DONKEY: Conservatives Shift Gun Rights Arguments After Shootings

Summary

Podcast Summary: The Breakfast Club

Episode: DONKEY: Conservatives Shift Gun Rights Arguments After Shootings
Date: January 27, 2026
Hosts: DJ Envy, Angela Yee, Charlamagne Tha God

---

Episode Overview

This episode of The Breakfast Club's "Donkey of the Day" segment zeroes in on the visible shift in rhetoric by conservative figures regarding gun rights after the tragic shooting of Alex Preddy. The hosts criticize the inconsistency and perceived hypocrisy among conservatives who typically champion Second Amendment rights but are now framing legal gun ownership as a justification for police violence. The conversation explores double standards in gun rights discourse, the fallout within the conservative and pro-gun community, and broader implications for civil liberties and governmental power.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Introduction: Shifts in Gun Rights Arguments

• Charlamagne Tha God highlights the ongoing tension between police and communities in America and frames the episode's subject as an exploration of how the conservative response to a recent shooting reveals contradictions in their Second Amendment advocacy.
  • "There is no question that there are problems in this country between police and community." (01:10, DJ Envy)
  • "White supremacist violence is and always has been the number one threat to our society." (01:30, Charlamagne Tha God)

Donkey of the Day Recipients & Background (01:44)

• Angela Yee and Charlamagne name:
  • White House Press Secretary Caroline Levitt
  • FBI Director Cash Battel
  • U.S. Attorney Bill Asali (mispronounced, discussed on air)
  • All conservatives who seem to waver on Second Amendment rights following recent gun violence.

The Second Amendment & Double Standards (02:01–03:32)

• The hosts reaffirm their belief in the right to bear arms, but argue for "common sense gun reform."
  • "I absolutely believe in my right to keep and bear arms. But I also believe in common sense gun reform." (02:15, Angela Yee)
• A Daily Show montage is played, revealing high-profile conservatives justifying police violence against lawful gun carriers at protests, despite open carry laws.
  • Conservatives portrayed as inconsistent—celebrating Kyle Rittenhouse for bringing a gun to a protest, but condemning recent victims who did the same.
  • "I don't know of any peaceful protester that shows up with a gun and ammunition rather than a sign." (03:05, DJ Envy)
  • "Peaceful protesters don't have nine millimeter weapons with two extra magazines." (03:12, Angela Yee quoting conservative)

Fallout Among Gun Rights Groups & the NRA (04:24–05:24)

• Angela Yee reads statements from the NRA and Gun Owners of America, both pushing back against conservative leaders' new rhetoric.
  • "Responsible public voices should be awaiting a full investigation, not making generalizations and demonizing law abiding citizens." (05:12, Angela Yee quoting NRA)
  • Gun Owners of America reject the notion that simply carrying a licensed firearm justifies lethal police force, emphasizing the protected right to bear arms, even at protests.

Authoritarianism, Historic Parallels, and Civil Liberties (06:13–07:20)

• Angela and Charlamagne warn that compromising on civil liberties in the name of security leads to authoritarianism.
  • "Authoritarian regimes are not sustainable, okay? The people will always revolt, especially in a country like America, the land of the free." (06:13, Angela Yee)
• They draw parallels to historic political shifts in America (McCarthyism, segregation, Nixon era abuses), arguing that anti-democratic impulses eventually face backlash and correction.
  • "Political movements that normalize anti-democratic behavior eventually face legal, cultural and institutional pushback. Okay, that's just a historically accurate statement." (06:40, Angela Yee)
  • "The de-MAGA-fication of America is upon us. And it's going to be fun to watch." (07:06, Angela Yee)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Regarding conservative reversals:
  • "In a world where Kyle Rittenhouse was held as a hero after bringing a gun to a protest and ended up killing two people, now conservatives are asking, who brings the gun to a protest?" (03:32, Angela Yee)
• On legal rights and risks:
  • "Having a legal firearm ... raises the risk of law enforcement using force against you." (03:57, Angela Yee)
• On public response & freedom:
  • "The freedoms we do have, we don't want them infringed upon by the government." (06:32, Charlamagne Tha God)

---

Key Timestamps

• 01:44 — Announcement of "Donkey of the Day" recipients
• 02:01–03:32 — Discussion of Second Amendment, conservative media montage, and reactions to protests and legal gun use
• 04:24–05:24 — NRA and Gun Owners of America push back, defend legal gun carriers’ rights
• 06:13–07:20 — Warnings against authoritarian overreach, parallels to historic American political shifts

---

Tone & Language

• The tone is urgent yet satirical, with the hosts expressing exasperation at hypocrisy, defending individual rights, and employing cultural references (e.g., "the de-MAGA-fication of America").
• Both Angela Yee and Charlamagne are direct but nuanced, supporting both gun ownership and the need for reform.
• The conversation mixes humor and serious commentary, keeping the podcast’s signature lively energy.

