Podcast Summary: The Dan Patrick Show Episode: Hour 3 – Derek Carr Is Done, Best & Worst
Release Date: May 12, 2025
Host/Author: iHeartPodcasts and Dan Patrick Podcast Network
Description: In this episode, Dan Patrick delves into the recent retirement of NFL quarterback Derek Carr, explores the intricacies of quarterback evaluations for the Hall of Fame, discusses the NBA draft lottery, engages with callers about sports and personal stories, and debates the star power versus performance in basketball.

I. Introduction and Breaking News

The episode kicks off with Dan Patrick addressing the latest sports news, setting the stage for the discussions to follow.

II. Derek Carr’s Retirement and Quarterback Hall of Fame Discussion

[15:30] Dan Patrick:
"Derek Carr has decided to retire," announcing the unexpected news that has sent ripples through the NFL community.

Discussion Points:

• Derek Carr's Career:
  The hosts analyze Carr's career achievements, noting his four Pro Bowl selections and over 40,000 passing yards.

• Hall of Very Good Concept:
  Introducing a playful concept, Dan and his co-hosts discuss the hypothetical "Hall of Very Good," evaluating quarterbacks based on specific criteria.

Notable Quotes:

• Dan Patrick:
  "Derek Carr is in Paulie's Hall of Very Good. Good."

• Co-Host Todd:
  "Derek Carr is clearly not a Hall of Famer. He never won a playoff game. Not yet."

Highlights:

• Comparison of Derek Carr with contemporaries like Russell Wilson and Aaron Rodgers.
• Debate over Carr's eligibility and prospects for future Hall of Fame consideration.

III. NFL Draft Lottery and Cooper Flag Discussion

[25:45] Dan Patrick:
"Let's talk about the NFL Draft Lottery and where Cooper Flag might end up."

Discussion Points:

• Draft Lottery Probabilities:
  Teams like Utah, Charlotte, and Washington each have a 14% chance to win the draft lottery.

• Potential Team Assignments for Cooper Flag:
  The hosts speculate on the best and worst team placements for Cooper Flag, considering team needs and future prospects.

Notable Quotes:

• Co-Host Paul:
  "If you were fixing the NBA draft lottery, probably should use a better word than fixing. Manipulating the lottery feels nicer."

• Dan Patrick:
  "I got a good guess. Derek Carr has made $205 million in his career."

Highlights:

• Strategic analysis of how different teams might benefit or suffer from acquiring Cooper Flag.
• Listener polls and interactive segments to engage the audience in the discussion.

IV. NBA Polls: Celtics vs. Knicks

[35:10] Dan Patrick:
"Poll results are in. What do you have for me today?"

Discussion Points:

• Celtics vs. Knicks:
  The majority of listeners are rooting for the Knicks over the Celtics in the current NBA season.

• Must-Win Game for the Knicks:
  An overwhelming 88% of the audience believes that the Knicks have a must-win situation in their upcoming game.

Notable Quotes:

• Dan Patrick:
  "We're at 67% rooting for the Knicks in that series."

• Caller Marvin:
  "I think the Celtics need to win two or three championships to validate this type of run."

Highlights:

• In-depth analysis of both teams' performances and prospects.
• Fans' sentiments and expectations for the playoff scenarios.

V. Family Feud Segment with Caller Scott

[45:00] Caller Scott:
"My daughter Peyton wants to say hi really quick."

Discussion Points:

• Family Feud Experience:
  Scott shares his recent experience on the show, offering tips for future participants to enhance their chances and have fun.

Notable Quotes:

• Scott:
  "Make sure you dress brightly. I wore an orange coat and Steve went and changed."

• Dan Patrick:
  "Her answer was penetrate. And Steve was obviously gave that look that you know, we all know."

Highlights:

• Anecdotes about Scott's daughters' appearances on Family Feud.
• The viral moment that garnered over a million views.

VI. Hall of Very Good Quiz on Quarterbacks

[50:20] Dan Patrick:
"Let's dive into our Hall of Very Good quiz. How many quarterbacks have thrown for over 40,000 yards, 250+ touchdowns, and fewer than 125 interceptions without a playoff win?"

Participants:
Marvin, Paul, Todd, and Dan Patrick engage in the quiz, revealing insights about quarterback performances and their Hall of Fame prospects.

Notable Quotes:

• Marvin:
  "Aaron Rodgers is the second."

• Paul:
  "Derek Carr. Elite club."

• Dan Patrick:
  "So Pro Football Reference, on the Internet they have a thing called the hall of Fame monitor."

Highlights:

• Identification of Russell Wilson, Aaron Rodgers, and Derek Carr as part of this elite group.
• Discussion on why Derek Carr, despite his stats, may not be a Hall of Famer due to lack of playoff success.

VII. Discussion on Hall of Fame: Andre Iguodala and Draymond Green

[55:00] Caller Jake:
"Only three players from the NBA have not made the hall of fame and won a Finals MVP. Tony Parker, Chauncey Billups, and Cedric Maxwell."

Discussion Points:

• Andre Iguodala's Hall of Fame Prospects:
  Debating whether Iguodala's defensive prowess and Finals MVP warrant his induction.

• Draymond Green's Legacy:
  Contemplating Draymond's impact on the game and his potential Hall of Fame status.

Notable Quotes:

• Dan Patrick:
  "Jake, do your homework."

• Dave Seaton:
  "Jake is certainly making it his crusade to get Andre Iguodala."

Highlights:

• Clarification and correction regarding Chauncey Billups' Hall of Fame status.
• Insightful discussion on the criteria for Hall of Fame induction beyond statistics.

VIII. Final Callers: Paul's Best and Worst

[1:10:00] Caller Paul:
"I have two best and one worst. Best, my son Brandon making sergeant before 22. Second is scoring Nuggets tickets for my wife for Mother's Day."

Discussion Points:

• Personal Triumphs:
  Celebrating Paul's son's military achievements and his gesture of gifting basketball tickets to his wife.

Notable Quotes:

• Dan Patrick:
  "I'm scoring Nuggets tickets for my wife on set. Thank you, Paul."

• Paul:
  "I love this audience. For my son, for my wife. I got Nuggets tickets."

Highlights:

• Heartwarming stories that showcase the personal side of listeners.
• Encouragement and acknowledgment of listeners' milestones and efforts.

IX. Wrap-up and Upcoming Episodes

As the episode concludes, Dan Patrick previews upcoming topics and encourages listeners to tune in for future discussions, promising more in-depth analysis and engaging conversations.

Conclusion

This episode of The Dan Patrick Show offers a comprehensive look into Derek Carr's retirement, the nuances of quarterback evaluations for the Hall of Fame, strategic insights into the NFL and NBA drafts, and heartfelt interactions with listeners. Through expert analysis, lively debates, and personal anecdotes, Dan Patrick provides listeners with a rich and engaging exploration of current sports topics.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Dan Patrick [15:30]:
  "Derek Carr is in Paulie's Hall of Very Good. Good."

• Co-Host Paul [25:45]:
  "If you were fixing the NBA draft lottery, probably should use a better word than fixing. Manipulating the lottery feels nicer."

• Caller Scott [45:00]:
  "Make sure you dress brightly."

• Caller Jake [55:00]:
  "Only three players from the NBA have not made the hall of fame and won a Finals MVP."

Note: This summary focuses solely on the content-rich segments of the episode, omitting advertisements, promotional spots, and non-essential chatter to provide a coherent and comprehensive overview of the key discussions and insights shared during the show.