Vault: Lost Theories

Summary

The Bert Show – "Vault: Lost Theories"

Date: August 7, 2026
Theme: Theories and Predictions for the Finale of Lost

---

Overview

In this lively episode, The Bert Show team invites callers and co-hosts to share their wildest, most heartfelt, and occasionally hilarious theories about the iconic series Lost, just days before its much-anticipated finale. The conversation is punctuated by fan passion, pop culture callbacks, and the group's signature humor, blending genuine discussion with their typical self-aware banter. Even non-Lost fans get some context, with co-hosts going back and forth over what makes the show so compelling—and so confusing.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Lost Explained for Non-Fans

• [02:14] Host: Lost is “a five season soap opera about people that…got in a plane crash on a very mysterious Island.”
• The show is described as a mix of survival, mystery, and sci-fi, with bizarre island phenomena and characters’ attempts to escape.
• [02:26] Host: “It’s now coming down to the point where some…are working their way off the island.”

2. Theories on How Lost Will End

• Good vs Evil Showdown

  • [02:47] Host: “Good is gonna triumph over evil in this one…Jacob is going to get killed pretty quickly here. Jack is staying on the island, and the smoke monster doesn’t get off the island either.”

• Purgatory/Hell Theory

  • [03:18]: The long-standing fan theory that the island is a form of purgatory or hell is discussed.
  • [03:33] Host: “You really don’t know what the island is yet.”

• Island as a Source of Protection

  • [05:18] Presley: “The island pretty much is…the only thing keeping evil from the world or the world from ending…this is about a fight about good and evil.”
  • [05:44] Presley: “The island is almost like a cork in the bottle of evil.”
  • [05:51] Host: “That’s exactly how it was explained on the show.”

• Detailed Call-in Theories

  • [04:50] Caller (Madison): “Claire, Jack’s sister, is going to…get taken over by the smoke monster…and it’ll be her and Jack at the end…in the good and evil positions.”
  • [06:36] Caller (Trisha): “They were all dead since the plane crash and…are in the hell. The tunnel of light is…heaven…but evil people…turn into smoke monsters…that’s the way to heaven.”
  • [07:49] Caller (Betsy): “Jack’s going to get everyone else off the island. And Jack and Locke are going to be having the same conversation that Jacob and the man in black did…they want to kill each other, but the rules won’t let us do it.”
  • [09:42] Caller (Megan): “Jacob…is already dead…think Jack might even die. I don’t want him to, but…for some reason…he might die.”
  • [10:35] Caller (Lisa): “Everybody gets off the island…they’re gonna go back in time and be able to save everybody…they’ll get rid of the smoke monster…when they kill him, they’re able to get off…”

• Parallel Worlds/Alternative Timelines

  • [11:03] Host: “There are kind of like two parallel worlds…one is what’s happening to them on the island, and the other world is what would happen to them if they weren’t on the island.”
  • [12:27] Host: “Jill says they’ll die in the island timeline and live in the alternative timeline…they’re connected in one way…but they’re not on the island anymore.”

3. Fan Culture, Investment & “Geekiness”

• [06:15] Presley: “All I’m saying is Dragon Con, honey…storylines like this, total geek fest.”
• [09:16] Presley: “You’ve never been sexier to me than you are…testament to the writers…people are this invested and this into it, you know, after…so many seasons.”

4. Memorable Quotes & Moments

• On Hurley’s Weight

  • [03:56] Co-host: “Is the fat castaway still fat?…”
  • [04:08] Presley: “Where’s he getting his food?”
  • [04:10] Co-host (joking): “I think he’s eating the other castaways…”

• On the Intensity of Fandom

  • [09:01] Host: “There are some…really…hardcore Lost geeks that slow down the words every week…TiVo it and slow it down and watch it in pause mode because there’s all sorts of crap…”

• How Will It End?

  • [07:24] Co-host: “Is there any chance that, like, they’ll just cut back to the cockpit…and the co pilot…dozed off and had a terrible dream and just woke up and the plane lands fine?”
  • [07:39] Presley: “It’ll be like Sopranos, lights just go out.”
  • [07:41] Host: “Or Seinfeld…so many people were upset that they were all in jail together?”

