1798 Robbery of the Bank of Pennsylvania

Summary

Summary of "Stuff You Missed in History Class" Episode 1798: The Robbery of the Bank of Pennsylvania

Hosted by Holly Frey and Tracy V. Wilson, Episode 1798 of "Stuff You Missed in History Class" delves into the intriguing story of the first recorded bank robbery in the United States—the 1798 heist at the Bank of Pennsylvania. This detailed exploration uncovers the wrongful accusation of a skilled blacksmith, Patrick Lyon, the true culprits behind the robbery, and the lasting impact of this historical event.

---

I. Introduction

The episode opens with Holly Frey introducing the groundbreaking story of the Bank of Pennsylvania robbery in 1798. She sets the stage by highlighting the wrongful imprisonment of Patrick Lyon, a blacksmith, and the subsequent legal battles that ensued.

II. Background: Carpenter's Hall and the Bank of Pennsylvania

Tracy V. Wilson provides historical context by discussing Carpenter's Hall, a significant building in U.S. history. Originally constructed in early 1770 for the Carpenter's Company of Philadelphia, the hall served multiple purposes, including housing the first free lending library and acting as an infirmary during the Revolutionary War. By 1798, Carpenter's Hall had become the leased space for the newly incorporated Bank of Pennsylvania.

III. The 1798 Bank Robbery

On the night of August 31, 1798, Carpenter's Hall witnessed the United States' first bank robbery. Remarkably, the thieves managed to escape with $162,821 (equivalent to over $4 million today) without any signs of forced entry or damage to the vault's locks. Tracy notes, “there really wasn't one. Nothing was broken” (06:59).

IV. Patrick Lyon: The Accused Blacksmith

Patrick Lyon, a skilled blacksmith from Aberdeen, Scotland, became the prime suspect. After moving to Philadelphia in 1793, Lyon had established a reputable business and was trusted by financial institutions, including the Bank of Pennsylvania. Given his recent work on securing the vault's locks, authorities quickly pointed fingers at him.

Patrick Lyon's Background:

• Born near Aberdeen, Scotland, in 1769.
• Relocated to London at age 11, where he honed his skills as a blacksmith.
• Moved to Philadelphia on November 25, 1793, seeking new opportunities.
• Married Anne Brindley in 1795 and had a daughter, Clementina, in 1796.

Tracy elaborates, “Patrick Lyon ... was inclined towards astronomy and mathematics” (03:26), showcasing his intellectual background beyond his trade.

V. Wrongful Imprisonment

As Philadelphia grappled with a yellow fever outbreak, Lyon attempted to flee to Delaware with his apprentice, James McGinley. Tragically, Lyon lost his wife and daughter to the epidemic in 1797, and his apprentice succumbed to the disease shortly after their departure (09:54).

Upon returning to Philadelphia, Lyon found himself the subject of intense suspicion. Despite his detailed accounts and attempts to clear his name, authorities remained unconvinced, leading to his arrest and detention at Walnut Street Prison. Holly describes his incarceration: “...he was put in a root cellar that wasn't being used. This was not in any way set up for a person to be housed in” (18:57).

VI. Revelation: Isaac Davis Confesses

The turning point came with the confession of Isaac Davis, a carpenter and the actual thief behind the robbery. Davis had initiated large, suspicious deposits at the bank, which raised red flags. Upon confrontation, Davis admitted to the robbery, revealing that his accomplice, Thomas Cunningham—the bank porter—had died of yellow fever, preventing him from reclaiming his portion of the stolen money.

Key Confession Points:

• Davis orchestrated the robbery and attempted to cover his tracks by depositing the stolen funds.
• Tracy recounts: “...he confessed then and there that he had been the one to rob the bank” (19:19).
• However, Davis later revealed discrepancies in his story, particularly regarding the whereabouts of the remaining money.

VII. The Aftermath for Patrick Lyon

Despite Davis's confession, the Bank of Pennsylvania and Philadelphia law enforcement remained skeptical of Lyon's innocence. The bank officials continued to tarnish Lyon's reputation, leading to significant professional and personal setbacks for him.

Lyon took legal action by publishing "The Narrative of Patrick Lyon," aiming to publicize his innocence and the bank's misconduct. His lawsuit against key bank officials for malicious prosecution highlighted the bias and prejudgment he faced.

Legal Proceedings:

• Tracy explains: “...his counsel sought to prove that the four accused men had conspired to keep Lyon in jail well after they knew he was innocent” (32:38).
• The trial showcased testimony that underscored the bank's prejudice against Lyon, ultimately leading to his exoneration and a financial settlement of $9,000.

VIII. Legacy of Patrick Lyon

Following his release, Patrick Lyon reinvented himself as an engineer, leveraging his mechanical expertise to design and build pump engines—early fire engines—that significantly impacted Pennsylvania and neighboring states. His innovations are still recognized today, with several Lyon-designed fire engines preserved in museums.

In 1825, Lyon commissioned a portrait titled "Patrick Lyon at the Forge" by John Neagle, symbolizing his identity as a blacksmith despite his newfound success. This portrait, which includes a depiction of the Walnut Street Prison’s cupola, serves as a poignant reminder of his wrongful imprisonment and is now housed in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, and the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Art.

Tracy notes Lyon’s enduring influence: “...he focused more on that after he was released. This may have also been a pivot that was necessitated by the damage to his blacksmithing reputation” (37:58).

