Two wars escalate abroad with political violence at home

Summary

Sources & Methods (NPR): “Two wars escalate abroad with political violence at home”

Date: September 11, 2025
Host: Mary Louise Kelly
Guests: NPR correspondents Odette Youssef and Greg Myre; Senator Alyssa Slotkin

---

Episode Overview

On the anniversary of September 11th, this episode examines national security flashpoints at home and abroad. Host Mary Louise Kelly is joined by NPR correspondents to discuss sudden escalations in the Israel-Hamas and Russia-Ukraine conflicts, as well as a surge in political violence within the US, notably the high-profile shooting of conservative activist Charlie Kirk. Later, Senator Alyssa Slotkin (D-MI)—a former CIA officer—reflects on the evolution and politicization of America’s national security institutions since 9/11, and what keeps her hopeful amid growing polarization.

---

Roundtable Discussion

1. Escalations in Two Major Wars

(03:19–05:25)

• Middle East:
  • Israel conducted an airstrike in Doha, Qatar—targeting Hamas leaders during peace talks.
    • "Israeli leader Benjamin Netanyahu unleashed this airstrike in Qatar as Hamas leaders gathered to discuss a peace plan backed by the Trump White House." —Greg Myre (04:33)
  • The attack is notable for taking place in a long-standing US ally and key mediator.
• Ukraine/Europe:
  • Russia escalated attacks, sending drones into NATO-ally Poland’s airspace.
  • NATO responded by scrambling fighter jets; seen as a test of alliance resolve.
    • "Russia's Vladimir Putin has stepped up attacks on Ukraine... Now he sent at least nine drones into Poland, seemingly as a way to see how the US and NATO might respond." —Greg Myre (04:02)

Key insight: Both aggressions occurred "despite President Trump's stated intent to end the wars," with foreign leaders seemingly unconcerned about US repercussions.

---

2. Political Violence at Home: The Shooting of Charlie Kirk

(01:54–03:19)

• Kirk was shot during a campus appearance in Utah; suspects remain unidentified.
• The incident highlights "the growing threat to national security" from political violence and rampant, reactionary speculation online.
  • "I’m just very concerned that the longer we go, some of this really incendiary rhetoric... is just going to keep on churning." —Odette Youssef (02:31)

---

3. 9/11’s Legacy: How American Security Has Changed

(05:35–11:21)

• Early Intelligence Warnings:
  • Greg Myre recounts covering the 1995 capture of Ramzi Yousef (1993 WTC bomber) in Pakistan, unraveling links to Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and failing early warnings of al Qaeda tactics.
    • "Here in 1995, we knew the potential target, the World Trade Center... using multiple airliners as weapons." —Greg Myre (07:16)
• Intelligence Adaptation:
  • Post-9/11, the CIA transformed into a paramilitary force, spearheading early actions in Afghanistan.
    • "It was transformed from an agency that gathered and analyzed intelligence... became a very different agency." —Greg Myre (08:44)
  • Creation of Department of Homeland Security and expansion of federal focus on foreign terrorism.
    • "The apparatus that was constructed right after 9/11 to protect the homeland was enormous. But the attention at the time really was on these foreign terrorist organizations." —Odette Youssef (10:00)
• Missed Domestic Extremism:
  • The focus on foreign terror meant domestic threats—from Oklahoma City to today’s white supremacist violence—were under-prioritized.
    • "The most lethal and persistent threat on the homeland, according to former FBI Director Christopher Wray, has been violent white supremacists." —Odette Youssef (10:47)

---

4. Current Turmoil in US Intelligence

(12:37–14:28)

• Upheaval as the Trump administration slashes staff, replaces agency heads, and allegedly censors intelligence not aligning with political narratives.
  • "We've already seen very clear instances of top national security officials being dismissed because assessments about Iran or Venezuela are at odds with what President Trump has been saying publicly." —Greg Myre (13:24)
• Redefinition of "terrorism" questioned—e.g., the administration classifying Venezuelan drug cartels as terrorist actors.
  • "Drug cartels have not traditionally fallen under the ambit of national security work... there’s concern... when the terrorism landscape is more complex than it’s ever been." —Odette Youssef (14:28)

