Loading summary
Tamsen Fadal
It's the Broadway show Uncut. I'm so glad you're joining us. I'm Tamsen Fadal. Broadway's biggest night's in the books, but we're also excited to talk about the future of Broadway, the stars of tomorrow, and the Jimmy Awards. The Jimmy Awards is a huge and amazing event that happens in New York City every year, featuring the absolute best of the best musical theater talent from high schools all across America. These incredible high school student performers take part by winning a regional competition. The regionals happen in around 40 cities all over America. Here's Paul Wontorek with the winners of the 2026 Jimmy Awards.
Paul Wontorek
Samia Posadas, Jake James. 2026 Jimmy Award winners. How are you guys doing? It just happened last night. Where are the Emotions?
Samia Posadas
I mean, through the roof.
Paul Wontorek
Did you sleep?
Jake James
Absolutely. Over the moon. Over the moon, yeah.
Paul Wontorek
So you've just finished a week and a half in New York City, Right. And it's this intense, like the Jimmy and Jimmy's Intensive. What was this experience like leading up to the big night at the Minsk Off?
Samia Posadas
Yeah. So, I mean, it was. It happened so fast. It was like, you know, you wake up, you do this, you go to sleep, you wake up again, you go to sleep, and then it's every day something new. You're learning something new, you're doing more things. And it kind of like it really felt like it was all leading up to that big moment. And it was just so rewarding once we got there. Like, biggest weight off our shoulders.
Paul Wontorek
That audience last night. What. I mean, I saw you both and a lot of your new friends, your high school theater friends. I saw a lot of you react to the audience because it's really, like, thunderous. At the Minskoff Theater. What was it like being on that stage?
Jake James
It was truly electric. Jake and I were just talking about it earlier that literally we walked out for the opening number during the drum roll and we couldn't hear the music. People started singing. We were like, oh, shoot, it's time to start singing. Cause the energy and the audience's. Just the volume in there was absolutely insane. Like, unlike anything that I've ever experienced before. It was crazy.
Paul Wontorek
Wow. I mean, did you all. What was it like backstage? What was it like with everyone? Sort of. I mean, I feel like everyone's very focused on the task at hand. Right. Theater kids, like, let's get really focused and do the thing. But the excitement level, what was it like? Just sort of being in the wings and being a part of that night.
Samia Posadas
Yeah. It was very professional because we're working with the people who work in the Minskoff on a daily basis. So it was, like, really cool to be there with them and working alongside them. But, yeah, it was very organized. Organized chaos. I think backstage. I mean, you go into the dressing room and everyone's, like, running around doing things. So it was really cool to have that experience. Yeah.
Jake James
Yeah, for sure.
Paul Wontorek
So you. How many people in the. How many did. You've been at the Jimmy's before? This is your third year at the Jimmy's, right? This is your first time. Were you involved in musical theater your whole high school?
Samia Posadas
Yeah, I've been doing musical theater. I started taking it seriously my freshman year. So, like, three years ago. Yeah.
Paul Wontorek
Okay. And so. And you, too?
Jake James
Yes.
Paul Wontorek
So tell me, like, how many roles did you. So you were obviously. Let me get through this. So you were honored for. You both were honored for musicals that I love, that are kind of not big blockbuster musicals. But you played Jacob in Water for Elephants, and you played Alice and Bright Star. I love both of those. Both of those shows. So the way that Jimmy's works is that it's two winners from each of these regional awards. So you both won awards and you won. Actually, I was sitting across from Schuler Hensley last night, and you won the Schuler Hensley award. Fantastic Tony winning actor. So it was fun watching him. He was very excited to see one of his winners win. And you won. So you're from Atlanta.
Samia Posadas
Yes.
Paul Wontorek
You're from Georgia, and you're from Arizona. So you won the regional awards. And when did that happen? Like, when did those awards happen?
Jake James
Mine were on May 14th, actually. May 17th. Yes, May 17th.
Paul Wontorek
Okay, so it's recent.
Samia Posadas
Yeah, like, two months, a month ago. Yeah, I can't think right now, but, yeah, it was. It was very soon.
Paul Wontorek
So you, like, win the original award. You find out that. And when you win the original award, I have a lot of questions about the Jimmy's because I love experiencing it. So the people that vote in the original awards, do they see the performances or they see what you do at the awards show?
