Bonus #151 - McDade's Maniacs Vol. 9 w/ Andrew Collin [PATREON PREVIEW]

Summary

Stavvy's World – Bonus #151: McDade's Maniacs Vol. 9 w/ Andrew Collin [Patreon Preview]

Date: October 23, 2025
Host: Stavros Halkias
Guest: Andrew Collin
Episode Theme: Navigating Relationship Fallout Over Porn & Trust

---

Overview

In this Patreon bonus episode, Stavros Halkias welcomes comedian Andrew Collin for an in-depth, characteristically irreverent discussion about relationship misunderstandings—primarily centered around a listener’s call about his fiancée’s extreme reaction to discovering his porn search history. The crew offers advice, commiserates with personal stories, and riffs on insecurity, trust, and the social taboos around porn in relationships.

---

Main Discussion & Key Points

1. Listener Voicemail: The Porn Star Search Dilemma

• [00:01–02:53]
  • Caller’s Situation: The listener describes a trusting, long-term relationship (engaged 3 years, together 6+). He usually has no secrets with his phone, but his fiancée finds that he searched for a specific porn star whose appearance is very different from her own.
  • Aftermath: She becomes very upset, calls him names, and for weeks won’t let him see her naked. She’s clearly wrestling with body image issues and equates his search with rejection.
  • The Question: The caller wants advice on demonstrating his remorse and repairing trust.

2. The Hosts React: Is This Reasonable?

• [02:53–03:50]
  • Stavros’ Take: "She's being unreasonable. That's fucking insane. ... You did literally nothing wrong." [03:24]
  • Andrew Collin Jokes: Likens her response to “weird Sharia law”—total sexual embargo.
  • Consensus: The punishment doesn't fit the 'crime'. Searching up a porn star, especially once, is normal behavior and not a betrayal.

3. Relatability and Role Reversal

• [04:35–06:18]
  • Andrew’s Anecdote: Shares being caught searching “bigger tits” than his wife—a similarly awkward situation. His defense: "I jerk off as fast as I can. ... I just need to get to come out.” [05:39]
  • Comedic Angle: The guys riff on the harmlessness and randomness of such searches, minimizing emotional weight.

4. Strategies & Emotional Realities

• [06:18–10:26]
  • Options Considered:
    • Try to “catch” her in similar behavior (suggested as tongue-in-cheek).
    • Understand if she’s projecting her own guilt or just wrestling with insecurity.
    • Discuss the line between normal behavior and addiction (e.g., OnlyFans vs. generic porn).
    • Suggest counseling if the reaction is so severe.
  • Stavros: “This is either a serious issue that you have to deal with or she's being very unreasonable and you have to figure this out, cuz you can't [let it continue].” [11:56]

5. The Boundary Conversation: What’s Actually Unacceptable?

• [09:17–11:04]
  • Discovery of Unspoken Boundaries: Relationships sometimes uncover “boundaries that you never explicitly discussed. One person thinks it's so obvious … who gives a fuck if you beat off to porn?” [09:24]
  • Stavros: Points out the danger of living in someone else’s “unreasonable reality” and the necessity of addressing fundamental insecurities or manipulations.
  • Stavros Cautions: Behavior like this can signal bigger marital problems—“what if she fucking behaves like this when you're married?” [10:28]

6. Satirical (Bad) Advice & Levity

• [11:07–12:35]
  • The comedians riff on “solutions” like buying her a gym membership or plastic surgery—satirical, not earnest:
    • “Babe, I'll get you fake tits. I thought about it. I know what the issue is—you're too disgusting.” [11:18, joking]
    • “You put a blindfold on… you take her to a consultation with a plastic surgeon. She thinks you’re going to the Bahamas.” [11:19]

7. The Underlying Message: Normalize and Address, Don’t Capitulate

• [12:04–13:34]
  • Recap of advice: The listener shouldn’t endlessly apologize or try to fix what isn’t actually a betrayal.
  • “You gotta talk. This is either a serious issue… or she's being very unreasonable. … you have to figure this out, cuz you can’t [live like this].” [11:56]
  • Normalize the idea that pornography is a reality for most people, and address deeper emotional fears head-on.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Stavros (on the severity of the fiancée’s reaction):
  “She's being unreasonable. That's fucking insane.” [03:24]
• Andrew Collin (on defensive explanations):
  “I jerk off as fast as I can. ... I just need to get to come out.” [05:39]
• Elder (on mismatched relationship boundaries):
  "Sometimes you'll be in a relationship, you, like, find a boundary that you never explicitly discussed. One person thinks it's like, so obvious." [09:17]
• Stavros (on personal responsibility):
  “You have to, like, show the reality here because you're living in her reality where this is ... a reasonable response and it just is not at all.” [08:48]
• Stavros (regarding moving forward):
  “This is your fiancée. … What if she fucking behaves like this when you're married? … It's important to deal with shit like this before.” [10:28]
• Andrew Collin (joking):
  “Maybe you want to try to do that … tell her to step up.” [11:50]
• Stavros (signing off the topic):
  "Anyway, good luck, buddy." [13:40]