---

5. OSINT (Open Source Intelligence) Picks of the Week

(15:05–17:47)

• Tom Hanks’ “Wokeness” Controversy:
  • Trump pressured West Point to rescind a civilian service award for Hanks over his perceived politics.
    • "Trump got wind of this, complained publicly and loudly, saying Tom Hanks is way too woke... and the West Point Alumni Association announced that they were... canceling the ceremony." —Greg Myre (16:17)
• Violent Extremism and Fashion:
  • Shein’s accidental modeling of a T-shirt by Luigi Mangione (charged in a CEO’s murder) underscores the intersection of criminal notoriety, viral culture, and AI.
• NATO Article 4 Invoked:
  • Poland invoked Article 4 following Russian drones, highlighting rarely-known protocols for emergency alliance consultations.

---

Interview with Senator Alyssa Slotkin (D-MI)

1. Living Through 9/11 and a Career in Security

(20:46–21:34)

• Slotkin was a young New Yorker on 9/11; the event turned her toward CIA service.
  • "The smell of that, the burning buildings... it completely changed my life. I mean, top to bottom." —Senator Slotkin (20:55)

---

2. Intelligence Community Upheaval & Political Pressure

(23:18–24:34)

• Slotkin criticizes politicization and staff purges in US intelligence agencies.
  • "I can't tell you how dangerous I think it is to politicize intelligence... I believe that to be dangerous for the security of the United States." —Senator Slotkin (23:18)
• She argues for reform, but not by “slashing and burning”—calls for strategic rethinking, not a simple return to pre-Trump status quo.
  • "Let’s actually take this as a moment... to do a little rethinking of how we are organized as an intelligence community and a Defense Department." —Senator Slotkin (24:34)

---

3. Greatest National Security Threats: Domestic Divisions

(25:01–25:56)

• Slotkin identifies internal polarization and economic decline as the most profound threats, connecting the rise of political extremism to the stresses facing the American middle class.
  • "The existential threat to the country is not coming from abroad. It’s the shrinking middle class at home and what that does to our stability here." —Senator Slotkin (25:05)
  • "When you can't provide for your kids what was provided to you... you feel shame, you feel anger, you feel cornered... and that is almost always someone who doesn't look like you or talk like you or pray like you." —Senator Slotkin (25:35)

---

4. Opportunities for Reform and Hope for National Healing

(26:09–28:27)

• She advocates for modernization, especially in the Defense Department, and rapid adoption of technology to meet 21st-century threats.
  • "Our way of taking 12 years to go from idea for a new weapons system to actually fielding it doesn't work for the modern age." —Senator Slotkin (26:09)
• Reflects longingly on the unity seen post-9/11, urging a return to political normalcy rooted in the majority “80% in the middle,” away from extremes.
  • "We were all on the same team. And I'm so glad that I got to be there in that moment to see that. And I'm so concerned with how far we feel from that moment." —Senator Slotkin (27:16)
  • "My practical, reasonable constituents get exhausted looking at the extremes and just want something normal." —Senator Slotkin (28:08)

---

Notable Quotes & Timestamps

• Odette Youssef (on post-attack finger-pointing):
  “I’m just very concerned that… incendiary rhetoric… is just going to keep on churning.” (02:31)

• Greg Myre (on foreign aggression):
  "Leaders… are going directly against the wishes of President Trump, seemingly because they think they can and there won't be any repercussions." (04:02)

• Mary Louise Kelly (on intelligence failures):
  “…all that was known in the late 90s... In the end, U.S. intelligence was not able to connect the dots. The 9/11 attacks happened." (08:03)

• Senator Slotkin (on politicizing intelligence):
  “It’s very hard to see some of these moves as anything other than attempting to shape the intelligence community to the will of Donald Trump. I believe that to be dangerous for the security of the United States.” (23:18)

• Senator Slotkin (on America’s existential threat):
  “The existential threat to the country is not coming from abroad. It’s the shrinking middle class at home and what that does to our stability here.” (25:05)

• Senator Slotkin (on hope):
  “My practical, reasonable constituents get exhausted looking at the extremes and just want something normal.” (28:08)