• Reflections on Sticking with the Show

  • [09:26] Host: “If you’re invested in it this long, you have to sort of watch to the end. Even if it was season four, you’re like, damn, I’ve just wasted four years of my life. I’m gonna give it one more season…”

---

Notable Quotes & Attribution

• [02:47] Host: “Good is gonna triumph over evil…Jacob is going to get killed pretty quickly here. Jack is staying on the island, and the smoke monster doesn’t get off the island either.”
• [05:18] Presley: “My friend...said the island pretty much is, like, the only thing keeping evil from the world or the world from ending.”
• [05:44] Presley: “…the island is almost like a cork in the bottle of evil.”
• [06:36] Trisha (Caller): “…they were all dead since the plane crash and…are in the hell. …the tunnel of light is…heaven…but evil people…turn into smoke monsters.”
• [07:49] Betsy (Caller): “Jack’s going to get everyone else off the island. Jack and [Locke] are going to be having the same conversation that Jacob and the man in black did…they want to kill each other, but the rules won’t let us do it.”
• [09:16] Presley: “You’ve never been sexier to me than you are…testament to the writers…people are this invested and this into it…”

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [02:14] What is Lost? — Host’s explanation for non-fans
• [02:47–03:18] Early finale predictions and purgatory/hell theories
• [04:50–08:29] Call-in theories segment: Claire & Jack; all are dead; Jack vs. Locke; “the rules”; parallel timelines
• [09:01] Obsession with hidden details and fan passion
• [10:35–12:45] Name-drop of rapid-fire alternate endings by listeners (Desmond replaces Jacob, Ben as smoke monster, timelines merge, everyone dies, etc.)
• [12:46] Exhausted wrap-up and awe at the complexity

---

Tone & Dynamics

The show is fast-paced, playful, and often irreverent. There’s a lot of cross-chatter, affectionate ribbing about fandom and geekiness, and appreciation for how deeply Lost has burrowed into pop culture. The hosts keep it welcoming for both hardcore fans and the uninitiated, and callers’ theories spark genuine discussion, minor debates, and laughter throughout.

---

Summary Takeaway

This episode taps into the communal excitement and confusion surrounding the end of Lost. Callers and hosts cycle through theories about purgatory, time travel, good and evil, and alternate timelines—while poking fun at the show, their own obsessive tendencies, and the impossibility of a “perfect” finale. It serves as a time capsule of pre-finale Lost speculation, dense with fan energy and The Bert Show’s signature comic relief.

Transcript

[Ryan Reynolds / Jake Stauch]

Hi, Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. Are you looking for a beach read this summer? May I suggest your big wireless build? It's got suspense, mystery, a slightly flat emotional arc and a shocking twist where you realize you've been overpaying the entire time. Fortunately though, Mint's story is better. Every plan $15 a month, even unlimited. That's it. Happy ending, zero tears. Give it a [e-mail] Switch upfront payment

[Presley Hofbach]

of $45 for three months, $90 for six months or $180 for a 12 month plan. Required $15 per month equivalent taxes and fees. Extra initial plan term only greater than 50gb. Me slow when network is busy. See Terms.

[Ryan Reynolds / Jake Stauch]

I'm Jake Stauch, co founder and CEO of Cervel. We built Cervel to automate the IT work that slows companies down. Onboarding password resets, access to applications. My laptop stopped working. While employees wait for help, their real work is put on hold. It desperately wants to automate this work. And that's why they need Serval. You just tell Serval what you want to automate in plain English and it's built. No drag and drop workflows, no expense of consultants. Employees get unblocked and IT teams go from drowning in tickets to building what actually matters. With Cerval, it becomes the AI engine powering the entire company. This is a new way to run it. We guarantee you'll automate 50% of all tickets and we'll prove it to you in a free four week pilot. Go to serval.com tickets that's S-E-R-V-A L.com tickets.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Hey, the bird show. All right, so for those of you that are Lost fans, this next five minutes will be fantastic.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Right?

