Vault: Her Twin Sister Wants Her Help Cheating?! - Part One

Summary

---

Podcast Summary: The Bert Show

Episode: Vault: Her Twin Sister Wants Her Help Cheating?! - Part One

Date: November 25, 2025
Host(s): Bert, Amanda, and multiple co-hosts
Featured Guests: Amanda's Twin Sister (voice disguised), Listeners

---

Episode Overview

This episode dives into a dramatic, real-life dilemma: a pair of twin sisters are considering swapping identities so one can clandestinely date a coworker while the other is with her long-term boyfriend. The show panel discusses the morality, logistics, and hilarity of the plan, all while fielding calls and opinions from listeners. The tone is lighthearted, irreverent, and rooted in the show’s hallmark banter.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Scenario Unveiled

[01:44 – 02:53]

• Amanda introduces her twin sister, who is on a voice disguiser to protect her privacy.

• The twin without a boyfriend explains the situation:

  • Her sister has been dating her boyfriend for about a year.
  • She’ll be away with his family in Charlotte for Thanksgiving.
  • Meanwhile, a male coworker—unaware of her relationship—has asked her out for the Friday after Thanksgiving.
  • The twin proposes going on the date in her sister’s place, for “fun.”

  Quote:
  “Well, I mean, it’s my idea, but my sister has been... going out with this guy for about a year... but she really likes this guy at work... he finally asked her out, but he asked her over the Thanksgiving holiday.” — Amanda's Twin Sister [02:05]

2. Motivation & Logistics

[03:13 – 06:15]

• The sisters have not pulled a switch like this before; she thinks it would be hilarious.

• The real challenge: navigating potential work conversations on the date.

• Hosts brainstorm excuses: avoid talking about work, set up ground rules.

  Quote:
  “When she told me that story, I said that I should do it because I just think it would be funny.” — Amanda's Twin Sister [04:06]
  “On a first date, a guy is so eager that you could set any limitation you want... She could say, ‘No references to work whatsoever.’” — Amanda [06:40]

3. Sister's Hesitancy & Ethical Gray Areas

[06:12 – 07:42]

• The twin with the boyfriend is only "20% into" the scheme.

• Her reservations: fear that her sister will “screw it up” and the risk of deception.

• Hosts debate if the sister can be convinced, suggesting prepping her on work trivia.

  Quote:
  “She’s afraid... that if she... lets me do it, I’m gonna screw it up somehow.” — Amanda's Twin Sister [07:33]

4. Could It Actually Lead to Cheating?

[08:00 – 10:06]

• The panel poses philosophical questions:

  • Is it “cheating” if the girlfriend’s body-double (her twin) goes on the date?
  • What actions would constitute actual cheating?

• Varied opinions: Amanda and some co-hosts say it is cheating due to intent and deception; others disagree.

  Quote:
  “If a twin goes on a date with a guy in place of a woman who is involved... is the woman who’s involved technically cheating?” — Host 2 [09:28]
  “Yes, because she knows the portrayal of her... but she’s not doing anything about it. Technically, you are your sister.” — Amanda [09:46]

5. Hypothetical Outcomes & Comic Escalation

[10:07 – 14:26]

• The hosts joke about outrageous scenarios:

  • The twin should intentionally “mess with” the coworker (e.g., claim her second-date tradition is wild, invent quirky facts).
  • Imagine the sister gets drunk or the office gossips spiral out of control.
  • Even tongue-in-cheek suggestions like getting pregnant to see what would happen.

  Quotes:
  “What if she did?... What if she slept with him on the first date?” — Host 1 [11:11]
  “You should do all sorts of crazy things. Let him go up your shirt... like, before the appetizer even gets to the table.” — Host 2 [11:05]
  “If she embarrasses her sister, I think...” — Amanda [14:01]

6. Listener Input & Moral Confirmation

[11:54 – 13:53]

• Listeners call in: Many think it’s absolutely cheating because it’s deceitful and feelings are involved.

• The hosts acknowledge the risks and emotional stakes, but still get a laugh from the absurdity.

