Podcast Summary: Stars on Suspense (Old Time Radio) – Episode 412: Harry Bartell

Introduction

In Episode 412 of Stars on Suspense, hosted by Mean Streets Podcasts, listeners are treated to performances by the legendary radio actor Harry Bartell. Known for his extensive work during radio's golden age, Bartell showcases his versatility in two gripping episodes of the classic Suspense series: "Final Payment" and "To a Deadly Drug". This episode delves deep into themes of deception, morality, and the unforeseen consequences of one's actions, all brought to life by Bartell's compelling performances.

"Final Payment"

Plot Summary

"Final Payment" is a taut thriller that follows Joe Thurston (played by Harry Bartell) and his acquaintance Sam Monroe (Peter Leeds) as they embark on what they believe is a flawless insurance fraud scheme. Their plan involves faking a car accident to claim a substantial insurance payout. However, as the narrative unfolds, the duo finds themselves entangled in unforeseen complications that test their morals and friendship.

The episode begins with Joe under trial, implying that their scheme has already gone awry. Through courtroom drama and flashbacks, listeners witness the meticulous planning and the eventual fallout when Sam sues Joe for a hefty sum, only to reveal ulterior motives that jeopardize Joe's life and relationships.

Key Points and Discussions

• Insurance Fraud: The central theme revolves around the allure and risks of financial deception. Joe and Sam's plan represents the lengths individuals might go to attain quick money, highlighting the ethical boundaries crossed in the pursuit of profit.

• Friendship and Trust: As the plot thickens, the fragility of trust between Joe and Sam becomes evident. Sam's betrayal serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of entangling personal relationships with illicit activities.

• Courtroom Tension: The courtroom scenes amplify the suspense, showcasing the legal intricacies and the psychological manipulation employed to secure a confession from Joe.

• Twist Ending: The revelation of Sam's alleged death is a pivotal moment that leaves both characters and listeners questioning the reality of the events, adding layers to the narrative's suspense.

Notable Quotes

• [07:21] Sam Monroe: "Your Honor, I just wish you'd call us when it happened, Mr. Thurston. You made a big mistake by not calling us."

• [10:12] Mary Thurston: "No one."

• [26:05] Judge: "No."

• [28:07] Joe Thurston: "Well, this is highly irregular."

• [57:18] Joe Thurston: "And they do what? Play games and listen to the radio."

• [86:14] Mary Thurston: "Ruth ran the ranch alone. A man started pestering her, and she hated him."

"To a Deadly Drug"

Plot Summary

In "To a Deadly Drug," Harry Bartell portrays Cal Foster, an ex-GI and dedicated pharmacist who finds his life spiraling out of control due to a tragic mistake. Cal inadvertently fills a prescription incorrectly, handing over a fatal drug instead of the intended medication for a young boy named Tippy Smith. As Tippy and his mother, Mrs. Peabody, are already on the road, Cal grapples with the urgent need to rectify his error before the innocent boy succumbs to the overdose.

The narrative intricately weaves Cal's desperation to locate Tippy, his ethical obligations as a pharmacist, and the escalating tension as time ticks away. The episode underscores the profound impact of seemingly minor mistakes and the moral responsibilities that come with professions entrusted with people's lives.

Key Points and Discussions

• Medical Ethics: The core of the episode addresses the Hippocratic oath and the ethical obligations that healthcare professionals bear. Cal's predicament emphasizes the dire consequences of lapses in professional responsibility.

• Desperation and Redemption: As Cal endeavors to save Tippy, his journey reflects a quest for redemption, illustrating how individuals strive to amend their wrongdoings.

• Technological Limitations: The challenges faced by Cal in tracking down the young boy highlight the limitations of the era's technology and the reliance on human networks and ingenuity.

• Family Dynamics: The strain on Cal's relationship with his wife, Marian, adds a personal layer to the narrative, showcasing the ripple effects of professional failings on one's personal life.

Notable Quotes

• [32:44] Mr. Hirsch (Mary Thurston): "Cal, you promised. It's 6:30 and you promised."

• [35:22] Joe Thurston: "What it's going to do. We got a real good for you."

• [45:10] Joe Thurston: "A deadly drug."

• [56:15] Sam: "It's news when it happens. A drugstore mistake."

• [73:45] Joe Thurston: "She would rather have the law do its justice than take matters into her own hands."

• [82:26] Joe Thurston: "How far?"

Conclusion

Episode 412 of Stars on Suspense masterfully showcases Harry Bartell's exceptional talent in bringing complex characters and intricate plots to life. Through "Final Payment" and "To a Deadly Drug," listeners are immersed in tales of suspense that explore the depths of human emotion, ethical dilemmas, and the unforeseen consequences of one's actions. Bartell's performances not only entertain but also provoke thought about the fragile interplay between right and wrong in desperate circumstances.

Listeners unfamiliar with the episode will find themselves captivated by the high-stakes drama and the moral quandaries presented, all within the timeless charm of old-time radio storytelling.