Prince Andrew And The Hope That The "Secret Document" Would Save Him

Summary

---

The Epstein Chronicles

Episode Summary: Prince Andrew And The Hope That The "Secret Document" Would Save Him

Host: Bobby Capucci
Date: May 20, 2026

---

Episode Overview

Host Bobby Capucci delves into the legal strategies surrounding Prince Andrew’s efforts to use a “secret document” — a 2009 legal settlement — in attempts to dismiss sexual assault claims brought by Virginia Roberts (Giuffre). Capucci provides analysis and commentary on the broader pattern of wealthy elites using legal technicalities to evade accountability, the public’s changing sentiment, and the role of high-profile lawyers like Alan Dershowitz in these cases. The episode’s core is a critical examination of whether the 2009 settlement can save Prince Andrew from facing a lawsuit, and what this case says about justice for Epstein’s victims.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The "Secret Document" and Legal Maneuvering (00:45 – 06:30)

• Capucci introduces the Daily Mail article revealing that Prince Andrew’s legal defense hopes to benefit from a confidential 2009 settlement signed by Virginia Roberts, which resolved her civil case against Jeffrey Epstein.
• The defense’s strategy mirrors that previously used by Alan Dershowitz, namely seeking out technicalities or broad liability waivers.
• Capucci is openly critical:

  "Take your game of technicalities, take your loopholes and shove them right into your… I'll let you folks decide where." (00:57)

• He notes that prominent lawyers David Boies and Sigrid McCawley (representing Epstein victims) have consistently outmaneuvered Prince Andrew’s and Ghislaine Maxwell’s legal teams:

  "They have completely outpaced Maxwell's team and Joe Exotic of the Windsor family's team, and it's not even close." (02:20)

• The "secret document" reportedly releases lawyers, employees, agents, and heirs from liability but does not mention Prince Andrew by name.

2. Legal Realities and the End of Technicalities (03:50 – 06:55)

• Multiple informed sources confirm the 2009 agreement does not shield Prince Andrew from civil claims.
• Capucci highlights the shifting landscape:

  "The game of technicalities, the game of loopholes, is quickly coming to an end..." (04:28)

• He suggests only truth and substantive evidence will protect defendants moving forward—legal trickery is less effective now.
• Direct criticism of Prince Andrew’s public denials:

  "He's not really a reliable narrator, is he? ... My days of getting gas lit are over. ... What about the picture? What about the email, you lying son of a bitch." (07:25)

3. Public Sentiment & Accountability (05:42 – 07:59)

• Capucci comments on public frustration across the UK and globally with powerful people dodging justice:

  "Meanwhile, the people of England are just like, fuck, man, we're trying to go to work, have a pint after. Why do you guys gotta dick around and ruin our lives?" (06:17)

• He positions the scandal as transcending political lines—people everywhere want accountability, especially for crimes of this nature.

4. Alan Dershowitz: The Lawyer’s Lawyer (10:03 – 12:00)

• Discusses Alan Dershowitz’s suggestion that the settlement could have been an “airtight defense” for Prince Andrew, but sources firmly disagree.
• Capucci’s personal disdain is palpable:

  "He’ll wrap himself in 87 layers of the law as his shield, and it'll be real hard to catch this dude up on anything with his connections. One of the most vile, vile human beings going, in my opinion." (10:25)

• Emphasizes the tactic is just a distraction—“another ruse”—to muddy the waters.