---

Episode Structure & Navigation

• 00:19: Reflection on 9/11’s unity (Slotkin, pre-taped for context)
• 01:27: Roundtable opens—intros & Kirk shooting in Utah
• 03:19: Israel and Gaza escalation / Ukraine and Poland
• 05:35: 9/11’s intelligence lessons & legacy
• 12:37: Turbulence in US intelligence community
• 15:05: OSINT segment—pop culture, odd intersections, NATO Article 4
• 20:46: Senator Slotkin interview—living through 9/11, DC intelligence changes, greatest threats, and hope for the future

---

Takeaway

This episode paints a stark image of contemporary national security: simultaneous escalation of international conflicts, an alarming rise in domestic political violence, and US security agencies under intense political strain. Yet, through Senator Slotkin’s lens, there remains potential for national renewal—grounded not only in institutional reform, but in rekindling the pragmatic, communal spirit that followed 9/11.

Transcript

[NPR Sponsor Announcer]

Support for npr. And the following message come from Bolen Branch. Turn your bed into a sanctuary this fall with their buttery, breathable bedding. Enjoy 15% off your first set of sheets at B O L L and Branch.com with code NPR exclusions apply.

[Senator Alyssa Slotkin]

Being in New York on that day, even in a place as cynical as New York City, people had their flags out. They were decent to each other. We were all on the same team. And I'm so connected, concerned with how far we feel from that moment.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

An Israeli airstrike inside US Ally Qatar, Russian drones in NATO airspace, meaning big escalations in the two big wars that have dominated U.S. foreign policy and resources lately. Very different wars than the one that arguably began 24 years ago today with the attacks of September 11th. This is sources and methods from NPR. I'm Mary the Weaver. Every Thursday, we discuss the biggest national security stories of the week. Later this episode, we will do that with Senator Alyssa Slotkin, who sits on the Armed Services Committee. But first, our regular roundtable with my colleagues from NPR's NATSAC team covering the military, the State Department, the intel community. Today we have Odette Youssef on the extremism beat for npr. Odette, welcome. This is your debut on the podcast.

[Odette Youssef]

I'm glad to be here. Thanks.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

And back with us again just recently and very happily safely returned from your latest tour in our Ukraine bureau. Greg Myre, welcome back. Welcome home.

[Greg Myre]

Good to be back.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

I will note your regular beat is the intel community, which has been in all kinds of upheaval since you left. Security clearance is yanked, people fired. I'm sure it will calm down completely now that you're home.

[Greg Myre]

Sources are telling me that I'm a little skeptical.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

I would be, too. Well, this week had already served up half a dozen significant nets stories to discuss. And then Wednesday night, the conservative activist Charlie Kirk was shot and killed while speaking on a college campus in Utah. So, Odette, I want to start there because domestic extremism is your beat. There's still a lot we don't know at this hour on Thursday afternoon. We are taping now at just past noon. We do know we're living in a country where political violence represents a growing threat to national security. So what questions are on your mind as you track what just happened in Utah?

[Odette Youssef]

So obviously the question is, who did it? You know, we are at this time of taping still without a suspect in custody. There were two arrests yesterday, but both of those individuals were released. And so we're really still in the dark about who's responsible and any motivation that there may have been. And I think what's been very concerning to see is that in this time that's elapsed, this very vacuum of any knowledge, there's been a lot of finger pointing and a lot of assumptions made about who's responsible for the political violence. And so I'm just very concerned that the longer we go, some of this really incendiary rhetoric that we've been seeing on social media and elsewhere is just going to keep on churning.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

Let's head overseas because I mentioned escalations in two wars. To recap, on Tuesday, Israel attempted to kill Hamas leaders in an airstrike in Doha, Qatar. Qatar, again, a US Ally that has been hosting for years now, ceasefire negotiations between Israel and Hamas. That's war number one. Then Wednesday, NATO announced it had scrambled fighter jets to take down Russian drones that were violating Polish airspace. Russia, of course, is actively attacking Ukraine, which is just across the border from Poland. Greg Myre, you have been reporting on both these wars on the ground ground in recent months, Middle east and Ukraine. A top line takeaway or two on this week's news.

