Podcast Summary: The Dan Patrick Show - 2024 NFL Regular Season Awards
Episode Details:
- Title: 2024 NFL Regular Season Awards
- Release Date: December 25, 2024
- Hosts: Bobby Skinner and Justin Pennock
- Network: iHeartPodcasts and Dan Patrick Podcast Network
Introduction
In this special holiday episode of The Dan Patrick Show, hosts Bobby Skinner and Justin Pennock delve into their comprehensive analysis of the 2024 NFL Regular Season Awards. Skipping over the usual advertisements and promotional segments, the duo focuses on key award categories, debating the top contenders for MVP, Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, Rookies of the Year, and Coach of the Year. Their discussions are rich with statistical insights, personal opinions, and spirited debates, making it an engaging listen for NFL fans eager to see how the season's performances stack up for these prestigious accolades.
Most Valuable Player (MVP) Race
Key Contenders:
- Lamar Jackson (Baltimore Ravens)
- Josh Allen (Buffalo Bills)
- Saquon Barkley (New York Giants)
- Joe Burrow (Cincinnati Bengals)
Discussion Highlights:
Bobby Skinner opens the MVP debate by identifying Lamar Jackson, Josh Allen, and Saquon Barkley as the frontrunners, emphasizing the statistical prowess and impactful performances of each player.
Bobby Skinner [04:23]: "MVP is probably one of the most interesting races in a long time. It's really between Saquon Barkley, Lamar Jackson, and Josh Allen."
Justin Pennock expresses hesitancy in definitively choosing one over the other, acknowledging the close competition.
Justin Pennock [07:08]: "I have a hope and I have a big speech that I want to go on But I'm not going to do that yet because I have to pick one Lamar Jackson."
The hosts debate the statistical advantages of Lamar Jackson over Josh Allen, with Bobby arguing that Lamar's superior passing yards and touchdowns make him the rightful choice.
Bobby Skinner [05:07]: "Lamar has 200 more passing yards than Josh Allen. He has 12 more passing touchdowns... Lamar is getting 250 more rushing yards."
Justin points out Josh Allen's efficiency, leading in EPA per play, which is a crucial metric for MVP considerations.
Justin Pennock [06:35]: "Josh Allen is leading the league in EPA per play and he is leading it by a somewhat good margin."
Bobby counters by questioning the reliance on EPA per play, advocating for total EPA as a more comprehensive measure.
Bobby Skinner [07:14]: "But it should be a total EPA, not a PPA per play."
The discussion acknowledges the tight race and the potential for a split vote, though Bobby maintains his support for Josh Allen.
Bobby Skinner [11:17]: "I'm shocked that it's even happened once with Peyton Manning or Steve McNair here. But we got to talk about Saquon in this too."
Conclusion: While both hosts recognize the exceptional talents of Jackson, Allen, and Barkley, Bobby Skinner firmly supports Josh Allen for MVP, whereas Justin Pennock remains slightly more favorable toward Lamar Jackson. The debate underscores the complexity of MVP selections, balancing individual statistics against team performance and overall impact.
Offensive Player of the Year
Top Contender: Saquon Barkley (New York Giants)
Discussion Highlights:
Bobby Skinner argues vigorously for Saquon Barkley, highlighting his outstanding rushing statistics and consistency throughout the season.
Bobby Skinner [15:36]: "There's no arguing what Saquon Barkley's done. Saquon's also played a lot more than Derrick Henry, too."
Justin Pennock concurs, noting Barkley's dominance over Derrick Henry in both yards and snap participation.
Justin Pennock [16:14]: "Saquon deserves it. I mean, there's really no if, ands or buts that you can come with."
Bobby emphasizes Barkley's nearing the all-time rushing record and his significant contribution to the Giants' offense.
Bobby Skinner [10:10]: "If Saquon breaks Eric Dickerson's rushing record and he doesn't win MVP, I'll be outraged."
Conclusion: The hosts unanimously agree that Saquon Barkley is the clear choice for Offensive Player of the Year, given his exceptional performance, durability, and record-breaking potential.
Offensive Rookie of the Year
Top Contenders:
- Jaden Daniels (Quarterback)
- Brock Bowers (Tight End)
Discussion Highlights:
Bobby Skinner presents Jaden Daniels as the frontrunner, citing his impressive dual-threat capabilities with significant passing and rushing yards.
Bobby Skinner [24:10]: "He has 737 rushing yards and seven touchdowns... That is not a small number."
Justin Pennock accentuates Daniels' high touchdown potential and efficiency, while acknowledging Brock Bowers' remarkable tight end performance.
Justin Pennock [24:47]: "Jaden Daniels is going to finish with over 30 total touchdowns... Brock Bowers catching a bunch of balls... but Daniels has had more of those moments."
Bobby counters by focusing on Daniels' rushing contributions, positioning him as a more versatile and impactful rookie.
Bobby Skinner [26:23]: "Jaden Daniels puts him as the clear winner here."
Conclusion: Bobby Skinner determines Jaden Daniels as the Offensive Rookie of the Year due to his versatile contributions on both sides of the ball, while Justin Pennock supports this choice by highlighting Daniels' game-changing moments and overall impact.