IX. Conclusion

The episode concludes by reflecting on the broader implications of Patrick Lyon's story, illustrating the challenges of justice and prejudice in early American society. Despite the establishment of foundational democratic principles, Lyon's ordeal underscores the imperfections and societal biases that persisted.

Tracy aptly summarizes: “...this was like fresh after all of our, you know, governing documents that theoretically were to create some version of freedom and equality, obviously not full freedom and equality for everyone” (40:55).

---

Notable Quotes:

• Tracy V. Wilson at [06:59]: “...there really wasn't one. Nothing was broken.”
• Holly Frey at [18:57]: “...he was put in a root cellar that wasn't being used. This was not in any way set up for a person to be housed in.”
• Tracy V. Wilson at [19:19]: “...he confessed then and there that he had been the one to rob the bank.”
• Tracy V. Wilson at [32:38]: “...his counsel sought to prove that the four accused men had conspired to keep Lyon in jail well after they knew he was innocent.”
• Tracy V. Wilson at [37:58]: “...he focused more on that after he was released. This may have also been a pivot that was necessitated by the damage to his blacksmithing reputation.”
• Tracy V. Wilson at [40:55]: “...this was like fresh after all of our, you know, governing documents that theoretically were to create some version of freedom and equality, obviously not full freedom and equality for everyone.”

---

Timestamp References:

• 06:59
• 03:26
• 09:54
• 18:57
• 19:19
• 32:38
• 37:58
• 40:55

---

This episode masterfully intertwines historical facts with personal narratives, bringing to light the complexities of justice and reputation in the early United States. Through the story of Patrick Lyon, listeners gain insight into the challenges faced by individuals navigating societal biases and legal injustices.

Transcript

[Narrator]

See Gladiator 2 only in theaters November 22nd. This film delivers action, an emotional and compelling story, and performances and spectacle on a scale unlike anything else. Gladiator 2 stands out with its immersive visuals and a gripping, character driven narrative. The film stars an extraordinary cast including Paul Mezcal, Pedro Pascal, Denzel Washington and Connie Nielsen. Reprising her role as Lucilla, get ready for an epic experience made for the big screen. Gladiator 2 only in theaters on November.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

22Nd here's to Turkey Day, the favorite day of the year for many. From cozying up by the fire to watch the parade to gathering in the kitchen to whip up casseroles, it's a time of joy and togetherness. And here's to the Chinette brand for making it all a little easier with the Chinat Classic collection. No need to worry about cleanup. Plus, Chinat Classic plates and bowls are compostable, helping not just to keep the sink clean but also leaving less of a mess for future generations. So here's to being together. Together. Here's to us. All of us. Find a local [e-mail] what does every.

[Holly Frey]

Grocery store aisle now have in common? Products that come in paper packaging, and not just the obvious ones like cereal boxes and juice cartons. From beauty products to boxed water, there are more opportunities to go papertarian than ever before. So why should you? Because paper comes from a renewable resource and can be recycled up to seven times. Simply put, it's the smart choice for the environment and it turns out, the easiest choice for you. Learn [e-mail] Papertarium this episode is brought.

[Sponsor]

To you by Bleecker street and their new film, the Return, the exhilarating finale to the Odyssey. Arriving home decades after leaving for the Trojan War, Odysseus is haggard and unrecognizable as his wife, Penelope is hounded by suitors vying to be king. He must rediscover the warrior within to win back all that he has lost. Ralph Fiennes and Juliette Binoche shine in what the Daily Beast calls a thrilling, terrifying take on the Odyssey. The return, in theaters December 6th.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Do you like podcasts, music and audiobooks? Because when you subscribe to Amazon Music Unlimited, you get all three in one app. Imagine listening to your favorite podcasts and music on the go to work, school, the gym, or better yet, vacation. Now imagine being on vacation with your favorite audiobook from Audible and then listening to a new one every month from a huge selection of popular titles. That sounds like a pretty Good Vacation, right Audible is now included on Amazon Music Unlimited. Download the Amazon Music app now to start Listening Terms apply.

[Holly Frey]

Welcome to Stuff youf Missed in History Class, a production of iHeartRadio. Hello and welcome to the podcast. I'm Holly Frey.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

And I'm Tracy V. Wilson.

[Holly Frey]

The first recorded bank robbery in the US Resulted in the wrong man sitting in jail for quite a while, a very strange confession from the actual perpetrator, and a rather serious lawsuit for the administrators of the bank that was robbed. Today we are going to talk about the bank of Pennsylvania and the robbery that took place there in 1798, as well as quite a bit about the prime suspect, who was a blacksmith named Patrick Lyon.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

In 1799 a book was published titled the Narrative of Patrick Lyon, and in its opening it shares the author's early life story. I began my mechanical study at an early age, being only turned of 11 years, and after spending nearly 14 years in London in different manufactories and having previously studied mathematics, etc. I resolved to come to America, which displeased my relations and friends in a great measure. I, however, undertook the enterprise and arrived in Philadelphia on 25 November 1793. And if ever there was a mechanical volunteer came into America, I certainly have fair claim to the title.

