
Loading summary
Narrator/Advertiser
Lets do the 60 second savings challenge. Step 1 Download Rocket Money. Step 2 Link your accounts and see every subscription you're paying for. Tap one you don't use and cancel it. That's money back every month. Step 3 Create a financial goal. $50 every paycheck. Or let the app automatically move small amounts of cash when you can afford it. In a week, you'll forget you set it up. In a month, you'll see real dollars piling up. In a year, you'll be shocked at how much money you've saved. Upload an Internet or phone bill and let Rocket Money try to lower it. You only pay if they find you savings. On average, Rocket Money members can save up to $740 a year when using all the app's premium features. Users love the app with over 186,000 five star ratings. Make saving money the resolution you actually keep. Start the 60 second savings challenge@rocketmoney.com cancel. That's RocketMoney.com cancel RocketMoney.com cancel Weight Watchers now offers access to affordable GLP1s. Weight Watchers has everything I need from weight loss medications to nutrition support and help with my side effects. With our program, our members are losing more weight with expert nutrition and side effect support.
Shane
Weight watchers prescribing GLP1 medications. It's been life changing.
Narrator/Advertiser
Better results, expert support, lose more weight, make it last. Get started today for as low as.
Spencer
$25 at weightwatchers.com hello and welcome to.
Shane
Smosh Reads Reddit Stories. I'm Shane and today's episode is a classic Am I the Asshole episode. And I'm joined by two good friends. I'm joined by Spencer and a Smosh legend, Mari Takahashi is here. Hi. Full name, the OG host of this channel.
Mari Takahashi
Yeah.
Shane
Yeah.
Mari Takahashi
Well, yeah, I guess it was holding down the fort, not knowing what I was.
Shane
But doing it all. Editing everything. Right. You're doing the whole shebang.
Mari Takahashi
It's one of those you just throw yourself into something and then you never know.
Spencer
Yeah. No, we were looking at a cause.
Shane
I know.
Spencer
Social team wanted to do something with you that was like a throwback. And we were looking at all the old titles.
Mari Takahashi
Don't look at them.
Spencer
Anytime you're in anything, they're like Asian lunch. It's just Mari does anything like Asian blank.
Shane
Like that was like. That was the.
Mari Takahashi
Yeah, that was the time. And also not wrong either.
Spencer
It's like technically it's like Asian Reddit stories.
Mari Takahashi
That is the description of what's happening.
Spencer
Have we done one of those yet.
Shane
Write that down.
Spencer
Asian Reddit space.
Shane
Oh, my God.
Mari Takahashi
It's 2010 all over again. Yeah.
Shane
Yeah. Well, we're happy to have you back.
Mari Takahashi
Thanks for having me. It's fun because it just feels like you're plopped back and you don't know what year it is, but I don't know. The comfort of being around y' all never goes away.
Shane
Yeah.
Spencer
Agreed.
Mari Takahashi
Yeah.
Shane
Well, are you ready to read some stories? Are you ready?
Spencer
You have to read them.
Shane
No, you have to read. I'm taking a break. No, I'm just kidding.
Spencer
One of these days, Shane, like, drops the iPad and it's just blank. It's been blank on there the whole time.
Shane
He's just like, all about. That would be awesome.
Mari Takahashi
That would be amazing.
Shane
Really cool. Our first one is an Am I the asshole? Posted October of 2025. Am I the asshole for replacing pictures of my cousins with pictures of my dog?
Spencer
We'll have to find out more.
Mari Takahashi
Contact needed.
Shane
My grandpa's birthday was a couple weeks ago, six weeks before his birthday. I texted all of my siblings and cousins. There's nine of us. And told them to send me a picture of themselves within the next four weeks so I could put it on a phone case for our grandpa's birthday. Two weeks later, I sent the text again saying I needed a picture of them and anybody that chooses not to send a picture will be replaced by a picture of my dog. I had three cousins tell me to screenshot something from their Instagrams. I didn't respond. I sent a text out the day before. I put in the order saying anybody that did not send a picture of themselves in the next 24 hours would be replaced by pictures of my dog. This is your second warning. Second warning. The same three cousins never sent pictures. Their spots have my dog in a sombrero, my dog at the pumpkin patch, and my dog in a chicken costume. They came over for my grandpa's birthday and saw him open his new phone case. They saw that their pictures weren't on the case and got mad at me for not picking something off their Instagrams like they told me to. I said that I sent three reminders to send me a picture with a clear warning that anybody that did not send a picture would be replaced with a picture of the dog. The they knew exactly what would happen. My grandpa finds it hilarious, but their parents. Oh, thank God. But their parents are telling my parents that I kept them off the phone case on purpose and they want me to apologize. Am I the asshole for replacing Them with pictures of my dog because they never sent me a picture.
Narrator/Advertiser
Woo.
Mari Takahashi
What a ride.
Shane
What a ride.
Spencer
What can be said?
Shane
No, not much can be said.
Mari Takahashi
I mean, I would say to take the time to explain so much of what happened over a phone case valid in being upset about it. That person's going through something, you know, where it's just like they kind of thought.
Spencer
I think they thought they had the best gift of all time. Like they were like, this is gonna make grandpa's laugh.
Mari Takahashi
Grandpa loved it.
Spencer
Grandpa did love it.
Shane
Grandpa loves it.
Spencer
Grandpa also thought it was hilarious that three of the cousins were replaced by dogs.
Shane
Yeah, that's kind of amazing.
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
And those photos of the dogs, probably better than any of the photos of the cousins.
Spencer
It's like, bro, just Google and throw those images on there.
Shane
Yeah.
Mari Takahashi
With that said, the dogs have a lot of variety. They're in different costumes. So there was a lot of thought put into that.
Shane
I agree. At least. Yeah, absolutely. I was gonna say this reminds me though. Cause this type of behavior, I fully understand it. Cause I feel like family group chats.
Spencer
Oh, it is much a thing where.
Shane
People just ignore it. You just like, everyone has their family group chat on. Do not disturb.
Mari Takahashi
Yes.
Spencer
Oh, no. When? I mean, I mean. No, I was gonna say. No, what I was gonna say is this reminds me of getting memes for who memed it or guesses for Shane. Guesses where it's like you have to text everyone a million times and be like, hey, I need you to submit this. And it's like, ah, I can't. There's just no response.
Shane
There's something funny about when something is so easy. You keep pushing it off and it's the thing you don't get done. Whereas if he was like, hey, I need all of us to knit a sweater for Grandpa. There's almost like an argument to be made of. Like, that might be easier to get people to do because it's a bigger undertaking. So it's like, oh, we're gonna take it seriously. But it's a photo, so it's like, I'll send a photo at some point or just look at my Instagram or something.
Spencer
Do we think OP should have screenshotted their Instagram pictures?
Shane
No, this was way funnier.
Spencer
Okay, that's fair.
Shane
And grandpa appreciated it. If he wanted to get petty revenge, he could have picked the worst photo off their Instagram.
Mari Takahashi
True.
Shane
Just something bad. Or like an environmental shot that one of them took on their Instagram. I'm not even in the photo. It's like, it's from your Instagram account.
Spencer
Like a screen. Like, or like their follow count or something like that. Like, ooh, which cousin has the least followers?
Mari Takahashi
I will say if OP was really thinking about Grandpa, though, probably would have made the move to screenshot the Instagram.
Spencer
Yeah. It's like, do you even care about Grandpa? What would Grandpa do?
Shane
I get that. What would Grandpa want, right? But Grandpa really enjoyed this.
Mari Takahashi
He enjoyed the dogs.
Spencer
So you call it op. Do you say Jiff?
Shane
Say op.
Mari Takahashi
Yeah, op.
Shane
Actually, I like OP as if he hates his grandpa. Like, he's like, oh, my op. I'm the op. Yeah.
Spencer
So actually, that was a trick. I knew you said Jif. Yeah, I know that. That's something I know about you is you say Jif. Okay, okay.
Mari Takahashi
That's something that you've clocked about me that you remember that. I don't want that to be like, on my permanent rap sheet that you.
Shane
Remember me about says Jif.
Spencer
Here, my phone is Mari Jif Takahashi.
Shane
Jiff. Brutal. That sucks, dude.
Mari Takahashi
Take that chat clip that.
Shane
The verdict is not the asshole comments. Grandpa liked it. That's all that matters. Not the asshole. Whatever. Grandpa liked it. Someone said, not the asshole. You gave them plenty of warning and told them exactly what would happen if they didn't send. And yeah, you could have screenshot something on their socials, but they didn't want to make any effort, so they didn't need to be on the gift. Someone tagged the subreddit. Malicious compliance. Someone also said, also, let's be real. They probably would complain if OP picked the wrong pic of them off their social media. There's no winning with these types of people.
Spencer
Who would have been the funniest person to jump in on the thread? Like, would it be Grandpa or one of the cousins? Or like, grandpa. I'm thinking Grandpa jumping in the thread.
