Loading summary
Amanda
When you think about meal kit companies, what do you see?
Jen
Probably long, complicated recipes and subscriptions you can't escape. But with the new Blue Apron, we're doing meal delivery differently. No subscription needed, faster, easier meals, and the same dedication to quality we've always had. Shop 100/Meals@blueapron.com, get 50% off your first.
Amanda
Two orders with code APRON50.
Jen
Terms and conditions apply.
Amanda
Visit blueapron.com terms for more.
Host (possibly Burt)
Reggie, I just sold my car online. Let's go, Grandpa. Wait, you did? Yep. On Carvana. Just put in the license plate, answered a few questions, got an offer in minutes. Easier than setting up that new digital picture frame. You don't say. Yeah, they're even picking it up tomorrow. Talk about fast. Wow. Way to go. So, about that picture frame. Ah, forget about it. Until Carvana makes one, I'm not interested.
Blue Apron Advertiser
Car selling made easy on Carvana.
Host (possibly Burt)
Pick up. These may apply. Hey, the bird show. This is something that I actually brought up during the running of the Brides because there was a statistic that showed that, like, 75 or 80% of women, if you got them alone and you asked them if they were happy with their the way that their men proposed marriage to them, they said no. They said no? Yeah. It's like 8 in 10 women.
Melissa
So they didn't like their proposal story or they've, like, recrafted it to retell it or something?
Host (possibly Burt)
Well, they didn't like it. They just didn't like the way that their men proposed. Like, they were expecting something a little bit more over the top or something a little bit more romantic or something a little bit more special. Either way, 8 in 10 women are not happy with the way that their men are proposing marriage to them. And intern Jen here heard a story a couple of weeks ago. Kind of hit my head.
Jen
It was actually a few months ago, one of my friends from high school got engaged back in the fall. And of course, the first question you want to ask the person is, how'd they do it? The second question is, what's the ring look like? But to me, more importantly, I want to know, what's the romantic, cute little story that he thought up for you? And when I asked her how he proposed, she was like, well, he came and picked me up, and we were driving around, and he just kind of pulled over and proposed. Oh, no, there was no story. There was no speech. It was just like, hey, will you marry me? And they'd been dating for three or four years, so it's not like he didn't have time to think it up. And it's not like it was supposed to. Spontaneous. He planned on doing it. He just had no plan.
Angela
He pulled over on the side of the road.
Melissa
They. They.
Jen
I don't know exactly where they pulled over, but I think they pulled over into a park or something. But he didn't plan a picnic. He didn't plan, you know, a speech. You gotta have something to go with there. I mean, just nothing.
Angela
The only thing I associate pulling over for is either having to pee or puking.
Host (possibly Burt)
Well, let's give them the benefit of the doubt. Like, let's say they met in that park or it somehow holds something special. No, they didn't. Nothing. Not even.
Melissa
And he wasn't deployed to Iraq? No, Right before that. Okay.
Jen
Nothing.
Melissa
Cause I thought, you know, if you're leaving for the military or something, you had to get married in a hurry. Maybe. I get that. Not having as great of a story. I understand that.
Host (possibly Burt)
Hey, Adrienne.
Amanda
Yeah.
Jeff
Good morning.
Amanda
How are you?
Host (possibly Burt)
Good, how are you? Oh, God.
Amanda
I know my husband's gonna be listening to this.
Angela
Well, maybe he should, if this is a bad story.
Amanda
I was living in New York and he was here, and we had been doing the long distance thing, and we had known each other for a very long time. We had dated, and then we had just been friends, and then we were reconnecting, and it was just kind of decided, you know, come move down here to Atlanta and we'll get married. But there was never an official proposal. And then I moved down here, and, you know, he's a really practical guy, which is great. And he was like, I don't know anything about jewelry. Come with me and let's pick out a ring. And I was like, all right. And I had a family diamond that I wanted to wear. So I said, oh, and here's the diamond. I pretty much did it. You know, we did it together, but there was never an official proposal.
Angela
And you just. I mean, you hold that. And she gave him just. Well, he's a practical guy. No, don't make excuses for him. He kind of, you know, didn't pick it up.