[Holly Frey]

That certainly sounds like it's going to be the story of finding a new life in a new country, and to some degree it is. But the real focus of that narrative is how Patrick Lyon was accused of what is often considered the first bank robbery in the US and the time that he spent behind bars.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Things had gone wrong for Patrick in the summer of 1798. But before we get to that, we'll talk about a building that's Carpenter's hall, which has an important place in U.S. history. Carpenter's hall was built starting in early 1770. It was to be the home of the Guild, known as the Carpenter's Company of the City and County of Philadelphia, that had been in existence for nearly 50 years when it purchased a plot of land and broke ground. But the hall was not used only by the Carpenters Guild, it was also used by other societies for their meetings and events.

[Holly Frey]

Carpenter's hall was also home to the first free lending library that started there in 1773 as part of Ben Franklin's Library Company. That library was the first Congressional Library, and it remained in the building until 1790. The first Continental Congress convened there in the building in 1774. During the Revolutionary War, the hall was used as an infirmary for both sides of the conflict. It is also sometimes called the First Pentagon, as it served as the main office for General Henry Knox, the first US Secretary of War in the early 1790s. It has served as the site of many important moments in North American history. But the part of Carpenter's Hall's history that's germane to today's topic is that it started to be used for banking in 1791. That was the bank of North America, which stayed in that space for two years. Starting in 1794, the First bank of the United States was housed there. It was there for five years as the institution's own purpose built building was constructed. And in 1798, it was leased to the bank of Pennsylvania, which had been incorporated in 1793.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

On the night of August 31, 1798, the hall was home to another first, and that was the first bank robbery in the United States. The thief or thieves got away with $162,821. In modern terms, that's comparable to a little more than $4 million. Although, as we always say, it's hard to accurately convert the value of money over time because there are so many variables involved. However, long story short, a lot. Millions of dollars.

[Holly Frey]

As for the break in, there really wasn't one. Nothing was broken. There was no indication of forced entry. The access points to the building and the bank vault were entirely undamaged. So it seemed to be the work of someone who knew the building and its locks. The bank had only just moved into the space at Carpenter's hall, and as part of that transition, there had been new carpentry work done and the vault doors had gotten new fittings and locks. Naturally, the first person suspected was the blacksmith who had worked on the vault.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

That prime suspect was, of course, Patrick Lyon. He'd been born near aberdeen, Scotland, in 1769. As a child, he went to school in the local parish and was drawn to astronomy and mathematics. Then, as we mentioned in the opening, when he was 11, he left school and moved to London to work as a blacksmith until 1793 when he moved to Pennsylvania.

[Holly Frey]

Lyon's first boss in Philadelphia was a blacksmith named Samuel Wheeler. But according to Lion's account, he, quote, discovered Wheeler was taking advantage of a stranger with regard to wages, et cetera. And as he had no great idea of cultivating the profession, I left him and went to another. Lyon went into business himself, and after having built up a professional reputation over several years, he was recommended to the bank of Pennsylvania. Before that move into Carpenter's hall was planned, he had worked on various projects for the bank of Pennsylvania and the bank of North America starting in 1797. And then after an attempted robbery at the bank of Pennsylvania, that institution was hurriedly moved from its Lodge Alley location to Carpenter's hall, and Lyon was asked to do a rush job so they could secure the vault there. The attempted robbery that caused the move had taken place on August 4, 1798, and that had involved someone trying unsuccessfully to pick a lock and then also to pick open an iron chest. Lyon and the bank directors apparently argued about the nature of the locks on the vault. For the new space, the bank wanted imported locks, which Lyon told them were not the correct option for their vault doors. They were adamant in their choice, though.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

In the time between his move to Philadelphia and his work for the bank, Lyon had been through a lot. He had married a woman named anne Brindley on July 4, 1795. Patrick and Anne welcomed a daughter named Clementina in 1796. The timing of the bank robbery was rather unique in that it happened during a yellow fever outbreak in Philadelphia. And this was a very serious situation. Hundreds of people died, including Patrick's wife and daughter. He lost both of them in 1797.

[Holly Frey]

As the epidemic continued to claim victims, people with the means to do so left the city. And one of the people who fled was blacksmith Patrick Lyon. After he wrapped up his work on the bank vault, he had arranged to travel with his apprentice, James McGinley, by boat to Delaware. They made it to the port at Lewiston, Delaware, but Lyon's apprentice was ill, although he seemed to get better briefly. And though Lyon hired two doctors to see him, James died just a couple days later. Lyon stayed in Lewiston to wait out the epidemic.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

When news of the robbery reached Delaware, Lyon, of course, was invested in the story. He had just worked on that vault and Lyon found out through a friend who had also made his way to Lewiston to get away from the yellow fever epidemic. He was the suspect. We'll talk about what he did after we pause for a sponsor break.

[Narrator]

See Gladiator 2 only in theaters November 22nd. This film delivers thrilling action, a compelling story, emotionally charged performances, and spectacle on a scale unlike anything else. Only Ridley Scott could pull off a cinematic marvel at this scale. With sweeping storytelling and relentless action, Gladiator 2 stands out in the modern cinematic landscape. With its immersive visuals, incredible score and a gripping character driven narrative, the film stars an extraordinary cast, including Paul Mezcal, Pedro Pascal, with Denzel Washington and Connie Nielsen reprising her role as Lucilla the fate of Rome rests on an uneasy alliance between Lucius and Macrinus, who need each other to further their ambitions. Gladiator 2 is a complex political chess game, action packed revenge story with a beating emotional core. You will be on the edge of your seat as you experience the unexpected twists and turns throughout the film. Get ready for an epic, immersive, visceral experience made for the big screen. See Gladiator 2 only in theaters on November 22nd. Don't miss it.