Shane
Being like, I loved it.
Mari Takahashi
I think Grandpa worrying, the chat being like, was this the time you guys went to the pumpkin patch? You look great. And it's like, grandpa, that's a dog.
Shane
You look good here. It's a dog, Grandpa. Mmm, I don't think so, snookum. I don't think so. Not the asshole. You could have easily just left every human off and put photos of your dog, and it'd be okay because it's your gift, not theirs. And then we have a note here from our producers. Unfortunately, we don't have pictures of the phone case or dog, because according to OP in the comments, I mean this in the nicest way possible, but I have a pretty weird looking dog, so I think pictures of him would be identifiable.
Spencer
Oh, I thought it was gonna be I have an ugly family is what he's gonna say for sure.
Shane
Yeah, my dog's awesome. My family ugly.
Spencer
Yeah, the cousins who did submit, not the ones I wanted.
Shane
That's why Grandpa was stoked. He's like, oh great, your dog and not our ugly. My ugly. Not ugly. That's Bob Ogre. My ugly ugly children. My little, my little ugly children.
Narrator/Advertiser
The number one resolution for people last year was to save more money, but nearly half gave up by February. Don't let that be you. Download Rocket Money to reach your financial goals this year. Track your spending, cut waste and automate savings in one simple app. Rocket Money shows you all your expenses and categorizes them so you know exactly where your money's going and where you're overspending. From there, the app cuts waste by canceling your unused subscriptions and lowering your bills. No customer service needed. With that money freed up, the app will automatically set some cash aside for your goals. Whether it's an emergency fund, paying off debt or saving for vacation, Rocket Money's got you covered. Users love the app with over 186,000 five star ratings and on average, users can save up to $740 a year when using all the app's premium features. Make saving money a priority this year. Go to RocketMoney.com Cancel to get started. That's RocketMoney.com Cancel RocketMoney.com Cancel Wellness doesn't.
Mari Takahashi
Have to be complicated. Sometimes it's just how your home feels when you walk in the door. Pura plus lets you create soft feel good moments with premium fragrances in open concept spaces automatically, beautifully and effortlessly. For a limited time, get a free Pura plus diffuser with your first scent subscription. 2 cents for 12 months, risk free, free for 30 days. Calm your space, lighten your day. Visit pura.com today.
Shane
This episode of Red Stories is sponsored by Quint. In the past I have purchased clothing that only lasted a couple of wears or the material felt extremely cheap and uncomfortable. As someone who is constantly building their wardrobe, I'm looking for premium pieces that have longevity and easy to wear items. Quince has organic cotton sweaters, Polos for every occasion, lighter jackets which are perfect for changing seasons or California weather, jeans, leather tees, activewear, you name it. They literally have everything to build your perfect wardrobe with all the essential staples. I recently purchased the 100% organic cotton rib polo sweater. The description says Smart enough for the office. Easy enough for off duty. Perfect. I don't have to change multiple times a day in between work and going out. And I'm already considering getting it in the other two colors that it comes in. Looking through the website, it's got all the essentials you could ever need. I mean, and it's good material. It's great stuff. I mean, hey, this jacket here, this is Quint's and I love it. Refresh your wardrobe with quints. Go to quince.com PitReddit for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E.com PitReddit free shipping and 365 day returns. Quints.com PitReddit Back to the show Our next story comes from Am I the asshole? September of 2025am I the asshole for not wanting our friend to ever come back to our house after he ate literally everything we owned? My friend a bear.
Spencer
I get both sides.
Shane
My friend Yogi Bear, Goldilocks, my husband and I live abroad. Earlier this year, a mutual acquaintance, let's call him K, reached out saying he'd been scammed with an apartment rental and had nowhere to stay. At first we only offered a weekend, but he was polite, helped around the house and seemed grateful. So we ended up letting him stay the full 20 days he asked for. During that time, some things rubbed us the wrong way. He never bought groceries and multiple times he pretended he was going to pay but forgot his wallet or claimed he could only use Apple. Pay not accepted at our local supermarket. He'd eat way more than his share with. Once my husband and I shared half a pizza and he ate the other pizza and a half. Nice without contributing. Still, we felt bad for him. We felt bad for him. So we let it go. We stayed friendly and a few months later we were planning a 17 day trip. Since he was struggling with rent, we offered him to stay at our place in exchange for taking care of our dog. I even wrote a Google Doc with instructions for the house dog care eat the dog. I even wrote a Google I even. I even wrote a Google Doc with instructions for the house, dog care, gym, access, et cetera. I told him he could eat anything that was going to expire. Fruit, veggies, yogurt, et cetera. When we came back, everything was gone. And I mean everything. The entire fridge, freezer, pantry. He finished two jars of jam, bro. The whole can of who has. Holy. He finished two jars of jam a Jar of peanut butter, a giant Costco bottle of olive oil, condiments, rice, snacks, cheese. Even my husband's supplements, creatine. He was like, oh, I'm so hungry. He's buff as fuck. Yeah, you had all those steroids in the closet? I did them all. He completely destroyed a ceramic pan. And he consumed things that usually last us six months in just two weeks. I honestly suspect he might have taken stuff with him, because it's insane. How much was he get to go back? I didn't confront him, except to ask him to replace the pan, which he mocked me about. It's just a pan. Why are you making it a big deal? Uh.
Narrator/Advertiser
Oh.
Shane
I felt deeply disrespected. Now he keeps texting me, acting like nothing happened, and wants to hang out.
Mari Takahashi
I told him, what.
Shane
You guys want to get dinner tonight?
Spencer
Your place?
Shane
Hey, you guys cooking something? I said, he floats to their. It smells so good. He's gonna bust some, like, cranberries. I told my husband I don't want him in our home ever again. My husband says I'm being too harsh, and if he wants to stay friends, that's his choice. But I feel completely taken advantage of and disrespected. So am I the asshole for not wanting to see this guy ever again and refusing to let him come back to our house? What's this? No Face from Spirited Away. This is like, oh, my God.
Mari Takahashi
I really want the other side. I want the friends.
Spencer
The other side's just, ugh, so hungry.
Shane
I could eat a thing. The other side is a family of raccoons. The only things that remind me of this is stories where wild animals eat a ton of shit. I one time was staying at an Airbnb, and there was a mini fridge on the outside, like, on the back porch that you could use. And there was kind of a little latch. White people shit. And we had like. And we had, like, a full carton of eggs, some milk, all this, like, a whole bag of cheese. And in the night, like, some raccoons got into it. And I'm talking. The whole carton was empty. The whole bag of cheese, shredded cheese was empty. All this stuff. And I'm like, somewhere there's a raccoon that just.
Mari Takahashi
That's so cute.
Shane
A balloon of raccoon. Just like, ah. But it also reminds me of Cocaine Bear, the real story about a bear who got into a bunch of cocaine and ate it all.
Mari Takahashi
There was a movie, right?
Shane
They made a movie, a fictionalized Elizabeth Banks, but in real life, the bear just had A good time and passed out. But in the movie, he killed.
Spencer
I did see people died. No. I did see a video recently of people unloading groceries and a bear comes up and they have no choice but to surrender their groceries.
Shane
Oh, you surrender your groceries to the bear?
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
And it's just. And he knows it.
Spencer
Bear's getting into people food.
Mari Takahashi
Bear's like, oh, I'm on my wallet.
Shane
Oh, you gotta have an apple pay.
Spencer
Then you ruined my pan.
Shane
Okay.
Mari Takahashi
It's just a pan, bro.
Shane
Okay, back to the story. The verdict is not the asshole. And I think that's completely fair to this guy. I very much have the vibe of when we have guests, or if you have someone who's cat sitting or dog sitting or whatever, I'm like, yeah, like take like, help yourself to everything. Everything I do. That's my vibe.
Mari Takahashi
But no one's ever actually the implication.
Spencer
Is that like, within reason.
Shane
Within reason, yes, of course. Like if I'm staying at someone's place or I'm cat sitting for someone or dog sitting and they say that I'm like, I'm gonna still be reasonable. I'm gonna know, like, oh, if they're.
Spencer
Still thinking about fruit gushers, I might have a thing.
Shane
I might have a fruitcusher. Yeah, absolutely.
Spencer
But so my thoughts. I'm gonna play devil's advocate.
Shane
Okay.
Spencer
If he's a hungry boy. Yeah. Have you ever been so hungry? If you are truly. So it was 17 days.
Shane
17 days.
Spencer
If you were in a house for 17 days, think of your apartment. I mean, maybe not specifically yours, but I think I could go through most of the food in my apartment, if not all of it in 17 days.
Mari Takahashi
If you're not buying anything, if you're not buying anything.
Spencer
If you're not getting doordash or anything like that.
Mari Takahashi
Just dry scooping creatine.
