Summary of "H&M's AI Models and the Future of Fashion Marketing" – The Business of Fashion Podcast

Episode Release Date: April 1, 2025
Host: Brian Baskin
Guests: Mark Bain (Technology Correspondent) and Hayley Crawford (Marketing Correspondent)

Introduction

In this episode of The Business of Fashion Podcast, host Brian Baskin explores the controversial decision by H&M to integrate AI-generated digital twins of real models into their marketing campaigns and social media presence. Joining him are Mark Bain, Technology Correspondent, and Hayley Crawford, Marketing Correspondent, who delve into the implications of this move for the fashion industry.

H&M's AI Model Initiative

H&M recently announced its plan to utilize AI-generated digital twins of real models in its marketing efforts. Chief Creative Officer Jürgen Anderson acknowledged the divisive nature of this decision, stating:

“[The AI model initiative] might divide people, but we aim to lead a conversation that considers the best interests of the fashion industry.”
[00:00]

Mark Bain explains that H&M collaborates directly with models and their agencies to create these digital twins. By capturing extensive photographic data, H&M ensures that models retain ownership and control over how their AI counterparts are used, including negotiations for compensation and usage in competitor campaigns.

Industry's Response and Concerns

Despite H&M's efforts to mitigate backlash by involving models in the creation process, the reaction has been predominantly negative. The initial response online and from industry insiders has been overwhelmingly critical. Concerns center around potential job losses not only for models but also for ancillary roles such as photographers, makeup artists, and hair stylists.

“There's a lot of concern that despite what H&M says, this will ultimately be used to save costs, meaning fewer people or lower pay.”
Mark Bain, [07:41]

Mark Bain highlights fears that AI integration could lead to a reduction in creative collaboration, which is deemed essential in the fashion imaging process.

“The communal creative process of creating fashion imagery is at risk of being lost.”
Mark Bain on conversations with makeup artists, [08:04]

Comparison to Levi's Previous AI Announcement

The podcast contrasts H&M's current initiative with Levi's 2023 announcement to use AI-generated models on its e-commerce platform. Levi's aimed to showcase a broader range of body types, races, and ethnicities without the logistical constraints of traditional photo shoots. However, Levi's faced significant backlash for perceived attempts to replace human models with AI.

“Levi's announcement was seen as another attempt to use AI to put actual human models out of jobs.”
Mark Bain, [04:05]

Evolution of AI in Marketing (2023 vs. 2025)

Hayley Crawford updates listeners on the advancements in AI from 2023 to 2025, noting that AI has become deeply embedded in various facets of marketing. The rise of a gig economy is cited, with AI accelerating task completion and reshaping job roles across the industry.

“AI has seeped into so many more parts of the marketing landscape, affecting everyone from models to creators of every ilk.”
Hayley Crawford, [05:37]

Personal Perspectives and Case Studies

The episode features insights from industry professionals impacted by AI's rise:

• Mary Irwin, a makeup artist, emphasizes the loss of the "communal creative process" inherent in traditional photo shoots, which she fears AI cannot replicate.

  “If you have one person sitting on a laptop typing in prompts, that's not really how it's going to work anymore.”
  Mark Bain, [08:04]

• Jana Sheptovitskaya, a photographer and creative director, discusses adapting to AI by leveraging it as a tool for creativity rather than seeing it as a threat.

  “This is the way things are going. It's happening. So, I’m trying to roll with it.”
  Hayley Crawford summarizing Jana's perspective, [09:10]

• Sibylle de Saint Lavon, an independent creative director, shares her experience using AI for campaigns with luxury brands like Hermes and Burberry. Despite initial positive reception, backlash emerged once the AI context was emphasized.

  “People do get very upset once you put it in the context of AI in the fashion industry.”
  Mark Bain, [13:20]

Legal and Ethical Considerations

Currently, there is no legal requirement in the U.S. for brands to disclose the use of AI in their marketing materials. However, Mark Bain notes that the EU is developing legislation that may mandate such disclosures in the future.

“The EU is putting together legislation that would require disclosure of AI usage, but it is all very much in the works.”
Mark Bain, [11:23]

Future Predictions

As AI continues to permeate the fashion industry, Hayley Crawford and Mark Bain offer their forecasts:

• Hayley Crawford envisions a dichotomy where low-end markets adopt rapidly produced AI content, while high-end segments maintain artisanal, human-driven creativity.

  “AI creativity or image generation that's just subpar and doesn't have strong human inputs is not going to survive.”
  Hayley Crawford, [17:05]

• Mark Bain anticipates a split in the market, with a proliferation of quick, AI-generated content on one side and a resurgence of human-centric, high-quality fashion photography on the other.

  “We'll see a lot of cheap, lower-end AI content and artisanal fashion photography with real humans on the other.”
  Mark Bain, [17:05]

Conclusion

The episode concludes with a reflection on the uncertain future of fashion marketing amidst the rapid integration of AI technologies. While H&M's initiative represents a significant shift, industry professionals remain divided on its long-term implications for creativity, employment, and ethical standards.

“It's hard to tell right now which jobs are going to be enhanced and which ones are going to disappear.”
Brian Baskin, Closing Remarks, [17:51]

Guests reaffirm the need for continuous adaptation and dialogue within the industry to navigate the evolving landscape shaped by artificial intelligence.

Notable Quotes:

• "This is the way things are going. It's happening. So, I’m trying to roll with it."
  Jana Sheptovitskaya
  [09:10]

• "The communal creative process of creating fashion imagery is at risk of being lost."
  Mark Bain
  [08:04]

• "AI is coming. We should try to find a realistic way to prepare for it."
  Mark Bain
  [06:25]

Further Reading and Resources:

• Mark Bain's Articles:

  • "H&M knows its AI models will be controversial"
  • "The Fake Fashion Campaigns that Show AI's Future in Marketing"

• Hayley Crawford's Feature:

  • "The Fashion Marketers AI Playbook"

Available exclusively for Bio Professional subscribers. Links can be found in the episode notes.

Production Credits:

Produced and edited by Olivia Davies and Eric Brea.

Follow Us:

Stay updated by following The Business of Fashion Podcast wherever you listen to podcasts.