[Austin James]

Hey, it's Austin James. Yes, I'm living with diabetes, but it doesn't have to define me. Thanks to the Freestyle Libre A three plus sensor, I get real time glucose readings throughout the day. The Freestyle Libre 3 sensor is small and easy to wear, giving me the freedom to focus on my life as a parent and a musician. Now this is progress. You can get a free sensor at FreestyleLibre US offer available for people who qualify.

[Sponsor]

Visit MyFreestyle US to see all terms and conditions. Certain exclusions apply. Data on File Avid Diabetes Care Prescription Only Safety info found @freestylelibre us do.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

You like podcasts, music and audiobooks? Because when you subscribe to Amazon Music Unlimited, you get all three in one app. Imagine listening to your favorite podcasts and music on the go to work, school, the gym, or better yet, vacation. Now imagine being on vacation with your favorite audiobook from Audible and then listening to a new one every month from a huge selection of popular titles. That sounds like a pretty good vacation, right? Audible is now included on Amazon Music Unlimited. Download the Amazon Music app now to start listening terms Apply if you use.

[Holly Frey]

Paper, you're a human, but if you choose paper, you're a papertarian. Someone who lives a paper based lifestyle because it has a positive impact on the planet and also because it's the easiest choice you'll make all day. Seriously, it's as easy as reaching for boxed instead of bottled water. It's as easy as opting for beauty products that come in paper packaging. It's as easy as grabbing eggs in a cardboard container. And that's all in one trip to the grocery store, which, if everyone's being honest, you were planning to go to anyway. But paper isn't just an easy choice. Papertarians know that. It's the smart choice too, because paper comes from trees, a renewable and sustainably managed resource. And paper products are designed to be recycled. In fact, when you choose products that come in paper based packag, those fibers can go on to be recycled up to seven times. So why wouldn't you go papertarian learn more at howlifeunfolds.com Papertarian.

[Sponsor]

Shop Dell Technologies Black Friday event for their lowest prices of the year. The Future is on sale today with limited time deals on select PCs like the XPS 16 that accelerate AI with Intel Core Ultra processors. Black Friday is their biggest sale of the year and the best time to upgrade, but it's only here for a limited time. Shop [e-mail] deals that's Dell.com deals.

[Holly Frey]

When Lyon realized that he was being sought by the law in connection with this robbery, he took a head on approach to dealing with it. He went back to Philadelphia as quickly as he could. Not only did he want to make sure he was cleared, but he also wanted to tell authorities about the men that he suspected. That was carpenter Samuel Robinson and a friend of Robinson's who had visited the hall as work was being done to prepare the space for the bank of Pennsylvania.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Lyon got in touch with the authorities and met with bank directors and Alderman Robert Wharton. He told them everything he knew, including his suspicions about the two other men. He later wrote about his encounter with them in detail and this is how he described it. Quote On Friday I began to operate on the doors. In the afternoon I was visited by Robinson the carpenter, who brought a person with him, a stranger to me. They both took a particular observation of the locks, keys, etc. I told Robinson at this time that those locks were not fit for a bank. In the hearing of this stranger, the reader will please to keep in direct and point blank view this stranger, and there may be a possible surmise of the character of some of his connections. During the whole work. Robinson informed me that Smith the cashier would not employ me after this was done, owing to the delay. I answered it made little difference to me. I gave Robinson and his companion something to drink, and they both went away towards Second Street. They had not been gone above 10 minutes when Robinson's companion, the stranger, came back and went into my shop while I was answering a young woman at the door. I took no notice of him, as he appeared to be Robinson's confidential friend and companion. He did not stop above a minute and came to the door. I said I was in a hurry and must work all night, as the bank was in such haste for their work being done. Robinson's companion answered that he would see all banks damned before he would kill himself in this hot weather. Then he took his course towards Front Street. He did not follow Robinson. Whether they met again immediately or not, I cannot tell, but suppose they did so. Of course he was establishing that he was not the only person who had access to the locks for the vault.

[Holly Frey]

Yes, and that mystery stranger is going to come up again. But the bank and the alderman thought that when lion told him all of this, that he was lying. And one of their reasons was that his account of what happened with Robinson and this mystery man was just too detailed, it seemed to them, unnecessarily. So. So they thought that made Lyon seem guilty. It was believed by everyone involved that the blacksmith must have made himself a key while working on the vault. Lyon was arrested, sort of not charged, just arrested and held at Walnut Street Prison. This was a very grim situation. As was relayed later in court. They decided that Lyon should go to jail. There was no circumstance alleged against him, but that he had had the doors in his possession before the robbery. The bail required was $150,000. It was impossible he could procure it. He was therefore committed to jail, in which there was 20 or 30 cases of yellow fever and a number of deaths followed. He was neglected while there and reduced to extreme want. The access of the few friends he.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Had was denied for some additional clarification and detail. There was no formal charge against him. He was just detained for being suspected. Because of his lack of charge, the jailer felt he should be kept separate from the other incarcerated men. So he was put in a root cellar that wasn't being used. This was not in any way set up for a person to be housed in. Patrick Lyon didn't even have a bed. He literally slept on the ground, malnourished and without much human interaction. At. He later said he never expected to make it out of Walnut street alive.

