Story Warz Episode 068: "Dreams"

GaS Digital Network | November 21, 2025
Guests: Duncan Trussell, Tim Butterly, Heidi Regina
Hosts: Big Jay Oakerson, Luis J. Gomez
Location: LIVE at Comedy Mothership, Austin, TX

Episode Overview

This raucous live episode of Story Warz brings together comedians Big Jay Oakerson and Luis J. Gomez with guests Duncan Trussell, Tim Butterly, and Heidi Regina for a fiercely funny "game of deceptive storytelling." Broadcasting from the Comedy Mothership, the panel navigates the theme of "Dreams"—each sharing bizarre, revealing, and hilarious dream-related stories (some true, some cleverly disguised as another's), while everyone else tries to guess the true author of each tale.

Throughout the night, the episode teems with quick wit, playful jabs, surreal anecdotes, and running gags—especially about panelists’ sexual exploits, metaphysical ponderings, and bodily embarrassments—with the audience and host crowd egging them on. By the end, a new champion is crowned in a highly competitive and laughter-filled contest.

Key Points & Moments

The Game & Stakes

• Format Summary: Each panelist (and the hosts) submitted several dream-related stories. Randomly selected stories are read aloud; the authors must convince others it's not theirs while the rest try to correctly identify each author.
• Points System: 2 points for a correct guess, 1 point for each panelist fooled. Final stories are worth double.
• Prize: Winner receives "The Book of Useless Information" (07:00).

Big Jay Okerson:

“This week’s winner takes home the Book of Useless Information by Noel Botham... a pointless collection of fun facts, odd history, and answers to questions nobody’s ever needed to ask.”
([07:00])

Story 1 – Shot by a Comedian

[08:51-15:25]

• Dream: Getting shot in the stomach by a comedian at a show.
• Panel debates, ribbing Heidi about comedy creeps and Louis for past traumas.
• Reveal: It’s Louis J. Gomez's story, based on a real dream about being menaced by a comedian online.
• Freudian Analysis:
  Duncan Trussell:

"Your dream is the explosion of desire. When you were penetrated by that gun... it woke something up inside of you."
([12:01])

• Duncan notes famous premonition dreams before assassinations.
• Notable exchange on whose story it could be, with playful jabs about being “creepy” ([10:03-10:41]).

Story 2 – Strip Club Mass Shooting Heroics

[17:39-27:07]

• Dream: In strip club during a mass shooting, saves a stripper by taking her to the hospital.
• Punctuated by comic interrogation about past stripper careers, management, and heroic scenarios.
• Reveal: Heidi Regina authored it.
• She reveals the stripper from her dream is now a real-life medical esthetician she knows.
• Quick roasts:
  Heidi:

“I still don’t have a stomach, though. It’s Tim, I think.”
([14:19])
Tim (sarcastically, on heroics):
"You're talking about me preventing a rape."
([19:23])

Story 3 – DMT Spaceship

[32:50-41:09]

• Dream/hallucination: First time doing DMT, guided by a comedian, experiences an "organic spaceship cocoon."
• Duncan instantly suspects deflection tactics: “This is some MK Ultra mind control shit right now.” ([33:23])
• Reveal: This is Louis J. Gomez, and Duncan Trussell was the comedian who gave him DMT.
• Memorable detail:
  Louis:

“There was aliens on the outside of it, and they were tapping on the bubble gum, going, doo, doo, doo. Hello. Be my friend.”
([39:59])

Story 4 – Dreamt of Pregnancy, Then It Came True

[43:09-51:09]

• Dream: Someone is told in a dream a girl is pregnant; she calls to confirm it’s true in the morning.
• Panel debates whether this is “girl logic” or premonition; leans hard on Heidi, who deflects convincingly.
• Reveal: Duncan Trussell.

“Somebody that I had lived with… in the dream, she’s like, ‘I’m pregnant.’ And then that morning called me, I haven’t talked to her in probably a year, and was like, ‘I’m pregnant.’”
([50:50])

Mid-Episode Standings & Banter

[51:23]

• Heidi surges into the lead, Tim has zero points (“fucking humiliating”).

Story 5 – Bedwetting at Professional Athlete’s House

[59:58-66:48]

• Dream: Recurring dream of walking into the bathroom, ends with bedwetting; happened at a pro athlete’s (Chris Cole's) house.
• Discussion turns to which genders or comics likely wet the bed.
• Reveal: Tim Butterly.
  “I would say lifetime... at nights I’ve slept away from home maybe 15% of the time.” ([65:44])
• Comic debrief on adult bedwetting etiquette and stains.

