DONKEY: Man Claims God ‘Ordered’ Him To K!ll His Father After Dispute Over Dishes

Summary

The Breakfast Club Podcast Episode Summary Episode Title: DONKEY: Man Claims God ‘Ordered’ Him To K!ll His Father After Dispute Over Dishes
Release Date: April 24, 2025
Host/Authors: DJ Envy, Jess Hilarious, and Charlamagne Tha God
Podcast: The Breakfast Club by iHeartPodcasts

---

Introduction to the Incident

In this gripping episode of The Breakfast Club, hosts DJ Envy, Jess Hilarious, and Charlamagne Tha God delve into a troubling and sensational case that has captivated national attention. The episode centers around Micaiah Icewinder, a 27-year-old man from Ohio, who confessed to killing his 59-year-old father, Joe Swindler. The tragic event stemmed from a seemingly mundane dispute over household chores—specifically, washing dishes.

Hosts' Initial Reactions and Discussions

The conversation kicks off with the trio exchanging light-hearted banter before turning serious as Charlamagne introduces the "Donkey of the Day," a recurring segment where a caller is highlighted, often for questionable or controversial reasons.

Charlamagne Tha God:
“Today for Thursday, April 24th goes to a 27-year-old Ohio man named Micaiah Icewinder.” [02:03]

The hosts reminisce about their childhood experiences with chores, prompting reflections on parenting styles and discipline.

Angela Yee:
“What did I do? I made donkey of the Day.” [01:40]

Jess Hilarious:
“Because you're mean. I am not.” [01:36]

This exchange sets the stage for a deeper discussion on the pressures and challenges of household responsibilities and the potential consequences of familial conflicts.

Analysis of the Tragic Incident

Charlamagne takes a contemplative stance, pondering whether modern "gentle parenting" might contribute to such extreme outcomes. He juxtaposes contemporary parenting methods with more traditional, stricter approaches.

Charlamagne Tha God:
“Sometimes I wonder if these are the effects of gentle parenting. Sometimes I wonder if we have to bring back beatings.” [04:15]

He further argues that accountability was fostered through stricter disciplinary measures in the past, suggesting that the lack thereof might lead to severe behavioral issues.

Charlamagne Tha God:
“Whenever you think God is... telling you to do something that will cause hurt to somebody or it'll end up with somebody being dead... please understand that Satan has a kingdom, too...” [04:23]

He references his favorite movie, Frailty, to illustrate how fiction can mirror real-life psychological struggles and decisions.

Detailed Breakdown of the Incident

The episode incorporates a news report detailing the sequence of events leading to the tragedy. Initially, police responded to a dispute between Micaiah and his father over dishwashing. Hours later, Micaiah called dispatchers, confessing to stabbing his father, attributing his actions to divine orders.

News Reporter:
“...a dispute that started over dishes ended tragically... I just killed my father.” [03:31]

This segment provides listeners with factual context, highlighting the severity of the conflict and the profound implications of Micaiah's claims.

Discussion on Parenting Styles and Accountability

Charlamagne delves deeper into the impact of parenting techniques on a child's psychological development. He expresses skepticism about the effectiveness of modern disciplinary methods and suggests that they may inadvertently contribute to rebellious or harmful behavior in youths.

Charlamagne Tha God:
“...if you do that, some kids still ain't going. Some kids just not going to do what it is you want them to do.” [02:56]

He emphasizes the importance of teaching accountability and consequences, proposing that traditional methods, albeit harsh, instilled a stronger sense of responsibility.

Race and Identity Debate

The conversation takes a turn as the hosts grapple with determining the racial background of Micaiah Swindler. This segment showcases the hosts' differing perceptions and challenges in identifying race based solely on names and limited information.

Jess Hilarious:
“Yo, what is his last name?” [06:33]
“Let me see. Makai gave it away. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Definitely black.” [07:55]

Charlamagne Tha God:
“Guess what, racist. Kya. I. Swinder of Ohio killed his father...” [06:43]

This discussion underscores the complexities and sensitivities surrounding racial identity and assumptions based on names or appearances.