[Holly Frey]

It seemed like Lyon was doomed. There was no way he could clear his name or even make a case for himself when he didn't even have a charge to fight. But then something happened. The bank of Pennsylvania had received several sizable deposits of money from one new account holder, Isaac Davis.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

When Isaac Davis, a carpenter who was not especially wealthy, suddenly had a lot of money, started to raise eyebrows, specifically the eyebrows of the bank. Here's how it was described in a statement made by a bank committee which was read in court and entered into court documents. Quote one, Isaac Davis, a carpenter by trade, had an account opened in this bank, and the first circumstance which excited the suspicions of the president and cashier against him was a deposit of $1600. Inquiry was made as to his circumstances and character, which were found to be such as to induce the officers to watch his conduct. On Saturday 13 November, just before the bank closed, he deposited $3,910. The suspicions were then increased, and it was thought proper to inquire at the banks of the United States and of North America whether he had accounts open with those institutions. And on Monday morning, such information was obtained as left no doubt that he was the robber.

[Holly Frey]

So Isaac Davis was brought before bank officials. He was kind of invited for a chat. And when he was confronted and asked how he was able to make those large deposits, Davis completely folded. He confessed then and there that he had been the one to rob the bank, the same bank where he was now depositing the stolen money. He also had an accomplice, and that was Thomas Cunningham. Cunningham was the bank porter, and he had spent the night in the bank the night of the robbery. But he had come down with yellow fever the day after the robbery and then died a few days later. Davis said that he and Cunningham had split the money, but the porter's untimely death meant that his portion was still in his house. Isaac returned the majority of what he had not already deposited with the bank. But it also turned out that Davis lied. When Cunningham's home was searched for the remaining money, there was nothing there. Davis eventually confessed that he actually had the rest, except for some that he had spent. And the bank recovered almost all of the money. Davis told them that Cunningham had procured a set of keys, but that he, Isaac Davis, did not know where those keys had come from. And that was a detail that the bank officials and lawmen would really hang on to.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Enter Benjamin Brannon, Esquire, the associate judge of Delaware county, and Isaac Davis's uncle. He visited the bank cashier and made some effort to make up the gap in the recovered funds through some legal doings with the intention that Isaac Davis would be pardoned. At one point, the committee we just quoted a moment ago had intended to prepare charges against Brannon because he, quote, contrary to the duties of his office, endeavored to prevent a certain Isaac Davis from being punished, whom he knew had robbed the bank of Pennsylvania. Brannon continued to wheel and deal, promising that his nephew would give up all the information on where the keys had come from and all of that in return for a pardon. And although this seemed like something that should have gotten Brannon into a whole lot of trouble, the office of Pennsylvania Governor John Dickinson did make a deal with Isaac Davis, which was, return the money and tell us how you did it, and we'll forgive everything. So Davis walked away from this entire affair with pretty much no repercussions.

[Holly Frey]

On November 20, 1798 the following story ran in the paper the North American under the somewhat odd of Democratic Mystery Unraveled Quote it is with great satisfaction we acquaint our reader that the notes robbed from the bank of Pennsylvania at the commencement of the fever have been recovered to within $4,000 of the whole amount, which there is also a further prospect of getting hold of. It appears that one Isaac Davis, a carpenter and a noted Democrat, in conjunction with a porter belonging to the bank who died of the fever, were the sole agents in this nefarious business. Davis had set up his carriage and pair and pretended that an Indiaman had arrived at New York, in which he sent out an adventure on the death of his accomplice. He took the whole of the cash of which a dividend had been made into his possession and was detected by means of the large deposits he had made in each of the banks. NB Citizen Davis has made off with.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

The crime solved and the money recovered, it would seem like Patrick Lyon's life should get back to normal. But it did not. We will talk about that after we hear from the sponsors that keep the show going.

[Narrator]

See Gladiator 2 only in theaters November 22nd. This film delivers thrilling action, a compelling story, emotionally charged performances and spectacle on a scale unlike anything else. Only Ridley Scott could pull off a cinematic marvel at this scale. With sweeping storytelling and relentless action. Gladiator 2 stands out in the modern cinematic landscape with its immersive visuals, incredible score and a gripping character driven narrative. The film stars an extraordinary cast including Paul Mescal, Pedro Pascal, with Denzel Washington and Connie Nielsen reprising her role as Lucilla. The fate of Rome rests on an uneasy alliance between Lucius and Macrinus who need each other to further their ambitions. Gladiator 2 is a complex political chess game, action packed revenge story with a beating emotional core. You will be on the edge of your seat as you experience the unexpected twists and turns throughout the film. Get ready for an epic, immersive, visceral experience made for the big screen. See Gladiator 2 only in theaters on November 22nd. Don't miss it.

[Austin James]

Hey, it's Austin James. If you're like me, trying to live your best life while living with diabetes, you can relate to worrying if you're doing a good job managing your diabetes. I use the Freestyle Libre 3 sensor to get real time glucose readings and see the impact of every meal and activity to make better decisions. The Freestyle Libre 3 sensor can help me live life with diabetes on my own terms and it gives me more time for the things I love, like being a dad and a musician. Now this is progress. Learn more at FreeStyleLibre US.