5. Legal Proceedings Update (12:30 – 14:00)

• Both legal teams for Andrew and Roberts filed a joint stipulation agreement in a New York court, confirming service of legal papers to Andrew and setting an extended deadline (October 29) to respond.
• Capucci predicts that Prince Andrew must now face the allegations directly—technical defenses alone will not suffice.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “Unless you have a high profile lawyer, a lawyer that costs dough, you are fucked. … That is what you should say. But two people close to the case insist the confidential agreement does not apply to him.” (03:20)
• “If you don’t have a client who’s telling the truth, you’re gonna get cooked.” (05:12)
• On Prince Andrew’s repeated denials:
  “If you’re gonna try and gaslight me and lie to me when a picture is available for me to see with my own two eyes of you hanging out with Virginia... That shit is not gonna fly with me.” (07:25)
• On Dershowitz:
  “Smarmy motherfucker. When he was writing them protection agreements for Epstein, what he didn’t have himself in mind? … Two plus two equals four no matter where you go.” (11:08)

---

Timestamps of Important Segments

• 00:45 – 03:50: Introduction to the "secret document" and legal defense strategies.
• 03:50 – 06:55: Why the settlement doesn’t protect Andrew; closing loopholes in elite legal defense.
• 06:17 – 07:59: UK public sentiment and Capucci’s reaction to Prince Andrew’s denials.
• 10:03 – 12:00: Detailed criticism of Alan Dershowitz’s tactics and why the settlement won't help.
• 12:30 – 14:00: Legal update on the case's next procedural steps.

---

Tone and Language

• The episode features Capucci’s signature, blunt, no-nonsense commentary—“no punches pulled”—with informal, sometimes explicit language, passionate criticism of legal and societal elites, and empathy for Epstein’s victims.

---

Summary:
This episode critiques Prince Andrew's reliance on a "secret" 2009 settlement as a legal shield, ultimately arguing that technicalities like these are obsolete in the current climate. Capucci underscores growing public demand for accountability and exposes the hollow strategies and attitudes of elites like Prince Andrew and Alan Dershowitz. The message is clear: The era of dodging justice through loopholes may finally be closing.

Transcript

[A]

Booking a VRBO vacation rental means you get VRBoCare and 247 life support, verified reviews from real guests and top rated homes with the Love by Guests filter. I just booked my VRBO because there was a sweet wine fridge. We all have our reasons. If you know you VRBO terms apply. See vrbo.com trust for details.

[B]

During Memorial Day at Lowe's shop household must haves for less. Save $80 on a Char Broil Performance Series 4 Burner Grill to chef up something special plus get up to 45% off select major appliances to keep things fresh. Our best lineup is here at Lowe' Lowe's Lowe's we help you save valid through 527 while supplies last selection varies by location. See lowe's.com for details. Visit your nearby Lowe's.

[A]