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 00:01–02:53: Listener voicemail dilemma
• 02:53–03:44: Immediate reactions from Stavros & Andrew
• 04:35–06:18: Andrew’s personal anecdote & comedic riff
• 06:18–07:17: Discussion on possible projection, insecurity
• 09:17–10:26: Relationship boundaries and counseling suggestion
• 11:07–12:35: Satirical solutions and recap
• 12:04–13:34: Real advice on normalization and communication

---

Final Thoughts

The episode underscores that minor, common behaviors like watching porn shouldn’t become major fault lines in otherwise healthy relationships. The hosts urge clear communication, honest acknowledgment of insecurities, and above all, not ceding to unreasonable demands. As always, they keep the tone light, self-deprecating, and full of classic Stavvy's World banter—with a mix of heartfelt advice and biting humor for anyone navigating modern love and its stumbling blocks.

Transcript

[A]

Oh, I love.

[B]

How you doing? Beautiful elders playing with his knob. Long time fan, first time caller. First of all, congrats, big bro and all the excess. Can't wait to see the new movie. It looks sick.

[C]

Thanks, dude.

[B]

Anyway, I got a little problem. I just want to hear your advice on it. Me and my fiance been together for a little over six years. Been engaged for three years. I never have a problem with her going on my phone, ever. I always hand her my phone. She needs to do something, look at my phone. I'd never give a fuck, you know, no big deal to me. Well, one day I give her my phone and in my 32 years of being alive, it's the one time I didn't clear my Internet search history. She goes on there and funny me, that morning I was at work alone in the truck and I was like, hey, I haven't seen this one porn.

[D]

Star in a while.

[A]

So I looked up at her on my phone.

[C]

I gotta check in on my old fave.

[D]

Huh? What's Rachel Starr up to?

[A]

Way worse than like, if you just type in big tit.

[C]

Sure.

[A]

That's not. But if you type in a girl, name specific game and like. Yeah, yeah, multiple times, it implies longing.

[D]

Yeah, for sure.

[A]

Yeah, like you want a relationship, which.

[C]

Is fine, you know, you're never gonna fuck this porn star anyway. Let's see what else we got. Eldis.

[B]

Just one porn star in a while. So I looked up that girl on my phone, looked at her for a second to put my phone away. Later that evening, my girl looks at my phone and first thing she sees in my search history is this porn star that looks absolutely not like her.

[C]

Come on.

[B]

So of course she, you know, loses her at me, calls me. Every name in the book just goes off.

[C]

I think that's kind of crazy.

[B]

Now fast forward about two weeks now everything between me and her, you know, kind of goes back to normal. We're back to normal, you know, enjoying each other's company, loving each other and all that. The problem is not only she's not letting me, she's not even let me look at her naked. She changes or anything. I have to be on the other side of the house.

[C]

This is crazy.

[B]

She ain't look, let me look at anything. And she said, what are you, a baby? It's because when she looks at her body now, she feels like, oh, this isn't good enough for.

[A]

Yeah, I don't have fake tits and a satanic tattoo. Yeah, yeah.

[C]

I don't have pentagrams around my nipples.

[B]

I tell her, yes, it is good enough. You're perfect. I love you, and you're sexy as. Yeah, sorry for rambling. All right. But now she's saying it's going to be like months before you're naked, let alone hit.

[C]

No, that's crazy.

[B]

Kind of like, I understand. But also it's like, is there anything I can do to, like, show her how really sorry I am and just how I've never. I don't even look at porn anymore. I gave up everything. I was kind of in a corner. Don't really know what the next move is. If you can give me some advice, I truly appreciate, brother. Thank you.

[C]

This is a tough one because I don't. Because this is. First of all, she's being unreasonable. That's kind of. That's fucking insane. It's. You let her look at your phone. You have. There's no. You have full trust in her. I thought he was gonna say, oh, wouldn't you know, it's the one time my crazy ex messages me. I don't talk to this ever. And she just had a sixth sense for it. And she sent me something weird and it looks bad. This is nothing. You did literally nothing wrong.

[D]

And even if it were a red line, it would have made more sense for her to just leave you. But now she's going about this weird Sharia law situation where she's not allowed. Yeah, that doesn't make any. It seems like torture.

[C]

I. I don't know. I mean, this is tough because she's just being unreasonable here. And it's almost like. I don't think you can your way out of this. I don't think you can. I don't think you can.

[A]

Like, yeah, you have to stand strong. Yeah, you gotta be like, capitulate anything. No, you can't.

[C]

You've already capitulated way too much. And I'm not obviously, like, whatever.