[Greg Myre]

Yeah, it's a clear escalation carried out by leaders who are going directly against the wishes of President Trump, seemingly because they think they can and there won't be any repercussions. Russia's Vladimir Putin has stepped up attacks on Ukraine. I saw that firsthand when I was in Ukraine. Now he sent at least nine drones into Poland, seemingly as a way to see how the US And NATO might respond. And so far they just say they're.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

Assessing testing the waters or testing the airspace as the case may be moved.

[Greg Myre]

That's what it seems so far. And in the Middle East, Israeli leader Benjamin Netanyahu unleashed this airstrike in Qatar as Hamas leaders gathered to discuss a peace plan backed by the Trump White House. Trump says he wants to end both these wars, but leaders are stepping up expanding attacks and so far they're not facing any consequences.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

Still, a lot of things we don't know about both. I'll inject a little on the ground reporting. Our colleague EA Batrawi is in Doha in Qatar. She went to try to see the Hamas residents and the locations that Israel hit. She couldn't get there because it's all cordoned off. But she said, I'm looking around and it's right in the middle of a neighborhood and embassies and schools speaks to the real violation this was of Qatar and as you say, of how President Trump appears to have hoped that things would go, yeah.

[Greg Myre]

And Qatar is sort of the Switzerland of the Middle East. No mountains, no snow, but it's a safe space where people can get together and talk. That's sort of Ben Qatar's deal.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

And we'll see whether they want to continue hosting those talks and where that goes in the days to come. So let me spin both of us. These wars in Ukraine and Gaza are the international national security crises du jour. But the three of us are sitting here speaking on the anniversary of 9 11. And so I want to spend our time today looking at the long shadow of those attacks, how we got here, and I want to back us up. Greg, I think I'm right in saying that many moons ago you were based in Pakistan, where you could kind of sort of start seeing the outlines of what might have been coming in the late 90s. Just tell us where you were, what you were seeing.

[Greg Myre]

Yeah, I was based in Islamabad in 1995. And one morning I woke up, up. And we start hearing reports that Ramzi Yousef, who was accused of the 1993 bombing of the World Trade center, where a large vehicle was packed with explosives and killed six people, wounded a thousand. So a major attack at the World Trade Center. He was accused. He was captured. It was about a mile from my home in Islamabad, a little shopping near a shopping area where I went to often. So I raced over there, asked some guys, you know, have you seen this guy? And they said, yeah, he's living at that guest house, the Tsukasa Guest House. And they said he went to that video store. So I raced to the video store and said, could we see this guy's video rental card? And they pulled it right out, knew exactly who he was. And I swear to you, the last video, the last movie Ramsey Youssef rented before he was captured was fugitive among us.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

You couldn't make it up?

[Greg Myre]

Absolutely not. But. But there were some even more important developments coming out of that. They seized his computer and they found a plan to simultaneously blow up multiple US airliners. And it later emerged that his attack in 1993 on the world Trade center was funded by his uncle, a guy named Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, who would go on to mastermind the 911 attack six years later. So here in 1995, we knew the potential target, the World Trade center, which had already been hit. He knew the method, using multiple airliners, US Commercial airliners, as weapons. And the family, Ramzi Yousef and his uncle, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

And we know that Ramzi Yousef had bad taste in movies. But that's a sidebar. I mean, it's reminding me of all that was known in the late 90s. Then CIA Director George Tenet talked about going to the White House and trying to brief them and that his hair was on fire because of all the incoming. In the end, U.S. intelligence was not able to connect the dots. The 911 attacks happened. Greg, one more to you. And then, Odette, I want to bring you in, but you cover the CIA 24 years on. How has the agency changed in the wake of that massive intelligence failure that was the attacks of 9 11?

[Greg Myre]

Well, I think it's changed a couple times, but at that point, it was transformed from an agency that gathered and analyzed intelligence, something it had been doing really for a half century, became this paramilitary force that was suddenly involved in fighting battles in the Middle east, capturing interrogating prisoners. It became a very different agency.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

The CIA was first into Afghanistan. They beat the Pentagon troops into Afghanistan after 9 11. Odette, jump in. Because what resulted after all those investigations and the hearings was suddenly this flood of money to combating terrorism. The whole US Government is suddenly geared up to fight Al Qaeda and Salafi JI and the definition of terrorism that took hold and where all that money was channeled. You have been reporting that maybe that was too narrow. Looking back, explain.