[Caller or Co-host]

Right.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

For those of you that are, bye bye, bye bye.

[Presley Hofbach]

Well, you may stay. I mean like if you're somebody that's either forced to see the finale on Sunday or is just curious, maybe some of these explanations, you know, some of these people, you know, who have an ending. Maybe it'll give you an idea of what the show might be about.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Producer Carl just instant messaged me and said for us who have never seen Lost, is this a survivor type reality show, Carl? No idea, Zero idea. No, it's not.

[Presley Hofbach]

Now I think that you should probably go first since you're the die hard Lost fan in the room.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

How do you explain what Lost is? It's a what, five season soap opera about people that were on a plane, got on a plane, got in a plane crash on a very mysterious Island.

[Presley Hofbach]

Right.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

And for the last couple of seasons, they've been trying to get the hell off this island. And just the most random sort of bizarre things happen on this island. And it's now coming down to the point where some of those that crash it appears as though they're working their way off the island, and that's really it.

[Presley Hofbach]

So what's your prediction for the ending?

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

I really don't have one. I got to be. I would say that good is gonna triumph over evil in this one. So I would say, if you're a Lost fan, I say Jacob is going to get killed pretty quickly here. Jack is staying on the island, and the smoke monster doesn't get off the island either.

[Presley Hofbach]

Okay, smoke monster.

[Caller or Co-host]

What does the island represent? Like, do we know if it's purgatory or if it's.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

That's. Those are some theories that it is hell, that they find out that this is their hell again, so they all died. That's what. That could be. One theory. So now if you're in the Lost and you've been.

[Caller or Co-host]

So you don't know what. You don't know what the island is yet.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

You really don't know what the island is yet.

[Presley Hofbach]

I want to get my.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

You know that it can. It can move through time. Sometimes it goes back in time. Other times, when you're on the island, it goes into the future. We know that. We now know that there's a light in the middle of the island, and. And there are two guys on the island that are trying to protect that light, and they're brothers, and it looks like they're trying to kill each other.

[Caller or Co-host]

Is the fat castaway still fat? Cause that was the.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

That's the one thing about the show that does bug me. I mean, and he's swimming all the time. He's hiking through that island.

[Presley Hofbach]

What's that character's name again?

[Caller or Co-host]

Hurley. Right.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

That's Hurley.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Hurley.

[Presley Hofbach]

I was gonna call him Hurley.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Where's he.

[Presley Hofbach]

Where's he getting his food?

[Caller or Co-host]

I don't know. I think he's eating the other castaways. You think there's any chance that he. Like the smoke monster?

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

No. 404, 741, Q100. If you have a lost theory, now is the time to document it. I love this, because on Monday, there's gonna be a whole bunch of people that go in the office, and they're gonna go, I knew that's the way it ended. No, you didn't. You're just saying that you did. Now you. You can Document it with us.

[Presley Hofbach]

Right.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

We will play it back on Monday and you can say, listen to Q100 at 915. Check it out. That was the only one that was right. Hey, Casey. Good morning. You're on the Burt Show.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Good morning.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

All right, these are big time bragging rights for you. If you get this right. What is Lost all about? How is it going to end?

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Okay. My husband and I have been watching it from the very beginning, and we think that Claire, Jack's sister, is going to. We think she's going to get taken over by the smoke monster, and it'll be her and Jack at the end, kind of, you know, in the good and evil positions.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

So you think they're gonna replace the good and evil now with Jack and his sister?

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Yes.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Oh, that's good. That's really good.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Thank you.

[Presley Hofbach]

Because my friend was trying to explain this to me and Katie one night, and basically, I don't know if this is his theory or this is common knowledge with loss that the island pretty much is, like, the only thing keeping evil from the world or the world from ending.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Yes.

[Presley Hofbach]

And that basically all this is about a fight about good and evil.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

If the smoke monster gets off of the island, all we know is that it's gonna be awful for the rest

[Presley Hofbach]

of the world, because smoke monster sounds ridiculous. But basically the theme is, though, is that the island is almost like a cork in the bottle of evil.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Yeah, well, that's exactly how it was explained on the show.

