Vault: She didn't hit her goal and she might lose her ring.

Summary

The Bert Show – "Vault: She Didn't Hit Her Goal And She Might Lose Her Ring"

Date: May 8, 2026
Main Cast: Bert, Kristin, Abby, Cassie, Tommy, & Guests
Summary Prepared For: Anyone who missed the episode and wants an engaging yet comprehensive breakdown of the conversation.

---

Episode Theme

Motivation by Humiliation: A Listener’s High-Stakes Weight Loss Challenge

This episode revisits the Bert Show’s controversial weight-loss motivation segment, “Motivation by Humiliation,” where listeners pledge something precious as collateral to hold themselves accountable. They focus on Trisha, a listener who risked her wedding ring—weighted with deep emotional significance—to reach her weight-loss goal. As the deadline arrives with the goal unmet, the show confronts the real-life complexities and emotional stakes of these on-air challenges.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The "Motivation by Humiliation" Concept

• The show’s unique approach: participants surrender a treasured item, to be returned only if a pre-set goal is reached.
  • Past examples: A listener handed over the deed to his van (and succeeded); another offered a flag from her deceased husband's funeral (she succeeded too).
  • Caution: The crew expresses discomfort with some emotional items, acknowledging the stress it can cause the participant and the show.
    • "We debated that a long time, if we even wanted to get involved in that." (E, 02:13)

2. Trisha’s Story: The Challenge and Stakes

• Trisha aims to lose 55–60 lbs by November 1st, handing over her wedding ring—custom purchased by her hardworking husband—as collateral.
  • "I'm willing to give you my wedding ring... it's very, very important to me. But I'm willing to do that for the challenge." (Trisha, 02:24)
• Trisha speaks of her 27-year marriage and sacrifices her husband made to buy the ring, underscoring its importance.
• At the update:
  • She lost 38 pounds—not the goal, but a major personal achievement.
  • Life threw obstacles: her husband disapproved of risking the ring, his job loss, personal illness, mounting stress, and time lost to the flu.

3. The Emotional Toll and Lifestyle Changes

• Trisha reflects on changes:
  • Consistent Weight Watchers attendance
  • Overhauling her eating habits (specifically, eating breakfast)
  • Persistence despite setbacks
    • "A lot of times before the diet, I was not ever eating breakfast...I had to change a lot of my eating habits." (Trisha, 06:12)

4. Team Debate: Should They Give Her the Ring Back?

• Dilemma: If they bend the rules now, does the segment lose credibility forever?
  • "If we give in, it's the last time we can ever do this segment." (C, 07:14)
• The team voices concern that “real life” will inevitably interfere and empathy must sometimes outweigh the show's structure.
• Listener Calls: Audience members and Trisha’s niece, Janet, passionately advocate for compassion:
  • "There is not a woman in the world who loves, adores, and worships her husband more than my Aunt Trisha does... Y'all can't take her rings." (Janet, 10:51)
• Considerations of gender: The panel notes men frequently lose weight faster; women’s bodies are biologically different, adding another layer of challenge for female participants.
  • "It is easier for men to lose weight. Doctors will tell you that." (D, 15:48)

5. Potential Compromises and Redefining the Segment

• Ideas floated:
  • Extending the deadline and raising the target weight—quickly dismissed as potentially unhealthy and never-ending.
  • Involving third-party panels for future decisions to diminish direct responsibility.
    • "We come up with a panel who make the decision on whether it gets returned." (F, 14:07)
• Ultimately, the recurring sentiment is that holding onto treasured items in perpetuity is unjust, especially in cases of major effort and partial success.

6. The Final Decision and Closure

• The hosts, after heartfelt debate and caller input, collectively decide to return the ring despite the missed goal, acknowledging Trisha’s achievement and the emotional reality.
  • "There's no way in good conscience we can keep that ring. So come get your ring… you did great. 38 pounds is fantastic." (C, 17:26)
• The segment, as they know it, is formally retired—learning that real-life stakes can be harsher than any radio bit.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On stakes and motivation:
  "If you really want to lose weight and want motivation, you have to give us in possession the thing you are gonna lose if you don’t make the cut." (C, 01:31)
• On emotional fallout:
  "It caused stress on the marriage, and then [my husband] lost his job. It's just been a downhill thing...but I've kept going." (Trisha, 04:35)
• Compassion from family:
  "I will do what I have to do, y'all make some kind of bet… I can't sit back and let that happen." (Janet, 10:51)
• On credibility vs. compassion:
  "If we give in... it's the last time we can ever do this segment... But the humanitarian in me is saying, come on man, give her some more time." (C, 07:14)
• On quitting the segment:
  "It's a stupid radio segment. We got plenty of material. So what if we never do it again?" (C, 17:01)
• Validation and pride:
  "You lost 38 pounds. You did not fail." (E, 17:42)

