The Jordan Harbinger Show
Episode 1197: CBD | Skeptical Sunday
Air Date: August 17, 2025
Host: Jordan Harbinger
Co-Host: Jessica Wynn
Overview
This Skeptical Sunday episode dives deep into the world of CBD (cannabidiol)—one of the most hyped substances in the wellness industry. Jordan Harbinger and researcher/writer Jessica Wynn peel back the science, industry practices, regulation, marketing, possible health benefits, and rampant misinformation about CBD. Their goal: to sort fact from fiction and provide critical context for anyone considering CBD products for themselves or loved ones.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
What Is CBD, and How Does It Work?
-
CBD Defined ([03:49] Jessica)
- CBD stands for cannabidiol—a cannabinoid compound found in cannabis as well as other plants like cacao, hops, and even carrots.
- “Cannabinoids are common, and we barely understand what most of them do.” (Jessica, [04:22])
-
CBD vs. THC
- Both have the same chemical makeup but different atom arrangements (isomers), resulting in different effects.
- “It’s like twins with very different personalities.” (Jessica, [05:04])
- THC binds directly to brain/body receptors and gets you high; CBD does not.
-
Endocannabinoid System (ECS) ([05:16]–[06:46])
- The ECS regulates mood, pain, sleep, immunity, and inflammation.
- THC binds directly and strongly; CBD only nudges receptor activity and slows the breakdown of the body’s “bliss molecule” (anandamide).
- “CBD slows that breakdown, so anandamide sticks around longer and chills us out.” (Jessica, [06:51])
Origins of the CBD Craze
-
Rapid Popularity Explained ([07:52] Jessica)
- ECS discovered in humans only in the 1990s; hemp legalized federally in the US with the 2018 Farm Bill, unleashing the CBD market.
- Hemp = cannabis with less than 0.3% THC; anything above is “marijuana” and is still federally illegal in the US. (Jessica, [09:08])
-
Legal Gray Areas
- CBD can be extracted from either hemp or marijuana.
- Full legality remains murky, especially when THC is present above trace levels.
CBD, Products, and Dosing
-
Types of CBD Products ([12:08] Jessica)
- Isolate: pure CBD.
- Broad Spectrum: CBD plus other cannabinoids, no THC.
- Full Spectrum: Includes THC—may lead to a failed drug test if over the limit.
-
Extraction & Risks ([13:05] Jessica; [14:44] Jordan)
- CBD is extracted via CO₂ or solvents.
- Hemp oil ≠ CBD oil; the former comes from seeds, the latter from flowers/leaves.
- Synthetic CBD exists, but it's unregulated, often structurally different, and best avoided.
- “Chemistry is fragile, though. I mean, it’s a valid concern.” (Jessica, [14:49])
-
Bioavailability & Delivery
- Oral absorption is poor; under-the-tongue (sublingual) is better.
- Researchers still evaluating comparative effectiveness of various methods.
- “I will definitely say, please don’t vape CBD. Just don’t vape.” (Jessica, [17:35])
Mislabeling, Quality, and Regulatory Issues
-
Wild West Marketing & Quality Control ([27:05] Jessica)
- Studies show up to 70% of retail CBD products are mislabeled in terms of actual content.
- “The percentages of CBD and THC we see on the packages are just completely unreliable.” (Jessica, [27:39])
- No requirement for extraction, farming, or toxicity info on labels.
- Look for third-party Certificates of Analysis (COA). ([16:37] Jessica)
- Studies show up to 70% of retail CBD products are mislabeled in terms of actual content.
-
Multi-Level Marketing & Scammy Business Practices ([28:21])
- CBD MLMs and questionable “lifestyle” brands abound.
- “If the business model of a brand has an Avon vibe like this, it’s more about recruitment than the product. And that’s a red flag.” (Jessica, [29:17])
Health Claims, Reality, and Placebo
-
What Does the Science Actually Say? ([30:11] Jessica)
- 27,000+ studies; promising for a few uses, but “most of the hype goes far beyond what can be proved.”
- “Some early research shows that it can help anxiety, sleep, chronic pain, but we just don’t have large controlled human trials...” (Jessica, [30:38])
- Side effects are mild but real: nausea, fatigue, liver enzyme interactions (important if on medications). ([31:03] Jessica)
- “It can mess with blood thinners, antidepressants, even antibiotics.” ([31:19] Jessica)
-
Placebo Power ([34:59]–[37:18])
- “There’s definitely a placebo effect. But that doesn’t mean the relief your dad’s getting isn’t real.” (Jessica, [34:59])
- Out of 16 clinical trials on chronic pain, only 1 showed significant improvement over placebo; remaining benefits likely placebo.
- The only FDA-approved medical use: Epidiolex (prescription-grade CBD) for rare childhood epilepsy.
-
Dosing Challenges and Individual Variation ([45:08])
- No agreed-upon effective dose; bioavailability strongly depends on product type and individual metabolism.
CBD and Children, Pregnancy, and Pets
-
For Children & Pregnancy ([54:13] Jessica; [55:40] Jessica)
- “If you’re pregnant or breastfeeding, just stay away from any CBD product.”
- No evidence of benefit in children; possible liver toxicity and adverse effects, especially with contaminated products.
-
For Animals ([61:53] Jessica)
- “There’s even less research to back up CBD as a pet treatment than there is for humans.”
