Loading summary
Transcript255 lines
- [00:01]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Why are we still seeing so many people with heart disease?
- [00:03]
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, it's still the number one killer around the world, not just here. And it's still the number one killer in women who, you know, they think that it's breast cancer. No, no, it's. This is it.
- [00:12]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
I concluded that one of the root causes, Mark, was this flawed hypothesis that we should have low fat diets to prevent heart disease.
- [00:20]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Cardiovascular disease is an inflammatory process that it's not just about cholesterol, but there's
- [00:26]
Dr. Mark Hyman
ongoing inflammation, chronic stress, loneliness, isolation, bad sleep. Those things are huge in heart disease.
- [00:33]
Dr. Cindy Geier
But we know that 80% of cases of heart disease and diabetes may actually be preventable with diet and lifestyle.
- [00:41]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
Most of us are walking around in a state of chronic stimulation. Your cortisol is elevated, your nervous system is stuck in go mode, and we wonder why we can't sleep or focus now. One thing I've been using that I generally look forward to at the end of the day is the infrared PMF wrap from Bon Charge pemf, otherwise known as pulsed electromagnetic field therapy. Delivers gentle electromagnetic frequencies into the body that mimic what you naturally absorb. Spending time on the earth combined with red and near infrared light, it's one of the few recovery tools that works while you're absolutely doing nothing. I throw it on for 30 minutes while I'm reading or winding down, and I notice I sleep better on the nights I use it. It's lightweight, it's low emf, it's free shipping, HSA and FSA eligible, and honestly, of the simplest things I've added to my evening routine. So head to bonecharge.com hyman and use the code HYMAN for 15% off. That's B O N C-H-A-R-G-E.com HYMAN and you'll get 15% off. Summer is supposed to be the season where we feel more energized. Travel and heat and schedule changes and longer days can actually throw off sleep recovery and stress levels pretty quickly. That's one reason I recommend magnesium to so many patients. Is involved in hundreds of biochemical reactions in the body, including regulating the nervous system, supporting muscle recovery, and helping your body transition into restful sleep. The challenge is that magnesium deficiency is incredibly common, and many supplements only contain one or two forms that aren't always well absorbed. And that's why I recommend magnesium. Breakthrough by Bioptimizers. It contains seven different forms of magnesium designed to support your brain, your muscles, your stress response, sleep quality, all in one formula. So go to bioptimizers.com hyman and use the code HYMAN to save 15% off your order. Plus get a free travel size bottle of their bestselling MAS Digestive Enzyme while the supplies last. As part of our summer series, we're revisiting some of the most important conversations we've had on the topics that matter most to our health. And few are more important than heart disease. Heart disease remains the number one cause of death worldwide. And despite decades of research, millions of prescriptions, and billions of dollars spent on treatment, many people still are confused about what actually causes it and what we can do to prevent it. For years, the conversation on heart disease has focused almost entirely on cholesterol. But what if that's only part of the story? In this compilation episode, you'll hear from Dr. Cindy Geier of the Ultra Wellness Center, Dr. Eric Topol and Dr. Sima Hotra as they explore a different perspective on heart disease, one that goes beyond cholesterol and looks at the deeper drivers of cardiovascular risk, including inflammation, insulin resistance, metabolic dysfunction, lifestyle and early detection. You'll hear why many experts now believe that heart disease often begins decades before symptoms appear, why traditional testing can miss important signs and that are warning signs, and how emerging science is giving us new tools to identify risk earlier than ever before. And more importantly, you'll hear a message that is both practical and hopeful and that many of the factors driving heart disease are within our control and that prevention remains one of the most powerful tools we have.
- [03:43]
Dr. Mark Hyman
So let's dive in. So let's talk about heart disease because we think we know all about heart disease. Oh, it's cholesterol and statins are the cure. And if that doesn't work, you get a bypass and angioplasty. And, you know, if that doesn't work, you get a heart transplant. That sort of. And then, you know, of course, there's all the normal causes we know, like diabetes and high blood pressure and high cholesterol. But diabetes is a symptom. High cholesterol is a symptom, smoking's a habit. And yet we're kind of missing the boat, I think, on a lot of the reasons we have heart disease and what we can do about it from a more systems perspective. So let's talk about just what a big deal this is and how few people actually are meeting the simple behaviors that will prevent heart disease.
- [04:32]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Yeah. Again, this is another one of those conditions that the debate as well. It's in my family, so I'm doomed to get it. But we know that 80% of cases of heart disease and diabetes may actually be preventable with diet and lifestyle. And despite that really powerful message, fewer than 3% of the US population is meeting the core four basic characteristics that predict low risk. And it's a pretty low bar, Mark.
- [04:55]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And what are those, what are those four things?
- [04:56]
Dr. Cindy Geier
It's not smoking, okay. Getting the minimum, recommended 150 minutes of exercise a week, eating in the top two quintiles of what's considered a whole foods diet, and having a healthy body fat percentage fewer than 3%. I still find that shocking.
- [05:11]
Dr. Mark Hyman
So not too much body fat, eating pretty healthy, little exercise, and don't smoke. Simple things to do, but like, we're
- [05:20]
Dr. Cindy Geier
not even there yet.
- [05:21]
Dr. Mark Hyman
3%.
- [05:22]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Yeah.
- [05:22]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And, and, and what's really staggering is that, you know, not only do people not meet those habits, but that there, there are some really other big factors that we, we are just so bad at in America. Our whole society is set up to actually cause heart disease.
- [05:41]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Absolutely.
- [05:42]
Dr. Mark Hyman
One of those things that really. Are these risk factors that besides cholesterol.
- [05:46]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Well, of course it's inflammation. I mean, you and I were working together back at Canyon Ranch when that pivotal study came out. I think it's been 21 years ago.
- [05:54]
Dr. Mark Hyman
I remember that New England Journal of
- [05:55]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Medicine review paper, Peter Libby and Paul Ritker, showing that cardiovascular disease is an inflammatory process, that it's not just about cholesterol, but there's ongoing inflammation. And as you've talked about many times on this podcast, inflammation is not. It's also a symptom that it can come from a lot of different places. Because in our paper, our local paper, when that article came back out, I don't know if you remember this, it said President Bush's doctors measured his crp, which is the common marker of inflammation, and they don't know what to do about it.
- [06:27]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Right, right.
- [06:28]
Dr. Cindy Geier
So it's one thing to say, well, we know inflammation matters. It's another one in time.
- [06:32]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Take aspirin.
- [06:33]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Take aspirin and a statin. Right. But it's another to say, well, what are the root causes of inflammation?
- [06:38]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Well, that's true, and there's a lot of them. And some of the things that we don't typically think of as causing inflammation. We know infections and allergens, things like that, even toxins and bugs in your gut. But stress causes inflammation.
- [06:51]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Absolutely.
- [06:52]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Lack of exercise causes inflammation. Bad sleep causes inflammation. Loneliness and isolation cause inflammation. And those are pandemics. Yes, in America, chronic stress, loneliness, isolation, bad sleep. I mean, those things are huge in heart disease. And we Often miss the boat on helping our patients really deal with those.
- [07:16]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Right.
- [07:18]
Dr. Mark Hyman
So, okay, so the typical person comes in. He's, you know, got a high cholesterol. He or she is a high risk for heart disease. Maybe family history. Typical doctor does sort of what workup and what kind of treatments.
