Story Warz, Episode 064: Kerryn Feehan, Dan St. Germain, Louis Katz | Arguments

Date: October 24, 2025
Host: GaS Digital Network (Big Jay Oakerson, Luis J. Gomez)
Guests: Kerryn Feehan, Dan St. Germain, Louis Katz
Location: The Stand Comedy Club, New York City

Main Theme

This episode of Story Warz centers around the panelists’ true (and hopefully deceptive) stories of infamous "arguments." Comedians Big Jay Oakerson and Luis J. Gomez compete against fellow comics Dan St. Germain, Louis Katz, and Kerryn Feehan, each submitting tales themed around personal disputes, then trying to guess whose story is whose. The show is a rambunctious contest of wits, roasting, and wild storytelling, all played out in front of a rowdy New York audience.

Structure and Game Rules

• Each panelist submits 3-5 stories around the topic “arguments.”
• Producer (Alex) reads the stories aloud, anonymously.
• Other panelists must guess who wrote each story.
• Points awarded for correct guesses and for successfully deceiving others.
• For the second half, “double points” round increases the stakes.
• Winner receives an ever-ridiculous prize, tonight: Upper Westside Catholics, signed (inscribed: “To my dear friend Lisa…”).

Key Moments & Discussion Points

1. Introductions and Riffs on the Crowd

• [02:02] Luis jokes about the ethnic makeup of the audience, singling out a lone Indian attendee:

  “I was gonna say it’s 100% white audience, then I looked right in this Indian guy's face. That was crazy, dude.” –Luis J. Gomez

• Jay welcomes newcomers and pokes fun at Luis' rare politeness.

2. Story #1: “Screaming match with a father and son, saved by a waiter”

• [07:35]
  Initial guess is Dan St. Germain, based on his “problem drunk” persona.

• Louie accuses:

  “I could see it for some reason, especially with that jacket. He’s, like, yelling, you know, jacket style.” –Louie Katz ([08:01])

• [13:12] Dan admits it was his story, sharing wild details:

  • Drunk in Koreatown LA searching for coke, gets jumped by two cholos, rescued by a Korean BBQ waiter.

  “I went for the 7-11, and I ended up… these two cholos were there… I got you, dad, ‘cause he was the first one who started kicking me.” –Dan St. Germain ([15:47])

• Scores Update:

  Last: Big Jay (0 pts), 4th: Dan (1), Lead: Luis, Louie, Karen (2 each) ([17:07])

3. Story #2: “Drunken argument with ex at a sporting event, both crying”

• [19:32] Karen considered the likely author due to her reputation:

  “This is too flowery of language… Like my assholes on the internet, you think I care somebody saw me fight at a game?” –Karen Feehan ([20:11])

• [24:49] Revealed as Luis J. Gomez’s story—an infamous UFC fight-night blowout with ex Kim Congdon:

  “She got in a fight with another guy, thought it was me… he spit in her face… I wasn’t fighting anyone, you crazy bitch… ran to the cops… they laughed in my face.” –Luis J. Gomez ([25:05–25:48])

• [26:36] Ralph Sutton witnessed the scene and called to tell Luis the next day.

• Scores Update:

  Last: Big Jay (0), 4th: Dan (1), 3rd: Louie (2), 2nd: Karen (4), Lead: Luis (5) ([27:02])

4. Story #3: “Screaming match with therapist after emotional breakdown over session notes”

• [30:02]
  Comedy panel riffs:

  “This is Louis Katz. This is a Jew thing.” –Karen Feehan ([30:21])

• [36:17] Turns out Dan St. Germain again—anger erupts as the rules confusion continues, but he details:

  • Couldn’t afford sessions, wanted the “brain spotting” notes, therapist refused, angry confrontation ensued.

  “It was brain spotting… you look at one spot and think about trauma… I called him a sucker, then he started screaming, called me a… I was like, alright, this guy’s not a good therapist.” –Dan St. Germain ([37:16])

• Scores Update:

  Last: Big Jay (0), 4th: Louie (2), 3rd: Dan (4), 2nd: Luis (5), Lead: Karen (6) ([38:09])

5. Story #4: “Comedian slaps me in the green room, so I ram their head into the wall until they apologize”

• [39:56] Panel debates who’s most likely to snap; suggestion it’s Louie Katz’s “secret psycho” side.

• [44:29] Louie admits the story:

  • Brent Weinbach slapped him after a prank, so Louie sought revenge at a different comedy club, demanded apology, and whacked Weinbach’s head against the wall until he relented.

  “I just punched him in the face—he goes, ‘You didn’t even say let’s fight first.’” –Louie Katz ([45:53]) “Sometimes violence is the answer.” –Louie Katz ([46:32])

• Scores Update:

  Last: Jay (2), 4th: Louie (3), 3rd: Luis (5), 2nd: Dan (6), Lead: Karen (8) ([47:07])

6. Story #5: “Major argument with SO at an amusement park; only happy on rides”

• [53:40] Jay teases Lewis as the likely candidate; much heckling about who loves theme parks and public fights.

• [59:46] Revealed as Big Jay Okerson’s story:

  • He and Christine (his girlfriend) argued all day at Universal Studios’ Halloween event, only enjoying the rides or a surprise Jabbawockeez show.