Melissa
I have a bad story. One of my best friends who got engaged, and I think they've since changed their story, but I was. My husband and I were the first ones to hear about them getting engaged. And the story was, well, it was her birthday, and I've been wanting to get engaged for a while. I've been thinking about, you know, trying to pick a good day and a good moment to do it. And I didn't have anything for her for her birthday.
Host (possibly Burt)
Oh, no, I know.
Melissa
So it was like an alternate birthday present. Like, he was like, well, just go ahead and like kind of knock them both out at the same time and just go ahead and propose.
Angela
And she knows that.
Melissa
Yeah, and she knows. But we were like the first ones they told the story to. So I think that the story has since changed.
Samantha
And of course, I would never correct.
Melissa
Them, but we were the first ones. And I think by our reaction, kind of like wide eyed looking at them, I think they realize they need to change that story a little bit later. Oh, so sad.
Host (possibly Burt)
Because you gotta. You can't shortcut this, guys. We can't shortcut this.
Angela
This is your time. This is the guy's time. The wedding is the bride's time. The proposal is the groom's time. This is your time to shine.
Host (possibly Burt)
Hey, Angela.
Amanda
Hi. How are you?
Host (possibly Burt)
Good. Good morning.
Amanda
Me and my husband, when he. Well, he didn't propose to me, actually. We were at a friend's house. He had two chances, actually, and he went and got my rings at a pawn shop. Well, that was fine, you know, and I knew we didn't have a lot of money and that we could do it, you know, get more rings later.
Jen
Mm.
Amanda
Well, we were at a friend's house. He just hands me these rings. And his friend asked me, he said, amanda, what is that? I was like, well, I don't know, because I was pissed off by that time. I was like, you know, I don't know. And so later on, about a week later, I looked underneath the rings. There was somebody else's name underneath the ring.
Host (possibly Burt)
Oh, no. So he went to the pawn shop, gets the rings, and when he gives it to you, somebody else had their engravement in it already.
Amanda
Yes. And so he actually. We actually went back and we got, you know, more expensive rings or whatever, and he did it the exact same way again. Just handed it to me. Never asked me to marry him, really.
Host (possibly Burt)
So that's. Here's the thing, and here's how we're. We're figuring it is that, guys, we need rules. We need a set. We need like a document to tell us exactly what to do and what not to do so we don't mess these things up. All right? And we started this a couple of weeks ago. The Birch shot, the Burt shows, Idiots and Guides. I think it started a couple of weeks ago with Phil.
Melissa
Yeah, we did the idiot's guide to traveling with your girlfriend.
Host (possibly Burt)
So I think what we got to do today is we have to spend a couple of times to do the Burt Show's Idiot's Guide to Marriage Proposals.
Melissa
I love it.
Host (possibly Burt)
All right, so women call up and think about, like, if we're making this book and guys would pick it up and read it, like, the 10 things that they absolutely must know about proposals to make it really, really special for you guys. Do you have a good example to start with?
Melissa
Well, I love my proposal story. My husband took me to a place that I had spent every summer growing up in my summer camp, and we hiked a mountain that I had hiked my whole life. And he proposed on top of the mountain.
Host (possibly Burt)
So not necessarily the story, but what do we get out of that? Like, it should be something from her past. Like.
Melissa
One of the rules. Just make it something special that she's told you in the past.
Host (possibly Burt)
Some kind of.
Jeff
So listen. You have to listen.
Melissa
Listen and connect it to a story she's told you in the past.
Host (possibly Burt)
Okay, so that would be like the first rule of the Idiot's Guide. Marriage proposals. You have an idea here, Melissa?
Angela
Well, it was based on the last caller who said her, you know, fiance or her husband had done it at a friend's party and just handed her the ring. My thing is, do it in private. Like, I. In some way. You know, whether. Even if it's in a restaurant or even at least it's private between the two of you. And there's not anybody else in the immediate vicinity.
Host (possibly Burt)
So no big family kind of thing. Like you proposed in front of the whole family.
Jeff
What about that diamond commercial where he gets the family together and they're all hiding behind the newspapers on the steps?
Angela
I mean, he re.
Jeff
Proposes.
Angela
We don't have to put it on. I like that one.