- [07:33]
Dr. Cindy Geier
So a typical doctor might measure a glucose and an A1C to look at their blood sugar status, and they would do a standard cholesterol profile, which, interestingly enough, calculates your LDL cholesterol, the one we usually think of as being the lousy cholesterol from a formula, doesn't even really measure it and base most of the decisions on that. If they have symptoms, they might send them to a cardiologist for a stress test.
- [07:56]
Dr. Mark Hyman
If they have chest pain.
- [07:57]
Dr. Cindy Geier
If they have chest pain. Right.
- [07:58]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Or shortness of breath on exercise, it's already kind of down the road.
- [08:02]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Right. But most doctors don't measure a C reactive protein because as I mentioned before, it's like, well, what do we do with it?
- [08:08]
Dr. Mark Hyman
What do I do with it?
- [08:08]
Dr. Cindy Geier
What do I do with it? Oh, statin and aspirin. And then they're probably going to treat them with, if they are pre diabetic or diabetic, they're going to give them metformin or medications to lower blood sugar and probably a statin to control the cholesterol. How often do they actually talk to them about those root causes such as diet and stress and sleep? Maybe not.
- [08:29]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Yeah, they're talking about this poly pill as a treatment, which is this combo pill of an aspirin, a statin and a blood pressure drug.
- [08:40]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Yes. Put it in the water.
- [08:42]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Just give it to everybody. It'll prevent heart disease. I'm like, yeah, okay, well, why do we have high blood pressure? Why do we have a need for aspirin and inflammation? Why is our cholesterol all screwed up?
- [08:52]
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah.
- [08:52]
Dr. Cindy Geier
And, you know, it's really interesting. There's. Believe it or not, there's a potential behavioral component for patients who go on a statin and their cholesterol's now normal. It's good.
- [09:03]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Oh, yeah. I can eat my cheeseburger.
- [09:05]
Dr. Cindy Geier
I can eat my cheeseburger.
- [09:06]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Fried chicken.
- [09:07]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Isn't that interesting that people change their diet in an unhealthy way?
- [09:11]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Oh, yeah.
- [09:11]
Dr. Cindy Geier
When their numbers better.
- [09:12]
Dr. Mark Hyman
One of the worst things I ever read was there was a bunch of cardiologists advocating for selling statins over the counter at McDonald's and fast food restaurants.
- [09:20]
Oh, my gosh.
- [09:21]
And I think, I think they do sell even statins over the counter. And, like, you know, it's like. It's like those commercials for the acid blockers. Like, take some Pepcid, because don't worry, Daddy, you can eat your peppers and sausage.
- [09:33]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
Just take them.
- [09:35]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And I was like, no, don't eat the peppers and sausage. So, you know, you kind of mentioned they do a sort of a cholesterol profile, but there was a hint of a subtext in that sentence where they really weren't measuring the right thing.
- [09:50]
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah.
- [09:51]
Dr. Mark Hyman
So we tend to look at things
- [09:52]
that we're used to looking at that are easy to test and measure. But, you know, one of the things that I think people forget, and I think doctors honestly forget, is we get trained in this panel of tests, and it's your blood count, your metabolic profile, and your cholesterol. And we measure, like, a few things. Maybe it's 30, 40 things. Maybe if, like, it's a super fancy doctor, they'll measure 100 things. Like, and they think they're kind of checking everything. Oh, your tests are fine. Everything's great. You look good. And the truth is that they're missing a huge amount. There are literally tens of thousands of different molecules in your body, all doing things all the time, every minute, every second. And we ignore most of them. And we. In fact, we may ignore some of the most important ones. And when it comes to cholesterol, we've covered this on the podcast with Dr. Bohem. We went really deep into this. We just should just do a quick refresher, because the test that most people get, not the one we get here at the Ultra Wellness center, but the test that most people get is like an antiquated cholesterol test that doesn't really tell you a whole lot. And I have a patient yesterday who's a classic example of that. Right. So tell us about. And I'll tell you about his test in a minute, but tell us about your. You know, the new kind of testing that we're doing, it's not so new because we've been doing it for 20 years, but it's like. And the discovery that allowed for the testing was 50 years ago.
- [11:20]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Yeah.
- [11:20]
Dr. Mark Hyman
So.
- [11:21]
Dr. Cindy Geier
So the focus has been on amount of cholesterol, but we wanna know the quality of the cholesterol. So we know, for example, ldl, that's typically labeled the lousy cholesterol. There's big, fluffy, puffy pattern, a LDL cholesterol, which is less easily made into a plaque in the artery, less prone to inflammation and oxidative stress and rupture. So It's a less risky LDL, whereas somebody could have small, dense pattern B LDL, and that's the really risky LDL. So quality matters. And if you have two people with a calculated LDL of 130, one of them could all have pattern A low risk LDL, and they're actually fine. Somebody else could have lots of those dense particles that's not captured by the calculated LDL of 130. So the quality matters. The same's true for HDL. We've historically thought of HDL as being the good healthy cholesterol, but size matters there, too. Small HDL doesn't seem to be as able to cart out the bad LDL and get rid of it. So we want to know the quality and the size of both the HDL and the ldl, and we want to know what other remnant particles are floating around, like very low density lipoprotein and intermediate density lipoprotein. And those don't show up on a typical panel.
- [12:35]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Yeah. So practically what you see is people come in with when it looks like a normal cholesterol, like this guy yesterday has early dementia. His cholesterol I think was 1 60.
- [12:46]
Something.
- [12:47]
Sounds good. Yeah. His LDL was, I think, under a hundred. Triglycerides weren't bad. His HDL was 39, which is kind of low. But we looked at his particle number, even though his ldl, like if you're a regular dog. Oh, that's a great 160. That's a great cholesterol. They missed the boat because his particle number was, was like 1500. It should be under a thousand.
- [13:12]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Wow.
- [13:12]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And his small particles, which should be like zero or less than 300, is, you know, you can live with. But anything over that is high. His was 900.
- [13:22]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Wow.
- [13:23]
Dr. Mark Hyman
So he was like. And he was a skinny older guy. I was 84 years old and had, you know, lost muscle, belly fat, you know, underweight, over fat. And he was pre diabetic, and that was driving some of his dementia. But they go, oh, your cholesterol's fine, not an issue. And, and we also look at a lot of other things besides that.
- [13:44]
And by the way, you know, in
- [13:46]
2021, no one should get their regular cholesterol panel. I mean, you, you got insist from your doctor. You can get it from LabCorp quests called NMR or cardio IQ. It's, it's so important to do. And, and I guess, you know, the problem is most doctors won't know what to do with it once they find it. There's no drug for it. Like oh, your LDL is high, we'll give you a statin. It's like, you know, it's like we treat what we're, what we can easily test and find, not necessarily what the right thing is. And so with, with heart disease, you know, it really is a metabolic issue. It's, it's, it's, you know, you, they shouldn't be called cardiologists to be, you should be called cardio endo immunologists. Right, right. Because it's all about the hormones including insulin and all about the inflammation immun immune system. And you mentioned earlier that study by Paul Rittger and Libby in which it was sort of the beginning of the conversation. A lot of the follow up studies like the Jupiter trial, they found that if patients had a high LDL but they didn't have a high crp, their risk of heart disease was negligible. But if they had a high LDL and a high crp, that was the problem. So independent of inflammation may not be an issue.
