Saul: The Tortured Soul

Summary

Podcast Summary: The Chosen People – "Saul: The Tortured Soul"

Host: Pray.com
Episode Release: May 20, 2026

---

Episode Overview

This episode of The Chosen People centers on the tragic fall of King Saul, exploring his profound inner torment after being rejected by God and the prophet Samuel. Through vivid narration and dialogue, listeners witness Saul’s spiraling psychological anguish and his desperate search for relief—culminating in the introduction of David as a soothing presence in his troubled court. The episode offers a stirring reflection on faith, failure, and the redemptive power of music and human connection even amidst overwhelming darkness.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Saul’s Downfall and Isolation

• Rejection by God: The episode opens with a dramatization of Saul’s confrontation with Samuel, emphasizing Saul’s acknowledgment of his sin and Samuel’s firm pronouncement of God’s rejection. (00:27–01:19)

  • Samuel: “Because you have rejected the word of the Lord, he has rejected you as king.” (00:27)
  • Saul: “I have sinned. I feared the people. I listened to them instead of God.” (00:35)
  • Samuel: “As you have torn my robe, so the Lord has torn the kingdom from you. He will give it to another…” (01:03)

• The Weight of God’s Absence: The impact of Saul’s rejection is depicted through Samuel's mourning and Saul’s deepening solitude.

  • Narrator: “Saul, in his solitude, felt the weight of God’s absence heavier than ever before.” (01:19)

2. Spiritual Desolation and Torment

• Manifestations of Saul’s Distress: The palace is shaken by Saul’s rage and suffering. His psychological unraveling is symbolized by violent outbursts.

  • Narrator: “A wretched cry shattered the silence of the palace halls, a guttural wail of frustration and fury…” (05:04)
  • Saul’s rage is both physical and emotional, his pain laid bare as he pleads with himself:
    Saul: “You’re the king. You’re the king, dammit. Act like it.” (06:19)
  • The darkness is personified as something “clawing” within him, “whispering venom into his ears.” (06:30)

• Voices of Doubt: Saul is haunted by internal voices echoing his failure.

  • Hallucinatory Voice (suggested to be Samuel or his own conscience): “You’re no king.” (06:54)
  • “Your legacy will burn. Nobody will remember you.” (07:03)

3. Family and Counsel Intervene

• Family’s Concern: Saul’s children and courtier Tavi express worry and loyalty, seeking ways to comfort him. (07:42)
  • Mishal (Saul’s daughter): “Father, you’re not well. What can we do to ease your pain?” (07:50)
  • Mishal: “We haven’t abandoned you, Father. We love you.” (08:04)
• Introduction of David: Tavi suggests bringing in a musician—David, son of Jesse—to ease Saul’s torment.
  • Tavi: “I met his younger brother…he is a skilled player of the lyre. His music was unlike anything I’d ever heard…” (08:50)
  • Saul is initially dismissive:
    Saul: “Music. What a waste of time.” (09:17)
  • Eventually, he concedes:
    Saul: “Very well. Perhaps music could help. Send for him.” (10:01)

4. David’s Humble Arrival

• Jesse’s Reaction: When Tavi visits Jesse to fetch David, Jesse is reluctant, reflecting his undervaluing of his youngest son. (11:15–12:39)
  • Jesse, reluctantly: “David will be in the presence of the king with his lyre in two days time.” (12:39)
• David’s Innocence and Compassion: The scene shifts to David, absorbed in humble farm work, unaware that his life is about to change dramatically.

5. Healing through Music

• Meeting Saul: David respectfully introduces himself to Saul in the gloomy throne room. (14:40)

  • David: “My king, I am David, son of Jesse, at your service.” (14:40)
  • Saul, weary and cynical: “I hear your music calms the soul, shepherd boy.” (14:58)
  • David replies with faith: “Only the Lord can calm the soul, my king. The music I play is unto him, and in his delight, peace pours forth.” (15:08)
  • Saul: “So you’re a poet as well? The Lord’s delight is fickle, boy. One day you have it, the other you don’t.” (15:21)

• David Plays: David performs a moving, psalm-like melody—its words underline faith in God’s protection and nearness. (16:31)

  • David, singing:
    “A thousand may fall beside me,
    10,000 may fade away,
    but I stand unshaken, for you are here…
    When I call, you’ll be with me through fire, flood, and pain.” (16:31–17:50)

• Effect on Saul: Saul’s agitation eases for the first time, and he drifts into peaceful sleep.