Spencer
Yeah. If I'm. If I'm eating a peanut butter and jelly sandwich a day, let's say I'm eating two peanut butter and jelly sandwiches a day.
Shane
Like two jars of jam and a jar of peanut butter.
Spencer
That's not that crazy. But the thing is with most food at home, like, I feel like it's kind of the cycle of like, well, I'm kind of tired of this. Let me buy some more. But if you're committing to those foods, I think you're finishing them.
Mari Takahashi
There is a giant Costco bottle of olive oil.
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
Maybe it's cooking a lot. There's a lot. There's a. But a giant Costco sized olive oil.
Spencer
Guess this, like Olive oil.
Shane
I love olive oil. I'd be using it all the time. That's a lot to get through in 17 days.
Mari Takahashi
He had to get his essential fats every day.
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
My God, he was like the drain. So hungry.
Spencer
You don't like pouring olive oil down the drain.
Shane
Yeah, we love doing that. What's it called? Is it a fatberg? That's like, when it's like a bunch of fat and tissue papers, it coagulates. Coagulates. And it clogs up the drain. Yeah, that's what he's making. He's doing experiments.
Mari Takahashi
Yeah. He's a man of science.
Spencer
He's like, I made a. So I made a volcano out of papier mache.
Shane
Holy crap. See, I almost. This has me almost fascinated. Where the next time they go on a 17 day trip, it's like, hey, leave only lean chicken, broccoli, rice. Come back. He's now a bodybuilder.
Mari Takahashi
Yeah.
Spencer
It's like, now you can do experiments on him. It's like whatever you leave in the house, he will eat.
Shane
He will eat. Like what things can you leave there to see if he'll eat it? Like, what? I just.
Spencer
Dude, performing experiments on your friend is like the funniest phrase ever. It's like, well, I've been performing experiments on you.
Shane
We wanted to see what you would eat.
Spencer
We wanted to see what you would do.
Shane
You would eat anything.
Spencer
Have you guys ever had a friend where it's like you go out to a restaurant together and no matter what's left over, they'll just be like, oh, let me finish that.
Shane
Oh, yeah.
Spencer
Even if it's like the. Yeah, it's awesome. Yeah. It's sick.
Shane
In many ways. It's such a great friend to have someone who will like take leftovers or whatever. I mean, he's kinda like, we have a Luke.
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
Yeah. We don't waste food here at smosh because Luke takes it home.
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
I hope he's cool with us saying that. But like, it's fantastic.
Spencer
Oh, it does. Yeah. We have. Yeah, we have a great guy who takes it home.
Shane
It's a great system.
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
No, they should leave a bunch of Vegemite. Oh, the next time they leave, they should have their normal food. But then like 10 jars of Vegemite and see if he goes through all of that.
Mari Takahashi
I feel like it's an acquired taste. Give him 17 days.
Shane
Give him the most acquired tastes around the world. Yes. Segemite, natto.
Mari Takahashi
Yes.
Shane
Like what?
Spencer
From durian?
Mari Takahashi
Yeah.
Shane
What's the fish? The Fermented fish.
Spencer
But he'll acquire it. He'll acquire the taste.
Shane
I want to see what he'll eat. Yeah. Experiments for me, reading a hypothetical story. This surpasses now where I'm mad into being like, fascinated.
Mari Takahashi
Yes.
Shane
And it's also hilarious.
Mari Takahashi
Yes.
Shane
But yes, disrespectful. He is not being conscientious.
Spencer
Yeah. The pan ruining.
Mari Takahashi
If he's not conscientious of this siloed thing in his life, what else is he not conscientious about? Space. Oh, man. Like taking up space with this.
Spencer
This stuff sitting like this. The whole episode like this.
Shane
Yeah, it's.
Mari Takahashi
And like, clearly her legs are touching and you're like, that's not bothering you. And then you do this.
Shane
And then you're like, someone does that rough.
Mari Takahashi
When there's the touchy in there. And sometimes I'm just like, have you.
Spencer
Guys ever seen when people have like their hair over the back of like.
Shane
The of the plane Old move or.
Spencer
Like their feet up in between the thing? I'd be like, I'm tickling those.
Mari Takahashi
Oh, with no socks on.
Spencer
Yeah. Oh, just dogs out. Yeah. I'm like, it's a liability.
Mari Takahashi
See, if this person was also that person, I'd be mad at this person.
Shane
I think they very likely could be. They seem like that they're not thinking about other people now.
Mari Takahashi
I'm not curious.
Shane
I know he's absolutely the asshole when they brought up the pan. He's like, it's just a pan. It's like, yeah, you ruined it. You gotta pay for it. All right, comments. He didn't consume it all in that time. He emptied your place and took it back to his to last him a while. He stole from you like he was on a shopping spree. That is the most likely scenario. It's a laugh forager. I'm laughing at the idea of him eating it all. That's funny and awesome.
Spencer
Okay, Shaggy.
Shane
Him stealing it. Him stealing it sucks. Someone said. I know, right? What was he otherwise doing drinking a cup of olive oil mixed with some creatine for breakfast every morning? Someone said, not the asshole.
Spencer
Hey, that sounds like something like a fitness bro would do.
Shane
Yeah. Someone said, not the asshole. This person is not your friend. And your husband needs to rethink anyone who mocks his wife over something that person destroyed. This friend has little to no respect for either of you. If your husband wants to lessen himself by continuing this one sided friendship with this guy, it's on him. However, you do not let anyone who treated your home the way he did. Back in again. You can decide if you'll reconsider if this guy apologizes, but he's not allowed to be in your home alone again. Home alone Op said. I think it's because we live outside our home country and it's not that easy for him to make friends here. I feel like he's being overly patient because he's very lonely. Still, I do realize this is something I need to talk to him about. I just needed a bit of validation. But I do plan to have a conversation with him on different terms because a real friend doesn't do this kind of things.
Mari Takahashi
Stop befriending raccoons.
Shane
Yeah, you know, stop befriending forest critters. Anyways, all right, moving on. Our next story comes from Am I the asshole? Comes from October 2025Am I the asshole for saying EW to a picture of my roommate's boyfriend? It's just like Home Alone that's WOOF on a burner account, so hopefully they won't find this I, a 19 year old girl, have been living with my roommate who's 19, since February of last year and ever since we have moved in together our relationship has been total chaos. She has a Great Dane that doesn't have enough space in our apartment. She doesn't care about the cleanliness of the hardwood floors nor being very hospitable towards guests. She is temperamental and gets upset over what seems like nothing and I can't get through to her why my friends and I don't want to spend time with her despite her wanting to be the center of attention constantly. She tends to get upset whenever she cannot be in control of a situation. Whether I have places I wanted to go and she tags along yet insists on going where she wants to until I cave or gets really mad and starts complaining despite the fact that she tagged along with me, not the other way around. She used to be rude to my friends but has been better with that, but since that happened my friends would rather not spend time with her since she tends to be very selfish and we don't have much in common. She expects me to talk to her when she is sad all the time but doesn't care about anything I do as well. Anyway, the other night Anyway, she's a stupid dumb idiot. Anyway, the other night she exploded on me because after sending a picture of her boyfriend I responded ew because I thought it was funny. I had my friends over earlier that day so I'm concerned that may not have helped, especially since she wanted to go out with us, but we said no. She got upset. She got upset and said, I'm constantly mean to her and she regrets ever meeting me. I would normally brush that off, but then when I said I would be going to bed, she said, don't wake up. And I felt that seriously cross the line. She blocked me and won't speak to me. Now am I the asshole? Wow.
Spencer
Many layers.
Mari Takahashi
Oh, to be 19 again.
Shane
Many layers, and I'm gonna eat all of them. Oh.
Spencer
Talking shit about this roommate for, like, 10 minutes and then being like. And then I said, like, I won't.
Mari Takahashi
Hang out with you.
Shane
I'm like, stop trying to prime us against this person. Like, you did an asshole thing. You're like, I don't care how much you hate her. She sent a picture of her boyfriend. You say, ew.
Spencer
I mean, that is pretty funny.
Shane
It's funny.
Spencer
I mean, like, I guess also, like.
Shane
You'Re not on that rapport.
Spencer
Yes, that's what I was thinking.
Mari Takahashi
Yes.
Shane
That's a fully fine response from a lot of people. If, like, you get the joke.
Mari Takahashi
Yes.
Shane
She knew, like, oh, yeah, this person who I hate. But we got this report.
Spencer
Was it, like, boyfriend. Is this the boyfriend reveal?
Shane
Reveal.
Spencer
That's crazy.
Shane
If it's boyfriend reveal, that's rough. Also, though, you know what I'm thinking about is, is, oh, you guys are going out tonight. Can I join? No, I don't think so.
Spencer
How do you say no?
