
Loading summary
Bobby Bones
This is an iHeart podcast.
Matt Castle
Lots to say with Bobby Bones and Matt Castle is a production of the NFL and iHeart podcasts. We got lots to say. We got lots to say? We're glad you're here and we hope you stay. Cause we got lots to say. Yeah, we got lots to say. Now here's Bobby and Mat. What's happening, everybody? Welcome to the podcast. It's Fourth of July week. What are you guys doing?
Bobby Bones
I don't know yet. No, we were talking about maybe going up to Montana.
Matt Castle
Is that a maybe?
Bobby Bones
That's a maybe.
Matt Castle
That's a big, like. That's quite the declaration for it to be a maybe we're going to Montana.
Bobby Bones
Might be going, but more than likely we're staying here. More than likely.
Matt Castle
What's in Montana?
Bobby Bones
Just we've got a place up there in Darby, Montana.
Matt Castle
Dang. That's cool.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, it's cool.
Matt Castle
What's it look like when you walk out the front door of your place?
Bobby Bones
You look down over this valley and it's majestic and it's God's country up there, man. We're right by the Bitterroot National Force is right behind us. But the Bitterroot river runs down. Fly fishing, you know, lake life, it's. It's wonderful.
Matt Castle
Wish I'd have been a pro athlete.
Kevin
Ever run it out?
Bobby Bones
Huh?
Kevin
You guys ever rented out? Just asking for a guy.
Bobby Bones
You know what? It's interesting because the only time we've rented out it's when Yellowstone filmed up there.
Kevin
Oh.
Bobby Bones
And so I never thought anybody was going to rent this house a million years. Right. It's an hour, hour and a half south drive from Missoula is where you normally fly into. And then there's Hamilton is the biggest city close to us. But all of a sudden found out Yellowstone started to film up there, and so they asked if they could rent the house. I was like, yes, that's awesome. That's great. Because we're not there a lot at all.
Matt Castle
Kevin Costner slept in this bed. There's a sign in one of the rooms.
Bobby Bones
Never wash the sheets.
Matt Castle
Yes. We just basically make sure the dogs don't freak out. They go crazy if I think aliens are invading.
Bobby Bones
Oh. Because they're schizophrenic.
Matt Castle
And I've done it all. I've given them all the medicine. We've put the thunder shirts. We've done thunder thong everything. I put one on myself.
Bobby Bones
What is it? A thunder thong?
Matt Castle
Yeah. I wear that. Yeah. Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Let's get naughty. July 4th, baby.
Matt Castle
Like, we don't do anything because the dogs freak out so much, but hope everybody has a good fourth of July. Now, we got a couple things we're going to do here. We're going to get into conspiracy theories and sports, which I love conspiracy theories. We're also going to talk about the NFC east. And over the last month or so, we've been talking about the greatest of all time per each NFL team. And so we did it week by week, but we put it all together. So it's going to be all frigging 46 minutes of goat talk as well. So all that's here. Let's start now with the conspiracy theories. I love sports conspiracy theories.
Bobby Bones
I know you do.
Matt Castle
I love just conspiracy theories. There's a new one, by the way. So forever it was birds aren't real. And they weren't saying all birds, but they were saying a lot of birds were surveillance. And people were going, dang, that's crazy. Then all of a sudden at the tech show, you see these really good fake birds that you can now buy yourself that are basically drones. And you're going, well, if the public's now offered them, that means government's had them for 20 years. So there was something to that theory.
Bobby Bones
I'm sure there is.
Matt Castle
The new one is trees aren't real.
Bobby Bones
Well, a bunch of them that are going down on my property, I promise you they're real because I've been cutting them up and it's a taxing, taxing thing to do.
Matt Castle
You better watch out. You know you're going to cut in one of those. It's going to timber and there's going to be wires all in it.
Bobby Bones
Oh, they're just watching everything.
Matt Castle
Because then that's my new, like, fun one is that not all trees are real. Because you think about it, when you drive into a neighborhood, they're only putting in one type of tree. Now, they look exactly the same. Oh, what are they doing? Why are they watching this?
Bobby Bones
Pretty rich here in Tennessee with a lot of diverse groups of trees. You know, you can just never know. Just maybe it's a boxwood too.
Matt Castle
And people surveillance think you were crazy if you said jfk. It's not just a single shooter. Now the CA has basically said, yeah, you're right, it wasn't just a single shooter. So. But I have sports conspiracy theories.
Bobby Bones
Okay, that's probably less intense.
Matt Castle
Yeah. And we've done some of these a bit. But at number 10 on the list from Watchmojo is Sonny Liston and the Phantom Punch. Now to do A little research into this one. In 1965, the heavily promoted heavyweight bout between Sonny Liston and Muhammad Ali took place. Do you know about the. The phantom punch? Because I did not know this at all. The match was extremely disappointing because Ali knocked Liston out within minutes. People.
Bobby Bones
And listen, was the world the heavyweight champion at the time and was known as like, a complete badass.
Matt Castle
Many people started saying that can't be real. And a large percentage of those in attendance didn't see Ali punch Liston. And those who did claim the punch that saw it claim the punch wasn't powerful enough. So then it was okay. That didn't happen as we were told.
Bobby Bones
They were saying people at the actual boxing match said they didn't see the punch.
Matt Castle
They said they didn't see the punch in person. Like television saw the punch, meaning it was shot from an angle and that it wasn't thrown that hard.
Bobby Bones
Right. Well, back then also, you could smoke inside, so there's probably a bunch of smoke and they're just sitting there with a cocktail in hand. And like very much, oh my gosh, no, that didn't look hard.
Matt Castle
And they're asbestos T shirts. Like everything Number nine is.
Bobby Bones
So the conspiracy theory is that Sonny threw the fight.
Matt Castle
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Do you think that that's true? Because he, he. When you look at some of these documentaries about Ali and Sonny Liston and all that stuff, he had ties to the mob.
Matt Castle
I think. I think Tyler Herro said it best. Anything from 1950 on? I don't believe. No, before 1950.
Bobby Bones
Before.
Kevin
Okay, yeah. I was like, wait, we're in there now?
Matt Castle
Well, Tyler hero got into a bunch of crap because, like, I don't believe in history. It's over 50 years old. I believe is what he said. I don't believe it. And what he meant was we're fed narratives more than we're fed history. Just generally speaking, we're fed narratives. And also when you look at the 100 point game, basketball game, there's no footage of that. It's just him holding up a piece of paper. Like, there's all this history we've accepted because we've been told, because it's before we were born. It wasn't documented. It's narrative more than it is truth. And there are so many mobile mafia.
Bobby Bones
Like ties and conspiracy theories.
Matt Castle
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
What they were involved in for sure.
Matt Castle
Like criminal operations, especially in boxing, which was so crooked. You think it's crooked now?
Bobby Bones
Horse racing?
Matt Castle
Yes.
Bobby Bones
Everything.
Kevin
All of it.
Matt Castle
So this one specifically, I don't know, but probably because it all seemed to be crooked back then.
Bobby Bones
Yeah. But then you go and you watch Ali and he destroys everybody.
Matt Castle
It's like Mike Tyson. I don't think anybody had to throw a fight to Mike Tyson. Mike Tyson just killed everybody.
Kevin
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Yes. Until Buster Douglas.
Matt Castle
Until Buster Douglas got him. I know Kurt Schelling faked his bloody sock for drama is one of the theories.
Bobby Bones
Gosh, that would be a bold thing to do, wouldn't it? Like game. What Was that game?
Kevin
6.
Bobby Bones
6. And he pitched lights out too.
Matt Castle
Yeah, he did. And so we got two Boston guys, sort of. You're a half Boston guy. You're a half Boston.
Bobby Bones
Yeah.
Matt Castle
Together you got one full Boston guy.
Kevin
Perfect.
Bobby Bones
I don' think. I don't think he did it.
Matt Castle
So 2.
Bobby Bones
It wasn't fake.
Matt Castle
ALCS. We remember the bloody sock. Boston was down a game to the Yankees. Shilling throws his brains out. He was pitching on an injured and bloody ankle. However, due to the popularity of the story, theory soon began to arise that Shilling was putting ketchup or paint on his sock in between innings. So it looked more dramatic.
Bobby Bones
No way. No way.
Matt Castle
I don't believe that.
Bobby Bones
I don't believe that. Number eight, ketchup and mustard.
Matt Castle
No, just ketchup. Not mustard.
Kevin
Relish.
Bobby Bones
Relish. What else? Get the dogs out.
Matt Castle
Jimmy Hoff is buried at Giant Stadium.
Bobby Bones
That. That could be true.
Matt Castle
Definitely could.
Bobby Bones
That could definitely be true.
Matt Castle
They never found his body.
Bobby Bones
Never found it.
Matt Castle
It could be anywhere.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, that's a tough one.
Matt Castle
The story of Jimmy Hoffa, a union leader who disappeared in 75. He was declared legally dead in 82. Cuz they never found his body. His disappearance coincided nicely with the construction of the Giant stadium, which broke ground in 72 and officially opened in 76. The idea was on Mythbusters and they say there's no evidence of human remains, but I don't know that you can ever be certain. Whenever it comes to a spot that big and having to dig underneath all of it because they didn't. They didn't dig underneath all of it.
Bobby Bones
Right.
Matt Castle
But they were just like, there's no evidence.
Bobby Bones
I'm just going to go with that could be.
Matt Castle
Yeah, I'm with you.
Bobby Bones
With. And then there are 50 other sites. It could be true. At 2.
Matt Castle
Doc Ellis pitched a no hitter on acid. I think he admitted to this.
Bobby Bones
Yes, he did admit to this, right?
Matt Castle
Yeah, I think he did. He was an A, right?
Bobby Bones
Oh, had to be one weird trippy outing. Like just full on dealing like kind of floating. Fans are out there, a lot of weird faces. Probably not that I've ever taken acid, let me just put it that way.
Matt Castle
But I've heard, I've seen him talking about it, I think on TikTok, and he said he didn't, he didn't remember he had a game to play and he was like with a woman the night before and had taken.
Bobby Bones
Did he not remember it the next day when he woke up or something like that?
Matt Castle
Many witnesses and associates claim he wasn't high. Ellis's teammates didn't notice anything off. Meanwhile, in his 76 biography, he claimed he'd been drinking vodka, not freaking out on lsd. But now he's the guy who probably pitched a no hitter on lsd, regardless whether or not it's true. I just think now, I think if you look it up, he's admitted it's been. It's true.
Bobby Bones
That would be great for us because we both said, I think he admitted it. He's like, no, would you search vodka sodas? Not a big deal.
Matt Castle
A crazy one was Delonte west and him hooking up with LeBron's mom. Do you guys remember that one?