Final Reflections and Moral Takeaways

Charlamagne offers a somber reflection on the incident, urging listeners to recognize the signs of deeper psychological distress and the dangers of misinterpreting or misattributing one's motivations to higher powers.

Charlamagne Tha God:
“...please give Micaiah Icewinder the biggest hee haw. And it's crazy that he didn't want to take his dad orders to simply wash the dishes, but he'll listen to the voice in his head that he said was God telling him to kill his dad.” [05:50]

He emphasizes the importance of mental health awareness and the need for supportive interventions to prevent such tragedies.

Notable Quotes

• Charlamagne Tha God:
  “Sometimes I wonder if these are the effects of gentle parenting. Sometimes I wonder if we have to bring back beatings.” [04:15]

• Charlamagne Tha God:
  “Whenever you think God is... telling you to do something that will cause hurt to somebody or it'll end up with somebody being dead... please understand that Satan has a kingdom, too...” [04:23]

• Jess Hilarious:
  “I don't want to wash dishes. Mine, but I will, so I won't get popped.” [02:35]

Conclusion

This episode of The Breakfast Club navigates through a harrowing tale of familial conflict escalating to violence. Through candid discussions, personal anecdotes, and critical analysis, the hosts explore the underlying themes of parenting, accountability, mental health, and societal pressures. The episode serves as a poignant reminder of the profound impact of everyday disputes and the importance of fostering healthy communication and support systems within families.

---

Note: This summary omits advertisements, promotional segments, and non-content related sections to focus solely on the substantive discussions and insights shared by the hosts.

Transcript

[Angela Yee]

Meetings, deadlines, emails. Don't you wish you could escape the chaos? That's where the all new Nissan Murano comes in. With available features like the relaxing, massaging seats to ease stress and the beautiful skyline views that bring in natural light. It's like cruising in your personal oasis. And if you need to set a vibe, 64 colors of personalized lighting and a Bose premium sound system have you covered. Hands down, the all new Nissan Murano is your stress free getaway. Sometimes the greatest rush isn't rushing at all. Drive the all new Nissan Murano today.

[DJ Envy]

Panoramic moonroof, ambient lighting, bows and massaging.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Leather appointed seats are optional features.

[DJ Envy]

Taking control of your career is empowering. Just don't tell my boss I said that. Building a career just isn't about a job. It's about creating a path that impacts our community and future generations. Whether you're starting out or making big moves, State Farm is here to support you with resources to help protect what you're working hard to achieve. They've got your back every step of the way. Because like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. Find out more@state farm.com what's up federation?

[Freddie Prinze Jr.]

It's Freddie Prinze Jr. And wrestling with Freddie is back and we're going all in on WrestleMania 41. From the unpredictable to jaw dropping finishes, this year's mania might have just changed everything. By the way, almost all the matches that we saw looked like real fights. I thought like they were like, yo, we're going hard today. Tomorrow we're going to hurt, but we're going hard today because it was like beast mode times 10 out there. Listen to this episode of Wrestling with Freddie on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.

[Angela Yee]

Wanted to know how you came up.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

With the donkey of the day.

[Jess Hilarious]

Because you're mean. I am not.

[Angela Yee]

What did I do? I made donkey of the Day.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

There's a bunch of donkeys out here in the street.

[Jess Hilarious]

That is why Charlamagne is here. Charlamagne is here.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

If we live a life where we bite our tongue based off who we may offend, we never would say it. You don't give a damn. Go throw it up.

[Freddie Prinze Jr.]

Hey, give it to him.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Give it to him.

[Angela Yee]

On the Breakfast Club.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

In the words of Charlamagne, the God donkey that was.

[Freddie Prinze Jr.]

Oh man, Charlemagne.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

You giving donkey today to who now don't you? Today for Thursday, April 24th goes to a 27 year old Ohio man named Micaiah Icewinder. Now, who in here had to wash dishes as part of their chores growing up. Raise your hand. Okay. Who in here enjoyed washing dishes as a child? Raise your hand. I'm live.