Shane
That's a tough spot to be in. And it's why. When people are like, if I'm ever, like, in a situation, I feel like it happens here where, like, people are like, oh, yeah, we're doing this thing tonight. I'm not gonna, like, ask if I can join. I'll be like, they'll. People walk. You wait for the. Yeah, I wait for an invitation, but I'm not gonna, like, be like, can I come? Cause what do people say to that?
Spencer
Well, you kind of have to say yes.
Shane
You have to say yes.
Spencer
Unless it's like, oh, we have a reservation for five.
Shane
But I also.
Spencer
Yeah. And even then, it's just like, oh, we'll try. We'll call and try to make it for six. Yeah.
Mari Takahashi
Why does that. You just feel so vulnerable, like you're in third grade being like, can I come?
Spencer
I think I know.
Shane
I understand. Even if it's like, a couple good friends of mine and we're a group. But I'm like. I get, like, certain. Like, there's certain situations, certain dynamics. Maybe people want to Talk about something. I don't know. It doesn't bother me. I don't think about it. But man, to ask to join, to go out and be told no. Ooh, and you're 19, you had that layer. Oh, God.
Spencer
The van's pretty full.
Narrator/Advertiser
Yeah.
Shane
Sorry. The Hyundai can't fit anymore. Oh, my God. Yeah, but I think it's like you're 19.
Spencer
It's like if you're in college, you're probably walking some.
Shane
I don't know, Like, I'm like, there's, it's. There's not a good situation. But I'm like, based on everything they wrote, I'm like, you're probably the asshole.
Spencer
I wanna know more about the brand.
Shane
I think they're probably both just assholes to each other. It sounds like having a great match.
Spencer
In an apartment though, that's pretty crazy.
Shane
Great Danes, I thought, can actually manage pretty well in small apartments. Cause they're pretty lazy.
Spencer
I just mean size wise. Oh, size.
Shane
They're huge.
Spencer
I'm like, that's a horse.
Shane
Yeah, it is a full horse.
Spencer
Yeah.
Mari Takahashi
But we also don't know, like, did they already have the dog and then this is just something that they're annoyed with or was it brought in after? You know, it just seems like there's so many layers that they're already not liking about this person.
Spencer
Yeah. Like the circumstances of the move in.
Shane
Roommate situations are messier than anything else.
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
Verdict was asshole. Comments?
Spencer
Comments? Ew.
Shane
Yes, Comments. Why did you include the first two paragraphs? They have nothing. Yeah, valid, straight up. They have nothing to do with the conflict at hand. All it's doing is creating the narrative you want to push forward for the actual question at hand. Are you the asshole for saying EW at a picture of her boyfriend because you thought it was funny? Yes. Yes, you are. It was uncalled for and frankly, mean. Someone said. Someone said you're the asshole. Yeah, it's mean. You're the asshole. She sounds unpleasant to be around, but in that specific interaction, you were being an asshole. Someone said, everyone sucks here. Not gonna lie. You both sound exhausting. Responding EW to someone's boyfriend photo is immature and rude and you are clearly trying to paint your roommate in a negative light. Your roommate has controlling tendencies and blocking and silent treatment as conflict resolution. You both suck.
Spencer
Get paid.
Shane
Don't wake up.
Spencer
Can't wake up.
Shane
Look at my boyfriend.
Spencer
Ew.
Shane
Kill yourself.
Spencer
Don't wake up. Don't wake up. In such a childish, like, oh my God. Like, oh, it's a Child, a war.
Shane
Is going on in this apartment. Oh, man.
Mari Takahashi
The poor Great Dane. Get the Great Dane.
Shane
I know that Great Dane's character just going like. He's like, I raked the whole kitchen. I drank all the olive oil. Come on, school. I'm now going back to the previous story. Imagine that guy making a sandwich out of everything in the house and unhinging his jaw and eating it.
Spencer
If bro's making Shaggy sandwiches every night, he has to.
Shane
All the ingredients for a Shaggy sandwich.
Spencer
A quart of olive oil. I'm saying you probably are. If you're making a Shaggy sandwich, realistically, you're gonna want copious amounts of olive oil.
Shane
Or, like, oh, it's gonna need it.
Spencer
Like oil, vinegar. Cause it's kind of like Italian. I know. He always uses salami. Shaggy's always uses salami on a sandwich.
Shane
Oh, Shaggy sandwich is Eldritch in nature.
Spencer
Yeah, it's unknowable. But he's probably not using. Like, to me, a jam would not be on a Shaggy sandwich.
Mari Takahashi
I disagree. There might be. There might be a little corner of it.
Shane
You could add some jam to the sandwich. You know, if you got some turkey in there.
Spencer
Yeah, it's like a cranberry. Like, in a cranberry. We don't know what's a seasonal Shaggy sauce.
Shane
We would move on.
Spencer
That's what the ghosts want us to do.
Shane
We're not usually like this.
Mari Takahashi
You're trying to convince me.
Shane
We're usually more professional. Yeah. Okay.
Narrator/Advertiser
I didn't realize I was wasting $415 a month until I downloaded Rocket Money. I thought I had my finances under control until the app laid out all my spending and categorized it for me. Takeout shopping and unused subscriptions were quietly draining my account, and as a result, my savings took a backseat. But Rocket Money doesn't just tell you what you're wasting money on. It takes action to save you money. First, the app looks at your income and monthly expenses and calculates how much you can safely spend each day to stay under budget. Rocket Money also fines and cancels unwanted subscriptions for you and even negotiates better rates on your bills so you have more money in your pocket. On average, Rocket Money members can save up to $740 a year when using all the app's premium features. Users love the app with over 186,000 five star ratings. It's time to simplify your finances and take control of your Money. Go to RocketMoney.com Cancel to get started. That's RocketMoney.com Cancel RocketMoney.com Cancel.
Shane
Today's episode of Reddit Stories is also sponsored by Zocdoc. I used to make a lot of excuses when it came to booking doctor's appointments. Oh, I work all day. Oh, I'll do it next week. Oh, I'm just too sleepy. I don't have time to book my dermatologist. Well, that's not the case anymore. With Zocdoc, you can book anytime, anywhere. So when you find yourself worried about a symptom, you can just log in and book your appointment with ZocDoc. ZocDoc is a free app and website that helps you find and book high quality in network doctors so you can find someone you love. I know there have been times where I've been so under the weather I could barely get out of bed. And thanks to Zocdoc, I can find a doctor that does video visits rather than in person so I can talk to a doctor without getting my sick ass out of bed. And there are so many ways to filter to find the right doctor. I specifically filter for doctors who are in network by location, and I look at verified patient reviews. Pretty much everything is on this app. Anything that you're worried about, any symptom you want to look for, any type of doctor you're looking for, you're going to find it there. I mean, I certainly did and I found appointments super fast. Stop putting off those doctor's appointments and go to zocdoc.com PittReddit to find and instantly book a doctor you love today. That's Zocdoc.com PitReddit Zocdoc.com PittReddit Thanks, Zocdoc, for sponsoring this message. Back to the show. Mm, nectarines are so good. Next story comes from Am I the asshole? Comes from October of 2025. Am I the asshole for crashing out? Because my friend called me a passport bro.
Spencer
Ooh, ooh, ooh.
Shane
Brutal.
Spencer
Curious about this one.
Mari Takahashi
I think I know what this is.
Shane
Have you ever heard of a passport bro?
Mari Takahashi
I think so.
Shane
What do you think it is?
Mari Takahashi
Is this somebody who travels to other countries and sleeps with people?
Shane
I think it's, yeah, they're going to another country to try to find a wife in that.
Mari Takahashi
Oh, a wife, specifically.
Spencer
Okay, that's kind of my understanding is like, yeah, this is someone who's traveling to like, kind of.
Mari Takahashi
Yeah, marriage tourism. Gotcha.
Shane
Okay, so it's not a good thing to be called.
Mari Takahashi
And this guy's crashing out.
Shane
And he's crashing out. I'm male, 26, I've been with my boyfriend Luca for five years. Basically, we met when I went to Italy for a photography project and we clicked really fast. I'm fluent in Italian. I've been learning since I was 10, and he is 100% Italian as well. Two years ago, I moved in with him in Italy. A week ago, we visited Canada, where I'm from, and stayed at my friend Emma's house. She was basically all over Luca and flirting with him and everything. Luca told me he was uncomfortable and I told her to stop. And then she started fucking swearing at me, saying shit like I was creepy for going for Italian men. Luca is legit the only Italian man I know. Then she called me a passport bro. And then she was like, you're fucking creepy because he has a more feminine and younger face. So basically you're attracted to younger Italian men. The jumps this girl jumped. Luca and I are the same age. And she was like, you're not teaching him English so he can be clueless and you can feed your white savior complex. And at that point, I fucking crashed out and said some not nice things and told her she should lay off on the Omega verse yaoi she's reading. Which was kind of out of left field for me to say, I admit, but I was mad. Now she's mad and got our mutual friends to gang up on me and Luca, saying I should apologize, but also set boundaries with her. Am I the asshole?