---

Timestamps of Important Segments

• 01:31 – Introduction to "Motivation by Humiliation" concept
• 02:24 – Trisha’s original pledge and explanation of the wedding ring’s significance
• 03:26 – Trisha provides her weight loss update (38 pounds lost)
• 04:35 – Trisha details emotional, marital, and health challenges
• 06:12 – Discussion of lasting lifestyle changes
• 07:14 – Host expresses the credibility/compassion dilemma
• 10:51 – Janet’s (Trisha's niece) heartfelt plea for compassion
• 14:07 – Proposal for a notary-panel decision for future challenges
• 17:26 – Decision to return the ring and end the segment as it exists

---

Flow, Tone, and Takeaway

The episode is a blend of humor, real-life struggle, and emotional honesty, typical of The Bert Show’s engaging style. Trisha’s journey becomes a lens to examine not just weight loss, but the ethical boundaries of on-air entertainment involving real stakes. The closing sentiment is one of empathy and realism: effort matters, and sometimes, even good intentions must yield to kind outcomes—radio segment or not.

---

For Listeners Who Missed It

You’ll feel both the tension of the high-stakes challenge and the warmth of a community rooting for someone to succeed. “Motivation by Humiliation” may have ended, but the bigger lesson is the power of perseverance, family support, and ultimately, the wisdom in choosing compassion over broadcast bravado.

Transcript

[A]

Dinner time. It's more than just a meal. It's when work comes to a halt, where macaroni masterpieces are made and little moments turn into lasting memories. With the Blue Cash Preferred card, you can get 6% cash back at US supermarkets so you can bring home the flavors that bring everyone together. We did say everyone make the special moments even more rewarding. Learn [e-mail] Explore BCP terms and cash back cap. Apply with Blue Cash preferred.

[B]

This podcast is sponsored by Talkspace. November is Men's Health Awareness Month. So Talkspace wants guys to know that being prepared for life's biggest challenges and opportunities means prioritizing mental health too. Talkspace can help you go beyond fine tuned workouts, supplements and productivity hacks. Talkspace can help you fine tune your inner life so you can succeed in being the best version of yourself in any situation. And with Talkspace, you can get therapy from anywhere and on your time. You, you can even text your therapist between sessions. If you're depressed, stressed, struggling with a relationship, or just need a little extra one on one support, Talkspace is here for you. Plus, Talkspace takes most insurance and most insured members have a zero dollar copay. Men's Health Awareness Month is the perfect time to reach out to TalkSpace. Now get $80 off your first month with promo code space80 when you go to talkspace.com match with a licensed therapist today at talkspace.com and save $80 with code [e-mail] get that's talkspace.com, promo code space80.

[C]

The bird show. So we call this motivation by humiliation. And we got smart about it because we did this a couple of different times. And then when listeners didn't meet their goal dates, we just never heard from them again. Weird how that happens, right? So the last time we did motivation by humiliation a couple of months ago, we said, look, if you really want to lose weight and you want motivation, you have to give us in possession the thing that you are gonna lose if you don't make the cut. I think one dude gave us like the deed to his van or something like that.

[D]

Yeah, yeah, he made it too.

[E]

He made it. And then Wendy gave us the flag

[F]

from her listener Wendy.

[E]

Listener Wendy. I'm sorry. Yes. Listener Wendy gave us the flag from her deceased husband.

[C]

That's right.

[E]

From his funeral.

[C]

We debated that a long time, if we even wanted to get involved in that.

[E]

Yeah, so that's the one we stressed out about and we worried about. But she made it and she was Able to get her flag back.

[C]

And this was Tricia calling in.

[G]

I want to lose 55 to 60 pounds. And I'm going to go with. I'm willing to give you my wedding reign. I've been married 27 years, and my husband worked through two weeks. Working one vacation. Two weeks. And worked straight through his two vacation weeks to pay for the reign. So it's very, very important to me. But I'm willing to do that for the challenge.

[H]

Wow.

[G]

Yes. It means a lot.

[C]

That's risky. That's really risky.

[G]

It is, but I want to do it. I need to do it for my health and for my family.

[E]

I didn't worry about this one. You know, like, if we talked about the one.

[F]

So much time, too.

[E]

She had the longest amount of time.

[C]

Right. And it was such a valuable commodity that we were like, we got this. Let's do it. You know? So her goal was to lose £55 by November 1st.

[E]

Mm.

