’s frustration, recognizing his family's intrusive and disrespectful actions. They support his decision to establish boundaries and prioritize his fiancée's well-being over familial pressure.

Story 6: Threatening Legal Action After Sister’s Toddler Destroys Gaming Setup

[59:15] Shane reads the Reddit post:
"A 25-year-old woman’s sister’s toddler destroyed her $2,000 gaming setup. Despite attempts to address the damage, the sister minimizes the incident, refusing to take full responsibility, prompting the woman to consider legal action."

Discussion Highlights:

• Parental Responsibility:
  [62:33] Unknown:
  "That sucks."

  [63:31] Riley:
  "They couldn't protect their child."

• Financial and Emotional Stress:
  [63:15] Riley:
  "She's threatening to sue for sympathy and replacement costs."

• Sister's Negligence:
  [64:32] Shane:
  "This isn't just exploring; it's testing boundaries."

Notable Quotes:

• [65:14] Riley:
  "That's my son because it's mine. It's really about you."

• [66:11] Unknown:
  "Babies explore an unfamiliar space, but that doesn't mean you let them destroy everything."

Verdict: Not Overreacting

[62:33] Unknown:
"That sucks. Not overreacting."

Conclusion:
The episode condemns the sister's irresponsible handling of her child and lack of accountability. The hosts validate the woman's feelings and support her right to seek compensation for her losses, highlighting the importance of responsibility and respect in familial relationships.

Final Thoughts and Wrap-Up

Throughout the episode, Shane, Riley, and Unknown provide candid, humorous, yet empathetic commentary on each Reddit story, often interjecting with personal anecdotes and relatable humor. They consistently advocate for self-respect, healthy boundaries, and the importance of mutual respect in relationships, whether romantic or familial.

Final Notable Quote:

[75:44] Unknown:
"Does it sound different?"

[76:04] Unknown:
"Get your pancakes and your flashlights out."

These concluding remarks inject humor, signaling the end of the intense discussions.

Overall Verdict:
In all six stories discussed, the guests unanimously agree that the individuals feeling wronged are not overreacting. The overarching message emphasizes the importance of setting boundaries, prioritizing personal well-being, and addressing unhealthy relationship dynamics.

Closing Remarks:
Smosh Reads Reddit Stories continues to blend humor with heartfelt discussions, offering listeners relatable scenarios and insightful perspectives on navigating complex interpersonal issues. This episode reinforces the value of validating one's feelings and standing up against disrespectful behavior.