Spencer
Okay, so you have to save these Italians.
Mari Takahashi
This one's got a lot of.
Shane
So it's sounding like this is a.
Mari Takahashi
Shaggy sandwich in itself.
Spencer
This is a shaggy sandwich of a story.
Shane
Yeah, he's not sounding like a passport, bro. He was in Italy, he met someone, then they clicked, and they've been dating for five years. He didn't go to Italy with the intention of this meeting someone. Yeah, absolutely. It doesn't sound like he's taking advantage of this person whatsoever. They're both the same age.
Spencer
From the facts presented, OP is like, has not displayed passport, bro. He could be omitting things.
Shane
No, what it's sounding like is that his friend Emma is just kind of weird.
Spencer
She wants to fuck Luca.
Shane
She was all over Luca. Luca got uncomfortable, said, hey, can you say something? I'm uncomfortable with how she's acting. The second he drew a boundary, she lost her mind and is trying to guilt him for it. So that's what's going on here. Verdict. Not the asshole. Someone said not the asshole. She was the asshole the moment she started flirting with your boyfriend. Then it sounds like she was projecting. She's probably jealous because your boyfriend sounds pretty cool and even trying to play fair for your sake, forget about her. She's not a friend. That went pretty well. Yeah. Don't wake up.
Mari Takahashi
Don't wake up.
Shane
Someone said, not the asshole. Just. What? How does she act like that and think she's in the right? And the fact that your mutual friends are ganging up on you either means this isn't the full story or your friend group has severe brain damage.
Spencer
It's all that Omegaverse yaoi.
Shane
That's what Omegaverse yaoi does to you.
Spencer
Do you know what the Omegaverse is?
Mari Takahashi
No.
Spencer
It's like some people are alphas and they are made to breed specifically the omegas. Right. And the betas are kind of separate from it. I'm not doing a good job explaining it, but it's like it's this whole. That's the omegaverse.
Mari Takahashi
So megas are the breedable ones?
Spencer
Yes.
Mari Takahashi
So then it's an omega verse yaoi. Cause. Okay, yeah.
Spencer
But I think that would just mean it's all gay.
Mari Takahashi
Oh, yo, I'm learning so much.
Shane
Wow. Omegaverse yaoi. Reddit stories would do numbers. Op responded to that comment saying she only told them about my yaoi Omegaverse comment and they genuinely won't listen to my side of the story. They're calling me an internalized homophobe. Someone responded to that saying, time for you to ditch them, I guess. Boy, you literally have a boyfriend. How the fuck are you homophobic when you're in a gay relationship? She's probably just super jealous because you have a hot boyfriend and she does not. What does she even think? She's flirting with a man in a gay relationship and it doesn't occur to her that he's most likely not interested in her? What was her goal here? All of this doesn't make sense. There were additional comments bringing up you can be homophobic if you bash Yowie. But OP wasn't doing that. Really? Just making a dig at Emma, which he regrets. But yeah. She just sounds jealous.
Spencer
No pulling the homophobia card.
Shane
Just like, you know, like Yugi.
Spencer
Yeah, like yaoi.
Shane
No. That's exhausting. That's unfortunately very exhausting.
Mari Takahashi
Very exhausting. Exhausting. But hey, get out of it.
Shane
Get out of it.
Mari Takahashi
Get out of it.
Shane
You're in Italy. Someone said, not the asshole. You need to take that girl to Italy and find her another boy because she is clearly jealous of what she doesn't have. Someone said Italian here. Please do not bring her here. We don't want her. Okay. But bringing her to Italy with the express purpose of finding a boyfriend makes her a passport, bro.
Mari Takahashi
A passport bro. Yep.
Shane
So our next story comes from Am I the asshole? October of 2025.
Spencer
Pretty. These are active recent assholes.
Shane
Yeah. Am I the asshole for being bad at D and D? Probably.
Mari Takahashi
Okay, skill issue maybe, right?
Spencer
Maybe.
Mari Takahashi
I'm already prejudging here using a throwaway.
Shane
Account because my campaign mates know my main account. So I've been playing D and D for about two years and have had a long string of player characters that have died during the campaign. I think the count is at six or seven. I genuinely try not to just put my character in dangerous situations, but I often feel like the rolls just don't go my way. First one was a barbarian and I was going reckless for every attack and then the bad guy got some good rolls and just crit me a few times in a row. Then they finished me off during death saves. Then another one I decided to try being a bard, got silenced and immobilized. Then some generic low level guys just came and beat me up and I was not able to fight back at all. Hey, this guy can't talk. This reminds me of There was a story where the DM created a bird that hates you that just killed that like wiped the party. Cause it was like yeah, this bird hates you.
Spencer
He was mad at his party so he was just like yeah and enter.
Shane
The bird that hates you. The bird that hates you. This one was actually a little funny at how useless I was. In any case, I know I'm not very good and will often try to strategize and my groupmates always seem to be on board and then the plans just don't pan out at all. I play for fun and don't particularly mind being bad, but my friends have been getting progressively more upset at me and even saying things like I'm an asshole for always dying and wasting their time.
Spencer
Oh that's crazy.
Shane
I will genuinely never try to go recklessly into a situation, but it feels like no matter what I do, all the aggression gets focused on me and then I get overwhelmed. I have started asking them if I should just leave the group and let them do their thing. This would be sad for me because this was a group of close friends and I thought we were having a good time. It's only been in the last three to four months that they've started becoming more angry towards me and I genuinely don't know why. In any case, all input would be Appreciated. And there may be a perspective I'm not considering, but am I the asshole for being bad at D and D? Okay, I have Eddie.
Spencer
I mean, no, no, he's not the asshole.
Shane
I was gonna say I have limited DD experience. Obviously, we've done it here at Smosh a little bit, but you're telling a story together, and the DM has. Does have some control on what's going on. The fact that you were silenced, immobilized, and then a group of characters beat you up. I'm like, I'm questioning, like, I think the DM's killing you a little bit.
Spencer
Yeah, it feels.
Shane
Immobilized is pretty intense.
Spencer
It feels like. I know there's a lot of nuance to DMing and so maybe it's truly just a string of bad luck, but it's like, how much can you blame? Like, you know, I would imagine you'd want to collab with the DM to be like, hey, what am I doing wrong? Like, I would talk to the dm.
Mari Takahashi
It's also not just the dm, it's also the group.
Spencer
Yeah, it's like you're the group.
Mari Takahashi
It is a fellowship. It is everyone together. You die as a barbarian. Wow. I mean, that's the rest of the group also not coming through.
Shane
I cannot blame this guy. Six to seven characters dying in a two year campaign. That is absurd. Like, that is going beyond. You can't just roll bad and have that many deaths.
Spencer
You can.
Shane
I can roll pretty bad, but even I didn't die that easily.
Spencer
Maybe, like, I want to know who else is dying. Are they the only person dying in these campaigns?
Shane
Everybody dying? But also the purpose of D and D is to have fun, man. You're not playing it professionally in this context. You're just having a good time. This is kind of like if you're playing pickup basketball and someone's playing way too intensely, it's like, hey, man, we're just having a good time here. We're not trying to, like, we're not trying to make the league. So, like, what league? The NBA?
Mari Takahashi
The Capital L. The league, dude. Capital L. The league.
Shane
Yeah. This just. I'm questioning this DM. I think this DM's killing him.
Mari Takahashi
I think the friend group doesn't like him.
Shane
It also seems the DD drama that I hear is agonizing.
Spencer
It's like some of these D and.
Shane
D groups are going through it.
Spencer
You can't do anything with that close of a group of people for that long. I think there's always inevitably gonna be drama.
Shane
Not all of them. I feel like I hear about good ones but it is a pot that can easily boil. It feels like Comments how old are you? And the other people involved.
Spencer
Beyond that he ran into it how old are you?
Shane
Yeah, that's crazy. How old are you?
Mari Takahashi
Wait, what was it after? How old are you?
Shane
How old are you? And and how old are you? And the other people involved including the DM? Apologies new to posting on Reddit. I am a 28 year old man and my friends are 25, 31, 27, 33. The DM is a 32 year old woman and she says she is trying to stay out of it. Someone said not the asshole. This sounds like a DM issue as much as anything else. A DM shouldn't be killing off players so easily.
Spencer
I'm sorry, how is the DM staying out of it?
Shane
Yeah, the DMs like I don't want any part of this.
Spencer
It's like you're running the game.
