The Book Review Podcast: "Draft for Publish" Summary
Release Date: December 27, 2024
Host: Gilbert Cruz
Featured Guest: Susanna Clarke
Reporter: Alexandra Alter
Introduction
In the holiday-off season of The Book Review podcast, host Gilbert Cruz presents a special end-of-year feature focusing on the illustrious career of Susanna Clarke, immortalized by her seminal work, Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell. Drawing from Alexandra Alter's insightful profile, the episode delves deep into Clarke's literary journey, her distinctive approach to fantasy, and her enduring impact on the literary world.
Susanna Clarke: A Literary Luminary
Alexandra Alter sets the stage by highlighting the profound influence Clarke has wielded over the fantasy genre. Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell, an 800-page historical fantasy novel set in Regency-era England, not only captivated millions but also redefined the boundaries between fantasy and literary fiction.
“It blurred the lines between fantasy and literary fiction in this really interesting way.” – Alexandra Alter [00:46]
Clarke's debut was monumental—selling over 4 million copies and garnering prestigious accolades like the Booker Prize nomination and the Hugo Award. Her ability to intertwine magic with historical realism drew comparisons to literary giants such as C.S. Lewis, J.R.R. Tolkien, Jane Austen, and Charles Dickens.
A Decade of Silence and Creative Resurrection
Despite the monumental success of her first novel, Clarke retreated from the public eye, leaving fans and critics eagerly anticipating a sequel. Nearly two decades later, she reemerged with Piranesi, a stark departure from her debut work. Unlike the sprawling narrative of her first book, Piranesi is a concise, philosophical exploration set in an enigmatic labyrinth.
“Critics were stunned that she had done something so different. And some people said, you know, this is proof that Susanna Clarke is not only one of the greatest fantasy writers of her generation, but just one of the greatest writers period.” – Alexandra Alter [00:46]
Clarke's sparse bibliography, particularly in genre fiction, stands in contrast to contemporaries who often produce prolific series. Her selective output underscores the quality and depth of her work, making her contributions exceptionally impactful.
An Intimate Look: Interview with Susanna Clarke
Alexandra Alter provides a personal glimpse into Clarke's life, inviting listeners into her tranquil limestone cottage in England's Peak District. The serene surroundings, replete with sheep-filled pastures and rugged moorlands, mirror the idyllic yet mysterious settings of her novels.
Childhood Influences and Literary Aspirations
Clarke reflects on her upbringing as the daughter of a Methodist minister, where emotional expression was subdued. This environment fueled her attraction to literature, particularly fantasy, as an emotional outlet.
“Books were home in a way that other places weren't.” – Susanna Clarke [06:11]
Her fascination with fantasy was not merely escapism but a profound means to explore and articulate complex emotions that were otherwise stifled in her household.
Academic Pursuits and Early Struggles
Despite studying economics, politics, and philosophy at Oxford, Clarke grappled with her writing ambitions. An unfinished detective novel and persistent struggles with chronic fatigue syndrome nearly derailed her literary career.
“I tried to give up writing and it hadn't taken. I just started again almost immediately.” – Susanna Clarke [08:46]
Her resilience was tested further when health issues impeded her creative flow, leading her to temporarily disassociate from her identity as a writer.
The Turning Point: BBC Adaptation and Renewed Purpose
The adaptation of Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell into a BBC television series served as a catalyst for Clarke's creative revival. The recognition and validation from the literary community and fans rekindled her confidence, prompting her to embrace her identity as an author once more.
“These people seem to think I'm a writer. Possibly I am.” – Susanna Clarke [12:28]
Evolution of Craft: From Historical Fantasy to Surreal Philosophy
Clarke's subsequent work, Piranesi, exemplifies her versatility and willingness to transcend traditional genre boundaries. The novel's surreal ambiance and philosophical undertones reflect a deeply introspective phase in Clarke's writing journey, paralleling her personal experiences of isolation and introspection.
“I was writing about someone who was in a fairly isolated position, but who was able to find a huge amount in that.” – Susanna Clarke [14:03]
Her latest endeavor, a forthcoming fable titled The Wood in Midwinter, continues this trend of exploring profound themes through fantastical narratives, focusing on a girl who communicates with nature and vanishes into the forest.
Additionally, Clarke is venturing into what she describes as an "anti-horror novel," aiming to craft a story that embodies sublimity and joy rather than fear—a testament to her innovative spirit.
“Write the way you can and not the way people tell you you're supposed to.” – Susanna Clarke [15:13]
Philosophical Underpinnings and the Essence of Fantasy
Clarke articulates a philosophical perspective on fantasy literature, viewing it as an extension of human emotion and subconscious exploration. Her work often serves as a metaphorical canvas, allowing readers to engage with profound emotional landscapes through magical realism.
“I think fantasy's got a line to the unconscious and I think the most interesting work comes from the unconscious.” – Susanna Clarke [08:18]
This approach not only enriches her storytelling but also invites readers to introspect and perceive reality through a nuanced, magical lens.
Conclusion: The Enduring Legacy of Susanna Clarke
Susanna Clarke's literary oeuvre, though limited in quantity, is vast in its impact and innovation. Her ability to seamlessly blend historical realism with fantastical elements, coupled with her philosophical depth, cements her status as a luminary in contemporary literature. As she continues to push the boundaries of genre fiction, Clarke remains a beacon of creative integrity and intellectual curiosity, inspiring both readers and fellow writers alike.
“If you could get sort of a bit further beyond your ego and the sort of ways in which we trap ourselves, if you could just see the world beyond, I think it, you know, it would be miraculous.” – Susanna Clarke [15:56]
This episode of The Book Review not only celebrates Susanna Clarke's remarkable contributions to literature but also offers a profound exploration of her creative spirit and the philosophical depths underpinning her work. For those yet to delve into her novels, this summary serves as an evocative invitation to experience the magic and introspection that Clarke masterfully weaves into her storytelling.
Subscribe and Explore More:
Unlock full access to The New York Times podcasts and explore a diverse range of topics from politics to pop culture. Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Listen to this podcast on the New York Times Audio app for iOS users by downloading it at nytimes.com/audioapp.