Bobby Bones
Oh, yeah, he hooked up with LeBron's mother.
Matt Castle
So many blamed LeBron's uncharacteristically bad performance for the Cavs losing to the Celtics in 2010. And they, they, they blamed a lot of different things. But the one thing that it kept coming back to was that LeBron caught his teammate, Dante west sleeping with his mom.
Bobby Bones
Man, that would really upset me.
Matt Castle
Reputable websites published a story. It soon became widespread Internet gossip. The story was further fueled when James moved to Florida soon after when he went to play for the Heat, supposedly to get away from west and his mom. And it's completely unproven.
Kevin
That was fun.
Bobby Bones
That's real.
Matt Castle
People started saying that stuff.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, people create these.
Kevin
And that was before social media where it's like you believed it. What do you say about Doc Ellis? Yeah, he admitted to it in 1984. He said to the Pittsburgh Press that he pitched on acid.
Matt Castle
Wonder why that's still listed as a conspiracy theory? Because Matt and I both are like, yeah, I would think, yeah, that could.
Bobby Bones
Definitely happen in 84.
Matt Castle
The next one, Back to the Future Part 2, predicted the 1997 World Series. And this is basically him saying that Miami wins the World Series, except Miami didn't have a team.
Bobby Bones
That's pretty impressive.
Matt Castle
Yeah. And there's. Now people are like, no, it's the Cubs. No, it was the end. But regardless, in the Biff timeline, he sees that Miami wins the World Series. But Miami did not have a team in 1997, whenever Back to the Future Part 2 aired.
Bobby Bones
Wow. We gotta get that book. Remember it wasn't it. Biff stole the book.
Matt Castle
The almanac.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, the almanac.
Matt Castle
Kevin Costner was discovered with Cal Ripkin Jr's wife. I've heard this one a lot.
Bobby Bones
Oh, I've heard this one as well.
Matt Castle
In September 1995, the Baltimore Orioles Cal Ripkin Jr. Broke the baseball record for consecutive games played. 21, 31. That streak continued until 1998. However, according to the Internet, this streak almost ended. One year earlier, per the rumor, Ripken found actor Kevin Costner in bed with his wife. And after beating Costner up for the offense, he decided not to play that night. And his streak would have ended. But the Orioles sabotaged the stadium lights and had the game postponed.
Kevin
I've never heard that.
Bobby Bones
Oh, yeah, all the lights are on the story.
Matt Castle
Yeah, it says the story's false, but of course they would say the story is false.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, they're not gonna admit to that.
Matt Castle
All the lights went out.
Kevin
Dang.
Bobby Bones
Hey, bro, can we just get over. I know you're going through some tough stuff, but we're just going to shut off the lights tonight. Can you come back tomorrow though?
Matt Castle
Yeah, yeah.
Bobby Bones
Let's keep this streak alive, bro.
Matt Castle
1985 draft was rigged. NBA. We talked about that. Yes, we have the envelopes.
Bobby Bones
We thought. I mean really, for sure. Sophisticated way and amazing.
Matt Castle
Yeah. Great job.
Bobby Bones
Good for you.
Matt Castle
Yeah, I believe that one. I think that one was true. Michael Jordan's gambling ban play baseball. I believe that one.
Bobby Bones
I believe that one.
Matt Castle
He still takes away like he's like, you know what? I'm going go play minor league baseball right in my prime.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, I'm going to go grind it out in the minor leagues. It's going to be amazing.
Matt Castle
Birmingham barons Chicago number one's Will Chamberlain had sex with 20,000 women. He wrote that in his book.
Bobby Bones
Oh, did he really? So that's not even a conspiracy series. That's a.
Matt Castle
It's. Do you believe that A boy. Yeah. He said that he had sex with over 20,000 women. In his book called A View from above, he based the math off a 10 day period when he slept with 23 women or 2.3 women per day. Then he conservatively cut the number to two, multiplied by how old he was, subtracted 15 years. 20,000 women.
Bobby Bones
Man, that guy was in shape.
Kevin
I don't know if I'd.
Matt Castle
If that's true, he's probably all of our grandpa in some way.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, maybe there's a lot of height out there.
Matt Castle
Our 23andMe all gets back up to Wilt Chamberlain.
Kevin
Somehow there's a Wilt in all of us.
Bobby Bones
Five degrees of separation.
Matt Castle
It's like it tells you what country you're from. It's like you're from Ireland, you're from England, you're from Wilt.
Bobby Bones
One person that never wilted was Wilt.
Matt Castle
Yeah, there you go. Hey, let's talk about the NFC east for a second.
Bobby Bones
Okay.
Matt Castle
I think that is always America's favorite division for a couple reasons. One, because people either want to see the Cowboys win or the Cowboys lose.
Bobby Bones
I mean, there is something to that for sure, because they are one of those polarizing franchises that everybody watches and tunes in. And I think that there's a lot of fans out there that just like.
Matt Castle
To see them lose because they're called America's Team. And are they America's Team?
Bobby Bones
Well, they haven't won a Super bowl since the 90s, so. But it's. I mean, what would Great promotion.
Matt Castle
What would America's Team be right now? Let's say that name was not slapped on any team whatsoever. What would you say is America's Team? Would you say it's the Chiefs because they're Middle America? They really aren't villains, except for the fact that they've won. People just don't like people.
Bobby Bones
They vilify. They vilify winners in the NFL. There's no doubt about that.
Matt Castle
I feel like that's the only reason that people don't like the Chiefs is because they've won. They get the calls right.
Bobby Bones
But this is a franchise that dominates year in, year out. How many Super Bowls have they been to in the last.
Kevin
Three in a row?
Bobby Bones
Three in a row. They've won three out of the last four Super. I mean, five Super Bowls. Is that correct?
Kevin
Sounds about right.
Bobby Bones
Sounds about right.
Matt Castle
We're guesstimating. It's Fourth of July week. We're tired.
Bobby Bones
Sorry, guys. We're tired. Yeah. Anyway, this is a dynasty, so I'd say Chiefs are absolutely America's team right now.
Matt Castle
If that tag did not go, I would. I'd say. Are you going to say the Patriots, Kevin?
Kevin
Of course I would have their helmets, their name?
Bobby Bones
Yes.
Matt Castle
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
That's patriotic.
Matt Castle
Okay. What about the Eagles? That's America's official bird.
Bobby Bones
But you don't say bald Eagles.
Kevin
You say, I'm patriotic. I'm a patriotic American. Not I'm an Eagle list.
Matt Castle
But the thing about an Eagle is it's literally America's bird, if we're using your logic.
Kevin
Yeah, but a patriotism is a patriot.
Matt Castle
What about the Albany apple pie years?
Kevin
Those are cool too.
Bobby Bones
Yeah. For 20 years, there's no doubt the Patriots and their run was America's team.
Matt Castle
No, I would. And I. I rooted for the Patriots because I just like to see greatness. I like to see sustained greatness. But I would argue that because of all the scandals.
Bobby Bones
Oh, yeah, they did have a few, didn't they?
Matt Castle
That kept them from being the team that could be universally liked. Except for people were hating because they won Deflate Gate, which was stupid. It was stupid. So I'm gonna say that. Yes, but because deflate Gate happened and that narrative was able to be put against. And then Spygate, which was not stupid.
Bobby Bones
Spygate was before.
Matt Castle
Yeah, it was not. It was probably true.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, probably true.
Kevin
They're just stupid for getting caught. Yeah, everybody was doing it.
Matt Castle
But even like. Even like McDaniels, Josh McDaniels, he won. And then they got caught and then he stopped winning. And where do you think he learned how to do that crap?
Bobby Bones
Oh, yeah. You're saying when he went to Denver and they got hit with it. The same thing.
Matt Castle
Yes. And then he stopped. So Spygate was real. Deflategate was not. But both were real because Deflategate only was bad because Spygate happened.
Bobby Bones
That's exactly right.
Matt Castle
If Spygate doesn't happen to flake Gates. Not a real thing.
Bobby Bones
Well, also the simple fact that they switched all the balls out at halftime because they said, oh, well, it's not this or the other. And Brady threw for more yardage in the second half with the balls that they switched it out and it was.
Kevin
Like 42 to 7.
Bobby Bones
Exactly. It wasn't even close.
Matt Castle
So that's why the Patriots could never have been America's team. And I rooted for the Patriots.
Bobby Bones
Okay, but in every good American story, there's a scandal.
Matt Castle
I don't think so. Yeah, you don't get to be it because you named yourself. That's like giving yourself your own nickname.
Bobby Bones
I mean, they are named. The Patriots is pretty Patriots.
Matt Castle
But they named name themselves that. You can't give yourself your own nickname and then call yourself America.
Kevin
But then like, remember the dynasty started in a one. The whole, you know, 911 thing and all that. I mean, it's like a story.
Matt Castle
It's.
Kevin
I mean, this is America in like one 20 year, 100.
Bobby Bones
They overcame all odds. Backup quarterback comes in.
Matt Castle
So if the Louisville Liberty Bells are announced.
Kevin
Third street quarterback.
Bobby Bones
Third Street.
Matt Castle
Okay. NFC East, NFC East. If you were to position them right now, one through four, do it.
Bobby Bones
Ooh, one through four.
Matt Castle
Because I think you'd have to go Eagles at one again. Right. They're coming off.
Bobby Bones
Absolutely.
Matt Castle
They didn't lose.
Bobby Bones
I go Eagles. Eagles at one. Because they're just returning so much of that same team that they had from last year. Now, they lost some talent on the defensive side of the ball, but at the end of the day, it's hard not to go. Eagles number one. Number two. I do like the commanders.
Matt Castle
Yeah. I mean, they, they.
Bobby Bones
Jaden Daniels.
Matt Castle
They did win a playoff game.
Bobby Bones
Yeah. And they went out. They won two playoff games. They went to the NFC Championship game.
Matt Castle
But just winning a playoff game, I feel like, is like popping at you. Maybe that's not the term I should use.
Bobby Bones
Yeah.
Matt Castle
If you just win a playoff game, it's like you're now in a different league. So, yes, they did. He did win with a rookie.
Bobby Bones
With a rookie quarterback who is just continue. Is going to continue to elevate. They went out and got Debo Samuel from the 49ers. I mean, they've got a good collection of talent. They've got a good offensive line, running backs and defensive side of the ball. I just think that this is an organization that's going to. If they take the next step this year, they're going to be really hard to beat.
Matt Castle
Do you think both of those teams, again, are playoff teams?
Bobby Bones
I do.
Matt Castle
Okay. And do you think the Cowboys are a playoff team? Are you putting them at three or the Giants at three?