---

Conclusion

This episode’s "Donkey of the Day" shines a light on apparent contradictions within conservative circles concerning gun rights after high-profile police violence incidents. The segment mixes critiques of political opportunism with calls to defend civil liberties, blending passionate argument with insightful historical context. The hosts reinforce the need for consistent advocacy for constitutional rights, regardless of political fallout.

---

For listeners who missed the episode, this summary captures the essential debates, arguments, and memorable moments, providing a clear picture of the shifting discourse and cultural stakes discussed by The Breakfast Club team.

Transcript

[Podcast Host]

This is an iHeart podcast. Guaranteed Human.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

The new year is when everybody's reflecting, resetting, and rewriting their story. But January is about turning that energy into action. If you've been talking about a side hustle or waiting for the right time to bet on yourself, Shopify makes that first step easier than ever. Whether you're just starting out or already running a business, Shopify can handle anything you throw at it. That's why we use it here. A few products are a full catalog. 1 Login simple tools and real growth. No more waiting. No more maybe build who you're meant to be with. Shopify. If 2026 is your year, go to shopify.combreakfastclub and make your move. Hollywood is buzzing. Award winning director Von Kovach has come out of retirement, promising to redefine the superhero genre with his remake of Wonder Man. At the center is Simon Williams, a man desperate to be a star but hiding a dangerous secret. He has superpowers outlawed in Hollywood. With Trevor Slattery mentoring him. Hilarity and Hart collide in ways only Marvel could deliver. Starring Emmy award winner Yahya Abdul Mateen II and Oscar winner Ben Kingsley. This is Marvel like you've never seen it before. Don't miss Marvel. Television's Wonder Man Screaming Tuesday. Only on Disney. Made it. This is America.

[DJ Envy]

There is no question that there are problems in this country between police and community.

[Angela Yee]

Yes, you are a donkey.

[News Reporter]

To the latest on that police killing of a black man.

[DJ Envy]

Now to new developments in the deadly spa shooting rampage.

[News Reporter]

And yesterday was a really bad day for him. And this is what he did.

[DJ Envy]

And so we are in a state of emergency.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Okay? White supremacist violence is and always has been the number one threat to our society.

[Angela Yee]

But I'm also very proud that my.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Wife is white man. The Breakfast Club, bitches.

[DJ Envy]

All right, Charlene, please tell me, why was I your donkey of the day?

[Angela Yee]

Well, donkey of the day for Tuesday, January 27th goes the White House Press Secretary Caroline Levitt, FBI Director Cash Battel. U.S. attorney for the Central District of California, Bill Asali.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

I think you pronounce his name. And every single conservative who all of.

[Angela Yee]

A sudden seems like they don't believe.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

In the second Amendment. Okay, what is the second Amendment? Well, it's in that document nobody seems.

[Angela Yee]

To care about anymore called the U.S. constitution. And the Second Amendment protects the rights of the people to keep and bear arms.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

I am too a all day.

[Angela Yee]

I absolutely believe in my right to keep and bear arms. But I also believe in common sense gun reform. Okay, I don't feel that anyone in America needs guns the size of little Duvall. Okay? And I think that's a rational way to look at this situation. But since the tragic murder of Ale Ready, conservatives have not been being rational about this situation. In fact, critics yesterday were saying that the right is betraying their base on gun rights. Now, I was watching the Daily show last night, and they had an amazing collage they put together of all of the conservatives just betraying their base on gun rights. Let's listen.

[DJ Envy]

When you are bearing arms and you are confronted by law enforcement, you are raising the risk of force being used against you.

[News Anchor]

You cannot bring a force firearm loaded.

[Angela Yee]

With multiple magazines to any sort of protest that you want.

[DJ Envy]

I don't know of any peaceful protester that shows up with a gun and ammunition rather than a sign.

[Angela Yee]

Don't let the left kid you with this. That this is just a normal protest. Peaceful protesters don't have nine millimeter weapons with two extra magazines.

[News Reporter]

I am sorry that this gentleman is dead, but he did bring a 9 millimeter semiautomatic weapon with two cartridges to what was supposed to be a peaceful protest.

[Angela Yee]

Lord have mercy. That was a Treasury Secretary Scott Besant. Listen, in a world where Kyle Rittenhouse was held as a hero after bringing a gun to a protest and ended up killing two people, now conservatives are asking, who brings the gun to a protest? Caroline Levitt said yesterday that any gun owner knows that carrying a gun raises the assumption of risk and the risk of force being used against you during interactions with law enforcement gun owners. Did y' all know that? Envy. Did you know that? I didn't know that. Okay. I didn't know that. Having a legal firearm that, you know, you have all your paperwork for raises the risk of law enforcement using force against you.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

By the way, Kyle Rittenhouse yesterday tweeted, and I quote, okay, Kyle Rittenhouse, okay, tweeted yesterday, and I quote, carry everywhere, period. It is your right.

[Angela Yee]

Hashtag shall not be infringed. Listen, gun right groups blasted the Trump administration yesterday. The NRA is had something to say. Let's go to CBS News for the report, please.