Jake James
It depends on the program. So, for example, for my program, we, similar to the Jimmies, we had an adjudication in front of our judges. Like, I think it was maybe a week before our actual show. And then at the ceremony, just like the Jimmies, we performed our medleys, and then they selected finalists, and the finalists performed their solos, and then they selected the winners. So that's how mine works. But.
Paul Wontorek
Right.
Samia Posadas
So at mine we do two rounds of auditions and an interview. We do a lot of things so that they know your character too, because they want to know who they're sending to represent the state. The winners are already decided before we even start working on the show.
Paul Wontorek
And.
Samia Posadas
And so that whole week is just about having fun with your fellow nominees and then you perform and it's just showing off. Like, honestly, you're not adjudicated there or anything. And then the winners are announced. So it's a lot more fun to have it in less of a competition atmosphere. Very different from here.
Paul Wontorek
I'm just thinking both of those roles, Alice and Jake, are very mature roles. Yes. Those are both like, very adult characters who have a lot of stuff going on.
Samia Posadas
Right.
Paul Wontorek
They've lived lives and it's kind of like the amazing thing about high school musicals is getting to see young performers inhabit roles like that. Is that easy for you to click into? I mean, Alice has a crazy story that we find out in Bright Star.
Jake James
Yeah, it was one of the most challenging things I've ever had to do or perform, especially just because her story is so rich and parts of it I can't necessarily relate to directly in my own life, of course, certain aspects and certain emotions and certain. Certain scenarios. She was 17ish when she got pregnant. And I think having the privilege of telling her story and the whole song, if you knew my story, everyone can relate to that. It's like you have no idea what I've been through. And I think that's always really important.
Paul Wontorek
What about Jacob? Yeah, he's a dark, dark guy.
Samia Posadas
Yeah. Very similar to Samia. I had a hard time relating to the grief aspect. And so I think this is the first time I attacked a role without really knowing how to go about relating to the character. So finding different ways to do that, I think was a really good learning experience. And I can, like, take that with me to whatever role I play next.
Paul Wontorek
Yeah, I mean, the Jimmy's are really a celebration of what, you know, theater does for kids in high schools and in schools around the country and the world. So I'm wondering, what is it like being in high school and carrying around roles like that? I mean, you just talk about sort of. It's like a whole other level that you're sort of working on at the same time as being a student. And what. And what does that do to your experience?
Samia Posadas
Yeah, I think you never know how a role is going to resonate with someone in the audience. And so hearing that feedback is very different because you expect things and then people will tell you something and you're like, oh, I never thought about that. Thank you so much. So I think working on those roles is really intricate in what the audience is going to think about it.
Paul Wontorek
Yeah, I feel like it's probably. You probably both have a lot going on in your heads, and you have the ability to sort of take on big roles because a lot of people maybe mistakenly assume that kids doing theater are doing sort of, like, lightweight things. Right. So it's interesting, the musicals that are being done, I mean, I learned last night Hadestown is clearly being done everywhere.
Tamsen Fadal
Yes.
Paul Wontorek
There's a lot of Hadestown nominees. So it's interesting the shows that high school performers are sort of digging into. I love thinking about that. And, you know, we really want to encourage. Encourage people and young kids to get involved in theater. Right. Were you scared at all entering? Think back to when you first started your high school careers. Like, what led you to those first moments of being like, I want to do this. You go first.
Jake James
All right, well, okay. So my freshman year, I was just in a very low place in my life for my first semester. And then my second semester was when I decided to try out for the spring musical, which was Legally Blonde. That year. And previously, I had only done theater third through eighth grade, I did one show, and it was always a Disney Junior show. So I did, like, Lion King junior Like Beauty and the Beast Junior like, et cetera, like all of those Disney Junior shows. So Legally Blonde was an incredibly monstrous task for me to take on, considering it was my first, like, quote unquote, real show.
Paul Wontorek
And I was past.
Jake James
As Elle Woods.
Paul Wontorek
Yes.
Jake James
As a freshman, as this little, like, five foot, like, Asian girl that's wearing a blonde wig on this stage. It was absolutely insane. But for sure, it definitely pushed me out of my comfort zone, both in my school, just because I was a freshman and I cared so much about what people thought at the time. So it really taught me a lot about myself as a human and as a performer in general. It was crazy.