  • Narrator: “The ache in Saul’s mind did not vanish…but for the first time in what felt like years, its grip loosened just enough for him to breathe…” (17:57)
  • Mishal, Saul’s daughter, thanks David silently for giving her father peace.
  • David remains by Saul’s side, quietly tending the fire and playing as the king sleeps—a gesture of compassion and hope. (18:30–end)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Samuel’s Pronouncement:
  “As you have torn my robe, so the Lord has torn the kingdom from you.” (01:03)
  (A symbolic moment anchoring Saul’s sense of loss)

• Saul’s Self-Loathing:
  “You’re the king. You’re the king, dammit. Act like it.” (06:19)
  (Underlines Saul’s internal torment and lost sense of self)

• David’s Theology of Music:
  “Only the Lord can calm the soul, my king. The music I play is unto him, and in his delight, peace pours forth.” (15:08)
  (A gentle rebuke and expression of faith)

• David’s Song:
  “A thousand may fall beside me…But I will stand unshaken, for you are here always.” (16:31)
  (Echoes themes from the Psalms—trust, perseverance, God’s faithfulness)

• Narrator’s Reflection:
  “A man tormented, a king drowning under the weight of his own crown. As David played, he caught a glimpse of Saul’s daughter, Mishal. She stroked her father’s forehead and mouthed a thanks to David.” (18:10)
  (A tender family moment signaling the episode’s stirring conclusion)

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Saul’s Rejection & Samuel’s Decree: 00:27–01:19
• Saul’s Rage and Torment: 05:04–06:30
• Discussion with Tavi and Saul’s Children: 07:38–10:01
• Tavi’s Journey to Jesse / David’s Introduction: 11:15–13:30
• David’s First Meeting with Saul: 14:40–15:21
• David Plays for Saul / Saul’s Relief: 16:31–18:30

---

Summary & Takeaways

“Saul: The Tortured Soul” is a poignant narrative about the consequences of spiritual estrangement, the vulnerability of leadership, and the power of small acts of service. The episode explores how brokenness doesn’t make us unworthy of love or comfort, as seen in David’s gentle ministry through music. Through rich storytelling and raw emotion, listeners are left with both empathy for Saul’s struggle and a renewed appreciation for compassion, humility, and the pursuit of God’s peace amidst life’s darkest moments.

Transcript

[Instacart Narrator]

Lets talk groceries. Specifically your groceries. With Instacart, you want your groceries just the way you like them, right? Well the Instacart app lets you do just that. They have a new preference picker that lets you pick how ripe or unripe you want your bananas. Shoppers can see your preferences up front, helping guide their choices. Instacart get groceries just how you like.

[Narrator]

Previously on the Chosen People.

[Samuel]

Because you have rejected the word of the Lord, he has rejected you as king.

[Saul]

Samuel, please. I have sinned. I feared the people. I listened to them instead of God. But it was not my will. Please pardon my sin. Return with me. Let me me worship before the Lord.

[Narrator]

Saul's hands trembled. He lunged forward, grabbing Samuel's robe. The fabric tore.

[Samuel]

As you have torn my robe, so the Lord has torn the kingdom from you. He will give it to another. The Lord has already chosen him. He is a man that seeks after the heart of God more than the

[Narrator]

heart of the and Saul, in his solitude, felt the weight of God's absence heavier than ever before. Samuel's hands curled into fists. He had pleaded with God, had wept for Saul's soul night after night, waiting for an answer that never came.