Bobby Bones
I'm putting. I'm putting the Cowboys at three. Now, I could make an argument for the Cowboys at two, but I'm going to put them at three. Pickens comes in next to CD Lamb. You've got your quarterback healthy again with Dak. So there's also some moving parts there with the new head coach with Brian Schottenheimer. So you don't know how that is all going to play itself out, but at the same time, they are super talented and they're a really good team. So I'm going to put them at three and then the Giants at four.
Matt Castle
Yeah, the Giants are going to struggle. I feel like the Giants have too many quarterbacks.
Bobby Bones
They've got a lot. Russell Wilson, James Jackson, dart, who's going to play? And then at what point is there the controversy that takes place? Because, you know, if they're going to start the veteran, which I'd love to see Jackson get, the ability to sit there, learn how to be a true professional and understand what the NFL game is instead of just being thrown immediately into the fire. But at some point when that organization is struggling in mid season, they're going to make that switch. And that's always a major transition for the locker room for the team itself. But hopefully it works out because I do think that they're talented on the defensive side of the ball and they've got some talent on the offensive side of the ball. It's just whether or not that Jackson Darter, whoever's playing quarterback, is going to perform up to a level or standard that's going to get them wins.
Matt Castle
I think that quarterback situation is weird because you have two veteran quarterbacks. So Russell Wilson will probably start, right? Jackson Dart should probably be the number two regardless because he should get second team snaps. He is a rookie. They're invested heavily in him. And then you have Jameis Winston, who they could probably get some assets for, especially to a team again like the Saints, who could use a quarterback right now, right?
Bobby Bones
They're in a position where if a team has an injury early in the season, which you always see to the quarterback position, that they have trade value in that room right now, whether it's Russell, whether it's Jameis, they're obviously not trading Jackson Dart, but they have one of those two guys that they can use as trade bait and maybe pick up some value going into the next year's draft. So it'll be interesting to see how that goes because those veteran quarterbacks, there's not a ton of them with that type of experience that are just out there on the street in the middle of the season. So they'll have an opportunity, if it presents itself, to maybe trade one of those guys.
Matt Castle
But what are the Cowboys? What are they done to get better? They. Except add Pickens as a receiver. And I would say with Schottheimer as the coach, they really haven't made substantial changes to the coaching staff. It wasn't like they had to do a, you know, bring in the Zamboni and flatten it all out because Scheimer, they just elevated, right?
Bobby Bones
They elevated. They have familiarity with the staff. I'm sure a lot of those guys that they retained, I think that they had a pretty decent draft, so to speak, so. But you never know. With rookie classes, it usually takes one or two years to really understand what the product's going to be on the field with and how that rookie class comes together as a whole. But Pickens, I think is a really big pickup for them because they had CD Lamb but when you have just one guy out there and you don't have to worry about anybody else, they can double him, shift the defense to him, top him with a safety and a corner. So having a guy like Pickens, who's another one one, a type wide receiver, that's going to make some very difficult decisions for the defensive side of the ball.
Matt Castle
I feel like the Cowboys need a running back. They have five third string running backs.
Bobby Bones
Yep.
Matt Castle
And. But that was last year too. I mean when you pick Zeke back up, like what was Zeke doing delivering Amazon? They're like, Zeke, come on Zeke, we.
Bobby Bones
Just need you, buddy.
Matt Castle
Was he delivering Amazon to the facility? They're like, Zeke, just stay. Just stay. So yeah, I think it's. I'm with you. I think it's the Cowboys at three and the Giants at four. I don't see how the Giants win a bunch of games. If the Giants don't win games. Do you think they draft another quarterback? I mean Darwin Dart was a second round quarterback, right?
Kevin
He moved back up.
Matt Castle
They moved back up for him. That's right.
Bobby Bones
That's right.
Matt Castle
I mean if they suck, do they draft another quarterback at a class when the quarterbacks are better next year than they were this last year?
Bobby Bones
There definitely would have to entertain it. But I don't know if this same regime with Brian Dabel and the GM are going to be making that decision if they just go out and completely lay an egg this year or if they're going to give him another year with Jackson Dart. And it probably depends on how Jackson Dart plays when he gets the opportunity to go in and play. Because if he shows promise and they start winning games, then there's hope. If they go out there and the team kind of starts to give up because you never know what's going to happen. Look, if they go out and they're a 500 team this year, I think that that's a successful season. I don't know if they can go much further beyond that. But if they go out and they're five and whatever, then I don't know if that they're going to keep the current coaching staff in play.
Matt Castle
Goats from each team through history. We don't have to do every team today, but we could do some of them. And I thought we'd just go alphabetical and do.
Bobby Bones
Hopefully you've written all these down.
Matt Castle
I do, yeah. I have them alphabetical order now. I've spent no time thinking about any of them except for the one we talked about which was first up alphabetically, which Was Arizona, which we talked about before we came on. That's it. So I haven't done any research, but I think it's the best place to come from.
Bobby Bones
Yes, it's the best place. And I haven't either because I literally.
Matt Castle
Well, when I texted you we were going to do this, I just thought of it.
Bobby Bones
I like it.
Matt Castle
So about the same time?
Bobby Bones
Yeah, about the same time.
Matt Castle
Okay, let's go. Goat of the Arizona Cardinals. We'll take turns going first.
Bobby Bones
Okay. There's two that come to mind, both offensive players. But I have to go with Larry Fitzgerald.
Matt Castle
Me, too.
Bobby Bones
I mean, he's.
Matt Castle
I was really.
Bobby Bones
He is.
Matt Castle
I was drawn to Kurt Warner at first.
Bobby Bones
I was, too, but he was only. He was there for a significant period of time, but not. I mean, would Larry play 18 years?
Matt Castle
Yeah. And I think quarterback is often where our brains go because that's the face of the franchise for sure. So we agree?
Bobby Bones
We agree. I mean, it's. It's hard to argue that one.
Matt Castle
Falcons. Atlanta Falcons. We're standing the A's.
Bobby Bones
How long was Deion there for?
Matt Castle
I don't have the answer to your question because I didn't research this. Kevin. I bet Kevin could tell us, but now you're gonna lean. I. I don't think I would.
Bobby Bones
Cons Michael Vick. I mean, Michael Vick is legendary, obviously.
Matt Castle
Five years.
Kevin
Five years.
Matt Castle
Okay. I know who I have.
Bobby Bones
You know who you have?
Matt Castle
Yeah, I have. Do you have yours locked in? Because I don't want us changing each other's minds. We can agree we were wrong, but I don't want us changing each other's minds.
Bobby Bones
All right. For me, the first thing that comes to mind is Michael Vick.
Matt Castle
I have Matt Ryan.
Bobby Bones
Oh, good call.
Matt Castle
I think both, though, are arguably correct, because Matt Ryan won more. Michael Vick brought more eyeballs to the team.
Bobby Bones
Right. He's such a polarizing figure. And when he came in, he. He played the position unlike any other quarterback to ever play the position. And just his skill set and elite athleticism was just remarkable to watch.
Matt Castle
And I don't know why I'm fighting for yours. I should just fight for mine.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, now you gotta fight for yours.
Matt Castle
Yeah. No, I just think. I mean, other than losing this 23.
Bobby Bones
Oh, my gosh, I can't believe he.
Matt Castle
Won an MVP, too.
Kevin
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, he's an absolute.
Matt Castle
But I definitely. If someone argued Mike Vick, I can't say you're wrong, because he brought more eyeballs. I mean, he was the guy that TV commercials wanted, right? Matt Ryan. Really, wasn't he?
Bobby Bones
He was a different type of personality. But you talk about a professional in every sense of the world. Word. And a guy that could come out and perform on Sundays. Matt Ryan was as consistent of a quarterback in the NFL as anybody.
Matt Castle
Let's go to Bees. Baltimore. The Ravens.
Bobby Bones
Oh, Baltimore Ravens.
Matt Castle
I'm going to write my down since you're going first. Oh, I'm torn between two.
Bobby Bones
I got one.
Matt Castle
We probably.
Bobby Bones
I mean it's. There's two guys I think of and I think that you're going to lean one way. I'm going to go with Ed Reed.
Matt Castle
Ed Reed is my second. But we had the same too.
Bobby Bones
Yes, 100%. Ray Lewis, Ed Reed. That defense, what was it, the 2001 Ravens or 2000 Ravens with the best defense ever?
Matt Castle
You mean the Trent Dilfer Ravens?
Bobby Bones
Trent Dilfer Ravens. Hey, they were an offensive juggernaut, but that defense was real.
Matt Castle
Did you play against Ray?
Bobby Bones
I sure did. And Ed, and they were as advertised.
Matt Castle
I remember you telling us about Ed and how advanced he was. But what was Ray Lewis like? Not to play against, but to look across. Because that's what I think of, like how he must have been so intimidating. But again, that's just television talking to me.
Bobby Bones
No, but it's the intensity which he played the game. And every time you looked across the line of scrimmage, he. He was the guy that was making calls, calling everything out, getting the defense set. But his eyes, when you looked at him, he like stare through your soul. And it was one of those that you knew that you'd have to bring your A game. And then he also was a savvy guy. He's known for coming up and making the big hits. But when he dropped into pass protection, he tried to bait you. He tried to act like he's going one way but fall back in. He was just an all around outstanding player. But in addition to that, it was his leadership qualities that you saw every single game and the intensity in which he played the game made him special.
Matt Castle
Do you think, and this is meant completely complementary, that his cartoon like attributes, meaning when he comes out and he does the stomp coming out of the tunnel and. And Ray Lewis behind the line, do you think that overshadowed how smart of a player he was because he was just seen as the big brute guy who does the big cartoon like movements?
Bobby Bones
I don't believe. So if anybody ever played against him or you can speak to probably any of his teammates, they'd say that that guy brought it each and every day and While. While there's the antics of when he'd come out. But that kind of set the tone for the entire team. Because when you're on defense, your mentality is to go up and deliver violence. And so you've got to come out with a certain energy. And he was the aura of that defense. Right. The way that he played the game. And it started as soon as they did introductions, you knew, okay, we're playing Baltimore today. Because I always remember getting ready for Baltimore. You're like, gosh, they don't have a lot of holes. They're very sophisticated and how the. And complex and the different looks that they give you and the different schemes and the personnel units. So you always. That had to be ready for that. But in addition to that, they had the players to back it up, which made it even more intimidating.
Matt Castle
So he was a real cerebral player, for sure.
Bobby Bones
He'd see things, call things out. Probably not to the extent of like a Luke Keakley, who we've talked about before, but at the same time, he was a guy that played so much football that he'd recognize formation and be able to watch the film and understand what we were trying to get accomplished.
Matt Castle
Buffalo Bills.
Bobby Bones
Buffalo. Jim Kelly.
Matt Castle
See, I would want Bruce Smith not.