Jump into the article here from Daniel Bates and Stephen Wright at the Daily Mail and we're gonna see just exactly what's going on with this strategy of the princes and this document from from 2009 headline secret document Virginia Roberts signed in 2009 to resolve civil Case she brought against Jeffrey Epstein will not save Prince Andrew from court Again. Take your game of technicalities, take your loopholes and shove them right into your. I'll let you folks decide where. But really, all kidding aside, do you folks see what I'm talking about with the technicalities and the loopholes? I know you all do. Most of you are smarter than me. Let's be real. And the way that these people roll, the so called elites with their technicalities and their loopholes and their bulldozing of witnesses and accusers, that shit's for the past. It's old. Nobody's buying it anymore. And especially in cases like this, the lawyers have picked up on the tactics and they've adjusted. And as you have seen, David boies and Sigrid McCauley have been a step ahead the whole entire time of Prince Andrews and Ghislaine Maxwell's lawyers. Now don't get it twisted. I'm not a gigantic fan of lawyers in any degree, for the most part. David Boy, I don't care. Right? I'm not. I don't. I don't. I'm not engaged. I don't engage in the whole putting people on pedestals and especially lawyers. But when you look at the way Boyes and McCauley have handled this situation, they have completely outpaced Maxwell's team and Joe Exotic of the Windsor family's team, and it's not even close. And they continue to do so. The Legal settlement Prince Andrew hopes will get his sex assault case dismissed will not protect him from a lawsuit filed by his accuser, Virginia Roberts. Two sources have told the Mail. Lawyers for the Duke of York, AKA the Joe Exotic of the Windsor family, asked to see a secret document signed in 2009 by Ms. Roberts to resolve a civil case she brought against Jeffrey Epstein, claiming it will release the Queen's second son from liability for her claims. So they tried the Dershowitz approach here, right? You know, Mr. Alan Dershowitz, the Lord of the Courts. Mr. I'm gonna try and get documents that don't even pertain to me. Here's an idea, Mr. Dirty Dursh, back to Martha's Vineyard. Naked volleyball and being a voyeur and looking at your neighbors naked, okay? No need to come running to your buddy Prince Andrew's defense and try and muddy the waters further. It is insane how long Alan Dershowitz has been getting away with putting his hands into the cookie jar. And this is what happens when you have the connections, right? Look, this is the most important thing. If you don't take anything away from the whole entire legal aspect of this, please take this away. Unless you have a high profile lawyer, a lawyer that costs dough, you are fucked. Just please take that with you if you take nothing else, because that's an important life lesson, okay? You ever get pulled over by the police, cops, feds, whatever it is. Not a word, folks. I'd like to speak to an attorney. That is what you should say. But two people close to the case insist the confidential agreement does not apply to him. Dealing a potentially major blow to Andrew's chances of avoiding a courtroom showdown over her claims. Well, look, he better get prepared for a courtroom showdown. The game of technicalities, the game of loopholes, is quickly coming to an end as Maxwell's team has figured out that route. That sort of defense is not going to work. You're gonna have to challenge these accusations line by line. And unfortunately, if you don't have the truth on your side, and you're just one of these audacious, brazen liars like I think the Joe Exotic of the Windsor family is, well, that's a little difficult, isn't it? I don't care if you're the greatest attorney of all time. I don't care if you are Zeus come down from Mount Olympus. If you don't have a client who's telling the truth, you're gonna get cooked. The settlement releases lawyers, employees, agents and heirs from liability in connection with the Epstein case. The Daily Mail has been told it did not include any additional provision for Andrew and it did not mention him by name. It is understood, one source said, I don't see how this applies to Prince Andrew. Yeah, the next one will be, oh, we're protected by the non prosecution agreement. That'll be their next line of defense. Scoundrel, ass scumbag. I mean, is this dude for real? You're the Prince of England, bro. What are you doing? And for the folks over in England, oh, there, I can't even imagine. Got this scandal going on, got other scandals going on. Meanwhile, the people of England are just like, fuck, man, we're trying to go to work, have a pint after. Why do you guys gotta dick around and ruin our lives? And that's the sentiment held amongst the populace around the world at this point. And I don't care what your political stripes are. I don't care about that dumbass paradigm of the left and the right. You all know where I'm at with that. I've evolved way past that shit. I see the forest through the trees and I know what's going on. But people around the world in general are pissed off. People aren't having it no more. You see it. I mean, how long are the children of never supposed to just sit back and take it? And especially when it comes to crimes like this. Miss Roberts claims that she was forced to have sex with Andrew three times when she was 17 after being trafficked by Epstein. She filed her bombshell lawsuit in New York last month. The Duke has repeatedly and strongly denied her allegations. Yeah, you know, because he's a credible source, right? He's. As George R.R. martin would say, he's not really a reliable narrator, is he? I honestly don't trust a word that comes out of this guy's mouth. And I've established my reasons why. If you're gonna try and gaslight me and lie to me when a picture is available for me to see with my own two eyes of you hanging out with Virginia, and then you're gonna act like you've never even met her. My friend, that shit is not gonna fly with me. My days of getting gas lit are over. The Bush administration saw to that when I was a young man. I will never get dog walked ever again. And this dude's out here talking about, oh, I've never even met her. What about the picture? What about the email, you lying son of a bitch.

