Podcast Summary: The Ancients – Episode: Origins of the Wheel

Introduction

In the December 5, 2024 episode of The Ancients, hosted by Tristan Hughes from History Hit, the pivotal invention of the wheel is explored in depth. This episode delves into longstanding debates surrounding the wheel's origins, presenting groundbreaking research that suggests its inception in Eastern Europe by the prehistoric Borelaz culture. Featuring insightful interviews with esteemed archaeologist Dr. Richard Bullet and computational engineer Dr. Kai James, the episode marries traditional archaeological methods with modern computational science to shed new light on this fundamental technological advancement.

The Great Debate: Where Did the Wheel Originate?

The wheel's invention is often hailed as a cornerstone of human progress, yet its exact origins remain a subject of considerable debate among historians and archaeologists. Tristan Hughes sets the stage by posing critical questions: "When was the wheel first created, by who? And for what purpose?" ([03:07]).

Interview with Dr. Richard Bullet: Unearthing the Borelaz Culture

Dr. Richard Bullet, Professor Emeritus at Columbia University, introduces a compelling argument that challenges traditional views. He posits that the wheel was first invented in the Carpathian Mountains of Eastern Europe by the Borelaz culture approximately 6,000 years ago. According to Dr. Bullet, these prehistoric miners developed the wheel to efficiently transport large quantities of copper ore out of their subterranean tunnels.

“The invention of the Wheel... remains fundamental to many of our daily lives down to the present day.” – Tristan Hughes ([03:07])

Dr. Bullet elaborates on why the Carpathian region is a plausible birthplace for the wheel:

“The wheels are attached to the axle in a way that they can't turn... this kind of wheel design was preserved in European mining and evolved into modern railroad technology.” – Dr. Richard Bullet ([24:03])

Challenging Traditional Theories

Traditionally, Mesopotamia has been regarded as the earliest site of wheel invention, with evidence dating back to 3000 BC. However, Dr. Bullet highlights the absence of wheels in contemporaneous civilizations like Egypt, despite their proximity and advancements.

“In Mesopotamia, we have no example of there ever being a wheel that couldn't turn.” – Dr. Richard Bullet ([22:40])

He contrasts this with the Carpathian evidence, emphasizing that the wheel's design in this region was suited to the mining environment, where straight, narrow tunnels provided an ideal setting for wheeled transport.

The Role of the Borelaz Culture

The Borelaz culture thrived during the Copper Age, preceding the Bronze Age. As surface copper deposits in Southeast Europe became depleted, these miners ventured deeper, necessitating more efficient methods to transport ore. Dr. Bullet suggests that the development of wheeled baskets was a direct response to this need.

“You found a mining culture that discovered that they could move ore more efficiently using a wheel, and then they celebrated their own achievement.” – Dr. Richard Bullet ([21:30])

Archaeological findings, such as drinking cups with wheel axles, serve as cultural artifacts celebrating this technological milestone. These cups, unique to the Carpathian region, signify the wheel's integration into daily life and its importance to the community.

From Rollers to Wheels: The Evolutionary Path

The transition from rollers to wheels has long been theorized but remained contentious due to practical inefficiencies associated with rollers. Dr. Bullet introduces a nuanced perspective, suggesting that rollers were a necessary precursor adapted specifically for mining environments.

“This is step one. Now, the problem with this step is that it reintroduces friction...” – Dr. Kai James ([50:17])

Interview with Dr. Kai James: Computational Engineering Meets Archaeology

Dr. Kai James, a computational engineer, collaborated with Dr. Bullet and software engineer Dr. Lee Alacok to employ modern computational methods in testing the wheel's origin theory. He explains the process:

“We created an algorithm that would simulate under these loads, how would the wheel and axle respond, how would it bend, how and when would it break...” – Dr. Kai James ([37:08])

Methodology and Findings

Dr. James outlines the three-pronged computational approach:

1. Simulation of Structural Integrity: Modeling how wheel and axle designs withstand heavy loads.
2. Effort Calculation: Determining the force required to push cargo using different wheel designs.
3. Optimization Algorithm: Iteratively refining wheel designs to enhance efficiency and durability.

Through this method, the team demonstrated that the optimal design for the mining context was a slender axle capped with round wheels, aligning with archaeological findings from the Carpathian region.

“The optimal design, given the particular objectives of the users of the wheel, was essentially... a slender axle capped on either end by two round discs, which we now refer to as wheels.” – Dr. Kai James ([40:12])

Innovative Steps: Roller to Wheel

The research outlines a clear evolutionary pathway from rollers to wheels:

1. Initial Use of Rollers: Cylindrical objects used to push cargo within the controlled environment of a mine.
2. Introduction of Socketed Rollers: Incorporating sockets in carts to retain rollers, reducing the need to constantly replenish spent rollers.
3. Grooving for Lubrication: Implementing grooves in rollers to apply lubricants, significantly reducing friction.
4. Hollowing the Axle: Gradually narrowing the axle increased efficiency, leading to the formation of a true wheel and axle system.

“We derived an equation that shows that as the axle gets more and more slender, the amount of pushing force decreases proportionally.” – Dr. Kai James ([51:58])

Implications and Future Research

The convergence of archaeological evidence and computational modeling offers robust support for the theory that the wheel originated among the Borelaz miners. This interdisciplinary approach not only resolves longstanding debates but also opens new avenues for understanding other ancient technologies.

Dr. James shares his future research ambitions:

“I would like to see if we can use these tools to understand other seminal technologies, like... the bow and arrow.” – Dr. Kai James ([57:10])

Additionally, he expresses interest in exploring the early evolution of the airplane, hypothesizing that its invention may have deeper historical roots than previously recognized.

Conclusion

This episode of The Ancients provides a comprehensive exploration of the wheel's origins, blending traditional archaeological insights with cutting-edge computational engineering. By pinpointing the Carpathian Mountains as the cradle of wheeled technology and elucidating the evolutionary steps from rollers to wheels, Dr. Richard Bullet and Dr. Kai James offer a transformative perspective on a technology that continues to shape human civilization.

“This has been fascinating to interview you and Richard before you about this extraordinary new paper... Thank you so much for taking the time to come to the podcast today.” – Tristan Hughes ([59:31])

Key Takeaways

• The wheel likely originated in the Carpathian Mountains among the Borelaz culture approximately 6,000 years ago.
• Its invention was driven by practical needs in copper mining, facilitating the transport of heavy ore.
• Computational engineering techniques validated the evolutionary steps from rollers to wheels, emphasizing environmental and functional factors.
• The interdisciplinary approach sets a precedent for future research into ancient technologies.

Notable Quotes

• Tristan Hughes: “When was the wheel first created, by who? And for what purpose?” ([03:07])
• Dr. Richard Bullet: “The wheels are attached to the axle in a way that they can't turn...” ([24:03])
• Dr. Kai James: “We created an algorithm that would simulate under these loads, how would the wheel and axle respond...” ([37:08])
• Dr. Kai James: “We derived an equation that shows that as the axle gets more and more slender, the amount of pushing force decreases proportionally.” ([51:58])

Further Exploration

Listeners interested in the intersection of ancient history and modern technology will find this episode particularly enlightening. The collaborative efforts between historians and engineers exemplify the innovative methodologies shaping contemporary archaeological research.

Subscribe and Engage

For more in-depth explorations of ancient civilizations and their technological marvels, subscribe to The Ancients on Spotify or your preferred podcast platform. Join History Hit's community to access hundreds of hours of original documentaries and ad-free podcasts by visiting historyhit.com/subscribe.