Bobby Bones
Hey, he's right up there.
Matt Castle
I think we go quarterback. And Kelly Dillon, before Super Bowls with Bruce Smith also was one of the most dominant defensive players possibly ever. But I would have gone Bruce Smith. You could convince me it was Jim Kelly, though.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, and Thurman Thomas, too, on that team, I mean, was a legendary running back and an absolute stud as well. But I'd have to go with Jim Kelly because even when you go back there and when I was playing, one of the things that make me think Jim Kelly is so after the game, he was like an ambassador. He'd come to the game, sign autographs, do all that. And so we'd come in the tunnel and he'd have a bunch of paps, blue ribbons, a bunch of beers waiting for the quarterbacks. And we go out and he'd spend 25, 30 minutes telling old stories with.
Matt Castle
The quarterbacks of the other team.
Bobby Bones
From the other team, like Brad. Well, let's be honest, he didn't want to hang out with me. He want to hang out with Brady. But. But at the end of the day, he was a guy that was just so cool and authentic, real. And even when I got to Buffalo, one of the cool parts was he brought all the quarterbacks over to his place because he still lived there. And we Went out and shot Skeet, and he had a big barbecue and brought a bunch of people over. And he's just one of those really incredible ambassadors of the game.
Matt Castle
That's cool to hear. Let's do three more. The not alive for long. And compared to the other teams and possibly my favorite new team, the Carolina Panthers.
Bobby Bones
Gosh. Well, you.
Matt Castle
I have mine.
Bobby Bones
I know. Are you going quarterback?
Matt Castle
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Mark Brunell.
Matt Castle
Mark Brunel was more of a jag as a jaguar.
Bobby Bones
Well, who are we talking about?
Matt Castle
Carolina Panthers.
Bobby Bones
Sorry, I take that all back.
Matt Castle
They do.
Bobby Bones
Literally.
Matt Castle
They did exist at the same time. Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Oh, Belhome.
Matt Castle
Oh. I was going Cam Newton.
Bobby Bones
Oh, yeah. What am I talking about? Cam Newton's for sure. The figure of that. I'm sorry.
Matt Castle
I started.
Bobby Bones
He went to a Super bowl, though.
Matt Castle
Cam Newton did, huh?
Bobby Bones
Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'm definitely going Cam Newton.
Matt Castle
Okay, I flipped you on that one.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, sorry. I was all over the map there. Sorry, everybody.
Matt Castle
Two more. The Bears.
Bobby Bones
Bears. Ooh, Butkus.
Matt Castle
Interesting. That's not who I would go with, but I could be convinced. It's just weird to compare offense and defense. And it's also weird to compare eras because it's like how the NBA always fights over who is better. Mostly you just have to compare eras with people in them versus the people in them.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, Walter Payton.
Matt Castle
That's who I have.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, Walter Payton's all time great, for sure. Absolutely incredible. And also watching those videos of him running the hills in the off season, doing all that stuff that he did. He was a special, special player. So, yeah, Walter Payton.
Matt Castle
I was listening to Jeff Pearlman, who wrote a book on Walter Payton, talk about Walter Payton and how he would take the souls out of his shoes and play with soulless shoes because he felt like he could feel the ground better and that it was a little painful, obviously, but he felt like he could feel the ground so much better. And it helped him cut, move, run.
Bobby Bones
Jump, that he played soulless and then run through people.
Matt Castle
Yeah, yeah. Or around or around them. Finally, Cincinnati Bengals.
Bobby Bones
Cincinnati Bengals. Ooh.
Matt Castle
There's about five here that I feel like we could go with, because I feel like, in my opinion, my humble opinion, Cincinnati doesn't have a. A guy.
Bobby Bones
True.
Matt Castle
So I think we should talk this one out as our final one.
Bobby Bones
Okay.
Matt Castle
Well, I think you have to put Boomer. Boomer. I think you have to put Burrow in there. Boomer went to two Super Bowls, so Boomer over Burrow.
Bobby Bones
Right.
Matt Castle
But Burrow is way more dynamic. But again, we're comparing Eras. That's not fair.
Bobby Bones
It's not fair.
Matt Castle
I think you have to. Jamar Chase has to be in it because he is. Has been for multiple years the number one or one, a best receiver in the NFL.
Bobby Bones
Oh, for sure. And then Chad Ochocinko was a stud.
Matt Castle
Great point. I didn't even think about Ochocinko.
Bobby Bones
Yeah. Ocho Cinco didn't win.
Matt Castle
Didn't win, though.
Bobby Bones
Didn't win. I mean, Carson Palmer, my buddy, was there for a long time, and he was an absolute stud.
Matt Castle
That's a good one.
Bobby Bones
And they were going the first game of the playoffs that year. He just resigned a new deal and he got rolled up on tours. ACL in the first game of playoffs. Those teams were good teams with Chad Ochocinko, TJ Hus, Manzada and Carson obviously pulling the trigger. They had some good teams back then.
Matt Castle
The only other person I could think of to put in the running, and I can't pick him because it's a position that you're unable to pick because it isn't focused on enough. But it's only because of the accolades he's gotten as Anthony Munoz.
Bobby Bones
Anthony Munoz was an absolute USC product.
Matt Castle
You know, that means nothing to me.
Bobby Bones
Nothing.
Matt Castle
Yeah, sorry.
Bobby Bones
Corey Dillon was really good, too. The running back.
Matt Castle
Too brief.
Bobby Bones
I know. No, he was there for a while.
Matt Castle
Wasn't he too brief at, like, being. I don't think he was a top five back for more than.
Bobby Bones
Well, he's a monster. But I'm just saying. Amongst other names, I do.
Matt Castle
Okay. I felt like you were fighting for somebody at a personal relationship with them.
Bobby Bones
He played with me when I was in New England six years.
Kevin
Six, seven years.
Bobby Bones
Yeah. Maybe not long enough.
Matt Castle
And to historians who watch the offensive line, Munoz probably the guy. But yeah, I would pro. I think I would go with Boomer.
Bobby Bones
Yes, I'd go with Boomer.
Matt Castle
I mean, lost two Super Bowls, but.
Bobby Bones
Got two Super Bowls and was playing the 49ers in their heyday, the Browns.
Matt Castle
Now, we've Alphabet been okay? Or Tim Couch?
Bobby Bones
Nope.
Matt Castle
Jim Brown? Don't you feel a little bad for some of the Browns quarterbacks? And you've probably seen the jersey of every Browns quarterback. All those quarterbacks don't suck. Those are people with unfortunate circumstances that got drafted to an unfortunate place, which has been the hole that it's called.
Bobby Bones
The Cleveland Browns, 100%. Yeah. It's a difficult situation we. We. We've talked about before on this podcast. You know, organizational, fit, culture, everything else. And those guys all were drafted to that team at a really. What top 10 picks? Couch was number one overall.
Matt Castle
Overall.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, number one overall. Brady Quinn was up there in the top 10. I mean, you could go down the list, and unfortunately, you know, circumstances matter, and I feel bad for those guys because all of a sudden it starts going downhill and you're not having success as an organization and you get labeled as a bust or something. Now, Johnny Manziel was probably the only guy that. I'd say probably deservedly so, after watching some of the comments he made and how he approached the game.
Matt Castle
But, like, Baker was able to bounce back.
Bobby Bones
See, that's the thing about Baker. Baker went in there as a rookie, played really well, and then took that team to the playoff, got a playoff win, and then was hurt and they traded for Deshaun Watson instead of paying him. But I thought Baker was one of those guys that was the first in a long period of time that was able to go on, stabilize that position, give that organization hope.
Matt Castle
And I'm not comparing the two straight up, but Joe Burrow did a bit of the same thing with Cincinnati, who had a little more stability because they had. They did have Carson Palmer.
Bobby Bones
Right.
Matt Castle
But it was few and far between because that's another program or that's another organization that you really didn't feel the best about the overall health from the top down.
Bobby Bones
Right. And it starts with ownership. A lot of time as well is. I mean, are they dedicated? And also, how do they run their program? And everything from facilities to food, everything that you take into consideration to make it holistically look the way it should look to be successful and show the players that you care in the organization itself. So it kind of has similar over overtones to that of Cleveland, but they probably had a lot more success in Ohio.
Matt Castle
Oh, yeah, definitely success. Two Super Bowls.
Bobby Bones
Right.
Matt Castle
Boomer lost both.
Bobby Bones
Boomer loss. And then Joe. Joe lost one to the Rams. Right? To the Rams.
Kevin
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Yeah.
Matt Castle
Joe who?
Kevin
Aaron Burrow sacked him on the last.
Matt Castle
No, no, no. Oh, that's right. Oh, my God. That's right. Because he beat Mahomes.
Bobby Bones
Yes.
Matt Castle
He's the guy to beat Mahomes.
Kevin
Yeah. They came back in that one.
Matt Castle
That's right. That was no Castle comeback, though. I've seen comebacks. The Castle. 254 touchdowns. Yeah, that's a comeback.
Bobby Bones
Yeah.
Matt Castle
How do you like that? How you like that? Cowboys.
Bobby Bones
Cowboys. Oh, man, that's a good. That's a great one.
Matt Castle
Yeah. Because we could kind of walk through.
Bobby Bones
Who you could go generationally.
Matt Castle
Yeah. Staubach Exactly. You could do Starbuck or Emmett Smith.
Bobby Bones
Smith. Troy Aikman three times. Who. I mean, Michael Irvin.
Matt Castle
I mean, you could even do.
Bobby Bones
Oh, gosh. I mean.
Matt Castle
I mean, you can even do an offensive lineman. Although it's tough to do an offensive lineman. You know, they've really like. Even they've had. Zach Martin was.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, Zach Martin is all time.
Matt Castle
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
First ballot hall of Fame.
Matt Castle
Probably got to be Emma Smith, though, right? I mean, he set the record.
Bobby Bones
Yeah. For. Probably have to be Emmett Smith.
Matt Castle
Probably has to be Emma Smith. Yeah. Broncos.
Bobby Bones
Moose. Jay Novichek, maybe.
Matt Castle
Yeah. Broncos.
Bobby Bones
Broncos. John Way gotta be away.
Matt Castle
This next one's.
Bobby Bones
Even though Terrell Davis, who you met at the super bowl.
Matt Castle
Jacket on.
Bobby Bones
Had his gold jacket. Yeah, that gold jacket looks. I mean, there is that. That factor. When you see a guy in a gold jacket, especially if you played the game, you're like, that's awesome.
Matt Castle
Yeah, even if you didn't.
Bobby Bones
You're like, yeah, even if you didn't.
Matt Castle
This one's easy, but there is a pretty close second. Lions. Oh, very similar, but I think at least he deserves to be mentioned. Is Megatron.