[Saul]

How long will you mourn for Saul? I have rejected him as k Fill your horn with oil and go to Jesse of Bethlehem. Among his sons you will find the

[Narrator]

king I have chosen. At the top of the hill, he found the boy. He was under the cypress tree, half reclined against its trunk, fingers dancing across the strings of his lyre.

[Saul]

Arise, anoint him, for this is the one I have chosen.

[Hillsdale College Narrator]

How much are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness worth to you? This is the question America's founders had to answer. You see, for more than 150 years, America's 13 colonies governed themselves until Britain declared they had no right to self rule. So ordinary people had to make extraordinary choices and risk their their lives, their fortunes and their sacred honor to fight for independence. And against all odds, they won. And in victory, they built one of the most stable and lasting republics in history. Now experience the American Revolution like never before, thanks to our friends at Hillsdale College. Revolutionary America, a new documentary from Hillsdale Studios and narrated by Tom Selleck, brings the founding of our nation to life through the voices of those who lived it. Alongside insights from leading scholars and commentators. At a time when history is often distorted, this is your chance to see the story as it truly happened and ask yourself what you would risk for freedom. Face the decisions our founders grappled with in revolutionary America. A Hillsdale Studios film Only in theaters May 31 to June 2. Get your tickets now by going to Hillsdale Edu Revolution. You don't want to miss the opportunity to see this on the big screen. Go to Hillsdale Edu Revolution to locate a theater near you and buy tickets

[Expedia/Visit Scotland Narrator]

now for Revolutionary America Expedia and visit Scotland. Invite you to come experience the beauty that awaits in Scotland. The sweep of wild coastlines, quiet lochs and untamed landscapes. Fresh cuisine that feels rooted in the land. Come experience the kind of stillness that stays with you long after you leave. Plan your Scottish escape [e-mail] VisitScotland mom, can you tell me a story?

[Carvana Narrator]

Sure. Once upon a time, a mom needed a new car.

[Narrator]

Was she brave?

[Carvana Narrator]

She was tired mostly. But she went to Carvana.com and found a great car at a great price. No secret treasure map required.

[Narrator]

Did you have to find a dragon? Nope.

[Carvana Narrator]

She bought it 100% online from her bed, actually.

[Narrator]

Was it scary?

[Carvana Narrator]

Honey, it was as unscary as car buying could be.

[Narrator]

Did the car have a sunroof?

[Carvana Narrator]

It did, actually.

[Narrator]

Okay, good story.

[Carvana Narrator]

Car buying you'll want to tell stories about. Buy your car today on Carvana. Delivery fees may apply.

[Narrator]

A wretched cry shattered the silence of the palace halls, a guttural wail of frustration and fury that sent the servants of cowering behind doors and tapestries. The crashing of metal and the splintering of wood followed. Lampstands overturned, goblets sent flying clay pots reduced to shards. The night air was thick with the echoes of Saul's rage, a rage that had no target but struck everything within reach. The kings staggered in the dim glow of the dying torches, his broad chest heaving, sweat dripping from his brow. His face, once noble, was now twisted in torment. His fists pounded against the stone walls, over and over until blood seeped from his knuckles. He welcomed the pain. It was a distraction from the far greater agony within. Saul slid to his knees, his great shoulders trembling. His breath came in ragged gulps as he pressed his forehead against the cold floor. He did not understand it.

[Saul]

You're the king. You're the king, dammit. Act like it.

[Narrator]

There was something inside him, something dark, something clawing. He had known anger before, but this. This was different. This was like a living thing. A living thing that slithered through his mind, whispering venom into his ears, stoking the fires of his madness.

[Hillsdale College Narrator]

You're no king.

[David]

Samuel said so himself.

[Saul]

The kingdom will be given to another. Your time is almost up. Your memory will fade. Your legacy will burn. Nobody will remember You.

[Narrator]

From the shadows, a door creaked open. Saul's head snapped up. His swollen, bloodshot eyes darted toward the entrance of the throne room.

[Saul]

Samuel? Samuel, is that you?

[Narrator]

Saul's children entered with Tavi. His daughter Nishal had worry creased all over her face.