[Sponsor]

For prescription only safety info found at FreeStyleLibre US.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Do you like podcasts, music and audiobooks? Because when you subscribe to Amazon Music Unlimited, you get all three in one app. Imagine listening to your favorite podcasts and music on the go to work, school, the gym, or better yet, vacation. Now imagine being on vacation with your favorite audiobook from Audible and then listening to a new one every month from a huge selection of popular titles. That sounds like a pretty good vacation, right? Audible is now included on Amazon Music Unlimited. Download the Amazon Music app now to start listening Terms Apply if you use.

[Holly Frey]

Paper, you're a human. But if you choose paper, you're a papertarian, someone who lives a paper based lifestyle because it has a positive impact on the planet and also because it's the easiest choice you'll make all day. Seriously, it's as easy as reaching for boxed instead of bottled water. It's as easy as opting for beauty products that come in paper packaging. It's as easy as grabbing eggs in a cardboard container. And that's all in one trip to the grocery store. Which, if everyone's being honest, you were planning to go to anyway. But paper isn't just an easy choice. Papertarians know that. It's the smart choice too, because paper comes from trees, a renewable and sustainably managed resource, and paper products are designed to be recycled. In fact, when you choose products that come in paper based packaging, those fibers can go on to be recycled up to seven times. So why wouldn't you go papertarian? Learn more at howlifeunfolds.com Papertarian.

[Sponsor]

Shop Dell Technologies Black Friday event For their lowest prices of the year, the Future is on sale today, with limited time due deals on select PCs like the XPS 16 that accelerate AI with Intel Core Ultra processors. Black Friday is their biggest sale of the year and the best time to upgrade. But it's only here for a limited time. Shop [e-mail] deals that's dell.com deals.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Although.

[Holly Frey]

A full confession from the actual thief should have resulted in an immediate release for lion, it did not. The bank was still entirely convinced that he had been involved and that he had made an unauthorized spare key to the vault, and Philadelphia law enforcement backed up the bank. So Lyon sat in jail. Moreover, he was finally formally charged with the charge of accessory before the fact. He went before a grand jury in 1799, but as there was no real evidence against him, the grand Jury returned a judgment that the case was insufficiently proven. It is worth noting that the bank never disclosed during that grand jury proceeding that Isaac Davis had confessed to the crime and said the lion was not involved. So even though they had not shared that information, Lyon was at last released.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

But that was hardly the end of it. After all he had been through, people still believed he had somehow been involved in the robbery. And that was due in no small part to the leadership at the bank of Pennsylvania. They continued to spread their belief that he had somehow gotten away with theft, even though the bank had its money back and a confession from the actual thief. But even worse, for a blacksmith who had done most of his business with banks and other sizable companies in Philadelphia, being accused by one bank tanked his reputation with the rest of the city's businesses. So his income suffered considerably after his release.

[Holly Frey]

Lyon wrote a book, the one that we quoted at the top of the show, which the short name of it is the Narrative of Patrick Lyon. He makes clear his intentions in that document, writing, quote, that the conduct of the bank of Pennsylvania on the late robbery cannot, in my opinion, be pardoned either on the score of public justice or national policy. But as the affair stands, the public still entertain their suspicion, and the matter remains unraveled, owing, if my suspicions are well founded and my judgment right, though not competent in law, to know, to a certain peculiar incomprehensibility, as several glaring reports are in circulation which in the body of this work I shall endeavor to explain. And as persons are generally the last to hear what materially concerns themselves, I shall take notice of them, that such suspected characters may have an opportunity of contracting the rumor that they have made it in their power to clear their conduct of the heavy suspicion which is leveled against them. For my own part, I have a right to speak because I suffered innocently, and as I am informed, no legal steps can be taken to enforce a recompense for false and severe imprisonment. I therefore take the liberty to lay my case before my fellow citizens. Ads for this book ran daily in Philadelphia newspapers, basically saying, hey, you want to know what happened to that guy they put in jail? He'll tell you all about it. Lyon wanted to make sure that his version of the story got out. But this book was actually a precursor to legal action on Lyon's part. He filed a malicious prosecution lawsuit against bank president Samuel M. Fox, head cashier Jonathan Smith alderman, and bank board member John Clement Stocker, and constable John Haynes. The case was heard before the Supreme Court of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania in 18 oh, 5.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

During the trial, there were witnesses called to testify that members of the bank's leadership had basically said they could do what they wanted regarding Patrick Lyon and that he was powerless in comparison to them. There were plenty of witnesses who relayed conversations with bank staff at all levels, establishing bias and presumption of Patrick Lyon's guilt. There was also testimony that it had been Samuel Robinson who had pushed for the locks that Lyon said were not usable and that Lyons had made clear that they would be easy to open. Lyons also thought the manner in which the doors were to be mounted was unsafe. Reading through all of that testimony, it really starts to seem like the bank was more interested in scapegoating and punishing Lyon than really anything else.