Shane
Yeah yeah my dm. Even when things get dicey there, there are always ways to get out of it and that's what makes a good dm. Also, your teammates should have been trying to help you. It's a team game. Yeah, if you die on Death Saves, it's like either the DM is sending someone to kill you during Death Saves or nobody came to rescue you. Yeah, not the asshole. D and D is about having fun with friends. At no point has any group that I have been a part of has ever been upset that someone's character died. There are only three explanations I can see for this. 1. Your friends are jerks 2. There is something left out of the story above. You are taking forever to make decisions or you require 100% of the DMs time while you make a new character which stops the game or some other social thing that is causing the game to be unfun for the group. Or lastly, this is fake AI op responded. They never used to get upset and it felt like the last three to four months was complete about face. I try to be quicker with decision making but these days I get more anxious with each of my turns because I don't want to be wrong. My friends have all been playing for 10 plus years and I was a new addition. Update the next day. Thank you everyone for your insights and support. I decided a few hours ago to reach out to the DM and just let her know I'm going to find a new group or just separate myself from this one. After a long conversation it came out that actually this group was in fact doing this on purpose and the DM was in on it. She ultimately told me because she says she felt guilty that it went so far. But this explains her lack of insight or help, I guess. Apparently this group had trouble getting through fights encounters, and the DM got frustrated that this was interfering with her storytelling. Then when I came around, they found that having all the enemy's attention on the new guy allowed the real players to explore their stories and encounters without having to retreat all the time. Honestly, it seemed like some convoluted logic to me, and I'm assuming they started expressing this anger towards me as a way of keeping me useless via insecurity of my experience and decisions. This inevitably made me feel like it was my fault. And then when my own decision stopped killing me, they would just allow my character to gradually die off by not equitably distributing help. In any case, I'm definitely out of this group, and they definitely are not my friends. This has made me really confused because I just don't really understand why they had to go about this in such a hurtful way. But I appreciate everyone for helping me get the courage to talk to them and push hard enough to actually get some truth. So this group was so bad at D and D that they needed to get someone in to be a punching bag so that they can also.
Mari Takahashi
They're so bad at communication.
Spencer
Oh, there's so many other ways to tackle this issue instead of having it differently.
Shane
Like, what the hell is going on here?
Mari Takahashi
Yikes.
Spencer
Yeah. That's way worse than anything I could have imagined.
Shane
How bad at storytelling do you have to be that it's like, okay, we gotta have someone so they can handle the bad stuff.
Spencer
And even I think there could be a world where you almost communicate with someone where it's like, oh, and I'll make the character that keeps dying and kind of throwing themselves. That is a character choice. That is funny. And maybe they figure a way to keep resurrecting him. And that's part of. That's the cool thing about D and D or any rpg is that you can.
Shane
Yeah. But the setup is that they are purposefully targeting so the others get to play the game. It doesn't make any sense.
Spencer
And that's what I'm saying. There's so many ways to circumvent that issue or be clever about it instead of just stringing a human being along.
Shane
Yeah. It sounds like they're really. It sounds like they're really bad at D. And D as a group. Bad players, bad friends.
Spencer
It sounds like they're just bad problem solvers, period.
Shane
Yeah, straight up.
Mari Takahashi
Yeah, you tell them. Yeah, bad don't wake up.
Shane
The DMs also a bad DM. Cause that just doesn't. That's a world where the logic doesn't make sense, you know, like you're supposed to be telling an interesting story.
Mari Takahashi
Stay out of it.
Shane
Everything in this world hates.
Spencer
Get silenced. Get immobilized.
Shane
Yeah, get beat up. All right, our next story comes from Am I the asshole? September of 2025 another recent one Am I the asshole for drawing an ugly portrait of someone who passed away like a character?
Mari Takahashi
Oh my God.
Shane
Ugly in quotations. So maybe OP does not think yeah, maybe they don't think for context. This happened a few years ago during my second to last year of high school. I recently shared this story with my friends at university and they argued over whether I was in the wrong, which is why I'm posting this. In my second to last year of high school, a girl in our grade passed away. She was terminally ill and the school did a short assembly speech and a memorial was set up. Admittedly, I was not that close with her. We were acquainted and spoke occasionally, but we weren't close friends per se. On the day before her memorial, I drew a portrait of her and brought it to school. I noticed that in the area set aside for her memorial, there were some framed photographs of her as well as portraits drawn by her friends. To be clear, I was not even planning on sharing my portrait to begin with. I intended to see if other people were sharing portraits first since I didn't want to overstep. I would also say that I am a good artist. I had a reputation as the class artist. When I placed my portrait next to the other portraits drawn of her, one of her friends came up to me and told me that my drawing wasn't welcome. I was confused since I saw that there were other portraits, but I realized that they were all drawn only by her close circle of friends. I was also told that my drawing was so ugly that it had to have been on purpose to mock her. Multiple people mocked my drawing. What I don't understand is that even if my drawing was ugly, that was obviously never the intention. I made the drawing to commemorate her and she had no right to disrespect me so openly. Even if she were a close friend of hers, she didn't have any right to decide whose artwork could or could not be placed on the memorial. Am I the asshole for refusing to take down my artwork. This was years ago. I do not have the drawing or any images of the drawing. I do remember that it was a pencil drawing done on a sheet of paper. All the other drawings at the memorial were also pencil drawings. Edit number two thank you for all the comments. I just wanted to clarify a few things for those who have been asking. Yes, I was grieving. You do not have to be close friends to feel the emotional impact of their death. Secondly, I only mentioned that I was the class artist to corroborate the fact that I am not a bad artist and so I was singled out for not being in their friend group. My motivation was the same as everyone else. Thirdly, this was an open memorial. People brought all kinds of things. Chocolates, pencils, they may have borrowed. Chocolates, chocolates, pencils they may have borrowed from her. Random things like that. The only people to bring drawn portraits were I and some of her closer friends.
Mari Takahashi
Pencils.
Spencer
She loved pencils.
Shane
She loved pencils. The verdict is asshole.
Narrator/Advertiser
The number one resolution for People last year was to save more money, but nearly half gave up by February. Don't let that be you. Download Rocket Money to reach your financial goals this year. Track your spending, cut waste, and automate savings in one single simple app. Rocket Money shows you all your expenses and categorizes them so you know exactly where your money's going and where you're overspending. From there, the app cuts waste by canceling your unused subscriptions and lowering your bills. No customer service needed. With that money freed up, the app will automatically set some cash aside for your goals. Whether it's an emergency fund, paying off debt, or saving for vacation, Rocket Money's got you covered. Users love the app with over 186,000 five star ratings, and on average, users can save up to $740 a year when using all the app's premium features. Make saving money a priority this year. Go to rocketmoney.com cancel to get started. That's rocketmoney.com cancel rocketmoney.com cancel and I.
Shane
Think I never maybe for not taking.
Spencer
It to me if someone was like oh that's not welcome here, I'd be like oh shit, I need to leave the house. I need to leave the school.
Shane
Yeah, I think the verdict makes sense because op in the way they're writing it and I know it's been some years, but it seems like they're making this all about themselves and I don't think it's that the drawing was ugly I think it's that she keeps mentioning it was, like, me and her closer friends. It's like, all right, so, like, her closer friends probably don't even know you that well, so they're like, why are you bringing this here? I don't know. I've never. You know, I never went to high school in person, so I never experienced anything like this. Obviously, multiple layers of that. So I don't know the etiquette and nuances of it.
Spencer
I mean, I do think it is always kind of like a thing when this is a weird topic, but when someone dies, it does feel. You almost feel protective of, like, oh, they were my friend in that way. And if someone comes in who it's like, oh, you barely even talk to them. Maybe that might have been their POV is like, why are you grieving? Where it's like. But it's also not a competition. Like, there's so many layers to this.
Shane
So many layers. Yeah.
Spencer
Grieving, competition. Challenge.
Shane
Pit.
Spencer
Challenge. Pit. Grief. Yeah. I mean, but it's like, draw. Like, I don't think they're. Asshole's a strong word, I think, for this. But, you know, they drew a picture, they tried to put it up. Like, I don't know.
Shane
It sounds a little bit like, yeah, everyone was grieving there, not just you. And this was a complicated situation, and they. They did. They felt offended by that for whatever reason. And it does. I think it ultimately just seems like she made it about herself. Yeah.
Mari Takahashi
Well, I think initially it probably wasn't. And she was also a teenager.
Shane
Yeah.
Mari Takahashi
You know, going through grief and these really heavy feelings. And this was an expression of, how can I use my talents to, you know, honor somebody?
Shane
Right.
Mari Takahashi
And trying to get through those feelings as a teenager is already so, so big. But now looking back on it, I would agree that not being able to think about what's external and what you can't control and making it about the one thing that you can control is, which is yourself and making it about yourself. I would agree that. Yeah, asshole. But originally, probably not.
Shane
Not that. Yeah. We're not saying you're a bad person for what you did. It's just like, oh, here's why what happened, happened.
Mari Takahashi
Mm. It's like, what can you control now as an adult? You know, looking back on the situation, but I think agreeable that, like, as a teenager. I mean, come on.
Shane
It is a weird situation. Yeah.