Story 6 – Anal Sex on a Cruise Ship

[74:12-80:48]

• Statement: “I’ve had anal sex on the Carnival Dream cruise ship.”
• The room (and Tim) quickly settle on Big Jay due to cruise attendance history.
• Reveal: It is Big Jay Okerson.
• Big Jay:

“There’s not much more to the story. We... butt fucked on the ocean. Then we ordered late night pizza.”
([80:36])

Story 7 – Ghost Encounter in New Orleans

[82:42-90:03]

• Dream: Terrifying dream in New Orleans, later realizes it matches the story of a real murder-suicide on location.
• Heidi and Luis banter on who “believes in ghosts,” Duncan is mocked for being the only one supernatural enough for the story.
• Reveal: Duncan Trussell.
• Duncan expands:
  “I had this terrifying dream... I’m in Antarctica... body bag falls out of the sky... in his pocket is a note to my girlfriend… next night, the bartender tells me the story of a guy who killed his girlfriend at the Ritz in New Orleans and jumped.”
  ([87:59]-[88:44])

Story 8 – Maze House with Shitty Bathrooms

[92:16-97:19]

• Dream: Recurring dream of being trapped in a house on a cliff full of overflowing, unusable bathrooms.
• Debate rages on word choice “convoluted”—so erudite no guy on the panel could have written it.
• Reveal: Heidi Regina.
  Describes 25 years of the dream—“the bathrooms are always like, none of them are working ... It’s horrifying, a nightmare.” ([97:19])

Final Scores & Winner

Final Tally:

1. Heidi Regina – 24 points (WINNER)
2. Luis J. Gomez – 13 points
3. Tim Butterly – 12 points
4. Duncan Trussell – 10 points
5. Big Jay Okerson – 6 points

“Heidi Regina, you become officially a story warrior tonight.” — Louis J. Gomez ([99:22])
“You have officially been treated better than Kill Tony has ever treated you.” — Big Jay Okerson ([99:56])

Notable Quotes & Exchanges

• On dream logic and comedy life:

  “Your win percentage is the same as Tim’s wet the bed percentage.”—Heidi, roasting Jay ([68:40])

• On the night’s competitive flavor:

  “If she wins, we all look like simps who let it happen.”—Big Jay ([91:20])

• On surreal dreams:

  “Is the human brain like a player piano? It just uses whatever printer ink is in your brain… The closest my brain could get to it was Pete Holmes.”—Duncan Trussell ([89:38])

• On honesty and embarrassment:

  “Hotels, dude. And it’s not a full piss. The worst part is realizing, oh, now I’m dreaming. Then my eyes shoot up, and then I’m pissing a little bit...”—Tim Butterly ([66:29])

• On game tactics:

  “No glory in coming in last place if you don’t have zero points.”—Jay ([68:01])

Memorable Moments & Bits

• Heidi repeatedly and hilariously dodging rumors and ribbing about being a stripper, manager, or sexual deviant ([18:24], [22:24], [77:38]).
• Louis and Heidi’s flirtatious barbs and side bets (“I’ll give you two of my points if you make out with me right now” [81:53]).
• Duncan giving psychoanalytic interpretations of every dream, to the delight and annoyance of the others ([12:01], [33:23], [44:08]).
• Extended DMT anecdotes—Duncan coached Louis through his “organic spaceship cocoon” journey ([39:38]).
• Big Jay’s confessional about anal sex on the high seas—“Then we ordered late night pizza on the cruise ship.” ([80:48])
• Tim’s candid, almost nonchalant recounting of adult bedwetting and panel’s mock support ([65:44]-[66:48]).

Timestamps for Key Segments

| Timestamp | Segment | |------------|----------------------------------------------| | 07:00 | The Game, Stakes, and Prize Explained | | 08:51 | Story 1: Shot by a Comedian | | 17:39 | Story 2: Strip Club Shooting Hero | | 32:50 | Story 3: DMT Spaceship | | 43:09 | Story 4: Dreamed of Pregnancy | | 59:58 | Story 5: Bedwetting at Pro Athlete’s House | | 74:12 | Story 6: Anal Sex on Carnival Dream Cruise | | 82:42 | Story 7: Murderous Ghost in New Orleans | | 92:16 | Story 8: Maze House with Shitty Bathrooms | | 99:22 | Winner Announcement & Closing |

Conclusion

The “Dreams” edition of Story Warz delivered exactly what fans expect: riotous banter, personal revelations, relentless teasing, and the sharp comedic instincts of some of podcasting’s best. The episode showcases the subtle art of comedic deception, with Heidi Regina’s deadly straight face and surprising vocabulary ultimately earning her the coveted title of Story Warrior. With rapid-fire wit, profound nonsense, and no shortage of bodily function humor, it’s a dream for comedy junkies.

“You have officially been treated better than Kill Tony has ever treated you.”—Big Jay Okerson ([99:56])