Stuff You Missed in History Class

Episode: Hammersmith Ghost Murder

Hosts: Holly Frey & Tracy V. Wilson
Release Date: October 29, 2025

Episode Overview

In this Halloween-themed episode, Holly and Tracy dive into the infamous “Hammersmith Ghost Murder” of 1804—a chilling story blending ghostly hysteria, mistaken identity, a fatal shooting, and a legal case that resonated through British law for centuries. Against the backdrop of early 19th-century London, they unpack how fear, folklore, and flawed law led to tragedy and legal precedent.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Setting the Scene: Ghostly Panic in Hammersmith

[03:41] Tracy V. Wilson

• Reports began in late 1803 of a "tall figure draped in white" haunting Hammersmith (now a London borough), especially near the churchyard and Black Lion Lane.
• The apparition was rumored to be the spirit of a local man who died by suicide, and its legend grew—details included horns, glass eyes, and even beastly attire.

[05:03] Tracy V. Wilson

• The hysteria escalated: locals (documented in Kirby’s Wonderful and Scientific Museum) suspected multiple ghosts.
• Panic led to real consequences: a carriage driver fled in terror, abandoning passengers; rumors spread that people were dying of fright.

Armed Citizen Patrols & Tensions

[06:23] Tracy V. Wilson

• Locals organized armed nightly patrols, decades before an official police force existed.
• Some believed a human prankster was behind the ghost; several “ghost chases” ensued, with the figure always escaping.

The Shooting: Mistaken Identity Turns Fatal

[07:30] Holly Frey

• On January 3, 1804, 29-year-old excise officer Francis Smith, armed and on patrol, encountered a white-clad figure on Black Lion Lane.
• Assuming it was the ghost (or a prankster), he called out but got no answer. In panic, he fired, killing the man—22-year-old Thomas Millwood, a bricklayer wearing white work clothes.
• Millwood had already been mistaken for the ghost on prior occasions.

[09:29] Holly Frey

• Smith was distraught and immediately sought help, stating he shot someone he believed to be the ghost.

[10:18] Tracy V. Wilson

• The coroner found Millwood had died from a single shot to the head: “death was recorded as a, quote, rash act of willful murder.”

Public Reaction and Community Context

[13:45] Holly Frey

• Smith was known as “gentle and kind.” Many testified to poor visibility and eerie conditions on Black Lion Lane, explaining how easy it was to mistake a person for something ghostly.
• Public support for Smith was strong, recognizing the role fear and hysteria played in the tragedy.

The Legal Aftermath: Trial at the Old Bailey

The Courtroom Drama

[15:26] Tracy V. Wilson

• Smith was tried for willful murder on January 13, 1804. His defense—accidental shooting due to mistaken identity under duress of community terror.

[15:50] Holly Frey (Smith’s direct words to the court):

“I went out with a perfectly good intention. After calling to the deceased twice and receiving no answer, I became so agitated that I did not know what I was about. But I solemnly declare that I am innocent of any malicious intention against any person whatever.” (16:12)

• Witnesses testified to Smith’s character and the widespread fear of the supposed ghost.
• Millwood’s mother-in-law (Mrs. Fullbrook) testified she had urged Thomas to cover up his white clothes, fearing he’d be mistaken for the ghost.

The Jury’s Dilemma & Judicial Ruling

[20:55] Holly Frey & [22:12] Tracy V. Wilson

• The presiding judge, Lord Chief Baron McDonald, told jurors:

“It would be impossible to calculate the dangerous consequences which would ensue if men were permitted to take upon themselves the right of shooting others for certain crimes... The prisoner had no right to construe such misdemeanor into a capital offense or to conclude that a man dressed in white was a ghost.” (20:55)

• The jury attempted a manslaughter verdict, but the court would only accept murder or acquittal; Smith was found guilty of murder and sentenced to death.