[Jess Hilarious]

Yeah, I know. You're lying.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Oh, no.

[Angela Yee]

All your kids, he likes drying the dishes. He don't like washing them.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Well, Jess, when you didn't want to wash dishes, what did you tell Ms. Robin?

[Jess Hilarious]

I don't want to wash dishes. Mine, but I will, so I won't get popped.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Okay. Did you ever have an argument with her about not wanting to wash dishes?

[Jess Hilarious]

Hell no.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Because you know she bust that ass, period.

[Jess Hilarious]

Yes.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Okay. Envy, I'm sure you make the kids wash dishes. They all raised their hand. Yes. Have they ever rebelled against you and said, nah, dad, that ain't happening?

[Angela Yee]

No.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

What about Maddie? Logie?

[Angela Yee]

No.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Neither. None of them?

[Angela Yee]

No.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

I don't believe that.

[Unknown]

No.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Logan Buck back at least once.

[Angela Yee]

Definitely didn't.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Okay, I don't believe you. Well, those are all constructive, productive ways to deal with your kids when you want them to do what it is you want them to do. When you want them to wash dishes. But even you know, if you do that. Okay, if you do that, some kids still ain't going. You know what I'm saying? Some kids just not going to do what it is you want them to do. And Micaiah Icewinder is one of those kids. See, a dispute that started over dishes ended tragically. Go to WWNY 7 News for the report, please.

[Unknown]

Nearly the first thing out of Makai Swindler's mouth on the phone with dispatchers and admission.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

I'm not gonna lie, I just killed my father.

[Angela Yee]

Wait, what?

[Charlamagne Tha God]

I killed my dad.

[Angela Yee]

What do you mean by you killed your dad? Like he's dead.

[Unknown]

We're learning what led up to the violent incident. Marysville police had been to this house earlier in the day responding to a dispute between Micaiah and his father, 59 year old Joe Swindler. A police report shows the issue started over a dispute over doing the dishes. This caused a verbal conflict. Hours later, another call to the home from Micaiah, who said he stabbed his father with a knife. The dispatcher asked him why.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

God. God told me to.

[Angela Yee]

God told you to.

[Freddie Prinze Jr.]

Yes.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Yes, ma'am. Okay. I had orders.

[Unknown]

K. Swindler was in court this morning where prosecutors called him dangerous and requested that he be held.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Sometimes I wonder if these are the effects of gentle parenting. Sometimes I wonder if we have to bring back beatings. Okay. I used to have to pick a switch. Nothing makes you understand the consequences of your actions. Like having to pick your own switch because you know you did something wrong. And now your parent or grandparent is leaving it up to you to decide what your punishment is. And if you go and bring back a switch that's not big enough, now they go get the switch, and you don't want them to go get the switch. So it just gave you a level of accountability for the things that you did. And when you get beat with a switch you picked, you really understand that you caused this on yourself. Jess, you said you never buck back at Ms. Robin because you knew she would. What?

[Jess Hilarious]

Beat my ass. What are you talking about?

[Charlamagne Tha God]

That's all I'm saying. Now, I don't know if whippings would have stopped this young man, Micaiah, from being a stone cold killer, but I highly doubt his dad wanted to go out like this, okay? Micaiah said he put his dad out of his misery. Actually, son, I just wanted you to wash the dishes, okay? Now, when this young man, Micaiah says, God told me to one of my favorite movies growing up was frailty. You should watch it if you never have. So I understand how that could be true. But, Micaiah, and to anyone out there listening to me, let me tell you something. Whenever you think God is, you know, telling you to do something that you know will. Will cause hurt to somebody or, you know, it'll end up with somebody being dead or end up with you in prison for the rest of your life, please understand that Satan has a kingdom, too, okay? I think we often forget that if we give Satan attention, he will give us direction. Micaiah, somewhere along the way, you gave your attention to Satan. You submitted your will to him, and he told you to kill your father. And now you charged with one count of murder. And where you going? Chores are not optional, okay? You're gonna be cleaning, you're gonna be doing food preparation, you're gonna be doing laundry, washing other people's drawers, you're gonna be doing maintenance. And you probably gonna be doing what Kanye was doing to his cousin until the age of 14. And the irony is, you might get stabbed and killed if you don't. Please give Micaiah Icewinder the biggest hee haw. And it's crazy that he didn't want to take his dad orders to simply wash the dishes, but he'll listen to the voice in his head that he said was God telling him to kill his dad. Yeah, killing his dad took way more. Way more energy.

