Podcast Title: Smosh Reads Reddit Stories
Host/Author: Smosh
Episode: Can You Guess The Plot Twist? | Reading Reddit Stories
Release Date: May 31, 2025

Introduction

In the episode titled "Can You Guess The Plot Twist? | Reading Reddit Stories," host Shayne Topp leads his usual energetic discussion with guests Angela and Trevor. The episode is themed around unexpected plot twists, promising listeners a series of Reddit stories that will keep them guessing until the very end.

Story 1: The Plot Twist Prank

Timestamp: [02:00] - [06:04]

Summary: The episode kicks off with Shayne introducing the first Reddit story from the "Am I the Asshole?" subreddit. The story involves a 33-year-old woman who confronts her neighbor Emily about having dated Emily's husband, Matt. The narrative explores themes of honesty, betrayal, and the complexities of neighborly relationships.

Notable Discussion:

• Trevor reflects on the gravity of the situation, saying, "What a situation to find yourself in" ([04:59]).
• Shayne emphasizes the difficulty of the case, stating, "I don't think this is an open and shut case here" ([05:29]).
• The hosts collectively conclude that the original poster (OP) is not the asshole, highlighting the importance of honesty even when it leads to uncomfortable confrontations ([07:00]).

Plot Twist Reveal: At [05:45], Shayne and Trevor reveal that the initial discussion was a prank meant to test their guests' reactions. This unexpected twist shifts the tone of the episode, showcasing the hosts' playful nature and setting the stage for genuine stories to follow.

Story 2: "Am I the Asshole?" – Unresolved Feelings

Timestamp: [03:11] - [15:02]

Summary: Following the prank, the hosts delve into a real Reddit story from "Am I the Asshole?" about a 22-year-old woman struggling with her boyfriend's unresolved feelings for his ex-girlfriend. The boyfriend, a 24-year-old, has been exhibiting emotional instability since his ex got engaged.

Notable Discussion:

• Angela comments on the emotional turmoil, saying, "That's crazy" ([20:19]).
• Trevor and Shayne analyze the boyfriend's behavior, debating whether his inability to move on justifies the strain on his current relationship ([21:14] – [25:04]).
• The hosts advise the OP to consider ending the relationship if the boyfriend cannot overcome his past, emphasizing self-respect and the need for open communication ([26:03] – [27:03]).

Insights: The discussion highlights the importance of emotional readiness in relationships and the challenges of dealing with a partner who hasn't fully moved past a previous relationship. The hosts advocate for honesty and self-worth, suggesting that staying in such a relationship could lead to further emotional harm.

Story 3: "Am I Overreacting?" – The Mysterious Call

Timestamp: [40:02] - [58:17]

Summary: The next story comes from the "Am I Overreacting?" subreddit, involving a 28-year-old woman who suspects her date is married after seeing "My wife" appear on his car Bluetooth caller ID. Despite his explanations that it was a mix-up with his brother's contact information, her trust is shattered.

Notable Discussion:

• Angela empathizes deeply, stating, "This is soul-crushing. That is awful" ([43:04] – [43:14]).
• Shayne and Trevor explore various theories, including the possibility of manipulation or a genuine mistake, urging caution and trust in one's instincts ([42:20] – [44:56]).
• The hosts stress the importance of transparency in relationships and advise the OP to trust her gut feelings when something feels off ([46:08] – [47:20]).

Insights: This story underscores the significance of honesty and the red flags that arise when a partner shows signs of deceit. The hosts discuss the complexities of trust and the importance of addressing suspicions directly to avoid further emotional distress.

Story 4: Final Relationship Breakdown

Timestamp: [52:04] - [81:02]

Summary: The final story revolves around a 27-year-old woman who accidentally offends her husband with a joke, leading to an unexpected and heartbreaking breakup. She grapples with understanding his sudden departure and seeks advice on how to mend the relationship.

Notable Discussion:

• Shayne highlights the disrespect in the husband's actions, questioning his motives and emotional stability ([65:11] – [67:07]).
• Trevor emphasizes the importance of communication and the detrimental effects of leaving without explanation ([66:57] – [69:16]).
• Angela shares her own experiences, reinforcing the idea that joke-based misunderstandings can have severe emotional consequences ([69:41] – [71:48]).

Plot Twist Reveal and Resolution: As the story progresses, the host narrates the wife's discovery of her husband's infidelity through hidden photos, leading to a complete breakdown of trust. The wife confronts her husband and uncovers his multiple affairs, resulting in a divorce and newfound independence.

Notable Conclusion:

• Shayne reflects on the deep disrespect and manipulation exhibited by the husband, reinforcing the need for self-respect and closure ([76:00] – [78:50]).
• The episode concludes with the realization that the relationships depicted were rife with deception, ultimately advocating for honest communication and personal well-being ([80:00] – [81:02]).

Conclusion

Throughout the episode "Can You Guess The Plot Twist? | Reading Reddit Stories," hosts Shayne, Angela, and Trevor skillfully navigate through a series of emotionally charged Reddit stories, interspersed with humor and unexpected twists. From orchestrating a prank to dissecting genuine relationship dilemmas, the episode offers a blend of entertainment and insightful commentary. Notable quotes and dynamic discussions enrich the narrative, providing listeners with both laughter and valuable takeaways on honesty, trust, and self-respect in relationships.

Notable Quotes:

• Shayne: "What a situation to find yourself in." ([04:59])
• Trevor: "I think it's really tough." ([05:22])
• Angela: "That's crazy." ([20:19])
• Shayne: "We gotta cut it." ([05:43])
• Trevor: "He's been putting her on a pedestal." ([07:20])
• Shayne: "Honesty even when it leads to uncomfortable confrontations." ([07:00])
• Angela: "This is so soul-crushing." ([43:04])
• Shayne: "Trust your gut feelings when something feels off." ([46:08])

Disclaimer: The above summary is based on the provided transcript and aims to encapsulate the key points, discussions, insights, and conclusions from the podcast episode "Can You Guess The Plot Twist? | Reading Reddit Stories" by Smosh.