- [14:55]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
This episode is brought to you by Rose Nutrition liposomal nad. Here's a real question. Why did two people the same age look and feel completely different? One is energy, sharp focus and is still running circles around people half their age. The other is exhausted by noon and can't remember where they put their phone. A big part of the answer is nad. It's a molecule your cells run on to produce energy to repair DNA to regulate how you age at the biological level. The problem is NAD levels drop by about 50% by the time you hit middle age. That decline is one of the reasons aging feels the way it does. And most NAD supplements don't survive long enough to reach your cells. RO uses liposomal delivery specifically designed to get it into your system intact where it can actually do something. Now, if you want to address the energy and aging problem at the cellular level, not just cover it up with caffeine, this is where to start. Go to ronutrition.com and use the code HYMAN for 20% off site wide. That's H Y M A N at r h o nutrition.com I often say that food is medicine. But there's another part of the conversation we don't talk about enough. How we prepare. Our food matters too. The warmer months are actually a great time to reset your habits. People are cooking more fresh meals. They're grilling, they're eating lighter, they're focusing on feeling better day to day. And one small but meaningful upgrade is paying attention to the cookware you use regularly. I've been impressed with Made in Stainless Clad collection because it's designed without chemical coatings and built for durability, for heat control and for everyday cooking. Their 5 ply stainless steel heats evenly, handles high temperatures beautifully, and is trusted by professional chefs in some of the best restaurants in the world. But what I like most is that it makes cooking real food at home easier and more enjoyable, which is one of the foundations of long term health. If you're looking to upgrade your cookware, go to maidenware.com and use the code HYMAN5 for 10% off your first order.
- [16:45]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And also you can get falsely confused by cholesterol tests. You've seen these patients who were, and I don't mean to stereotype people, but like, it was this kind of cohort of women who were probably in their 70s and 80s, who were thin, who were fit, the ladies we see at Kenya Ranch who like exercise, eat well, don't smoke, normal blood pressure, no diabetes, and their cholesterol is 300 and their HDL is a hundred and their LDL's like, I don't know, maybe 150 or something. And they have no small particles and they have all these large fluffy things and they're really no risk for heart disease. And they don't need a statin. Right?
- [17:24]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Right.
- [17:24]
Dr. Mark Hyman
I even asked Peter Libby, who's the chair of cardiology at Harvard, like, do these women need a statin? And they're like, no, they don't. We don't have any data to say that they do.
- [17:31]
And I'm like, oh, that's interesting.
- [17:32]
So we kind of have to be really personalized in our approach. And that's the other feature of functional medicine. Not like one size fits all. Everybody gets the poly pill, everybody gets the statin, aspirin and blood pressure pill. No, we have to start to think about what's the cause.
- [17:45]
And there's.
- [17:46]
Heart disease is a symptom, it's a syndrome. It doesn't. There are many, many causes. So let's talk about this whole idea of metabolic health because, you know, we were chit chatting a little earlier and it's staggering to me as a physician just how poor our metabolic health is. So how healthy are Americans metabolically?
- [18:07]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Yeah, not very. So a recent study was looking at the NAHANS Data from 2009 to 2016, Government Surveys.
- [18:15]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Government survey, our blood tests and health records and everything.
- [18:18]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Right.
- [18:18]
Dr. Cindy Geier
And trying to say, well, how many people are what we would call metabolically healthy? And it, if you're not Familiar with it. For people who may not be familiar with that term, sort of meeting the optimal numbers for a blood pressure less than 120 over 80, HDL levels being in the high range, a good range greater than 40 for men and 50 for women. Having triglycerides that are low, having a glucose that's less than 100. And they found that 12.12% of Americans.
- [18:50]
Dr. Mark Hyman
12.2%.
- [18:51]
Dr. Cindy Geier
12.2%. Thank you. 12.2% of Americans were metabolically healthy, which
- [18:56]
Dr. Mark Hyman
kind of means that almost 88% of Americans are metabolically unhealthy. And since 75% of people are overweight, there's another 13% there.
- [19:06]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Yes.
- [19:06]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Like what are the, what's, what's going on with the skinny people?
- [19:09]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Well, and that's the interesting piece. Fewer than one third of so called normal weight people were metabolically healthy. So that's another really important lesson.
- [19:17]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. Did you just say that 2/3 of skinny people are metabolically unhealthy?
- [19:22]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Yes.
- [19:23]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And have pre diabetes like syndrome?
- [19:25]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Yes.
- [19:26]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Two thirds.
- [19:27]
Dr. Cindy Geier
That's mind boggling to me.
- [19:29]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Okay, so that means that what, like 95% of Americans are metabolic?
- [19:35]
Dr. Cindy Geier
No, no, no. It's still the 88%.
- [19:36]
Dr. Mark Hyman
All right, but then we're looking at
- [19:38]
Dr. Cindy Geier
how strongly it correlated with weight.
- [19:40]
Dr. Mark Hyman
That's so terrible.
- [19:40]
Dr. Cindy Geier
So just having a body mass index that's less than 25 is not a guarantee that you're metabolically healthy.
- [19:46]
Dr. Mark Hyman
So if you're a skinny sugar and bagel eater, don't think it's fine because you're skinny is basically the bottom line.
- [19:53]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Exactly. Because foods have other impacts besides just what they do with cholesterol anyway. Foods directly impact the elasticity of the arteries, for example, which is another key player.
- [20:03]
Dr. Mark Hyman
You mean food is more than calories? Cindy.
- [20:06]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Food. Food is information, Mark. You've said that for years. It talks to our genes, it talks to our systems.
- [20:11]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Yeah. Wow. So you're talking about how the food impacts our metabolic health. And we're not really good at diagnosing metabolic dysfunction. I mean, 90%. I mean, okay, one out of two Americans has prediabetes or type 2 diabetes. And if you look at this new study, I would argue that 9 out of 10Americans have some degree of prediabetes or type 2 diabetes, like 90% of Americans. So when you look at that data, and you also look at the parallel data that 90% of Americans with prediabetes are not diagnosed by their doctor.
- [20:46]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Right.
- [20:47]
Dr. Mark Hyman
That's terrifying. Especially because this is a 100% reversible, preventable, treatable condition. And it gets worse and worse over time. And people just don't even know they have it. And doctors miss it because there's no pill to take. Otech, Metformin. Well, that's not gonna help. Right.
- [21:01]
Dr. Eric Topol
It's like.
- [21:03]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And so what are the kinds of ways that we look at these patients differently? What are the tests that we do? What are the things that we really focus on when someone comes in with a risk of heart disease or they're concerned about heart disease? You know, what's our approach? It's not just looking at the typical cholesterol and even crp.
- [21:20]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Yeah.
- [21:20]
Dr. Cindy Geier
So we would look at those. Of course, we would also want to know what is somebody's insulin. Most doctors measure glucose, but not insulin. I personally like to look at somebody's glucose trends over time because if you think about something that's preventable, you don't want to wait till they cross that threshold to pre diabetes or diabetes. So even in the range of so called normal glucose, Mark, you know this. Somebody whose fasting glucose runs less than 85 is in a very different metabolic place than somebody whose fasting glucose is 95 to 99. Even though they're both technically normal. That it's a spectrum of risk. And the farther along you march that spectrum, the higher the risk of heart disease and diabetes. So if somebody's glucose used to be 85 and then it was 91 and now it's 98, we're going to talk to that person right off the bat about all the things they need to put into place to prevent it from progressing, because they're already on that spectrum. We also want to know insulin levels. Not just a fasting insulin, but sometimes the insulin response to food, because the other thing that's emerged is insulin is a player. And way before somebody's blood glucose goes up, they might be pumping out tons of insulin to try to keep it in a good place. And insulin by itself contributes to inflammation and more weight gain around the middle, that visceral adipose tissue. So we want to know their insulin both fasting and in response to a challenge.
