Summary of "The Royal Treatment w/Sutton Foster! Plus, Jenn Colella in 'Suffs'!"

Episode Release Date: September 4, 2024
Podcast: The Broadway Show: Uncut
Host: Tamsen Fadal

Introduction

In this compelling episode of "The Broadway Show: Uncut," host Tamsen Fadal delves deep into the hearts and minds of two powerhouse Broadway actresses: Sutton Foster and Jenn Colella. The episode offers listeners an intimate glimpse into the creative processes, personal journeys, and the profound impact of their respective shows, "Once Upon a Mattress" and "Suffs."

Interview with Sutton Foster: Reviving "Once Upon a Mattress"

Embracing the Role of Princess Winifred

Sutton Foster opens up about her exhilarating experience portraying Princess Winifred in the Broadway revival of "Once Upon a Mattress." She describes the character as "wild" and "unhinged," emphasizing the freedom and collaborative spirit the role offers. [00:50]

Sutton Foster:
"It's been amazing. It's really been a delight and a joy. And it's really fun to play such a wild, unhinged character. There's so much freedom." [00:50]

The Collaborative Spirit of the Cast

Foster highlights the supportive and innovative environment within the cast, where each member contributes ideas and encourages one another. This synergy fosters a dynamic and vibrant production.

Sutton Foster:
"We all are giving each other ideas, cheering each other on. It's a room full of yes people." [00:50]

Physicality and Comedy in Performance

Discussing the physical demands of her role, Foster mentions a challenging three-minute sequence involving twenty mattresses. She balances the physical comedy with mindfulness to ensure safety and performance quality.

Sutton Foster:
"There's a little bit of mindfulness. Cause it is a very physical role... there is a lot of freedom and a lot of play." [01:55]

Connecting with the Legacy of Carol Burnett

Foster shares a touching moment of meeting Carol Burnett, the original actress who made the role of Princess Winifred famous. She describes the encounter as "surreal" and deeply meaningful, underscoring the impact Burnett had on her as a role model.

Sutton Foster:
"Meeting her was surreal because I still feel like that kid sitting in the bean bag watching the Carol Burnett Show... she gave me her blessing." [05:12]

Personal Insights and Inspirations

Reflecting on her journey, Foster speaks about her first Broadway experiences and the lasting impressions they've left. She recounts witnessing an understudy step into a major role during a national tour of "Me and My Girl," which sparked her fascination with the magical aspects of theater.

Sutton Foster:
"What's that? Like, what's going on behind the curtain? Like, what is that magical thing?" [08:30]

Working with Amy Sherman-Palladino

Foster discusses her collaboration with renowned writer Amy Sherman-Palladino, praising her humor and unique voice. Their partnership on the Encores production showcases a harmonious blend of tradition and modernity in the script.

Sutton Foster:
"Amy Sherman Palladino has... you know, maybe giving it an update... she seamlessly weaved a new little voice throughout it." [09:11]

Interview with Jenn Colella: Championing Women's Suffrage in "Suffs"

The Essence and Impact of "Suffs"

Jenn Colella delves into the political and historical significance of "Suffs," a musical celebrating the women's suffrage movement. She emphasizes the show's relevance in today's socio-political climate, underscoring the ongoing struggles and the necessity for continued advocacy.

Jen Colella:
"It's wild. The reverberation of these women's voices... it's something we need right now." [11:26]

Portraying Historical Figures with Depth

Colella discusses her role as Carrie Chapman Catt, highlighting the complexity of portraying a real person who balanced personal beliefs with public advocacy. She strives to present Carrie as a multi-dimensional character who was both a leader and a human being with flaws.

Jen Colella:
"She's very complex. But anytime I'm in the mindset of Carrie, I try to think you're doing the best you can." [21:36]

Personal Growth Through Historical Research

Preparing for her role in "Suffs," Colella admits her initial lack of knowledge about the suffrage movement. Through intensive research, she gains a deeper understanding of the movement's dynamics and the resilience of its leaders, which enriches her performance both on and off the stage.

Jen Colella:
"Learning about the movement and these women is helping me be a better person and advocate." [13:44]

Balancing Motherhood and Broadway

Colella shares the challenges and joys of balancing her role in "Suffs" with motherhood. She credits her wife, Mo Mullen, for managing their family life, allowing her to pursue her passion for theater while nurturing their daughter.

Jen Colella:
"Being her mom has definitely put things in perspective. There's nothing more important." [16:23]

The Perfect Timing for "Suffs"

Discussing the show's debut, Colella acknowledges the timing as pivotal, especially amidst the COVID-19 pandemic. The delayed opening became a lesson in patience and trust, ensuring that the show resonated deeply with audiences when it finally premiered.

Jen Colella:
"Had we opened all those times, it might not have been received in the same way." [18:25]

Influence and Recognition

Colella expresses gratitude for Hillary Clinton's support of "Suffs," noting how influential figures can amplify the show's message. She views this recognition as a testament to the show's significance and impact.

Jen Colella:
"Hillary Clinton quoted 'Suffs' in her speech... it feels very powerful." [19:43]

Collaboration with Shayna Taub

Highlighting the collaborative nature of the production, Colella praises Shayna Taub for her leadership and inclusivity. Taub's acknowledgment of the team's contributions fosters a sense of unity and shared purpose within the cast and crew.

Jen Colella:
"Shayna... she shares all of the collaboration credit with us." [20:41]

Conclusion

This episode of "The Broadway Show: Uncut" masterfully captures the passion, dedication, and complexity of two leading figures in the Broadway scene. Sutton Foster's portrayal of Princess Winifred in "Once Upon a Mattress" and Jenn Colella's commitment to bringing "Suffs" to life exemplify the transformative power of theater. Through their stories, listeners gain a deeper appreciation for the intricate blend of history, artistry, and personal growth that defines Broadway today.

Notable Quotes:

• Sutton Foster:
  "It's really fun to be silly. I can be completely free and do all those silly things." [01:37]

• Jenn Colella:
  "We are seeing some signs... this sense of hopefulness and joy politically that we have not felt." [12:11]

• Jen Colella on Motherhood:
  "She's made me love the morning as a theater person. It was six this morning... it's been beautiful and challenging to do both." [16:15]

This detailed summary encapsulates the essence of the episode, providing listeners with a comprehensive overview of the discussions, insights, and heartfelt moments shared by Sutton Foster and Jenn Colella.