[Odette Youssef]

I mean, it's so interesting because I think 911 really woke people up to sort of what's the capacity? What were the silos that were existing within the intelligence community? And it led to the creation of a whole new department, the Department of Homeland Security, an enormous federal agency now.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

And the Director of National Intelligence, Counterterrorism Center. None of those existed.

[Odette Youssef]

The apparatus that was constructed right after 911 to protect the homeland was enormous. But the attention at the time really was on these foreign terrorist organizations. You know, that made sense at the time. But we also have to remember that just two years after that World Trade center bombing that Greg referenced earlier, you know, back in 1995, Timothy McVeigh bombed the federal building in Oklahoma City. And so, you know, we have had throughout American history instances where there were threats here on the homeland against other Americans by Americans themselves. And what we've been seeing more recently is that there has been a rise in political violence in the United States, and the most lethal and persistent threat on the homeland, according to former FBI Director Director Christopher Wray, has been violent white supremacists. And so it's sort of been one at the expense of the other. And I think one of the issues that we're really facing the reality of today is that the threat landscape here in the homeland today is vastly more complex than it was 24 years ago.

[NPR Sponsor Announcer]

This message comes from Charles Schwab. When it comes to managing your wealth, Schwab gives you more choices like full service, wealth management and advice when you need it. You can also invest on your own and trade on Think or swim. Visit schwab.com to learn more Support for this podcast and the following message come from Strawberry Me. Be honest, are you happy with your job? Are you stuck in a job you've outgrown or never wanted in the first place? Are your reasons for staying really just excuses for not leaving? Let a career coach from Strawberry Me help you get unstuck. Discover the benefits of having a dedicated career coach in your corner and claim a special offer at Strawberry Me.

NPR this message comes from Wise, the app for using money around the globe. When you manage your money with Wise, you'll always get the mid market exchange rate with no hidden fees. Join millions of customers and visit wise.com Ts and Cs apply.

This message comes from Progressive Insurance and the name your price tool. It helps you find car insurance options in your budget. Try it today at progressive.com, progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates Price and Coverage Match Limited by state law, not available in all states.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

So let me bring us up to today. All of the work that was done post 9 11, all of the institutions that were created are now in a state of huge flux. The National Security Council staff has been slashed. The Director of National Intelligence, Tulsi Gabbard, is trying to cut her staff by nearly half. I could go on. Who makes sure that relevant information is going to get to the people and persuade the White House? This is important. We need to pay attention to it now, right?

[Greg Myre]

Well, that's a very big, tough question to answer. But every day the president does get a presidential daily brief, and that is run by the Office of the Director of National Intelligence. And Tulsi Gabbard, therefore, is responsible for that.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

And that continues. But she's going to have half the number of people standing behind her. Now.

[Greg Myre]

That's true. And it's also a question of what direction she provides. The president might get a list of a half dozen things that the intelligence community thinks are important on that particular day. But we've already seen very clear instances of top national security officials being dismissed because assessments about Iran or Venezuela are at odds with what President Trump has been saying publicly. So as a career official in intelligence, do you really want to Put your whole career and reputation on the line by writing something you may believe, but it's at odds with something that President Trump has stated publicly.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

You just mentioned Venezuela, which is making me, of course, think of this strike that obliterated what the Trump administration says was a Venezuelan drug boat a few days ago. Trump has defended that strike and claimed that the people on that boat were terrorists. Which prompts a question to you, Odette. Is the, you know, in 2025, is there agreement on what terrorism is?

[Odette Youssef]

No. I mean, there's a lot of questions right now from the counterterrorism world on this sort of reorientation of the definition of terrorism that we're seeing from the administration. Drug cartels have not traditionally fallen under the ambit of national security work. I mean, that's been typ a law enforcement matter. And so there's, you know, concern that I'm hearing about, well, what is this going to mean when it comes to allocation of resources at a time when the counterterrorism, when the terrorism landscape is more complex than it's ever been?

