Sword and Scale: Episode 310 Summary
Release Date: August 7, 2025
Introduction
In Episode 310 of Sword and Scale, listeners delve into a harrowing true-crime story that intertwines teenage rebellion, manipulation, and brutal violence. This episode meticulously unpacks the tragic events leading to the murder of James Stewart, a disabled man, orchestrated by a 15-year-old girl, Morgan Leppert, and her 22-year-old boyfriend, Toby Lawry.
Background: Putnam County, Florida
The story unfolds in Putnam County, Florida, a region characterized by its rural tranquility and tight-knit communities. Attorney Bradley Waldrop, a lifelong resident and former prosecutor, provides insight into the area's dynamics:
Bradley Waldrop [04:03]: "Jerry Melrose is a beautiful community... very tight-knit."
Morgan Leppert resides in the modest town of Melrose with her mother, Jerry, and her older brother. Jerry, aware of the challenges of raising a rebellious teenager, employs an open-door policy to monitor Morgan’s social interactions.
Morgan and Toby's Relationship
Morgan's quest for independence leads her to Toby Lawry, a charismatic but troubled young man with a criminal record. Their relationship quickly escalates, culminating in Toby moving into Morgan's home:
Morgan Leppert [06:56]: "He moved in with us. Yeah, he lived in three months."
Toby's presence becomes a point of contention. At just 15, Morgan is significantly younger than Toby, whose age and past go unnoticed initially. The relationship intensifies, leading Morgan to leave home despite her mother's reservations:
Mike Boudet [09:54]: "Don't you think that's kind of a big age gap?"
The Disappearance: April 22, 2008
On April 22, 2008, following her mother's discovery of Toby's true age and criminal history, Morgan defies Jerry and absconds with Toby. Their departure marks the beginning of a dark journey, taking them away from the safety of their hometown:
Narrator [13:36]: "They simply disappeared in a silver truck. No one knew where they were going or what they'd already done."
Morgan and Toby embark on a road trip, stealing a silver Toyota Tacoma—a vehicle central to their ensuing crimes.
Murder of James Stewart
Their violent spree culminates in the murder of James Stewart, a 66-year-old disabled man living alone in Melrose. Stewart, known for his resilience despite his disabilities, becomes an unintended victim of Toby and Morgan's escalating desperation:
Toby Lawry [46:17]: "And I'm like, God damn it, dude. You fucking made me, dude."
Toby recounts the brutal assault, detailing how he and Morgan forcibly took Stewart's truck. Their interrogation reveals the sheer brutality of the act:
Toby Lawry [07:33]: "Let me ask you a personal question. Are y'all having sex?"
Interrogations and Confessions
During interrogations, both Morgan and Toby provide conflicting narratives. Morgan insists she acted out of love and was manipulated:
Morgan Leppert [25:13]: "I've never seen him. That guy before."
Conversely, Toby offers a graphic and remorseful account of the murder, highlighting his own volatility:
Toby Lawry [37:02]: "I can't do it. No, I ain't got the heart to do that."
Despite Toby's detailed confession, the interplay between their testimonies complicates the legal proceedings.
Trial and Sentencing
In 2010, both individuals face trial for the murder. The prosecution paints a picture of premeditation and cold-blooded violence orchestrated by Toby, with Morgan portrayed as a naive teenager under his influence:
Bradley Waldrop [50:51]: "This is the worst case that I've encountered as far as brutality."
Toby pleads guilty to first-degree murder and is sentenced to life without parole. Morgan, initially receiving a mandatory life sentence, sees her sentence reduced to 40 years in 2020 following a Supreme Court ruling that deemed mandatory life sentences for juveniles unconstitutional.
Aftermath and Victim’s Legacy
James Stewart's family mourns the loss of a man whose life was characterized by resilience and achievement despite his physical limitations. His nephew offers a heartfelt tribute:
James’s Nephew [50:51]: "He taught me that the word can't is for cowards, losers..."
Conclusion: The Dark Side of Obsessive Love
Episode 310 concludes by reflecting on the twisted concepts of love and manipulation that drove Morgan and Toby to commit such heinous acts. The episode underscores the tragic consequences of unchecked obsession and the vulnerability of youth manipulated by predatory figures.
Narrator [65:34]: "Morgan had an obsessive, all-consuming type of quote unquote love for Toby... but love doesn't ask for everything you have."
This episode serves as a chilling reminder of the depths to which individuals can descend when driven by distorted emotions and the catastrophic impact of abusive relationships.
For premium content and additional episodes, visit swordandscale.com.