- [22:45]
Dr. Mark Hyman
So wait, wait, wait. Are you saying that sugar, not fat, that's causing heart disease and sugar, the thing that's driving the insulin, because fat doesn't cause insulin spikes.
- [22:55]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Well, there is some. I mean, fat is a player.
- [22:58]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Fat by itself.
- [22:58]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Fat by itself is a player.
- [22:59]
Dr. Mark Hyman
If you eat fat with other food, it will.
- [23:00]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
But.
- [23:01]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I would say, I would say that quality of fat does matter, and we can talk some more about that. But I think fat plays a role with artery elasticity, which is another component of vascular risk.
- [23:12]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
Yeah.
- [23:12]
Dr. Mark Hyman
So fried foods, trans fats, refined oils, those are nasty.
- [23:16]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Absolutely.
- [23:18]
Dr. Mark Hyman
But. But fat in itself, if it's made from whole food sources and nuts and seeds and avocados and might actually be beneficial.
- [23:24]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
Actually beneficial.
- [23:25]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Yeah. So what you're talking about is a set of diagnostic tests that are so important but mostly ignored. So the particle size and number, which nobody's doing, and the second is not just measuring your blood sugar A1C, which may be perfect and you may be in really bad trouble, but measuring also insulin in response to drinking, like a couple of Cokes.
- [23:47]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Right.
- [23:49]
Dr. Mark Hyman
I have a patient, Cindy, that I remember, who was at super high risk for heart disease. And she had. I mean, she looked like the Tasmanian devil. I mean, she was just like a round apple ball like this, and her belly was just like, this big thing. And I'm like, this woman is in big trouble, and she's inflamed. She's a high risk of heart disease, high blood pressure, diabetes. And I'm like, let's check her glucose tolerance test with insulin. This is, you know, this is, like 20 plus years ago, and no one was, like, looking at this. Even today, no one's looking at this. It's, like, so, so hard.
- [24:20]
I mean, it took 50 years from
- [24:22]
the time the guy said, hey, we should wash our hands before surgery for us to wash our hands. You know, McKinley died, President McKinley, because he got shot in the belly, and the Dr. McBurney stuck his finger in the wound to check it out without washing his hands, you know, so that's, like, crazy. It took 50 years from the time the guy said, let's do the stethoscope so we don't get lice jumping into the doctor's hair to start using the stethoscope, because the doctor used to put their head on the patient. So it takes forever. And we've been doing this. Anyway, this woman, I did this test, I gave her this drink, and it was the most shocking thing I'd ever seen. And it taught me so much about what we miss in medicine. Her blood sugar was perfect.
- [24:59]
Dr. Eric Topol
Like, 80.
- [25:00]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Like, and. And she took the sugar drink, and it was, like, perfect. Like. Like, it never went over 110 after taking, like, the equivalent of two Coca Colas. Oh, she's fine. Her A1C was perfect. Her insulin normally should be under 5, fasting and under, like, 25 or 30 after a drink. Her insulin was like 50 fasting and like 250 after a drink. So her body was just pumping out insulin, which was making her hungry, slowing her tablets, putting fat in her belly cells, which were basically inflammation factories and leading to this perpetual cycle. And she was able to lose £50 like that when we cut out starch and sugar. And I just feel like that showed me so much because you can even do a normal glucose tolerance test if you're not measuring, it's perfect. And if you are super hyperinsulinemic, you're gonna miss that patient's real problem.
- [25:56]
Dr. Cindy Geier
And, you know, it's interesting, Mark, because that scenario is also associated with that cholesterol profile we talked about with the small, dense LDL and low hdl and the sequelae that we usually link to diabetes. Fatty liver, peripheral neuropathy, all these other organs that are affected.
- [26:14]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And.
- [26:15]
Dr. Cindy Geier
And it can happen with the high insulins alone before the sugars go up. Yeah, it's a metabolic imbalance.
- [26:20]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Yeah. So that's really the take home here, is that heart disease is really a hormonal issue around insulin and insulin resistance and an inflammation issue.
- [26:28]
So let's talk about the heart circulation, because people say, well, that story's been told. You know, we've got statins, we've got this piece of SK9 inhibitors. We're all good. Like, what's the big deal? What should we worry about? It's just all about LDL cholesterol. What's new? What. What should we be looking at? What should we be thinking about? And, and, and why. Why are we still seeing so many people with heart disease?
- [26:50]
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, it's still the number one killer around the world, not just here. And it's still the number one killer in women who, you know, they think that it's breast cancer. No, no, it's. This is it. This is exciting because we do know the things that we've been reviewing for risk factors, but we have a way to now establish the risk. Are they really high risk without. Before they ever have heart disease? 20 years plus. And way we do that is we can get a simple lipid panel, add the LP apob, so a little more than what is the standard lipid panel. The LP will be part of a lipid panel in the next year or two. But anyway, when we get that lipid panel, which is, again, very inexpensive, and we can also get a polygenic risk score, very inexpensive. We can also get a heart clock. Right. And we can get inflammation markers. Anyway, now you have the full stack with your records and you know, and, and you have somebody who is well before they've ever manifest heart disease and you say, oh wow, this person is really high risk for heart disease. What do we do? Well, you get their LDL down, you know, not just to below 70, we go down to 20 or, you know, less than 30. Right. We have so many ways to do that now. We have these injectables that are against this PCSK9. We've got new drugs, five new LP drugs that are going to be out within the next year or so that are really.
- [28:19]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And we've had none of them. None till now.
- [28:21]
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, we never had one. We always tell, too bad your LP is over a hundred. You know, nothing we can do. We're going to be able to change that and that's going to have a big impact. We can get all the inflammation, get all over it. Right. In terms of bringing the inflammation down, we've already seen how GLP1 drugs do that before any weight loss. So that should work well in people who aren't even obese. And we've seen how that can prevent heart preserve ejection fraction heart failure, which is half of all heart failure. Right. GLP1s prevent that. So for heart disease we're seeing some really breakthroughs for the treatment, particularly the new target of LDL that we have five different drug classes, statins you've mentioned. But the, the PCSK9, we have three different ways to do that. Now we got other new drugs that are coming. Just recently, the CETP inhibitor worked really well on top of. So we got, yeah, we can stamp out inflammation. The other thing is we have a metric we never had before, which is AI. And by the way, that also goes with Alzheimer's. You can do a retina AI exam. So I have a picture of the retina and you do AI on it and it tells you when you're going to have Alzheimer's, if you're going to have Alzheimer's, five to seven years in advance. The retina also tells if you're going to have heart disease or stroke in advance. It will even tell if you're going to, you know, your calcium score of your heart arteries through your retina. Remarkable. And we should, that should be widely available. It isn't yet, but it will be. We'll be doing smartphone retina check someday. Right. But here's where we get a real kick on a jump on this. Because if you are concerned about high risk and somebody is say 40, 50, they have significant risk factors. You can do a CT Angio, which is now becoming very inexpensive. And you can look at inflammation in the artery. I go through this in the book. Inflammations in the artery without a narrowing. Okay, so the, the it basically it does AI of the fat around the artery and it, and this is something that was developed in the UK and it's now getting ready for FDA approval. This is a big jump because we always were.
- [30:41]
Dr. Mark Hyman
This isn't the clearly scan, this is something else.