[Mary Louise Kelly]

Yeah. Now, I'm going to let the two of you go before my interview with Senator Slotkin. But first, I want to talk through some osint that is open source intelligence. That is the way we usually wrap this part of the show. OSINT meaning kernels of intelligence, sometimes little tiny crumbs that are hidden in plain sight but that have caught our eye or ear this week. Greg, go first.

[Greg Myre]

Tom Hanks.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

We're back to movies.

[Greg Myre]

Yes. If you're familiar with his screen career, you may have noticed he's played some US Troops over the years in Saving Private Ryan and in Forrest Gump. And off screen, he's done an awful lot, been very involved in supporting U.S. troops and veterans. So the West Point Alumni Estate association announced that they were going to give him a big annual award for somebody who's not a graduate of West Point but has done a lot to serve the US Military. President Trump got wind of this, complained publicly and loudly, saying Tom Hanks is way too woke that he has supported Democratic candidates over the years. And the West Point Alumni association announced that they were, in fact, canceling the ceremony.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

Really? Has Tom Hanks said anything?

[Greg Myre]

I have not seen any comment from Tom Hanks on this.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

Interesting.

[Greg Myre]

But we will stay tuned.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

All right, Odette, what you got?

[Odette Youssef]

I have something at the strange intersection of violent extremism and fashion. Last week, the fast fashion brand Shein had to remove an image on its website for a T shirt that it was selling that appeared to be modeled by Luigi Mangione. You may remember, Mangioni is the man that's been charged with killing the United Healthcare CEO Brian Thompson late last year.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

Right.

[Odette Youssef]

You know, my guess is that it was AI generated. Sheehan attributed this image to a third party vendor. But I continue to be fascinated by the ways that Mangioni seems to have kind of captured the culture.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

Yeah, I was gonna ask, why would anyone want a Luigi Mangioni T shirt? Why would that be fashionable?

[Odette Youssef]

Well, you know, I think he's been getting a lot of fan mail in prison or in jail just because of his appearance. But, you know, there's also playing in San Francisco, Luigi the Musical. I don't know about you all, but I've seen on cars just driving around Luigi campaign bumper stickers like it's a different thing that seems to be happening around his legacy than I have seen in my lifetime around any other person that's been accused of a crime like that.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

The strange intersection indeed of fashion and extremism. All right, I'm not sure I can top either of those, but I will inject into this mix NATO Article 4, which I'm raising because I don't think I could have told you what NATO Article 4 was until this week. We all talk a lot about NATO Article 5, which is the collective defense, the cornerstone of the alliance. But this week, Poland invoked Article 4 after, as we discussed these Russian drones crossing to Polish airspace. So I was trying to bone up fast. What is Article 4? What does that mean to invoke it? So we called someone who should know who sat in meetings on this, Rose Gottemoller. She is a former deputy Secretary General of NATO. And she said, well, it's a way to very quickly gather members to consult in the event of an urgent security situation. And I pushed her on that a little bit because they're all in Brussels anyway. Couldn't they get together or just hop on a call without invoking Article 4 of the NATO treaty? And she said, look, it's, you know, it conveys a seriousness of concern about what the response should be. So there you go. I offer it up. Next time either of you have a family crisis, you can tell them you are invoking Article 4 and you can have an urgent security summit at the family dinner table. NPR national security correspondent Greg Myre, NPR domestic extremism correspondent Odette Youssef making her debut on Sources and Methods. Thanks to you both. Thank you.

[Greg Myre]

Sure thing, Mary Louise.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

And after a short break, my inter with Senator Elissa Slatkin.

[NPR Sponsor Announcer]

This message comes from Viking. Committed to exploring the world in comfort. Journey through the heart of Europe on an elegant Viking longship with thoughtful service, destination focused dining and cultural enrichment on board and on shore. And every Viking voyage is all inclusive with no children and no casinos. Discover [e-mail] this message comes from Progressive Insurance.