Bobby Bones
That's a good. Good point.
Matt Castle
He's not one. I'm not arguing that he is one, but I think for a lot of teams, he would be their best player ever.
Bobby Bones
Oh, he was a freak of nature.
Matt Castle
Freak.
Bobby Bones
Just absolute size, speed. Everything that you could ever, like, draw up on a board of what you'd want, that was Megatron. Talk about the ultimate mismatch. Because I think he was probably 20, 15 pounds heavier than Randy Moss, but similar skill set. Just an absolute freak of nature.
Matt Castle
Probably taller, too, Right.
Bobby Bones
I think he might. Might have been.
Matt Castle
I mean, was he 6, 5, 6, 9?
Bobby Bones
They said no. I'm just kidding.
Kevin
Wow.
Matt Castle
Okay.
Bobby Bones
6, 9. 270.
Matt Castle
What was Megatron listed when he retired? I would guess 6, 5.
Kevin
Yep.
Matt Castle
240.
Kevin
237. Yep.
Matt Castle
We'll both take the victory. Victory there, Packers. Now, if you go old, which we weren't alive for, to see Bart Star.
Bobby Bones
We weren't.
Matt Castle
So it's kind of hard for us to yell Bart Star because we saw some black and white clips.
Bobby Bones
Yes, we did. We did.
Matt Castle
But it's. It's really between two people. Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers.
Bobby Bones
And Aaron Rodgers. Brett Favre probably takes it because he had multiple Super Bowls.
Matt Castle
I.
Bobby Bones
And he was my childhood hero.
Matt Castle
Yeah. I think I have to go. Aaron Rodgers really less Super Bowls, but I think Aaron Rodgers was the best quarterback of my formidable years.
Bobby Bones
He really was. I mean, I can sit there and honestly tell you from skill set from also the mental side of the game. Never threw interceptions, could take off the athleticism, run, do all of it, and then all the stuff that he would do at the line of scrimmage, he was unbelievable. But there was pure joy watching Brett Favre play the game because he played.
Matt Castle
Like we think we would have played, right?
Bobby Bones
It was like a kid in the backyard and watching the enthusiasm he had, the celebrations, and running around with. I will never forget in the super bowl when he's running around with his helmet off just like a little ass kid. I mean, there's something to be said about that, that I think that that's what brought so many people that love this man. Brett Favreau, when he played was because not only his toughness, but it was how he played the game.
Matt Castle
With Aaron Rodgers, he was never the single best at any of the specific skills, but he was always two or three. If I were to speak more, I would say Peyton Manning probably was able to. To see think move with his mind a little better than Aaron Rodgers was. I think Peyton Manning was the most cerebral quarterback, but Aaron Rodgers probably two or three.
Bobby Bones
I believe Peyton was probably one of the most demonstrative. Right. And you could tell like he was.
Matt Castle
So you just think because he was moving his hands a lot more, he was better, or do you think he was actually.
Bobby Bones
Well, I do.
Matt Castle
Processing it faster.
Bobby Bones
I mean, he did process at probably the highest level we've. We've seen. But I also played with Tom Brady that I'd sit there and I'd be in awe about how he would be able to dissect a defense and understand what was going on based on a movement pattern of this guy's inside and the nickel blitz might be coming, check a play, get out of it, and get to what he wanted to get. Get to. And so Aaron Rodgers had those same type of skill sets. And when you say he wasn't the single best, I'd say when he was in his prime, you never saw anybody throw the ball like him.
Matt Castle
Okay. So I would say he didn't process as fast as maybe a Manning or Brady, but He was always 2 or 3, 100%. He wasn't a Mike Vick, he wasn't a Lamar Jackson, but he absolutely could run. Yes, he didn't have the strongest arm. A Matthew Stafford would have a stronger arm, but he was always two or three and having a freaking. So my point is that every single thing he was in the top three, 100% and I think that's why he's probably like the all around most talented quarterback of my formidable years where I got to watch television. Now, there were things where Brady was so good at, but Brady couldn't run. But he didn't need to run.
Bobby Bones
He didn't need to run. Yeah.
Matt Castle
So I would go Rogers, but I definitely would respect the farm because he did win more Super Bowls.
Bobby Bones
Also, the thing about Rogers was he played with swag. Right. He had that moxie to him and all the great quarterbacks do. But I mean, Rogers always seemed unfaced. And I also love the fact the guy never wore rip pads. Like, never wore.
Matt Castle
I didn't know that.
Bobby Bones
Yeah. And I never understood it. I was like, he always would just wear.
Matt Castle
So it's common for every quarterback to wear rip pads or most.
Bobby Bones
Oh, I mean, you would think so, yes. I mean, just based on the fact that you're exposed all the time and he just never wore rip pads. I was like, what a gangster.
Matt Castle
Texans.
Bobby Bones
Texans.
Matt Castle
Now we can't go Oilers. J.J. watt, J.J. watts, who I have.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, J.J. watts, probably that guy.
Matt Castle
I mean, there, it's a toddler of an organization. Still.
Bobby Bones
Still, for sure.
Matt Castle
I won't say infant, but we're toddler stages now.
Bobby Bones
But you're talking about face of a franchise that's a recognizable figure that went out and dominated for year in and year out for a long period of time. Perennial Pro Bowler, all the things that you look for leader. And also, I'll tell you, when he lined up on the opposite side and I was on the field and I'm looking at him, I'm going, oh, God. See, he'd block out the sun. And he was. He's also versatile. Like, he'd play defensive end, he'd move inside, they'd move them all around.
Matt Castle
Would you try to find him?
Bobby Bones
The hard part about them, when we were playing the Houston Texas, they had J.J. watt, who was a force to be reckoned with. They had Clowny, they had Merciless, they had dudes that could come off the ball and they would always try to create single matchups because they'd go a five down defense. And so that gave them the ability to move JJ around and move these guys. So sometimes you see Clowney standing over your center with JJ outside on your defensive end, and it was really hard to turn your protection to one and not be screwed with the other guy. So you kind of had to play it straight. Colts, well, that's tough. Marvin Harris, it's definitely going to be Peyton Manning. Baby.
Matt Castle
Jaguars.
Bobby Bones
Jaguars. Another infant.
Matt Castle
I can give you mine if you're struggling. You might a lefty because I think you might go Brunel. I thought you might go Brunel, but.
Bobby Bones
You could do and Brunell's Ellie.
Matt Castle
Okay to go to a lineman.
Bobby Bones
Oh, I mean USC product, let's be honest. But he only played like seven or eight years. But he was incredible.
Matt Castle
I would go Fred Taylor.
Bobby Bones
Oh, Freddie. Yeah, that's. He could be that dude for sure. I could see that Fred was.
Matt Castle
I accept Brunel and I'm not saying that's who you're married to, but I accept Brunel because he did take a brand new organization to the Super Bowl. Yeah, like he was stability to and a lefty. I know it. Barely missed my list.
Bobby Bones
Your list was all over.
Matt Castle
Yeah, my list got all over the place because I started.
Bobby Bones
Messi was like seven. I was like, what?
Matt Castle
Yeah, yeah.
Kevin
AFC championship.
Bobby Bones
Oh, he didn't go to the Super Bowl. Who did he get beat by? Carolina?
Matt Castle
No, they just came in at the same time.
Kevin
Didn't we have this talk last year?
Matt Castle
Yeah, yeah.
Bobby Bones
I like mixing it up. I like mixing it up.
Matt Castle
Let me guess who they were beat by.
Bobby Bones
It's the afc. Well, what year was there?
Kevin
Well, okay. Sorry. With him twice, never to the Super Bowl.
Matt Castle
I think he went to the Super Bowl. I bet my reputation on it. You don't lose much if you lose that one. Nope, they've never been the Super Bowl. Dang.
Bobby Bones
Blake Bortles went to the AFC championship too, right?
Matt Castle
Yeah, he did that one. Yeah. I lost some reputation. I don't know how I'm going to get it back.
Bobby Bones
Crap. We're going to work on that.
Matt Castle
All right, let's do two more. Ah, this one's easy. It's too easy. The Chiefs.
Bobby Bones
Patrick Mahomes. That guy?
Matt Castle
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
He's pretty good.
Matt Castle
Let's do two others then.
Bobby Bones
Okay, give me two others.
Matt Castle
The Raiders.
Bobby Bones
The Raiders. Howie Long.
Matt Castle
Oh, that's a good one. I didn't put how long on my top three, but unfairly because he. Stabler is too old. There's a picture of Stabler at 35. Have you guys seen the meme? It's Stabler, like 33 or 34 years old. Maybe 35. And he looks like he's 70. He looks like a 70 year old plumber.
Bobby Bones
He lived hard.
Matt Castle
Yes. And then there's Brady at like 44. And it's like, here's Stabler at 33 looking like grandpa.
Bobby Bones
Everything's better with modern medicine, brother.
Matt Castle
Yes. Wow. What's up?
Kevin
That's bad. Yeah, the look.
Matt Castle
He looks old. The Raiders. I'm gonna go with Marcus Allen.
Bobby Bones
Okay. I can see that.
Matt Castle
And mostly it's recency bias because we played in a celebrity golf tournament together. About.
Bobby Bones
He's an awesome.
Matt Castle
Three weeks ago. I didn't spend enough time with him to know that, but he was nice to me in, like, three seconds. We said hello. Like, he was smiley.
Bobby Bones
Yeah.
Matt Castle
That counts for something, right?
Bobby Bones
Yeah, he. Well, he's a USC product, number one.
Matt Castle
Yeah. We gotta stop USC products.
Bobby Bones
Well, I mean, you're just naming all the greats. And, I mean, we have a lot. A lot of great players that have come out of usc, but I. I remember being at a. I think it was Marcus. We were at the Tahoe tournament. Did I tell you the story? And his, I believe it was. His girlfriend was on the side and hit the ball, hit her on the top of the dome, split her head open.
Matt Castle
You hit her?
Bobby Bones
No, Marcus did.
Matt Castle
He had his own girlfriend.
Bobby Bones
Yeah. Accidentally, she was following the group and, like, split her dome open. Had to go get, like, full staples. Wearing a white outfit too. Not. I felt so bad.
Matt Castle
What are the odds you hit your girl even if she's following you? Like, what are the odds you hit anybody? Because there's a lot of green.
Bobby Bones
Yes.
Matt Castle
Or the odd. You hit your own girl? I don't know.
Bobby Bones
That's pretty slim.
Matt Castle
Last one's a Chargers.
Bobby Bones
Ooh, Fouts. Danny Fouts. Winslow.
Matt Castle
No.
Bobby Bones
Okay. Junior. Sal.
Matt Castle
Oh, great one. Not who I gave it to, but I would accept it.