[C]

So we're not quite there yet.

[G]

That's Sunday.

[C]

So there might be some wiggle room.

[A]

Exactly.

[C]

I just don't know the total.

[A]

Oh, God, I'm gonna be sick.

[C]

Good morning, Trish.

[G]

Good morning.

[E]

How are you?

[G]

I'm okay. Oh, no. It's not good news. It's not good news.

[C]

Is it close?

[G]

I lost 38 pounds.

[E]

That's great.

[A]

That's good.

[G]

And I actually was wanting. I put my target at 50, and I'm not quite there yet.

[E]

So £12 by Sunday.

[C]

£12 by. That's not safe.

[F]

Master Cleanse, do we say November 1st? Or maybe we said the end of November.

[C]

Maybe it was November 1st was the date.

[G]

I was hoping it was the end of November, but I wrote it down in a journal, and it was November 1st.

[C]

So £12 by Monday or. You okay, Jim? Poor little thing.

[E]

She's upset.

[C]

She came in here with a cold. We all sort of like fighting this thing off. All right, so £12 by the first. That's probably not gonna happen.

[G]

No.

[C]

And we still have the ring in our possession.

[F]

Yeah.

[I]

Okay.

[F]

We have it in a.

[C]

What happened? I mean, this was so important to you and all.

[G]

Yes, it is. It's very important. I didn't realize at the time that my husband was as much against it as he is. He felt that I could have done it without making a sacrifice of the reign. That caused stress on the marriage, and then he lost his job. Just. It's just been a downhill thing with me, But I've kept going, and then. I don't know. It's just a lot of Stress, but I haven't given up. I'm losing every week. I've lost something. There was one week, I think I gained 4 ounces and then I went to my Weight Watchers class Tuesday. I lost another four pounds and four more ounces. The four ounces that I'd gained, I lost that. So I'm not giving up. Either way, I'm going to do it. I'm going to reach the go. I just had emailed Tracy and asked if there was any way I could try to get like an extension a little bit longer. And I've had the flu. I can't seem to get rid of it. So that stopped me from being able to go out to the gym as much. And everything just became very stressful. Everything just, it was just a domino effect. Life just got harder and harder and with the stress I was unable to give myself more and more time that I needed to try to reach the goal.

[E]

Well, Natricia, I mean this kind of goes onto the idea about it being a lifestyle more than a diet because it just shows that there's always something that goes on and that weight loss is such a, such a huge obstacle. Have you changed like what in, in this year? Because obviously you've been successful. I mean losing as much weight as you've lost 38 pounds is a lot. So I mean, what have you changed specifically, you know, to that consistently that you will continue to do even after,

[G]

you know, whatever goal is reached, the exercising and just. I've changed all my eating habits. I go to Weight Watchers now. So I've changed all my eating habits completely. And just motivation. I've just tried to motivate myself to keep trying. And like I said, I have to. When I do fall back, I do have to pick myself back up and start over and build myself back up again. But that's been the life change as far as just my eating habits. A lot of times before the diet, I was not ever eating breakfast. I never ate breakfast. And I found out that wasn't good within itself that I should eat something. So I started trying to do that and I had to change a lot of my eating habits.

[C]

You guys need to help us with this. 404-741-Q100. Here's my knee jerk reaction. I've got two knees. Two knee jerk reactions.

[E]

One knee a little better than the other.

[C]

But what's that?

[E]

I said one knee a little better than the other.

[C]

In this case, they're both equally jacked up from a programming standpoint, from a strictly Radio station segment standpoint, if we give in, it's the last time we can ever do this segment.

[E]

Right.

[C]

Because people won't take us seriously. The problem here is that it has worked so successfully with others that when they really want to lose weight, they've lost the weight because they know that we're gonna take away their van, we're gonna take away their stars and stripes. So it's been very, very effective. If, in this case, we don't take the wedding ring, we can never do this again because we'll have no credibility. People don't lose weight. They're really not motivated. And the humanitarian in me is saying, come on, man, give her some more time. Give her some more time.

[A]

End of November.

[C]

But once you do that. But once you do that, end of the segment.

[F]

But I think the fact that she has lost 38 of the 50. 50. The only problem is if. If there's, like with the holidays, like, I'm just. I'm trying to think of the other. And this is. This comes across as a negative word, but I don't mean it in a negative way. I'm trying to think of the other excuses that you can come up with. Like, you say you battle the flu and the stress and everything. So if we did extend it, I mean, we're looking at 10 months. So if we extend it one more month to the end of November, but

[E]

I don't think we can do that.

[C]

And we started this when? Well, 10 months ago is when we started it.

