Standard of Truth Podcast: S4E51 Fallacies, Forgeries, and Football
Release Date: December 19, 2024
Hosts:
- Dr. Garrett Dirkmot, Associate Professor of Church History and Doctrine at BYU
- Dr. Richard Leduc
1. Introduction and Lighthearted Banter
The episode kicks off with the hosts engaging in playful banter, setting a relaxed and humorous tone. Dr. Dirkmot introduces himself and welcomes Dr. Leduc, who humorously juggles the title “Doctor” multiple times [00:01–00:27]. Their lighthearted exchange continues as they discuss the iconic eastern redbud tree of Oklahoma State University, weaving in jokes about tree poisoning and the severe consequences it would entail.
Dr. Leduc: “We need to get our crack research staff on that.” [02:08]
2. Listener Shoutouts and Personal Stories
Transitioning from introductions, the hosts share personal anecdotes and listener interactions, providing a glimpse into their lives outside academia. Dr. Dirkmot talks about his upcoming graduation, complete with western attire and a sequined jacket, while Dr. Leduc humorously recounts an encounter where a Target delivery person mistook him for a podcast host.
Dr. Dirkmot: “So I'm here in Stillwater... under the shadow of the eternal hills and the eastern redbud tree.” [01:14]
They also acknowledge listeners like Alan and Sarah, sharing amusing stories about being recognized in unexpected places, such as basketball games.
3. Early History of BYU Football: Christmas Day Game of 1897
A significant portion of the episode delves into the intriguing history of Brigham Young University’s (BYU) early football games. The hosts examine a contentious Christmas Day game from 1897 between the Provo men and the Crescent team. This discussion highlights the rough-and-tumble nature of early American football, marked by violence, profanity, and chaos.
Dr. Leduc reads excerpts from a Salt Lake Herald Republican article detailing the game's abrupt end due to disputes over ball possession and subsequent altercations involving the referee.
Dr. Leduc: “The serene Christmas afternoon was marred by a chaotic football game... Captain Hyde of the Provo team withdrew from the contest in protest.” [20:43]
They explore the social and cultural context of the time, emphasizing how far the sport has evolved in terms of rules and conduct. The hosts draw parallels between the historical roughness of football and modern-day fan behavior, noting the persistence of intense rivalries.
4. Examination of Joseph Smith Document and Forgeries
Shifting focus, the hosts tackle the sensitive topic of document authentication within the Latter-Day Saints (LDS) history. Dr. Leduc recounts an encounter with a listener named Stephanie, who presented a letter purportedly written by Joseph Smith in 1842. The letter’s authenticity is scrutinized, with Dr. Leduc highlighting discrepancies such as inconsistent signatures and geographical impossibilities.
Dr. Leduc: “There was no possible way for Joseph Smith to have been in Alexandria in 1842... It’s likely a blatant forgery.” [44:38]
They discuss the importance of verifying historical documents, referencing the Joseph Smith Papers project. The conversation underscores the challenges historians face in distinguishing genuine artifacts from forgeries, especially when relying on names as common as "Joseph Smith."
5. Handling Negative Feedback and Listener Interactions
The episode also addresses the emotional toll of receiving negative feedback. Dr. Leduc shares his experience with an angry listener who disputed his research and beliefs, culminating in an anonymous letter accusing him of fraud. The hosts emphasize the importance of maintaining integrity and compassion when confronted with criticism, even when it feels personal.
Dr. Leduc: “I am not the best person. I clearly have anger issues... But I am certain that Joseph Smith was a prophet of God.” [58:54]
Dr. Dirkmot adds insights into managing such interactions, promoting a respectful dialogue despite disagreements. This segment highlights the podcast’s commitment to fostering understanding and faith amidst challenges.
6. Conclusions and Reflections
In wrapping up, the hosts reflect on the intertwining of history, faith, and personal experiences. They reiterate their dedication to uncovering and sharing authentic historical narratives that bolster the faith of Latter-Day Saints. The episode concludes with a reaffirmation of their belief in Joseph Smith as a prophet and a commitment to continuing their scholarly pursuits.
Dr. Leduc: “I believe that Joseph Smith was a prophet of God... I hope that when you listen to this podcast, you know that for all the things you may dislike about me, that is a sincere and honest belief.” [67:49]
Notable Quotes:
-
Dr. Leduc on Team Spirit: “There were 22 of the most furious gladiators who ever wore the padded vestments of the gridiron.” [29:09]
-
Dr. Dirkmot on Early Football Violence: “In early American football, it was not nearly as organized as it is now. Local towns and communities would create their own football clubs.” [21:12]
-
Dr. Leduc on Document Forgery: “This is where the context of documents makes a big deal. There just was no possible way for Joseph Smith to have been in Alexandria.” [50:00]
Final Thoughts:
"Fallacies, Forgeries, and Football" offers a rich blend of historical exploration, personal storytelling, and thoughtful discourse on faith and authenticity. Dr. Dirkmot and Dr. Leduc skillfully navigate complex topics, providing listeners with both educational insights and relatable experiences. This episode not only deepens the understanding of LDS history but also reinforces the importance of integrity in both scholarship and personal beliefs.
For more information and resources discussed in this episode, visit standardoftruth.com.
Share the Podcast: If you know someone who would benefit from this episode, please share it with them. Your support helps us continue to explore and illuminate the rich history of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints.
Thank you for listening to the Standard of Truth podcast.