[A]

I think I have an idea. You buy the porn stars online, let her walk in on you.

[C]

You're like, oh, sorry.

[A]

Oh, sorry. Is this.

[C]

Oh, is this what you wanted?

[D]

You.

[A]

Yeah, this is bad.

[C]

Yeah. Yeah, this is bad. I guess I'm going to other women then. If I can't. You and I'll start with the molds of their. And then we'll see. Then we'll get to real. If you don't start acting right, That's.

[A]

What do you think he has to do? I think he has to show what's actually bad.

[C]

Cu.

[A]

What he did was so. I get so angry when it's like, he didn't do anything. He didn't do anything wrong. I mean, I think you looked at it longer than a second in your truck.

[C]

Yeah, listen, you beat off.

[A]

You beat off in your truck.

[C]

Cares if you beat off. We don't care. Again, don't lie to us. You just kept tabs with her. Who gives a if you jack. I don't know. This is like. And I guess I'll defer to all of you because you're all in. We have two married men. We have. And M. Mr. McD is in a serious relationship. Like, I don't even. I wanna you guys take a spin at this before I weigh in. But I don't know.

[A]

I mean, that happened to me. I've lived this.

[C]

Really?

[A]

Yeah. I mean, she didn't. I was caught. And obviously I typed in like bigger. Just bigger tits than my wife, which.

[C]

Is.

[A]

Not much bigger.

[C]

Four years younger than my wife. Bigger tits.

[A]

No, it's not. Yeah, dude, it's random.

[C]

It's Joe. It's AI.

[A]

Dude, you're being weird. No, but it was something like big jugs or whatever.

[C]

Big Ju Legs is awesome.

[A]

And she called me and she gave me about it, but I was like, I don't. You gotta just.

[C]

I.

[A]

At least what I did is I said, look, I don't jerk off. I don't. I jerk off as fast as I can.

[C]

Yeah.

[A]

Yeah. I just need to get to come out. I swear to God. Has nothing. Also, it's so generic. I do. Most viewed. This guy.

[D]

Didn't you get to the top 40 radio stations?

[C]

You're dragging off to the Kesha of pornography.

[A]

All right.

[D]

I guess I'm into stepmom.

[C]

Yeah.

[D]

This is what they're serving me.

[A]

That's what I do.

[D]

Wow.

[C]

With.

[A]

It's tougher because it's specific.

[C]

Still. He's Jack. We're talking about jacking off.

[A]

So what I said to her, I go just say like, look, I jerk. I don't. This is nothing. This is. There's no connection. I just need to get it out. That's all it is. You know, and just really sell it on like it means nothing.

[C]

Yeah. Which it doesn't. Yes, but go ahead. You guys want to weigh in here? Elder sir jp this is a tough one.

[D]

This is real tricky. I don't know. You got. Do you. Do you try to catch her or something? You try to like. Oh, do you hit her with the inquisition? Like, what are you beating off to?

[A]

Yeah, look at her phone.

[C]

Probably nothing. She's probably turtled into being like asexual. Which is the real problem.

[A]

It'd be so great if she was cheating the whole time.

[C]

Yeah, I mean that. I don't think she is. But there is. That does happen a lot with people who are cheating are like really protective in a way that's like.

[A]

Cuz they're doing it, they're protecting.

[C]

Projection. Happens constantly.

[D]

People have this issue with like the phones and the porn and the stuff like that, but it's never ever a response like this and this. I mean, clearly she has her own right not to punt to like relationship counseling or anything, but it might be a good idea to sit down and talk. Like if she's having this response where she doesn't want to even be touched at all, that might be something a little deeper with her.

[C]

Yeah, I mean, because. Because my, my initial thing is like, she's the one who's wrong now. You did like a very. My. If you. I wouldn't even call what you did a, A transgression. But let's say it is. You did the most minor transition.

[D]

Let's say you've talked about it before and now this is like, right?

[C]

And now she's like. And look, obviously she doesn't have to like do. You don't get to just someone because you're in a relationship. She doesn't owe you anything. But it's like she is really taking extreme measures.

[A]

Like this is like denying herself.

[C]

If you were cheated on, if you cheated on her and she acted this way, it would make sense, you know what I mean? Like, not if you looked at pornography. So in my head now what, what's telling what I, what. What's screaming for me is like, you have to act like the one who's being wronged here, because I think you are. But then again, I don't know if that's healthy to up the ante in a negative way or if it you. If you have to be like, like I would be like, you're being ridiculous. I mean, don't say like that. But it's like, this is crazy. We have to talk about this because like, clearly I've triggered some kind of body image issue. I don't know what. Maybe we need to go to couples counseling. Maybe we need to figure this out. But like this is completely unreasonable for you to react this way. Looking at porn is normal. If there's a way that you would prefer me to do it, like, that's fine, but like I'm not, not gonna look at porn. And that has no bearing on our relationship. But this guy's even said, I don't even look at porn anymore. Like, he's fully, like, cucked himself. And be like, I'm not even jacking off. So it's like, I think you're. You have to, like, show the reality here because you're living in her reality where this is. Where this is a reasonable response and it just is not at all.