Melissa
It's a reproposed. But I like. I like what Melissa's saying. I think something private. And then you go make the announcement together in front of your family.
Host (possibly Burt)
Unless it's a special circumstance, make it private. Yeah, that makes it safe.
Angela
Yeah.
Host (possibly Burt)
Good morning, Michelle. You're on all the hits. Q100.
Amanda
Good morning, everyone.
Angela
Hi.
Amanda
Okay, you would think this would be common sense, but I guess not. Have a ring.
Samantha
That's a good one.
Melissa
There you go.
Amanda
My husband proposed to me in a bar with a bar straw made into a ring.
Samantha
Oh, dude.
Host (possibly Burt)
Now, I guess on one hand that could be endearing, but on another hand, you're like, no, not at all, Samantha.
Jeff
And the bar. What was the bar?
Amanda
It was the bar back up in Massachusetts.
Melissa
Yeah.
Amanda
What's the name of a Small little hole in the wall.
Jeff
The name of it is gonna be very telling.
Amanda
I don't even remember. Oh, the post office. The post office post.
Host (possibly Burt)
Yeah, I got engaged at the post office with a straw. All right, so have a ring. That seems like the most basic thing for an idiot's guide to marriage proposals. R.J. good morning.
Amanda
What's up, guys? How you doing?
Host (possibly Burt)
Good, thank you.
Amanda
Well, this is kind of playing off a little bit about what Jen was saying. I think a very important thing is planning. A lot of times guys are just out with their buddies. They're like, yeah, I'm gonna go home and do it, you know? No, don't do that. Take a little time, put something together. Maybe run it past, you know, some friends or parents to, you know, find out if that's gonna work out and then do it. You know, it shouldn't be spur the moment is good, but something that'll give a story that she'll have to tell, you know, friends, family, her children one day, I think is very important.
Melissa
I agree with that one. Preplanning is a good one. Another one is take a knee.
Host (possibly Burt)
Take a knee. For sure. Take a knee. Really?
Melissa
For sure. Take a knee.
Jeff
Good point.
Host (possibly Burt)
404-741-1005. Good morning, Jennifer. The Idiot's guide to Marriage Proposals.
Amanda
Hi. Good morning.
Host (possibly Burt)
Hi.
Amanda
How are you? Good, good. Okay, My suggestion is my husband. We didn't have a really over the top proposal. But what I found out later meant more that he took time out to study a little bit. About what? Diamonds. You know, the different classes of diamonds and the colors and all that. And he got a good understanding and gave me a perfect diamond. It's not huge, but it's perfect. And that meant a lot. I mean, you know, you can forget, you know, you get Alzheimer's one day and you forget how you were proposed to, but you can't forget the. The diamond you get on your finger.
Host (possibly Burt)
If you hear that once you hear it a million times.
Jeff
And plus, once you get the Alzheimer's, you look at your hands like you're seeing it again for the first time.
Jen
Every time.
VRBO Advertiser
Exactly.
Jeff
You might as well make it one that you love.
Melissa
Well, I'm not sure about the ending there, but I think that her point in doing the research on diamonds, you know, get educated, I think is a good thing.
Angela
Research diamonds, research. Think of Alzheimer's.
Jeff
Look at that. I'm engaged.
Host (possibly Burt)
Hey, Amanda.
Amanda
Yes? The guy actually needs to ask. Ask the question.
Angela
Okay.
Melissa
Will you. What happened, Mary? Man.
Angela
Yeah. Did you not get that?
Amanda
I'm Sorry.
Jen
My.
Amanda
My husband got me this big old box with a bunch of his family's wrapping paper in it with a brick. And I turn around, I was like, honey, there's nothing in here. And he's down on one knee and just says, do I even have to ask?
Host (possibly Burt)
Oh, no, you see, you got to make it. You gotta say the words. Do I even have to ask?
Angela
Don't put me to the trouble of having to ask you to marry me.
Melissa
Yeah. Four words have to be included in your proposal. And those are? Will, the four words. It's simple, guys.
Host (possibly Burt)
Seems pretty basic. Good morning, Jennifer. You're on all the hits. Q100.
Amanda
Good morning.
Host (possibly Burt)
Hi.
Amanda
Pick a date that's significant.
Melissa
Oh, that's a good idea.