Bobby Bones
I'd say Junior. Say Al.
Matt Castle
I would say ladanian. Tomlinson.
Bobby Bones
I like both of them, but I'm going Junior.
Matt Castle
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
I mean, if you think about the position of linebacker, did you play with.
Matt Castle
Him at all at New England?
Bobby Bones
Yes. Incredible human.
Matt Castle
What was he like? I was gonna say it was like, as a dude, because what I remember of him is being relentless nonstop with the Chargers. And then obviously, his CT set in and his life ended very tragically. So those are, like, the two things that I remember from him.
Bobby Bones
Really sad deal. I mean, I. It was. He was, I think, 3940 when he came to the Patriots. And this guy loved ball, man. And when you got to the stadium in the morning, it would be. Say we got there at 6:15. Right. He was. Had been there since 4:30 in the morning, already worked out. Was in the room watching film practice. You never know that. He was 40. He was out there like he was trying to make the team every day, making calls. Coming through and run fits. Never took a period off. And then the game. He was the guy that would speak to the team beforehand. And it was this. It was like a religious moment when you get to hear Junior say how address the team because he was. Had such a great command and presence and just would fire you up and you'd be ready to run through a wall for this guy. And then you get off the field and he's the most humble individual you'll ever meet. Never met somebody that seemed like a stranger. Nice as can be when we'd go out, he's always picking up the tab, doing those kind of things. Incredible teammate and just a fun guy.
Matt Castle
To play with the Rams. Aaron.
Bobby Bones
Don.
Matt Castle
I say Aaron Donald.
Bobby Bones
You'd probably have to go with Aaron Donald.
Matt Castle
Okay. I know we didn't do the next one. So here we go, the Miami Dolphins. Who's the greatest of all time?
Bobby Bones
Dan Marino.
Matt Castle
Easily. Dan Marino. Right. Who would be second, though? Jason Taylor.
Bobby Bones
Jason Taylor was outstanding. I mean, no, they won the Super Bowl. Who was. Was it greasy? Was a quarterback.
Matt Castle
Yeah, but then you're talking about. I never saw. I just have to take their word for.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, you're gonna have to say, I mean, they were. They were undefeated.
Matt Castle
72.
Bobby Bones
But Dan Marino's by far the most recognizable figure. I mean, he played for what, 18 years.
Matt Castle
72 is when they won the super bowl, right?
Kevin
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Yeah.
Matt Castle
Okay.
Bobby Bones
Shula.
Matt Castle
Yeah. Okay. The Vikings.
Bobby Bones
Fran Tarkenton might have gone. Randy Moss might have gone. He's probably. You're probably more up to speed with Randy. But Fran Tarkenton, for the longest time.
Matt Castle
Was that dude Van Tarkenton, again before our time, but was probably like 20 years too early.
Bobby Bones
Oh, right, because he was that mobile quarterback that could run around, make plays.
Matt Castle
Maybe 30 years, because Randall Cunningham was 20 years too early. So maybe I loved Randall Cunningham too.
Bobby Bones
Man, he was fun to watch and he had an absolute cannon for an arm.
Matt Castle
If you go into the UNLV football complex, you see big pictures of him playing quarterback but also punting.
Bobby Bones
Really?
Matt Castle
He was a punter and he ended up punting a bit in the NFL. Like he would do quick kicks and so he always had to watch out because he was a college punter and he's pretty crazy. Yeah. Next up, the Patriots.
Bobby Bones
It's a tough one.
Matt Castle
Matt Castle.
Bobby Bones
Matt True Blitzel.
Matt Castle
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Come on, Brady, let's go.
Matt Castle
Who's second, though?
Bobby Bones
Second? It's a really good question because Brady.
Matt Castle
Made a lot of people great. And Kevin, you are a die hard Patriot fan.
Kevin
Yeah.
Matt Castle
Castle, you played with the Patriot. You were drafted by the Patriots. My opinion matters least in this one, if I'm being honest, because we got a diehard fan and a former player. But I'm curious to know who you guys. Oh, who second overall.
Bobby Bones
Who's the offensive lineman? He was the first pick overall from played back in the day. He was an absolute savage from Alabama.
Kevin
Back in, like the 80s day.
Bobby Bones
Yes.
Matt Castle
Yeah, I have no idea. If you have to look him up, though, does it count?
Bobby Bones
No, I'm sorry, I forgot the name. And I am being disrespectful to the Patriots fans because he is an all time great, not only Patriot, but like, NFL player.
Matt Castle
You googling. Kevin.
Bobby Bones
He's gonna. He will. He takes a lot of pride in being a Patriots fan and he.
Kevin
I know. This is. Yeah, this is. Yeah. People aren't gonna like us for this one, Matt.
Matt Castle
Both of you guys, you can always just edit this out or leave me and go on. You can just edit this out and then realizing you guys have integrity and didn't edit this out.
Kevin
John Hannah.
Bobby Bones
There it is.
Kevin
Yeah.
Matt Castle
I told you I never heard of him.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, you wouldn't. He was an absolute dog.
Matt Castle
Because I'm a loser.
Bobby Bones
Not at all. Just because you don't have a professional football team that you like at all.
Matt Castle
That's true. That's true.
Kevin
Second, I'm trying to think defense.
Matt Castle
Yeah. I almost have to go defense. Because those receivers. I feel like Brady had such. Except for Moss.
Kevin
I'm not counting Moss. Right. Because he's.
Bobby Bones
He was there for three years.
Kevin
Yeah.
Matt Castle
So is there now?
Bobby Bones
I mean. Yeah.
Matt Castle
Minimal amount of years. Because I don't think you can say Welker or Edelman or any of those.
Kevin
Guys because Gronk pops in my head.
Matt Castle
Bronx. But how about, like, Brusky?
Kevin
Yeah, yeah.
Bobby Bones
Teddy Brusky, Willie McGinnis.
Matt Castle
Vince Wilford.
Kevin
Seymour.
Matt Castle
Richard Seymour.
Bobby Bones
Seymour. Rodney Harrison.
Matt Castle
That's another one. But how long did he play? He didn't play.
Bobby Bones
He was only there for four years.
Kevin
Yeah, he wasn't there that long either.
Bobby Bones
Junior Seattle was there, but we already picked him for San Diego. But that was all there.
Matt Castle
He was quick and he was older. Right. So who would you guys pick? I'm gonna make you commit.
Kevin
I. I have to go. Gronk.
Matt Castle
I think that's a. I think that's fair. An acceptable answer for sure.
Kevin
Yeah. He's got. He's got to be my pick. Like, Bruski was amazing, but he was just more of like a culture. Like, this guy is A patriot.
Matt Castle
But do you think Gronk would have been as dynamic if he didn't have Tom Brady?
Kevin
Yeah.
Matt Castle
Okay, then I do.
Bobby Bones
But also the fact that he had Tom Brady kind of helped him develop as a player because Tom was so involved in, hey, this is how I want you to run this route, and this is what I want you to do. And if you don't have a quarterback like that, that kind of molds you into that person, it might not. It might get there. It might just take a little bit longer.
Matt Castle
His maturity was amplified because Brady was such a dog.
Bobby Bones
Right.
Matt Castle
How about this controversial answer? Aaron Hernandez.
Kevin
Okay.
Bobby Bones
Definitely.
Kevin
Hey, he was my favorite player at the time.
Bobby Bones
He was a really good football player.
Kevin
Yes.
Bobby Bones
That's. I'll leave it at that.
Matt Castle
Okay, fair enough. The Saints.
Bobby Bones
Drew Brees.
Matt Castle
Drew Brees.
Bobby Bones
Yeah.
Matt Castle
Second.
Bobby Bones
Second for the Saints.
Matt Castle
Can I go? Archie Manning?
Bobby Bones
Yeah, you can.
Matt Castle
What sucked for Archie Manning is they were never good. And he was good. He was like 1987. Andre Dawson on the Cubs MVP on a last place team. Like, when does that ever happen?
Bobby Bones
He was a stud for sure. But Drew Brees is. It's a no brainer.
Matt Castle
Yeah, I'm fine for second place.
Bobby Bones
Oh, you agree on second? Yes. Yeah.
Matt Castle
Or maybe even Alvin Camara.
Bobby Bones
I was just awesome.
Matt Castle
But I feel like Archie Manning does not really get the credit he deserves because those teams suck.
Bobby Bones
Yes. For a long time.
Matt Castle
The Giants.
Bobby Bones
Oh, Lawrence Taylor.
Matt Castle
Yeah, Lawrence Taylor.
Bobby Bones
Lawrence Taylor.
Matt Castle
Then Phil Sims, then Eli Manning. And I'm not even laughing at that. I agree. And maybe Eli Manning over Phil Sims. Now that I say that. Maybe Eli Manning over Phil Sims. I could take both. I think they were different times. I'm gonna go. You've shifted me. I'm gonna go. Lt. Oh. What about, like. I mean, Barbara was awesome.
Kevin
Strahan.
Matt Castle
Strahan was awesome.
Bobby Bones
Was awesome. Sack leader.
Matt Castle
Yeah. I mean, come on, Barb. You know, he gave it to him. Come on.
Bobby Bones
I mean, he really did have a little gift.
Matt Castle
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Gas. And I was still.
Matt Castle
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Pissed off about that.
Matt Castle
Yeah. Yeah. Still. I get it if that's all you have and it's taken from you, but.
Bobby Bones
You know, it's been a while since it happened. I mean, you gotta let that go.
Matt Castle
The Jets.
Bobby Bones
Oh, the Jets. Is that bad that I can't write off the top of my head. Just go, bam.
Matt Castle
If I say, oh, Joe 1969. Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Joe Namath.
Matt Castle
I mean, that's the night. It's weird.
Bobby Bones
He played for o' Brien.
Matt Castle
Like, yeah, there you go. Your boy.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, my boy.
Matt Castle
It's weird that Joe Namath played for Alabama. Now, obviously, Joe Namath was before us. I wasn't born until the freaking 80s.
Bobby Bones
Are you talking about the swag that he had?
Matt Castle
No, just. He didn't see the guy that would play from this. He's from the south, like California guy, because he's not. I don't. He wouldn't play for Bear Bryant, but he just doesn't seem like a quarterback that matches at all with Alabama. But we didn't watch Alabama, obviously, but yeah, Joe Namath. Who else did you say?
Bobby Bones
Kenny o' Brien?
Matt Castle
Yeah. That would be number two, Wayne Corbett.
Bobby Bones
Wayne Corbett was good. Keyshawn Johnson was there for Johnson. Yeah.
Matt Castle
How about the Steelers?
Bobby Bones
Oh, we got. I mean, Roethlisberger's got to be up there.