Public Outcry & Royal Pardon

[23:56] Holly Frey

• Massive public support led King George III to intervene, commuting Smith’s sentence to one year’s hard labor for manslaughter. He served only part of this before being released for good behavior.

“The Ghost” Revealed (and Not!)

[25:25] Holly Frey

• After the shooting, ghost sightings ceased—until the day after Smith’s sentencing, when John Graham, a local shoemaker, confessed to impersonating the ghost as a prank. His initial motive: playfully retaliating against employees scaring his children with ghost stories.

[29:35] Tracy V. Wilson

• Many locals remained unconvinced, claiming to see the ghost again (sometimes breathing fire!), fueling theories about copycats or mass hysteria.

Legal Ramifications: Legacy of the Hammersmith Case

A Legal Precedent that Reverberated

[30:30] Holly Frey

• The Hammersmith case left English law unsettled regarding mistaken self-defense. Only in 1983, with Regina v. Gladstone Williams, was it clarified: if a person genuinely and honestly—if unreasonably—believes force is necessary for self-defense or crime prevention, they may have a valid defense.

[34:29] Tracy V. Wilson (Court summary):

“In a case of self defense or the prevention of crime... if the defendant believed or may have believed that he was being attacked or that a crime was being committed and that force was necessary... if the defendant may genuinely have been laboring under it, he is entitled to rely upon it.” (34:29)

• Tracy noted discomfort with the legal implications—highlighting how such defenses can be misused in contemporary law.

Haunted Legacy: The Black Lion Pub

[35:47] Tracy V. Wilson & [36:55] Holly Frey

• The Black Lion Pub, near the site of the shooting, remains entwined with the story. Local lore claims Thomas Millwood’s ghost now haunts the site—adding a layer of historical irony.
• A plaque outside recounts the infamous shooting and the ghost’s story, preserving the legend in Hammersmith folklore.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Holly: “As I mentioned on an earlier episode this month I haven’t been as Halloweeny... But anyway, this one is probably our most Halloweeny.” (02:33)
• Smith's defense: “I can only declare that I went out with a perfectly good intention... I am innocent of any malicious intention against any person whatever.” (15:50)
• Lord Chief Baron McDonald: “No man is allowed to kill another rashly. The judge also told the jury that they could not take into account whether Francis Smith was a good man or not.” (20:55)

Timeline of Key Segments

| Timestamp | Event | |------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| | 03:41 | Introduction of the Hammersmith ghost legend and local hysteria | | 06:23 | Formation of citizen patrols and failed attempts to catch the “ghost” | | 07:30 | Francis Smith shoots Thomas Millwood | | 09:29 | Immediate aftermath and discovery of mistaken identity | | 10:18 | Coroner’s report and determination of “willful murder” | | 13:45 | Public defense of Smith and context about Black Lion Lane | | 15:26 | Francis Smith’s trial at the Old Bailey and legal implications | | 23:29 | Smith convicted, death sentence handed down | | 23:56 | King George III’s pardon and commuted sentence | | 25:25 | John Graham confesses to being the “ghost”; lingering ghost stories and copycat theories | | 30:30 | Legal legacy: Gladstone Williams case and clarified self-defense doctrine | | 35:47 | The haunting legacy of Thomas Millwood and the Black Lion Pub |

Episode Tone & Style

The hosts balance historical depth with conversational warmth and frequent asides, keeping the story accessible but thoroughly researched. Holly’s wit and skepticism mesh with Tracy’s methodical approach, providing context and commentary on both the social history and legal complexities.

Conclusion

The Hammersmith Ghost Murder is a fascinating intersection of folklore, social anxiety, the limits of self-defense, and the capacity for human error under duress. The case haunted British law for nearly two centuries and left a literal and figurative ghost in Hammersmith’s history—reminding us how powerfully belief and fear can shape our world.

For more exceptional historical deep dives, subscribe to Stuff You Missed in History Class wherever you get your podcasts.