  Quote:
  “It’s cheating, right? From the beginning. It’s deceitful. You’re purposely and willfully deceit[ful]. Absolutely. That’s totally cheating.” — Caller Rob [11:54]
  “She knows about it, and she’s a playing partner in it.” — Amanda's Twin Sister [12:15]

---

Most Notable Quotes & Moments

• Amanda’s Twin Sister, on why she wants to do it:
  "I always thought it would be just hilarious to do." [04:16]

• The philosophical question:
  "If a twin goes on a date with a guy in place of a woman who is involved... is the woman who involved technically cheating?" — Host 2 [09:28]

• Amanda’s playful doubt:
  "This is such a ridiculous scenario. I love it." [13:20]

• Jesting about possible fallout:
  "What if she got wasted drunk, and then all of a sudden, around the office, the sister is known as the wasted drunk?" — Host 1 [13:55]
  "Or she should come in as the sister to work, like in 10 months, and just start nursing a child in front of the guy..." — Host 2 [14:16]

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Scenario Introduction by Amanda & Twin Sister: [01:44 – 02:58]
• Discussion on work logistics & motivations: [03:13 – 06:15]
• Is it cheating? Panel Debate: [09:28 – 10:43]
• Escalating jokes & hypotheticals: [10:47 – 14:26]
• Listener calls & moral arguments: [11:54 – 13:53]

---

Tone & Style

As always, the Bert Show keeps a playful, comedic edge—even with the drama at hand. The panel is candid, sarcastic, and sometimes outrageous, balancing sincere listener input against their own banter. The participants remain down-to-earth and relatable, mocking the situation while recognizing its emotional complexity.

---

Conclusion

The episode teases a unique blend of real-life twin drama and relationship ethics, posing big questions with humor and wit. The ongoing debate—how "cheating" is defined, and whether the prank is innocent or potentially devastating—is left unresolved, setting the stage for further episodes. Listeners are clearly invested, and the hosts encourage more feedback and calls for advice.

---

Useful for: Anyone interested in relationship dilemmas, sibling mischief, and hilarious moral debates—classic Bert Show territory.

Transcript

[Burt]

Oh, hey, welcome to gift wrapping.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Whoa.

[Burt]

So is Saldana.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Hey, can you wrap these please?

[Amanda]

Wow.

[Burt]

IPhone 17s.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

You splurged at T Mobile. You can get four iPhone 17s on them. The new center stage front camera is amazing for group selfies. It's the perfect gift for everyone.

[Burt]

I'm the worst. I only got my mom a robe.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Well, it's better than socks.

[Burt]

So I have to trade in my old phone, right?

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

No, AT T Mobile. There's no trade ins needed when you switch. Keep your old phone or give it as a gift.

[Burt]

Incredible.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

In fact, wrap up my old phone too for my aunt Rosa. Forget that. Aunt Liz will be jealous.

[Burt]

Sounds like my family drama.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Oh, I got it. I'll give it to my abuela. I'll take reindeer paper with. Hey, where are you going?

[Burt]

To T Mobile. The holidays are better. AT T Mobile get four iPhone 17s on us. No trade in needed when you switch plus four lines for just 25 bucks a line. And now T Mobile is available in US cellular stores with 24 monthly bill credits and four eligible board inside essentials for well qualified customers. Auto pay + taxes, fees and $35 device connection charge credits ended balance due if you pay off earlier. Cancel Contact Us Finance Agreement Twitter fee 56 gigabytes. $830 required.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Visit T mobile.com youm know you've reached peak couple energy when your undies match. Meundies Match Me has you both covered, literally in super soft ultra modal undies, socks, PJs and loungewear. Festive prints. Check. Cozy vibes. Double check. And right now, it's deal season. Get up to 50% off site wide for Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Take your couple game to the next level with Meundies Match Me. To get deals up to 50% off, go to Meundies.com acast Enter promo code acast that's Meundies.com acast code acast.

[Burt]

The Birch Show.

[Amanda]

Good morning, Amanda. You are on the Birch show and you are on the voice disguiser.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Hi.

[Amanda]

Hi. How are you?

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Good, good. How are you doing?

[Amanda]

Okay. You are not the twin with the boyfriend. You are the twin sister.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Yeah.

[Amanda]

Okay. I don't even know where to start.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Well, I mean, it's my idea, but my sister has been. She's been going out with this guy for about a year. She's going off with her boyfriend for about a year and she's going home to his family for Thanksgiving and they live in Charlotte, so she won't be here for Thanksgiving. And just I guess recently she's this guy at work that she's been, she's been kind of, you know, she really likes and you know, she's not really sure what she's, what she's going to do, but she's, she's, you know, she's been talking to this guy and she really, you know, she, she likes them and, and he finally asked her out, but he asked her out over the Thanksgiving holiday.

[Host 1]

Okay, so to go on a date. Not to go.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

No, not to go on a date. Like to go on like the day after.

[Amanda]

All right, so one sister being involved with a guy for a year would be at Thanksgiving dinner with a family, while the other, this would obviously be you. You would be out with the new co worker.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Yeah.

[Host 2]

And the new co worker, one is like a first date. So there aren't a lot of, like, it's not like you have to do some big studying up thing, right?