Defensive Player of the Year
Top Contenders:
- T.J. Watt (Pittsburgh Steelers)
- Miles Garrett (Cleveland Browns)
- Jared Verse
- Andrew Van Ginkel
Discussion Highlights:
Bobby Skinner advocates for Miles Garrett, emphasizing his superior statistics in sacks, tackles for loss, and overall pressure metrics.
Bobby Skinner [20:24]: "Miles Garrett has more sacks... his pressure percentage is 4% better."
Justin Pennock, however, argues for T.J. Watt's comprehensive defensive prowess, including his run defense and ability to force fumbles.
Justin Pennock [19:14]: "I think TJ Watt deserves it because I think overall more complete."
The hosts debate the importance of different defensive metrics, such as pass rush win rate, average depth of tackle, and run defense capabilities. Bobby highlights Garrett's edge in raw sack numbers, while Justin values Watt's multifaceted contributions.
Justin Pennock [20:35]: "Defensive player of the year is kind of like sacks matter more than total pressure."
Bobby Skinner [20:45]: "Miles Garrett is first for edges... his pressure percentage is better."
Conclusion: The debate remains split, with Bobby Skinner favoring Miles Garrett for his statistical edge, while Justin Pennock champions T.J. Watt for his all-around defensive impact. Both players present compelling cases, underscoring the difficulty in selecting a single Defensive Player of the Year.
Defensive Rookie of the Year
Top Contenders:
- Jared Verse
- Chop Robinson
- Kenyon Mitchell
Discussion Highlights:
Bobby Skinner supports Jared Verse, citing his disruptive playstyle despite a recent dip in sacks and tackles for loss.
Bobby Skinner [27:55]: "I'm still giving Jared Verse the defensive rookie of the year over Kenyon."
Justin Pennock concurs, reinforcing Verse's overall impact and consistency as a rookie.
Justin Pennock [27:55]: "I am too."
Bobby also considers Chop Robinson's impressive performance when fully healthy, arguing that his speed and power make him a strong contender despite some missed tackles.
Bobby Skinner [28:22]: "Chop Robinson has more sacks than Jared Verse now... he's a fun watch in terms of speed and power."
Kenyon Mitchell is mentioned as a high-performing cornerback but is critiqued for lacking interceptions, which often influence award decisions.
Bobby Skinner [29:17]: "Kenyon Mitchell... nine pass breakups... no interceptions will hurt him when it comes to award season."
Conclusion: Bobby Skinner and Justin Pennock ultimately lean towards Jared Verse for Defensive Rookie of the Year due to his disruptive presence and overall contributions, despite some recent statistical challenges. Chop Robinson remains a close second, demonstrating significant potential when fully fit.
Coach of the Year
Top Contenders:
- Kevin O'Connell (Minnesota Vikings)
- Dan Quinn (Washington Commanders)
Discussion Highlights:
The hosts evaluate the coaching performances over the season, considering factors like team improvement, strategic decisions, and leadership.
Bobby Skinner praises Kevin O'Connell for his ability to elevate the Vikings' performance through smart evaluation and timely decisions.
Bobby Skinner [30:11]: "Kevin O'Connell... teams with low expectations might end up with the number one seed."
Justin Pennock counters by highlighting Dan Quinn's successful transition to the Washington Commanders, emphasizing his positive impact despite initial skepticism.
Justin Pennock [31:13]: "Dan Quinn deserves it... he's bringing the team together and making significant improvements."
The conversation touches on Quinn's ability to instill belief in the team and O'Connell's offensive strategies, leading to a competitive debate.
Bobby Skinner [31:30]: "Dan Quinn kind of coming in here second, you know second life as a head coach. I think he deserves it this year."
Conclusion: Bobby Skinner advocates for Kevin O'Connell, citing his strategic acumen and the Vikings' rise under his leadership. Conversely, Justin Pennock supports Dan Quinn for his transformative work with the Commanders. The episode underscores the nuanced criteria for Coach of the Year, with both candidates presenting strong cases based on their respective team improvements and leadership qualities.
Comeback Player of the Year
Top Contender: Tim Patrick (Buffalo Bills)
Discussion Highlights:
Bobby Skinner briefly mentions Tim Patrick as a potential Comeback Player of the Year, showing a light-hearted approach to this category.
Bobby Skinner [32:00]: "I'm going to go Tim Patrick, shout out Tim Coffey."
The segment is brief, indicating that the hosts might not consider this category as significant compared to others.
Conclusion: While not extensively debated, Tim Patrick is acknowledged as a noteworthy candidate for Comeback Player of the Year, adding a final highlight to the episode's award discussions.
Closing Thoughts
Bobby Skinner and Justin Pennock wrap up the episode with their selections and reflections on the NFL awards, providing listeners with a clear outline of their preferred candidates while acknowledging the competitive nature of each category. The hosts blend statistical analysis with personal insights, offering a balanced perspective on the season's standout performances.
Notable Quotes:
- Bobby Skinner [05:07]: "Lamar has 200 more passing yards than Josh Allen."
- Justin Pennock [07:08]: "I hope they split it."
- Bobby Skinner [15:36]: "There's no arguing what Saquon Barkley's done."
- Justin Pennock [19:14]: "I think TJ Watt deserves it because I think overall more complete."
This episode serves as a comprehensive guide for NFL enthusiasts looking to understand the dynamics and debates surrounding the 2024 NFL Regular Season Awards, offering informed opinions and fostering engaging discussions on each award category.