[E]

At the beginning of the year sometime. Yeah.

[C]

You're always going to have stresses.

[E]

Right.

[C]

You know, so that doesn't feel like a viable excuse to me. You're going to get colds. You had 10 months to lose that weight.

[E]

You know, so it's. It what it. So we take the ring and the engagement ring, and we can do whatever we want to with it. Correct. Because the only loophole I can find, humanitarian loophole that I can find, is that we take it, but we give it to her husband. I mean, it's a loophole.

[C]

It's still just saying.

[F]

Yeah, but then it's the same thing that Bird says. The thing's killed. I got one of them Cash for gold envelopes on my desk.

[G]

Oh, no.

[D]

I know. I missed a lot of it with my coughing fit in the hallway, but

[C]

she's had 10 months to lose all this weight. She did lose 38 pounds.

[D]

She's a total win.

[C]

She needed to win.

[F]

Her goal was 50.

[D]

It's hard to do. And I'm impressed That she stuck with it that far. I say we give her through the end of the year.

[F]

The end of the year?

[D]

Yeah.

[A]

I say end of November.

[D]

It was a New Year's resolution. I say we give her through the end of the year. Melissa going into 2010, it's a different story. That's what I say.

[E]

Yeah. I mean, I stick with. You know, the only thing I can think of is what I said, because I think that if we extend the deadline, we do, we lose our credibility. We can't ever say, oh, well, you know, we can do this again and say we're going to stick to it. Because then. Because I think this just shows the problem with dieting. It just shows the problem that everybody struggles with. I think this is a. Trish is a realistic case where it is just a struggle to. To keep weight off if you're not in a certain lifestyle. But I'm also curious what Wendy and the guy and Burchau listener. Wendy and the owner of the van. I apologize, I forgot his name, but. And they're feeling on it.

[F]

Good point.

[C]

Here is Trisha's niece, Janet. Hey, Janet.

[G]

Hey.

[C]

Hey. You're calling to say keep the ring, right? Don't give it back?

[H]

No, I am not calling to say keep the ring. I'm gonna tell you right now, there is not a woman in the world who loves, adores, and worships her husband more than my aunt Trisha does. And Trisha's my aunt by marriage, and she loves my uncle unconditionally. They have been through so many struggles through life. They have just been. Y' all can't keep the rings. I'll make a deal with you to win the rings back from you. Whatever. Y' all can't take her rings. I will do what I have to do. Y' all make some kind of bet, some kind of deal with me to get her rings back, because I can't sit back and let that happen.

[F]

Well, you need to lose £50.

[H]

If I lose £50, there won't be much of me left. I mean, seriously, 38 pounds, that is a feat within itself for anybody.

[D]

I agree.

[C]

That is impressive, for sure.

[H]

And I'm telling you, you couldn't find a more awesome, better person than the one that you're talking to and that you made this deal with. And I know that she has tried with every ounce of her heart and soul to do this, because I know what kind of person she is.

[E]

I mean.

[C]

I mean, what do you say to that?

[E]

I mean, there's. Yeah. And I appreciate that.

[F]

Not even her niece.

[E]

You know, it's just. It just makes me wonder about this whole concept of doing this because it. We will always have someone who doesn't make a goal and always have reasons, and it'll always be gut wrenching, and they will always, you know, make the effort.

[C]

So basically what we're saying is if we give the ring back, we'll all agree that we're not doing this segment.

[E]

We're not doing it anymore. Yeah.

[C]

Which. I mean, that's what we got to do. That's what we got to do. Hey, Rosie, good morning. You're on Q100.

[H]

Good morning. How are you?

[C]

Good. How are you?

[H]

Good. I wanted to call in because I have an idea, a way that she could earn the. But it might be a more fair way to keep doing the program.

[E]

Okay.

[H]

My idea is go ahead and give her an extension through the end of the year. But instead of just saying you have to lose 50 pounds, up it to 60. Because originally when she called in, she said she wanted to lose 55 to

[E]

60, you just renegotiate the deal.

[D]

But I don't know if that's healthy to lose that much weight that fast.

[F]

Yeah. And then what do we do in 30 days when she's. When she hasn't lost? That we play the game again.

[C]

Yeah. I mean, it would be. If we extend it, it would. We potentially could be just doing the same thing over and over and over again.

[F]

I know how. It's a win. Win.

[C]

Jeff has got it. Here he comes. I saw the light bulb go off.

[F]

Here's what we gotta do.

[D]

The angels are all around you.

[F]

This is gonna take care of our listener. What's her name?

[E]

We'll find out today.

[C]

Trisha.