[Expedia/Visit Scotland Narrator]

Father, you're not well. What can we do to ease your pain?

[Saul]

I'm fine, my dear. I just. I need to rest, is all.

[Expedia/Visit Scotland Narrator]

We haven't abandoned you, Father. We love you.

[Saul]

I. I know. I know you do, sweet girl. If only a daughter's affection was enough to quiet this. This voice.

[Narrator]

Tarvy hesitated. He had seen Saul like this before. Many times, in fact. He had learned that when the king was like this, it was best to tread carefully, to step lightly around his fractured mind.

[Tavi]

My Lord, it's clear that a harmful spirit torments you.

[Narrator]

Saul's gaze flickered toward him, but he said nothing. Tavi continued, emboldened by the lack of an immediate outburst.

[Tavi]

I was recently in Bethlehem, speaking with one of your budding new generals, Eliab, son of Jesse. While I was there, I. I met his younger brother, and he's a shepherd boy, but, oh, he is a skilled player of the lyre. His music was unlike anything I'd ever heard before. It was. It was like listening to the heavenly hosts themselves.

[Narrator]

Saul scoffed under his breath.

[Saul]

Music. What a waste of time.

[Expedia/Visit Scotland Narrator]

Please, Father. It would be nice to have some music around the palace. It may do you some good.

[Tavi]

And this young man is not only a musician, my king. Why, I've heard that he is resourceful as well. He could be a nice shield bearer for you.

[Narrator]

Tavi hesitated, but Saw's dark eyes pinned him in place. Saul leaned back into his throne, the weight of exhaustion settling into his limbs. He closed his eyes and exhaled slowly. The rage still boiled beneath his skin, but there was no strength left to unleash it.

[Saul]

Very well. Perhaps. Perhaps music could help. Send for him.

[Narrator]

Tavi bowed and left. Saul did not watch him leave. His eyes remained shut, his fingers curling over the arms of his throne as another tremor of anger and shame coursed through him. His torment was not over, but maybe, just maybe, a shepherd's song could give him a moment's peace. Tavi rode into Bethlehem as the morning sun bathed the hills in gold. The dust of the road clung to to his robes as he entered the town, the hooves of his horse kicking up small clouds with every step. His destination was clear. The house of Jesse, the father of the boy he sought. Jesse was already awake, overseeing his household with a careful eye. He was a man of means, not rich like a Noble, but prosperous enough that his name carried weight in the town. When he saw a servant of the king approaching, his brows lifted in intrigue.

[Samuel]

First the prophet and now a royal messenger. The Lord must truly favor me.

[Narrator]

He stepped forward with open arms.

[Samuel]

Good morning, my lord, and long live the king. How might I serve you?

[Tavi]

I have come seeking your son.

[Samuel]

Of course. Eliab is always ready to serve the king. I shall retrieve him for you.

[Tavi]

No, sir, not a lieb. The king requires your youngest son. The shepherd boy who plays the liar. What was his name again?

[Narrator]

Jesse's smile faltered.

[Samuel]

What would the king want with him?

[Tavi]

The king has requested he play the lyre for him in the throne room. And there may be some other stuff. Service is required as well. That will be for the king to decide.

[Narrator]

Jesse stiffened, his nostrils flaring ever so slightly. He glanced over his shoulder toward the stables. There, crouched in the straw, was David. He was shearing a sheep, his fingers moving with precision, his arms flecked with tufts of wool. He worked quietly, humming to himself, unaware of the eyes upon him. Jesse turned back to Tavi, quickly masking his displeasure. His lip curled for the briefest of moments before he smoothed it into a forced grin. Of course.

[Samuel]

David will be in the presence of the king with his lir in two days time.