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

No, no. And you know, and, and she has already agreed to go out with him because she just got like foster in front of him and when he asked her out, she said yes. And, and you know, he asked her for Friday and she's never going to be here.

[Amanda]

So now how long has she been working with this guy? Because if it's been any amount of time at all or they've had any.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

He works in the field and she works in the office. Okay, so they were, you know, they know each other. They've been working together, you know, for like, I guess I think it's been a while. But I don't think that they, you know, know each other, you know, that well. But he doesn't know that she has a boyfriend.

[Amanda]

So why are you so eager to help her out? I mean, she's, I mean, this obviously isn't the right thing to do. She's in a committed relationship.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

When she told me that story, I said that I should do it because I just think it would be funny.

[Host 1]

Entertainment.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Well, I mean, we never, we've never did something like this. Okay. And I always thought it would be just hilarious to do.

[Host 2]

And now this is your chance because you're obviously available here in Atlanta to take out guy number two. And she can. And then you could report back to her as a sister, you know, the objective outsider point of view. Man, this is a great guy. He held the door open for me. You. And he would insist that he wouldn't even let me buy him a thank you dessert for me. You after the meal.

[Host 1]

Right Now. Have you gone through in your mind what you're going to do when work conversations come up because you're going to either have to brush up on.

[Amanda]

Oh, that's easy. That's easy. That's an easy one to take care of.

[Host 1]

Just. I don't want to talk about.

[Amanda]

Look, when I'm outside of work, I just don't really like to talk about it. Can we talk about something else?

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

That's my sister's problem. That's what she's worried about is the work conversation.

[Host 2]

Yeah, I think you should Jack with her. I think you should. I think you should go out with him on Friday and then spend the entire time telling him that historically, on the second date, you become the biggest sex freak ever in the history, man. All kinds of stuff. And then make up random things like, say, you know, whatever food your sister hates. Be like, you know what my favorite. The most romantic thing a guy ever said did to me was he sent me three pounds of calamari at work. I love calamari. Like, if that. If she hates it, just Jack with her.

[Amanda]

So you've suggested I'll go out on the date, but your sister's not so hot on the idea.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Actually, she kind of. She was kind of going for it for a while. She's kind of sold on it a little bit. Like, you know, she doesn't know what to do about, you know, going on with him because she really wants to follow him, and she doesn't know how to back out of it without seeming like she's not interested. And so she's kind of. She's sort of on the fence about it. Like, I'd say she's about 20% into doing it. I just want to figure out how I can convince her to do it.

[Amanda]

How to push her over the edge a little bit. Because you really want to do this.

[Host 1]

I know. I think you do need to get the work 101 from her. Because even if you're not talking about, like, the actual projects they work on at work, there will be people references that will come up about, you know, Bob in accounting or, you know, Greg that works two cubicles over from her. And, you know, like, there will definitely be work references that will come up. And if he'll be like, oh, yeah, you know, like Greg's family and not a crazy story, you're going to be like, yeah.

[Amanda]

You see this, though? Here's the deal is that on a first date, a guy is so eager that you could set any limitation you want on a first date. So she could immediately go in the car and she can Go. Look, I just want to set this one parameter right off the bat. No references to work whatsoever, okay? Let's just try to make sure this thing has legs without us doing the easy thing and talking about work and a guy because we're so eager to please and be accepted on that first date. Buy it like that.

[Host 1]

You don't think he'll bring up anybody at all?

[Amanda]

Because she can go anytime during the day.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

That's the rule.

[Host 2]

That's true.

[Amanda]

I mean, this is cake.

[Host 1]

That might help your sister be into it.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Now, you said she's.

[Amanda]

You said she's only 20% into it. Is that what you said?

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Yeah, she's like. She was kind of, you know, she was kind of going for it, but then she's like, is it.

[Amanda]

Is there any other reservation besides the work conversation?

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

I also think that she's afraid, you know? I mean, she's just afraid that if she, you know, that she's just afraid that I'm gonna screw it up somehow.

[Amanda]

Well, there are some potential potholes for sure. Let me put you on hold for a second. And this might not have been a situation you were thinking about, but Hoss won't put our caller on hold, so I will just tell you that Wendy says that what if. Need the voice disguiser back on?

[Burt]

Yeah.

[Amanda]

What if you start. What if you fall for the guy?

[Host 1]

Oh, yeah.

[Amanda]

I mean, what if you guys have some amazing chemistry because you've already taken the office out of the scenario, and you guys have to talk about real things, and before you know it, you're falling for this guy. You can do nothing about it. Zero.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

I don't know. I mean, that's funny. I don't know. I doubt that would happen. I wouldn't do that to my sister, though.