  “We were not talking. Walking through haunted houses… even the Jack Nicholson at me with a chainsaw had no effect.” –Jay ([60:45])

• Scores Update:

  Last: Louie (3), tied 3rd: Big Jay & Dan (6), 2nd: Luis (9), Lead: Karen (12) ([63:13])

7. Story #6: “Broke into neighbor’s apartment, almost got caught, ended up fighting two women”

• [66:16] Karen is accused due to wild party-girl past; all assume it’s her, but [72:16] Alex reveals—Big Jay again!

• Jay recounts:

  • Illegal eviction drama in Queens; he and Nate Bargatze’s wife broke into the landlord’s illegal basement for evidence; caught by the landlord’s mother and daughter, led to a bizarre street brawl.

  “The girl… almost like on an honor patch, she grabbed my sweatshirt and ripped it. This 70-year-old grandmother ripped my shirt.” –Jay ([76:27]) “…Me and Laura Bargatze went back-to-back like a John Woo movie…” ([76:44])

• Scores Update:

  Last: Louie (3), 4th: Dan (6), 3rd: Luis (9), 2nd: Karen (12), Lead: Jay (14) ([78:34])

8. Story #7: “Booger revenge: After a parking spot argument, I put my boogers under the other car’s door handle”

• [79:21]
  Extreme disgust on the panel.

• [87:04] Luis J. Gomez owns it:

  • Recent incident; pissing contest with a woman over a CVS parking spot; exacted retaliation the only way he knew how.

  “I dug every booger that I could get out of my nose. There’s not much more to it.” –Luis J. Gomez ([87:04])

• Scores Update:

  Last: Louie (7), 4th: Dan (10), 3rd: Karen (12), 2nd: Luis (13), Lead: Jay (14) ([89:13])

9. Story #8: “Caught in the middle of a beef between rival capoeira guys”

• [92:59] Most believe it’s Louie Katz due to his San Francisco and world-traveling comic reputation.

• [98:35] It is indeed Louie:

  • In Brazil, camping with capoeiristas, he’s swept up in a dancing martial-arts gang beef on an island.

  “I was in Brazil… I guess they have rival capoeira gangs, which I didn’t even know…and I just—one of them got in a fight, runs down the jungle path, jump kicks the other guy…” –Louis Katz ([99:58–101:09])

• Final Scores:

  Last: Dan (10), 3rd (tie): Luis & Louie (13), 2nd: Jay (14), WINNER: Karen (16) ([102:06])

Notable Quotes & Banter

• [09:11] Luis:

  “Oh, that was a Jewish joke. You guys heard that?”

• [24:27] Jay:

  “I would have heard the story of the one time I have.”

• [31:10] Jay:

  “I went once or twice and I was like, this is gay.” (on therapy)

• [46:32] Louie Katz:

  “Sometimes violence is the answer.”

• [56:45] Luis (to Louie):

  “Louie, have you ever gone to an amusement park with your boyfriend?”

• [64:57] Jay (on sponsor ad):

  “It’s made with mandelic acid, which sounds a fake thing…now featuring Guy Juice.”

• [73:33] Jay:

  “…Me and Laura Bargatze, Nate Bargatze’s wife, went back-to-back like a John Woo movie. Dove, shot out, and then me and her fought these two Asian ladies.”

• [87:04] Luis:

  “I dug every booger that I could get out of my nose…”

• [96:44] Jay:

  “Yeah, he told you, ‘hey guys, stop gangbanging and do dancing gay karate.’”

Final Moments & Winner’s Circle

• [102:21] Karen is gleefully stunned to win her first Story Warz, as the panel and crowd erupt.
• [103:15] Jay honors her:

  “Everybody, welcome your newest Story Warrior, Karen Feehan.”

Standout Bits and Tone

• Energy: The episode is raucous and insult-laden, with constant jokes about gender, ethnicity, and each other’s dark personal failings.
• Quotes: Panelists riff off each other:
  “This is a Jew thing.” —Karen ([30:21])
  “Favorite meat? My favorite cured meat.” —Jay ([32:32])
  “You shaved your head. You were sud me to jail.” —Jay ([68:53])
  “Hand turkey!” (running gag for “worthy” jokes)
• Game Play: Several guests are confused by the rules, especially around voting and admitting stories, which itself becomes a recurring punchline.
• Audience Participation: Live audience responds boisterously, manipulated for laughs.

Important Timestamps

• [07:35]: Story 1 read and discussed
• [13:12]: Dan admits story 1 (father/son fight)
• [19:32]: Story 2 read and discussed
• [24:49]: Luis reveals UFC breakup story
• [30:02]: Story 3 read and discussed
• [36:17]: Dan admits therapist fight
• [39:56]: Story 4 read and discussed
• [44:29]: Louie admits comic head-ramming story
• [53:40]: Story 5 (amusement park fight)
• [59:46]: Jay reveals amusement park argument
• [66:16]: Story 6 (break-in & fight)
• [72:16]: Jay reveals landlord street brawl
• [79:21]: Story 7 (parking spot booger revenge)
• [87:04]: Luis admits booger handle
• [92:59]: Story 8 (capoeira beef)
• [98:35]: Louie reveals capoeira street fight

Wrap-up

Karen Feehan’s underdog victory, after years of defeat on Story Warz, was a crowd-pleasing payoff to an episode packed with self-deprecating humor, comic violence, therapy horror stories, and one of the grossest acts of revenge ever described on a podcast.

This was classic Story Warz: combative, filthy, and very, very funny.