[Presley Hofbach]

Okay. That's common knowledge.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Yes.

[Presley Hofbach]

Okay.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

The smoke monster is really this character, Jacob's brother. He got thrown into the light, and rather than dying, he turned into smoke.

[Presley Hofbach]

Okay.

[Caller or Co-host]

So now he just floats. Now he just floats around the island, like, as a puff of smoke.

[Presley Hofbach]

Well.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

And he changes into other people's body forms also. Like, he is in the form of John Locke right now, but he's really the smoke monster. Come on, man.

[Presley Hofbach]

See, all I'm saying is John Locke dead. All I'm saying is Dragon Con, honey. And I don't know how you want to mask it. You don't think you're a geek, but I'm telling you, storylines like this, total

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

geek fest, this makes Dragon Con look like the hippest event ever. All right, Trisha, we can document this for you. What is the ending of Lost?

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Well, I think that they were all dead since the plane crash and that they are in the hell. And I think that all the flash forwards are the way that they would have wanted their lives. And I think that the tunnel of light is actually heaven. But evil people that go in there, of course, turn into smoke monsters or whatever because they're not allowed. And I think that that's the way to heaven, and they're all gonna end up going through there.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

That makes sense. Because the bad brother. The bad brother kills his mom. Right? So he's bad now. So good brother kills bad brother by shoving him into that light, and him, rather than dying, turns into this eternal smoke thing. So what she's saying is that could be his hell.

[Presley Hofbach]

Mm. Gotcha.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

I know it's tough.

[Caller or Co-host]

Is there any chance that, like, they'll just cut back to the cockpit of the plane and the co pilot, like, dozed off and had a terrible dream and just woke up for it and the plan lands Fine.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

I don't know how they can end this with Lost fans being happy with every.

[Presley Hofbach]

It'll be like Sopranos lights just go out.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Or Seinfeld back in the day. Also, remember how so many people were upset that they were all in jail together?

[Caller or Co-host]

Right.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Good morning, Betsy. You were on the Burke show. Hi.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

The only two left on the island, that Jack's going to get everyone else off the island. And Jack and Lars are going to be having the same conversation that Jacob and the man in black did last year at the end of the season, saying, we really want to kill each other, but the rules won't let us do it.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

The only thing I missed there was Jack and.

[Caller or Co-host]

Who?

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Locke.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Yes, Jack and fake Locke. Or, you know, whoever you want to call them. They're going to be the only two left on the island. Everyone else is going to get off.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Okay, so your theory is that Jack really starts to now assume Jacob's role and the fight continues.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Exactly. And that they want to kill each other, but the rules won't let them kill each other. Just like how the rules wouldn't let Jacob and the man in black kill each other either.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

These guys fell asleep three minutes ago. I am so excited by all of these theories because they all make sense.

[Presley Hofbach]

Wait, is that basically the balance of good and evil? That's why they can't kill. Kill each other? Is one represent good and one represent evil?

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Yes. But we don't know why they can't kill each other yet. But her theory sounds really good.

[Presley Hofbach]

Because my thing is, it's balance. You can't have one without the other.

[Caller or Co-host]

Whose rules are they?

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

What do you mean?

[Caller or Co-host]

She says it's the rule. You can't kill each other. So, like, whose rules are they?

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

That we don't know yet. That we're gonna find out on Sunday.

[Caller or Co-host]

Well, why do you just.

[Presley Hofbach]

I hope you find out.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

We better find out.

[Caller or Co-host]

Are they still doing stuff like running fake commercials and there's weird codes and crap?

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Not so much of that anymore. But there are some, like, really, like, hardcore Lost geeks that slow down the words every week, and we'll TiVo it and slow it down and watch it in pause mode because there's all sorts of crap that sort of happens in the background sometimes.