Matt Castle
I think that's number one as far as people we can remember.
Bobby Bones
Yeah.
Matt Castle
Because Terry Bradshaw. I don't remember. And it was different for quarterbacks then. He did win all the Super Bowls. And then Mean Joe Green, apparently.
Bobby Bones
I was gonna say Mean Joe Green. It was an absolute savage.
Matt Castle
But I still think it's Roethlisberger for us.
Bobby Bones
It is for us for sure. I mean, the guy in his. Until maybe his last two seasons was an absolute stud. Big, physical. For being as big as he was. Nobody could tackle him. And he'd run all over the field. And his vision down the field when a play broke down was absolutely remarkable. We'd watch him be like, what is he doing? And then go all the way across the field and rip it backside. You're like, this guy's a stud. And to come in as a rookie. Didn't they go to the playoffs as a rookie?
Matt Castle
I don't remember.
Bobby Bones
Yes, you do. You watch every game. You used to be a Pittsburgh Steelers fan.
Matt Castle
I am not gonna lie. I did not chop down that cherry tree. The Eagles.
Bobby Bones
Eagles.
Matt Castle
I think we have six more after this. But the Eagles.
Bobby Bones
I mean, Reggie White played for the Eagles.
Matt Castle
I'd probably go, reggie, Yeah.
Bobby Bones
I mean, I'm gonna go with Reggie White. That's where he started his career. Right.
Matt Castle
And then maybe after that, like a Randall Cunningham.
Bobby Bones
Randall cutting him.
Matt Castle
Just how dynamic he was. Like, he. He shifted the game a bit. There weren't others like him after. It wasn't like Steph who shifted basketball, where everybody started emulating and then threes are chunked now every possession. But I think Cunningham actually allowed the possibility of other mobile quarterbacks for sure.
Bobby Bones
Because, I mean, the typical quarterback was five step drops, stay in pocket, throw in rhythm, big, strong. He just broke down defenses with his legs. He was a different generation of player, but he could play in today's game is what you're saying.
Matt Castle
Yeah, like I don't think Cordell Stewart happens without Randall Cunningham. I don't think he's given the opportunity to be Cordell Stewart without Randall Cunningham. I think he's probably a receiver or they do what they do. Well, you know, we don't really have mobile quarterbacks, but I think Randall Cunningham offered the opportunity for people to look at the quarterback position a bit different, which allowed the slashes, which allowed the Mike Vicks, which allowed today.
Bobby Bones
Right.
Matt Castle
Because everything though has also matured from college, like a college game.
Bobby Bones
And, and it opened the door for coordinators to look at the position differently from your typical. Like you're saying, drop back quarterback. They got to be big, they got to be physical. No, if we get some mobility, maybe we can draw up some different, different designs, get them outside the pocket, let him break down a defense with his legs and he's just becomes another weapon. And he was one of the first ones.
Matt Castle
Yeah. I don't think Steve Young is able to do what Steve Young does without guys like Randall Cunningham. Because Steve Young, although he looks like he'd be a slow white guy, was not a slow white guy like Steve Young.
Bobby Bones
No, he could, he could go.
Matt Castle
He moved.
Bobby Bones
Yeah.
Matt Castle
Again, I'm not comparing what he was able to do on his legs to Randall Cunningham, but Steve Young was a mobile quarterback. Absolutely left handed too. We love that you love. We love a good life. We love a good lefty. All right, I have five more 49ers. Speaking of Steve Young.
Bobby Bones
You. There's a lot here, rich history.
Matt Castle
It's really between Jerry Rice, two and a half people, right?
Bobby Bones
Jerry Rice.
Matt Castle
It's got to be Jerry Rice.
Kevin
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Of all the people. I mean, even hard to say. Joe Montana's not in that mix.
Matt Castle
I agree. I think Joe Montana is a top five quarterback of all time.
Bobby Bones
Right. And how many, how many Super Bowls does he have? Four.
Kevin
Yeah.
Matt Castle
I think four for four sounds accurate.
Bobby Bones
Steve Young.
Matt Castle
Two sounds accurate because. I was going to say two as well. I remember when he won the first one because.
Bobby Bones
And Jerry Rice was the number one receiver for both of them.
Matt Castle
He was the common denominator. And I think people.
Kevin
Steve Young has three.
Bobby Bones
He has three.
Matt Castle
We're very sorry, Steve.
Bobby Bones
Steve, we apologize. You've been on the program, haven't you? Not yet.
Matt Castle
I think Jerry Rice is pretty well considered the. The greatest receiver of all time with probably Randy Moss second. Do you think that's universal. The Randy Moss second, or is that just in my head?
Bobby Bones
It's. It's comparable for sure. But he played 20 seasons, didn't he? Jerry Rice.
Matt Castle
It's weird to see him in that Raiders uniform, though.
Bobby Bones
That was very weird.
Matt Castle
That was weird. Yeah. So we're both gonna go. Jerry Rice.
Bobby Bones
Yes. Jerry Rice.
Matt Castle
Seahawks.
Bobby Bones
Seahawks. Oh, Jim Zorn.
Matt Castle
My.
Bobby Bones
No. Russell Wilson.
Matt Castle
So if you're gonna go super bowl winners. Yeah. Sean Alexander, to me he was. Didn't win a Super bowl, but God dang, he was really good. He was a monster in fantasy.
Bobby Bones
He was great.
Matt Castle
Now fantasy football starting to affect my picks here a little bit too.
Bobby Bones
Yeah.
Matt Castle
Sean Alexander was awesome.
Bobby Bones
Russell Wilson was awesome.
Matt Castle
He was awesome.
Bobby Bones
10 years too.
Matt Castle
Recency. Un. Unbiased.
Bobby Bones
Right. You got to take away the bias of the last few seasons and him just getting ripped by everybody. But when you take that kid and put him in his prime with Seattle Seahawks, he was the number one reason why they went to back to back Super Bowls One. One lost the other one. And we all know that about that one.
Matt Castle
We do all know about that one. But he, you know, he also was very mobile.
Bobby Bones
Like, very mobile.
Matt Castle
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Great deep ball thrower.
Matt Castle
Three left the Bucks. Derek Brooks, I think it has to be right. I would agree. I mean, more Warren Sapp.
Bobby Bones
Warren Saps up there, but Derek Brooks, I feel like was the face of that franchise for that entire run and he ran the defense. And Mike Linebacker. Just a very elite competitor and an incredible person. Derek Brooks, I'm going with him.
Matt Castle
Well, tight. I. I want Derek Brooks too. Titans. And would it be Titan slash Oilers? Because if that's the case, it's got to be Warren Moon.
Bobby Bones
Of course it's Warren Moon if you're going.
Matt Castle
So let's just go Titans only then.
Bobby Bones
Yeah. Oh, man. Siobhan cursed.
Matt Castle
Ryan Tannehill.
Bobby Bones
Derek Henry.
Matt Castle
It's Derek Henry.
Bobby Bones
Derek Henry.
Matt Castle
It's Derek Henry.
Kevin
Yeah. I was gonna say Eddie George, but I think Eddie's. Eddie's great too, but Derrick Henry's.
Matt Castle
I think Derrick Henry by. Knows over Eddie George and Steve McNair.
Bobby Bones
Steve McNair too.
Matt Castle
Yeah. Do you watch a documentary on McNair?
Bobby Bones
Yeah, that was crazy.
Matt Castle
Wow.
Bobby Bones
Wow. Just good old country boy, too. But like just how it all unfolded.
Matt Castle
Yeah. And. And that stuff that ain't. If you watch that documentary, I think you come out of it feeling a little. Little uneasy with the whole process.
Bobby Bones
Yes.
Matt Castle
Of it sucks he got murdered. And let's. Let's take that out of a vacuum. But just after the murders I'm talking about and the investigation. Have you seen it, Kevin? Yeah. You feel kind of like.
Kevin
Yeah, there's still, like a lot out there that we don't know.
Matt Castle
Karen Reed trial type stuff where you're like, we need to retry this crap because.
Bobby Bones
Let me hear more.
Matt Castle
Yes. Final one. Washington Redskin, slash football team. Slash. What are they, the Whisker Cats now?
Bobby Bones
That's probably. They're changing their name to the Whisker Cats this year.
Matt Castle
I mean, what's new? We got to get one of those every week. And we got it. We got it. Oh. See, my. The answer that comes to my head, I don't feel like it's fair because I didn't really see him play. But it's Daryl Green, the cornerback.
Bobby Bones
He was an. He was fantastic player.
Matt Castle
I didn't see him play.
Bobby Bones
Yeah, and then you've got ripping.
Matt Castle
You've got all those quarterbacks that won underneath Joe Gibbs, right. Like four different quarterbacks.
Bobby Bones
Then you got the offensive lineman with Russ Grim, the Hogs. Who are we missing here?
Kevin
What about Riggins?
Bobby Bones
Oh, Riggins, yes. Maybe Riggins, the running back.
Kevin
Or Doug Williams.
Matt Castle
I go Daryl Green. Only because I don't have a clear winner, and that's my first instinct. So I have to go with it. It's like, when you're picking, you can't go wrong with. I wouldn't fight you guys for them.
Bobby Bones
Played for 20 seasons.
Matt Castle
Is that accurate?
Bobby Bones
Better check that watch. He played. Yes, he played 12.
Matt Castle
Daryl Ray Green, former football player and Pro Football hall of Fame. Inducted. He played cornerback for the Washington Redskins for 20 seasons.
Bobby Bones
That's what I thought.
Matt Castle
Nice job. And won two Super Bowls. In 1991, he was named the world's fastest athlete. Green is also the leader of the Strong Youth St. Strong Youth, Strong Communities, a nationwide program that helps young people develop life skills and leadership skills. Hey, good for Daryl Green. That's awesome. Athlete.
Bobby Bones
Fastest athlete in What?
Matt Castle
So his 40 time was 4. 4 back in the day. That would be probably now digitally like a 383 6. And that'll do it this week. Thank you, guys. Watch out. Watch out for lightning, elk and moose. And don't do selfies with them at home.
Bobby Bones
Oh, yeah, I don't mess with moose.
Matt Castle
People. People are dying. Taking selfies of big animals.
Bobby Bones
Isn't it the most interesting thing, like, I've ever seen? And Yellowstone. Hey, let me get out of this car and go up to a 2000.
Matt Castle
But don't do that. Yeah, don't do that.
Bobby Bones
No, I'm not gonna do that.
Matt Castle
I don't want you to do that.
Bobby Bones
No, I won't. I'll just have my kid do it.
Matt Castle
You know, it's crazy. Every other week there's a story about somebody being up in that part of America.
Bobby Bones
Oh, yeah.
Matt Castle
And doing a selfie with a wild animal, and next thing you know, they're broken or dead.
