Podcast Summary: The Ancients – Episode “Livia: Empress of Rome”
Release Date: August 3, 2025
Host: Tristan Hughes
Guest: Dr. Emma Southern
Introduction
In the August 3, 2025 episode of The Ancients, host Tristan Hughes delves into the life of one of Rome's most influential yet controversial figures: Livia Drusilla, the first Empress of Rome. Joined by historian Dr. Emma Southern, the episode seeks to separate historical fact from enduring myths surrounding Livia's reputation.
Livia's Reputation: Fact vs. Fiction
The episode opens with Livia's notorious portrayal throughout history. Often depicted as a manipulative and villainous figure responsible for numerous family murders to secure her son Tiberius's ascension, Livia's true character remains a subject of debate.
Dr. Emma Southern (03:45):
"I don't think she's a victim. I will say that I don't know that she's that much of a villain... she is seemingly in control of everything that is happening and she has genuinely astonishing power in the Roman Empire."
Sources and Historical Accounts
Central to understanding Livia's legacy are the primary sources from historians like Tacitus, Suetonius, Plutarch, and Cassius Dio. These accounts range from neutral to overtly hostile, often influenced by the authors' own agendas and the socio-political climate of their times.
Dr. Emma Southern (07:02):
"Tacitus... insinuates that she was involved with things. Dio... embellishes a lot... she is the wickedest stepmother of all wicked stepmothers."
Conversely, poets like Ovid offered flattering depictions, though with a limited perspective influenced by political exile and personal motives.
Livia's Early Life and Marriage to Augustus
Livia's early years were marked by political turmoil and strategic maneuvers. Born into the prestigious Claudian family, she married Tiberius Nero at 15, bearing her first son, Tiberius, at 16. Her subsequent marriage to Octavian (later Augustus) at age 20 was both a political alliance and a pivotal moment that elevated her status.
Dr. Emma Southern (14:25):
"She undertakes an extraordinary amount in her first 20 years... she marries Octavian when she's 20... an extraordinary life of becoming and being an empress."
Livia’s Political Influence During Augustus's Reign
As Augustus transitioned Rome from a republic to an empire, Livia played a crucial role behind the scenes. She was instrumental in political appointments, sponsorships, and the creation of the Julio-Claudian dynasty. Her influence extended to public life through statuary, coins, and architecture, portraying her as the ideal Roman matron.
Dr. Emma Southern (12:43):
"All of this huge amount of archaeology of how she is portrayed by Augustus... represents the ideal of perfect, chaste, modest, pious wife."
The Tragic Deaths of Augustus’s Heirs
The Julio-Claudian lineage was marred by the untimely and often suspicious deaths of several potential heirs to Augustus. These deaths fueled rumors of Livia’s involvement, despite a lack of concrete evidence. The recurring pattern of young heirs dying under mysterious circumstances became a cornerstone of her infamous reputation.
Dr. Emma Southern (40:11):
"It's a cascade of bad luck that people perceive her to be benefiting from it... it's very hard to think she did it, but she was able to benefit from it."
The Portrayal in "I, Claudius"
The television series and subsequent literature, notably I, Claudius, cemented Livia's image as a malevolent schemer intent on consolidating power for her son, Tiberius. These dramatized accounts amplified historical suspicions, embedding the villainous portrayal in popular culture.
Podcast Host (11:07):
"It's the I, Claudius portrayal, isn't it? That has endured for decades."
Archaeological Evidence of Livia's Life
Beyond literary sources, archaeological findings offer a tangible glimpse into Livia's life. Her residences, including her house on the Palatine Hill and various properties across Italy, reveal her immense wealth and the lifestyle she led. Inscriptions and artifacts, such as bricks stamped with her name, provide evidence of her influence and status.
Dr. Emma Southern (12:44):
"We have things like her palaces that she lived in... reconstruct what it was like inside her house from knowing that there was somebody in her house whose job was exclusively to look after her white dresses."
Livia and Julia: A Complex Relationship
The relationship between Livia and her stepdaughter Julia, Augustus's only daughter, was fraught with tension. Julia's rebellious behavior and eventual exile for adultery strained familial ties, highlighting the complex dynamics within the imperial household.
Dr. Emma Southern (44:06):
"She absolutely despises each other... her revenge or her rebellion against her father is that she just starts having sex with absolutely everybody."
Livia in Tiberius’s Reign
Tiberius's ascension marked a shift in Livia's influence. Initially powerful, her role diminished as Tiberius sought to assert his authority and distance himself from his mother's pervasive influence. Despite attempts to curb her political sway, Livia remained a significant, albeit constrained, figure until her later years.
Dr. Emma Southern (54:38):
"She is very invested in her political project, which is allied with her husband's political project."
Final Years and Legacy
In her final years, Livia witnessed the consolidation of power under Tiberius, coupled with increasing isolation as political maneuvers like Sejanus's rise overshadowed her influence. Her death marked the end of an era, with her legacy contested between recognition as a shrewd politician and condemnation as a power-hungry empress.
Dr. Emma Southern (60:33):
"She dies in her palace pretty much at the top of her game... She is the only one who does it well. I think that she would be an unbelievable Margaret Thatcher if she had been allowed to."
Conclusion: Rethinking Livia’s Legacy
Dr. Emma Southern advocates for a nuanced understanding of Livia, recognizing her as a formidable political operator who navigated the complexities of imperial Rome with remarkable skill. While historical sources have often cast her in a negative light, a closer examination reveals a woman deeply entwined with the political fabric of her time, deserving of a more balanced appraisal.
Dr. Emma Southern (62:46):
"I think that you should remember Livia as an incredibly political woman... she works it so much better than everyone else."
Final Thoughts
The Ancients episode on Livia Drusilla offers a comprehensive exploration of her life, influence, and the enduring myths that surround her. Through insightful dialogue with Dr. Emma Southern, listeners are encouraged to reevaluate Livia's role in Roman history, moving beyond centuries-old stereotypes to appreciate her as a key architect of the early Roman Empire.
For more insights into ancient history, subscribe to The Ancients on Spotify or your preferred podcast platform. Explore additional content and supporting materials at History Hit.