[Holly Frey]

Another interesting bit of testimony came from one of the bank guards, a man named Philip Coldwater. He explained that he worked with Thomas Cunningham and another porter named Potter, and that Cunningham was routinely trusted with the vault key. Coldwater, incidentally, quit the bank when the money was returned, exasperated that he and the other guards had been suspected. Another witness, John Corneck, who ran a lodging house, also testified that Thomas Cunningham had stayed at his house the night before the robbery and that he wore a large key on what Corneck called a garter around his neck.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Witnesses verified Lion's claims about the conditions of his incarceration. But more than anything, his counsel sought to prove that the four accused men had conspired to keep Lyon in jail well after they knew he was innocent, to keep him from retaliating against them for everything he had endured. His legal team of Alexander J. Dallas and Joseph Hopkinson argued, quote, after the grand jury had refused to consider Lyon as the accomplice of Davis and Cunningham, what could induce his persecutors to continue their endeavors to put and keep Lyon down? But malice, and malice, too, the most execrable kind. But they assign another motive. They justify themselves on the principle of self defense. We must put down Patrick Lyon or he will put down us. We must cripple him in his cause and in his means, or he will dare to meet us in a court of justice. And they have hitherto pursued the road they laid down for themselves. But it is hoped you, gentlemen of the jury, will stop their career.

[Holly Frey]

There was a clear display of prejudice against Lyon on behalf of the bank, as shown by the arguments of the bank's defense attorney, William Raul. Even though Davis had confessed and had stated that Patrick Lyon was in no way involved, and even though there was ample evidence to place lion in Delaware when the heist happened, Rawl continued to suggest that Lyon had to have been involved. It was claimed that he was the best keymaker in Philadelphia and was the only man who could have possibly unlocked the vault outside of bank staff. The defense also argued that everything it did, it did for the interest of civil society. Rawl argued that, quote, it was an important and imperious duty imposed upon the defendant who were entrusted in perilous times with great property and founded on correct principles. There were others as well as Lyon to be considered principle and duty and not rancor and malice were the only motives that influenced the defendants.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

There was a great deal of discussion about the procedural use of the bank's keys, who had them, and when, and whether the porters and guards had carried out the procedure as usual. The night of the robbery, they claimed that Cunningham couldn't have gotten into the vault, only into the bank itself. Then there was more suggestion that somehow Lyon was involved. Rawl also once again invoked the specificity of Lyon's account to the bank management as suspicious, noting, quote, Mr. Lyon gave a minute account of all of his proceedings. This from the time he left Philadelphia till his return. Minuteness and particularity appeared very remarkable and extraordinary to Messrs. Wharton, Stalker and Fox. Upon his being told that they could prove it against him, he immediately became confused and called for a glass of water for that he was almost fainting. Mr. Wharton then, supposing that he was about to disclose the whole affair, said, if you discharge him, you would do wrong. You ought certainly to commit him. So the defense also clearly stated that lion was held. That's committed based on nothing other than suspicion. Incidentally, when Wharton was called to testify, he clarified that. He said to the other men involved in Lyon's questioning, quote, the importance of his examination and the embarrassed situation he appears in would, if I were the magistrate, induce me to commit him. I believe Mr. Stalker then committed him. Patrick Lyon was extremely minute in his narrative, as I have mentioned before. And this formed, in my opinion, the ground of my advice where I was convinced that he had been concerned.

[Holly Frey]

Yeah, Wharton is definitely trying to be like, no, no, I didn't do it. I just said like I would do it based on what he said. When it was time for jury deliberation, the judge made clear to them that they had to determine if the bank had probable cause to detain lion. And if the bank did, the malice charge could not stand. After just four hours of deliberation, the jury found in favor of lion, and they awarded him 12,000 doll thousand dollars. He didn't actually get that much though? The defendants appealed and a new trial was scheduled for March 1807. But as that second trial date approached, the bank and Patrick Lyon reached an out of court settlement and he received a payout of $9,000.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Once Lyon's suit was concluded, he went back to his life and his business. He had remarried to Catherine Taggart even before the 1805 trial had started. And he didn't go back to blacksmithing. He had worked on various mechanical projects even before he was wrongfully detained, and he focused more on that after he was released. This may have also been a pivot that was necessitated by the damage to his blacksmithing reputation. But even so, it also turned out to be quite lucrative. He started making pump engines. That's early fire engines. He's credited with building several dozen fire engines that were put to use in Pennsylvania and the surrounding states, and several still exist in museums. In addition to focusing on engineering, lion invested his money in real estate.

[Holly Frey]

Yeah, there is could be a whole other story about his pump engines. There are people that really, really love specifically Lyon designed fire engines. And you can find lists of where you can go visit them, which is just kind of an interesting thing. In 1825, Lyon commissioned a portrait of himself by painter John Neagle. That portrait, titled Pat lion at the forge, or its much longer name, full length portrait of Mr. Patrick Lyon representing him as engaged at his anvil, is an unusual portrait for a number of reasons. For one, it's considered one of the great examples of early US portraiture. For another, the artist Niegle was young, just 29 at the time. But the most unique attribute of this image is the way in which Lyon chose to be represented at this point. Lyon, who was in his late 50s, was wealthy and successful and had not had to work at the forge in quite a while. But that is how he wanted to be painted. Not informal attire, looking like a well to do businessman, but as a blacksmith. Where he started this is believed to be in part because he associated the portraits of men in their finest attire with the type of men who had seen to it that he was wrongfully imprisoned. This is kind of supported by something he asked to have included in the artwork. In the top left of the image, through a window in the blacksmith workshop, the cupola of the Walnut street prison is visible. That's a detail Lyon insisted on. That portrait is now part of the collection of the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, and it can be seen in the Kristen and Rogers Servison Gallery. There is actually a second version of this painting, which Lyon commissioned for himself after he let the Boston Athenaeum display the first one. The second one is a slightly more detailed rendering, but it's very similar, and that second one is displayed at the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Art.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Patrick Lyon died on April 15, 1829 at the age of 60.