[Jess Hilarious]

Yo, what is his last name?

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Swinder. Oh, you want to Play a game. Yeah, let's play a game of guess what, racist. Okay.

[Angela Yee]

All right.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Kya. I. Swinder of Ohio killed his father because of a dispute over washing the dishes. Jeff. Hilarious. Guess what, racist.

[Jess Hilarious]

I want to say white, but your name A. Kaya. Ah.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Mixed for real.

[Jess Hilarious]

Black and white.

[Angela Yee]

Do we have a mixed one?

[Charlamagne Tha God]

We just gotta play them all at the same time. Okay.

[Angela Yee]

All right.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

DJ Envy Maia Swinder killed his father over a dispute over washing dishes. Guess what, racist swipe. Well, I'm. I'm gonna be honest with you.

[Angela Yee]

Oh, boy.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Envy's wrong.

[Angela Yee]

Oh, he's not right.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

I don't know if Jess is wrong.

[Angela Yee]

Let me see.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

Jess might be half right. Because I don't know if he's. He look. He looked Miami black.

[Angela Yee]

He black.

[Jess Hilarious]

Let me see.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

But he could be mixed. Hold on.

[Angela Yee]

Makai gave it away.

[Jess Hilarious]

Makai. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Definitely black.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

He got a rod wavish look.

[Jess Hilarious]

Yes, he definitely like Rob Makai.

[Angela Yee]

Yeah, Makai was. Was a black name.

[Jess Hilarious]

And he from Florida.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

No, he's from Ohio.

[Jess Hilarious]

Ohio.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

He.

[Angela Yee]

Look, see, he said Ohio, not there's no black people in Ohio. But I'm like, Ohio and then he killed his parents.

[Jess Hilarious]

That's like a white person to be washed. I mean, you know, wash dishes. Oh, yeah, yeah, I knew, but I. The makaya gave it away. Yeah, you're all right.

[Angela Yee]

Well, thank you for that dog here today. Up next, Jess fix my mess. 800-585-1051. If you're having relationship issues or any type of issue, call Jess right now. She'll help you out with all your problems. Call up 800-585-1051 is the breakfast Club. Good morning.

[Charlamagne Tha God]

The Breakfast Club donkey of the day is sponsored by renowned personal injury attorney Michael the Bull Laminsoft. Don't be a donkey when you need a fighter on your side. If you're ever injured, go to Michael the Bull dot com. That's Michael the Bull dot com. And mess with the bull, you get the horns.

[DJ Envy]

The best moments happen when you're with your people, laughing, vibing, just enjoying life. Coke is making those moments even sweeter. Sherry Coke is back. And it's all about sharing with the whole crew. Doesn't matter if it's your bestie or bro, There's a can with their name on it. So grab one for the squad and make some memories. But hurry, because these Coca Cola limited edition bottles and cans won't be here forever. Don't miss your chance to share a Coke with your favorite people.

[Freddie Prinze Jr.]

What's Up Federation, It's Freddie Prinze Jr. And wrestling with Freddy is back. And we're going all in on WrestleMania 41. From the unpredictable to jaw dropping finishes, this year's mania might have just changed everything. By the way, almost all the matches that we saw looked like real fights. I thought, like, they were like, yo, we're going hard today. Tomorrow we're going to hurt, but we're going hard today because it was like beast mode times 10 out there. Listen to this episode of Wrestling with Freddie on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.