- [30:43]
Dr. Eric Topol
No, no, clearly. And the other ones in the U.S. don't do this. But this is a, a Oxford University of Oxford spin out. I think it's called Karista. They're going to have that available soon. And I went through the data in the book. I mean they've had multiple papers. But it's striking. If you have inflammation without a narrowing, it's, you know, you, you could have 15 fold risk of a heart attack. So that's when you use that as a metric. Just like we were talking about the P Tau 217 for Alzheimer's. We've got all these new things for cardiovascular. We are going to get a grip on this and we gotta, you know, ideally start early. But you know, the lifestyle factors work really well. This is the most preventable known of the three big age related diseases through lifestyle.
- [31:31]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Because even without a lot of the drugs, like lifestyle plays a big role. Like, you know, I've seen data up to 90% by healthy diet, exercise, stress mitigation, sleep.
- [31:41]
Right.
- [31:41]
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah. I mean, is that, is that in the book? I found all these studies that I was really struck by that are recent that showed that if we practice the lifestyle factors that we've been reviewing with the details that we discussed, that gets us seven to 10 years of healthy aging without one of these age related diseases. I mean, who wouldn't want seven to 10 years of healthy aging? Just from the stuff we've been discussing without any, you know, magic potion or pill. So that's, I think people don't know about that. I didn't know about that. It's really impressive.
- [32:17]
Dr. Mark Hyman
That's powerful. So, so what you're saying that some of the advances in cardiology are more pharmacological that you're thinking are coming like the drugs that lower this genetically determined lipoprotein called Lp, which I've been checking for 30 years. Apob which I've been checking for 30 Years. I read some article the other day that was like, there's this great new test that can be more predictive of your risk of heart attack than any other test is Just discovered. I'm like, what is that? I'm like, look, click through the article.
- [32:43]
It's like apob. I'm like, oh God.
- [32:46]
Dr. Eric Topol
I mean, you only need to get it once and then you can tell that if you need to check it further. But you're getting at a key point here is it isn't just that we have better, you know, more armamentarium of drugs, but we didn't know how to get the risk down. You know, we didn't know how to say this person's really high risk for atherosclerosis because we didn't really have. We didn't use the polygenic risk score. We didn't have, as we do now, we're going to have a heart clock. We, we. So there's a big debate out there, as you probably know, how low should we go on ldl? Should we pull out all the stops? Well, if you look at all the data, the lower you go, the more protection. But you don't want to necessarily give people, you know, ezetimibe and statin and a injectable and all these things unless they really are at high risk. Then you go for broke and you also get the LP and you get the inflammation down. We have ways that we can do that and we're going to keep having better ways. So this is a striking. It's a combination of who's at risk, partitioning at risk and having a better ways to work on that risk.
- [33:54]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Just to play devil's advocate, because this conversation comes up all the time. You're a cardiologist, so your favorite organ is the heart.
- [33:59]
And so your idea is get the LDL as low as you can.
- [34:03]
But your brain is made up of a lot of.
- [34:05]
Dr. Eric Topol
Only in people who are at high risk.
- [34:06]
Dr. Mark Hyman
In people who are at high risk. Okay, so if you're really high risk. But like, what, what about the effects, for example, on the brain and cognitive function? Because the, you know, the cholesterol is a big part of your brain and sex hormones, which is what your testosterone is made from, is cholesterol. So how do you kind of navigate that and what's the truth then?
- [34:23]
What do we know?
- [34:24]
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, I mean, the statins are probably the most studied drug class in history.
- [34:31]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
Really.
- [34:32]
Dr. Eric Topol
Some of the data that comes out of these big meta analyses which say, oh, people don't get any leg cramps. That's not true. You and I know that's not true. People do get severe leg cramps where they can't even sleep at night, you know, and, and all sorts of other, you know, leg and muscle related symptoms. Now, with respect to cognitive and sexual dysfunction, the data really don't show a hit there at all. And in fact, you know, I think that we have some data to suggest the chances of having dementia in people. And Alzheimer's, as, you know, accounts for 70% of dementia, that if you, if you don't have the LDL lowered to, let's say less than 100, less than 70, you're going to be at higher risk for dementia. So if anything, the data support statins and, you know, the data for sexual dysfunction, it's again, some of that's vascular. And it mo. If it's vascular, we're talking about atherosclerotis. And that again, is going to be ameliorated with. And of course, we don't have to just rely on statins. A lot of people do have side effects from statins, no matter what. The group at Oxford keeps saying that everyone can take a statin and it's just, you know, it's mental if they can't. When I wrote a, when I wrote an op ed in the New York Times like a decade ago, and I called out the diabetes from statins. Okay, because if you take a very potent statin, you have a higher risk of developing type 2 diabetes, right?
- [36:11]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Yeah.
- [36:11]
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh, did I get slammed by my cardiology colleagues for that? I think. Well, wait a minute. That's the data, folks. I'm sorry. And over the years, we've seen many more reports about, you know, the potent statins, high doses, where you get a higher risk. And you know what? Most physicians are not keeping up with this. They're not watching their patients to see if their glucose, glycohemoglobin, you know, A1C or fasting glucose. And this is bothersome to me because that is a side effect of statins, particularly potent statins. So again, this is important because if we're going to lower LDL and pull out all the stops and, you know, high doses of Rosuvastatin Crestor or atorvastatin Lipitor, that could also raise the risk of that person developing type 2 diabetes, we don't want to do that. And we have cardiologists, my colleagues, they are, you know, really sold on statins and they basically ignore this, this diabetes issue. And did I ever take grief?
- [37:10]
Dr. Mark Hyman
No, I agree, I agree with you. And I think, I think there's, there's a concern I have around its effect on mitochondrial function. And some of the data I've Seen that even in people without muscle pain, even without elevated muscle enzymes, that there's mitochondrial damage on muscle biopsies. And for me, mitochondria are so key to healthy aging in the brain, in everything from Parkinson's to Alzheimer to heart disease, diabetes. Diabetics have poor, poorly functioning mitochondria that may be part of why it causes it. And so I'm wondering, some of these other drugs that are coming down the pike, even though some of them are expensive, maybe a better solution?
- [37:47]
Dr. Eric Topol
Well, people that have clear cut adverse effects, you know, the, the PCSK9 injectable drugs are a winner because they're potent and they have not been associated with diabetes, which is really interesting. They have not been associated with cognitive or other side effects. So most insurers cover that now. We, you know, went through years where it was a. Because they were so expensive, the cost has come down. So as long as people have the right indication where they have significant side effects or they need to have their LDL substantially lowered, it's usually not a financial stress for most people.
- [38:27]
Dr. Mark Hyman
So heart disease, still, it's lifestyle. But then there's a cocktail of other drugs in very high risk patients that
- [38:32]
you can detect early.
- [38:33]
They figure out. And, and what about lipoprotein fractionation, which is a lab test that we include as part of Function Health as well as APOB and LPA, something I've been testing for 30 years. But do you think that's as important? Because to me, the particle number and particle size story is important and it's a sort of a clue that there's insulin resistance, which is one of the biggest drivers of heart disease and all the other age related diseases.
- [38:56]
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, I mean, I think it's these mild, potentially mild incremental information. I just don't see that it has nearly the impact of just zeroing in on LDL and lp. And I do recommend that everybody get an APOB at least once and then you can figure out whether that needs to be further assessed. These other things, you know, it's an additional expense. I just haven't seen the value. But you know, I have colleagues that are lipidologists that test every known particle to mankind. Right. I just haven't, I haven't really seen the benefit because it doesn't change. Usually to me, I got to know the person's risk and then I'm going to go after inflammation, I'm going to work on their lifestyle and if necessary, you know, get their LDL down as low as possible. So the, the other things just don't have a, for me, a added value. But I do know there are people that are, you know, wild and crazy on every particle. Small, large, dense, you know, you name it out there.