You chose to hit play on this podcast today. Smart Choice. Make another smart choice with Auto Quote Explorer to compare rates from multiple car insurance companies all at once. Try [e-mail], progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Not available in all states or situations. Prices vary based on how you buy.

This message comes from Carvana. Selling your car shouldn't take all day with Carvana it doesn't get a great offer in no time. Then choose to drop off or pick up and get paid on the spot. Sell your car today on Carvana.com pickup fees may apply.

This message comes from Mint Mobile. Mint Mobile took what's wrong with wireless and made it right. They offer premium wireless plans for less and all plans include high speed data, unlimited talk and text and nationwide coverage. See for [e-mail] Switch when the planes.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

Hit the World Trade Center 24 years ago, Alyssa Slotkin was 7 miles away, 25 years old, a grad student at Columbia University.

[Senator Alyssa Slotkin]

The smell of that, the burning buildings and that very sort of toxic chemically smell that was just hanging over New York for weeks if not months and it completely changed my life. I mean top to bottom that is.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

Slotkin speaking to the Washington Post. She told the paper that the 911 attacks led her to a job the CIA, later at the White House, the Pentagon. Her two decade national security career evolved into a political one. Alyssa Slotkin is now Senator Slotkin. The Michigan Democrat serves today on the Armed Services, Homeland Security and Veterans Affairs Committee. Senator, welcome to Sources and Methods.

[Senator Alyssa Slotkin]

Thanks for having me.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

So when I started mapping out earlier this week what I wanted to ask you, I was definitely going to start with Israel's attack on Hamas leadership in Doha. And then Russian drones flew into Poland and NATO scrambled fighter jets to shoot them down. And suddenly we were watching NATO engaging enemy targets in NATO airspace for the first time. And then in Utah, in our country's latest horror of political violence, the conservative activist Charlie Kirk was shot and killed. I find it hard some days to wake up and know where to start. And I wonder if you feel that from your perch in the Senate.

[Senator Alyssa Slotkin]

Yeah, I mean certainly, I think I'm used to that in the national security context where, you know, you can't control Events that are happening abroad. I think it's the combination of those with just the events that are going on inside the country, just every single day, something new and different. It certainly feels saturating. And I know a lot of people have, frankly, just kind of decided they're going on a media diet, which you can't do.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

No, no, no. Nor can I. It's the fire hose every day. So the institutions that U.S. intelligence and national security has to deal with, these are the institutions that were created in the wake of 9, 11. And now the Trump administration is working to reshape many of those institutions, pushing through, for example, a nearly 50% cut at the Director of National Intelligence on her staff, pushing out the leaders of the National Security Agency, the Defense Intelligence Agency. I could go on. What do you make of the current upheaval in the intelligence community in which you used to serve?

[Senator Alyssa Slotkin]

Yeah, I mean, look, it's difficult to watch. I can't tell you how dangerous I think it is to politicize intelligence. And it's very hard to see some of these moves as anything other than attempting to shape the intelligence community to the will of Donald Trump. I believe that to be dangerous for the security of the United States, you know, if there's a threat coming from abroad or, you know, something happening, you have to call balls and strikes on that, or else people can get, you know, deeply hurt.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

I will note that Tulsi Gabbard, the Director of National Intelligence, sees this totally the other way around. She says she is trying to get politics out of intelligence, that she's trying to restore the intelligence of the intelligence community. I wonder how fine a line it feels like you are walking as an elected U.S. senator and a Democrat. When you criticize the Trump administration. Does that risk weeding into the politics of it all?

[Senator Alyssa Slotkin]

Well, but the thing is, is oftentimes I think Trump has the wrong answer to the right question. It's the way he goes about it, the wholesale slashing and burning of things and organizations because he didn't like what they did in the last administration.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

So you're not saying, hey, we couldn't do this better, you're saying this isn't the right approach?

[Senator Alyssa Slotkin]

I would say even further, I think, with Trump doing what he's doing, let's actually take this as a moment not to just snap back to the same system we had before he came in, but take it as a moment to do a little rethinking of how we are organized as an intelligence community and a Defense Department and other issues as well. I don't like the Democratic response. That's like, just maintain status quo. The status quo was not working.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

What do you see as the biggest national security threat facing our country today?