Amanda
Significant to your relationship. Not just, you know, the cliche of Valentine's Day.
Host (possibly Burt)
Again, this kind of goes back to what Jen was saying about it. It should be sentimental in some way, shape or form.
Melissa
Yeah, but a sentimental date, like the date you first started dating or the day you said the album. Phil, what was that?
Jeff
I. I had a friend who, I mean, still smartest man that I know, proposed marriage on April Fool's Day, so that at any point, if he decided he didn't want to get married, he.
Host (possibly Burt)
Could just say, that's hilarious. I bet she found that to be very, very funny. Hey, Kim.
Amanda
Yeah.
Host (possibly Burt)
Idiot's guide to Marriage Proposals.
Amanda
Hey. Hey, guys. How are y'? All?
Host (possibly Burt)
Good.
Amanda
This is not so much as a suggestion as it is a warning. And Jeff, it's not because we're demanding. It's maybe because maybe a lot of men are lazy.
Host (possibly Burt)
8 and 10.
Amanda
And the warning is if the proposal is boring, you can pretty much suggest that the sex life is going to be boring and unimaginative.
Host (possibly Burt)
Also, as a general rule. Now that goes with the statistics that we've talked about before. Also that 2 and 10, if I.
Amanda
Can'T think of anything special on that, certainly, you know, long term marriage.
Host (possibly Burt)
Yeah, it's the exact same statistic. Because you guys have told us. Yep.
Angela
Right.
Melissa
It's that 8 and 10 aren't good in bed. Right.
Jeff
I'll give you one that Bert violated.
Host (possibly Burt)
Okay.
Jeff
Don't do it in conjunction with another person's event.
Host (possibly Burt)
Yeah, probably not. What Jeff is talking about is that I proposed after Stacy's brother's graduation.
Angela
Yeah.
Host (possibly Burt)
It was the. He had already graduated, but I proposed that night. We didn't tell anybody until the next morning. So I think that's probably good because you don't want to take it away from anybody else.
Jeff
You want it to be completely your. Your day. And ask the dad.
Host (possibly Burt)
It's another one I violated, if possible. I didn't ask the dad.
Melissa
Some women don't have dads around anymore. So if possible, if her dad's in her life, if they have a relationship.
Samantha
I think the mom.
Angela
If the dad's not there.
Host (possibly Burt)
My attitude. My attitude back then was, what's it going to matter? It seems so fake that if I ask him and he says no, I'm going to propose anyway. But A, he was going to say yes, and B, now that I look back at it and I've become close to her dad, I'm sorry that I robbed him of that, because it's only going to happen for him one time. M. Theoretically.
Angela
And I just. Yeah, I just think that that's where. I mean, a proposal is where you think outside yourself for a guy. I mean, that may be hard for some guys, but, like, you. I mean, like, well, I'm going to propose to her anyway. Well, you know, you think outside yourself.
VRBO Advertiser
This is.
Angela
This is more than just about you.
Host (possibly Burt)
Yeah. Now that I'm a dad, I realize how important it would have been to him. I'm bummed I didn't ask him. Good morning, Camille.
Amanda
Hey.
Host (possibly Burt)
Hi.
Amanda
How are you guys?
Host (possibly Burt)
Good, thank you.
Amanda
I just had a quick antidote. You guys remember Stepmom, the movie?
Host (possibly Burt)
Stepmom was just on Julia Roberts and Susan Saranda, where he did a string.
Melissa
Thing and he put the ring finger on the string. That was cute.
Amanda
Yeah. And that was simple, but not too over the top or anything like that, but just really, you know, sentimental.
Host (possibly Burt)
So something. It can be simple, but it just, again, has to tie into sentimentality.
Amanda
Well, it was the words that he said, along with the fact that he dropped the ring on the string and pretty much said, spend, you know, the rest of my life with you.
Host (possibly Burt)
Effort, effort, effort. Now, Phil here has a theory about his proposal, and I think you're walking down a. Another road to failure here.
Jeff
Another.
Host (possibly Burt)
I already know how I'm going to propose to whoever I marry. I already have my entire proposal planned out.
VRBO Advertiser
See, look at.
Host (possibly Burt)
Did you see that reaction? Okay.