Paul Wontorek
Wow. What about you? How did it start for you?
Samia Posadas
Yeah, I started, I think, in eighth grade is when I started the journey of, like, oh, maybe I do want to do this. Actually, I played Jack Kelly and Newsies Jr. And I mean, I just loved the role. It was the second time I did the show, but first time I played Jack and I just fell in love with the character. And then once I got to freshman year, I played Monte Navarro in A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder, and that just changed My life, like, I never had so much fun on stage, and. And me. There's the Dye Squiff family is another character, and we made. Had the best bond, and we, like, we became such good friends through that. And I was like, these are the people that I want to be around.
Paul Wontorek
Yeah. So it's really about finding your community.
Samia Posadas
It really is.
Jake James
It really is. Yeah.
Paul Wontorek
Yeah. What is it like thinking about those communities? I mean, you're sort of representing them by being here in New York and celebrating these. Obviously, you did these incredible performances in high school, but you had amazing companies behind you, and you both kind of acknowledged that in your speeches last night.
Samia Posadas
Yes.
Paul Wontorek
What is it like thinking about those communities and how those relationships sort of lift you up in moments like this?
Jake James
I think. I mean, at least for me, I have learned. So I don't think I would be the performer I am without my community and my true. My theater troupe back at home in Tucson. And I think in having the honor and opportunity to kind of perform, like, the role that I played in our school show at such literally on a Broadway stage at this high level is me. It's kind of my way of giving back to them in a way, because, like, parts of me as a performer are because of them. So therefore, I'm gifting that to whoever, whichever audience is watching me on that stage. And I don't think it's necessarily myself, but, like, I'm a mosaic of everyone that has shaped me, and I think it's beautiful.
Paul Wontorek
I'm thinking of a wicked song for good.
Jake James
Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.
Paul Wontorek
I mean, those emotions are true. The same for you?
Samia Posadas
Yeah.
Paul Wontorek
Yeah.
Samia Posadas
There are many reasons that I do theater. I think the main one is to inspire, to storytell, and to be inspired. And so to be able to be here representing the people who inspire me at home and be able to give that back by giving them that sense of I can do it too, and I can do this, and, like, I'm such good friends with them. I just feel like that's such a wholesome moment to think back. Like, this is where I came from, from Georgia, and these are the people that I grew up with, and that's just amazing.
Paul Wontorek
You both have incredible voices. I want to see you play all kinds of roles now.
Samia Posadas
Thank you so much.
Paul Wontorek
And I actually realized I saw you on Instagram because you're one of the many people who did the Nicholas Christopher. You nailed the Nicholas Christopher chest moment. Yeah. That got you a lot of Instagram attention.
Samia Posadas
It blew up, for sure. That was very unexpected.
Paul Wontorek
Y So I was like, wait a minute, I think I know him. Isn't it funny how, like, you recognize people in that way? Yeah. So that's a role you could do. Maybe just give some other as you could do.
Samia Posadas
That'd be a dream come true. Are you kidding?
Paul Wontorek
What are the dreams now? So I know you're going to usc. Congratulations.
Samia Posadas
Thank you.
Paul Wontorek
So you're off to California.
Jake James
Yes, I am.
Paul Wontorek
Yeah. And what are you doing in the fall?
Samia Posadas
In the fall? I'm going back into my senior year of high school.
Paul Wontorek
Oh, okay. So you still have another year. Okay, so. Okay. Wow.
Samia Posadas
Yeah.
Paul Wontorek
It's so crazy to think about, you know, what it means to be a high school performer. Because you talk about this whole process of these. You know, when you do a musical in high school, now that there are these local awards and you kind of know about this path, which is so interesting to think about, versus just like doing the school show.
Jake James
Right.
Paul Wontorek
You actually, in the back of your mind, like, wait a minute, I could end up at the Jimmy Awards? Especially if you've been here before.
Jake James
It's insane.
Paul Wontorek
Yeah, that's like. It changes the mindset, I feel like, of young performers.
Jake James
Yeah.
Paul Wontorek
But is that a good thing or a bad thing? Or does it add, like a pressure?