[F]

Trisha is gonna take care of Trisha and her weepy niece and the hell now niece's got her back and allow us to do it again.

[E]

Okay.

[F]

Whatever we do, we come up with a way for her to get the ring back, lose five more pounds or give it to her tomorrow or whatever. She's got the ring back. Right. And we do it again next year. But we don't hold the property. We hold it. We'll still lock it in the same safe deposit box that it's locked in right now. But we come up with a panel of people who are the ones who make the decision on whether or not it gets returned.

[C]

But still, then there's wiggle room. Then you're doing the motivation. Humiliation. But you're still saying in the back of your mind, well, even if I Don't make it. I can still go in front of the panel.

[F]

And it's not our decision, though. Like, the panel could just pick three random people, and then they could be tartasses. They could go, yep, we're not giving it back, and there's nothing we can do. And we'll sign a document. Those signed documents mean business. And we'll have it notarized.

[A]

Ooh, that stamp means so much more.

[F]

Yeah.

[C]

Hey, good morning, Brandon. You are on Q100.

[I]

Hi. Hey. How you doing?

[C]

Okay. How are you?

[I]

I'm pretty good. Just trying to spray these lines.

[C]

Trying to what?

[I]

Trying to spray the lines. I'm a turf specialist, so I'm spraying lines this morning.

[F]

I thought that was slang for something, but you literally are spraying lines.

[G]

That's awesome.

[I]

Yeah, pre emergence is the big thing.

[C]

What's your take?

[I]

Actually, I told the young lady that I didn't want to get on the air, But I lost £100 in 10 months, and I didn't put anything on the line. So when you put something on the line, especially something like a wedding ring, that should already give you the incentive to lose what you're supposed to lose. So I'm saying it's very possible to lose 50 pounds in 10 months.

[C]

So if you were on this panel, you'd say, keep the ring.

[D]

I.

[I]

No, I can't say that because I'm a humanitarian like you guys. So I don't know that the lady that caught a minute ago with the idea, I mean, that's possible. Add something on. Give her a little bit more of a chance.

[D]

I do think it's harder for men to understand because it is easier for men to lose weight. I mean, physically, even. Doctors will tell you that men can shed the pounds really, really quickly. And my new favorite show is Dr. Oz, and he was talking about it last week how women have a certain percentage more body fat than men do. Just period. We just do. And he was explaining it, and that's why we have to pee more often, because there's more weight sitting on our bladders than there is for. But I really do think that our bodies are very different, so I have more compassion for Trish.

[C]

Trish, Trish, Trish. I would also say this, like, if you only lost 12 pounds, then I wouldn't feel bad about keeping the ring. But you've lost 38. That's an impressive and impressive number. You must have busted your butt in some ways to get to that weight loss, because that's really impressive, and it

[D]

could have been probably easily 40. If you just sweat a whole bunch and got rid of some of the water weight, be 40 pounds. So you're really 10 pounds off.

[E]

I'm just.

[D]

I need to be.

[E]

I don't want to extend it anymore. If we're going to give the ring back, just give the ring back. Let's not renegotiate or extend it or whatever. We just have to redefine how we do it next time.

[C]

Is that what we're all agreeing on?

[A]

Yeah, I got. I want to give the ring back. An extension or something.

[C]

It's a stupid radio segment. We got plenty of material. What? So what if we never do it again? We never do it again.

[E]

But at least.

[C]

You lost 38 pounds.

[E]

You lost 38 pounds.

[A]

That's fantastic.

[D]

But I would like to follow up and see if she can do the 50 by the end of the year. I mean, Tricia, do you want to keep going?

[G]

Yes, I'm gonna keep going.

[F]

What if we use like one of our new plastic butter knives and pry a couple of the stones out of there to give the ring back? We keep some of the stones.

[C]

Trisha, if you want your ring back, go ahead. I mean, you lost 38 pounds. You didn't reach the goal. But there's no way in good conscience we can keep that ring. So come get your ring. And you did great. 38 pounds is fantastic.

[G]

Thank you. I appreciate it. Okay.

[C]

Don't feel bad about it. You lost 38 pounds.

[E]

You did not fail.

[C]

Okay. You lost 38 pounds.

[G]

And Bert, Jeff, that was my niece. I do have a niece named Janet on my husband's side of the family.

[C]

Oh, yeah, you can't muster up that kind of crime

[D]

related. No.

[C]

Right. All right, so I'll put you on hold and we'll get the ring back in your hands, okay?

[G]

Okay. Thank you so much.

[C]

Sure. I mean, and we sacrifice a segment.

[I]

Big deal.

[E]

I mean, our barks were sent, our

[C]

bite the bird show.