[B]

During Memorial Day at Lowe's Shop Household must haves for less. Save $80 on a char, broil. Performance Series 4 Burner Grill to chef up something special plus get up to 45% off. Select major appliances to keep things fresh. Our best lineup is here at Lowe's Lowe's we help you save valid through 527 while supplies last selection varies by location. See lowe's.com for details.

[A]

Visit your nearby Lowe's

[C]

Dish has been connecting communities like yours for the last 45 years, providing the TV you love at a price you can trust. Watch live sports news and the latest movies, plus your favorite streaming apps all in one place. Switch to Dish today and lock in the lowest price in satellite TV starting at $89.99 a month with our two year price guarantee. Call 888-D dish or visit dish.com today

[D]

I drive my bus in a busy city. That's why road safety is so important to me. I know that I must slow down and be extra careful when I make a wide turn. Buses need more room than cars. Everyone can help keep our roads safe. Next time you're driving, remember to give buses plenty of time and space to finish turning before driving ahead. Let's all plan to share the road safely. Learn how at www.sharetherodesafely.gov.

[A]

The prospect of the settlement helping Andrew was raised this month by Harvard Law professor Alan Dershowitz, who Ms. Roberts separately sued for defamation and battery. The case was dropped because he had given Epstein legal advice, meaning he qualified as a lawyer. And you see, Dershowitz is smarter than the rest of these guys. He'll wrap himself in 87 layers of the law as his shield, and it'll be real hard to catch this dude up on anything with his connections. One of the most vile, vile human beings going, in my opinion. And honestly, I don't even care about saying it. I really just the distaste I have for this man is almost unparalleled. Mr. Dershowitz told the newspaper that he thought the settlement was an airtight defense for Prince Andrew, who Ms. Roberts has sued for battery and infliction of emotional distress. Informed sources told the Daily Mail the legal agreement would do little to aid the Duke's defense. And again, I agree. I definitely think that it is one of those ploys, just another ruse. They know it's not gonna help him. But if they throw a little bit of, you know, discontent out there, if they throw a little bit of, you know, shade on things, they're hoping that, like, maybe they can steal the narrative away, maybe they can get things to break in their direction. Well, guess what? Here in the New public space called the Internet, around the water cooler if you will. We all see it for what it is. We all see you for what it is. So good luck come trial time. One source said there is no Prince Andrew clause. Another source said this doesn't apply to friends or acquaintances. If Prince Andrew is relying on this for his defense, it won't go very far. A spokesman for Andrew declined to comment. And I had a suspicion that when Presco was so quick to say sure, go ahead, come and get it, that this would be the case, I didn't think there would be anything in there to protect Andrew. Now Dershowitz on the other hand, smarmy motherfucker. When he was writing them protection agreements for Epstein, what he didn't have himself in mind? Come on, stop it. My opinion, obviously I don't have any evidence to back that up. But again, two plus two equals four no matter where you go. Last night, Andrew's lawyers made their first official engagement with the case by filing a stipulation agreement at the New York court. A statement jointly submitted by both sides of the basic facts they all agree on. The filing acknowledges that the Duke was served with legal papers on 21 September. He would normally have 21 days to respond, but both sides have agreed an extension until the 29th of October. So. Alright, shit's getting real for Ol Joe Exotic of the Windsor family. If he's hoping to rely on loopholes and technicalities and all this other BS that him and his so called elite friends have relied on for so long, he's in big trouble. You better come ready, you better come prepared and you better have some receipts because we've seen just circumstantially alone with the evidence that's built against you that you my friend, are a liar. That is certainly what the circumstantial evidence looks like. Now of course that means little and less when we get to court, right? Still gotta convict, still gotta prove it in court to a jury of their peers. But as of now, around the water cooler, guess what sir, the game of technicalities and loopholes is over. If you'd like to contact me, you can do that@bobby capuchirotonmail.com that's B O B B Y C A P U C c [e-mail] youm can also find me on Twitter Boby Capucci all of the links that go with this episode can be found in the description box. Alright everybody.