Jake James
I think for me, especially because I have the opportunity to go my freshman year. So it almost set some sort of precedent mentally. But at the end of the day, like, I'm doing it. Cause I love it. Not because I want to get to some level of this competition. You know what I mean? Like, I'm just. It makes me really happy. So wherever the wind takes me is where I'm gonna go. And it's brought me to the Jimmy Awards. So here I am.
Paul Wontorek
So usc.
Jake James
Yes.
Paul Wontorek
So you have a couple months now until I guess you're. You head out there.
Jake James
Yes, I will be there in August. Moving in Los Angeles.
Tamsen Fadal
Cool.
Paul Wontorek
How excited are you?
Jake James
I am so excited. I was just telling someone earlier that, like, ever since I was really young, I've just. I kind of grew up very fast. And I always was like, oh, I can't wait to go to college. I can't wait to do X, Y and Z and like, be an adult. And now that I'm like, growing up and I graduated high school and I'm actually going to college, it is like, wait, I don't know if I want to do this. And I was talking to someone also, because a song that I sang, where Am I Now? Is like this self conflict. And like, I am at a stage in my life where I'm like, what? Like, where it's very unprecedented. And, like, I think there was a lot of beauty in me being able to relate to that. So I am really excited for college, though, and I'm super grateful that I'm able to pursue it at usc.
Paul Wontorek
Yeah. By the way, that song is from Lysistrata Jones, a short lived Louis Flynn classic. He wrote that score. That's not a song that many people know. In the competition last night, the finalists get. Get your solo moments right on stage. You did Parade.
Samia Posadas
Yes.
Paul Wontorek
Which was beautiful. And I feel like the choice of those songs must be really important. I mean, it's really interesting to think about.
Samia Posadas
Incredible.
Paul Wontorek
Again, you both chose really good, meaty things. And, like, that was a rare song. So it made me, as someone who considers myself kind of a Broadway expert, I was like, wait a minute, wait a minute. Why don't I know this song? It took me like a minute to. To like, really lock into that song. So was that a big part of your decision making for figuring out that final moment in case it happens?
Jake James
I mean, you can take.
Samia Posadas
Yeah, yeah. It was really, really, really important for me singing that song. I'm from Marietta. That's where I grew up, and that's where that story took place. So to be able to actually represent that. And a fun fact. Leo Frank was actually in the trial. He was sentenced to death on June 21, 1915, which was the day before the Jimmy Awards.
Jake James
Wow.
Samia Posadas
And so when I went into the audition, that day of it meant so much to be able to tell that story. And I worked so hard to be as respectful and as representative as I could to that community and to be able to tell that story in the best way possible. So it really, really, really meant so much to me to sing that song on that stage.
Paul Wontorek
Well, no wonder these. These performances resonated. You had all that, and then you're talking about how much that song means to you. I mean, but I think that really says a lot about sort of connecting with the work you're doing. Right. It's not just up there singing a song beautifully.
Samia Posadas
Yes, exactly.
Paul Wontorek
So I have a question. Do you, like, bring the Jimmy Trophy to your new dorm for all your new classmates? Is that what you do? Do you make a shelf for it? Is there a special light on the Jimmy?
Jake James
I'm not sure. I actually have a feeling that I'm gonna, like, have all of my jimmies and my regional awards program memorabilia that I, like, collected throughout high school at my house and, like, I have all my, like, New York Times papers that the Jimmies put our headshots in. Like, they're all framed in my room. So I guess my mom will be able to admire that while I'm gone. Miles away.
Paul Wontorek
I love it. I have a few sort of rapid questions. So first of all, Broadway star, you're dying to meet.
Samia Posadas
Nicholas Christopher. I want to meet him so bad.
Jake James
Dying to meet. Dying to meet. Dying to meet. To meet Tom Francis.
Paul Wontorek
Oh, love that.
Jake James
Yeah, yeah.
Paul Wontorek
Okay. Most played cast album on your iPhone.
Samia Posadas
Waitress.
Jake James
Sunset Boulevard.
Paul Wontorek
That. That. Sunset Boulevard. Nicole stars. I got Sunset Boulevard. Is there a Norma Desmond in you at some point?
Jake James
I mean, years to come. Years to come. I am 18, but I saw the show three times. I love it so much. I love the soundtrack. I loved that cast. We'll see. I guess we'll see.
