Podcast Summary: The Dan Patrick Show - Episode: Devers Won't Move off 3B for Bregman (with Jared Carrabis)
Release Date: February 17, 2025
Host/Author: iHeartPodcasts and Dan Patrick Podcast Network

Introduction to the Devers-Bregman Situation

In this episode, Dave Portnoy engages in a deep dive with Jared Karabas regarding the Boston Red Sox's star third baseman, Rafael Devers, and his stance on moving off third base for Alex Bregman. The conversation centers around the implications of Devers' decision on the team's lineup and future strategies.

Jared Karabas [03:50]: "He won't move off third. Absolutely not. Won't do it."

Analyzing the Red Sox Lineup Dynamics

Karabas and Portnoy explore the potential scenarios if Devers had agreed to shift positions for Bregman, including possible trades involving Nolan Arenado. Jared emphasizes that Devers' unwavering commitment to his position has significant implications for the team's flexibility.

Jared Karabas [04:16]: "If Bregman signs with the Cubs, the Red Sox pull the trigger on a Nolan Arenado trade... Devers was cool with moving off third for Nolan, obviously he's going to be fine with moving off third for Bregman."

However, Devers' refusal to relocate creates challenges in optimizing the lineup, potentially leading to a balance where both players take grounders at third or adjustments in their roles.

Comparisons to Past Team Dynamics

The discussion draws parallels between the current Red Sox and the 2018 Atlanta Braves, highlighting how team chemistry and young talent can influence championship outcomes. Jared suggests that, much like the Braves, the Red Sox have a window of opportunity that could lead to postseason success, albeit with some unpredictability.

Jared Karabas [26:58]: "The 2025 Red Sox are most comparable to the 2018 Braves because that team... they won it without Acuna."

Assessing Other Teams in the AL East

The conversation shifts to other American League East contenders, including the Toronto Blue Jays, Baltimore Orioles, Texas Rangers, and Seattle Mariners. Jared critiques the Blue Jays' handling of key players like Vlad Jr. and Tristan Casas, expressing skepticism about their long-term strategies.

Dave Portnoy [24:10]: "If Vlad doesn't sign that extension with the Blue Jays, the Red Sox are going all in on Vlad Jr."

The Orioles and Mariners receive their assessments, with Jared pointing out missed opportunities and strategic missteps that could affect their competitiveness in the division.

Jared Karabas [38:34]: "How do you not make something like that happen? Dude, pop 44 homers. You guys need offense. Pay the dude."

Pitching Staff and Rotation Evaluations

Both hosts examine the Red Sox's pitching rotation, discussing the depth and potential of players like Garrett Crochet and Chris Sale. They debate whether the starting rotation meets the team's needs and how bullpen acquisitions like Hendrick Chapman might impact playoff scenarios.

Dave Portnoy [14:59]: "They have a good bullpen with Whitlock and Chapman, but the rotation needs to hold up."

Season Outlook and Future Predictions

Looking ahead, Jared and Dave express cautious optimism about the Red Sox's chances, acknowledging both the strengths and uncertainties that lie ahead. They speculate on possible playoff appearances and the team's ability to navigate the competitive AL East.

Jared Karabas [37:23]: "I think the Red Sox could fall backwards into an ALCS... they've got Bregman, a guy who's been there, done that and has a history of playing in the playoffs."

Personal Insights and Podcasting Life

Towards the end of the episode, Dave and Jared shift gears to discuss their personal lives and experiences in podcasting. They touch on the challenges of maintaining work-life balance, especially with the demands of covering live sports events and managing personal relationships amidst public scrutiny.

Jared Karabas [43:24]: "I've just been able to do a little bit of a mixed bag of everything, which is awesome."

Conclusion

The episode concludes with reflections on the dynamic nature of baseball team management and the ever-evolving strategies within the AL East. Both hosts emphasize the importance of adaptability and strategic planning in achieving postseason success.

Dave Portnoy [56:40]: "That's the beauty of this time of year. Teams are figuring themselves out, and it makes for exciting baseball."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Jared Karabas [04:16]: "If Bregman signs with the Cubs, the Red Sox pull the trigger on a Nolan Arenado trade... Devers was cool with moving off third for Nolan, obviously he's going to be fine with moving off third for Bregman."

• Jared Karabas [03:50]: "He won't move off third. Absolutely not. Won't do it."

• Jared Karabas [26:58]: "The 2025 Red Sox are most comparable to the 2018 Braves because that team... they won it without Acuna."

• Dave Portnoy [24:10]: "If Vlad doesn't sign that extension with the Blue Jays, the Red Sox are going all in on Vlad Jr."

• Jared Karabas [37:23]: "I think the Red Sox could fall backwards into an ALCS... they've got Bregman, a guy who's been there, done that and has a history of playing in the playoffs."

This episode provides a comprehensive analysis of the current state of the Red Sox, the challenges posed by Rafael Devers' position preferences, and broader implications for the AL East's competitive landscape. The hosts balance statistical analysis with personal anecdotes, offering listeners both informative and relatable content.