Podcast Summary: So True with Caleb Hearon Episode: Charlie and Natalie Are in The Queue Release Date: July 3, 2025

Introduction In this episode of "So True with Caleb Hearon," hosted by the beloved gay comedian Caleb Hearon on Headgum, Caleb is joined by musician Charlie Puth and podcast personality Natalie McCray. The trio delves into topics ranging from podcast engagement within the LGBTQ+ community to personal romantic experiences, all while maintaining their signature humor and candidness.

Podcast Preparation and Engagement The episode kicks off with Caleb addressing the preparation for the show, highlighting that neither he nor his guests regularly listen to podcasts. This sets a relatable tone for listeners who might find themselves in similar situations.

• Caleb Hearon [01:34]: "You guys are supposed to prepare a. So have you guys listened to the show? Be honest."

Charlie acknowledges having listened to clips but emphasizes the entertainment value, setting up a humorous dynamic between the hosts.

• Charlie Puth [01:53]: "Because the clips were so funny."

Discussion on LGBTQ+ Community Engagement Caleb raises a poignant question about why gay men seem to disengage from his podcast, noting a lack of follow-back on social media compared to lesbians.

• Caleb Hearon [06:23]: "But it's gay guys. Gay guys don't follow me. You're blocked. They don't support me."

Natalie and Charlie explore potential reasons, touching on competitiveness and scarcity mindset within the gay male community.

• Natalie McCray [06:48]: "I think there is a competitiveness among gay men."

• Charlie Puth [08:04]: "And let's just name them that have a different social situations..."

Romantic Life Updates The conversation shifts to personal lives, with both Charlie and Natalie sharing their current romantic statuses. Natalie describes herself as "30, flirty and thriving," while Charlie expresses a longing for deeper connections despite being single.

• Natalie McCray [11:13]: "I'm 30, flirty and thriving. I'm going on dates, seeing if anything sticks, trying to love myself."

• Charlie Puth [12:44]: "I love New York. So that's combo."

Caleb humorously reflects on his own dating struggles, blending self-deprecation with insightful commentary.

• Caleb Hearon [13:03]: "I did move to New York to find love, but I wonder if I'm capable of it."

Anecdotal Stories and Humor Caleb shares an amusing story about a failed attempt to charm an Avis rental car employee to secure a vehicle, highlighting his social interactions and the humorous side of dating mishaps.

• Caleb Hearon [42:01]: "I was like, hey, hey, listen, it's just me and you..."

Natalie and Charlie add their humorous takes, creating a lighthearted atmosphere.

• Charlie Puth [43:33]: "He was like, oh my God, I'm sorry."

True or False Game Segment The trio engages in a lively game of "True or False," testing each other's knowledge with quirky facts. This segment not only entertains but also showcases their camaraderie and quick wit.

• Caleb Hearon [58:29]: "Bamboo can grow up to 35 in one day."

• Charlie Puth [59:17]: "No, it's tea."

Natalie impressively answers several questions correctly, adding to the playful competition.

Closing Remarks and Promotions As the episode nears its end, Caleb encourages listeners to engage further through Patreon for exclusive content, while also promoting Charlie and Natalie's own podcasts. The conversation wraps up with expressions of mutual appreciation and affection among the hosts.

• Caleb Hearon [81:58]: "We're donating it."

• Natalie McCray [82:05]: "If you made it this far..."

Notable Quotes

• Caleb Hearon [06:21]: "It's a competition mindset, a scarcity mindset, especially when there's a kind of outspokenness or confidence..."

• Natalie McCray [07:31]: "Sometimes people just act like they know you, and it's like it's okay to be like, I don't know who you are. I'm giving you warmth."

• Charlie Puth [08:14]: "You're the sociopath I thought you were."

Conclusion "Charlie and Natalie Are in The Queue" offers listeners an engaging blend of humor, personal anecdotes, and insightful discussions about social dynamics within the LGBTQ+ community. Caleb Hearon, alongside his guests, creates a welcoming space that balances lighthearted banter with thoughtful conversations, making it a compelling listen for both regular followers and newcomers alike.