[Amanda]

There's a possibility.

[Host 2]

But if you.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Yeah, I mean, I would never do that.

[Host 2]

Do you have. Are you seeing anyone?

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

No.

[Amanda]

Okay, so she's.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Tell me about this other guy.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Oh, yeah. He's been dating him for about a year. And I. You know, she's. I think, like, in the last, you know, couple of months, like, you know, she's. She really does. She loves. She loves him, and she's been with him for a long time, but she just. Maybe, you know, maybe this guy. I think the guy at work is sort of like, you know, kind of getting her to realize that the guy that she's with is. He is not that great.

[Amanda]

All right. Okay. So it's more than a flirtation.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Yeah.

[Amanda]

This thing is getting. It's getting to the point where they're gonna make a decision.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

I think so.

[Host 2]

Now here's a. Here's the. I wish we had that girl who was on her way to philosophy class on with us yesterday. Because here's a pretty deep question.

[Amanda]

Hey, I'm pretty good at philosophy. Let me help you out.

[Host 2]

Okay.

[Amanda]

Failed it. How many times? Three times. Logic. Three times.

[Burt]

Okay.

[Host 2]

Ladies and gentlemen, the Dao of Bert. All right, if a twin goes on a date with a guy in place of a woman who is involved.

[Amanda]

Is.

[Host 2]

The woman who involved technically cheating?

[Amanda]

Yes. Yes, because she is portrayed. She knows the portrayal of her, but she's not. Is happening, and she's not doing anything about it. So technically, you are your sister.

[Host 2]

So what is she doing? My question is, what acts that take place that evening would constitute cheating?

[Host 1]

Just going on the date. Why?

[Host 2]

Why is that cheating? Because the sister, the twin Tweedledee, is gonna be up in Charlotte with the boyfriend. Right?

[Host 1]

Right.

[Host 2]

So she's not. No matter what happens, if you get a kiss at the end of the date, the involved sister didn't kiss. I know a person playing the role of the involved sister that's like. Is an actress who has. Did. Who was the actress who had that love seat with Billy Bob Thorne? Was it Halle Berry?

[Amanda]

Yeah.

[Host 2]

Okay, so she had that hot. If either of them were involved, were they cheating? They were acting.

[Amanda]

No, because the assumption is, in acting, you know, it's somebody that is playing the part of somebody. Whereas here you think it's the actual person.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

He doesn't know.

[Amanda]

I want to know. Going on what Jeff just said.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Are you gonna kiss the guy at.

[Amanda]

The end of the night?

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

I mean, maybe. I mean, that's part. That's part of what I think is gonna be fun, is gonna be going on a date with someone. You don't even really care what happens. Like, I won't care whether or not goes well, or like I won't care if he likes me or. That's the fun part about it.

[Host 2]

You should do all sorts of crazy things. Let him go up your shirt and stuff. Like, before the appetizer even gets to the table.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Yeah.

[Host 1]

What if she did? What if she slept with him on the first date?

[Amanda]

Would you ever tell your sister if you slept with this dude? Would you ever tell him?

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Oh, my. I would never. I would never sleep with him.

[Host 1]

What if he's, like, the hottest guy you've ever seen ever, and you don't ever have to claim it. Cause it's not you?

[Host 2]

I think you should. Yeah. You should do all sorts of Crazy things like. And imagine the stories that'll go around the office.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Oh, my God.

[Amanda]

Take.

[Host 2]

She didn't even let me get into the restaurant. She just said, let's just do it in the car. I'm doing it in strange places.

[Amanda]

I think everything they just said is why your sister's only 20%.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

I was gonna help her.

[Amanda]

Amanda, hold on one second. I don't need the voice discussor. Hey, Rob. Go ahead.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Hey, it's. Yeah. It's cheating. Right? From the beginning.

[Host 2]

How?

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

It's deceitful. You're purposely and willfully deceit. Absolutely. That's totally cheating.

[Amanda]

Totally. Totally.

[Host 2]

But it's funny, right? But how is it cheating? Like, the woman who is involved in a relationship is not doing anything wrong.

[Amanda]

But it's assumed that person.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Yes, she is. She knows about it, and she's a playing partner in it.

[Host 2]

So what? She's not cheating. She's not emotion. Getting emotionally involved. She's not getting physically involved. She's not sharing intimate secrets. I don't think it's cheating.

[Amanda]

It totally is.

[Host 1]

It wouldn't be cheating if she told this guy at work, hey, I know you want to take me out, but I'm involved. Why don't you take out my sister? You know what I mean?