Spencer
Someone telling you, like, your drawing's not welcome here, though, that would send me. I would crash out. Yeah, I might crash out.
Shane
Yeah.
Spencer
I'D be like, ew.
Mari Takahashi
Ew.
Spencer
Someone saw the drawing of the girl and said, ew.
Mari Takahashi
Yeah. No, that's really hurtful.
Shane
Oh, super hurtful.
Mari Takahashi
And especially, like, you know, as a reflection of not only you wanting to do something nice for somebody, even if you didn't know that person, I think that it is still your way of expressing your art.
Shane
Right.
Spencer
Maybe OP is just, like, legit and annoying person that nobody likes. And so when they brought the drawing there, everyone was like, we don't want that.
Shane
It's possible.
Spencer
And they left that part out of the story. It's like, op, 19. Annoying.
Shane
Yeah, I think. Cause I think I am a little confused. Like I said, I'm speaking from a very outside perspective when it comes to high school, but an open memorial. I'm like, you kind of think everything would be welcome. The whole school's bringing stuff.
Spencer
Chocolates and pencils. Weird thing to leave.
Mari Takahashi
Pencils that you borrowed.
Spencer
Where's the effort?
Mari Takahashi
Pencils that you had borrowed. It's like, here's the back.
Shane
High school's such a complicated, rough place. And then you add this layer to it. So.
Mari Takahashi
And you're, like, visible in your scene, and you're probably feeling like everyone's judging every move you make while you're in that direction.
Spencer
So then to bring a drawing up and have someone be like, mm, mm.
Shane
Mm, Yeah, I would be mad. Yeah, I get that. I also think it's a tough one to, like, recount, because I'm like, that's such a. Like, I don't know. With a story like that, I'm like, I wasn't there in a moment. Because that sounds like such a wild thing to say at an open memorial that I'm like, I don't know. You were in high school. What your relationship to these people were in high school. What the vibe of everything. What if you were.
Spencer
What if OP was a bully?
Shane
We don't know all that stuff. And some people, like, don't reconcile with themselves being bullies back in high school. Yeah. They don't think they were bullies back in high school. And there's just a lot of stuff that's going on where I'm like, at face value. Yeah. It doesn't sound like it was.
Spencer
I need more details.
Shane
But the way they're telling the story is, I think, where the asshole verdict is kind of coming from. So the verdict was asshole, but the comments are kind of all over the place. We have one. You're the asshole. You didn't draw the portrait to mock Her. But you did make a girl's tragic early death about you. And even years later, you're making this moment about you. Her friends likely felt like you were encroaching on this moment. They lashed out at you in grief, which isn't fair, but they were children who had just lost a friend. You should let this one go. Has like 4,000 upvotes. OP said, Fair enough. Someone said, no.
Spencer
Hit him with the fair enough.
Shane
Someone said no, assholes. Here you are all kids who lost someone their own age that they knew. For some of those kids, it may have been their first experience with death. I know death is always hard, but there's something a little extra jarring about losing someone your age when you're that young. Everybody grieves differently. And while you didn't do anything wrong, I also understand why they lashed out. I'm sure there was nothing wrong with the drawing, and they were just being teenagers, which is emotional enough on its own without adding losing a friend to the mix. Lastly, someone said, you said that you intended to honor the deceased. I can't know if the multiple people who mocked your picture were bullying you or if it really was an unflattering picture. You admitted that you and the deceased weren't close. On the surface, since I can't know what anyone was thinking, it seems that everyone behaved badly. No one should have mocked your artwork, and you should have taken it down in the interest of peace at a funeral. Everyone sucks here. Interesting.
Mari Takahashi
That's such a hard thing to do as a 17 year old, to have your art mocked and be like, you know what? You're right. I'm not gonna make it about myself. I have so much empathy for a teenager going through that totally adult different story.
Shane
It's a tough thing too. It's one of those stories where it's like we're trying to draw these lines of who's in the wrong, who's in the right. I'm like, it's an awful situation. And yeah, like, you're all teenagers going, like, dealing with grief and things are complicated. Like, yeah, I do agree with, like, let it go. Like, move on.
Mari Takahashi
Agreed. Yeah. I think judging how somebody grieves is such an interesting thing, because it's probably a projection of how we're judging ourselves of how we're grieving, you know? And, like, that's a projection. But, yeah, letting it go.
Narrator/Advertiser
Agreed.
Mari Takahashi
It's been years. It's a sucky situation. All of it was sucky.
Shane
You get a Jake.
Mari Takahashi
It's high school, and, you know it's like maybe it is bringing it back to the point of honoring that person.
Shane
Right?
Spencer
Draw better.
Mari Takahashi
Oh, wow. Wow, Spencer, Anything else?
Shane
Get better at drawing, Dude, I would.
Spencer
Have left your pencils. Or chocolate. I'm sorry, I'm really hung up on that. Yeah, you are.
Shane
No, it has me wondering what those memorials do, like, after. What do they do with all the stuff?
Mari Takahashi
Give them to Spencer. This guy loves pencils.
Shane
He loves these. Loves those pencils.
Spencer
I would commemorate the pencils.
Shane
All right, it's time for our final story Comes from. Am I the asshole Am I the asshole for cheating at an eating competition?
Spencer
He's back.
Shane
No, it's not him. He wants. Wouldn't eat a cheat. So our local restaurant that has really good wings was hosting a hot pepper eating competition recently.
Spencer
Y' all did a few of those?
Shane
Yeah, with. Yeah, we've had a few of those with a bunch of coupons for free wings on the line. I have a weird genetic quirk where my body doesn't register capsaicin normally, so my spice tolerance levels are way higher than normal. So I entered the competition and won the coupons, but my friends are now telling me that I cheated and I should have let normal people compete and get the wings. So Reddit, am I the asshole for competing? The wings are so good, though.
Spencer
He's like.
Shane
He's like, you're an X Men. I was gonna say he's like, unbreakable.
Spencer
But for eating wings.
Shane
That's how shit works, man. What's his name?
Spencer
Lance Armstrong and his big ass heart. And the drugs.
Shane
And the drugs help. Joey. Joey Chestnuts. You can't tell me that guy has, like a normal stomach. He's gotta have some sort of genetic thing going on. Oh, I'm sorry. Oh, that's being like, oh, NBA players. Like, you guys are all cheating. You're all really tall. Yeah, can't do that. No.
Spencer
But him having like, the mutant power of not being able to, like, taste, that's.
Shane
That's kind of awesome.
Spencer
Yeah, it's like, that's your calling.
Shane
Yeah, truly.
Mari Takahashi
But then there's a sadness also of not being able to experience spice.
Spencer
There is a sadness.
Shane
That's true. That's sad.
Spencer
That's the sacrifice, I'm gonna say, though.
Shane
Like, I wonder if his butt has the sacrif. Same powers. That does. There's a second part.
Mari Takahashi
Second part of the asshole to it.
Shane
That was when the first time I had to have a habanero pepper here, I was like, oh, my God, that was awful. It was like, horrendous. And then later, when I used the bathroom, I was like, that was worse. That was terrifying. I was scared. Yeah.
Mari Takahashi
First time I did have an error on the channel, it was with the warp zone and one of the warp zone. And I went into the bathroom at the same time. After the shoot was done, we came out like, 45 minutes later. the same time. We were like, they had y' all.
Spencer
Eating so many peppers back then.
Shane
So many habanero peppers over the years. Like, easily a dozen.
Spencer
Like, I think it's time to bring it back. We gotta have, like, Angela and Amanda. Like, we would actually be down, like, has enough time pass, like. Cause we brought back five nights at Freddy's, like, last year or something like that. And I'm like, is the time. Is it pepper time again?
Shane
I might just. Pepper time. I can just do it. I'm just gonna do it on Smoshmouth. Just going to be talking.
Spencer
I'll just pop.
Shane
I'm going to do that. Do smelling salts at the same time. Just be fucked up.
Spencer
Have you ever done smelling salts?
Mari Takahashi
I haven't done a smell, but I know it's crazy.
Shane
I did it once.
Mari Takahashi
Is it actually, it's crazy. I just always watch juju mufu have it.
Shane
I did it once for a TikTok. I was at home by myself, and I was like, I've always been curious, so I'm going to do it. And, like, you truly just buy it. It's a cheap.
Mari Takahashi
You get a ball experience.
Shane
It is.
Spencer
It's like getting slapped in the face.
Shane
You know, like, how horseradish, like, does that. Imagine that times a million where, like, you truly. Like, the bottle was here, and I went like. I was like, okay, I'm gonna try this. And I have the TikTok. I could. We could show it a second of it. I see God. I see God. Oh, my God. It's crazy. I was genuinely like, I'm gonna try to, like, not react that much. I'm gonna do my best. And it's not like. It's also just, like, the moment, and then it doesn't go away for a while. And I was just like. I just cry in tears. So, I mean, it wakes you up.
