Episode #665: Developing Strategies That Cut Through the Omnichannel Noise with Arianna Vogel from Foursquare

Release Date: April 18, 2025
Host: Greg Kihlström
Guest: Arianna Vogel, Senior Director of Product Marketing at Foursquare

1. Introduction to the Episode

In Episode #665 of The Agile Brand with Greg Kihlström®, host Greg Kihlström engages in a deep discussion with Arianna Vogel from Foursquare. The primary focus centers on navigating the complexities of attribution in an omnichannel marketing landscape, emphasizing strategies that help brands measure and optimize their campaigns effectively.

2. Challenges in Attribution & Measurement in Omnichannel Marketing

Arianna Vogel begins by outlining the fundamental challenges marketers face in accurately measuring campaign success amid the intricate omnichannel customer journey.

• Understanding True Marketing ROI:
  “Do you really understand how your channels are working together? Do you truly understand how your results ladder up to the core business objectives for your brand?”
  (04:31)

  Insight: Marketers often grapple with deciphering the actual return on investment from their marketing efforts, struggling to link campaign outcomes directly to overarching business goals.

• Mid-Campaign Optimization:
  “Where should I reinvest? Where should I de-invest... without having to wait until the next campaign.”
  (05:33)

  Insight: There's a critical need for real-time optimization of campaigns to enhance efficiency and cost-effectiveness, rather than relying solely on post-campaign evaluations.

3. Strategies to Cut Through the Noise: Personalization and Segmentation

Addressing the competitive retail environment, Arianna emphasizes the importance of refined segmentation in delivering personalized marketing messages.

• Balancing Granularity and Scale:
  “You want to make sure that you're targeting with the most specificity that you can... but you also need to simultaneously keep enough scale in mind.”
  (07:12)

  Insight: Effective segmentation requires a delicate balance between targeting specific customer profiles and maintaining a broad enough reach to maximize campaign potential.

• Leveraging Real-World Behavior Over Digital Footprint:
  “Your digital footprint might be one that's more aspirational, but the other, your real world purchasing power tells you so much more about true intent.”
  (07:12)

  Insight: Focusing on actual in-store behaviors provides a more accurate gauge of customer intent compared to solely relying on digital interactions.

4. The Role of Technology in Simplifying Attribution

Greg probes into how technology can streamline the complex process of attribution across multiple channels.

• Unified Metrics Across Channels:
  “We offer a common methodology and set of KPIs to be able to measure across them so that you're able to get that more apples to apples type of reporting experience.”
  (09:08)

  Insight: Foursquare’s attribution tools consolidate various channel metrics into a unified framework, enabling consistent and comparable performance analysis.

5. Foursquare's Impact on Marketing Measurement: Location Intelligence

Arianna delves into how Foursquare leverages location intelligence to enhance marketing strategies and bridge data gaps.

• Enhancing First-Party Data:
  “Location intelligence is really an ideal tool... to help solve those sorts of business challenges and will only become even more important in the years to come.”
  (12:08)

  Insight: Integrating location data augments first-party information, providing deeper insights into customer behaviors and preferences.

• Aligning Marketing with Business Objectives:
  “Having those metrics... allows marketers to kind of share that common language and be reporting out on the same things that will be important to the brand overall.”
  (12:08)

  Insight: In-store measurement metrics facilitate a direct connection between marketing efforts and tangible business outcomes, fostering alignment and budget justification.

6. Real-World Examples: Jack in the Box and Ashley Furniture

To illustrate the practical application of Foursquare’s tools, Arianna shares success stories from notable brands.

• Jack in the Box Campaign Success:
  “It increased foot traffic to their stores, over a million store visits as a result of that exposure.”
  (16:50)

  Insight: Targeted out-of-home advertising, measured through location intelligence, significantly boosted in-store visits and influenced consumer behavior.

• Ashley Furniture’s Transition to Connected TV:
  “They were able to prove out that they could increase store visits, but they also were able to decrease their cost per store visit with this more effective connected TV channel.”
  (16:50)

  Insight: By leveraging Foursquare's attribution, Ashley Furniture successfully transitioned from traditional to digital advertising, optimizing costs while enhancing store traffic.

7. Advice for Marketers Exploring Attribution Tools

Arianna offers strategic advice for marketers aiming to harness attribution tools effectively.

• Adopt a Holistic Marketing Strategy:
  “Especially when you're trying out a new channel... offers a constant in an experiment where there are multiple variables.”
  (20:50)

  Insight: A comprehensive approach that integrates location intelligence ensures consistency and reliability when experimenting with new marketing channels.

• Prioritize Measurability Across All Tactics:
  “Hold your out of home tactics to the same standards of measurability as you would your digital tactics.”
  (20:50)

  Insight: Equipping all marketing channels with robust measurement capabilities ensures uniform evaluation standards and maximizes the effectiveness of campaigns.

8. Future Trends in Attribution and Measurement

Looking ahead, Arianna highlights emerging trends that will shape the future of marketing attribution.

• Artificial Intelligence Integration:
  “AI is a massively emerging, rapidly emerging trend. Whether that's being used for segmentation, being used for customer journey analysis and measurement...”
  (23:02)

  Insight: The incorporation of AI will revolutionize segmentation, customer journey analysis, and campaign optimization, making marketing strategies more precise and responsive.

• Flexible and Adaptable Strategies:
  “What marketers really need is a flexible strategy that can be continuously reevaluated so that teams can adapt really nimbly.”
  (23:02)

  Insight: Agility in strategy formulation and execution will be paramount as consumer behaviors and market dynamics evolve unpredictably.

9. Staying Agile in Marketing Roles

Arianna concludes by sharing personal strategies for maintaining agility in her role amidst the ever-evolving marketing landscape.

• Continuous Learning and Industry Intelligence:
  “Continuously staying on top of what's happening in our space, continuously investing in learning...”
  (25:19)

  Insight: Proactive engagement with industry developments and ongoing education are key to adapting and thriving in dynamic environments.

• Structured Processes for Intelligence Gathering:
  “Setting up processes to turn the exercise of industry intelligence into a regular practice.”
  (25:19)

  Insight: Establishing systematic approaches to gather and analyze industry intelligence ensures sustained agility and informed decision-making.

Conclusion

In this episode, Greg Kihlström and Arianna Vogel from Foursquare delve into the intricacies of marketing attribution in an omnichannel world. They explore the challenges of measuring true ROI, the significance of location intelligence, and the pivotal role of technology and AI in simplifying and enhancing attribution processes. Through real-world examples and strategic insights, listeners gain a comprehensive understanding of how to develop agile, data-driven marketing strategies that resonate in today’s competitive landscape.

Stay Connected:

• Learn More About Arianna Vogel and Foursquare: Follow the links in the show notes.
• Subscribe and Rate the Podcast: Ensure you never miss an episode by subscribing on your preferred podcast platform and leaving a rating.
• Visit The Agile Brand: Explore additional resources and episodes at theagilebrand.com.