[Amanda]

Like, because he's assuming he's going out with her.

[Host 1]

Thing to do.

[Amanda]

Hey, Andrea, good morning. You're on Q100.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Good morning.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Good morning.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

I love your show.

[Amanda]

Thank you.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

So do we, all the time.

[Amanda]

Yeah. There are times where I really love it, too. And right now is one of them.

[Host 2]

Yeah. We love our show and we love our listeners.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

I have to say, this is so cheating. It is cheating. No, it's not. It is cheating. I'm gonna tell you why. Because she, the girlfriend, knows that her sister is going out with this guy.

[Host 2]

Yes.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

And her feelings are involved with that. With her boyfriend.

[Host 2]

Okay.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Got feelings with this. With this man. And she's getting her sister to portray her. He's betraying this guy.

[Amanda]

This is such a ridiculous scenario. I love it.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

It is. It's crazy. I've never heard anything like it. And as a sister, I don't have any sisters. But if I was the sister, there's no way I go for this.

[Amanda]

I know. We gotta figure out a way to talk her into it. Send that 20% up to 100%.

[Host 2]

The sister is obviously nervous because she thinks that, like, she's nervous, number one, because she likes the guy. But what if the sister falls for him? I think that's probably what she's Nervous about two. It's just a weird. But there is no harm that could come from this.

[Amanda]

That's not true. Plenty could come.

[Host 1]

What if she got wasted drunk, and then all of a sudden, around the office, the sister is known as the wasted drunk?

[Amanda]

Yeah. If she embarrasses her sister, I think.

[Host 2]

She should try to get pregnant. I think she should try to get pregnant and then just have the sister show up like 10 months later with an infant at work. What do you mean? You didn't know?

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Oh, my God.

[Host 2]

Or she should come in and as the sister to work, like in 10 months and just start nursing the child in front of the guy and go, well, I'm gonna.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

God, please.

[Host 2]

Yes, sir.

[Amanda]

Or my hope is that he has a twin brother and his twin is going out with Amanda's twin.

[Host 2]

Aha.

[Amanda]

There's a cruel twist of fate. All right, so Amanda, right now we don't have anybody calling up that's really giving you solid advice on how to get your sister to do this. But we. I gotta be honest with you. I sure hope it happens.

[Burt]

The Burt Show. Oh, hey. Welcome to gift wrapping.

[Amanda's Twin Sister]

Whoa.

[Burt]

So is Saldana.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Hey, can you wrap these, please?

[Burt]

Wow. IPhone 17s. You splurged.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

At T Mobile, you can get four iPhone 17s on them. The new center stage front camera is amazing for group selfies. It's the perfect gift for everyone.

[Burt]

I'm the worst. I only got my mom a robe.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Well, it's better than socks.

[Burt]

So I have to trade in my old phone, right?

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

No, AT T Mobile. There's no trade ins needed when you switch. Keep your old phone or give it as a gift.

[Burt]

Incredible.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

In fact, wrap up my old phone too, for my aunt Rosa. Forget that. Aunt Liz will be jealous.

[Burt]

Sounds like my family drama.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Oh, I got it. I'll give it to my abuela. I'll take reindeer paper with. Hey, where are you going?

[Burt]

To T Mobile. The holidays are better. AT T Mobile get four iPhone 17s on us. No trade in needed when you switch. Plus four lines for just 25 bucks a line. And now T Mobile is available in US cellular stores. 24 monthly bill credits eligible board inside essentials for well qualified customers. Auto pay + taxes, fees and $35 device connection charge credits and imbalance due if you pay off earlier. Cancel contact US Finance Agreement 256 gigabytes. $830 required. Visit T mobile.com why choose a sleep number? Smart bed.

[Co-Host (unnamed)]

Can I make my site softer?

[Host 2]

Can I make my site firmer?

[Burt]

Can we sleep cooler? Sleep number does that cools up to eight times faster and lets you choose your ideal comfort on either side your Sleep Number setting Enjoy personalized comfort for better sleep night after night. It's the final days of our Black Friday sale. Recharge this season with a bundle of cozy, soothing comfort. Now only $17.99 for our C2 mattress and base plus free premium delivery price is higher in Alaska and Hawaii. Check it out at a Sleep number store or sleepnumber.com today.

[Host 1]

We all love our pets, but we love to travel too, and sadly they can't always come along for the ride. Don't stress. Trusted House Sitters connects you with verified sitters who will stay in your home and care for your pets, all in exchange for a place to their travels. So while you're off exploring, your pets get to stay safe and happy at home, right where they belong. Find a loving in Home Pet sitter [e-mail].