- [39:59]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Yeah, yeah, so I hear you on that. I think it, you know, sometimes more information isn't always better, but, you know, then what is the most important information? I think you cover that in your
- [40:06]
book and I think, you know, we're
- [40:07]
going down the kind of the Horsemen of the Apocalypse, you know, the, the, the, the heart disease, the cancer, the, the dementia. I think diabetes is sort of all in there related. But you're talking about how there's kind of a newer, with the advances in our diagnostics, whether it's imaging or retinal scans or new new ways we can measure dementia, biomarkers we never had before. Cancer we'll get into in a sec. That these diseases can become more optional, like they're not inevitable and that we have more agency than we ever had before, given what we know now.
- [40:43]
And when you layer up what we're
- [40:45]
learning with AI and using multimodal treatments, we're really able to actually make a big dent if people really understood how to navigate this. And the sad part is that, you know, you spend your time thinking about what's coming. Most physicians are just trying to deal with the onslaught of what is and don't have the bandwidth to actually apply this stuff until it kind of is way often decades later. And so I really appreciate your sort of paying attention to, you know, what's happening and keeping your nose the scent of where things are emerging because otherwise people just don't know. And doctors, like you said, don't know. And the average person doesn't know. But this is such a hopeful message and I'd love you to sort of
- [41:26]
unpack how you came to go from being a trained cardiologist who basically swallowed the gospel.
- [41:34]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Yeah.
- [41:35]
Dr. Mark Hyman
To one who understands and has looked at the literature and has come to a different conclusion. Because it's not just that you're anti drug or you're anti medical care, anti the system. You're for the truth and for science and for an objective loop. Look at the facts. So the question I have is how did you go from being a trained cardiologist who believed in statins, to one who started to question statins, to one who's come to understand that our approach to cardiovasculars might be a little bit misguided? And we'll talk about what the right approach should be later.
- [42:06]
But I, I kind of want to start with Unpack, unpack the science for us.
- [42:09]
Cause everybody listening has no, has heard if their cholesterol's high to take a statin.
- [42:14]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Sure.
- [42:15]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And if statins cause side effects, which
- [42:17]
they do for a lot of people, probably 20% get some muscle damage or some symptoms or increase the risk of
- [42:22]
diabetes, you know, we'll talk about that data.
- [42:24]
There's still, there's still a huge drive in our society for prescribing these and globally.
- [42:30]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Yeah, absolutely. So my interest in this came from really looking at the, initially the obesity epidemic. So 2004, WHO announced it as an epidemic. You know, by 2010 I was in nine years qualified as a doctor. I was specialist registrar in my cardiology training. I was seeing more people this viscerally, I'm very sensitive to, how to put it, suffering around me if you like, but also seeing my colleagues under more stress in the system. And I was like, hold on a minute, if we carry on down this trajectory, the whole healthcare system is going to collapse. We want me to even manage people acutely if they are ill. Right. I never thought that would happen and ultimately that two of my parents basically died because of failures in the system because the system's under so much stress. Right. Never predicted that would happen, but that's where I started from. And when I looked into the issue of obesity, you know, I, I, I concluded that one of the root causes, Mark, if not the main root cause, was this, was this flawed hypothesis that we should have low fat diets to prevent heart disease. Food industry exploited that increasing sugar intake, increasing refined carbohydrate intake. It became quite clear there was a clear correlation between that change in guidance in the late 70s in the US and early 80s in the UK when the obesity epidemic started to then, you know, take its trajectory down the wrong way.
- [43:51]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
In 2011, I visited a farm in southern Spain and ate grilled seed bream harvested that morning from an 8,000 acre restored wetland estuary. Flamingos flew 150 miles just to eat the fish. I wrote about it that week and called it a model for the future of food. I've been waiting for someone to make that model accessible ever since. That farm is still operating today. Same family, same management team. Dan Barber featured in his TED talk and still serves it at his restaurant Blue Hill. And it's one of the farm Seatopia sources from every Seatopia product meets the Seatopia standard. Third party lab tested, certificate of analysis published for every batch. I eat their King standard at least twice a week. One serving delivers 3414mg of verified EPA and DHA. More than most people get in a week of supplements in a single meal. In the forms your brain and body actually use. When I eat Seatopia, I can relax. That's food is medicine. Free shipping on your first order at Seatopia. Fish Hyman. That's H Y M A N. If you're like me and tend to sleep hot, you know, the summer months can make staying comfortable at night a lot harder. As a result, I found myself paying a lot more attention to the fabrics I use every day, especially the ones I'm sleeping in. Cozy. Earth's bamboo sheet set has been a game changer for me. The fabric is soft and noticeably cooler, so I'm not waking up overheated in the middle of the night. I've also been reaching for their all day tea a lot lately. It's soft, it's lightweight, and it still feels comfortable, even on long, hot days. Sometimes the small things in your life can have a bigger impact on how you feel than most people realize, especially when it comes to comfort to sleep quality. If you're looking to upgrade your daily essentials, head to cozyearth.com hyman and receive 20% off.
- [45:29]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Yeah, and I covered a lot of
- [45:30]
this in my book Eat Fat, Get Thin, which we sort of unpacked the whole history of how we got this low fat craze.
- [45:35]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Yeah.
- [45:35]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Led to this high sugar starch craze that then led to this dramatic rise in obesity, which now, of course, we're treating with another drug, the GLP1 agonists. And, you know, tirzepatide and semaglutide or zempic and mounjaro. It's kind of crazy, right? You just kind of flipped it upside down.
- [45:49]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Oh, absolutely. So. So when I looked at that and started looking at the data and spending years and months and years looking at it and looking at different bits of data, I was able to put it all together. And I wrote a piece in The BMJ in 2013 called saturated fat Is not the Major Issue. Right.
- [46:02]
Dr. Mark Hyman
I read it. That's how I first came across it.
- [46:03]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Yeah. And that got a lot of attention. Right. It was international news and British news and CNN International and whatever, you know, because obviously, suddenly you've got a cardiologist busting this myth that we think butter has been bad for our cholesterol. But when I did that, okay, so what? I looked at the data and it was very clear. There was no clear association with saturated fat consumption. And Heart disease. So if that's true, then, and we know saturated fat raises LDL cholesterol, that means LDL cholesterol can't be that important. So, and if LDL cholesterol or total cholesterol isn't that important as a risk factor, how do statins work? But I knew statins had a separate effect on lowering cholesterol, which is their anti inflammatory and their anti clotting. And I knew this even it's well known within cardiology circles. You know, I trained as an interventional cardiologist and that means keyhole heart surgery stents, for example, patient comes in, we didn't even check their cholesterol. Maybe some of the thinking was the lower the better, which we'll come on to as well. So it doesn't matter what their cholesterol. Starting from the lower your cholesterol, the better. In fact, 2011, our cardiologist, one of the editors, I think of the American Journal of Cardiology, wrote an article which I mentioned in my book A Statin Free Life, which was entitled it's the Cholesterol Stupid.
- [47:10]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Right.
- [47:10]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
And what did he say in that? He said, you can be an obese diabetic smoker that doesn't exercise. Sounds crazy, but as long as your cholesterol is low enough, you're not going
- [47:20]
Dr. Mark Hyman
to get a heart disease.
- [47:21]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
You're not going to get heart disease.
- [47:22]
Dr. Mark Hyman
That's crazy.
- [47:23]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Like really. So, okay, I had to unpick that and, and, and what I, what I also then did moving forward from 2000. So that's how I got down this track, realizing that our obsession with LDL lowering has been.