- CBD may harm pets’ livers; THC is toxic for animals.
The Shady World of CBD Products
-
Some Ridiculous Offerings ([58:58] Jessica)
- CBD-infused sports bras, tampons, toilet paper (“calm your ass down”), bath bombs, cheeseburgers (via loophole for one day in CO), and more.
- “CBD-infused tampons...just please don’t do it.” (Jessica, [60:09])
- Marketing often uses pseudo-scientific reports or “mid-year updates” as window dressing.
-
Celebrity Endorsements & Influence ([54:39])
- Kim Kardashian’s 2019 CBD-themed baby shower pushed questionable usage in the public eye.
Legal and Political Intrigue
-
Regulatory Whiplash ([18:19], [48:54])
- CBD is legal federally if derived from hemp and low in THC.
- Enforcement is inconsistent (e.g., grandma arrested at Disney World for CBD oil).
- Texas politicians, alcohol industry lobbying, and new bans as recent as summer 2025 threaten the industry.
-
Industry Scale & Growth ([51:19] Jessica)
- CBD market valued at $3 billion in 2021; projected to reach $60 billion by 2030.
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
- [05:04] Jessica: “Sort of. I mean, more like maybe twins with very different personalities. You know, in the case of CBD and THC, the atom arrangement causes different effects on your endocannabinoid system.”
- [07:26] Jordan (via Trey Kennedy’s joke): “If you don’t know what CBD is, it’s like if essential oils had a weird cousin that lived in a van.”
- [10:33] Jessica: “A single instance of consuming CBD that’s just 0.39% THC…can result in a positive drug test for THC.”
- [14:44] Jordan: “Maybe that’s an anti-science standpoint because I don’t understand it, but when you say, oh, it’s synthetic… I don’t want to find out in 20 years those two extra hydrogen atoms was the reason this wasn’t cancerous in one form and is in another.”
- [29:36] Jordan: “So are we now buying fake CBD from wellness cults?”
- [31:09] Jessica: “CBD can cause mild side effects…most importantly, CBD interacts with our liver enzymes that metabolize 60% of common medications…which means it can mess with blood thinners, antidepressants, even antibiotics.”
- [34:59] Jessica: “There’s definitely a placebo effect. But that doesn’t mean the relief your dad’s getting isn’t real.”
- [37:55] Jessica: “They just kind of gave up and said, look, taking CBD is a waste of money. It’s potentially harmful to your health.”
- [47:02] Jessica: “According to the World Health Organization, CBD shows no signs of being addictive. And to date, there’s just no evidence of...[problems] associated with the use of CBD isolate.”
- [51:19] Jessica: “In 2021, the global CBD market was worth about $3 billion US. By 2030, it’s projected to hit $60 billion.”
Comprehensive Timeline of Important Segments
- 01:28 – Show/segment intro; what to expect from Skeptical Sunday
- 03:18 – What is CBD?
- 05:16 – The endocannabinoid system explained
- 07:52 – Origin of the CBD trend and legality context
- 09:08 – Definitions: hemp, marijuana, THC, CBD
- 12:08 – CBD types: isolate, broad, and full spectrum
- 14:44 – Synthetic CBD, safety, and chemistry concerns
- 16:37 – Certificates of Analysis and importance of quality
- 17:35 – Delivery methods, bioavailability, why not to vape CBD
- 18:19 – CBD and the law, Disney World grandma case
- 21:03 – Pre-2018 hazards: imported, contaminated CBD products
- 26:11 – CBD as 'supplement' and lack of FDA oversight
- 27:05–29:36 – Mislabeled/scammy CBD products and MLMs
- 30:11–34:59 – What actual research says; side effects; placebo; risk with other medications
- 37:43 – Legit medical CBD: Epidiolex for rare epilepsy
- 40:45–45:28 – Dosing, product variability, and effect variability
- 48:54–50:14 – International regulations, US lobbying, and industry lobbying against hemp/CBD
- 51:19 – Economics of CBD
- 54:13 – CBD and pregnancy; Kim Kardashian’s infamous baby shower
- 55:40 – CBD and children: strong warning against
- 58:58 – Wild product offerings: sports bras, tampons, toilet paper
- 61:53 – CBD for pets: evidence lacking, cautions for toxicity
Main Takeaways
- CBD is neither a scam nor a miracle—its proven efficacy is extremely limited, and most over-the-counter products are unregulated, inconsistently labeled, and of unpredictable quality.
- Placebo effect explains a significant portion of its perceived benefit for pain and anxiety.
- Risks: Potential for liver enzyme interference (esp. with meds), poor efficacy for most marketed ailments, and possibility of ingesting unknown substances due to lack of oversight.
- Only one FDA-approved use: prescription-grade CBD for certain rare epilepsies.
- Over-the-counter CBD is, at best, harmless but expensive for most; at worst, a possible health risk with zero real benefit.
- Be skeptical, check for third-party lab tests, and always discuss with your doctor, especially if on medication.
Final Note
“Just because it’s sold at CVS doesn’t mean it’s safe or effective or even real, I guess.”
— Jordan Harbinger ([63:45])
“If you have a medical condition, my advice: always talk to your doctor before using CBD, especially if you’re on prescriptions.”
— Jessica Wynn ([63:45])
If you're considering CBD—or any wellness “miracle”—approach every claim with skepticism, do your homework, and remember: when in doubt, talk to your doctor.