[Senator Alyssa Slotkin]

I really believe that the existential threat to the country is not coming from abroad. It's the shrinking middle class at home and what that does to our stability here. Explain, if you want to understand why we are at this moment in our history, this fractious, authoritarian moment where people, Americans, are turned against each other. I mean, look at what just happened to Charlie Kirk. I mean, if you want to understand and why we are so polarized. To me, it is about the fact that just more and more Americans do not feel like they can save every month and live the American dream. And when you do that, when you can't provide for your kids what was provided to you, you feel shame, you feel anger, you feel cornered, and you start looking for someone to blame. And that is almost always someone who doesn't look like you or talk like you or pray like you.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

So I was gonna ask, because I hear you being critical of the approach that the Trump administration. But you've also argued this is a moment of huge opportunity. Give me an example. Sure.

[Senator Alyssa Slotkin]

So we understand that it is important that we are, you know, Americans, maintain leadership roles in the world. We know we've made a lot of mistakes. You know, if you're thinking about a different way of doing what we need to do to be postured for the future, I think we got to change the Defense Department. I think that our way of taking 12 years to go from idea for a new weapons system to actually fielding, it doesn't work for the modern age. I think we have a problem with adopting technology fast enough, and that is a real threat to us. When China can move, you know, from idea to fielding in five years.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

So circle back to that pretty morning in New York. Obviously, what happened on 911 was. Was horrific. But in the days that followed, the whole world stood with the United States and Americans pulled together, set aside our political differences, which I'm describing that, and it sounds like a time capsule from a different planet. What, if anything, remains of that moment? What gives you hope?

[Senator Alyssa Slotkin]

Yeah. Gosh, I think about that moment. I thought about it a lot today, because even in a place as cynical as New York City, you know, people had their flags out. They were decent to each other. We were all on the same team. And I'm so glad that I got to be there in that moment to see that. And I'm so concerned with how far we feel from that moment, look, what gives me hope is that I go home every weekend and the vast majority of Michiganders live in that 80% middle that don't scream on the Internet, that don't, you know, want to hurt their neighbors when they happen to disagree. They just want Team Normal. I grew up, my dad's a lifelong Republican. My mom was a lifelong Democrat. It was totally normal when we grew up. And a lot of Michiganders really think about that time and wish for that time because we're very mixed politically. And that gives me hope that my practical, reasonable constituents get exhausted looking at the extremes and just want something normal.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

To find our way back to the middle.

[Senator Alyssa Slotkin]

To find our way back. That keeps me buoyed.

[Mary Louise Kelly]

Democratic Senator Alyssa Slotkin of Michigan, as you heard, thank you for stopping by. Thank you. That's our show for today. A quick note that you can email us at Sources and [e-mail] at that is sources and methods all spelled out, no spaces. And the link is in our episode notes. Now, we do love to hear from you. Send us your feedback, ideas for topics, your reaction to anything we talk about here. It is all very much appreciated. Something else we would appreciate as a brand new podcast is for you to rate and review us on whatever platform you use to listen. That actually goes a long way toward helping new listeners find us. Now, if you're not the rate and review type, we get it. We would settle for just telling a friend who you think will like the show. Show. We are back next Thursday with another new episode. I'm Mary Louise Kelly. Thank you for listening to Sources and Methods from npr.

[NPR Sponsor Announcer]

This message comes from NPR sponsor Oracle. In business, they say you can have better, cheaper or faster, but you only get to pick two. What if you could have all three at the same time? Oracle Cloud Infrastructure is the blazing fast platform for your infrastructure, database, application development and AI needs. With oci, you can run any workload in a high availability, consistently high performance environment and spend less than you would with other clouds. To try OCI for free with zero commitment, go to oracle.com NPR this message comes from Bombus. You need better socks and slippers and underwear because you should love what you wear every day. One purchased equals one donated. Go to bombus.com NPR and use code NPR for 20% off.

This message comes from Charles Schwab. When it comes to managing your wealth, Schwab gives you more choices like full service, wealth management and advice when you need it. You can also invest on your own and trade on thinkorswim visit schwab.com to learn more.