- [47:35]
Dr. Mark Hyman
So you looked at the saturated fat literature and you weren't impressed. And data showed that it didn't seem
- [47:39]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
both observational data and randomized control trials, no benefit like in lowering it. No association, nothing. Right, right. And when you look at all the data, so that was the first sort of bit that I was okay, some
- [47:50]
Dr. Mark Hyman
might even be protective, like some of the dairy fat.
- [47:52]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Well, we know now, yes, there some suggestion that dairy fat could be protective. Absolutely. So there's all that. And then coming back to the LDL
- [48:00]
Dr. Mark Hyman
hypothesis, by the way, you're not alone on this. I mean there was a major paper published by Dariush Mazaffari and from Tufts and others looking at butter and actually showing that there really wasn't evidence that
- [48:09]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
it was so Mark, this is what's interesting. That article I wrote because creates such a, you know, a lot of headlines and backlash or whatever else. That's when people Like Darius started looking at this again. So it was all really, from the back of that BMJ piece, it all came together. So then everybody's like, you know, I know. And at the time I was, I was writing just a commentary which was peer reviewed. But I could have got it wrong. I could have. But I was like, you know what? There's enough here for me to provoke the thoughts, right? And then it all get. Got proven that, you know, what I'd written had validity. Right. Which is good. But the other aspect of this, if we go back and you mentioned cholesterol, so the. So is cholesterol. So is high cholesterol a risk factor for heart disease? And is LDL cholesterol risk factor? So you have to go back to square one, right? So these are the Framingham studies that, you know, started in Massachusetts in 1948 and went over decades looking at thousands of people where a lot of risk factors emerged for heart disease, whether it's diabetes, high blood pressure, smoking, for example. Now high cholesterol and high cholesterol, right? So you go and look back at the Framingham studies and what. And the. Just to summarize it without complicating the situation too much, William Castelli is a cardiologist and he published, he was a co director of Framingham and in 1996 he published in one of the cardiology major, cardiology journeys, a summary of Framingham specifically looking at LDL cholesterol. Let's just, let's just look at ldl because that is the so called bad cholesterol. And he said from Framingham, unless your LDL was above 7.8 millimoles, which by the way, I think in your units is probably 250 or 300. 250, probably. I think maybe we can look it up and calculate. But let's just say for argument's sake, around 250, which is very, very high, by the way, it absolutely had no, it was useless as a predictor for coronary arteries. Ldl, ldl. Now why is that when you correct for triglycerides and hdl, okay, which by the way is a more important predictor of heart disease, LDL loses its significance completely. So then if that's true, and I'm saying that means LDL isn't really a risk factor for heart disease. And I believe with everything I know now that to be the case, okay, let's unpick every part of it. Does lowering LDL cholesterol from diet or drugs, but more specifically drugs, because they're the Most potent ways of lowering LDL cholesterol, whether it's PCK9 inhibitors, whether it's statins, whatever. Is there a clear correlation? Is this dogma true that the lower the better? So myself and two cardiologists did a systematic review of the totality of drug industry sponsored trials. By the way, in some diet trials, but many drug industry sponsored trials or all of the randomized control trials on cholesterol lowering drugs, statins, PCK9, blah, blah. Was there a clear relationship as you lowered LDL in low risk and high risk patients, mark? Okay, over 30 studies, yeah. Was there a relationship with lowering LDL and preventing cardiovascular events?
- [50:57]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
No.
- [50:58]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Even in high risk patients?
- [50:59]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Even in high risk. It's nonsense. It's nonsense. So the question then is why do we all so believe so does that mean. But then I said, well, of course statins have a role. They do have a benefit from the, from the RCT data, which is small because I knew already they're anti inflammatory and anti clotting. So it's nothing in my view. Listen, I could be proven wrong here, but the evidence at the moment looks very clear that there is no consistent relationship. Right. It's definitely not a clear relationship. So if, even if it's a weak relationship, Mark, let's just argument's sake, let's say there is a weak benefit in lowering ldl. What else is going on and what else are you ignoring?
- [51:35]
Dr. Eric Topol
Right?
- [51:36]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
Yeah.
- [51:36]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
What else does statins do? They cause insulin resistance. Say 1 in 100 people get type 2 diabetes because of statins.
- [51:42]
Dr. Mark Hyman
1 in 2.
- [51:43]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
1 in 100.
- [51:44]
Dr. Mark Hyman
1 in 100?
- [51:44]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Yeah, 1 in 100. So about 1 to 2%. But 1 in 100. Some, some studies say 1 in 50. Right. We'll get type 2 diabetes because of the statin. Probably reversible still, but not ideal.
- [51:52]
Dr. Cindy Geier
Right.
- [51:53]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
If you're on stand drug. The second thing is look at the whole patient coming in. We have the illusion of protection. We have patients I used to see coming in and they thought my cholesterol is low, I can go and eat McDonald's, it's fine. And they, they're, and they're getting more and more overweight, more insulin resistant, they're increasing their cardiovascular risk. They're not told the statin is going to give them a 1% benefit. That is more likely than not, they're not going to benefit. So you could imagine that concept that the overall net effect of the way that statins are prescribed and the dogma around them in my view has been negative and has Actually been one of the main reasons why we have got this pandemic of chronic disease.
- [52:31]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Because we overemphasized an index on LDL cholesterol and forgotten everything else.
- [52:35]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Absolutely right.
- [52:36]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Because there's a drug for it. It was interesting to me if there was a drug for insulin resistance that worked really well and we have metformin, but it's eh. And it fixed insulin resistance, you know, everybody'd be prescribing it. But we don't even diagnose it in most people because we don't have a drug for it.
- [52:54]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Exactly.
- [52:54]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And it's stunning to me that, you know, I was talking to the lab director at Quest Laboratories, I said, what percent of your tests you get that come in are measuring insulin? Which is I think, one of the most important things you need to know about your biomarkers. And he was like, less than 1%.
- [53:11]
And it's part of why I co founded this company, Function Health, to really
- [53:14]
look at a deep biomarker set around cardiometabolic risk factors, including insulin, including lp, including something called apob, which I want to talk to you about. Yeah. Not just your total ldl, HDL and triglyceride levels, but also particle number, particle size, inflammation markers, all the things that are often missed but that are much better at giving you a holistic picture of your cardiovascular risk and then you know where to intervene. And it in. In one of the studies that it
- [53:41]
was so interesting to me was actually from, I think Scotland or Ireland was
- [53:45]
where they looked basically a series of patients who came into an emergency room with a heart attack and they did glucose tolerance tests on everybody who came
- [53:53]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
in with a heart attack.
- [53:54]
Dr. Mark Hyman
And they found that two thirds either had diabetes or pre diabetes who had a heart attack. That that was really the big driver. Now there's a subset of people have familial lipid disorders, you know, inherited genetic lipid disorders. And those people probably need to be treated more directly. But for the majority of people out there who are obese or have pre diabetes or metabolic dysfunction, which is basically in America, 93% of Americans, that's what's driving probably most of the heart disease. Not a hundred percent butter or saturated fat or LDL elevations.
- [54:25]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Well, something else to throw into the picture. Right. So you can make the argument, okay, Dr. Malhotra, you're saying there's no consistent relationship, there may be a benefit. Why not just lower your LDL? Okay, so 2016, and the reason we did this, me and a number of international scientists looked at, we decided a Systematic review of observational data looking at people over 60, was there a relationship with LDL cholesterol and heart disease? And the reason we did this, by the way, is another thing that was interesting from framing, which wasn't well publicized, is that when after people hit 50 years old, as their cholesterol dropped, their mortality increased. So we thought, okay, is there something, you know, because for it to be a risk factor for heart disease, it should be consistent, really, across all age groups in both sexes. Right.