Mari Takahashi
So what? Okay, so people do it before, like, lifting weights and stuff. What did it make you want to do if you like, you just, like, had the superpower.
Shane
I don't think enough people use it like that, but it truly is like, oh, my. Adrenaline, everything. I was like, oh, my. But mostly it was here, and it's just like, it goes through. You feel your entire, like start taking olive oil. It's nuts.
Mari Takahashi
Just chugging that olive oil.
Shane
It was unbelievable. It's not painful. It's just like, whoa.
Spencer
Are either of y' all in the video where Cordy eats the raw onion?
Mari Takahashi
I don't think so.
Spencer
And she's like crying the whole time.
Shane
No, it's not the raw onion. It was the.
Spencer
There's a raw onion. Where she takes a bite of a raw onion and like there I have.
Shane
Like very bites of raw onions. That's not so bad. Courtney did the. No, Courtney did the chip. The one chip.
Spencer
The one chip challenge.
Shane
She did that. And truly we almost were like, should we cut? Are you okay? That was back on show with no name.
Mari Takahashi
What's that chemical that's on, like sour patch candies and stuff?
Spencer
Oh, Garrett's favorite.
Shane
Oh, malic acid.
Mari Takahashi
Yeah.
Shane
I don't react to that.
Mari Takahashi
That's.
Shane
See, I have what this guy has. Malic acid. That's a weird Super Bowl Sour stuff. Doesn't. Just doesn't. It reaches like a limit and then it doesn't get more sour.
Mari Takahashi
I'm like thinking about the malic acid and my mouth's already like, I did.
Shane
So much malic acid on either Eat it. And I just was fine.
Mari Takahashi
Say that sentence without the malic.
Shane
I know I did so much acid. Comments. Congrats. You are the Michael Phelps of chicken wings. If he wasn't cheating by having a genetic advantage when it comes to swimming, you weren't cheating by having a genetic advantage when it comes to spicy food. Someone said it's like telling a guy who's 7ft tall not to enter basketball dunking competition so guys under 6ft can have a fair chance. Someone said. Fuck that. You didn't cheat. Your friends are weak minded individuals. Not the assholes. Someone said your friends. What?
Mari Takahashi
Lion says.
Shane
Someone said your friends are stupid. They should have bet on you winning. Not the asshole.
Spencer
Bet on it.
Shane
Someone said, we need to get you on hot ones. Update. Thanks, guys.
Spencer
I guess update.
Shane
I love hot ones. Thanks, guys. Sean Evans here. Thanks, guys. I guess the consensus is that the chicken wings gods blessed me and my friends are just jelly. I now have to embark on the holy pilgrimage to all hot pepper contests in the Fire Nation to conquer them all. Wish me luck. Since many people asked. No, it doesn't hurt throughout the whole body, nor on the way out. Wow. So he's got superpower all the way through.
Mari Takahashi
That's true power.
Shane
That's awesome.
Spencer
Unbreakable.
Shane
That's really cool.
Mari Takahashi
What else do you do? Other than, like, winning these contests and getting free T shirts? What do you do with this power?
Spencer
Hey, what else do you need? I need.
Shane
That's kind of all you need? Just any. Almost so many restaurants you could go to and probably get free stuff. Cause they all have competition.
Spencer
Just me sitting down at Chili's.
Shane
Hey, I'll eat whatever you want. Just give me free wings. Free stuff. Like that guy could be on every single wall at so many restaurants. Halal guys has their wall of fire, whatever, where you have to do their challenge.
Mari Takahashi
He just doesn't have to pay for dinner.
Shane
Just go do that. Anyways, well, that's all our stories today. And they. I cried laughing nonstop. This was amazing.
Spencer
The guy eating. The guy who eats is what favorite guy?
Shane
The man who eats. The man who eats these stories. Hey, they ate. Yep. Mari, thanks for being here.
Mari Takahashi
Yeah, thanks for having me. This is great.
Spencer
Yeah.
Shane
So fun. And, Spencer, you're out of your mind, as always. Thank you so much for watching and listening. Before we go, Mari, is there anything you want to shout out? Anything you're working on or anywhere people can find you?
Mari Takahashi
You can find me at Atomic, Mari, as usual. And I don't know, I'm just up to a bunch of stuff. Enjoying life.
Spencer
Oh, yeah.
Shane
Hell yeah.
Spencer
Sick life.
Shane
Sick. Thank you for watching and we'll see you next Saturday.
Date: February 7, 2026
Host: Shane Topp
Guests: Spencer Agnew, Mari Takahashi
In this classic “Am I The Asshole?”-themed episode, host Shane Topp is joined by Smosh cast regular Spencer and longtime Smosh legend Mari Takahashi. Together, the trio reads a wild collection of recent Reddit stories, providing their gut reactions, heartfelt advice, and signature comedic banter. This episode covers tales involving family drama, overstepping roommates, intense food situations, awkward social dynamics, and the pains of tabletop group drama. Mari’s nostalgic return brings an extra layer of warmth and hilarity, as the group navigates tall Reddit tales with refreshing honesty.
[03:19 – 09:32]
Story:
A Redditor coordinated a family photo phone case for Grandpa’s birthday, repeatedly asking cousins for new photos. After multiple reminders and clear warnings (“send a pic or be replaced by my dog”), three cousins never responded. Their spots were filled with silly dog photos (dog in a sombrero, pumpkin patch, chicken costume). The non-participating cousins got mad at the final result, while Grandpa loved it.
Insights & Commentary:
Memorable Moment:
Shane: “If he wanted to get petty revenge, he could have picked the worst photo off their Instagram.” [06:51]
[13:02 – 24:09]
Story:
A desperate acquaintance named “K” stays with a couple, promising to help around the house. Later, while house-sitting and tasked with eating any perishables, K devours literally everything in the fridge, freezer, pantry (entire Costco bottle of olive oil, jars of jam, husband’s creatine), and even ruins a ceramic pan—without offering to replace anything. The couple is divided: one wants to cut contact; the other feels that's harsh.
Insights & Commentary:
Memorable Moment:
Shane: “What things can you leave there to see if he'll eat it?” [20:27], leading to ideas like filling the pantry with Vegemite and natto as an experiment.
Consensus:
Not the asshole. The group enjoyed the outlandishness but firmly supported the absent friend's boundaries.
[24:09 – 32:07]
Story:
A strained roommate dynamic comes to a head when the OP says “Ew” in response to a photo their roommate sends—specifically of the roommate’s boyfriend. The roommate explodes, accuses OP of always being mean, and blocks them.
Insights & Commentary:
Memorable Exchange:
Spencer: “‘Don’t wake up.’ Can’t wake up.” [30:15], riffing on the melodrama.
[34:40 – 39:59]
Story:
A Canadian in a five-year relationship with his Italian boyfriend brings him to visit Canada. A supposed friend flirts with the boyfriend, gets rebuffed, and accuses OP of being a "passport bro" (suggesting he’s exploiting international romance). The friend later rallies their circle against OP.
Insights & Commentary:
Notable Quote:
Shane: “Get out of it. Get out of it. You’re in Italy!” [39:37]
[40:07 – 48:53]
Story:
A D&D player keeps losing characters (six or seven deaths in two years; mostly via bad rolls or group inaction). Lately, friends grow hostile, claim he’s “wasting their time,” and he wonders if he’s to blame.
Insights & Commentary:
Memorable Moment:
Mari: “They’re so bad at communication.” [47:47]
[49:26 – 59:49]
Story:
A high schooler creates a memorial drawing of a classmate who passed away, only to have her friends angrily declare it unwelcome and mock its style. OP defends her intent, feeling excluded and insulted.
Insights & Commentary:
Notable Quotes:
Mari: “Judging how somebody grieves is such an interesting thing, because it's probably a projection of how we're judging ourselves of how we're grieving.” [59:49]
[60:39 – 67:28]
Story:
A contestant wins a hot pepper eating contest due to an extreme genetic tolerance for spice, while friends claim this is "cheating" and suggest he shouldn’t have entered.
Insights & Commentary:
Memorable Moment:
Shane: “Congrats. You are the Michael Phelps of chicken wings.” [65:45]
Mari Takahashi:
Shane Topp:
Spencer:
The episode balances hilarious group chemistry with occasional heartfelt reflection, never shying from poking fun at themselves and the stories’ absurdities. Mari adds nostalgic flair and thoughtfulness to the chaos, while Spencer and Shane keep the pace lively with sharp wit and goofy hypotheticals. The team delivers a mixture of laugh-out-loud moments, sharp advice, and empathetic analysis of human behavior.
A quintessential Smosh Reads Reddit Stories episode: smart, playful, occasionally spicy (literally), and always deeply human. Mari’s return provides a nostalgic throughline, while Shane and Spencer keep the laughs rolling and the advice real. If wild family drama, food fails, or tabletop betrayal are your thing, this one’s a must-listen.