[E]

I think she's had a few good weeks of, like, overreacting and he's, like, went along with it. But yeah, I think at the very least, he owes it to himself to just be like, okay, this is unreasonable.

[C]

It is.

[E]

You could say that to her and be like, whatever, I get it. You don't like it. But I just don't think porn is a big deal. And, you know, maybe this is like, you know, sometimes you'll be in a relationship, you, like, find a boundary that you never explicitly discussed. One person thinks it's like, so obvious. Like, who gives a if you, like, beat off to porn, right? This is like, be like, well, I'll probably beat off to porn again in the rest of my life.

[A]

Like, I'm not gonna.

[E]

I'm not doing it now. I'm being a good behavior, but I'm gonna beat off, right?

[C]

And when we. We have to be able to like. And look, if she means. If she's real about how she feels, two things are happening here. She has body image issues that you need to figure out because that's something that's going to affect her just for her. You should try and help her through it. But also, it clearly affects your relationship. Or the more sinister thing is she's being manipulative and using a thing that you can't be like. You can't be like, come on, stop withholding pussy. If she's like, you triggered really bad, like, in body image stuff for me.

[D]

Yeah, that would be either sociopathic, but.

[C]

But those are the two things that are going on here. Either she has a real issue that you guys need to deal with as a. As a couple, or she's being a. She's being ridiculous. And it's also like, I don't mean to, you know, press the red panic button here, but it's like, this is your fiance. You love her. But it's like, what if she fucking behaves like this when you're married? Like, it's important to deal with shit like this before. I mean, not that you're clear, you're clearly committed to her. I'm not saying, like, oh, well, if she's not. If she's not giving up after you jack off the porn, send that whore to the curb. That's not what I'm saying, but a little bit.

[A]

You should.

[C]

You should investigate this.

[A]

I think he buys her a gym membership. Yeah.

[C]

Babe, babe, I'll get you fake tits. Yeah, I thought about it. I know what the issue is.

[A]

You're too disgusting.

[C]

Yeah. You put her. You put a blindfold on. You're like, I got a surprise for you. You take her to a consultation with a plastic surgeon. She thinks you're going to the Bahamas.

[D]

She just feels markers on her sharpie all over.

[C]

You're like, I hope your passport's in order.

[A]

Here's a photo of star behind her. It's like exhibit A. It's just a.

[D]

It's literally exhibit. It's pimp my ride. Yeah, Pim my. Pim my.

[A]

Pim my.

[C]

Pimp my.

[D]

No dog.

[A]

Yeah, maybe you want to try to do that.

[C]

I think that's your other option.

[A]

Tell her to step up. But no but yeah, yeah.

[C]

Dude, you gotta. You gotta talk. This is. This is either a serious issue that you have to deal with or she's being very unreasonable and you have to figure this out, cuz you can't.

[A]

Also, what's worse, if you jerk off to your brain. If a girl walked in and I'm just in the dark room.

[C]

Oh yeah. Cuz if I'm jerk off to my brain, it's somebody I already. I'm not imagining someone I have.

[A]

Or it's like something weird. Yeah, maybe it's a dog you want.

[D]

Yeah, I'm imagining the suffragettes of the early 1900s. I'm hard for how much I respect them. Exactly. Like, it's like Susan B. Anthony's getting me rock hard.

[A]

They should love that. It's just a porn star. That means nothing.

[C]

You know, I. I sort of agree with you. Like this would be semi reasonable if she found him. Like we, we kind of come up against this stuff when like a. A husband or a boyfriend is basically addicted to only fans. Yeah. And then that is. That's different. That is a different. That's like going to a strip club and having a specific dancer that you give thousands of dollars to like. But this is just. This is just like, you know, whatever.

[D]

Girlfriend a Cheesecake factory gift card for her birthday and you're giving the stripper like thousands.

[C]

Yeah, yeah, exactly.

[A]

Look, I get you more than an appetizer, but yeah, we're strapped here. Yeah, this is. Yeah, you gotta just man up a little or not. Man up.

[C]

Yeah, just person up.

[A]

Person up.

[D]

You have a truck for words where I cut off.

[A]

You know what?

[C]

Yeah. Like, the whole thing hasn't been misogyny. We haven't been misogynistic for, like, half of this.

[A]

Yeah, get her a new.

[D]

We draw man up.

[C]

Sorry, that language is problematic.

[D]

We draw the line at reinforcing the gender now.

[C]

Anyway, let's. Let's get back to the pimp your ring. Anyway, good luck, buddy.