[Holly Frey]

I love that weird story. It is very weird and sort of wonderful and I hate that he went through all that. But it's also just a great example of like as you and I discussed right before we recorded this was like fresh after all of our, you know, governing documents that theoretically were to create some version of freedom and equality, obviously not full freedom and equality for everyone. And yet it was not as though those were truly the things that were dominating people's judgment at the time.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Yeah, throwing someone into effectively a root cellar without cause and keeping them there. One of the things purportedly prevented through things in the Constitution.

[Holly Frey]

Right. And yet there it goes. I really, really just wildly enjoy this story though, and we'll talk more about it in the behind the Scenes on Friday. But in the meantime, I have a wonderful listener mail that includes animals we have not featured in our pet tax before.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Nice.

[Holly Frey]

Or an animal that we have not featured. This is from our listener Tanya who writes hi ladies, I just finished listening to your Richer dad episode and thought I would send a pet tax photo of a pet you may not have heard of before. This is my daughter's blue death feigning beetle, Drogon, who is about the size of a nickel. I end up bug sitting him frequently when she goes on trips. I am also attaching a photo of my sweet moyen poodle Stella. Her mother was a standard and her father was a mini. She is a perfect 20 pound size. I enjoy listening to your podcast on my drives to and from work and while working around our mini farm in Pennsylvania, which also tied it back to this episode. So voila. First of all, Stella is adorable. Stella is also the name of one of my Joro spiders this year, so clearly it's the best name. And this little blue death feigning beetle is so cute and one we have not had before. And I was trying to look up while we were doing this what their lifespan is and I couldn't easily find one but it's really, really sweet and I've never seen one and I want to know more about it because I like keeping all the bugs just as much as anything else. I was very excited that I caught our spider Stella doing some very active things last night. She's been kind of chill. So apparently a raccoon on the deck startled her and she got very busy with her web.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Oh goodness.

[Holly Frey]

She's like, intruder alert. Intruder alert. She's great. She's fine. It just startled her. It's. She's completely out of reach. But she's very, very keenly aware of when animals are on the deck. That's when she gets really busy. So thank you, thank you Tanya for sending us those pictures again. Stella is so cute. I want to boop that snoot. If you would like to write to us with a pet tax or without, you don't have to have one. Don't feel pressured. You can do that@history podcastiheartradio.com you can also subscribe to the show on the iHeartRadio app or wherever you listen to your favorite podcast.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

Stuff youf Missed in History Class is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows. Here's to Turkey Day, the favorite day of the year for many. From cozying up by the fire to watch the parade to gathering in the kitchen to whip up casseroles, it's a time of joy and togetherness. And here's to the Chinette brand for making it all a little easier with the Chinette Classic collection. No need to worry about cleanup. Plus, Chinet Classic plates and bowls are compostable, helping not just to keep the sink clean, but also leaving less of a mess for future generations. So here's to being together. Here's to us. All of us. Find a local [e-mail] See Gladiator 2.

[Narrator]

Only in theaters November 22nd. This film delivers action, an emotional and compelling story, and performances in spectacle on a scale unlike anything else. Gladiator 2 stands out with its immersive visuals and a gripping, character driven narrative. The film stars an extraordinary cast including Paul Mezcal, Pedro Pascal, Denzel Washington and Connie Nielsen. Reprising her role as Lucilla, get ready for an epic experience made for the big screen. Gladiator 2 only in theaters on November.

[Tracy V. Wilson]

22 this holiday season, surprise everyone on your list with the best gifts. Tickets to see the their favorite artists live, choose from thousands of concerts and comedy shows including Mariah Carey, Mary J. Blige, Matt Matthews, Metallica, Thomas Rhett, Trans Siberian Orchestra, Sarah Silverman and so many more. Share a memory together or give a gift they'll never forget. Find the most exciting gift for every [e-mail] gifts.

[Sponsor]

That's livenation.com gifts we've all got a thing, an obsession. For some of us, it's vintage fashion. Our cars, anything we can collect, they all live under one roof. Ebay. It's where closets get filled with statement pieces and vintage finds, where must have sneakers wait for you. And designer handbags are the real deal on ebay. Doors open to stacks of the rarest trading cards. And a garage stocked with all the car parts you need for any DIY job. EBay's home to whatever thing you're into that keeps you up at night. Ebay. Things people love. Your teen requested a ride, but this time, not from you. It's through their Uber teen account. You drive your teenager around a lot. To their friend Jacob's house, their other friend Jake's house, to James, to Jaden's, to Jalen's, to.

[Holly Frey]

Uh. Mom, this is Jake's house, not Jacob's.

[Sponsor]

Now, with an Uber teen account, your teen can request a ride under your supervision. They'll ride with a highly rated driver, and with live trip tracking, you'll follow along the whole ride to their friends'houses that all sound the same. Add your teen to your Uber account today. See app for details.

[Holly Frey]

Bye, Mom.