[Narrator]

Tavi gave a nod of approval, mounted his horse, and rode off. Jesse watched him go, his hands tightening into fists at his sides. The runt. The forgotten one. David. Jesse exhaled sharply through his nose and turned back toward the stables. David was still working, lost in his own little world. He had no idea that his life was about to change forever. The wooden doors groaned as David creaked them open, their heavy weight straining against the hinges. The throne room was dark. The iron lampstands along the walls remained unlit, casting long shadows in the corners. The fire pit at the center of the hall flickered weakly, its glow barely stretching to the far reaches of the chamber. David stepped forward softly, his lyre cradled in his hands. His footfalls echoed against the stone, each step amplifying the silence that surrounded the slumped figure at the end of the hall. King Saul. Even in the dimness, the boy could see the sheer size of him. His broad front frame was sprawled across the throne, though there was nothing regal in his posture. His head rested against his fist, his eyes dark and sunken. The firelight barely touched his face, but it glinted off the massive sword mounted above the throne, the weapon of a warrior king. The polished steel caught the glow of the flames, refracting it in sharp, shifting lines that danced along the walls. David lowered himself to one knee.

[David]

My king, I am David, son of Jesse, at your service.

[Narrator]

Saul's gaze dragged lazily over the boy, scanning him from head to foot. He rolled the cup of wine in his hands and took a swig.

[Saul]

I hear your music calms the soul, shepherd boy.

[Narrator]

David lifted his head.

[David]

Only the Lord can calm the soul, my king. The music I play is unto him, and in his delight, peace pours forth.

[Saul]

So you're a poet as well? The Lord's delight is fickle, boy. One day you have it, the other you don't.

[Narrator]

David did not answer. Instead, he lowered himself onto a stool beside the fire pit. He plucked the first notes from his lyre, a soft, quiet melody that hummed through the air like a distant wind. The music was gentle, not demanding attention, but drawing it all the same. Saul closed his eyes. The anthem David played was neither boastful nor forced. It was raw, unguarded, drawn from some deep well within him. The rise and fall of each note carried with it an unspoken truth, an invitation to rest, to cease striving. It was the song of the hills, of the still waters and open fields, the sound of the heavens stretching wide over the earth.

[David]

A thousand may fall beside me. 10,000 may fade away, but I stand unshaken, for you are here. No plague will come near my home, no darkness steals my peers. Your angels stand to lift me up. Your hands will keep me because I love you. You answer because I know your name. When I call, you'll be with me through fire, flood, and pain. A thousand may fall beside me. 10,000 may fade away, but I will stand unshaken, for you are here always.

[Narrator]

Saul's shoulders loosened. His children entered. Jonathan, young Ishbosheth, Merab, his oldest daughter, and Mishal. David bowed his head to all of them and continued to play. The ache in Saul's mind did not vanish, nor did the dark thing that lurked within him flee. But for the first time in what felt like years, its grip loosened just enough for him to breathe. The knots in his chest unwound, his heartbeat steadied. He inhaled deeply and let out a slow exhale. The King of Israel drifted into sleep. David smiled softly. He watched the weight slide off Saul's face, if only for a moment. A man tormented, a king drowning under the weight of his own crown. As David played, he caught a glimpse of Saul's daughter, Mishal. She stroked her father's forehead and mouthed a thanks to David. Carefully, David stood, taking care not to wake him. He picked up a fresh log and placed it on the fire. The flames licked at the wood hungrily, curling higher, stretching outward. The warmth of the room deepened. David sat again, and as the king slept, the shepherd played on.

[Production Credits Narrator]

This prey.com production is only made possible by our dedicated team of creative talents. Steve Catena, Max Bard, Zach Schellewager and Ben Gammon are the executive producers of the Chosen People. Narrated by Paul Coltofianu. Characters are voiced by Jonathan Cotton, Aaron Salvato, Sarah Seltz, Mike Reagan, Stephen Ringwald, Sylvia zaradoc, Thomas Copeland Jr. Rosanna Pilcher and Mitch Leschinsky. Music by Andrew Morgan Smith. Written by Aaron Salvato, Bree, Rosalie and Chris Baig. You can hear more Prey.com productions on the Pray.com app, available on the Apple App Store and Google Play Store. If you enjoyed the Chosen People, please rate and leave a review.