[News Anchor]

The killing of Alex Preddy has raised concerns among a group of Americans not known for criticizing the Trump administration advocates for the Second Amendment. The federal government says part of the reason he was killed is because he had a gun. But Preddy was licensed to carry, and the video shows that the weapon stayed in his waistband. One Trump administration official said online, quote, if you approach law enforcement with a gun, there is a high likelihood that they will be legally justified in shooting you. Here is the NRA's response. Responsible public voices should be awaiting a full investigation, not making generalizations and demonizing law abiding citizens.

[Angela Yee]

The NRA said responsible public voices should be awaiting a full investigation, not making generalizations in demonizing law abiding citizens. That was the nra and I agree with them. Okay.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Gun Owners for America said in a.

[Angela Yee]

Statement that its leaders condemn the untoward comments by people like Bill Aceli. I think I'm pronouncing that right. Who put on X? No, I know I'm not pronouncing that right, but he put on X. If you, if you approach law enforcement with a gun, there is a high likelihood they will be legally justified in shooting you. No. Okay. Having a gun on your person in an open carry state and having a permit for it doesn't mean you should be killed. Stop this madness. All right? Gun Owners of America said in response to him. Federal agents are not highly likely to be legally justified in shooting, shooting, concealed carry licensees who approach while lawfully carrying a firearm. The second amendment protects Americans right to bear arms while protesting a right the federal government must not infringe upon. This goes back to what I said.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

To you all yesterday.

[Angela Yee]

Authoritarian regimes are not sustainable, okay? The people will always revolt, especially in a country like America, the land of the free. All right?

[Charlamagne Tha God]

They call it the land of the.

[Angela Yee]

Free because of the values that this country upholds. Now we know all freedom hasn't been created equal in this country, but the freedoms we do have, we don't want.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Them infringed upon by the government. And yesterday I told you, I told you the Nazis ultimately lost. What I was simply saying in a.

[Angela Yee]

Very me way was political movements that normalize anti democratic behavior eventually face legal, cultural and institutional pushback. Okay, that's just a historically accurate statement. Okay?

[Charlamagne Tha God]

I don't care if it was McCarthyism.

[Angela Yee]

That collapsed and became toxic segregationists, politics became socially radioactive, Nixon era abuses reshaped.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Epic laws and oversight.

[Angela Yee]

The demagafication of America is upon us. I repeat, the demag ification of America is upon us. And it's going to be fun to watch. So please give all those conservatives who have betrayed their base on gun rights.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

The biggest he hawk.

[News Anchor]

All right?

[Angela Yee]

Yes, indeed.

[Caller]

Well, thank you for that donkey today.

[Angela Yee]

Yes, ma'.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Am.

[Caller]

Now let's open up the phone lines. We were talking behind this, behind the scenes. I don't know where Lauren just went. We were talking about Kanye. Apologized to the black community and the Jewish community.

[Angela Yee]

What does forgiveness look like, man?

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Well, I mean, nothing we can give. We not God.

[Caller]

I mean, I'm just saying. But should people forgive? Should he just, you know, write this letter and say thank you and should.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Who are people?

[Angela Yee]

There's no Jewish people in the room.

[Caller]

Well, black people.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

We can speak for ourselves.

[Caller]

Black people as well. And I'm sure Jewish people do listen.

A lot of black people mad at him. But, like, when you say forgiveness, right? Like, what does that mean? What, buying his albums again or streaming.

His albums or going to his shows or. Yeah, I don't know what that means. Do we?

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Public supporters who stopped, though?

[Caller]

I never stopped listening to Kanye.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Had a number one album last time he dropped.

[Caller]

People still wear sneakers. Yep, I do. Yeah. I still listen to his music.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

So what do y' all talk about?

[Caller]

I openly love Kanye. He publicly support.

[Angela Yee]

Yeah, I want Kanye to be mentally and emotionally healthy. That's what I want. I don't care about anything else. You know what I'm saying? When I see a brother that clearly we all watched, you know, struggling with some type of mental and emotional issues.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

When I see him, you know, get quiet for a year and then, you know, pop out, and people that have seen him and have talked to him have said he's in a better space, a better headspace. That's what I hope for the brother. So I'm never going to be against that.

[News Anchor]

Yeah.

[Caller]

Well, let's open up the phone line. Let's discuss 800-585-1051. You heard his apology, and I guess what the ADL came back with pretty much saying, show us what he said.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

The best apology is change behavior.

[Caller]

Absolutely. Don't just tell us, show us. We want to see you do better. And let's discuss 800-585-101. 051 is the Breakfast Club. Come on.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Hollywood is buzzing. Award winning director Von Kovac has come out of retirement, promising to redefine the superhero genre with his remake of Wonder Man. At the center is Simon Williams, a man desperate to be a star but hiding a dangerous secret. He has superpowers outlawed in Hollywood, with Trevor Slattery mentoring him. Hilarity and heart collide in ways only Marvel could deliver. Starring Emmy award winner Yaya Abdul Mateen II and Oscar winner Ben Kingsley. This is Marvel like you've never seen it before. Don't miss Marvel. Television's Wonder man screaming Tuesday, only on Disney.

[Podcast Host]

This is an Iheart podcast. Guaranteed human.