Paul Wontorek
I love that for you. What is the Broadway role that you could probably learn in a week and just go do the show?
Samia Posadas
Currently playing Broadway role, Phony Boy Curtis and Outsiders. I would do that tomorrow if I could.
Paul Wontorek
Cool.
Jake James
I would say Eliza and Hamilton.
Paul Wontorek
Cool.
Samia Posadas
Okay.
Paul Wontorek
I like these. Just throwing some ideas out there, everybody. And finally, what was the greatest moment of your time in New York with the Jimmy Awards, other than winning? Let's just talk about the experience of the full. Everything you got to experience while you were here.
Jake James
I would say, okay, so I'm a big person. I find so much joy in, like, the little moments and, like, the little things. And there was a moment when we were on a big bus tour with our little Jimmy pod group, and I was sitting on the bus on the top level with Jake James, and it was nighttime, and, like, we were going over a bridge into Brooklyn and we saw the New York City skyline, and it kind of grounded me. And I was like, wow, this is crazy. And I keep saying it was one of those moments where when you're in it, you want to stay there forever because you feel like you're going to miss it when it's gone. And it truly felt surreal. I was like, wow, I'm here. City of dreams. It was unreal.
Paul Wontorek
I love that because there's so many, like, 116 kids overall. So I was always thinking whether you two had a connection at all during the week, but I guess you did.
Samia Posadas
Yeah.
Paul Wontorek
That's awesome.
Samia Posadas
Yeah. From the beginning of the week, we were in the same boat pod. And so from then we met, it was great. Yeah, there was a lot of. Yeah, we were together a lot.
Paul Wontorek
Yeah. So what show could you do together?
Jake James
People are saying Miss Saigon.
Paul Wontorek
Oh, wait a minute.
Samia Posadas
I like that. I like that.
Paul Wontorek
I'm always down for a Miss Saigon romance.
Tamsen Fadal
Me too.
Jake James
Me too.
Paul Wontorek
Love that. What about your. What was your greatest moment?
Samia Posadas
Yeah, so I would say watching all of the other nominees perform their songs and, like, watching them shine, because everyone on this stage is, like, so right here with each other. Like, it's crazy how talented everyone is. And so watching them and being able to be inspired by them and, like, take things from their performances was just. It was amazing. Like, I got shivers watching people. It was amazing. Yeah.
Paul Wontorek
My favorite thing was, not that you asked, but I was sitting in a seat sort of to the side, and I could see in the wings, and I loved watching other everyone watch each other, like, watching the other students. It's really incredible. It's just a beautiful energy on that stage, and I'm so thrilled for both of you. Congratulations. So nice to meet you. I can't wait to keep seeing you throughout your career.
Samia Posadas
Thank you.
Paul Wontorek
And thank you for being here.
Samia Posadas
Thank you.
Jake James
Thank you so much.
Tamsen Fadal
That's gonna do it for this latest episode of the Broadway show Uncut. Until next time, I'm Tamsen Fadal, and this is the Broadway show Uncut.
Date: June 24, 2026
Host: Tamsen Fadal, with interviewer Paul Wontorek
Guests: 2026 Jimmy Award winners Samia Posadas (Georgia) and Jake James (Arizona)
This episode celebrates the 2026 Jimmy Award winners, highlighting the next generation of Broadway stars. Host Tamsen Fadal and correspondent Paul Wontorek interview Samia Posadas and Jake James about their life-changing Jimmy Awards experiences, their journeys through high school theater, the impact of community, and their dreams for the future. The conversation delves into their award-winning performances, the significance of representing their regions, and what the “Broadway of tomorrow” looks like through the eyes of these talented young artists.
[00:41–02:18]
[02:38–04:44]
[05:01–06:37]
[06:37–10:28]
[11:04–14:08]
[15:25–18:53]
[17:18–18:28]
This episode offers a heartfelt and insightful look at the Jimmy Awards through the eyes of its 2026 winners, Samia Posadas and Jake James. Listeners hear firsthand the exhilaration of performing on Broadway, the importance of embracing complex roles, and the lifelong value of supportive communities. The conversation is filled with memorable quotes, moments of laughter and reflection, and advice for aspiring performers. The future of Broadway shines bright through these voices, marked by their passion, humility, and hope.