Amanda
Oh, no.
Host (possibly Burt)
It's like you got a paper cut in the eye. No, because this is.
Melissa
No, that's like generic proposal 101.
Angela
You can't do it.
Host (possibly Burt)
See, you don't know, though, because it is probably one of the most, like, romantic spots I've ever been to in my entire life. And my theory is.
Melissa
With who?
Angela
With who?
Host (possibly Burt)
I was with nobody. I've just been There. It's somewhere I've been before and I'd love to go back. And my theory is, if I. When I find the girl.
Jeff
The back bar at Peachtree Tavern, When.
Host (possibly Burt)
I find the girl that I'm gonna marry and I know I'm gonna spend the rest of my life with her, we're gonna have. You know, we're obviously gonna have a lot in common. And I think if I find this spot as romantic as I do, that I. My hope is that she will too. I think you gotta cater it to the woman you're gonna marry. Man, you're like, so focused right now. But I think. But I think if we both.
Angela
If she will like what I like, if she' be mild, it's a very.
Host (possibly Burt)
It's a. It's a very romantic, sweet, romantic.
Melissa
Okay. Take her there on a picnic, right? If you guys have a great time there and it's something significant that becomes a sentimental part of your relationship in the future, then I would say it's okay. But you can't just take her somewhere random and propose. And it's like fill in bride here.
Jeff
And if you take one girl there, it's out for any future.
Host (possibly Burt)
I know.
Jen
And no.
Host (possibly Burt)
And no. I've never. I've never. I've never had a. Another female with.
Angela
Stanford Stadium is not a place to propose to a woman.
Melissa
Sorry.
Host (possibly Burt)
Georgia Florida game in Jacksonville. Consider it done. Hey, the Birch Show.
VRBO Advertiser
Get a jump on next summer with vrbo's early booking deals. Don't wait to claim your dream summer spot, whether that includes a good porch swing or a poolside lounger. When you book early, you get the best places at the best prices. But back to the poolside loungers. With vrbo, you don't have to reserve any loungers. They're all yours. In fact, the whole private home is yours. Book with early booking deals and you can lounge around all summer long however you please@vervo.com.
Blue Apron Advertiser
Why does every recipe I try need 18 ingredients, including a jar of something paste I'll never use again, but will sit in my fridge for nine months? I just want dinner in the oven fast. That's why I love Blue Apron's new One Pan, assemble and bake meals. They send you fresh ingredients that are already chopped. All you do is put it all together and bake. That's it. No chopping, no weird leftovers. Just delicious, easy to make meals. Get 20% off your first two orders with code APRON20. Terms and conditions apply. Visit blueapron.com terms for more.
Host (possibly Burt)
Hey, listeners meet Russell Hey, Russell just launched a fitness app, and he needed to get the word out to busy professionals looking to stay fit. So I turned to acast. I used their Smart Recommendations feature to easily find shows that talk about health and fitness. Booking sponsorships through their platform was a breeze, and just like that, my app was in their ears during their morning run. Sounds like a smart move, Russell. How's business looking now? Sweat is pouring, and so are the installs. Spread the word about your business with podcast ads on Acast. Start today at go.acast.com advertisement.
Date: December 31, 2025
Host & Cast: Bert (likely the main host), Melissa, Angela, Jen, Jeff, Amanda, Samantha, and callers
This lively episode centers on the perennial question: How should a marriage proposal be done right? Prompted by the revealing statistic that “8 in 10 women are not satisfied with their proposal stories,” the hosts and listeners get candid about proposal horror stories, share memorable moments, and together compile “The Bert Show’s Idiot’s Guide to Marriage Proposals.” This episode is packed with humor, real-life confessions, and practical advice—making it both entertaining and educational for anyone thinking about popping the question.
The cast remains playful yet honest throughout, with rapid-fire banter, supportive advice, and lighthearted teasing. Humor is frequently used to call out silly mistakes—like using a straw at a bar or recycling pawn shop rings—but every story comes back to the importance of effort, thoughtfulness, and genuine expression.
For listeners (or proposers!) seeking real-life wisdom, laughs, and a checklist for their own big moment, this episode delivers both cautionary tales and a guide to getting it right.