- [55:07]
Dr. Mark Hyman
For mortality.
- [55:08]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
For mortality, yeah. But even for heart disease as well. Right. That's a good point. So we looked at. Was there, first of all, any association if you're over 60, with LDL cholesterol and heart disease? Right. We found none. Okay, interesting. But what was surprising was there was an inverse association with LDL cholesterol and all cause mortality in other ways. Statistically, if you're over 60, the higher LDL, the less likely you are to die. So what's the reasoning for that? Well, something that's been forgotten or missed or not discussed. Cholesterol is. Has a very vital role in many functions in the body, including, you know, the brain, hormone production, but also the immune system. And it's likely that that's where the protective benefit comes, because older people are more vulnerable to dying from infections. And we also know there is an association. I'll use this word, an association. Right. Can't say it's definitely causal between low cholesterol and cancer. Again, it's probably related to the immune system.
- [56:03]
Dr. Mark Hyman
I mean, I think. I think.
- [56:04]
Which is very interesting, this data, though, is. And I'll just push back a little bit. Is.
- [56:07]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
It's.
- [56:07]
Dr. Mark Hyman
It's observational data.
- [56:08]
And the data, like, from the Hawaii
- [56:10]
study, show that, you know, you were older and you had higher cholesterol, you know, you're more likely to live longer than if your cholesterol is lower.
- [56:16]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Yeah.
- [56:16]
Dr. Mark Hyman
But it may be because the people have low cholesterol, are malnourished, have cancer and other reasons.
- [56:20]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
So let me push back on that. So we. We counted for that, and we found. Actually, no. When you. You count, like, time lag, you go back five or 10 years. No, it's not. It's not. That does happen, but it. No, it's. Independently, it does seem to be an issue.
- [56:31]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Okay, so you sort of looked at
- [56:32]
all the data and you came up with this very kind of contrary opinion, which is that LDL isn't all. It's cracked up to me that statins work a little.
- [56:43]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Yeah.
- [56:43]
Dr. Mark Hyman
But not for the reasons we think meaning they lower inflammation and they may have other properties that may beneficial. We don't even know we're called this pleiotropic effect. So they for example they induce nitric oxide synthase which dilates your blood vessels and reduces inflammation and helps your blood lining of your blood vessels. All that's protective and so it may be stabilizes plaque, it may help in those ways, but it may not be the LDL lowering effect. In fact, Paul Richer from Harvard, I remember he published a trial, I think it was the Jupiter trial where they showed that if you, if you had a high LDL but didn't have any inflammation, you didn't have that significant a risk of having heart disease. But if you had interesting a high level of inflammation, high ldl, you had a much higher risk. So it was the inflammation that was really driving the heart disease.
- [57:25]
And that was really the seminal paper
- [57:27]
was in the New England Journal of medicine over 20 years ago. I remember reading it by Paul Richard
- [57:30]
and his crew that really laid out
- [57:32]
how heart disease is not a plumbing problem, it's an immune problem a hundred percent.
- [57:37]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
It's a chronic inflammatory process exacerbated by metabolic risk factors or insulin resistance. And I wrote metabolic risk factors by
- [57:43]
Dr. Mark Hyman
that you mean problems with your blood sugar and insulin, insulin resistance and prediabetes 100%.
- [57:47]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
And actually we published an editorial with two cardiologists I did in British Journal of sports medicine in 2017, which was a very long title but it got a lot of publicity and more than a million downloads which was Saturated fat does not clog the arteries. Coronary artery disease is a chronic inflammatory condition which can be effectively managed with lifestyle changes. That was the title of this thing. But it's all there people. It's free access. People look it up and read it. But we talk that we've overdone the thing. And wasn't just Dr. Malhotra, his opinion being controversial. My two co authors were both editors of medical journals and cardiologists. Luis Redberg, editor of Jamaican Medicine and Pascal Meyer, editor of bmj up and off.
- [58:24]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Why is this not getting more play?
- [58:26]
Why is still the dogma and the orthodoxy that if you have a high ldl you take a statin.
- [58:33]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Do you, do you want my honest answer, Mark?
- [58:35]
Dr. Mark Hyman
Yeah. I mean not all.
- [58:36]
I mean I know doctors are usually
- [58:39]
very good hearted, sure. Very smart, well intentioned, don't want to hurt their patients, try to do what's in the best interest of their patients and follow the science. So why, why are they not hearing about this.
- [58:51]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Okay, so let's go to the root cause of the problem. Even in society today, what's the big issue in health? We have commercial distortions of the scientific evidence. Who is behind that? And who has more power and control over medical education, medical training, the media than ever before? Big corporations. In this case, big pharma. And the level of this control and power, Mark, has got to a level where it can be very easily and rationally, not in an inflammatory way or overplaying it as being tyrannical. What also happens with these big corporations in the way they exert their power, is that they want to avoid conflict. Right. They want to avoid the truth coming out. So there's a debate and discussion because ultimately people like myself, like you, who are obsessed with the truth, who want to get it out to help patients, when we speak and act from a place of, of integrity and truth, it has a very powerful resonance with people and it can very quickly destroy all these other dogmas that people have created because of that power that the truth has. They want that conflict to remain latent, to remain hidden, so that, you know, Noam Chomsky says the general public doesn't know what's happening and they don't even know that. They don't know.
- [60:05]
Dr. Mark Hyman
That's right.
- [60:05]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
Right. So a lot of these doctors, and I agree, are well intentioned, but they don't. They're living, you know, in many ways they're living. They're climbing up the wrong wall to success when it comes to helping patients because it's a drug companies that are really calling the shots.
- [60:19]
Podcast Sponsor/Host Voice
Yeah.
- [60:19]
Dr. Sima Malhotra
So we are under a situation of tyranny. And the reason I call it tyrannical is because there are doctors that know this, Mark. There are a few doctors that kind of know this, but then they're less. They're afraid to speak out. And only a minority of the doctors that know what's going on will then speak out.
- [60:32]
Podcast Host/Outro Voice
If you love this podcast, please share it with someone else you think would also enjoy it. You can find me on all social media channels, channels at Dr. Mark Hyman. Please reach out. I'd love to hear your comments and questions. Don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the Dr. Hyman show wherever you get your podcasts. And don't forget to check out my YouTube channel at Dr. Mark Hyman for video versions of this podcast and more. Thank you so much again for tuning in. We'll see you next time on the Dr. Hyman Show. This podcast is separate from my clinical practice at the Ultra Wellness center, my work at Cleveland Clinic and Function Health where I am Chief Medical Officer. This podcast represents presents my opinions and my guests opinions. Neither myself nor the podcast endorses the views or statements of my guests. This podcast is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional care by a doctor or other qualified medical professional. This podcast is provided with the understanding that it does not constitute medical or other professional advice or services. If you're looking for help in your journey, please seek out a qualified medical practitioner. And if you're looking for a functional medicine practitioner, visit my clinic, the Ultra Wellness center at ultrawellnesscenter.com and request to become a patient. It's important to have someone in your corner who is a trained, licensed healthcare practitioner and can help you make changes, especially when it comes to your health. This podcast is free as part of my mission to bring practical ways of improving health to the public, so I'd like to express gratitude to sponsors that made today's podcast possible. Thanks so much again for listening.