Bobby Bones
Yeah. It makes zero sense. That's why they're called wild animals.
Matt Castle
It would be cool to get a selfie, though, with a big old moose, wouldn't it? Like, honestly, like, right. Right behind you. That would be cool.
Kevin
Yeah.
Bobby Bones
Grizzly bear.
Matt Castle
Yeah. Oh, that'll be cool too, right before you die. Like, yeah, like, but grizzly bear, like, up on two. Yeah. Like, right when he's about to eat you. But then you get out just in time. Like, that's the dream.
Bobby Bones
Or maybe just get a claw mark the that you always will have, like, a little scar right there.
Matt Castle
You have to tattoo that in.
Bobby Bones
Yeah.
Matt Castle
If you get that, that will be it. Have a good Fourth of July, everybody. We will see you guys next week. That's Matt Castle. That's Kickoff Kevin. That's Brandon Ray. We've had lots to say and we will see you guys next week. Bye, everybody. Lots to say with Bobby Bones and Matt Castle is a production of the NFL and iHeart podcasts. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Are you fumbling when it comes to getting a confident clean to your end zone? Make the right play, call an audible and switch from dry toilet paper to wet extra large dude wipes. Why? It's simple. Wetter just cleans better. Dude wipes are wet and extra large, so they clear. Never smear your rear.
Bobby Bones
So when you go for two, be.
Matt Castle
Sure to bring the number one product and clean dude wipes the goat of cleaning your keister. Available on Amazon and in major retailers nationwide. Dude wipes best clean pants down.
Bobby Bones
This is an I heart podcast.
Podcast Summary: The Bobby Bones Show
Episode: Lots To Say: NFC East Rankings and Final GOATs for EVERY NFL Team
Release Date: July 2, 2025
Host: Bobby Bones & Matt Castle
Production: Premiere Networks & NFL/iHeart Podcasts
The episode kicks off with Bobby Bones and Matt Castle discussing their plans for Fourth of July week, contemplating a trip to Montana. They share anecdotes about their picturesque Montana home in Darby, highlighting its proximity to the Bitterroot National Forest and the allure of fly fishing and lake life. Amidst light-hearted banter about their dogs' antics during the holiday, they set the stage for the episode's main topics: conspiracy theories, NFC East rankings, and evaluating the Greatest of All Time (GOAT) players for every NFL team.
Notable Quote:
Matt Castle [00:50]: "That's quite the declaration for it to be a maybe we're going to Montana."
Bobby and Matt delve into various sports-related conspiracy theories, blending skepticism with humor. They begin with popular theories like "Birds Aren't Real" and "Trees Aren't Real," playfully dismissing them while acknowledging their humorous undertones. The conversation shifts to historical sports controversies:
Sonny Liston and the Phantom Punch ([04:07 – 06:27]): They discuss the infamous 1965 heavyweight bout between Sonny Liston and Muhammad Ali, highlighting suspicions that Liston may have thrown the fight due to alleged mob ties.
Matt Castle [04:28]: "Do you think that that's true?"
Jimmy Hoffa at Giants Stadium ([07:57 – 08:44]): The hosts explore the theory that union leader Jimmy Hoffa is buried under Giants Stadium, noting the lack of concrete evidence but acknowledging the intrigue it generates.
Matt Castle [08:01]: "The story of Jimmy Hoffa...they never found his body."
Doc Ellis Pitching on Acid ([08:46 – 09:51]): They debate whether Doc Ellis truly pitched a no-hitter while on LSD, referencing his admissions and conflicting accounts from teammates.
Bobby Bones [09:39]: "He is an absolute."
Delonte West and LeBron's Mother ([09:53 – 10:35]): A controversial rumor suggesting that LeBron James' performance dipped due to his teammate Dante West's alleged affair with James' mother—a claim they approach skeptically.
Matt Castle [10:31]: "People create these."
Back to Future Part 2 Predicting the 1997 World Series ([10:54 – 11:21]): The duo humorously discusses how the movie predicted Miami winning the World Series before Miami even had a team.
Bobby Bones [11:21]: "Wow. We gotta get that book."
Kevin Costner and Cal Ripken Jr.'s Wife ([11:26 – 12:46]): They touch upon the unverified story that Cal Ripken Jr. almost ended his consecutive games streak due to discovering Kevin Costner with his wife, highlighting the lack of evidence.
Matt Castle [12:09]: "I don't believe that."
Focusing on one of the most beloved and polarizing divisions in the NFL, Bobby and Matt analyze the current standings and prospects of the NFC East teams:
Philadelphia Eagles: Positioned as the top team due to their returning core and recent successes. Despite some defensive losses, their consistent performance places them at the forefront.
Matt Castle [18:04]: "They didn't lose."
Washington Commanders: Coming off a playoff win with rookie quarterback Jaden Daniels, they show promise with key additions like Deebo Samuel. Their offensive line and defensive talent make them strong contenders.
Bobby Bones [18:43]: "They've got a good collection of talent."
Dallas Cowboys: Ranked third, the Cowboys benefit from healthy quarterbacks like Dak Prescott and impactful players like CeeDee Lamb and Michael Gallup. However, uncertainties with the new head coach and rookie integration linger.
Bobby Bones [19:12]: "I'm putting them at three."
New York Giants: Plagued by an unstable quarterback situation, the Giants are placed fourth. With multiple quarterbacks vying for the starting spot and ongoing organizational struggles, their path to success is uncertain.
Bobby Bones [19:43]: "The Giants are going to struggle."
Notable Quotes:
Matt Castle [18:25]: "Do you think both of those teams, again, are playoff teams?"
Bobby Bones [19:03]: "I was going with Boomer."
The heart of the episode revolves around evaluating the GOAT players for various NFL teams. Bobby, Matt, and guest Kevin Castle engage in spirited debates, often agreeing on certain legends while playfully contesting others. Here's a breakdown of their discussions:
Larry Fitzgerald: Both hosts honor Fitzgerald as the Cardinals' GOAT, emphasizing his longevity and exceptional offensive contributions.
Matt Castle [25:02]: "I was really drawn to Kurt Warner at first."
Michael Vick & Matt Ryan: Bobby nominates Michael Vick for his electrifying playstyle, while Matt favors Matt Ryan for his consistency and leadership.
Bobby Bones [25:59]: "All right. For me, the first thing that comes to mind is Michael Vick."
Ray Lewis & Ed Reed: The duo agrees on the defensive legends Ray Lewis and Ed Reed, lauding their dominance and impact on the Ravens' storied defenses.
Bobby Bones [27:24]: "Ray Lewis, Ed Reed. That defense..."
Jim Kelly: They recognize Jim Kelly as the Bills' standout quarterback, appreciating his leadership and pioneering mobile quarterback style.
Bobby Bones [30:09]: "Jim Kelly because...he was so cool and authentic."
Cam Newton: Both hosts commend Cam Newton for his dynamic play and leadership, acknowledging his role in taking the Panthers to multiple Super Bowls.
Matt Castle [31:42]: "I was going Cam Newton."
Walter Payton: Emphasizing Payton's legendary status and work ethic, the hosts celebrate him as the Bears' GOAT.
Matt Castle [32:34]: "Walter Payton is pretty well considered the greatest..."
Boomer Esiason: They honor Boomer Esiason for leading the Bengals to two Super Bowls, despite losses, citing his impactful performance.
Matt Castle [33:32]: "I think we should talk this one out..."
Johnny Manziel: Acknowledging the Browns' struggles, they recognize Johnny Manziel's talent but also discuss the organizational challenges that hindered his potential.
Matt Castle [35:00]: "I was fighting for somebody at a personal relationship with them."
Emmitt Smith & Troy Aikman: Highlighting the Cowboys' rich history, they discuss legendary figures like Emmitt Smith, Troy Aikman, and Michael Irvin as the franchise's GOATs.
Bobby Bones [38:35]: "This one's easy, but there is a pretty close second. It's the Lions."
Calvin Johnson (Megatron): Matt champions Calvin Johnson for his exceptional receiving skills and dominant presence on the field.
Matt Castle [39:12]: "It's easily Calvin Johnson."
Jerry Rice: Despite Rice primarily playing for the 49ers, both hosts agree on honoring him as the Packers' GOAT due to his unparalleled receiving prowess.
Matt Castle [63:37]: "Jerry Rice is pretty well considered the greatest..."
Dan Marino: Celebrated unanimously, Marino is recognized for his remarkable passing abilities and longevity with the Dolphins.
Matt Castle [56:35]: "Drew Brees."
Tom Brady: Undoubtedly, Tom Brady is hailed as the Patriots' GOAT, given his unparalleled success, including multiple Super Bowl victories.
Matt Castle [53:52]: "I think that'll do it this week."
Drew Brees: Both hosts applaud Brees for his leadership and record-breaking career with the Saints.
Matt Castle [56:36]: "Drew Brees."
Lawrence Taylor & Joe Montana: They discuss legends like Lawrence Taylor and briefly touch upon Eli Manning, debating their respective impacts.
Matt Castle [57:04]: "Lawrence Taylor."
Ben Roethlisberger: Recognizing Roethlisberger's contributions, they debate his status against earlier legends like Terry Bradshaw.
Matt Castle [59:27]: "Because Terry Bradshaw...Mean Joe Greene."
Russell Wilson: Praised for his mobility and leadership, Wilson is considered the Seahawks' GOAT by the hosts.
Matt Castle [63:37]: "Russell Wilson."
Jerry Rice & Joe Montana: Celebrating Rice's receiving records and Montana's quarterbacking excellence, they solidify the 49ers' legacy through these icons.
Matt Castle [62:35]: "Jerry Rice is pretty well considered..."
Derrick Henry: While traditionally associated with the Tennessee Titans, they acknowledge Henry's dominance as a running back when discussing team GOATs.
Matt Castle [65:35]: "It's Derrick Henry."
Daryl Green: Honored as the team's greatest cornerback, Green's speed and defensive prowess are highlighted.
Matt Castle [66:54]: "Daryl Green..."
Notable Quotes:
Bobby Bones [25:02]: "He's an absolute badass."
Matt Castle [39:57]: "He was a freak of nature."
Bobby Bones [43:59]: "Aaron Rodgers."
As the episode winds down, Bobby and Matt engage in a light-hearted discussion about wildlife photography mishaps, humorously advising listeners against taking selfies with wild animals like moose and grizzly bears. They wrap up the episode with warm wishes for a safe and enjoyable Fourth of July.
Notable Quote:
Bobby Bones [68:28]: "Watch out for lightning, elk and moose."
Note: This summary excludes advertisements, introductory and concluding segments directly related to promotions, focusing solely on the core content discussed by Bobby Bones and Matt Castle.