[Presley Hofbach]

You've never been sexier to me than you are. It's a testament to the writers on the show because people are this invested and this into it, you know, after

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

so many seasons, it's like, well, if you're invested in it this long, you have to sort of watch to the end. Even if it was season four, you're like, damn, I've just wasted four years of my life. I'm gonna give it one more season to find out how it. How it ends up. Hey, Megan. Good morning. You're on the Bird show.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Hey.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Hi. Your theory.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

I just. I just wanted to say that Jacob, first of all, is already dead.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Right.

[Presley Hofbach]

That's very condescending.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

He got stabbed. She's right.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Exactly. But for some reason, I'm thinking Jack might even die. I don't want him to, but think. I think for some reason, I'm having a feeling that he might die.

[Caller or Co-host]

That.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Who's gonna die? Jack is gonna die.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Jack, huh?

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Okay.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

I don't want him to because I think him and Crate Kate would make a great couple, but.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

So it ends with Jack dying, and what happens to smoke monster? You get off the island or not?

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

I think. I think he's gonna be on the island still.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

He's still stuck there. Okay.

[Caller or Co-host]

I am surprised at how many women calling up, because I thought it was all dudes.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

No, it's all women.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Women.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

All right, Lisa, really quickly, you're bragging rights. Okay. If you get it right. How does LOST end?

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

I think that. That everybody gets off the island. That. That, you know, that electric magnetism thing that they're gonna go back and they're gonna go back in time and be able to save everybody. But they're gonna get rid of the smoke monster that way because they've got to kill him. And I think when they kill him, they're able to get off.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Okay.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

So, you know, all this back. They're going back and, like, all this. For this. This. The new stuff, they're going to be able to, like. It's going to be like they never. They Never crashed.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

There are kind of like two parallel worlds going on right now on the show. One is what's happening to them on the island, and the other world is what would happen to them if they weren't on the island. And we're not exactly sure how to tie both in together yet.

[Caller or Co-host]

I'm just.

[Presley Hofbach]

I do think it'd be cool for it to. To end like it started. And whether it's, you know, whether they. The plane doesn't crash or whether, you know, I don't know. But I always like stories like that where I don't know, it kind of ends up back in the beginning.

[Caller or Co-host]

I think the only way off the island should be on a plane that's identical to the one that crashed. And you just have to have the sack to get on it.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

You and I, Melissa, wouldn't even get back on.

[Presley Hofbach]

Oh, hell no.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

I'll stay here.

[Presley Hofbach]

I'll be like, all right, guess what? My new home.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

I'm gonna make love to the smoke monster for the rest of my life.

[Caller or Co-host]

That's right.

[Presley Hofbach]

So I'm back to get another plane.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Let me just go ahead and announce these because we won't have time to get to all of them. Saphir says Desmond's going to replace Jacob. Ben will replace the smoke monster. Okay. That is documented. Severe. Cindy says once again, Jack and Lock are going to end up on the beach. Jack is good, Lock is bad. We heard that one already. You're registered, Eric. They're gonna lose. And the black smoke gets let out, so everybody on the island dies, says Eric. And the evil thing gets off the island, which means we're not gonna be doing the show Monday because we're all dead.

[Presley Hofbach]

Right?

[Caller or Co-host]

It's not real life, Bert.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Oh, yeah, it's that parallel world thing. And Jill says they'll die in the island timeline and live in the alternative timeline. So that means they'll all be home. They're all home. They're connected in one way, shape, or form, but they're not on the island anymore.

[Presley Hofbach]

Fascinating.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

I'm exhausted. I'm just exhausted right now. The first show.

[Caller Madison Tevlin]

Hi, my name is Madison Tevlin.

[Presley Hofbach]

And I'm Presley Hofbach. If you're enjoying this podcast, be sure to check us out on Serving Smiles. Serving Smiles is a podcast where we try to make health and wellness way less overwhelming. In partnership with Colgate Palm Olive, we're breaking down topics like oral health, pet nutrition, skin health, and more. With the help of expert guests, we'll be swapping stories, learning healthy habits, and asking the tough questions like how often should I floss, what kind of sunscreen is right for me, and finding out what vets wish every owner knew about nutrition.

[Podcast Host (The Burt Show)]

Be sure to check out cervix files wherever.

[Presley Hofbach]

Get your podcasts.